Speech by President of the Government and subsequent Q&A session at Annual Assembly of Institute of Family Business
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed the Annual Assembly of the Institute of Family Business in April 2014, reviewing Spain's economic progress since his government took office.
- Main themes
- Spanish economic recovery, family businesses in Spain, unemployment reduction, GDP growth, foreign investment, current account balance, sovereign debt improvement, government economic policy, exports and tourism, inflation stabilization
- Duration
- ~62 min
- Words
- 7,456
- Sentences
- 307
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.5
- Syntax
- 3.13
- Vocabulary
- 1.99
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
307 sentences in 106 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen, a very good day to you.
Allow me to firstly thank your new president, Javier Moll, for his words of welcome.
One year on, and I am back here with you again. Since 2005, when you invited me here for the first time to attend a congress of the Institute of Family Business, this is now my tenth attendance at meetings such as this one here today. On other occasions you have heard me say to you that I will always attend if you invite me to do so, save for unforeseen circumstances. For me, now, as President of the Government, and before, as leader of the main opposition party, meeting up in this auditorium is a true privilege. Your companies not only represent a considerable percentage of the Gross Domestic Product and of the number of employees of our country, but they also provide a fine indicator of our economic life. So you don't need to thank me for being here, but rather I should thank you for inviting me to attend this type of event.
Ladies and gentlemen,
This year has seen a change in presidency of the Institute. José Manuel Entrecanales, after completing his two-year term of office, has handed over the mantle to Javier Moll. Please allow me, friends, to congratulate José Manuel Entrecanales on the role he has played during this time. Allow me to thank you, as your colleagues have and wish you all the very best for the future. And I am convinced that Javier Moll will give his very best in this new phase now commencing, I am also convinced that he will find the way to keep up the good work of his predecessors. Your institution has a tradition of success, because you, all of you, have made that possible, among other things, because you have found the correct formula to choosing your leaders.
Ladies and gentlemen,
I would like to start this speech by continuing the tale I started to tell you at the 14th Congress held on 25 October 2011. I said back then that I wasn't going to speak, like on previous occasions, as the main opposition leader, but rather as the candidate, with the backing of the Spanish people, for the Presidency of the Government in the general elections to be held three weeks later, and I added that "I am not going to speak about what needs to be done but rather about what we would need to do in the event of being backed by our compatriots".
At your last two assemblies, I have taken stock of this commitment to you. In fact, last year I finished my speech here by saying, "Ladies and gentlemen, members of the Institute of the Family Business, if next year, in April, as usual, you are again kind enough to invite me to your assembly, we will have the occasion to see if it is true what I have said today: that we are on the verge of turning our situation around and that the bases for achieving this are increasingly more sound". And I added the following, "Without hype, without triumphalism, which leads to nowhere good, but by maintaining our course and stepping up our efforts we will continue working to leave the economic recession behind us and give Spanish society good reason for hope. And I would like to take stock of all of this to you when the coming 12 months have passed and we are present at the next annual assembly".
Well, let's honour this promise. One year on, and is the situation of the Spanish economy worse, the same or better? Let's look at some changes.
The Spanish economy has gone from recession to economic growth: since the third quarter of 2013 we have moved from a recessive period to the start of recovery.
As regards employment, the European Union Statistical Office informed us just a few days ago that in the month of February, the number of unemployed in Spain had fallen by some 330,000 people when compared with 12 months previously, which is more than half the total fall in unemployment seen in the European Union as a whole in this period. This is the first time we have seen four consecutive months of falling unemployment in Spain since 2007.
The level of prices has maintained a practically flat rate; in the last six months the Consumer Price Index has risen by an average of 0.1% whereas in the previous comparable period prices rose by 2.9%.
For the first time in the last 15 years, the balance of current account and capital payments - our economic relations with other countries - showed a positive balance of 1.5% in 2013. Both our exports and tourism sector are showing historic figures.
Foreign investment - a clear reflection of growing confidence in Spain - has returned with a vengeance to our economy. The risk premium and, consequently, the interest on our sovereign debt, has fallen to less than one quarter of its maximum in 2012, currently standing at around 160 basis points. In just the last few days, we have seen the Spanish 5-year bond pay lower interest than the equivalent 5-year bond in the United States.
Friends,
I believe that in short, these figures are a good reflection of those that have changed the Spanish panorama in the last 12 months. Some of you might think that this has all happened by chance, or been influenced by matters overseas, or by a change in cycle that came out of the blue; but you will remember how I have informed you over the last few years about the situation we inherited, of the events that caused this situation, of the diagnosis we made to seek solutions and of the plans we have been implementing to, firstly, stop the rot, and, secondly, to return to a period of growth.
If today we can see this change in trend, a change in course that has moved us from moving backwards to forwards, from a fall to a recovery, this has not been by chance, in the same way as practically nothing in this world happens by chance. This has been due to a collective effort by Spanish society as whole, which has found a way to adapt, with sacrifice but also with expectations, to the new strategy adopted by this government.
Friends,
The good news we are hearing about the Spanish economy is starting, fortunately, to become more common. Nowadays, other countries, and you know this as well or better than me, look at our economy as an example of how to exit a crisis. We are assessed by what we have done and what it is believed we will continue to do. And that does not mean that we have overcome the crisis, but rather that it is possible and it is within our grasp to recover strong growth and create jobs.
I don't want to convey even the slightest glimmer of self-complacency or triumphalism. The first and foremost objective targeted by this government was to create jobs and reduce unemployment, and, despite the promising figures we have mentioned, when the number of people out of work comfortably exceeds five and a half million, it would be an empty boast to talk about the success of the economic situation in our country, to say the least.
That is why we will continue down the same path we have been following for more than two years now: gaining in competitiveness without devaluing our currency, which is enabling us to reduce the imbalances of our economy and establish the bases for stable growth that lead to job creation. Some thought it was impossible to devalue our currency internally without exiting the Euro or asking for a bailout, but we have shown that one can be done without the other.
As I have said on various occasions, this government's economy policy actions have been realised in two phases: firstly, correcting the imbalances and secondly, driving recovery in key sectors whilst exiting the crisis.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The first phase focused on correcting the imbalances, which can be summed up very simply: to start to prosper it is necessary to stop living beyond one's means. When we said that it was necessary to reduce the public deficit, it was because the public administration spent more than it collected in revenue and the difference lies in a greater deficit, and hence, in more debt that will need to be paid off in the future. If this debt is astronomical, those who are financing us think that it is not going to be paid off and that is what generated the doubts surrounding the financing of our public sector debt and the debt crisis such as the one we went through two years ago.
Secondly, the country had an enormous foreign trade deficit, in other words, we bought more goods and services than what we sold to pay for them. The foreign trade deficit rose to more than 10% of our Gross Domestic Product. Once again, a country cannot buy up high quality and technologically advanced goods and services and not have exports to pay for them. In exchange for what were these imports being bought? In exchange for debt, debt which eventually became, as you are aware, unsustainable.
We thus had problems surrounding our competitiveness and a foreign deficit, and we had a financial system that was lending at that time much more than it had in deposits, thus becoming highly indebted whilst, at the same time, loans were made for activities and to clients that didn't turn out to be profitable.
Hence, the first step in our economic policy was to correct these imbalances: the public deficit, the lack of competitiveness, with the consequent foreign deficit, and the clean-up of our financial system. These imbalances affect us on a day-to-day basis, although they may seem very distant; the day-to-day life of our companies and of our citizens. It is the imbalances that build up over many years that make the economy weak, in the same way as consumption, affecting the trade sector, tourism, distribution, etc; and it is also due to these imbalances that Spain lacked financing and, in order to correct this, many jobs have been shed.
Ladies and gentlemen,
You either correct imbalances or they correct you, which is what happened to the Spanish economy. If you do nothing, you reach an extremely serious situation with a fall in activity, an unemployment increase in the millions and the collapse of entire sectors. If you correct them, you gain in competitiveness, improve exports, moderate prices and have them, as now is the case, at contained rates. The more dynamic sectors are boosted and export capacity increases.
So, in a situation such as the one we now have, it is necessary to maintain confidence in the Spanish economy. The history of our country over the last few decades has been one of success, among other things, because Spain is the sixth leading country in the world in terms of per capita increase in Gross Domestic Product; an increase which, over the last 20 years, has exceeded that of Germany, France and Italy. Hence, our collective effort should be aimed at recovering a continued drive in the not too distant future. Our aim as a country must be to pull ourselves up to the levels of well-being and wealth of the more advanced European Union countries.
Now that we have come out of economic recession, and find ourselves on the first rungs of recovery, we should remember the goal we set ourselves. In this regard, the budding recovery must be a point of connection with the path to our historic target.
Some, in seeking quick and easy solutions, have felt nostalgia for those periods in which we could devalue our currency to improve our competitiveness overseas; but we should not forget that devaluation means impoverishing the country vis-à-vis the rest of the world: increased prices deriving from more expensive imports, particularly in a country such as ours, which is so energy-dependent, and a loss of foreign investments, which consequently makes the country less attractive as a place to invest and, thus leads to increased interest rates.
But, at the end of the day, it is not worth devoting a second more to something that is no longer in our hands. We have had to recover the balances lost by means of what some call a cold devaluation and others an internal devaluation. This requires greater sacrifices and effort in the short term, but the clean-up is more far-reaching and lasting. Without undergoing a devaluation, our challenge has been to recover competitiveness through price, salary and income moderation. And, when many thought that this was impossible, we have started to achieve this thanks to the hard work from everyone; we are managing to become more competitive than our trade partners while maintaining the purchasing power of our citizens.
In short, friends, we are now starting a new phase. I don't mean setting a new course, but rather a new stage on the course that we plotted at the start of the legislature. We will continue working very hard on fiscal consolidation at all levels of the public administration services. We will remain focused on the far-reaching clean-up process being carried out on our financial sector to guarantee its absolute solvency. And we will continue improving the organisational quality of our labour market, which is already starting to show the first signs of the success of its reform.
So, to avoid wearing you out, we will maintain everything that is already under way; but we will take some additional steps because this legislature, as I have said on various occasions, must be the legislature of on-going reform processes. I will name just some that will be implemented this year:
Ladies and gentlemen,
At the start of the legislature, we asked the Spanish people to make a great effort. The situation we inherited forced us to raise taxes to maintain social policy and benefits to pensioners and the unemployed whilst reducing public spending. Now that the economy is more stable, this new situation allows us to adopt a new tax system. It is time to start to return to society the contribution it made to improve the economic situation. The budding economic recovery is leading to a rise in the tax bases, thus making possible today what was impossible two years ago.
We are going to modernise our tax system by designing a raft of fairer and simpler taxes. Nine months ago, as you are aware, the Council of Ministers commissioned an expert committee to reform the tax system. This committee, made up of independent experts of renowned academic and professional standing - you have heard some of them speak here today - were tasked with performing a comprehensive study of our current tax system with the aim of drafting proposals for its reform. They were given the simple guideline that the new system must contribute to improving economic growth and to exiting the crisis, combined with renewed job creation.
Spain needs more modern taxes, adapted to the new framework of world globalisation and stronger economic competitiveness.
A little over a month ago, the government received a proposed reform from the aforesaid committee which, after in-depth analysis, will be drafted in a series of rules that will be submitted to the Council of Ministers and then to Parliament within the following three months. The opinion of the experts obviously does not coincide with that of the government, but the general lines will define its future development.
I cannot announce the specific details of this reform, but I can tell you that it responds to the following economic objectives:
This reform is not a short-term objective; it is a complete programme that will extend the reduction in taxes over a period of various years and help underpin economic growth beyond 2015:
Corporate Income Tax will continue to enjoy incentives for SMEs and the self-employed, in addition to incentives for reinvesting benefits and investment in R&D. The reform will be completed with a reduction in the nominal rates, thus converging with the more competitive countries in the European Union.
Finally, the tax reform, due to its impact on transfers between the regional public administration services, will include an assessment of the situation of the system of regional and local financing, which will be adapted to the changes that take place in the different tax figures. These changes, far from being automatic, will allow progress to be made in guaranteeing the availability of sufficient financing for the provision of essential public services for all our citizens under similar conditions throughout the country.
As I already said, we need to wait under the regulatory modifications are enacted, but these are the general lines of action.
I will finish now, ladies and gentlemen. I repeat that, if you are kind enough to invite me here again next year to your Assembly, we will have the opportunity to assess what I have outlined for you here today.
What remains to be done requires great dedication and hard work, in the same way that Spanish society has done to date; but now, at least, we have some tangible evidence that the efforts being made lead to a change of direction in our course from one of disaster to one of success; success achieved through an economy capable of reducing unemployment and generating an increasing number of new jobs. I am convinced that with your collaboration and help, which is absolutely essential, we will be able to achieve this.
Thank you very much indeed.
Q&A Session with President of the Government following his speech at the annual assembly of the Institute of Family Business
Q.- With your permission, Mr President of the Government, I have a number of questions I wanted to ask you. The first being, what are the risks that, in your opinion, could threaten the recovery of the Spanish economy? Are you concerned by deflation, the high level of unemployment or, for example, another possible accident to the Euro, such as that which took place in Greece, with the subsequent turmoil in the markets?
President of the Government.- I will tell you what I think, as you would expect. I believe that the situation in Europe has changed significantly over the last few months. I assumed responsibility for the presidency of the government on 21 December 2011 and let me tell you that 2012 was an extremely hard year. In 2012, debate surrounded whether the Euro was going to continue or not, whether all of the countries were going to remain in the Euro that had been present until then or only certain countries, and whether there was going to be a first and second division Euro, with Spain being in the latter category. What was basically being debated was whether Spain would be bailed out or not; what we were talking about was whether we would receive financing at our next auction or not.
That was a very complicated year, we had to face a sovereign debt crisis and also a financial crisis. I believe that things have now changed significantly. I believe that Europe is now going through a period of stability; I believe that this is very positive. I think that the Euro is calm, as are the markets, and those countries subject to a programme have significantly improved their respective situations: Ireland has terminated its programme and Portugal will do so shortly.
Hence, from the perspective of the European situation, I am more relaxed because, in addition to solely and exclusively speaking about fiscal consolidation, austerity and the fiscal compact - I lived through this at the beginning of 2012 - we have started speaking about European integration, greater economic union, youth unemployment, small- and medium-sized enterprises… There has clearly been a significant change.
I believe that things are going well in Europe. I hope that now, following the European elections, people will support the parties that believe in this project, which, on the other hand, is irreversible as a European project, because the European Parliament will now take on new powers that are greater than ever. Sometimes people don't realise but 70% of the laws applied in Spain now come from Europe - I repeat - 70%. And the European Parliament will take on, as from the upcoming elections on 25 May, very considerable new powers. Hence, I am relaxed as regard the issue of Europe.
In Spain, I am aware that we still need to see results coming through; we have seen some but they are clearly insufficient, and there are many people who you could say have still not seen economic recovery. But if one thing is clear, it is that we are laying solid foundations, as I tried to explain in my speech, for the future.
As regards the public deficit, we have tried to reduce the public deficit during a recession, which is not easy, have that absolutely clear in your minds. The public deficit is being turned around and this will continue.
On the matter of the foreign sector which, as I said in my speech, amounted back then to a deficit of 10%, it now has, for the first time in 15 years, a surplus of 1.5%. That is a very positive figure.
The tourism figures are good. You are well aware that we are exporting, and exporting a lot. Sometimes people say, "this is the country of construction and tourism". No, excuse me, we export capital goods - our biggest export - and chemical products, and the agri-food industry is on a truly significant rise, as is the automobile sector. Hence, this should be seen as reasonable.
The other day we read a report from the Bank of Spain, containing some encouraging figures. Apart from higher growth forecast than that of the government, and while that is positive it is not the most important thing; there are other figures that have greatly surprised me; let's see if they then turn out to be true. Consumption will improve; private consumption; that is a very important fact. Everything points to 2015 - let's see if it's true or not, but it's what the Bank of Spain says - being a positive year for the construction sector. It's been negative for many years now, worse than 10%; the forecast is now for 4% this year. If this is indeed the case, they are encouraging figures. At any event, the foundations have been laid.
What problems might there me? What would I like to see? A different exchange rate to that which we have, because that will allow us to export even more than we already do. That is not within the powers, as you know, of the government I head up; it is one of the European powers, specifically of the European Central Bank, even though I would like to see that.
What would I like to see? You mentioned the matter of inflation to me. For us it would be good to have a rate of inflation that is lower than our partners in the European Union and than our trading partners, since in that way we gain in competitiveness; however, what is not good for us is for inflation in Europe to be around the 0.5% mark, despite it being at zero in Spain, above all taking into account that the inflationary target in Europe is 2%. That is why I don't understand some people. Listen, if the target is 2% and we have 0.5%, just because we have 1.5%, while others have 0.5% or 0.7% is hardly a major problem.
These are two issues that concern me. I continue to be concerned by credit, but I must say that things have improved on that front, as you yourselves have pointed out. I heard this just now when your president presented his survey.
But, in short, I believe that there is recovery in Spain. We had 0.7% set as the figure for growth this year and then in the Debate on the State of the Nation I announced the figure of 1%. We must now present our Stability Pact to the European Union together with the new macroeconomic scenario. The Bank of Spain announced growth of 1.2%, for the time being the government will stick with 1% and then let's see what happens. And, of course, it is not the same to grow by 1% as to shrink by 1.2%, which is what happened in 2013. Hence the difference amounts to 2.2%.
In summary, I believe that there are things that would be good for us, such as a change in the rate of inflation, but I don't see any major risks and I believe that we are entering a much better phase now. The problem is - and of course we started off in such a bad situation - more than five and a half million people being out of work is wholly unacceptable. And that is a battle which we obviously need to win.
Q.- You said this before, and you have just said it again now that your government has reduced the public deficit against a recessive backdrop; however the hardest part is still to come. Will it be necessary to implement significant cut-backs in the Welfare State or will it be enough with just economic growth?
President of the Government.- In 2011, we had a public deficit in excess of 9%. We were asking for almost 90 billion euros each year, which is something, as almost anyone can appreciate, that is absolutely unbearable.
We were in a situation whereby in just two years - 2008 and 2009 - we lost almost 70 billion euros in revenue. I believe, because I have been told this, that the tax experts that were here today recalled that, for example, Spain, of the 28 Member States of the European Union, is number 28 in VAT collection, in other words the last in terms of the proportion of VAT collected out of the Gross Domestic Product. That makes reducing the deficit all the more difficult.
In the first year, in 2012, the target set was 4.4%. That is an outrageous figure. You cannot ask anyone to reduce the deficit from 9% to 4.4% in a recession; that is something that is quite simply impossible. Following someone complicated negotiations - and believe me when I say they were complicated - a different deficit target was set which I believe we met reasonably well. In 2013, also following some tough negotiations, a reasonable deficit target of 6.5% was set. The other day the Minister for the Treasury announced the final figure, 6.61%. This is a deviation of only 0.1% which, after the summer as a result of the new methodology to be used by Eurostat for revising GDP figures, it will be seen that we met the deficit target. And next year the target set stands at 5.8%.
Will we meet this? I believe we will because, obviously if in 2012 economic growth stood at -1.6% and in 2013 it stood at -1.2%, and if this year it will stand at +1%, we will clearly collect more in revenue. Indeed, in the first two months of the year, revenue has been markedly higher than in the first two months of 2013 after all the new tax measures came into effect.
There is another very important figure: interest rates. Last year the fall in the risk premium meant that we saved 8.5 billion euros in Spain compared with what was budgeted, or 0.8% of the public deficit. I believe that this year the interest rates will also be helpful in this respect.
Remember that all the reforms we have implemented are not going to produce results overnight, they take time and there are some important reforms waiting to produce results.
The reform of the public administration services. This reform is something that is constantly being talked about and I can say this as I have been the minister in charge of the public administration services: everybody is talking about the reform of the public administration. We are carrying out a reform of the public administration, but the issue at hand is that this reform is not very attractive for public purposes. For the people, a reform of the public administration means getting rid of an autonomous region or something similar. No, the reform of the public administration means making savings, being more efficient; explain this well to the man in the street…
And, since the start-up of the reform of the public administration services, which I have commissioned the Vice-President of the Government to undertake and on which a team of well qualified public servants is solely and exclusively working at this time, we have already saved 7.38 billion euros, which by the end of 2015 will have risen to an accumulated total of 28 billion euros. This is a major structural change, one of the most important ones to have been implemented by this government.
The OECD itself has said - they came here and evaluated this reform - that this is a comprehensive reform that affects its general culture and operation, and which covers many policies, such as budgetary stability, the management of human resources, an improvement in administrative coordination, the use of new technologies, transparency, etc., etc.
Allow me to mention just one fact; I don't want to bore you; and that is the Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability. I remember that two or three years ago people were saying, "Spain cannot meet its deficit target because the autonomous regions will be a disaster and they cannot meet their targets". Well, just look, with all the problems we've had, in the end we have been able, by working together, to draft a Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability in which everyone has their target deficit. It is true that some have strayed from their deficit target, but in the end, the country as a whole, which is what we submit to the European authorities, and what gives us credibility with the markets or not, has met its public deficit target for this year.
The same has happened with the local authority reform, a reform which came into force not long ago, and which will take time to have an effect but which will also result in a significant cost saving.
Hence, we will continue meeting our deficit targets, among other things, because we cannot continuously have a deficit, and I believe that we can do this without having to raise taxes, as we were forced to do before, and without having to make any further cuts than those we have already had to make.
Q.- Mr President of the Government, you have spoken to us about the new tax framework, you have also spoken to us about taxes and you have announced that we can expect a reduction in the Corporate Income Tax rate. The fact is, that against a backdrop of crisis, you have managed to double Corporate Income Tax collection since you came to power. My question is that many of the measures that have been taken were originally announced as temporary stop-gap measures but they seem to be here to stay for a little longer than originally foreseen; will these measures be overturned, revised, or…?
President of the Government.- That is an issue about which I haven't taken a definitive decision. I seem to remember that the expert committee is the party that argued that. And that is the decision that you don't approve of.
What I can say at this time is what I indicated before: that the nominal rates will be lowered, and that, little by little it will be necessary to bring effective tax rates in line with nominal tax rates. You are all also aware of the tax rates that companies have been paying for the last few years. Some pay more, others pay less. We will try to do something sensible and reasonable, and something that does not prejudice our companies, but which also helps the rest of the country as a whole to generate economic growth, employment and the collection of tax revenue.
Q.- As regards Europe, earlier President Javier Moll showed you the results from our survey regarding the assessment we have made of the European Commission and the European Central Bank, where the Commission comes out worst while the ECB is much closer to receiving approval. Do you agree with this opinion, Mr President of the Government?
President of the Government.- When we came to power, we saw something very clearly and based on that we started working very hard. Here, in order to exit the crisis, to generate wealth, to create jobs and to be a great country, it is very important… I believe that nowadays the most important thing is that you are capable of doing the best you can with the powers at your disposal, in this case, in Spain; but, of course it is also very important that we are in Europe, and the decisions taken there, by the European Central Bank, by the Commission itself and by the European Council, which are the governing bodies.
I believe that there are five things that must be done and we have put all our efforts into that: firstly, fiscal consolidation in Spain. I believe that it is very positive to reduce the public deficit. I explained earlier that this must be done in a reasonable manner. You obviously cannot ask anyone to reduce their public deficit by nine points; in other words, it must be reduced, but in a reasonable manner. And the target of reaching budgetary stability is something very sensible and reasonable, as we are all well aware: in this world it is better not to owe anything and, if possible, that no-one owes you anything either.
Secondly, structural reforms in our country. We have implemented many and we continue to do so. But that has not been enough and that is from there that I will deal with your question.
Thirdly, Europe must continue working on its internal market and on more economic union. There are matters that have not been resolved. For example, just look at what has happened in Crimea as a result of the events in Ukraine; you have seen how one country has raised the gas prices for another by no less than 40%. The gas we consume in Europe comes, firstly, from Norway, but right next to Norway is Russia. Spain doesn't import any gas from Russia, Spain receives its gas from Algeria. Now, if things had been done properly, there would be interconnections that would allow Europe to rely on a number of different gas suppliers. That is progress in economic union. This is a debate that was recently held, because these events took place in the Ukraine a short time ago. Hence, we must continue making progress on economic union.
I believe, moreover - and this has been done, we have spoken about the Digital Agenda; progress is being made, fourthly, the decisions that have been taken in Europe regarding greater integration have sent a positive message out, because they have removed many doubts regarding the irreversibility of the Euro. When banking union is implemented, the message being sent out is that these people are serious, because the Spanish banks are now going to be supervised by the European Central Bank and not by the Bank of Spain. The Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring (Spanish acronym: FROB) that we have here in Spain, through which we have made the restructuring of many banks possible, will now become a European FROB and there will be a European regulation that guarantees deposits and that says what must be done when there is a situation regarding a financial entity that needs to be resolved.
In other words, it is a very clear message on integration that is easy to understand. Hence, we must continue down this path, and I believe that in this matter Europe, the Council, and also the Commission, have done this as well.
Then you have the European Central Bank. This is an independent body which has done some very positive things. I remember that in 2011 it bought up bonds on the secondary market; then it created the famous LTROs, in other words, loans to banks over three years, and during that period it also did something very positive which was to say, "listen, just in case anyone doesn't have this clear, we are here to help". That is important. This is not a specific measure, but it is a very clear message.
Hence, can the European Commission, the Spanish Government, the European Central Bank do things better? Yes, they can. In the end, we have had many battles with the European Commission on many issues, in the same way as the regional governments have them with us. For example, one of the issues over which we have had a major dispute was the issue of the shipping industry. This is a very important issue for many people; for example, in Galicia or in the Basque Country. This is an important matter; it is a key sector for us.
Navantia will soon be commissioning ship-builders in Galicia and in Puerto Real to build two vessels, each for a value in excess of 300 million euros. I believe that this is undoubtedly something very positive. We have had a dispute with the Commission over this matter, like on many other matters; but I believe that in the end things are being done reasonably well.
The operation being performed in Europe is… I don't know of any other larger operation, at least over several centuries, than that being carried out by the European Union. If you said to someone just a few years ago that there are no borders and that there is free movement of goods, capital and services, that there is no national currency, that someone else decides on your monetary policy, that the European Commission tells the fishermen in my village where they can go to fish, because this is one of the powers that corresponds to the European Commission… We have now reached an agreement with Morocco and, in order to fish in Morocco, it was necessary to go the European Parliament. This European Parliament did not approve this agreement the first time round and we had to return there to fight on this issue.
This is very tough but Europe is irreversible, Europe exists, it must be taken very seriously and, as I said before, we must be aware that a lot is at stake in the upcoming elections, although it would seem that some don't see this as so.
Hence, I am optimistic. Of course things can be done better, but I am optimistic. The Commission is about to be renewed; just look at the democratic progress this represents; the fact that we now have candidates for the presidency of the European Commission, is of great relevance.
Q.- One and a half questions, Mr President of the Government. What started as a whisper that was barely audible has now snowballed. Do you believe that the situation created in Catalonia can be resolved through dialogue to the satisfaction of all parties concerned?
President of the Government.- I sincerely hope so. Nothing else has gone through my mind. I believe that we need to talk; but yes, it is good that we know that Parliament, which tomorrow will be asked to transfer an exclusive power over to the State, was made aware, in the same way as I was and all the members of my government were made aware, through the media, of the decision adopted by one person to call a referendum, setting the date and the questions to be asked, and now we are going to have a debate on the decision that I have taken. So, of course, should we say yes? This is called, as you are well aware, a membership agreement, apart from which I am not going to get involved in any other legal considerations or considerations of any other nature.
I hope that tomorrow we have a clarifying debate in Parliament, but I will remain positive. This is the oldest nation in Europe, we have spent more than 500 years living together and we are bound by all sorts of ties: family ties, emotional ties, blood ties… I said "blood ties" the other day and it is true; we are also bound by blood ties. We have done many things together throughout history. We have made many mistakes and we have made them together, but we have also got many things right.
In the last 50 years, Spain is the fifth country in the world, no not the fifth, among the five leading countries - but that includes Hong Kong and Singapore which have a special status - with the greatest per capita income increase. And since the Spanish Constitution was approved in 1978, growth in Spain has been amongst the highest, if not the highest, of all the OECD countries.
We have done many things together, and very important things, but it seems that we sometimes don't realise this; but the changes that have taken place in this country have been spectacular in each and every region of this country.
Catalonia has historically been very important for Spain and it will remain so in the future. It is land of people who are entrepreneurs, who risk their money, who work hard, who make an effort, who do things, and who contribute a great deal to the national GDP. We may have our problems and argue about whether the model of financing is the right one or not. I have spent many years in politics and I have heard this debate on many occasions, but I have also heard the Regional Government of Catalonia say in 2009 that "this is a great model of financing", as I also heard in 2002.
We can discuss many things, but what we cannot do now, because it makes no sense, because the whole world is undergoing a process of integration… It is not possible to be small these days; you can't do that. I have spoken to you here, without knowing that you were going to ask me about this issue, about banking union, about greater economic union; I have spoken to you about fiscal union and about fishermen in Galicia needing the agreement of the European Parliament. That is where the world is heading. If not, why would the Pacific Alliance exist? If not, why is the European Union negotiating a free trade agreement with the United States and with Japan? If not, what is MERCOSUR?
I obviously believe that we must all make an effort, I believe that we must all be subject to the law and I believe that these things are resolved through dialogue, and not by taking unilateral decisions and then proposing them to others.
Q.- The last question. As it is almost obligatory and follows the script, the media have been speculating almost since the very start with a government crisis and with changes in your government. We are not on the same page. I wanted to ask you about the possibility of Luis de Guindos ending up being the President of the Eurogroup.
President of the Government.- That is very difficult to answer, because there is now a very important debate ahead… No, not a debate, but elections and in the coming months we need to appoint the President of the European Commission, the President of the European Council, the EU's High Commissioner for Foreign Affairs, the President of the Eurogroup and we need to appoint many commissioners and vice-presidents of the Commission. Some are more important than others, aren't they?
I believe that Spain has earned itself credit because Spain, which was in the situation you are well aware of, because we had to hear about what was being said of us in 2012, I believe that it has made a great effort. I say Spain, not the government, because it has been a collective effort by the people of Spain. I believe that we have earned ourselves credit and we are entitled to fight for things, because we want to collaborate with our talent and with our hard work to building Europe.
As to what will happen, who knows. Let's wait and see.
Q.- Thank you very much, Mr President of the Government.