Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 November 2017 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish Congress during a parliamentary control session on November 21, 2017, responding to questions about fair financing for the Valencian Community.
Main themes
Regional financing model, Valencian Community funding, autonomous communities agreement, investment disparities, parliamentary control, consensus-building, Popular Party minority government, historical debt, public services distribution, corruption allegations
Duration
~52 min
94th percentile
Words
6,202
94th percentile
Sentences
197
89th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
14.4
70th percentile
Syntax
3.40
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%44%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Economic 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

197 sentences in 88 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Carles Mulet, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Mulet.- Mr. President, I hereby pose the question: What measures will the Government adopt to give the Valencian Community a fair treatment that takes into account, at a minimum, financing, investment, and historical debt?

President.- Mr. Mulet, as you know, I have been in political life for several years now and, among other things, I have had the opportunity to debate various models of regional financing. Moreover, I have done so from both sides: I did it as a representative of an Autonomous Community, serving as Vice President of the Xunta de Galicia, and also, from the perspective of the State, I had the opportunity to agree with other Autonomous Communities on new models of regional financing when I held the portfolio of Public Administrations.

My experience on this matter tells me the following: first, the only fair financing model is the one that is agreed upon; above all, the one agreed upon by the Autonomous Communities unanimously and by a majority in the Chambers, whether in the Senate or in the Congress, or better yet, in both. I say this because, as you know, there are many opinions on how resources should be distributed to meet the needs of citizens among Autonomous Communities. There are some, among others, I suppose you, who are more in favor of prioritizing the criterion of population; but there are others who believe that other criteria should also be used, such as the age of individuals — for example, in the case of healthcare, it has its interest and its reasons for argument; the dispersion of the population — it is always more difficult to provide public services when the population is dispersed and not concentrated; the criterion of insularity, etc., etc.

Therefore, I believe that agreement is the most positive thing and that is what we are working on. I already proposed a pact on this matter during the Investiture Debate, and I did so for two reasons that you will surely understand very well: the first, because it is good to agree on this, and a good proof of this is that the current model, which is from 2009, was not agreed upon, and that is why we have all the problems and difficulties that we have. I myself voted against that model in the Congress of Deputies, which is the one in force, from 2009. And, secondly, in addition to this reason, which is substantive, there is a second reason, which is that the Popular Party, which I lead, has 137 seats in the Congress of Deputies and at least 176 are needed — it is better if there are more — to push this matter forward.

That is why I brought this to the Conference of Presidents; we agreed to create a commission of experts, which has already done its work and issued its report; that report has been delivered to a working group that includes all the Autonomous Communities that wanted to participate, and, in addition, the Socialist Party has requested that this matter be addressed in the commission we have created in the Congress of Deputies to evaluate the situation of the Autonomous State, which I think is fine.

In summary, this is my position. I am at the disposal of this entire Chamber and also of the Congress. I have the utmost interest in reaching an agreement, but let us not deceive ourselves: I lead a party that has 137 deputies, that governs in five Autonomous Communities, and I believe that the best thing is for us to reach a consensus, as I said at the beginning, among the Autonomous Communities and a very broad majority in the Congress and the Senate.

Therefore, all I have left is to encourage you to urge your partners to make a proposal from your entire party that can be compared with ours and with others that may be put forward by the various gentlemen and ladies deputies and senators.

Mr. Mulet.- Mr. M. Rajoy, President of the Government and President of the first party prosecuted for corruption, I was asking about measures and you have not given me any measures.

This Saturday — I imagine you know this, and if not, I will explain it to you — the employers' association, the unions, organizations of all kinds, and all political parties, except one, took to the streets demanding fair treatment for the Valencians; all except the Popular Party. We all cried out to end the continuous mistreatment of the Valencian people, because you know that the Valencian PP cares a lot about what happens in Catalonia, but very little about what happens in the Valencian Community. The Valencian PP was very interested in the Valencian Community to plunder it, as it did during the governments of Zaplana, Olivas, Camps, or Fabra.

We have been underfunded for years and years, with an insufficient and unjust system. You know perfectly well that we, the Valencians, are 11 percent of the population and 12 percent of the Gross Domestic Product; but they return it with 3.5 percent of real investments. The General State Budgets, you know perfectly well, are unjust to us; not just now, they were also unjust when the Socialist Party was in power. But, despite being unjust, then, in matters like Development, they execute a third of what was already unjust.

The Valencian Community was a rich Community until its people were plundered, until its people impoverished it with erratic policies designed to fill the pockets of their friends or their own leaders, as they did with the businessmen of Gürtel. We were rich until your people, along with, in many cases, the Socialist Party, led us into savage urbanism and the politics of the windfall. They blew up the financial sector and took away our banks and savings banks. They robbed us with theme parks, with Formula 1, with visits from the Pope, or with extravagant policies.

But it seems to you that it is fine that we were robbed or that we were impoverished, because for you the convict and criminal Carlos Fabra was just an exemplary citizen and politician. What an example, right!

We all remember what came out of your mouth, Mr. M. Rajoy: "Alfonso, I love you. I love you, damn it. Your successes are my successes." And what a success, right? The success of Alfonso Rus in counting the bills! I don’t know if anyone else counted the off-the-books bills as well as Alfonso Rus. You, who believed so much in Camps and committed to being behind him, in front of him, or beside him, we don’t know if you were also behind, beside, above, or below when he was getting the suits.

With such company, I imagine you would find it normal to do a "simpa" like the one you did when in 2008 you held a congress at FIRA Valencia and left without paying the 568,000 euros that the congress cost.

We need a fair financing system, like the one we do not have, because we do not disguise the Treasury as other people do; we do not count bills with kickbacks, as other people do; we need a fair financing system, because we do not steal money from humanitarian aid, like the convict Blasco; we are not like Olivas, Camps, Cotino, or Serafín Castellano; we are not...

President.- Thank you very much for your words, Mr. Mulet. I appreciate the ideas you have contributed. Your proposals on the financing model undoubtedly reveal a truly remarkable understanding of what we are discussing here.

Undoubtedly, you have studied very thoroughly how the financing model works and have demonstrated that the interests of all citizens living in the provinces of Castellón, Valencia, and Alicante matter a lot to you. I suppose they will be absolutely delighted with the suggestions you have made to the President of the Government, and in this situation, all I can tell you is what I said in the first part of my intervention.

There is a Conference of Presidents, a group of experts has been created, they have already started working, we need the support and collaboration of other political forces because we cannot approve it alone, and from there, the principles we will handle are fundamentally the principles of solidarity, sufficiency, equity, transparency, and fiscal co-responsibility.

I must say that we have lived, as you all know, through a very difficult economic crisis and that the main problem of financing for Public Administrations, both for the national Government and for the Autonomous Communities, does not come from the regional financing model, but from the economic crisis that made us lose seventy billion euros in revenue in two years. This affected everyone, the Autonomous Communities and also the national Government.

But now, with the economic recovery, the financing of all Administrations is improving. Specifically, the Valencian Community has improved its financing by one billion this year 2017 compared to 2016, and already in 2016 it was one billion compared to 2015.

I want to add that all Spaniards have been supportive of each other. It was a very difficult stage. Debt maturities could not be met, nor could payments to suppliers be made. We launched the FLA and the Supplier Payment Fund, the Valencian Community received 43 billion euros in liquidity, 6 billion euros were saved in interest, and in terms of investments, the Government has invested 4.5 billion in these six years.

But undoubtedly, the most important thing is that with the economic recovery and the increase in employment, revenue from VAT, revenue from personal income tax, and revenue from Special Taxes increased, and, considering that the Valencian Community, like the others, receives more than 50 percent of the income from personal income tax, property tax, and Special Taxes, its financing has improved.

Therefore, the great objective remains to maintain the economic recovery. In the last month of October, 39,000 jobs were created in the Community, and that is very positive because that, apart from providing employment to people, is undoubtedly more resources for healthcare, education, social services, and the issues that matter to the entire citizenry.

We will continue to work in that direction. We sincerely appreciate your brilliant contributions, I will pass them on to the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, I hope they are received as they deserve, and from there, you know that, as always, I am at your disposal for whatever you deem appropriate and convenient.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ander Gil, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Gil.- Mr. President of the Government, last September the document of the Pact against Gender Violence was approved; a pact promoted and demanded by the Socialist Party since 2014. And I think it is good to remember that it was done with the support, the backing, almost unanimous, of almost all political forces in the Congress of Deputies.

I remind you that it is the Government's responsibility to promote and make possible the implementation of each and every one of the proposals included in this State Pact, as well as, Mr. Rajoy, to budget for it; an idea on which I want to emphasize.

It is our duty, as opposition and an alternative to the Government, to monitor the compliance with the proposals that make up this State Pact. It is, therefore, Mr. Rajoy, your obligation to implement these measures and fulfill the commitment of the economic agreement, which is none other than to guarantee two hundred million euros so that this Pact can be implemented next year 2018. That is why my Group, the Socialist Parliamentary Group, asks you, Mr. Rajoy, what steps the Government is taking to implement the State Pact against Gender Violence.

President.- Mr. Gil García, allow me to take advantage of this question and the upcoming commemoration of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women to have a meaningful remembrance of all the victims. No society committed to equality and dignity can tolerate this, look the other way, and, therefore, while there is a single victim, the priority must be to improve the protection and response of the institutions. I also believe it would be good for us to reinforce the spirit of consensus that you have referred to in a matter of this nature.

When I submitted myself to the investiture in the Congress of Deputies, I proposed, among other possible agreements for the Legislature, an agreement on gender violence. I then brought this matter to the Conference of Presidents; there was a practically unanimous agreement, truly unanimous, from everyone. A commission was created in the Congress and, as you have recalled here, also a working group in the Senate. And, as you know better than I do, both the Senate and the Congress, the Senate unanimously and the Congress by majority, with some abstentions, have issued their report which, without a doubt, as you said, must serve as a basis for a parliamentary agreement that will help us achieve a State Pact.

These documents were sent to the Government. The Government is seeking, with the mandate of the Congress and the Senate, the maximum possible support for the agreement. It has created an interministerial group, which has already met four times; it has also convened a Sectoral Conference with the Autonomous Communities, various social entities, and the Plenary of the State Observatory on Gender Violence. There is a document with the observations of all, which is being sent by the Minister of Health, Social Services, and Equality to the various agents with the aim that we can, after the work of the Senate and the Congress, reach an agreement and sign it throughout this year.

In relation to the economic allocations you referred to, as you know, there has been an agreement to implement the dedicated items in the budgets amounting to one billion over the next five years, and therefore, next year, 2018, two hundred million euros will be included in the General State Budget.

Mr. Gil.- Mr. Rajoy, you have provided a good parliamentary account. I wanted to focus the issue on the budget allocation. We know nothing about the General State Budget as of today; but it would not even be necessary to address them from that point of view. In just an hour, a non-legislative proposal from the Socialist Parliamentary Group will be debated in the Congress of Deputies, in which we propose to your Group that the Government adopt a Royal Decree Law that allocates two hundred million euros for the Pact, in case the General State Budget needs to be extended.

Mr. Rajoy, you have a golden opportunity to tell us right now whether your Group is going to support it or not, whether you are going to send a "WhatsApp" to your Parliamentary Group in Congress telling them "support the initiative this afternoon from the Socialist Group" to clear up doubts on a matter that is fundamental to guarantee the viability of the State Pact. Mr. Rajoy, I ask you: are you going to support this initiative? Yes or no? I would like you to clarify that for us.

Mr. President, the violence exercised against women is the cruelest and most unbearable manifestation of inequality. We agree on this. So much so that we cannot speak of a democratic society or a Social and Legal State if half of its population lives at risk of suffering violence and being murdered.

From the Socialist Party, as I mentioned earlier, we have been working tirelessly since 2014 to achieve this State Pact against violence and to make it a reality as soon as possible. For that reason, Mr. Rajoy, I already inform you that we will be demanding in its compliance, as it cannot be otherwise.

Mr. Rajoy, you must already allocate the committed resources for the eradication of gender violence. The unity, to which you referred, against gender violence does not admit desertions for electoral calculation, nor a relaxed management by anyone, and less so by the President of the Government.

You mentioned it: 44 women have already been murdered in our country; a matter that requires an immediate response. It is a public health and security problem for women in our country. This is so because women and men do not have the same opportunities, nor do their lives, unfortunately, run the same risks. The patriarchal and macho culture condemns women, Mr. Rajoy, to lower wages, longer hours, unequal relationships, to being objectified and also to suffering violence.

Even so, it is true that our country has advanced legislation in this field; legislation that has often been hindered in its development precisely by the budget cuts that your Government has been perpetrating for the past six years, Mr. Rajoy, which also have a lot to do with the point we find ourselves in.

But it is true that the Cortes, and you have described it very well, have been working tirelessly -- and I have witnessed in the Senate the great work that a group of senators, or rather, female senators, have done in this regard; but the budget allocation, that commitment of one billion euros over five years, is absolutely vital. Without that budget allocation, the Pact will be, Mr. Rajoy, worthless paper and the lives of women is a matter that cannot wait even one more minute.

There is something very symptomatic in all this, something that I miss, and take it, really, as a constructive criticism: Mr. Rajoy, I miss you talking more about gender violence and macho violence in your major speeches. I miss you dedicating more time to a very serious problem for this society, and do not take it as a reproach, but as a constructive criticism. I invite you to include this issue in each and every one of your major speeches, because I believe that half of the population of this country deserves that their President dedicates time to this issue.

Mr. Rajoy, I conclude by emphasizing two issues: the first, and I would like you to clarify it, that we all leave the Senate with this issue clear, is the budget. Will your Group agree to support that initiative from the Socialist Group, which would bring peace of mind to all those who are waiting to see if this Pact starts to function or not? I invite you to do so today in the Senate. And, second, we will be extremely vigilant about the full compliance of each and every one of the measures contained in this Pact. We believe it is our role, our obligation.

Mr. Rajoy, I believe that this uncertainty regarding funding has generated a lot or some distrust around it. And women who are victims of gender violence must have the certainty and confidence that the State, Mr. Rajoy, will do everything possible to guarantee their safety and freedom. That is something that, above all, corresponds to the President of the Government.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Gil García, I will try to respond to some of the statements you made in your speech.

In principle, the idea would be to present the General State Budget at the beginning of next year, but, as you recalled, today a non-legislative proposal is being debated in the Congress of Deputies, which my Parliamentary Group, to honor its commitments, will vote in favor of.

I agree substantially with the intervention you just made and, even, I accept the constructive criticism; but, in any case, you cannot deny that since the Investiture Debate, as I said at the beginning, when I raised the need for an agreement on this matter, as well as later in the Conference of Presidents, the Government and the Parliamentary Groups that support it, both in Congress and in the Senate, worked with the same constructive spirit that you worked in both Chambers.

In any case, although what is important is the future, I would like to point out that important advances have been made, and have been made for some years now, in this area. Specifically, in 2003 we approved the Protection Order for Victims; in 2004, a law that you presented in the Congress of Deputies and then in the Senate, which we supported from the opposition; even in the last legislature there were important regulatory changes: we reformed more than a dozen laws; among others, the Penal Code, the Criminal Procedure Law or the Victim Statute.

In this Legislature, of which we have been in office for at least a year since the Government took office, some concrete measures have been adopted, which I am absolutely convinced are already being useful for us to be more effective: the launch of an application for the prevention and detection of gender violence in women with disabilities; the launch of the Pantallas Amigas campaign with Twitter to prevent violence among the adolescent population; the agreement with phone manufacturers to erase the traceability of calls to 016 on devices; the strengthening of the State Observatory on Violence against Women...

Undoubtedly, there are many things left to do, but I believe that together we are taking steps in the right direction.

I also believe that we can say that there are results. Today more than 77 percent, that is, many women, are leaving abusive relationships and this is more than what was happening a few years ago. While we are at 77 percent, we cannot celebrate; but we can say that steps are being taken in the right direction.

Both the reports and the protection orders are increasing, which means that more women are taking the first step to break the silence, and greater protection once they have managed to do so. In addition, Europe recognizes our advances and is positively valuing the decisions that are being made in our country.

I believe that we must continue working in that direction, we must continue with the "roadmap" marked by the decisions adopted, both by the Senate and by Congress; we must listen, without a doubt, to the social agents who are very directly involved in the fight against gender violence, and I hope that in very few days we will be in a position to give a definitive boost to this work with the formal adhesion of all those who want to do so, which I hope will be the majority.

I reiterate what I said at the beginning: we will fulfill our commitment to dedicate one billion more than what is currently allocated to the fight against gender violence and next year will be the first two hundred million, as we had agreed at the time.

Thank you very much.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ramón Espinar, from the Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Espinar.- Mr. President of the Government, what is your assessment of the proportionality and weighting of the intervention of Public Administrations that has occurred, at the request of your Government, in recent times?

President.- Mr. Espinar, the Government always tries to act with prudence, with proportionality and with consideration of the interests at stake, and, of course, all actions of the Government are governed by one principle, which is compliance with the Law, something that is required of anyone present here, but even more so from those of us who have Government responsibilities.

What I want to guarantee you is that neither the Government I preside over, nor I myself, have any interest in intervening in any public administration, whether it is regional or local. I believe in the autonomy of Local and Regional Administration, and, in fact, I have assumed responsibilities: I have been a councilor and provincial deputy, and I have also been part of a regional government. I am fully aware of how they operate, how they provide public services and the importance of preserving their autonomy.

But there is a different thing, which is compliance with the Law, which binds us all; here there are no exceptions. It binds those of us who are here, those who are in Congress, those who govern in Autonomous Communities and also those of us who are in the national Government. It is a basic principle enshrined in our Constitution, its article 103, which states that Public Administrations must serve "with objectivity the general interests" and "act with full submission to the Law and the Right." That is fully logical and I share it, because the rules are there to be followed; they are not a whim. And, if they are not followed, logically, they bring their consequences and, in any case, we try, when it is up to us to decide what they are, to do so with consideration and proportionality.

Mr. Espinar.- I would like to say, with due respect, that one would like everyone to be able to exhaust their time in their interventions in this Chamber.

That said, Mr. President of the Government, it has been two weeks since your Government decided to increase the pressure on the accounts of the Madrid City Council. The Madrid City Council, as you may know or as you should know to make a decision like the one you have made, at the request of Mr. Montoro, presents each year a surplus of over 1,000 million euros for a budget of 4,500 million, which is not bad. And the Madrid City Council has reduced its debt by 2,000 million euros, after the management -- you will agree with me -- disastrous of Mr. Gallardón and Mrs. Botella.

We have reduced the debt of the Madrid City Council by more than two billion euros and we present accounts with a surplus of more than one billion euros. You approved a Budget Stability Law, known as the "Montoro Law," which prevents those one billion euros from being used to provide public services, which forces them to go directly to pay off the debt, and we do not agree with that Law; we have told you many times. In fact, your Government today has vetoed a proposal from my Group in the Congress of Deputies to reverse it. Another law that your Government vetoes, Mr. Rajoy.

In any case, I ask you, because I celebrate that you defend here the rule of law, the defense of laws and their compliance; I celebrate that you do so, but this week we have learned that you have forgiven an intervention to the managers of the Jaén City Council, something you have not done with the Madrid City Council.

And I want to ask you what the difference is between the non-compliance of the Jaén City Council and the non-compliance of the Madrid City Council. I have a conjecture, which I will explain to you, although I hope you will answer me, because in the Community of Madrid, as far as I know, there are municipalities, let’s say Parla or Torrejón, with budgetary situations of much greater non-compliance with the Budget Stability Law than that of Madrid, and you have not exercised any intervention. But the City Council of Marbella, or that of Jaén, have been systematically forgiven by your Government.

Do you know what those four Public Administrations I just mentioned have in common? That they are governed by the Popular Party and that the City Council of Madrid is governed by Manuela Carmena. For some, the Law is strictly enforced, and for others, the Law is enforced with laxity. Let's see if we need to apply to you, Mr. Rajoy, that saying "I give advice that I do not follow myself."

I am going to explain some pillars of our democratic functioning and the distribution of power in our country. One is the separation of powers, and the separation of powers implies that your Government cannot systematically veto laws in the Congress of Deputies; that you must submit to the Legislative; that you have a lot of power, but you are the Executive and cannot also govern over the Legislative and the Judicial.

And when I hear you here defending the Law and defending the separation of powers, I must say that I celebrate it; but the problem is that you here, with all solemnity, defend the separation of powers and then, when we learn of conversations among members of your party in private, it seems that you believe in this separation of powers much less. You veto laws, you do not respect the separation of powers in our country in private, and you proclaim your agreement with some general principles of democratic functioning, but then you do not exercise it, Mr. Rajoy.

The second element I wanted to discuss regarding the pillars of power distribution and democratic functioning in our country has to do with governing in the service of the general interest, and not of self-interest. And I will not be as exhaustive as Mr. Mulet, but we all understand each other.

The third principle has to do with administrative decentralization. You manage 50 percent of every euro that Spaniards contribute to the public treasury; the Autonomous Communities manage 35 percent, and Local Entities are left with 15 percent. Let the Local Entities govern with that 15 percent and do not intervene with arbitrary criteria.

Now we come to why you intervene in the City Council of Madrid. You intervene from a deep arbitrariness because you have not done the same with other institutions. From a deep arbitrariness, and this is very serious, you prevent the more than one billion euros a year that the City Council of Madrid has in surplus from being invested in social spending and in the needs of citizens, and you do not have a single objective criterion to do this.

You simply intervene in the Public Administrations that you do not control, Mr. Rajoy; the Public Administrations where your party does not govern. And particularly, you have a problem with the Public Administrations where change governs. And you have a problem with the Public Administrations where change governs for a very simple reason: because every time you argue with us, you proclaim the arrival of the horsemen of the Apocalypse if we come to power; but we are demonstrating in City Councils like that of Madrid that Manuela Carmena governs much better than you and that the political formations of change govern much better and with much more honesty and integrity than the Popular Party.

We are very proud of that, and you simply cannot stand it. That is why you have intervened in the accounts of the City Council of Madrid: because the example will spread, because people in this country know that Manuela Carmena governs much better than you, Mr. Rajoy; that Ada Colau governs much better than you, Mr. Rajoy, and that where change governs, no one puts their hand in the till and things go much better for the citizens.

You, gentlemen of the Popular Party, lost the elections to the City Council of Madrid at the polls, and now you want to manage the City Council of Madrid from the Ministry of Economy, and that is something that to you, Mr. Rajoy… To you, Mr. Rajoy, the intervention of the City Council of Madrid does not place you as a president of all Spaniards, who governs in virtue of the general interest; it places you as a president of the Popular Party who uses the Administrations he controls for the benefit of his party.

President.- Mr. Espinar, I am not going to enter into the debate here about how well you govern or how badly I do things, among other things, because we would not agree, and therefore, it makes no sense to do so.

Well, there is one thing on which you might agree with me, in which I might even be right, and that is that in the City Council of Madrid, the Popular Party did not lose the elections at the polls; they won them at the polls. Then, there was an agreement that led to the formation of a different municipal government.

Mr. Espinar, those are minor issues and, as I said before, even if some are objective, we will not agree. But I would like to refer to two matters that you addressed in your speech: one, that of the City Council of Madrid, and the other is about the Rule of Law and the division of powers.

I celebrate hearing you talk about the Rule of Law because I am an enthusiast, perhaps even a fanatic, of the Rule of Law, of the separation of powers, of the primacy of the Law, of the rule of Law, and of the subjection of all of us here, as I often say, to those laws that ultimately govern our coexistence and are the expression of the will of the majority.

You said that we have vetoed laws, and it is true, in the Congress of Deputies; then, in the Senate, I suppose not because, if they were vetoed in the Congress, they would not have reached here. But we have done so using an article of the Constitution that states that when there is an undesirable increase in expenses that prevents a budget from being successfully carried out, the Government has the right to veto initiatives, and all Governments have done this since 1977 in Spain and in all countries of the European Union.

If we had not vetoed the processing of laws that implied an increase in spending, that increase would be 89 billion euros. We would be nine points higher in public deficit, which would mean saying that the Spanish public accounts were not out of control, but in total and absolute bankruptcy, and we would return to the time when, due to excessive spending, we had the economic crisis that you know so well.

Therefore, that is the first clarification, which is important, that I wanted to make to you and that has nothing to do with that Rule of Law to which you have referred.

What has happened in the City Council of Madrid? The Ministry of Finance and Public Function, which I must say serves the general interests objectively and without any kind of sectarianism, at the head of which is a person who has been assuming responsibilities in politics for many years, has had to adopt measures to control municipal accounts and has done so in accordance with the Organic Law of Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability, which you know, because the City Council has systematically failed to comply with that norm; only for that reason. The City Council must also comply with the laws. And this norm is not an invention nor is it a whim of the Government; it is a rule of European governance that we all countries that make up the European Union must comply with. I signed, and I found it already done by the previous president, in January 2012 the Treaty that obliges us to this kind of decisions.

What has the City Council of Madrid done? It exceeded the spending limit in 2015, it was told that it had to make an economic-financial plan, it did so, but in 2016 and 2017 it did the same thing again.

The Government, after a long time of dialogue and repeated non-compliance, has acted in a justified, very proportional, and very measured manner, Mr. Espinar, because we have neither intervened in the City Council nor sent a commission of experts, but we have established financial oversight over the City Council, telling it that it cannot spend above the spending rule, because the City Council of Madrid cannot bypass the Law.

And believe me, whether you believe it or not, we treat the City Council of Madrid exactly the same as any City Council in Spain. And there are other cities that have not respected the spending rule, and the same has been done.

I cannot share your assertion that the Government acts with more laxity when it comes to City Councils governed by the Popular Party. It is not so, Mr. Espinar. We try to be serious, comply with the Law, and we must continue to make an effort so that in Spain that Law of Budgetary Stability is ultimately adopted by all, because it is what allows us to control public spending in our country and what allows us, as has happened with structural reforms, to reach an economic situation in which we grow at 3 percent and we all have resources; we do not owe money, which is the worst thing one can do; we go little by little, which the City Council of Madrid is doing, it is true, reducing public debt.

That is a very positive fact, but I insist, as so many times in this Chamber, a Government, nor even a natural person, can spend what it does not have, spend what it does not earn, because that sooner or later inevitably leads to bankruptcy or a similar situation.

Thank you very much.