Guest lecture by Prime Minister Rutte on democracy

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

20 February 2023 · Guest lecture on democracy

Context
Rutte delivered a guest lecture at a university hall named after Professor Cleveringa, reflecting on democracy's strength nearly one year after Russia's large-scale invasion of Ukraine.
Main themes
Democracy vs. tyranny, Russian invasion of Ukraine, support for Ukraine, democratic values, international legal order, Dutch history and identity, NATO and collective security, geopolitical positioning, rule of law, freedom and human rights, Dutch Constitution, Winston Churchill on democracy
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,342
80th percentile
Sentences
205
89th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.1
11th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 38%33%
  • Institutional 21%18%
  • Social 20%17%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Economic 11%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

205 sentences in 88 paragraphs

Why democracy will always remain 'the shining city on a hill'

Ladies and gentlemen, dear students,

As a historian, I am of course aware that the question of whether something is historical is always answered in hindsight. But I do not think I am exaggerating when I say that on February 24, 2022, a page in the book of world history was turned.

I was in Kyiv last week, and as you walk around there and hear all those heartbreaking stories, you cannot come to any other conclusion. To be honest, I am still at a loss for words.

In three days, it will be exactly one year since the large-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine.

A year of war, in which we have seen and continue to see every day how autocracy, lust for power, and a total lack of respect for human life lead to the most horrific acts and the deepest human misery.

But it is also a year that proves how powerful a president, a people, a country can be when they fight for their freedom with conviction. We can only have the utmost admiration and deepest respect for that. And we must continue to provide Ukraine with all the financial and military support.

What concerns us most after this year is the fate of Ukraine and the Ukrainians. This terrible war must come to an end, the senseless loss of human lives and the destruction of buildings and infrastructure must stop. After that, an immense task of reconstruction, truth-finding and justice, and a new future for Ukraine awaits.

There is much to think about after this year. About how we should position ourselves geopolitically in relation to countries like Russia, China, and Iran. About cooperation with our allies and partners with whom we share democratic values, both Transatlantic and European. And about how much our freedom, our rule of law, and our democracy are actually worth to us.

Very literally, what is it worth to us, what do we have materially to spare for it? Questions we did not have to ask ourselves for a long time. But now we do.

I would like to discuss this with you. But first, let me share my thoughts on why I believe that democracy will always be stronger than tyranny. And where better to argue that than in this hall, named after one of the most principled defenders of the democratic rule of law in our history, Professor Cleveringa.

Democracy is not flawless, certainly not without weaknesses, and certainly not without threats. But it is incredibly strong. Or as Winston Churchill said in that well-known quote:

“Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.”

And that brings me to the fact that there is strong support in the Netherlands for military and financial assistance to Ukraine. Why is that support so great and massive?

It has everything to do with democratic values and our own history. We know what it is to be threatened or trampled by a large and powerful neighboring country.

That runs very deep because of World War II. But it goes back much further.

In the time of the Republic, the threat actually came from all the European great powers around us: Spain, England, France. With the Disaster Year of 1672 as a dramatic low point. And in the years between 1795 and 1813, the Netherlands was de facto under French rule. So the David-versus-Goliath feeling, that you cannot invade a smaller neighboring country with impunity as a large country, is ingrained in us.

I think the Dutch also understand well that this war is about their own future as well. About our future.

It is a simple question: if we had let Putin have his way, would he have stopped at Ukraine? We may seriously doubt that, and thus NATO territory itself would be seriously threatened. And therefore the international legal order, as it was established after World War II.

That would hit the Netherlands at its core, both militarily and economically. Ensuring that Putin does not win this unjust war is therefore simply a hard Dutch interest.

Since February 24 of last year, there has not been a day that I have not been occupied with the war in Ukraine. Almost every day there are new developments that require a quick response. This makes it all the more important that our own Constitution contains a solid legal and international law basis for support to Ukraine.

I recently realized this again, thanks to Afshin Ellian and Bastiaan Rijpkema, who were kind enough to offer me a copy of that beautiful new book with commentaries on the Dutch Constitution. What struck me was the combination of two components.

First, the general provision, which has only been in our Constitution since last year.

It now states: “The constitution guarantees fundamental rights and the democratic rule of law.”

Secondly, our Constitution has long contained that special Article 90: “The government promotes the international legal order.”

I am convinced that these two are closely related, because the safeguarding of fundamental rights and the democratic rule of law in the Netherlands can only occur if the international legal order functions properly. And thus, the law contains an extra incentive, a mandate, to continue supporting Ukraine as part of a coalition of countries.

It is astonishing how quickly the conversation about war and peace has become normal in just a year. It seemed so far away, trenches in Europe, the shelling of civilian targets, torture and rape as the most vile weapons of war. But in hindsight, how close it was. And how much the world has changed because of it – especially ours in Europe.

During the preparation for today, I was reminded of my own student days. At that time, the Berlin Wall fell – in 1989. We now know for sure that it was a historic moment.

In that same year, Francis Fukuyama wrote his famous essay and shortly thereafter his book about the 'end of history'. In Fukuyama's thinking at that time, it revolved around the thesis that with the end of the Cold War, liberal democracy had become the ultimate form of governance. It seemed a matter of time, a historical inevitability, that our Western political system would become dominant worldwide.

Call it naïve, but it was a feeling that was widely shared at the time, even by me. We wanted to believe it.

And looking back, it may be obvious to say that the wish was the father of the thought. That we suffered from a serious form of collective wishful thinking.

But that optimism did come from somewhere. The end of the Cold War ushered in a wave of democratization worldwide. And a sense of optimism, especially when Nelson Mandela was released in 1990 and apartheid was abolished in South Africa. It seemed inconceivable that that trend towards more freedom and democracy would be reversed.

Seemed.

In recent decades, we have seen that democracy is under pressure or being pushed back worldwide. The American NGO Freedom House has seen a global trend of democratic decline for 16 years.

As in Russia, where after the Cold War, with ups and downs, the path to democracy was initiated. Putin turned back the clock – back to a totalitarian regime.

Gradually, through a web of organized lies and a step-by-step elimination of the free press, of any form of opposition, and of independent judiciary. To the point where we are now: with Putin as a dictator, waging a ruthless colonial war of conquest against a sovereign neighboring country.

That other great power, China, has never been a democracy with free elections and everything that comes with it. The country is not on that path either – on the contrary, China is becoming more autocratic. And in Iran, Myanmar, Syria, Afghanistan, North Korea, fundamental rights and human rights are trampled on in the most blatant ways every day.

And now we see how in countries that we long considered stable democracies, democratic institutions are being hollowed out from within. Who would have thought that we would have serious doubts about the rule of law in EU member states like Poland and Hungary? Or that the Capitol could be stormed in the United States?

We all watched those terrible images with disbelief and shock.

And yes, the conspiracy thinking, political distrust, and social discontent that erupted on January 6, 2021, have not simply disappeared. And yet…

And yet I am convinced that former American President Ronald Reagan is still right. He spoke of America as a champion of freedom and openness and of his country as 'the shining city on a hill'. As a beacon of hope for the world.

To refresh your memory: Ronald Reagan was a former B-movie actor and Republican who was not taken seriously in left-progressive circles, especially at the beginning of his presidency in the early 1980s. When he left office in 1989, the Cold War was over, nuclear arsenals in East and West were being reduced, and everyone knew the words 'glasnost' and 'perestroika'. A democratic wind was blowing across the world. Thanks to two men: Ronald Reagan and the Russian leader Mikhail Gorbachev.

I have always had a soft spot for Reagan. Especially because of his speeches, in which he managed to make the most difficult things understandable in a homely tone and with indestructible optimism.

Where Reagan spoke, the hope for a better future was never far away. I particularly remember the image of the 'shining city on a hill' from Reagan's farewell address, his farewell speech to the American people.

That was an impressive argument in which he told Americans that every great change in the United States began at the dinner table, with a conversation between children and their parents about what it truly means to be American. Part of that tradition for him was that children should be able to challenge their parents in that conversation.

Typical Reagan – making big things small. And perhaps also typically American, that unabashed and self-aware pride in one's own country.

You often hear it said that the 20th century was the century of America and that the 21st century will be the century of China or Asia. I think differently. I believe that this will again be the century of America. And I also think that we in the Netherlands and Europe would do well to continue investing heavily in Transatlantic cooperation.

Let me explain why I think that. And I will start with the eternal pioneering spirit that is so characteristic of Americans. With the frontier mentality, which still exists in a metaphorical sense, the idea that borders exist to be pushed back. And with that enormous American talent for change – and then again and again until it works.

Everything with the firm conviction that the future will be the superlative of the now: better, freer, more beautiful, higher.

It is no coincidence that America is the country with the most startups in the world, about 70,000 last year. India is in second place, a country with four times as many people, with 13,000 startups.

The drive to move forward is stronger in America than anywhere else. And that way of life is fed by a deeply rooted idea of freedom, which you can only understand if you know American history.

America is a country born out of resistance, out of the slogan 'no taxation without representation', out of a Constitution that does not place the government at the center but 'we the people'. As Reagan said in his farewell address: 'We the people tell the government what to do. It doesn’t tell us.' That urge for freedom is so deeply embedded in American society that you cannot push it over.

And make no mistake, we must not be naïve about the weaknesses of American society. Or about the dangers that threaten American democracy. They exist, and they are real.

But I also see something else. I see that there is a young generation of politicians in the United States who stand up for the rights of everyone and resist the erosion of democracy. That movement is broad and diverse, with moderate and more outspoken individuals.

But one person who stands out to me is Pete Buttigieg, the current Secretary of Transportation.

He is a man who, in his own campaign for the Democratic nomination, brought forth a new and young voice, with equality as a core value in his program. And with that, he is one of the people who, for the umpteenth time in history, show that democracy is inherently dynamic, self-correcting, and self-renewing.

And I see something else, namely that Americans, after the Russian invasion of Ukraine, have taken the lead again without hesitation in defending democracy, sovereignty, and freedom. Far from their own home. For the umpteenth time since World War I, butter for the fish.

Just a few weeks ago, an impressive shipment of military equipment arrived in the port of Vlissingen, for the defense of NATO's eastern border. When you see those images of hundreds of tanks and other rolling stock – 1,300 units in total – you realize how crucial Transatlantic cooperation is for our security.

No European country comes even close to this. And so – I will just say it – President Trump was right when he told Europe: you need to carry your own weight much more and spend 2 percent of your national income on defense, as agreed. That is now happening quickly, also in our country, and that is desperately needed.

And still, there is no alternative to Transatlantic cooperation, with a strong America in a strong NATO – and a strong and united Europe, that is not a playing field on the world stage, but a player. That is what we have learned this year.

And that asks something of us. Namely, that we are willing to bear the financial consequences, both in the short and long term.

Democracy is – literally – not free. Another lesson we have learned at a rapid pace this year.

We see this reflected in the national budget, with substantially more money for defense and already this year an amount of 2.5 billion euros for support to Ukraine. And we feel the effects of the war at home, in our own wallets. Gas is expensive, electricity is expensive, groceries are expensive.

The bottom line is: the Netherlands is a wealthy country and we can do a lot to alleviate financial uncertainty for people. There is a limit to that, however, because no one can predict how the war will develop and what the financial consequences will be.

We will have to deal with that uncertainty for the time being. Even if the war lasts longer, or even much longer than we currently hope, we must be willing to bear the consequences.

In peacetime, it is easy to pay lip service to democratic ideals. But when democracy is under attack, it comes down to it. It raises the question: how much are our freedom, our rule of law, and our democracy actually worth to us?

Putin counted on a divided Europe and a weak NATO. Instead, he now sees a massive bloc of countries standing firm for strong democratic values. Countries that know from experience that democracy is more than just a political system.

Democracy and freedom resonate in the economy, in culture, in the social structure of a country. Because democracy gives people the space to bring out the best in themselves – and that leads to creativity, innovation, entrepreneurship. There is therefore a direct link between a strong democratic rule of law and a prosperous and attractive country.

The historian Niall Ferguson published his groundbreaking book

Civilization. The West and the Rest in 2011. In it, he examines how it is possible that after 1500, a few relatively small countries in the most western point of Western Europe, and later the United States, could become so dominant in a short time and remain so for centuries.

His analysis is that 6 'killer applications,' as he calls them, have been decisive in this. 6 concepts that he believes were unique to the West.

He mentions, among other things, the emergence of competition as a driving force for improvement. He also mentions the importance that the West began to attach to knowledge and science and the development towards a system of rule of law, towards the modern state of law. We in the Netherlands naturally think of Hugo Grotius as the founder of international law of war and maritime law, and thus of international law as we know it today.

Inter-competition, knowledge, and rule of law historically make for a better country to live in. And they are still important pillars of the liberal democracy in which we live.

On the website freedomhouse.org, you will find a map that clearly shows the connection between freedom and rule of law on one side, and prosperity and well-being on the other side. The Netherlands belongs to a very select group of countries that scores close to 100 percent freedom. Almost 100 percent freedom – let that sink in.

And that explains to me why we always score so high on lists that measure other things, such as happiness, health, quality of life, innovation power, or average income.

If you could be born at a self-chosen time and place in world history, then the Netherlands in the 21st century is not a bad choice.

So there is something to defend in our beautiful country. And yes, there is much to improve.

Not everything is going well in the Netherlands either. In the Netherlands, the 'fear of falling,' that is, uncertainty about the future, also leads to dissatisfaction, protest, and polarization.

And I can shout very loudly that our country does not get better from polarization, that no one benefits individually from it, but ultimately there is only one thing that really helps. People who stand up to participate. People with new and fresh ideas. People who become active to change and improve things.

Recently, a woman said to me: my daughter thinks it is high time for you to step down. I can always get a bit grumpy about that, because fine of course, but what are you going to do about it? If you really think that, then take action, make use of your democratic rights, become politically active, and send me packing. That is possible in the Netherlands!

And that is also my call to you and to all young people in all educational institutions in the Netherlands. Not necessarily to send me away, of course, although that is fine.

No, what I mean is: stand up and engage. Read newspapers, follow the news, and find something. And if you then think that things need to be different and better, then also become a member of a political party.

Ukrainians, Iranians, and other peoples have to fight for freedom and democracy.

You, I, we in the Netherlands have inherited it, and that creates obligations. I understand that you want to take action on issues you are passionate about, such as climate, or student financing, or even your pension.

But politics ultimately never revolves around one issue. In politics, it is always about weighing different interests and about money that we can only spend once. So you have to make compromises. Especially in the Netherlands, the land of coalitions. And that compromise is not ugly but rather beautiful, because it brings together 2 essential characteristics of democracy: freedom and reasonableness.

That does not necessarily make the political craft easier, but from my own experience, I can say: there is little more satisfying and nothing more honorable. Democracy is a human endeavor, and ensuring that democracy continues to work requires that the best people are willing to commit to it.

Think about that.

Thank you.