Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

7 March 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to opposition questions during a parliamentary control session in the Spanish Congress on March 7, 2017, defending his government against allegations of interference in anti-corruption prosecutions.
Main themes
Anti-corruption prosecution, attorney general appointments, judicial independence, government interference in justice, Popular Party financing scandal, parliamentary accountability, rule of law in Spain, Murcia regional corruption case, political party corruption investigations
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,979
75th percentile
Sentences
110
67th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.26
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

110 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, I believe that Spanish citizens have watched with perplexity and some concern certain actions and statements from your Government regarding prosecutors who have been fighting against corruption for many years. You have relieved prosecutors, at the proposal of the Attorney General, appointed by you, in key positions in the fight against crime: the National Court, the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, and certain Superior Courts of Justice.

Your Minister of Justice, who is present here, has publicly criticized the actions of prosecutors in the Region of Murcia who are fighting against corruption, to defend a party colleague of his, the president of the Region of Murcia, currently indicted for alleged crimes of abuse of power, fraud, forgery, and embezzlement of public funds. In fact, all of Spain caught your Minister of Justice desperately trying to speak with the president of the Region of Murcia just hours before the Attorney General relieved him of a second indictment. What would have happened with a similar episode involving the Minister of Justice in France or Germany?

What I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, is whether you believe that these episodes improve citizens' trust in Justice.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Hernando. You referred in your speech to two issues: first, a matter concerning a Region of Spain, Murcia; and, second, to the appointments of prosecutors.

On both matters, the Attorney General has intervened in this Chamber, and I believe he has been sufficiently clear. In the case of Murcia, he stated that there was no type of interference, pressure, or following from the Government, and he affirmed that he acted in full accordance with what is provided in the Statute of the Public Prosecutor's Office in case of disagreement between prosecutors and their hierarchical superiors. And regarding the appointments, as you know, these positions are discretionary. They are made for a period of five years; 35 positions have now been called (twenty-five because their term ended and ten for other reasons), of the twenty-five, nineteen have been renewed, and only five have been changed. They were proposed by the Attorney General after hearing the Fiscal Council, fulfilling all the requirements established by law, and the Government has ratified them.

You referred here to the case of the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office; quite simply, it was vacant. You also referred to the case of the National Court; the person who was not renewed had been in office for eleven years, and there is no reason why he should be there for another five, or no reason why he cannot be replaced, as has been done, in accordance with the law.

Therefore, I regret to say that I cannot share your reasoning or your arguments, and I do believe that this does not benefit Justice.

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. Rajoy, I already imagined you would tell me that everything is normal; "it wasn't me, let them search me," which is what you almost always say to me.

The issue is that we have learned that the last Attorney General was relieved of her position for resisting making the appointments that have now been carried out. Three attorneys in five years: the first left because he could not withstand the pressures or refused to admit the pressures, and the last one left because she did not want to make the appointments that have now been pushed through.

What I tell you, Mr. Rajoy, is to stop meddling with Justice, especially in those cases that directly affect you, for the Popular Party to stop trying to annul the proceedings in which it is involved, and to stop destroying evidence or destroying computers, because Justice, in the end, will reach its ultimate consequences, and so will politics.

And why do I say that politics will also come, Mr. Rajoy? Because, in this Congress of Deputies, you will have to give explanations about the financing of the Popular Party in the last twenty years and about the "black box," because there is an investigative commission, registered by my Group, that we are going to bring to this Plenary for it to be voted on and, surely, approved. And this, regardless of the fact that you literally disregard the agreement you have with another political formation to investigate, among other things, why four treasurers of the Popular Party are currently indicted. You no longer have an absolute majority; it will be investigated, and the truth will be known, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- Mr. Hernando, I must say that the reason why the previous Attorney General is no longer the Attorney General is not the one you have stated here. It is absolutely false that any appointment was attempted to be imposed on the previous Attorney General. Therefore, I must state in this Chamber, solemnly, that you are not telling the truth.

Secondly, I am not going to tell you what the previous Attorney General appointed by you did, because it makes no sense. I believe that does not contribute anything, nor does it make sense for us to have a debate on this topic.

I want to reiterate that you have not provided a single argument on the substance of the matter. You have not explained here why the Government has made the appointments poorly, and you have not explained here why the words of the Attorney General, which I read at the beginning of this intervention, are not acceptable. Frankly, I believe that the question you just asked here leads absolutely nowhere. If there are indictments from my political force, it will be because the Prosecutor's Office has acted, and I sincerely believe that if we want to build for the future, what we need to do is work on the creation of the subcommittee that will deal with the National Justice Strategy.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, of the Citizens Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President of the Government, we reached an investiture agreement to support your investiture, that of your Parliamentary Group, from Citizens and the Popular Party, 150 reforms to improve Spain, and I must acknowledge that some of them are progressing: we have launched the Citizens' self-employed reform; the Minister acknowledged yesterday or the day before that he will lower the cultural VAT for live performances; we have changed the paternity leave, which has been increased; we are in an educational pact that has never existed in this Chamber, and today a new Electoral Law, a reform of the Electoral Law, is being approved after forty years. And I must say that until we utter the word "corruption," everything is going well.

What is the problem? That we have run into corruption, Mr. Rajoy. When we talk about meeting the demands, those six demands, and one of them is to create the investigative commission on the alleged illegal financing of the Popular Party, there you do not comply, you have no word.

This is the agreement of the anti-corruption pact; here is the signature of Mr. Juan Carlos Girauta, and I believe, if he has not forged it, that it is that of Mr. Rafael Hernando; I believe it is yours. So, if this is the signature of Mr. Rafael Hernando and you said in that chamber that "do not doubt that I will fulfill the 150 points," I ask you why you tell us that you will not fulfill just the point to study the illegal financing of your party.

President.- I certainly have not said that I will not fulfill any of the 150 points of the agreement. Moreover, as you have just pointed out here, when we have been in the Legislature for very few months, we are already fulfilling a very important part of the agreement we signed with all of you.

In any case, I also want to remind you that one of the points of the agreement is the creation of a Commission for Democratic Quality, which we have created; that there is a subcommittee for studies to discuss, among other things, the financing of political parties -- I suppose from all political parties--; that in that commission a series of independent experts have appeared who, among other things, have said that the proposals approved by the Popular Party in the last Legislature undoubtedly go in the right direction; that we can continue working for new proposals, and I am willing to consider them, and that the treasurers of all parties will appear before that Commission, who, without any doubt, will give a good account of the matter you are interested in.

Mr. Rivera.- Well, you are not going to fulfill the point of the investigative commission! But do not worry, Mr. Rajoy; there is a parliamentary majority, and you no longer have an absolute majority. I do not know if you have realized that you do not have more than 180 seats; you have 137, so that commission will be set up.

But, Mr. Rajoy, you supported and requested, Mrs. Sánchez-Camacho, and I was in Parliament, the investigative commission on the "Pujol case" because it was the "Pujol case," and it was not Bárcenas in the "Pujol case," it was Mr. Pujol.

In Andalusia, Mr. Moreno Bonilla rightly requested, with us, the investigative commission on the training courses, and the commission on the training courses was set up. However, when it is from the PSOE, it must be set up quickly; when it is from Convergència, it must be accelerated quickly; and now, when it is from the PP, we must study possible measures of… No, no; we are going to study the "black box" of your party, Mr. Rajoy, and do you know why? Because you have full attendance at 15: four of the treasurers are indicted. I do not know if they will come or if they will have to do Sky, like Mr. Granados, from prison; but they will come, and there will be an investigative commission.

And I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, to keep your word. This Parliamentary Group, and it was not easy, fulfilled. We were responsible, we gave support, we trusted that you had your word, we trusted that your party would comply, and you are not complying. So I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, to keep your word, because, with you or without you, the investigative commission on the "black box" of the Popular Party will be set in motion.

President.- I have already told you, Mr. Rivera, that I am willing to discuss this matter with you or with whomever you tell me. We can talk about creating an investigative commission, indeed, on this point in the Congress of Deputies or in the Senate, because the agreement does not specify where it will be created; we can discuss whether it only affects the financing of the Popular Party or also the financing, for example, of Podemos, of the PSOE, or of yours; we can also discuss whether the financing is from 1990 or from when, and we can, above all, discuss, Mr. Rivera, whether this is positive or serves to build something.

In any case, as I said before, I believe that there are many parts of the pact we have signed that are being fulfilled. The other day there were some magnificent data regarding job creation in our country: more than 580,000 people found a job in the last year. I believe we need to discuss whether we want to build for the future on dependency, on pensions, or on the stevedoring, what we are going to do with the stevedoring, because this is a very important issue, as you know, Mr. Rivera. And these are issues that undoubtedly matter to all citizens.

Therefore, I am willing to talk with you about all the topics you want to address; but I would also like to say that I believe it would be positive for us to look to the future because, if we look too much to the past, it may happen like to Lot's wife, do you remember?: she turned into a pillar of salt.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Tardá, of the Esquerra Republicana Parliamentary Group

Mr. Tardá.- Mr. President, today the struggles for women's rights are commemorated worldwide, whether they have a vulva or a penis, and since Spanish legislation guarantees equality between men and women, I would like to know what you attribute to the fact that Spain is the second State in the European Union with the highest female unemployment rate. For what reason does the wage gap already reach 20 percent? For what reason do seven out of ten female pensioners live on the brink of poverty? Why are there women hotel maids who earn two euros per hour worked? Or why do the vast majority of transgender women suffer social and labor exclusion, if not harassment?

Then, I ask you: are you convinced that there is effective and real equality?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Tardá.

I want to begin this intervention by condemning in the strongest and most emphatic terms the violence exercised against women, which is undoubtedly the cruelest exponent of the lack of equality.

That said, I believe that the laws in Spain, in general, are good. Naturally, they are improvable, like any human work; but I believe that our problem is not a problem of laws. What we fundamentally need to do is eliminate the barriers of fact. In any case, I am absolutely convinced that steps are being taken in the right direction, that we are on the right path, and I will give you just one piece of data, just one in this part of my intervention: this March 8, 2017, is the March 8 in history with the most women working in our country. I believe this is great news, and I think this should encourage us to persevere in what we have done together in recent times. There is much to be done, but I believe we are taking steps in the right direction.

Mr. Tardá. - Mr. Rajoy, you have not been able to bury or combat the sociological Francoism that coined a heteropatriarchal model, yes, a heteropatriarchal model, that generates inequalities.

And yes, it is a problem of laws. Let me give you an example: if you are not able to grant a mandatory and equal leave for both members of the couple, it is ultimately the woman who assumes the responsibilities of family care. This entails, in addition to imposing a double workload... Furthermore, it means precarious work, part-time jobs. Inability to advance professionally and, of course, minimal contributions to Social Security, which means a greater feminization of poverty.

But I must also tell you that I am not surprised because, after forty years of democracy in the Spanish State, you have a Constitution --this is said by a republican and one who is not Spanish; he is, but he is not--, how is it that the Constitution still states that the male is preeminent over the female in the line of succession. This, to you who are Spanish and monarchic, should embarrass you and on a day like today, even more so.

So, do not give us lessons on anything. Today is a day when you should recognize that you have not been able, I repeat, to bury sociological Francoism and, since you have not been able to bury it, you should acknowledge that it is a problem of laws. Yes, it is a problem of laws and, as it is, I believe that at the very least it would be a politically good and sincere gesture that today...

President. - Thank you very much, Mr. Tardá. I have no intention of giving you lessons on absolutely anything. Well, I would like you not to give me lessons either, but if you want, I couldn't care less, because I can also learn something from you.

What I say is that if you want to modify some laws, say so and we are willing to consider it; in fact, we are doing so in this Chamber. But I believe that the fundamental problem --I believe so, you may think otherwise-- is not a problem of laws and I believe that, moreover, we are making progress and taking steps in the right direction.

Earlier I spoke to you about what is happening at the level of all Spain. Today I tell you that this March 8, 2017, is the March 8 in the history of Catalonia, where there are more women working and that is a positive fact. A few years ago, female unemployment was growing at 9.64 percent per year and now it is decreasing at 8.79 percent per year. Well, that is also a positive fact.

The activity rate between men and women is getting much closer: look, in 1987 the difference was 36 points and now the difference is 11 points. The same goes for the wage gap: the latest data from Eurostat says that between 2009 and 2014 the difference has decreased by three points. The same happens with pensions.

Mr. Tardá, we are doing things better, the whole of society --I am no longer talking about the Government of Spain-- and I believe that this is improving. Can it improve more? Without a doubt. So let us work together to do so; but let us not use any day or any opportunity to criticize the Government. I am willing to consider what you do but, honestly, I believe you are wrong and, once again, you have been unable to provide a single idea beyond the permanent complaint.

Thank you very much.