Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

29 November 2016 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on public broadcaster RTVE's credibility, financing, and governance during a congressional control session on November 29, 2016.
Main themes
Radiotelevisión Española reform, public broadcasting independence and credibility, financing model for public media, pension increases, labor reform, fiscal policy and autonomous communities, media audiences, governance of public broadcaster, political negotiation and consensus
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,127
60th percentile
Sentences
77
50th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%39%
  • Institutional 34%32%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

77 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, in the latest CIS, 19 percent of the citizens acknowledge getting information through Radiotelevisión Española; five years ago that figure was 39 percent, a drop of twenty points in five years. Meanwhile, there has been a unilateral change in the majority to elect the President, allegations of manipulation by professionals, and also a drastic decrease in the contribution from the General State Budgets.

Today we have a Radiotelevisión Española, with excellent professionals, but drained in terms of credibility, quality, and audience, and with an economic model currently questioned regarding its sustainability.

I have heard you on various occasions, Mr. Rajoy, say that your ideal model is that of the BBC, and what I want to know is whether you believe you have taken the right steps to achieve it and, if not, what are you going to do from now on?

President.- Mr. Hernando, the Radiotelevisión Española Corporation and the professionals who work there are plural and independent. You may like how one news item is presented more or less than I do; but I, for my part, defend the professionalism and independence of those professionals.

In Televisión Española and Radio Nacional, leaders of different parties that are part of this Chamber are interviewed; you or me, probably you more often than me. Furthermore, external collaborators, journalists who work in different media with different perspectives, regularly participate in the news programs, and there they express their opinions as they see fit and appropriate.

Regarding the economy of Televisión Española, I remember that you carried out an ERE that cost the public treasury 1.5 billion euros, and I remind you that you left us without income because you eliminated advertising. I also tell you that, for the first time in a long time, this year Televisión Española will close its accounts without any deficit.

As for the audiences, look at the audiences for the month of November: the news services of the Radiotelevisión Española Corporation are the ones that accumulate the highest number of viewers.

Mr. Hernando.- Evolve, Mr. President. Our goal is to guarantee a quality public service, with content that is attractive, independent, credible, and economically sustainable. And, as we are at the beginning of a legislature and at the end of a framework mandate, what I propose to you and the other Groups in the Chamber is that we reach a great agreement to create a new financing model, a new governance model for the Radiotelevisión Española Corporation, and a new public service programming model, Mr. Rajoy, that guarantees, on the one hand, excellence and, on the other hand, the future of Radiotelevisión Española and its professionals.

And why now? Because you do not have an absolute majority, and that is very positive, Mr. Rajoy, because it forces you to rectify and negotiate, on this issue of Radiotelevisión Española and also on other issues such as, for example, pensions. You have vetoed the pension increase that several Groups in the Chamber have requested, and the elderly need that pension increase, Mr. Rajoy.

Last week I told you: you have an important meeting with the unions, and that meeting did not go well for you, because the unions, the next day, were calling for mobilizations, which we support, because they refuse to reform the most harmful aspects of your labor reform. This week you have a Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, which will go poorly if you insist on not negotiating with the Autonomous Communities and with the Groups so that there are no cuts in the services, in the benefits that the Autonomous Communities and Local Entities provide.

Therefore, Mr. Rajoy, do not obsess over the policies of the past, do not obsess over the past. Rectify, rectify now, in Radiotelevisión Española and also in the increase of pensions.

President.- You have made a mix, Mr. Hernando, because pensions, the Autonomous Communities, Local Corporations, unions, and other colleagues have appeared here.

I am willing to talk to you about anything you want. I do want to point out one thing: that the most important challenge that Televisión Española has is not the challenge you have referred to -- this is the discourse we have heard for the last forty years, and you and we have done it; the most important challenge that Televisión Española has today is to ensure that it is at the forefront of the movements that are taking place.

Important things are happening in the audiovisual world: new technologies, new forms of consumption, interactivity, the multiplication of supply… Today there are new distributors and new producers that compete with classic operators. Today, content is consumed through screens, mobile phones, tablets, and computers. Many people already watch television on demand, and it is also very important the number of people who watch television on demand. And I believe that the most important challenge that Televisión Española has today is to adapt to the changes that are taking place in the audiovisual world.

I am willing to talk to you about whatever you want, but this is, without a doubt, the key issue and it is what will serve to guarantee…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Manuel Iglesias, of the Confederal Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President, what does the Executive plan to do to implement the decisions of the Legislature?

President.- We plan to implement those that must be implemented.

Mr. Iglesias.- Impressive response, Mr. Mariano Rajoy.

As you know, the Spanish Constitution, as is normal, reserves legislative power to the Cortes Generales; a power that these Cortes share with the Government, by delegation through legislative decrees, or through the Government's own initiative via decree laws. I will not fall into the temptation of quoting Baron de Montesquieu to talk to you about the separation of powers; for that, your partner Albert Rivera already covered himself in glory yesterday by claiming the anti-Semite Henry Ford as an entrepreneurial figure. But I will tell you that, in Spain, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, sovereignty resides in Parliament and sovereignty is expressed through Parliament's ability to make laws that modify people's lives in some way.

First question, Mr. Mariano Rajoy: you have said that you will veto any decision of this Parliament that affects the Budget. You have even used the veto to position yourselves against a decision of this Parliament, such as the suspension of the LOMCE calendar, which is a social demand in this country. First question, Mr. Mariano Rajoy: do you not think that if this Parliament cannot make decisions that affect the Budget, its legislative power and, therefore, its exercise of sovereignty is compromised and limited?

Secondly, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, you have informed this Congress that you are dissatisfied with the fact that proposals related to such disparate issues as judicial fees or energy poverty are being processed here. I ask you a question: what concerns you more, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, what this Parliament thinks or what the German Chancellor, Mrs. Merkel, thinks? Because I believe that many citizens in Spain have the impression that Mrs. Merkel has more power in Spain than this Parliament, and that is a problem that should concern you.

President.- Mrs. Merkel has never given me an order, but if she has given you one, let me know, because I will call your attention.

Mr. Iglesias, we live, as Mr. Rivera has very well said, in a system of separation of powers. There are three powers, and each has its functions, and the functions of all three must be respected.

The Legislative Power (Article 66 of the Constitution) has, fundamentally, three functions: to approve the Budgets, to control the government's actions, and to exercise legislative power; therefore, the Legislative Power is in charge there. The Executive Power, according to Article 97 of the Constitution, has other functions: to direct domestic and foreign policy, civil and military administration, and the defense of the State, to exercise the executive function and regulatory power, that is, to govern; in that area, the one who decides, as is natural, is the Government. And there is another power, which is the Judicial Power, which guarantees compliance with the Law by all, by the Legislative Power and by the Executive Power and by any citizen.

That is democracy: three powers, each with its functions and each independent.

Therefore, the control of the Government is done as this Chamber says; the Budget that is approved is the one that this Chamber approves; the laws that the Government must comply with and respect are the ones that this Chamber says, and the rest is the function of the Government: to govern. And that, Mr. Iglesias, is the case, I must say that fortunately, it is so in all the countries around us, it has been so in our country since 1977, and I hope it continues to be so in the future.

It is about respecting the competencies of all: Legislative Power, Executive Power, and Judicial Power. Frankly, I do not think it is that difficult.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gabriel Rufián, of the Esquerra Republicana Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rufián.- Mr. President, as you know, tomorrow is an important day, it is the International Day of the Fight against AIDS, and, as you probably also know, the condom is our main ally in this fight. And I do not say this, experts as distinguished as Buenaventura Clotet say it. Given that, since you became President of the Government, the Budget in this area has been reduced by 70 percent, what types of measures do you have in mind to promote the use of condoms?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Rufián. Indeed, tomorrow is World AIDS Day. It is a reminder for all of us to continue fighting this disease and other sexually transmitted diseases. Much progress has been made in recent times, as you know, in prevention and treatment; but we must continue working with at-risk groups, we must combat the social or labor effects that these diseases generate, we must raise awareness among citizens, we must advance in early diagnosis, and we must further promote the training of healthcare personnel, among many other areas.

It is an effort that we will seek to redouble this Legislature, continuing the efforts that both the Government and the Autonomous Communities, which have a substantial part of the competencies in this area, have made in recent years.

Mr. Rufián.- Mr. President, the truth is that the question was about the condom, the condom. We are not talking about Bárcenas; you can say it: condom, preservative. That said, it is also worth remembering, and since it seems you are not very clear on this, from Esquerra Republicana we propose that, for example, the same VAT should not be paid for a hotel suite as for a condom and, while we are at it, the same VAT should not be paid for a "Jaguar" as for a diaper.

President.- Thank you very much for your reply, Mr. Rufián.

As you know, although it may not seem so to you, numerous efforts are being made by the Ministry of Health, and as I mentioned earlier, also by the Autonomous Communities in the fight against AIDS.

Prevention measures are very important, they are essential, and that is why the Government coordinates, through the Ministry of Health, the Strategic Plan for the prevention and control of HIV infection and other sexually transmitted infections in a plan that is agreed upon with the Autonomous Communities and scientific societies.

In addition, the Government collaborates in various programs with grants to Non-Governmental Organizations. These grants have increased by 72 percent, and this Friday, in the Council of Ministers, we will agree on their distribution.

We must also add to these programs those developed by the Autonomous Communities, in which the Government I preside also collaborates, whose basic objective is to raise awareness, especially among adolescents, about preventive and responsible behaviors.

On the other hand, there is also a great international battle, led by the United Nations, in the fight against AIDS. Spain has already met two of the major objectives for the year 2020, as it did in 2015. More than 90 percent of diagnosed individuals are on antiretroviral treatment, and more than 90 percent of those on treatment have an undetectable viral load.

There are undoubtedly many things left to do; but we will continue working in the same direction, coordinated with Non-Governmental Organizations, the Autonomous Communities, scientific societies, and the Government of Spain…