Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

19 September 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish parliament on 19 September 2017 during a parliamentary control session, responding to questions on judicial resources and the Catalan independence crisis.
Main themes
Judicial resources and staffing, administration of justice in Spain, anti-corruption prosecution, rule of law, Catalonia and democratic legitimacy, budgetary investments in justice, parliamentary accountability, judicial independence, Spain-Catalonia political crisis
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,429
66th percentile
Sentences
92
59th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.32
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 64%61%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

92 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Margarita Robles, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Robles.- Mr. President, do you consider that in Spain the number of judges and prosecutors is sufficient to make the exercise of their function a reality?

President.- Ms. Robles, as you very well know, Justice is an essential public service, it is a pillar of our Rule of Law, and the objective of any Government, and certainly of the one I preside over, is to provide Justice with the adequate means to exercise its function.

We have made significant efforts in recent times. The Justice Budgets have grown in 2015 by 1.2 percent; in 2016, by 7.3 percent, and they are growing again this year by 7.7 percent, much more than the average of the Budget, as you know. For this year, investments for the improvement of infrastructures, technological modernization, and equipment renewal have also increased by 86 percent. We have bet on the digitalization of Justice. We are providing tools that allow for better organization of it. There is strong support for the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office: the number of prosecutors has increased by 40 percent; the number of delegates in provinces, by 14 percent; the number of support staff in the Tax Agency has grown, as well as the support staff in the Civil Guard, and since 2014, 317 reinforcements have been approved in the Prosecutor's Office.

In 2017, 100 new judge positions are created, as well as 89 new Courts, and we are working on the preparation of the Budget for 2018: we are going to create 75 new judicial units, 69 new units in the Prosecutor's Office, in addition to another 300 new positions for judges and prosecutors; specifically, 200 for judges and 100 for prosecutors.

Ms. Robles.- Mr. Rajoy, I see that you know little about the reality of the Administration of Justice and, what is worse, I believe you care little.

I would refer you here, to this parliamentary avenue, and that you see the appearances of the associations of judges and prosecutors this month of May that practically launched an SOS in the face of the situation of collapse that Justice is experiencing in Spain. And I would tell you that when you go out, for example, in Pontevedra, to take those walks, you should meet with the citizens, not just with journalists; with those 1,296 citizens in Pontevedra who have filed lawsuits for floor clauses and who have to go to a Court in Vigo that is absolutely overwhelmed with work. And I would also tell you that you care little about the Administration of Justice because you should take into account the reports from the Council of State; this Council of State that says that Spain has an average number of judges that is very, very inferior to that of other countries in Europe.

And what do you propose? Ridiculous situations: simply, 65 positions for judges and 35 for prosecutors for this year 2017. And do not talk to me about the inherited legacy. In the last three years of the Socialist Party's Government, a thousand positions for judges and prosecutors were created.

But I will tell you one thing, Mr. Rajoy: the Socialist Party has a profound sense of State, wants Justice to function and function well, and wants it to function well and supports judges and prosecutors without the need for any type of statement or non-legislative proposal.

You know better than anyone that the Socialist Party is in defense of legality and support for the Rule of Law, in support of your Government in the defense of legality and in support of judges, and we will continue to be there: defending legality, supporting the Government. And I will tell you that for that, the Socialist Party does not need any opportunistic non-legislative proposal that seeks protagonism. We will always be with legality, with the defense of the Rule of Law and supporting the Government in that defense of legality.

President.- What matters to me is what you said at the end of your intervention.

As for the rest, I must say that we will try to increase the resources to the extent of our budgetary possibilities. We are making an effort, not only in resources but with organizational legislative reforms. And, by the way, in this Chamber, a subcommittee has been established to agree on a National Justice Strategy, and there you have a magnificent opportunity to build for the benefit of all citizens.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gabriel Rufián, of the Esquerra Republicana Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rufián.- Mr. Rajoy, Mr. President of the Government, do you believe that your Government is giving an adequately democratic response to the will, to the immense will, of the people of Catalonia?

President.- Mr. Rufián, I tell you as I think, with total frankness: I believe that the Government is doing what it must do, I believe that the Government is fulfilling its obligation, and I must tell you that we will continue to do so until the end: doing what we have to do and fulfilling our obligation.

I believe that we are also acting with proportionality after the things we have seen in recent days in Catalonia. What you have done, some members of your party and other political forces, is of extreme gravity and, as you know, profoundly undemocratic. In a few hours, on the 6th and 7th of September, this month, you attempted to liquidate --I repeat, in a few hours-- the Spanish Constitution, the Statute of Catalonia, and the legal system, invent a new legality and even a new Constitution, which is the "Transitional Law." You bypassed all the parliamentary procedures typical of a democracy, the opinion of the legal advisors of the Parliament of Catalonia, the Statutory Guarantees Council, and the rights of the deputies, who could not amend or debate, and saw how in a very short time all their rights were curtailed.

Fortunately, the Rule of Law and democracy have functioned, all that has been annulled, and although it may not matter to you, the truth is that the Rule of Law will continue to function. Therefore, I believe that we have done what we had to do and what was our obligation.

Mr. Rufián.- Mr. President, you destroyed the Constitution one summer night in 2011, along with your colleagues from the PSOE, in the disgraceful Article 135. Do not give me lessons in constitutionalism.

To be honest, I had an ironic intervention prepared. I wanted to talk to you about your miserable intervention regarding the mayors, about the neighbors who elect the mayor and the mayors who want the neighbor to want the mayor… And I wanted to ask you about the persecution of more than seven hundred independentist mayors. I also wanted to ask you about your Minister of the Interior --I will not qualify him-- who boasts of seizing dangerous independentist cartels, when he forgets about the forty billion euros stolen in the bank rescue.

But today everything has changed, this morning everything has changed. We woke up with the Civil Guard in front of our friends' houses. You and your lackeys are currently detaining Catalan elected officials simply for their ideas. I ask you, I demand; I ask you and I demand that you take your dirty hands off the Catalan institutions; I ask you and I demand that you stop doing so stealthily and with premeditation. And know, both you and your lackeys, that for each one of us, for each one you detain, there are hundreds who are also willing to do it; ultimately, to respect the unequivocally popular mandate that we have behind us.

Mr. Rajoy, know that the will of the people of Catalonia is unstoppable and know that this is no longer a struggle for the national rights of Catalonia, but a struggle for the civil rights of all. And now we march to support our friends.

President.- Sir, I am not going to explain to you, because it makes no sense, what the Rule of Law is. You neither know it nor have any interest. You are completely indifferent to it.

This is an operation that has been carried out by decision of the judge, and any democrat --not whether you are one, nor will I enter into the analysis-- has the obligation to comply with what one of the three powers of the State says. Therefore, this is a judicial operation that is carried out to guarantee what I have told you so many times here: that the Law is complied with.

But, while you continue to persist in your mistakes, while you skip the Law and while you want to trample over everyone, it is worse for everyone, Mr. Rufián; worse for everyone. I, of course, have to fulfill my obligation, and all those who are responsible for ensuring that the Law is complied with in this country will also do so.

You talk about threats and things like that… I take this opportunity to ask you to cease the threats from your partners in the CUP and others against mayors, councilors, local police, people who do not think like you, because there we are no longer talking about the right to self-determination, but we are talking, Mr. Rufián, about attacks against the individual rights of people, including the deputies of the Parliament of Catalonia.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, of the EAJ-PNV Parliamentary Group

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, do you consider that the position adopted by your Government will provide a solution to the conflict raised in Catalonia?

President.- Mr. Esteban, no one in their right mind likes this situation, I do not either, and you know it or at least can sense it.

There is much talk of dialogue. I must say that I have spoken with the President of the Generalitat of Catalonia on numerous occasions; he is my interlocutor. But I have only been given one option, which is referendum yes or referendum yes. I could discuss some aspects of the referendum; I was even proposed: "instead of 50 percent, let it be necessary 60 percent. We can talk about the date." But when the President of any country, in this case, the President of Spain, is asked to authorize a referendum --which, by the way, he cannot do-- with the sole objective of liquidating national sovereignty, the response cannot be other than the one we have taken.

I have had many interlocutors throughout my political life; I have had them there and I have had them there. Of course, I have never had an interlocutor who asked me for impossible things or who wanted to bypass the Law. I cannot do it. Put yourself in my place.

I believe that we are acting with common sense, with moderation, and with proportionality. Of course, the Law in Spain must be complied with, and from there, we can talk about whatever you want, but, of course, no one should count on me to liquidate the unity of Spain or national sovereignty. For that, I do not dedicate myself to political life.

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, what initially began as a problem of economic competence has, over time and largely due to your actions and inactions, become a genuine social conflict, with a clear Catalan national background. The response being given is simply compliance with the Law, and without possibilities of changing it, threatening freedom of expression, sending the Police to some media outlets, entering printing houses, and blocking the accounts of the Generalitat.

The Attorney General calls the mayors, and moreover, threatens them with detention if they do not attend, in a "Minority Report" and Tom Cruise style, because he is sure they will commit some illegality. And today, at this very moment, we wake up to the news that there has already been a detention of public officials from the Generalitat.

Mr. President, in this problem, you cannot hide behind the judges or the prosecutors, because this matter is not going to be resolved with threats and with force.

I disagree that the referendum could not be held. I believe it could have been agreed upon, I believe there were paths, and I believe conditions could have been adopted. But, at this point and at the moment we are in, what is important is to know if your Government is willing to seek solutions, that is, if you are willing to face the fact that there is a Catalan national question that needs to be addressed; secondly, if you are willing to reach a political agreement and, above all, if with your own votes you are willing to modify the Law so that this political agreement can become a reality; ultimately, if you accept that, finally, the decision about your status will have to be made by the people of Catalonia.

That is, are you going to start doing politics because, frankly, from the threats, from simply appealing to compliance with the Law as it is, there will be no possible solution?

President.- Mr. Esteban, it is important never to forget what has happened, because it has no precedent in democratic Europe. Of course, for someone to attempt to liquidate all the legal framework that we have established in the last forty years in a few hours does not seem like an excessively democratic act: the Constitution, the Statute, and the rest of the norms. And to do so by bypassing all democratic procedures and taking away from the deputies the right they have to express their opinion is of enormous gravity.

In the face of this, the reaction of the Rule of Law is, within the Law, to prevent abuses from occurring, as have already occurred in the Parliament of Catalonia on the 6th and 7th. It was an act of democratic barbarism. It was neither normal, nor democratic, nor decent, nor respectful of the rights of the deputies and the citizens who voted for them, nor with what European legislation is.

Sir, if the abuse of norms, laws, and our democratic practices is allowed, what do we have left? We are left with injustice and arbitrariness. Therefore, the Law must be complied with.

And I, of course, have been doing politics for many years, and I am willing to talk, and I am willing to build; what I am not willing to do is to…