Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

9 September 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from opposition MPs during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on 9 September 2014.
Main themes
Labor reform effects, wage moderation, minimum interprofessional wage, working poor, unemployment reduction, collective bargaining, Spanish competitiveness, social inequality, poverty, OECD recommendations, job creation
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,752
72nd percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.35
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%62%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

98 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, from the Parliamentary Group of the Left Plural

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, what effects has the wage decrease brought about by your labor reform had on Spanish society?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara. As you know, Mr. Lara, it is not the Government nor a law that sets wages in the private sector, but rather the social agents and the negotiators of collective agreements who are fully sovereign to agree on workers' remuneration. In this regard, I remind you that at the beginning of 2012, the social agents reached agreements recommending moderate wage increases aligned with the economic situation for the years 2012, 2013, and 2014. The labor reform only introduced some modifications in the laws, giving in some cases priority to company agreements over others; but in any case, it would always be the social agents who would carry out that negotiation.

Therefore, this has been an agreement between the parties, but I have no objection to giving my opinion on it. I believe it has been sensible. I insist, I supported it, but I did not impose it, because it is not my competence; but I believe it has been useful to prevent the loss of many jobs in Spain, to ensure that jobs are being created today, and to improve the competitiveness of the Spanish economy.

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, the labor reform has indeed been a competence of the Government, it cost a general strike, and the labor reform has allowed cheap dismissals of workers who had decent wages and, in many cases, have been replaced by workers with miserable wages and contracts. All the recipes promoted by the CEOE, the International Monetary Fund, and the Bank of Spain itself, to lower wages have failed. The OECD itself, which once recommended lowering them, now states in its latest report that wage reductions increase poverty, that there is more inequality between the rich and the poor — we say that — that competitiveness has not improved, and that the real economy is not recovering. The excuse of exporting, of lowering wages to export more, has been a sham, and the results are there: your own visit to Japan, where you went to sell cheap labor in our country. We do not know what the results are for wages, the economy, and employment in Spain.

Cáritas of Catalonia says that one in four people who go to public dining rooms has a contract, but a miserable contract. The other day, a happy father appeared on television. He was happy because his children were going back to school, but it was not just because the children were going to study, but because they could finally eat at school, due to the hunger they had endured, basic needs, during the summer period.

There are families that cannot afford books at the start of the school year, and with your Government, a new figure has been created in this country, which is the figure of working poor with contracts. That has happened under your Government. Are you not ashamed of this, Mr. Rajoy?

You have frozen the Minimum Interprofessional Wage at 645 euros, and I ask you directly, and look me in the face: Could you live on 645 euros a month? Bring a proposal for the Minimum Interprofessional Wage in the next Budget, because that is indeed the Government's competence. In France and Germany, the Minimum Interprofessional Wage is over 1,400 euros. Bring a proposal to raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage in this country to 1,100 euros; that is indeed your competence, and that would be a minimally decent minimum wage.

President.- Mr. Lara, I insist that it was the social agents, that is, the business and union organizations, who signed the wage moderation agreement. I insist that, in my opinion, it was good for the economy.

The OECD has spoken about the labor reform and has said the following: "The reform has contributed to promoting hiring, particularly permanent hiring. The empirical analysis of the report suggests that the reform may have created about 25,000 new permanent contracts per month."

I will give you another piece of data from the labor reform: when the labor reform was approved in our country, unemployment was growing at an annual rate of 12 percent; now, when the labor market reform has already come into effect, unemployment is decreasing at rates around 6 percent annually.

Finally, I want to tell you something that is important and you should take into account: in 2014, the average wage increase is at 0.55 percent, but in our country, prices are falling by 0.5 percent. Therefore, a wage increase of 4 percent with a price increase of 6 percent is not the same as a wage increase of 1 percent with no price increase. Moreover, this has been enormously positive for the improvement of Spanish competitiveness, as all international organizations say, and as the numerous policy study services that have been applied in the vast majority of countries that are doing better at this moment also indicate.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Sánchez Llibre, from the Parliamentary Group of Catalan Convergence and Union

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Mr. President of the Government, is the Spanish economy doing better today than a year ago? Yes, but the truth is that the real economy is not doing well. With an unemployment rate in Spain of twenty-four and a half percent, growing at acceptable rates will be very difficult, and if we also take into account that a part of the Spanish population of young people, which is more than 50 percent of them, neither study nor work, we have a really serious problem. How many jobs are going to be created in 2014 and 2015? Five hundred thousand, Mr. President of the Government? Welcome, but insufficient.

There are a series of economic factors that will hinder economic recovery: falling real wages, negative growth in exports, increasingly unbearable debt… Therefore, we ask you what political and economic measures you are going to implement to make recovery a reality.

President.- You ask me — this is the text of the question — for our assessment of the evolution of the Spanish economy. We assess it positively, with caution, without complacency, and determined to continue working, because there are still many problems that remain unresolved and many Spaniards who live with difficulties.

I will not tire you with data, but there are some results that are certainly hopeful: we have had four consecutive quarters of growth after a long time in recession, which means that for a long time we have lost well-being and wealth; in the last quarter, we grew by 0.6 percent and 1.2 percent year-on-year; we have grown three times more than the eurozone and we have been the country in the eurozone that has grown the most. Obviously, there is still much to be done, but this is a very positive data.

Regarding unemployment, which is the most important challenge facing the Spanish economy, in the second quarter of this year, for the first time in six years, there has been net job creation. There are almost two hundred thousand more employed than last year, there are four hundred thousand more employed in the second quarter than in the first quarter, and unemployment has been reduced by more than three hundred thousand people.

Therefore, we are on the right track; things will still require a great effort from us; but we must also see what the starting point was that we faced to make a fair judgment.

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

From Convergència i Unió, we also understand that to promote recovery, political factors must be taken into account. We believe that what really threatens recovery is that, in the face of the demands of Catalonia, there is not even a half political proposal from the Government that allows the markets to trust in an agreement and not in a train crash, Mr. President, and to avoid the continuity of the problem, because this really, Mr. President, exists and will not only not disappear because you make the consultation unfeasible, but we understand that it will become entrenched. And this will bring economic distrust, instability in the markets, an increase in the risk premium, and will affect growth and job creation. Look at what happened recently this past Monday in the London Stock Exchange and what happened to the pound.

In the face of these attitudes, we have neither a political response nor incomprehensible attitudes, like that of Mr. Montoro the other day, in his last intervention, where the forms were really humiliating and ridiculing, from our point of view — the forms, not the substance — and have not been used in other matters; and because we have also seen attitudes, like in the case of Utrecht, where you prevented the presentation of the book at the Instituto Cervantes by Mr. Sánchez Piñol, and, on the other hand, you have allowed…

President.- Mr. Sánchez Llibre, it is not my intention to argue with you; but I cannot share, and I am very sorry, anything you have said. Well, probably, what generates a political problem is that there are rulers who threaten to violate the law or who even threaten to make a unilateral declaration of independence. That can indeed create a political problem and difficulties in the markets.

In any case, I will tell you one thing: Catalonia is a great engine of recovery for the whole of Spain. Catalonia is growing, Catalonia is creating jobs, and we are delighted that it is so, because that is good for the Catalans and for all Spaniards. And that is the result of the effort of all: the citizens of Catalonia and all Spanish citizens, of some positive things, not in the area you mentioned, that the Government of Catalonia has also done, and certainly of the economic policy carried out by the Spanish Government and this Parliament, which is undoubtedly benefiting the recovery in Catalonia, as in the rest of Spain.

If you want there to be no problems, what you have to do is say "we are not going to call an illegal referendum," and you will see that then there would be no problem in any market.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Ladies and gentlemen, it is an honor for me to address all of you as president of the Socialist Parliamentary Group. We are going to carry out a citizen opposition, we are going to defend the interests of the citizens, and when you get it right, Mr. Rajoy, you will have us by your side, and when you do not, you will have us in front.

The first question I would like to ask you, Mr. President, is the following: what is your assessment of the economic situation? It is true that today you have described that recovery as "cautious," but it is also true that a few days ago you spoke of vigorous roots, and very likely, in your speech, you will use some macroeconomic data; but I tell you one thing, Mr. Rajoy… I ask you not to do so, because you must not forget that many of the figures you use have nothing to do, unfortunately, with the figures that most Spanish families use in our country.

President.- Thank you very much, good morning. I am pleased that you say you are going to defend the general interests, because I have been doing so for quite a few years. Specifically, since I began my political activity.

You ask me how I see the political, economic, and social situation in Spain. I see it with concern, but also with hope. I see it with concern because there are many people who cannot work, many young people; there are many people who have been without finding a job for a long time. We still have economic imbalances, and there are people living in difficulty.

Therefore, I see it with concern, but I also see it with hope because, given the situation we started from, given how we are today, and given the forecasts we have for the future, we can say, as I told your colleague Mr. Sánchez Llibre, that the economic situation is improving, that the social situation is beginning to recover, and that in the political situation, I believe we are addressing, with the sensibility, common sense, and responsibility that the case requires, some of the political problems — to which Mr. Sánchez Llibre referred — that we have in our country.

So, concern, yes; but at the same time, hope for what may happen in the future in our country.

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, believe me, if there are good positive news in our country, the Socialist Party, the Socialist Parliamentary Group, will be happy, of course!; but what you cannot do is confuse four macroeconomic figures with the reality of the Spaniards.

Three years ago, Mr. Rajoy, you took a photograph in the unemployment line, at the INEM, which, by the way, I encourage you to visit to see if those people support your management and think that you are doing a political job in the general interest of this country. But, in any case, you said in that interview that you were going to lower unemployment. Three years later, since you became President of the Government, eight hundred thousand jobs have been destroyed, and there are six hundred thousand fewer affiliations to Social Security. Is this, Mr. Rajoy, the promised economic recovery: less work and more labor poverty?

Look, if you want to create jobs, what you have to do is, first, repeal the labor reform; second, raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. If you want to create jobs, what you have to do, Mr. Rajoy, is to stop the bulldozer of labor rights that you have set in motion since you became President of the Government and to start the engines of reindustrialization in our country. Because, ladies and gentlemen, we need to reindustrialize our country. We need to invest in research, in science, in innovation; we need to prevent, precisely, scientific exile; we need to promote the export of our companies to more places in the world, and that, Mr. Rajoy, is how jobs will be created in our country.

Regarding the vigorous roots you referred to in a rally in Galicia, I will tell you that they may exist in the oasis where you live isolated; but the majority of Spaniards, Mr. President, believe me when I say, still thirst for work and for decent work.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez. You have spoken about the three years of government. I will explain to you what happened in these three years.

At the end of 2011, we came to power after a legislature in which 3,400,000 jobs were lost in Spain; from a legislature in which 70 billion euros of revenue were lost; with a risk of poverty, social exclusion rate, with figures of social inequality and with the 80-20 indicator from Eurostat that kept breaking negative records, and with economic imbalances that prevented us from growing and creating jobs.

Well, today there is still a lot to be done. That is why I told you that I am concerned about the state of the economy, but things are improving because we are starting to grow and because, as I pointed out earlier, net jobs are already being created in Spain. Today there are more employed and more registered with Social Security than a year ago, and today the registered unemployment figures are already lower than when we came to power. And the figures for exclusion, the risk of poverty rate, and the 80-20 indicator are improving.

This is the change that is taking place, but there is still much to be done, and that is why I tell you that I am concerned. But given the mountain of problems you have left us, and which you must know very well because you supported from those seats the government that caused it, I must say that today, considering the current situation, I can say we can look to the future with hope.

Thank you very much.