Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

15 November 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain's Congress on November 15, 2017, addressing tax fraud and corruption allegations.
Main themes
Tax fraud, fiscal consolidation, tax amnesty, parliamentary accountability, corruption, transparency, State Tax Agency, VAT compliance, constitutional court rulings, illegal party financing
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,414
66th percentile
Sentences
105
65th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
36th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 56%56%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

105 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Margarita Robles, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Robles.- Mr. Rajoy, what measures is your Government going to take to combat tax fraud?

President.- Ms. Robles, the fight against tax fraud has always been a priority for the Government in itself; but, moreover, it is an essential pillar, as you know, for fiscal consolidation, which has been a basic objective for the recovery of our economy.

That is why, between the years 2012 and 2016, five years, we have collected 65.232 billion euros, which are the best historical figures of the State Tax Agency. We have approved various regulations to be more effective in the fight against tax fraud, we have promoted several initiatives at the international level, and this year we have increased the budget of the Agency by one hundred million, and an extraordinary public employment offer has been approved.

I would like to emphasize an important issue: since July 1, the so-called immediate supply of information in the field of VAT has been applied, which allows us to control the collection of this tax. Large companies must report to the State Tax Agency within four days of the operation subject to VAT, and this is undoubtedly very useful in the fight against fraud. And we will continue to act in this line in the coming months.

Ms. Robles.- Mr. President, your Government has been characterized by opacity and lack of transparency, if not tolerance, in the fight against tax fraud.

According to the General Council of Economists, there are 26 billion euros that do not enter public coffers as a result of tax fraud. There are 144 billion euros hidden in foreign tax havens. Opacity. You say nothing.

But do you know what is even worse? The tolerance you have for tax fraud. I will remind you... I know you don’t like me talking about the rulings of the Constitutional Court, you said so last week, and even more so when the Constitutional Court declared the nullity for unconstitutionality of your tax amnesty, of your Government's tax amnesty.

You know the rapporteur of the ruling, Mr. Ollero, right? You know him perfectly, and in the tax amnesty it is not only said, as you often say, that it was null for formal reasons, because it was done by decree law; it is said that you abdicated your obligation to pursue tax crimes and that what you did was violate the principle of equality and contributory capacity. Furthermore, it states, and this is very serious, that you legitimized tax fraud. Under the pretext of raising funds, you legitimized tax fraud. The Constitutional Court says so unanimously.

Look at this: most of those who abstained and said that tax fraud was okay, that nothing was wrong, were precisely involved in corruption proceedings. Yes, corruption. That which you also do not like to name, Mr. Rajoy. And then, what happened? They only collected 1.2 billion euros, when they should have collected 8 billion euros.

Therefore, do not come to us with triumphalism. You are legitimizing tax fraud with your tax amnesties, and from my Parliamentary Group, we ask you, we demand that you have, please, zero tolerance for tax fraud. We cannot demand that citizens pay their taxes, contribute, and, in the meantime, the great fortunes and the corrupt take refuge in your tax amnesty.

President.- Your Honor, you have cited here a few organizations that say there are twenty-some billion on one side, a few more billion on the other... I would appreciate it if you and those who have undoubtedly informed you would bring this to the attention of the Minister of Finance, who can be assured that we would act immediately.

We have already debated here on several occasions about the rulings of the Constitutional Court. You know just as well as I do, because you have read the dispositive part of the ruling, that the reason why the Constitutional Court declared what it declared to be contrary to the Constitution is for a formal reason: because we did it by decree law and not through a Bill.

In any case, everything you have said and everything I have said is very well, but the data is indeed difficult to dispute. In the last five years, as I told you before, more than 65 billion euros have been collected in the fight against tax fraud. That is exactly 48 percent more than in the previous five years. So, if we are so ineffective, as you have said, I do not want to tell you about the effectiveness of the previous Government that collected 48 percent less.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pablo Iglesias, of the Confederal Parliamentary Group of Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. M. Rajoy, what do you think about your name being confirmed indicatively in this very Chamber by the chief inspector of the UDEF as a recipient of illegal payments from the B box of your party?

President.- What I think is that yesterday, as you know perfectly well, that information was denied.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. M. Rajoy, I regret to inform you that what you state is not true. I will read you the legal definition of circumstantial evidence: Circumstantial evidence is that which allows certain facts to be established in a judicial process based on the reasonable deduction of other related facts from which the certainty or accreditation of the first can be inferred. In plain language, Mr. Rajoy, two things have been established: one, that you received illegal bonuses regularly, at least from 1997 to 2008; two, that you lied when you stated in court that you never received bonuses. This shame cannot be covered by any flag, Mr. Rajoy.

And it is not that I say you are corrupt; it was made very clear by the chief inspector of the UDEF in his statement on the 7th in this Chamber. He described Gürtel --I quote literally-- as "an organization that has penetrated deeply into Public Administrations to the point of parasitizing them." He described it --I quote literally-- as "pure corruption."

We know each other, Mr. Rajoy, and I calculate that you are going to ask me now about Iran, about Venezuela, and you are going to tell me that I am the Spanish Inquisition. In the Government's control session, it is not foreseen that the opposition responds to the Government, so I will allow myself to anticipate your questions.

Although your political police have tried to fabricate evidence against us and although your admired pseudo-journalists try to fabricate evidence --what a nice photo of Mr. Inda yesterday with the criminal from your party, Mr. Granados, eating before appearing in the Senate--, the truth is that reality is determined by three facts: one, Justice has dismissed the accusations against us up to fourteen times; two, the leaders of the Manos Limpias group are in prison; three, this Congress proved that you used the police to fabricate evidence.

Do you know what the UDEF inspector also said, Mr. Rajoy, last Tuesday? I quote literally: "The Popular Party acts as a criminal organization." Do you know what the members of criminal organizations are called, Mr. M. Rajoy? Criminals.

President.- I had no intention, Mr. Iglesias, of talking about what happened yesterday in the Senate, but since you have insisted on doing so, I could answer in this Chamber whether it is true, as Mr. Riobóo has said, that you paid and received in B. You should explain that in this Chamber. You should also explain in this Chamber whether you and your party have been financed by Venezuela and Iran; and also, what your friend Mr. Monedero was doing traveling for seven consecutive years to receive resources from the Government of Venezuela. You have not explained that, but you are the one who has spoken here about Venezuela and who has spoken here about Iran.

In reality, you always ask me the same thing. You even went so far as to propose a motion of censure. It seems that you are obsessed and that this is the only thing that matters to you. But, well, I do not know why you ask me because you are absolutely indifferent to what I might respond to you, because you are, at the same time, police, judge, prosecutor, investigating judge, and, moreover, sentencing tribunal.

The truth is that this way of doing opposition, Mr. Iglesias, as is evident, is not working for you. Every time you come here, you have fewer votes and less support from the Spanish people. They will end up putting a motion of censure against you, and the worst of all this, for you of course, is that it may prosper, especially after the latest events and after the latest decisions you have made in Catalonia.

In any case, Mr. Iglesias, I sell advice that I do not have for myself. Apply it to yourself.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, of the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President, "nationalism is the poison of Europe," said Jean Claude Juncker recently in Salamanca. Mr. Macron also said that nationalism has shown us the bonfire where Europe may perish." I subscribe to the words of Mr. Juncker and I subscribe to the words of Mr. Macron.

And, as nationalism is the danger to Europe, Mr. Rajoy, in Catalonia we have elections called, where nationalism has tried, and still tries, to destroy our country, and the Government and the State have called those elections.

Mr. Rajoy, no one is unaware that all the anti-European nationalists will work to ensure that those elections in Catalonia are not held with guarantees or freedom. And I am not saying this, the European Union is already warning about it, and so are the intelligence services. And I want to ask you, Mr. Rajoy, what is your Government and Presidency going to do, specifically, which is responsible for national security, to prevent the elections from being "hacked," to sabotage the Catalan elections, to prevent foreign interference in the outcome of those elections.

President.- I believe, Mr. Rivera, that things are being done, and they are difficult, in a reasonable manner:

- We activated, as the whole Chamber knows, Article 155 for the first time in the history of our country. We did it to recover legality and normality. Among other decisions, we dismissed the Government of Catalonia, also for the first time in history.

- In parallel, Justice acted with full independence.

- No country in the European Union or the world has supported the independence movement.

And today I can tell you that things are better, public services are functioning well, public employees are fulfilling their duties with professionalism, and we have ahead of us elections that I hope will serve to open a new stage of tranquility. I am concerned about the economy, because we have said that the forecast for economic growth would be 2.3 percent for the year 2018, but if things go well in Catalonia and from January next year there is tranquility, the economy could grow at a rate of 3 percent, as it has done in the years 2015, 2016, and 2017.

I am absolutely convinced that the elections will be held, unlike the so-called referendum we experienced on October 1, in a climate of normality and tranquility. For now, everyone is going to present themselves for the elections accepting the regulations set forth in the Constitution and the Statute. And from there, we will take all necessary measures to ensure that your fears do not translate into anything concerning.

Mr. Rivera.- I share what you have said, but I was specifically asking what the Government and, in this case, the Department of National Security, which depends on the Presidency, is doing... What are you doing to prevent cyber attacks, sabotage, and "hacks" from foreign powers? The question is very clear.

Mr. Dastis referred the other day in an interview, and the European Union is warning us about it. The Netherlands had to change its voting system and do it in a traditional way to avoid hacking by Russia. We also had that situation in France, and in this case, the United States has confirmed the attack on the structures of the French elections. There was a cyber attack against one of the candidates, against Mr. Macron, despite his eventual victory. And I ask you what our Government, which is the one calling the elections, and the Department of National Security, which depends on you, is doing? What are you doing to prevent those elections from being hacked and sabotaged? The question could not be clearer.

Mr. Rajoy, the enemies of Europe do not rest; the enemies of Spain do not either, who are the same; and the nationalists, moreover, boast of having dangerous friends and acquaintances among those who try to break Spain and break Europe. Therefore, I believe we have sufficient reasons to be concerned, and I want the Government to do its job. That is why I ask you that, as you directly depend on the Presidency, I hope your Government takes care of that, which has the full support of this Group, so that elections are held in Catalonia that are free, with guarantees, and without anyone attempting to manipulate the decision of the Catalans.

President.- It is true that there are countries that have been forced to make decisions, but, as is natural, decisions are not counted before they are made, but are counted once they have produced effects after the elections are held.

What I can assure you is that, regardless of all the friends that the separatist gentlemen have, to whom you have referred, we have very important friends, which are the Spanish Constitution and the Law. That is why Article 155 is in motion, that is why the Government has been dismissed, that is why elections are being held on the next December 21, and that is why all those political parties are running in the elections within the framework of Spanish legality.

Therefore, trust in Spanish legality, which is equipped with sufficient instruments for things to function democratically and for people to vote with full freedom and make the decisions they deem appropriate and convenient.

Thank you very much.