Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

10 February 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from opposition MPs during a congressional control session in Spain on February 10, 2015.
Main themes
Jihadist terrorism agreement, poverty and social exclusion, unemployment, labor reform, economic recovery, child poverty, worker rights, minimum wage, energy poverty, pensions, company relocations, long-term unemployed assistance
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,763
72nd percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 46%45%
  • Social 37%37%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

108 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of the Left Plural

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, do you think it is more urgent for Spanish citizens to sign an agreement against jihadist terrorism rather than one against poverty?

President.- That the Government and the two main parties in the Chamber sign an agreement against jihadist terrorism seems to me to be pure common sense, and that they agree on this matter as well. Furthermore, this is an agreement open to all political forces and absolutely compatible with signing an agreement to fight against poverty.

Mr. Lara.- Thank you, Mr. Rajoy, for your response; but yesterday we learned of a report from the European Network Against Poverty stating that there are almost thirteen million people in Spain who are at risk of poverty; five million in severe exclusion. We are the second country in child poverty in the European Union, and nine million people are experiencing energy poverty. Your recovery and takeoff is a fallacy: eighty thousand more unemployed in January and two hundred thousand fewer contributors to Social Security. Your labor reform continues to provoke more cheap dismissals. Multinational companies are relocating businesses mercilessly and seeking miserable wages for workers. One third of salaries in Spain are undignified, while banks continue to have more profits and large companies do as well. And your Government is complicit in all this, not only because of your labor reform but also because of the shameful Minimum Interprofessional Wage.

I am meeting every week with workers from companies in crisis: those from Coca-Cola demanding compliance with the ruling; those from John Deere who have announced an ERTE; with workers from companies in Sagunto and, specifically, this week with those from Bosal: 222 workers who were dismissed with a letter on the Day of the Three Kings. What a paradox! These workers are real Spain, Mr. Rajoy. Look at this t-shirt, which is not just a t-shirt. It is real Spain. It is Spain that is suffering the dramas of your policies. They are thousands and thousands of workers who built this country, and who never dreamed, even in their worst nightmares, that they would suffer so many humiliations as they are suffering at this moment.

On behalf of all of them, Mr. Rajoy, I demand today in this Chamber that you create a plan to fight against poverty, that you present an urgent employment plan for the long-term unemployed who have no assistance, and that you repeal the labor reform because, if you do not do it, another Government with a different majority in this Chamber will do it, because this is indeed a true social emergency in this country.

President.- I insist again on what I said in my first response. I believe that signing the agreement against jihadist terrorism is a good decision for our country, it is therefore a good decision for Spain and very positive on the part of those of us who have done it, and I hope that you will also join this agreement.

From there, you have painted a country, frankly, Mr. Lara, that I do not know. Listening to you, one would get the impression that we live in the worst country in the world, where things are worse, where there is more unemployment, where there are more problems, where people have more difficulties… You have painted the worst country in the world and I tell you one thing: Spain has gone through a very significant economic crisis, many things have been done, progress has been made, things are getting better and will continue to improve in the future, but it is true that there are still things to be done. Therefore, I believe that those of us who are dedicated to this should try to have a somewhat balanced judgment of how things are.

But I will tell you some of the decisions we have made that I believe are very positive for fighting against poverty, and the results. First of all, this is a country that is growing economically, it did so in 2014 and will do so in 2015, after six years of negative economic growth. That is activity, that is well-being and wealth.

Last year, after six years of continuous unemployment increase, there were 487,000 fewer unemployed. This year there will be more unemployed less and that will also be a very positive figure.

We have guaranteed pensions and increased them, which affect 9,200,000 people. We have spent, in these three years, almost one hundred billion euros on paying unemployment insurance, we have extended the PREPARA and we have signed an agreement with the trade union organizations, in December, to assist those people who are in the most difficult situation.

We have created a fund against child poverty. Through the Supplier Payment system, we have assisted all those social organizations dedicated to helping those people who were in the most difficult situation.

The latest data from Eurostat, which is the official body of the European Union, indicates that after four consecutive years of increasing poverty, understood as those people who are below 60 percent of the median income of the country, in 2013 there was already an inflection and the data is now more positive; in 2014, and although they are not definitive, they will also be.

Therefore, we are clearly getting better and I ask for a little balance in the judgment.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Parliamentary Group of Catalan Convergence and Union

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, do you not think you should qualify your perspectives for the year 2015 much more, in terms, logically and basically, of economic forecasts?

President.- Mr. Durán, in principle, the forecasts and perspectives for the year 2015 are positive, and I believe that is the data that should encourage us the most. We have always tried to be prudent when making projections. In fact, in 2014 we said in this Chamber that the economy would grow by 0.7 percent, then we changed and said it would be 1.3 percent, and in the end it was 1.4 percent. The same happened with employment forecasts: we said "there will be an increase in unemployment" and we said "employment -0.2 percent"; however, in the end it was plus 0.7 percent. Therefore, I believe it is better to be prudent.

For the year 2015, we believe that the economy, as of today, will grow by 2 percent, we believe that employment will grow and we think there will be six hundred thousand more affiliates to Social Security, which, added to the somewhat more than four hundred thousand from 2014, will put us at one million more people affiliated to Social Security in two years. We believe that the external sector in 2014 will close positively, the deficit will continue to decrease, domestic demand will rise, both consumption and investment, inflation will remain low, and we will gain competitiveness.

In principle, we will modify the forecasts in April when we present the Stability Plan to the European Commission and then, either in July or September, we will make the definitive forecast, as has been customary.

Mr. Duran.- Thank you, Mr. President, for your response. We do not ignore, I do not ignore, undoubtedly, positive aspects of economic improvement, especially in the macroeconomic sphere, and it would be absurd, in this sense, not to recognize it, and it would also be absurd to say that when something goes well, the Government has to have something to do with it, just as when things go badly, we attribute it to the Government.

But having said that, we cannot share and I would like to add the voice of our Parliamentary Group to those voices that believe that you, especially in acts of your political party, are committing an excess of propaganda regarding the exit from the economic crisis.

It is not about painting a black picture, it is about painting a real picture. It is not about painting catastrophism. I am aware that it is good to try to send positive messages that optimize for the future; but one cannot engage in that kind of abusive propaganda when one knows the number of millions of people who do not have jobs. One cannot engage in that abusive propaganda when one knows that more than 50 percent of young people do not have jobs and many, and very well prepared, have to leave the country. One cannot engage in that abusive propaganda when one knows, and you just mentioned competitiveness, that if there is a growth in competitiveness, it is at the expense of wages. And one cannot engage in that when one knows that we are destroying the middle classes. And so many other things, or when credit does not reach SMEs.

Therefore, Mr. President, I suggest that you do less propaganda and face with a plan that you present to this Chamber to really rebuild the social "devastation" --and I emphasize the word "devastation"-- that the economic crisis has caused. Crisis is an economic concept that has its social consequences and no one, neither you, nor I, nor anyone, from either side, has the right to use it in a propagandistic manner, even though we are in an electoral year, obviously.

President.- I regret to say that I cannot share your statements. I have recalled here our forecasts for 2014. The reality was, fortunately, much better for Spain than the forecasts we made, both in terms of growth and job creation. I have spoken to you about the year 2015 and we are talking today about a growth for this year of 2 percent; but the International Monetary Fund says it will be more, the European Commission says it will be more, and all the consensus of analysts that FUNCAS collects also says it will be more, both in terms of employment and in terms of economic growth.

Therefore, I believe we are realistic and I believe we are even making lower forecasts. I insist, we have done this throughout the Legislature and I believe we are doing it now.

On the other hand, it is evident that there are many people who have gone through many difficulties and it is evident that there are people who will continue to do so in the future; but one must say, hey, that things today are better than some time ago and will continue to improve. And I believe that also giving a positive message to the entire Spanish society is good.

If you look at the data we have known in recent times, both in consumption, investment, car sales, housing sales, or in the issue of credit. The year 2014 was the year, according to data from the Bank of Spain, that credit to SMEs grew the most. Prices at this moment are controlled, the competitiveness of the economy is improving, and there are even some external factors that help, such as the exchange rate.

Therefore, moderately optimistic, but there is still much to be done.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, do you consider that your educational counter-reforms are guaranteeing equal opportunities among our youth?

President.- One of the fundamental objectives of our educational reforms is precisely that, to guarantee equal opportunities. I will only refer to one piece of data in this first intervention: an educational model in which dropout rates exceed 26 percent, which were the figures that existed when we came to Government in 2011, is clearly an educational model that is unbearable for parents, for children, for the country, for taxpayers, and for all citizens. That truly undermines equal opportunities and doing nothing would be irresponsible. That is why we have made some important reforms in the area of education.

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, from these seats on the left, and also from the blue benches, the socialists when we have been in Government, have established a free, quality educational system that precisely guaranteed the equal opportunities that you are breaking.

We made it possible for the daughter of a worker to share a university classroom with the son of a wealthy person in this country. We made the desire of many people to become a working middle class possible. And you, with your cutback policies, Mr. Wert and Mr. Rajoy, what you are doing is breaking that dream.

You, Mr. Rajoy, have approved a LOMCE. You have approved a reform of the university system by Royal Decree that is precisely breaking that equality of opportunities. You have cut, Ladies and Gentlemen, 11.5 billion euros in public education investment; you have cut 210 million euros in scholarship policy, while increasing university fees by 40 percent, and you have cut, Mr. Rajoy, remember well, 33,500 teachers in our educational system, 6,000 of them university professors.

It is true that you have now approved in that university reform that famous 3+2, which has nothing to do with merit, effort, or talent of students; on the contrary. It is clear, crystal clear, in the resolution of the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy of the Autonomous Communities and of Mr. Montoro in his measure 108: the 3+2 means a saving of one billion euros. That is to say, cut, cut, and cut in our university system.

Look, Mr. Rajoy, whenever the right governs, they orient their educational policy in the same direction, which is to break equality of opportunities. You want to create in our university system first and second division students, whose future possibilities depend on the bank account of their parents, and we will not allow that, Mr. Rajoy.

Any middle-class working parent wants a government that helps their children open universities so they can study for a degree, not close them, as you have been doing since you have been governing this country, Mr. Rajoy. But, look, there is good news about your educational counter-reforms: they will last little, as little as your government, that is, until next November.

President.- I agree with the last part of your speech: that if you come to power, you would repeal the reforms made by the Popular Party, because you have done it once before. The problem is that this time I am afraid you will not come to the Government of Spain.

But that said, I would like to tell you one thing. Mr. Sánchez, there are too many children who drop out of school or fail, there are too many in our country. There are too many who are not good enough, and for many years now, the PISA reports on Spanish education have shown this. And, moreover, and most importantly, there are too many young people who cannot find work in our country due to lack of qualifications. In a situation like this, there are two options, only two: one, to do nothing, which is your thesis, and the other, to try to make reforms, which is ours. And I remind you that the only laws that have been applied in Spain in educational matters in recent years were those of the Socialist Party, and I remind you that the results in education are absolutely improvable.

I want a public, free, and universal education; but I also want a quality education that generates opportunities for people to be employed. That is the purpose of the reforms we have proposed throughout this legislature.

There are some positive data that we are already seeing, such as the increase in the number of people enrolled in Vocational Training -- we have gone from 703,000 students to 793,000 in one year -- or the new Basic Vocational Training cycle, which has already generated 46,000 places.

You talk about cuts in education. Tell me one single year in the budgetary history of this country, since 1977, where more money has been dedicated to scholarships. Tell me one single year. Tell me one single year in which more money was dedicated than in 2014 and in which there are more university scholarship holders than now. And I remind you that the Autonomous Community of Spain that has made the most cuts in education over the years has been Andalusia, and that it is the third community with the fewest teachers in public centers. Therefore, it would be advisable, apart from preaching, to give wheat.

Thank you very much.