Speech by President of the Government on presentation of report from Public Administration Reform Commission

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

18 June 2013 · Presentation of report from Public Administration Reform Commission

Context
Rajoy addressed an audience in Spain on 18 June 2013 to present the Public Administration Reform Commission (CORA) report as part of his government's broader economic reform agenda.
Main themes
Public administration reform, economic modernization, reduction of public deficit, elimination of administrative overlap and inefficiency, fiscal sustainability, competitiveness, job creation, CORA commission report, structural reforms, transparency, public sector efficiency
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,576
89th percentile
Sentences
177
86th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.11
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%55%
  • Economic 27%25%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

177 sentences in 80 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, thank you very much for coming here today.

A year and a half ago, the government started an enterprise that is as difficult as it is important; an ambitious reformist project aimed at overcoming the worst economic crisis we have ever known, to correct the imbalances that put the brakes on our economic growth and lay the optimum foundations on which to build a new cycle of economic prosperity and employment for the Spanish people.

We are speaking about the first 18 months of a ceaseless fight against the public deficit and a schedule of unprecedented reforms in our democracy, both at a national level and in turn at a European level, which will continue relentlessly to the very end of this legislature.

Measures such as the labour reform, the Budgetary Stability Act and the restructuring of the financial system, together with many other reforms that are currently being implemented, such as the Entrepreneur Act, the Transparency Act, the Market Unity Act and the reform of our education system, just to mention a few noteworthy examples, represent substantive and unprecedented reforms in each respective area of action.

Viewed as a whole, we can see a common denominator in all of them: the decisive commitment to modernising Spain, the determination to restore our competitiveness vis-à-vis the rest of the major economies and the clear objective of returning to the path of balanced growth, job creation and wellbeing.

Within this future horizon, it gives me great pleasure today to present you with a document that will be of vital importance in this ongoing modernisation process.

I refer, as you are aware, to the report from the Public Administration Reform Commission (Spanish acronym: CORA) deriving from the most detailed analysis made of our public sector during our entire democracy; a document that could prove to be very useful for both Central Government and the Regional Governments for refining our public administration services along the lines of the progress already forged in other areas. This reform will be joined by a reform of the local authorities that is soon to be passed.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We, as Spaniards, can be very proud of our excellent public administration services and of our public servants. Over the last 35 years they have taken a qualitative leap forward, something acknowledged by the whole country. We have set a benchmark to be imitated by other countries in many areas. From the difficulties in which this country finds itself, we should recognise an unquestionable reality: Spain has good public administration.

But we can hide from no-one the fact that, in the normal development of its functions, perfectly inevitable inefficiencies and unnecessary overlaps between the various public administration services have come to light: on the majority of occasions we are faced with over-zealousness deriving from the best of intentions, which is none other than attending in the best possible manner to our citizens; on other occasions, the defect derives from certain inertia in the management of public affairs. But it is clear that providing the same service twice, or even thrice, is not necessarily the most beneficial for our citizens.

For this reasons, in an ever-changing world, it is perfectly understandable that the public administrations would be left behind, without making improvements, without incorporating successful models from the private sector and without adapting to new demands and new realities.

If continuous improvement is imperative for any business, this must also be the case for the public administration services. Indeed that is the case. A competitive economy requires modern, transparent and flexible public administration services. It requires a public sector free of overlaps, duplication and unnecessary expenses, devoted to the service of our citizens and companies, and comparable with the most efficient systems available. This report, which I will broadly outline shortly, represents a before and an after in this right direction.

Dear friends,

The reform of the public administration services must be based on four core areas:

- The need to streamline public expenditure.

- Public demand; in other words, listening and responding to our citizens.

- Performing an in-depth and sustained analysis.

- Responsibility and political commitment, not only to implementing change but also seeing that it is maintained.

It is now time to implement these four premises, all of which point in the same direction: the need to have more efficient and financially sustainable public administration services to the benefit of our citizens.

First of all I would like to do away, once and for all, with a myth about the true size of the Spanish public administration. Contrary to what many claim - and with the 2012 data to hand - we can say that Spain is one of the Eurozone countries spending less of its Gross Domestic Product on public expenditure: 43%, 43.3% to be precise, compared with the Eurozone average of 49.7%. In other words, more than six points less than our peers. And, if we look closer at the structure of this expenditure, we can see that almost two thirds of our public expenditure is set aside for social costs and basic public services.

Having said that, it is true that the growth of the weight of the public sector in our economy has been particularly strong over the last few years. Between 2005 and 2011, public spending increased from 38.4% of GDP to 45.2%. Only two OECD countries recorded a greater increase in their public sector during this period, and those two countries are Ireland and Greece. Enough said.

Another question is that relating to public employment, because I want to make it clear that when we refer to the "administrative apparatus", in other words to the professionals that are engaged, with irreproachable commitment, to the strictly administrative and management tasks, we are only talking about one quarter of the public servants of Central Government and the Autonomous Regions. The remaining 75%, in other words the vast majority, are teachers who educate our children, doctors and nurses who look after us when we are ill, and law enforcement agents, the military and the judiciary who take care of our security and the conservation of our rights and fundamental freedoms. In other words, professionals that provide essential services to our Rule of Law and our Welfare State, divided between the three tiers of government.

Up to this point, you will say to me that the Spanish public administration does not seem to present any problematic peculiarity compared with our peer countries. In reality, our greatest problem at present is the huge slump in public revenue as a result of the economic crisis that has affected all the public administration services, but at the same time has united us.

At the close of 2012, Spain was the country with the lowest level of public revenue as a share of its GDP in the Eurozone, with the exception of Ireland and Slovakia. Compared with a Eurozone average of 46.2%, Spain stood at 36.4% in terms of public revenue as a share of GDP, in other words, 10 points below the average. We are the country with the lowest revenue.

This gap that exists between revenue and expenditure drives us to be twice as productive, above all when we have a series of expenses, such as servicing our debt, which leaves us with little room to manoeuvre.

This is the reason why - since our very first day in office - it has been imperative to do more with less, without renouncing in any way the levels of quality reached in the provision of our public services over all these years. In other words, I am not only talking about saving, but also about improving and without this costing us one euro more.

Ladies and gentlemen,

The reform of the public administration services in Spain started on our very first day in office. As the report itself states, the Commission's work has not been from scratch, but rather it is an extension of the far-reaching legislative changes undertaken in 2012 on matters of fiscal consolidation and streamlining of the public sector.

To a considerable extent this as a result of the raft of measures aimed at saving - and within the framework of the Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability Act - by which we managed to reduce the deficit of all three tiers of government as a whole in 2012 from 9% to 6.98%.

We are talking about a reduction of 22 billion euros, or 2% of our Gross Domestic Product, achieved under the worst possible circumstances of a serious economic recession which has so harshly affected both Spain and Europe in general. This adjustment process has been tough, necessary and painful. We have implemented it with hard work from everyone and it is right and necessary to acknowledge this at all times.

In terms of primary structural deficit, this achievement takes on greater importance. Specifically, it has been reduced by 3.1 percentage points, much higher than our peer countries, as was acknowledged by the International Monetary Fund itself. In barely 12 months, we have moved up to the very front line in the fight to combat the deficit.

Once again, I must thank all the regional governments and local governments for their coordinated and joint efforts on the matter of fiscal consolidation. We have worked side by side, pulling in the same direction and we have sent a very important and very positive message of unity and responsibility abroad.

As is to be expected, the government has headed up this process.

From the very moment we took office, with the restructuring of the ministerial departments, 20% of senior positions were eliminated.

Public employment measures have been adopted that are considered to be the fundamental core of their administrative reform in our peer countries and which have resulted in an increase in the productivity of Spanish public servants. The application of a zero replacement level of public servants, except in specific functions to fight against fraud and in essential services has exceeded that adopted in other countries, where rules of thumb such as "2 for 1" have been established as a fundamental instrument in reducing the size of the public sector.

We have restructured the public business sector and public foundations, and we have brought order to the number, remuneration and compensation of the top executives of public companies, because it was unthinkable that a public servant could be appointed as a top directive of a company and then, upon leaving this post, be reappointed to his former position and receive a significant payoff. That will not happen anymore.

And this effort has been extended to other public administration services. The Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability Act has imposed strict guidelines on public expenditure at all levels. Recent figures show that.

The majority of the Regional Governments have complied with their deficit objectives, To give you an example, the plan to reduce the number of public companies in the autonomous regions, at an advanced stage of execution, includes the elimination of more than 700 bodies, with an estimated saving of some 1.5 billon euros.

Indeed the same has happened in the case of Local Authorities. The deficit target was set at 0.3% of GDP which was comfortably achieved.

The results of this effort can be seen in numbers: a reduction in public spending of almost two percentage points of GDP; an unprecedented streamlining of the public administration services. The figures from the Active Population Survey (Spanish acronym: EPA) show that since the end of 2011, 375,000 positions as public servants have been shed, which is more or less the same number by which it had increased in previous years, in the midst of the crisis. As you will appreciate, this type of decision is very difficult and unpleasant for any government to have to take.

Dear friends,

As I mentioned earlier, the far-reaching reform of the public sector first requires a comprehensive audit of the same. To this end, the Council of Ministers agreed last October, seven months ago, to set up a Public Administration Reform Commission (CORA).

CORA has thus taken charge of preparing a report on proposed regulation and actions to improve the efficiency of the public administration services in various respects: the elimination of duplication and strengthening mechanisms for coordination between the different services, simplifying documentation and the revision of the regulatory framework, a revision of the typology of the so-called institutional administration and, fourthly, the management of common services and resources.

CORA is also commissioned with the mission of providing a raft of concrete proposals for the work groups set up in other institutional areas such as the Conference of Presidents and the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council.

The work of CORA, which has been led by the Vice-Presidency of the Government and the Ministry for the Treasury and the Public Administration Services, is the result of the sum of the efforts made by representatives of various institutions and public administration services, together with social stakeholders and our civil society, such as trade unions, employer's associations and other organisations. I would thank all of them today for their wonderful work, performed, moreover, in record time; work enriched by the crucial voice of our citizens, channelled through the receipt of more than two thousand suggestions that have been of great use in the final drafting of the report.

Ladies and gentlemen,

The document contains a total of more than two hundred proposals of sweeping measures. All the initiatives, of which I will give some examples later, have been selected according to the same criteria: doing things better. Or, which is the same, reduce spending in the interest of greater efficiency from the public administration services; simplify paperwork; eliminate unnecessary bodies and institutions; speed up processes and improve the management of public resources. And all of this within the framework of a clear commitment to the opportunities afforded us by new technologies.

The difficulty of the exercise does not lie in the fact that the saving will come from removing services or aspects that are necessary for our citizens, nor will it come from an increase in public revenue, but rather in improvements to management; in the elimination of administrative structures that are not necessary to comply with the public service. Pure and simple. Here lies the truly transforming nature of the report.

In summary, this report, which will be analysed this Friday at the Council of Ministers, establishes a new culture of public management in Spain. Although much has been done to date, this document is a starting point for obtaining the public administration services demanded by the people - services which are more austere, more useful and more effective.

Because the first beneficiaries of the reforms affecting our services are the people, through fewer forms, less paperwork and fewer counters. In exchange for that, greater flexibility, more facilities and, of course, lower costs and greater savings.

Friends,

I will not go into too much detail. I shouldn't at an event of this nature. Tomorrow there will be a seminar here to that end. Please allow me to explain just a few specific measures from among the 217 announced.

For example, the modification of the methodology in drawing up the General State Budget; specifically Chapter 2, corresponding to running costs for goods and services, and Chapter 6, on real investments, To date, each ministerial department had budgeted its own costs and services according to the budgetary stability objectives set by the Ministry of the Treasury and Public Administration Services, and the level of budgetary execution achieved the previous year. If by this means it was estimated that the needs were satisfied, nothing further was done. Well, it is proposed to change this situation and seek better allocation of budgetary resources. We are not going to budget, to give an example that's easy to understand, electricity or telephone expenses according to what was spent the previous year, in terms of cuts to be made, but rather we are going to budget what I should spend by making optimal use according to the size of my installations and number of employees. This is called "zero-based budgeting".

In this way, the most beneficial sub-contracts for the public administration can be sought and it is not hidden from anybody that the generalisation of these practices will result in a substantial and permanent saving for the public treasury.

What I have just pointed out may appear to be a mere technical issue, but it has its importance and is an example of one of the many things that can be improved on and reformed, as is the management of the cash pool of the General State Administration. Do you know that, at today's date, the General State Administration alone has more than 4,800 banks accounts open in its name? Or, to give you another example, the initiatives designed to centralise the service and supply contracts of the public administration services. What sense is there in buying individually when by buying together we can buy cheaper and better? What sense does it make for each ministerial department to sub-contract individually, and at different prices, energy, cleaning or communications services?

Another example. CORA has analysed the duplications in terms of the institutional bodies of the various public administration services in depth. The areas of activity of each ministerial department have been analysed in detail, the administrative body or institution that exercises for the State or for each autonomous regions its respective powers has been identified and recommendations have been made to proceed along the lines of the principle of one public administration service, one competence. And the conclusion has been reached in the report that, for example, the autonomous regions can do away with their meteorological agency, their competition body or their energy agency or not, to give you a few examples, because there are some autonomous regions that do not have these structures, which are expensive, and the State is providing the same service, or the same or of a better quality and without any additional cost for the citizens.

Savings are in sight and, if the up to 120 proposals contained in the report for eliminating duplications are applied, this would give more breathing space for the budgets of the autonomous regions or the central government of the country. Not only in these cases but in many more cases, such as what the offer, on the part of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, represents of installing offices overseas within the State's Embassies and Consulates. At the end of the day, this falls under a legal principle that everyone understands: the principle of unity of State action overseas, which, in this case, would save a great deal of money for the people of our country. On this matter, it should be said that significant improvements have already been made, through the signing of various protocols of collaboration between the Ministry and various individual Regional Governments.

But it is not only a case of us carrying out this kind of exercise in times of crisis. In the future we must all be much stricter when setting up new public businesses and other new bodies. That is why we will make a legal change that better defines what type of public body or institution can be set up, what special aim justifies its creation and with what resources it will operate, so that no-one evades the necessary controls. And this will be strictly monitored.

Dear friends,

I could mention other measures that directly deal with the wellbeing of our citizens and the competitiveness of our companies, such as the major projects for administrative simplification proposed in this report: from the simplification of procedures for environmental evaluation or the implementation of a one-stop shop for foreign trade. Or I could speak about one of the main demands that have come from our citizens and our entrepreneurs: making e-government a true reality.

I am speaking about proposals that affect us on a daily basis, such as the implementation of the digital clinical history, so that people who move from one autonomous region to another, on holiday, for example, can be attended by doctors and nurses who have all the data in their clinical history available. In short, it is a question of our health system following our citizens rather than our citizens following the health system.

And all of this is being done thinking about our citizens. From the electronic appointment at the Public Employment Service or the Provincial Traffic Headquarters to the single notice boards for edicts of the public administration services or the implementation of the e-invoice for the public administrations services to facilitate trade relations with their suppliers.

Speaking about suppliers, I will explain another proposal to you, which is none other than overseeing the trade debt of the public sector for the purposes of budgetary stability. This proposal is based on the principle that financial sustainability is not only a question of controlling public debt but also of controlling the trade debt. In other words, that suppliers - who for the most part are small- and medium-sized enterprises and the primary generators of wealth and employment in our country - should be paid the debts owed to them by the public administration services.

So, the reform is geared towards integrating oversight of the trade debt within the principle of financial sustainability. In the interest of strict control, the concept of average period for the payment of suppliers is introduced, which the public administration services are obliged to publish on a regular basis. In short, a very specific proposal to do away once and for all with late payments on the part of the public administration services and the breaches of the legal term for payment that, as you are aware, have caused so many difficulties both now and in previous years for thousands of companies in Spain.

Friends, allow me to draw to a close.

I have left dozens of measures on the sidelines. In reality, I have left the majority of the measures out, measures that I would have liked to have explained to you: from the simplification of administrative paperwork to the incorporation of a company, contained in the "Start in 3" Project, or the mutual recognition of authorisations, such as, for example, and this is easy to appreciate, the hunting and fishing licenses between different autonomous regions, or the creation of a general electronic notification service, which will be implemented on a progressive basis. One comment on this issue: a postal notification costs 2.55 euros whereas an electronic notification costs 0.19 euros.

In short, what we are talking about in each and every one of these cases is not idealistic principles, but rather specific and detailed proposals that will have a very positive repercussion in terms of savings for us all and also when facilitating a whole host of daily tasks, both personal and professional in our daily lives.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I have mentioned that the report from this Commission is not the end of the road. As well as being a detailed diagnosis, it is a useful instrument in the hands of the government and at the disposition of the regional governments to move much further on down the path that we set out on at the start of this legislature.

This is a reform that affects all the public administration services and, precisely for this reason, we should all benefit from its proposals and recommendations. To achieve this, we are going to seek the maximum level of consensus between the political forces and the various public authorities in order to make possible the transformation of the public sector.

The end of the road will not be reached until we have a public administration model that serves the general interests of our society in the best possible manner. In the same way as for other objectives, this is within our grasp.

In order for any reform to be successful, it must combine reality and ambitions in the right doses. Both conformism and impractical idealism are the sworn enemies of reformist projects to the extent that both prevent these projects from becoming fully effective and prevent aspirations from becoming a reality.

But no reform - however much in principle it may solve existing problems - is an end in itself. Once brought into practice it immediately opens up new possibilities of progress and improvements previously unthought-of until then. That is why it is the government's obligation to carry out dynamic and ongoing management of all these matters, maintaining a firm and permanent hold on the path mapped out and not dropping its guard in the pursuit of leaving its citizens with a better country than they started off with.

Today the main objectives of our country are closer than they were a year and a few months ago. Thanks to the hard work by everyone the worst is now behind us. We have made progress to the extent that we have persevered, to the extent that we have not allowed the faith in our possibilities to be broken.

And this is how we will continue working, with the best intentions and without losing sight of the purposes that characterise this legislature: reforms to return to growth, to return to job creation and live again in a country of opportunities for everyone. We will achieve that. That will be our great legacy.

I will end by way of summary. Thank you to those who have worked on this report. In October last year, we asked them to finish it by 30 June this year, 2013. This deadline was necessary because in a matter of these characteristics, good will and the improvisation that tends to accompany this don't lead anywhere. Those who have worked on this report have more than fulfilled their duty. Believe me when I say this has been an immense undertaking. We now have a document drafted by people that know our public administration services, a document on which, furthermore, other people have collaborated with other visions, from other perspectives, but who share the same objective of improving things and serving our people.

This document is a proposal. We would like, as I said earlier, to reach a consensus with all parties. We will try to achieve this in good faith. There are no ideologies here, simply an attempt to be more efficient, which is our obligation.

Central Government takes onboard what the document states and will act accordingly, and we will start on this on Friday. We will start with this now. We will start with reforms such as the Law on the Legal System of the Public Administration Services, the Law on Subsidies, e-government and late payments by public authorities. At the same time, we will start taking other decisions that do not require legal reforms.

The other public authorities, as I promised at the Conference of Presidents last year, will have this report available to them for the debate on the Fiscal and Financial Council. I believe that this document provides good ideas, and I repeat, it aims for nothing more than efficiency. I am absolutely aware, as you are, because this is not an easy operation, that the task will be arduous, difficult and that it will require great determination, but believe me when I say that it is worth it. At least, that's how I see it.

Thank you very much.