Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

10 March 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish parliament on March 10, 2015, responding to questions on child poverty and industrial policy during a parliamentary control session.
Main themes
Child poverty, unemployment and job creation, social inclusion programs, industrial policy, innovation and R&D investment, energy competitiveness, logistics and transport infrastructure, fiscal policy for industry, Mediterranean Corridor, parliamentary accountability
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,170
61st percentile
Sentences
99
62nd percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%36%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

99 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, I ask you to speak with your heart in your hand. I ask you to be sincere, to say what you think, to say what you feel. Do you think enough is being done against child poverty? Do you think it is being done well or do you not care? Or does it go in one ear and out the other? What a sad pity, Mr. Rajoy. What a sad pity!

President.- Speaking of quotes, Mr. Bosch, the Zero Poverty campaign, which brings together more than 4,200 organizations in the field of social action in Catalonia, issued a statement last January saying that it sees no progress in the Generalitat's budget for 2015 in the fight against poverty and inequalities. Those budgets were supported by your political group.

I will tell you what we are doing on a topic that, precisely because it can be dramatic, requires us to be fair and act sensibly and set aside demagoguery.

I want to make the following considerations. The first is that the main factor explaining child poverty is parental unemployment and, therefore, the most important policy in this area, as in many others, is to make an effort to generate employment in our country and end unemployment. Fortunately, substantial progress was made in 2014, and I hope that between 2014 and 2015, one million jobs will be created in our country.

That said, what I have just pointed out is by no means sufficient, and that is why we have done more things and are willing to do whatever is necessary to improve the situation of children.

We have approved a Social Inclusion Plan, and this plan, to which you refer, is endowed this year with 32 million euros; a concerted plan aimed at social services and Local Corporations for an amount of twenty-seven million euros; subsidies for social programs from personal income tax, more than six hundred million in this Legislature; a food payment fund, forty million euros, and the FLA and the Payment Plan to Suppliers also serve to attend to health, education, and social services of the municipalities and Autonomous Communities.

We have created a new financing mechanism, which is the social fund, so that the services that municipalities dedicate to social purposes through agreements with Autonomous Communities can effectively be reimbursed. We have approved a specific fund for families in situations of special difficulty. We have extended the PREPARA program and have signed an extraordinary program with the unions to train people so they can work. We have approved emergency social programs, aid to the social housing fund, and a great effort has been made in the Income Tax.

Can much more be done? We will do whatever is necessary, but it is not fair to say that this problem is not being addressed.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pere Macías, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Macías.- I would like, first of all, to express our heartfelt solidarity with the people of Madrid, today, March 11, a day of sad remembrance.

Mr. President, to get out of the crisis, industrial policy is needed. Europe wants all countries to have 20 percent of their GDP generated by industry. We have lost a million jobs. You know, Mr. President, the ripple effect that industry has on other economic sectors. Recovery will only be sustainable with industry. This, in other words, was formulated by our spokesperson in the Debate on the State of the Nation, a debate in which we heard many disqualifications and, certainly, few proposals. In fact, no response to our spokesperson regarding industrial policy.

For this reason, we reformulate some of the most relevant issues that, in our opinion, should guide industrial policy, and we will address four topics: we will talk about promoting innovation, being competitive in energy, reducing logistics transport costs, and a fiscal policy that attracts industrial investment. There are some industrial sectors, for example, the chemical industry, in Tarragona and other industrial parks throughout Spain, very concerned about these aspects.

Mr. President, first of all, energy policy. Our industries are not competitive with an energy reform that has only been made for budgetary reasons.

Regarding innovation, between 2010 and 2015, budgets have decreased public investment in innovation by 50 percent. This is unacceptable at this time.

If we talk about logistics and transport, two issues: authorization of vehicles with greater load capacity. In Portugal, sixty tons; in Spain, forty. How are we going to be competitive, Mr. President? If we talk about logistics, the Mediterranean Corridor, according to you, was supposed to be operational in February 2015, and the works have yet to begin.

And if we talk about fiscal policy, we have just withdrawn aid for investment in environmental modernization. Europe demands that we apply the best available techniques.

What are we doing to help industry? We are withdrawing aid. Industries, Mr. President, are going to leave. For this reason, I ask you, Mr. President, to sharpen your focus on industrial policy.

President.- I join your initial words, Mr. Macías, and the initiative of the President of the Chamber.

I want to tell you that I agree with you on the importance of industrial policy for generating economic growth and employment. We are talking, moreover, about a sector that, as everyone knows, generates stable employment; generates qualified employment; concentrates the majority of our exports, 80 percent; the activity of R&D+i that the private sector carries out is very important and is associated with a significant volume of activity in the services sector.

Therefore, you are absolutely right; that is to say, industrial policy is very important in our country.

What have we done throughout this time? First of all, all the necessary reforms, and also those that we will make in the future, have as their fundamental objective industrial policy. Labor reform is useful for industrial policy, so is energy reform, so is financial reform and the return to credit, as well as the market unity program and the tax reform that we have launched.

I could cite many others; but, in addition to this, due to its specific nature, I want to refer to the Agenda for Strengthening the Spanish industrial sector. These are more specific measures that contribute to improving the business environment in which the industrial productive fabric develops its activity. There are many concrete measures: financial support measures, industrial investment measures, and programs for sectors such as automotive, naval, or aerospace.

The PIVE, the PIME, the Food Chain Law, regulations on ship financing, shipbuilding, aid for R&D+i, and the aerospace sector have been launched.

Therefore, important decisions have been made for an industrial sector that is now growing and is being useful for creating jobs in the Spanish economy.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, do you consider your management adequate given the effects of the Ebro flood?

President.- I want to start by conveying my solidarity and support, and that of the entire Government, to all the people affected by the events that occurred last week, as I already did last Friday in the city of Zaragoza.

I believe that from the very first moment we have worked in a coordinated manner with the Autonomous Communities and with the municipalities, the Civil Guard, the UME, the Police, the firefighters of the Provincial Council, and the staff of the General Council of Aragon. Everyone has been up to the task. I believe that the technicians have also done an essential job in terms of reservoir management.

The Government has been there. On February 11, before the events occurred, the Vice President was already meeting with several government delegates. On Friday the 27th, the president of the General Council of Aragon was at the advanced command post and visited all the municipalities. We spoke with the Government of Aragon over the weekend. On Sunday, the Secretary of State for the Environment was present; on Monday, the Minister of the Interior; and on Tuesday, the Minister of Agriculture. Throughout the week, we prepared the Royal Decree Law to compensate for the damages.

I was in contact on several occasions with the president of the Community, and on Friday I presented to the mayors of the affected municipalities the measures agreed upon in the Royal Decree Law that we studied in the Council of Ministers on the same day, and we also proposed to start making decisions to try to prevent, which is not easy because it is not the first time this has happened, that these serious events occur again in the future.

Therefore, ideally, as is natural, this type of event should not have occurred; but I believe that what needed to be done was done.

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, you, on March 6, when you hastily visited the city of Zaragoza, summarized your political action philosophy in a single sentence; you said: "I go where I am taken." You said that verbatim: "I go where I am taken."

Ladies and gentlemen, this is the problem. The problem is that we have a president who does not empathize with the suffering of the people. We have a Prime Minister who does not know where he is going and, what is more serious, ladies and gentlemen, we have a Prime Minister who is neither present, nor interested, nor cares about the suffering of the people. That is why you have not yet met with the farmers, nor with the ranchers, nor with the affected neighbors of the Ebro River, who are not only in the city of Zaragoza; they are throughout the province of Zaragoza, Mr. Rajoy, and they are also in Navarra, in La Rioja, and in Castilla y León. And they are waiting for you and your Government, Mr. Rajoy.

The undeniable fact is that there are some things your Government could have avoided: for example, the inaccuracy in the river's flow; for example, the systematic cuts in everything related to public investments in maintaining the riverbed, and also in the payment of the compensations that you still have pending to pay to all those affected by the floods of 2013. Although that must be the usual tone from your Government, because that also happens with other compensations: for example, in Puerto Lumbreras or, for example, also in the disaster in Lorca, Mr. Rajoy.

And now you present a Royal Decree hastily that is, in all respects, insufficient; insufficient. I will tell you one thing, ladies and gentlemen of the Popular Parliamentary Group, Mr. President of the Government, Mr. Rajoy: you have left many things behind in that flood. One of them is your credibility as Prime Minister, Mr. Rajoy; yes. You hide every time there is a problem, and that is why you have refused to answer questions here that relate to the "Gürtel" plot and that directly implicate your party, Mr. Rajoy; yes.

But the problem, do you know what it is? The problem is that, while you remain silent, we have a Minister of Justice who intimidates and threatens the investigating judge of the "Gürtel" case, and we have a Minister of Finance who does not collaborate with justice and uses the Tax Agency in a partisan manner.

And I tell you one thing, Mr. Rajoy: as president of the Popular Party, have you paid the 245,000 euros bail demanded by the National Court for the "Gürtel" case? Stop hiding, come here to the Congress of Deputies and take responsibility as president of the Popular Party that...

Mr. Posada: Mr. President, I remind you that you only have the right to respond to the question on the agenda.

President.- I will do so, Mr. President, and I will not ask Mr. Sánchez for explanations about the 850 million from the EREs in Andalusia, which we still do not know in this Chamber what they were allocated for, nor about the more than 250 indicted that have occurred, nor for the lack of explanations from the president of the Junta de Andalucía.

I will not refer to that. I will refer to what you did when you went to Zaragoza. It was there when the Government had already been there. You went there to criticize everyone: the Prime Minister, the Minister of Agriculture, the Minister of the Interior, and the Secretary of State for the Environment. It gave the impression that you went there to see if you could fish something. You wanted to withdraw the question you asked me here today because you saw that you could no longer do anything. You forgot to tell the entire Chamber that the major works, such as Yesa and Biscarrués, were halted, which would probably have prevented many of these problems.

Really, the impression I have, Mr. Sánchez, is that you should not campaign at the expense of people's suffering, nor should you discredit the technicians.