Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

7 October 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on October 7, 2014, addressing oil drilling policy and regional investment disparities.
Main themes
Oil drilling in the Canary Islands vs. Balearic Islands, environmental policy consistency, energy dependence on foreign hydrocarbons, regional autonomy and consultation rights, parliamentary accountability, political hypocrisy accusations, public investment in Catalonia
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,423
66th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.47
93rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 32%32%
  • Social 25%24%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

82 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Quevedo, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Quevedo.- Mr. President of the Government, what reasons justify your high environmental sensitivity regarding oil drilling in the Balearic Islands, in contrast to your opposing behavior in the case of the Canary Islands?

President.- In fact, none, because the environmental criteria applied in Spain are exactly the same anywhere in Spain, which are also exactly the same as those applied anywhere in Europe, since they are set by the European Directive.

Mr. Quevedo.- This response would be fine if it coincided with reality, wouldn’t it? Because, of course, in the case of the Balearic Islands, I will refer to some of your literal statements: "As long as I am President of the Government, there will be no oil exploration if there is the slightest indication that it could generate the slightest problem in terms of the environment, and, moreover, this is going to take a long time." We will have to discuss this issue a lot in the case of the Balearic Islands.

In the Canary Islands, after the most significant demonstrations in history on the islands of Lanzarote and Fuerteventura; after the general pronouncement of scientific, social, environmental sectors, etc.; after the numerous institutional proposals requesting consensus and debate on this issue; after having asked your Government, through your minister, Mr. Soria, for the need to discuss with Canary society what the risks and benefits of this activity are, what has happened is exactly the opposite of what has occurred in the Balearic Islands. And we, as you will understand, have nothing against the Balearic Islands; in any case, we will have a healthy envy.

So much so has been the discriminatory treatment that you have not yet responded to the request, the question, the request for authorization that the Government of the Canary Islands has made to you, as a result of an agreement from the Parliament of the Canary Islands, regarding the possibility of authorizing a consultation on oil explorations in the Canary Islands. It is simply a dismissive attitude.

Well! It is already public and notorious in the Canary Islands that this is your behavior, that the behavior is unequal with the Canary Islands. In front of a Community that uses exactly the same arguments as ours to say "no to oil," "no to oil drilling under these circumstances," the behavior is exactly the opposite. And if you have any doubts about what the majority opinion of the Canary people is regarding this issue, do you know what I sincerely recommend, with the utmost good faith? You should request a consultation, which is not to request the independence of the Canary Islands, but to ascertain the opinion of the Canarians on this matter, and you will see the surprise you get.

President.- Mr. Deputy, the criteria are exactly the same anywhere in Spain, and what is said for one place in Spain applies to any other.

These explorations have been authorized for the following reasons: first, because we believe it is good for the general interest of all Canarians and all Spaniards: our dependence on foreign sources, in the case of hydrocarbons, is 99 percent, and we spend one hundred million euros a day to import gas and oil. Second, because there is no risk, as some speak for tourism and the environment, as established by the Environmental Impact Declaration that has been made following scrupulously the criteria applied in all places in Europe.

There will undoubtedly be opinions for all tastes; but I will tell you what the opinion of the head of your party, yours, Mr. Román Rodríguez, is: "my last assessment: there is no country in the world --he says--, of any condition, that, having the possibility of finding oil, does not seek it with the necessary guarantees, which is what we are going to demand." Exactly the same as what the Vice President of the current Government of the Canary Islands says: "The Socialist Party of the Canary Islands -he says-- would carry out explorations with their eyes closed." And exactly the same as what Coalición Canaria said when it ran in the last elections, demanding this competence for the Government of the Canary Islands.

I would appreciate it if you did not engage in demagoguery, if you did not deceive the entire Canary citizenry, or if you explained why, when you were in power, you wanted explorations and now it seems that you do not. Since the Popular Party is in charge of the Government and makes the decision, it now seems that you do not want the explorations to take place. You cannot mock the people in that way.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pere Macias, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Macías.- Mr. President, in 2012 you presented your first Budgets, and in Catalonia, the strong drop in public investment was received with surprise and displeasure: against the 18.7 percent that represents the Catalan GDP and the 16 percent that is the weight of the population of Catalonia in the State, the investment fell from 15 to 11 percent.

Despite the unanimous complaints, in the following Budgets, the percentage has continued to decrease, until the 2015 project where it reaches a record low: a meager 9.5 percent, the lowest in the last seventeen years.

Mr. President, do you consider that this constant under-investment by the State in Catalonia, in addition to being profoundly unjust and ineffective in terms of improving the productivity of the Spanish economy, is appropriate at this time? Do you not think it is a serious political irresponsibility to punish Catalonia?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Macías. I regret that I cannot share your statements. I believe that these Budgets are good for Catalonia and also for the whole of Spain. They are the best of a legislature that you know has been very difficult, and in this Legislature, things have been improving little by little. We are facing the Budgets of economic consolidation. There will be a growth of 2 percent, it will be the second year of growth after six years of negative growth, employment will increase by 350,000 people --it is the second year in which employment will increase after seven years of decline-- and they are also the Budgets of tax reduction.

Pensions account for 40 percent of spending, investment increases, the allocations dedicated to promoting employment, R&D, culture, and agriculture, and the reduction of the deficit continues in structural reforms, which is a very positive figure for the whole of the Spanish economy, and therefore also for Catalonia, which sees its investments rise by 19 percent compared to last year.

Therefore, I regret to say that I cannot share your statements and much less the expression of the word "punishment," because I believe they are good Budgets.

Mr. Macías.- Mr. President, the data on public investment is so overwhelming that I believe it does not deserve your time trying to refute them.

Since you have been in power, public investment in Catalonia has decreased by 58 percent, more than in any other Community. We are the autonomy with the lowest investment per capita. While there are more kilometers of toll roads, it is where the least is invested in highways. You are going to initiate a highway plan worth five hundred million: not a single new kilometer in Catalonia.

But, in addition to the meager public investment in your Budgets, none of the demands made by the Generalitat are addressed. Nothing about recognizing the historical debt --in other Communities, yes--; nothing about compensating for the paralysis of the tax on bank deposits --in other Communities, yes--; nor to mention applying the corresponding Competitiveness Fund for the fiscal year and a much greater demand on the Communities than on the Government in reducing the deficit.

Mr. President, you say you deeply love Catalonia. I believe you, but prove it with actions, and if this reason is not enough for you to act, I suggest you heed the recommendation of the Financial Times in light of your stubborn entrenchment. The warning from your editorial is very clear: "Has the Government considered the economic problem that could mean for Spain not responding politically to the Catalan issue?"

President.- Mr. Macías, your words are profoundly unjust, and believe me, it is very difficult to build anything this way.

I reiterate that I do not agree with you. I believe that starting to grow after a long time is very positive; I believe that having growth in Catalonia above the average is also very positive for Catalonia; I believe that starting to reduce unemployment in Catalonia and increasing the number of employed and affiliated with Social Security is also very positive; I believe that in 2015 we will be the country in the eurozone that grows the most is also very positive; and I believe that the effort made by the State, providing forty billion to pay the debt maturities of Catalonia, to pay the deficit, to pay suppliers, pharmacies, and public services, I sincerely believe is very positive.

And I believe that what is being done in terms of investment in these Budgets is also very positive. Investment is 1.8 percent of total spending. Investment in Catalonia rises by 19 percent: roads, 24 percent; railways, 27 percent; airports, 11 percent, and the allocation for ports also increases.

In the overall investment, it is the fourth Community. First is Andalusia, then Castilla y León and Galicia; but in Castilla y León and Galicia, the high-speed train is being built that affects several Autonomous Communities and, of course, northern Spain. Even so, investment continues in Catalonia in Vandellós (Tarragona), in the Mediterranean Corridor, in Cercanías and works on the AP-2 and AP-7 highways, among the most important works.

Therefore, and I reiterate what I said at the beginning, your intervention is profoundly unjust…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, Members, you know, Mr. Rajoy, that today I was going to ask you about employment, about the situation of our labor market; but, unfortunately, Spain is going through exceptionally serious circumstances. The first case has been reported, and we hope it will be the only case, of infection by the Ebola virus, and I would like to convey some considerations on behalf of my Parliamentary Group.

First of all, let it be clear that we will not contribute to sowing doubts or anxiety in public opinion. We will have the opportunity, Mr. Rajoy, to determine what the political responsibilities of this serious case are, which they are, and are, I insist, very serious as well, Mr. Rajoy. But until then, what I ask of the President of the Government and his Government is clarity, information, and, above all, rigor and solvency to guarantee health security in our country.

Look, Mr. Rajoy, I would like to convey to public opinion three issues: first, our wish for the swift recovery of the nursing assistant who has been infected with the Ebola virus; second, our support for all healthcare professionals who are often performing their duties under extraordinarily difficult circumstances due to cuts in public health and also due to the attempts at privatization by their regional governments; and, third, Mr. Rajoy, I would like your Government to convey certainties, guarantees, transparency, clarity, and not to hide information. And judging by what we have seen, and public opinion, over the last few days, Mr. Rajoy, it is more than evident that your Minister of Health, precisely when she has spoken, has only caused more uncertainty and more anxiety in public opinion.

What we ask of you, Mr. Rajoy, is: one, to clarify what has happened; two, what the risks are, the mistakes that have been made; third, if there is an evident risk of infection from the Ebola virus; and fourth, what measures you have put in place to prevent this from happening.

And finally, Mr. Rajoy, we would also like you to allocate all necessary resources to healthcare professionals so that they can carry out all their duties under the best conditions, because it is more than evident that today they cannot do so.

Mr. Rajoy, I would like, ultimately, for you to provide daily information to public opinion and to answer a clear and simple question, and to do so today, here, in the Congress of Deputies, Mr. Rajoy: do you have the Ebola virus infection under control? Can you guarantee that Spaniards are not at risk…?

President.- We are undoubtedly facing a matter that concerns, and rightly so, the whole of public opinion, and I will try to explain to the entire Chamber what decisions and measures have been adopted over the past 48 hours.

First, a Monitoring Committee has been created to ensure that there is coordination between the responsible parties in the Community of Madrid, the Government of Spain, and also with European institutions, with which we speak every day.

The instructions that have been given are as follows: first, to provide all the information that can be given to the public opinion as a whole, and therefore, total transparency in this matter. The first objective is to attend to all patients, to the people who have contracted the disease; one up to this moment. The second objective is to monitor all the people who have been in contact with them. The third objective is to investigate what has happened and why this contagion has occurred. And, fourthly, to explain to the public opinion what the situations are in which this type of situation can occur.

What I ask is that they let the professionals work, that we trust the professionals. They have an established reputation. The Spanish healthcare system is one of the best healthcare systems in the world, and what they are telling me at this moment, which is what I have to convey to the public opinion, is that this is a contagion that is not easy, that direct contact with the patient in an advanced stage is necessary, and that at this moment what we have to do is to be attentive, but maintaining calm.

This is the position of the Government which, I insist, will inform promptly of each and every development that occurs.

Thank you very much.