Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

17 December 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a December 2013 congressional control session, defending his government's economic record and electoral promises.
Main themes
Economic recovery and job creation, government promises vs. performance, austerity measures and public sector cuts, labor reform and unemployment, corruption allegations, energy prices and poverty, judicial council independence, electoral program fulfillment, banking sector bailout, pension and public service cuts
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,963
56th percentile
Sentences
70
46th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 39%39%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

70 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Madam Deputy, at this point in your political career, you should also know the exact situation of the members of the General Council of the Judiciary. These members are not linked to the proposing body, and this is demonstrated by the prohibition of imperative mandates and the establishment of a five-year term that does not coincide with the mandate of this General Courts. And at this point in your political career, you should also know how to read the rulings of the Constitutional Court correctly, because the Constitutional Court states that any of the procedures — direct election by judges, election of judges by Parliament, or this mixed system by Parliament endorsed by judges — fully complies with the current constitutional text.

Therefore, read the laws carefully, interpret them correctly, and be more modest. Perhaps you are not right, and 93 percent of the deputies are.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of La Izquierda Plural

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, how do you justify the failures to fulfill the promises made to the citizens?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara.

The electoral program of my party was structured around six fundamental structural axes. The first, and most important, was growth and job creation. After several years of crisis, growing economically and creating jobs was the great objective, and today there are already positive data in the Spanish economy; insufficient, but positive data. After nine quarters of negative growth, the third quarter of this year saw positive quarter-on-quarter growth, and the fourth will also.

The same is true for employment. Since 2007, there has not been a single month, none, with less unemployment than the same month of the previous year. This has already happened for the first time since 2007 in October and November of this year.

Therefore, we are taking steps in the right direction, we have overcome very complicated moments, we are here, next year will be better, and I can tell you that today we are better than last year, but we are worse than next year, which encourages the Government to continue working and achieve the great objective of this Legislature: to grow and create jobs.

Mr. Lara.- You do not clear my doubts, Mr. Rajoy. We believe that you are failing to keep your word, as committed in the program, and you are governing in electoral fraud, therefore.

You committed to creating more than three million jobs, and there is one million more unemployed; you promised to create permanent jobs and are replacing permanent jobs with precarious ones; you promised not to lower the salaries of civil servants and, on the contrary, you are punishing them very harshly; you promised not to make dismissals cheaper, and your labor reform enshrined the cheapest dismissal in democracy; you promised not to raise VAT, and you raised it by 21 percent; you promised not to make tax amnesties, and Mr. Montoro's tax amnesty has been shameful and scandalous; you promised to combat corruption, and your party has only dedicated itself to destroying evidence to cover up the corruption scheme; you promised transparency and have denied creating commissions to investigate financial fraud and the illegal financing of political parties; you promised that you would not touch pensions, and your reform is a brutal cut for current and future pensioners; you promised not to touch healthcare or education, and the "white" and "green" tides in the streets attest to the cuts; you promised not to help the banks and a hundred billion euros in guarantees in your first decree; you promised not to create a "bad bank," and there it is, created, selling assets at bargain prices to "vulture" investment funds; you said that the bank bailout would be paid for by the banks, and we citizens have already paid 36 billion. Is there anything you promised that you have fulfilled?

In the last six years, electricity prices have risen by 70 percent, and when Rodríguez Zapatero authorized the increase in 2010, you said these words: "not even for Christmas did you have a gesture of kindness towards taxpayers, not even for Christmas; this is very strong and is a new twist of the screw on the economy of the Spaniards."

History repeats itself, Mr. Rajoy. The only gesture you are going to have with the Spaniards this Christmas is yesterday's rejection of our proposal to end energy poverty and, instead, giving the electricity companies a new increase in electricity prices so they can continue to profit. You do not fulfill your promises to the people because you are at the service of the banks and the electricity companies, and, after all these failures, Mr. Rajoy, have a gesture for Christmas: resign with your Government, which many people will thank you for.

President.- Mr. Lara, you have painted an apocalyptic scenario that, as you can understand, I do not share at all. In fact, I hardly share anything of what you said this morning.

Spain is a country with many problems. We are trying to emerge from a very harsh crisis, and we are starting to do so; but Spain is not what you painted in your speech, it doesn't even resemble it.

In the last fifty years, this country has seen the highest increase in per capita income in the world, surpassed only by four countries; the fifth country in the world. Spain is a country that has a social protection system like very few countries in the world: a public pension system, a public healthcare system, an educational system, unemployment insurance, and social assistance. It is a very advanced country, and you should feel proud of the country you live in. I know that while we were celebrating the Constitution here, you were in Cuba. Perhaps your model is the Cuban one. Mine is certainly the Spanish one. You laugh because you have no argument to counter what I just told you.

What this country needs is what is being done, Mr. Lara: fiscal consolidation, taking care of public accounts, making reforms, and from there, as I have already told you, economic growth will come, and employment will come, which is already starting to arrive. Certainly, with your recipes, your theories, your partners, your allies, and your apocalyptic speeches, you are not going anywhere. You should feel proud of the country in which...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you think that, halfway through the Legislature, the rights of Spaniards have been fulfilled?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.

When we came to power, the starting situation, as you know, was not easy at all. We had to overcome a financial crisis, a debt crisis, avoid the rescue of our country, and at the same time, we had to correct the serious imbalances in the Spanish economy to grow and create jobs, which was the capital objective of this Legislature. To do this, we had to end the uncontrolled public accounts and make structural reforms. We did it, and we continue to do it, and we did it equitably, preserving the essentials and trying to help those who were in a more delicate situation.

All of this was not easy, but as I have already told Mr. Lara in my speech, we are already beginning to see, even if timidly, that the efforts made had meaning. Today, Spaniards can see the future with much more security and much more hope than two years ago when we came to power.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Three news items from yesterday, Mr. Rajoy. Last year there were twenty thousand fewer interns in Spain, and fewer interns mean less equality of opportunity, restrictions on the right to study for those who cannot afford their studies. Yesterday, you decided to take away the health card from Spaniards who are three months outside of Spain: first, it was irregular immigrants; then, those who had not contributed to Social Security, and yesterday, those who go to look for jobs abroad. What is the next group, Mr. Rajoy? You have broken the principle of universal healthcare, and more and more Spaniards are having difficulties accessing public healthcare. And yesterday we learned that for the fourth consecutive quarter, salaries in Spain have decreased. Not all, the lowest ones; the salaries of IBEX executives continue to rise while 650,000 jobs were destroyed in Spain. The result is your labor reform: fewer rights for workers in Spain. I could continue with the justice fees or the right of women to freely decide about their own motherhood, which you are going to end in the coming days.

Summary: two years, more unemployment, more taxes, more debt, fewer labor rights, fewer social rights, and more inequality. That is the balance, Mr. Rajoy.

Forty seconds to talk about the territorial problem in our country, which has worsened after President Mas's decision. You know, Mr. Rajoy, and this Chamber knows well, the unequivocal position of the socialists regarding self-determination. You also know, because I expressed it in the State of the Nation Debate, my position regarding the difficult situation in the relations between Catalonia and the rest of Spain, and I want to reiterate to you today, Mr. Rajoy, to you and to the Groups in this Chamber, the willingness of the socialists to dialogue, to reach consensus, and to update our rules of coexistence contained in our Constitution.

I know it is not an easy task, but I believe we must undertake it if we want to continue on the path that 35 years ago all Spaniards, in much more difficult circumstances, were able to begin to walk, which has led us to the longest period in the history of our country of coexistence, progress, and freedom.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, I will start by referring to the second part of your speech. I believe we will agree on that issue. I never questioned that you were against the right to self-determination, which, by the way, does not exist in any Constitution of any country in the world.

Where I fear we will not agree is in the first part of your speech because, quite frankly, the greatest blow to the rights of all was the economic policy of the Government in which you were when you did not realize — we are now living the consequences — anything that was happening in Spain. 3,400,000 people lost their jobs during that time, public administration revenues decreased by 70 billion, and, as you can understand, that decrease of 70 billion is very difficult to recover and undoubtedly affects the public spending that the State then makes.

We were on the verge of losing access to credit; we were on the verge of being rescued; you made decisions such as freezing pensions or eliminating some decisions that had been adopted, such as the 400 euros or the 2,500 euros of the "baby check"; you generated serious imbalances in the Spanish economy, and all of that forced us, because it is our obligation, to make tough decisions over these two years. But, as I said in my previous speech, those efforts made sense, and now we see that, for the first time in a long time, there is already positive quarter-on-quarter growth in Spain, in the third quarter and in the fourth, and now we will see that by the end of this year, unemployment will be exactly the same as last year, and next year, jobs will be created in our country.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, what we are doing, ultimately, is correcting the messes you made during your time in Government…