Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

8 April 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on April 8, 2014, addressing child poverty and social policy.
Main themes
Child poverty in Spain, universal child benefit, social inclusion policies, government response to economic crisis, family protection measures, EU child poverty comparison, budgetary priorities, social welfare programs
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,574
69th percentile
Sentences
92
59th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 41%40%
  • Social 31%30%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

92 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

Ms. Díez.- In the Debate on the State of the Nation, on February 25, 2014, on behalf of my Parliamentary Group, I asked the President of the Government that the protection of children against violence and exclusion, poverty, and discrimination should be recognized as a fundamental right in the Spanish legal system. I then provided, in that intervention, 2,826,549 reasons, which are the Spanish children living below the poverty line.

Today I want to insist with the same arguments, but with new data on that same issue, on that same concern, which must have political significance, as we are not talking about a sectoral issue.

UNICEF has also just made known some new data: the extraordinary fund for the fight against child poverty in Spain, of seventeen million euros that was approved, represents two euros per year per child identified as being in poverty. An amount, Mr. President, that you will understand is clearly below the needs of child poverty in Spain.

Another important piece of data: of the twenty-eight member states of the European Union, twenty-one have universal child benefits; twenty-one out of twenty-eight. Spain is not among them; Spain does not have that benefit.

I think it would be interesting for you to tell us whether the Government plans to establish that universal benefit because, after all, when one looks at the data, when one sees the picture, which you surely know and which I am not going to show you because it is not about me getting a photo with the picture, Spain ranks as the third country by child poverty rate in the twenty-eight of Europe, being the second country that does not have a universal benefit.

As when I raised this issue in that debate I have cited, you referred… You told me in your reply that you did not agree with what I was saying but that, above all, you believed that this was not a matter I should address in the Debate, and you told me, verbatim: "when you talk about child poverty, the only thing I will say is that I better not enter into your intervention on that matter." You told me more, you said: "better watch yourself on television."

That is why I ask you today: do you believe that the Government is doing what it should in this matter?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez. Undoubtedly, this is the most bitter and painful face of the economic crisis. And child poverty is a cross-cutting objective in the National Action Plan for Social Inclusion that we have recently approved and which is endowed with 136 billion euros. It will be present in the different axes and specific objectives that make up the 240 planned measures.

Not only is that Extraordinary Fund for the Fight Against Child Poverty, to which you have just referred, included, amounting to seventeen million euros; the Social Urgency Programs are also included in the call for IRPF subsidies.

We have approved, and we are already applying, the National Strategic Plan for Childhood and Adolescence, endowed with more than 5 billion euros for the next four years, with 120 measures.

We will do everything that budgetary possibilities allow us, because I agree with you that it is a matter of enormous importance. And, if we have sufficient resources, we will once again implement the universal child benefit in our country.

Ms. Díez.- Mr. President, politics and governing is about making choices. "If we have resources…". We have resources if you prioritize these policies; that is, it is your decision and we cannot blame anyone else.

President.- Yes, Your Honor, governing is about making choices; but we are making very important decisions in this regard. The best way to combat inequality, poverty, and child poverty is to create jobs. Fortunately, things are starting to move in Spain.

We have strengthened the PREPARA Plan, increasing aid for beneficiaries with family responsibilities; we exempt from the payment of medications when parents have exhausted unemployment benefits; all minors under eighteen are guaranteed healthcare, without exception; we have dedicated forty million euros to provide food to many people; we are going to take measures to incorporate women into the labor market; we are going to improve, in the tax reform, the taxation of families with children — that is an important decision — and also the legal protection framework for them; we are working to strengthen the legal protection framework for minors and we will soon approve a Comprehensive Family Plan, which we will bring to this Chamber, which will strengthen their social, legal, and economic protection.

Therefore, the Government is fully aware of this problem. It has already made many decisions and will continue to do so throughout the remainder of the Legislature.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of United Left

Mr. Lara.- Mr. President, how does the Government plan to reduce social inequality with the upcoming announced tax reform?

President.- Mr. Lara, I will spare you, as it is well known, the explanations about the Commission of Experts, its purpose, and the results of its work. I only remind you that the objective is to present this tax reform in this Chamber this spring.

The reform will fundamentally have three objectives: first, the creation of jobs and the improvement of the competitiveness of the Spanish economy, which is a national objective; second, the fight against fraud. As you know very well, Spain is the last country in the European Union in terms of VAT collection in proportion to GDP: twenty-eight out of twenty-eight. And the third major objective is that the contribution to public burdens is made with criteria of justice, so that those who have more capacity to pay contribute more.

I believe that if we achieve these three objectives, which are what the tax reform aims for, we will make significant progress in reducing social inequality, because more jobs, less fraud, and more justice in the distribution of burdens will undoubtedly lead, in this case fortunately, to less social inequality.

Mr. Lara.- We agree on philosophy, but then in concrete practice we do not agree, Mr. President.

Inequality is fought with resources, and everyone knows that. And I believe, and we believe, that the Government has no will to fight against inequality. Maintaining a tax fraud of eighty billion euros, without combating it thoroughly, is unreasonable. A 9 percent decrease in revenue in 2013 has been obtained with the fight against tax fraud; the data is published, and the Government has not denied it.

You maintain — it is said, and Mr. Lagares has said in an interview — that you had an orientation to move to a tax pressure that ranged between 37 and 38 percent. That is nine points below the average of the European Union in tax pressure, and that is the orientation that the Government has given to Mr. Lagares; otherwise, you will have to deny it.

It is happening, not only because there is an unjust tax system, which it is, but because capital gains are taxed very little in this country. And there is a published fact that the Government does not deny either: that the three thousand largest companies in this country, in the Corporate Tax in 2011-2012, and it has not been corrected, paid an average of 3 percent. Therefore, there is no will to fight against tax fraud.

Moreover, it is said that taxes will be lowered; it is in the campaign of the Popular Party, you have said it. Well, if we are at a tax pressure of 37 percent and, in addition, you think you will lower taxes further, you have to explain to me how you will continue not cutting and how you will manage to combat social inequality in our country. Because, in addition, it is supposed that the taxes will be lowered for the same people, as in the tax amnesty, and will be charged, in any case, to the social majority, as has been done through VAT.

That is why people have come to Madrid, that is why people are mobilizing; that is why the Marches of Dignity arrived. And they demanded three things to end inequality; they were: bread, shelter, and work.

And I formally propose to you again today, Mr. President of the Government, that ending social inequality in Spain is a matter of political will. Make an urgent shock plan for the long-term unemployed, start working on a basic minimum income so that no one is left in exclusion, and withdraw resources from Andalusia so that everyone can have the right to a roof, to decent housing, as stated in the article…

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara. As I have said, the objective is more employment, less fraud, and better distribution of burdens among citizens.

The issue of employment requires many things: it is not just a problem of fiscal policy, as is well known by all present; it is not just a problem of taxes, but it requires reformist economic policies like the ones we are carrying out. One of the latest measures we have adopted is the flat rate for Social Security of one hundred euros per month.

Therefore, the fundamental objective of that reform is to create jobs, which is undoubtedly a fundamental instrument to fight against inequality.

Secondly, regarding the issue of fraud, which is another of the major objectives, I must say that some positive effects have already occurred: collection has improved, the Public Employment Offer provides many more material and personal resources to the State Tax Administration Agency, and we have collected, so far this year, 6.4 percent more than last year.

I want to tell you that the large Spanish companies paid last year, the rate, double that of the previous year and that in some cases, the withholding went from zero to a withholding of more than 50 percent.

Regarding the future, the IRPF will maintain its progressivity. We will lower the rate for everyone, but especially for the twelve million with low and medium incomes; those who earn less than one thousand euros will not pay taxes; there will be special protection for families and disabled individuals, and the personal minimums for children and dependents will be raised.

Therefore, I believe that this will be a tax reform that you might even be able to applaud.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Parliamentary Group Socialist

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you share the criticisms of Minister Montoro towards two NGOs that have just denounced the increase in inequality in Spain?

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, I respect and value very much the work of Non-Governmental Organizations that carry out a task of enormous social importance.

I am absolutely aware, on the other hand, of the situation and the difficulties that many Spanish families are going through. I work, together with my Government and the Minister of Finance and Public Administrations, to improve that situation, and believe me, that is the objective of the Government.

What surprises me is that you are concerned about this issue now and not during your time in Government, when poverty and social exclusion, according to Eurostat, grew five times faster in Spain between 2008 and 2011 than in the rest of the European Union. It was that period when 3,400,000 Spaniards lost their jobs, and it is that period that we are now overcoming through much effort on the part of Spanish society as a whole, which could have been avoided if you had not carried out the economic policy that you applied in your day.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- I was going to start my question differently, saying that I agree with Mr. Montoro, that you are indeed beyond repair, and saying that you are the author of the shortest tax cut in history: it lasted twenty minutes. But I will talk about Mr. Rajoy's response.

Look, you and I have statistical differences; that is evident. I ask you to read the report of the Ombudsman from the year 2013; 2013, your time in Government, you had been governing for a year. 2013, there appears the inequality that your measures, Mr. Rajoy, your measures, have created in our country and that the NGOs denounce, those with which Mr. Montoro messes. Do you know why? Because you mess with anyone who tells you the truth, with anyone.

And I will tell you more: Mr. Montoro has talked about statistical realities or statistical measurements. He said: no, it is not social reality; it is statistical measurements. Look, Mr. Rajoy, the statistics are what you are using, and the social reality is what you are not seeing, because there are millions of families in Spain who cannot make ends meet because of your policies, Mr. Rajoy, because it is your policies that have created inequality. You have lowered wages in Spain, you have taken away rights from workers, you have cut many social benefits, and you have raised many taxes on those who can hardly make ends meet. And that, Mr. Rajoy, creates inequality. That is your policy, the one you have carried out in 2012 and 2013.

I will tell you more, or I will tell you in another way: labor precariousness, the lowering of wages, and the difficulties in making collective agreements in Spain, which leave workers unprotected, are not collateral effects of a policy that Mr. Rajoy has developed, no. It is Mr. Rajoy's policy that creates inequality in Spain.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, I am not going to talk about statistics or statements; but I will talk about social reality, because you have referred to it.

Social reality is the 3,400,000 Spaniards who lost their jobs when you were in government; social reality is the pensioners who saw their pensions frozen when you were in government; social reality was the macroeconomic imbalances that you left when you were in government; social reality was the seventy billion euros that you lost in revenue when you were in government; social reality was the elimination of the four hundred euros; the elimination of the baby check of 2,500 euros; social reality was the liquidation of employment and an economic policy that left Spain on the brink of rescue and on the verge of falling into the situation that other countries fell into.

The reality of this government is that it has been forced to make tough and difficult decisions to avoid rescue and to prevent this country, completely indebted, from going bankrupt.

You do not have, you do not have it, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba --it seems unbelievable that you do not realize-- moral authority to talk about these things, because it is your policies that have led us to this situation. And now it is us who are implementing an economic policy that is already beginning to produce results and, because it is beginning to produce results, I already have the feeling that you are starting to get nervous, when you should be happy that we have been able to resolve and turn around the situation that a government, like the one you vice-presided, generated.

Enough already!, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.