Speech by Prime Minister Mark Rutte to the Atlantic Commission

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

2 October 2019 · Speech to the Atlantic Commission

Context
Rutte addressed the Atlantic Commission on October 2, 2019, delivering a speech on NATO's 70th anniversary and the importance of transatlantic security cooperation.
Main themes
NATO's continued relevance, transatlantic cooperation, European security, Dutch foreign policy, hybrid threats, defense investment, Russia's assertiveness, multilateralism and international law, public support for NATO, NATO-EU relationship
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,595
69th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 62%61%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

148 sentences in 48 paragraphs

"As long as international law remains dependent on the whims of individual states, as long as there is no higher legal system or international morality to which all states bow, we cannot build international politics on the quicksand of idealistic hope. We must face the hard truth; above all, we must ensure that we become economically and militarily strong enough to defend our freedom. We should take to heart the – freely translated – statement of Hilaire Belloc:

'Fighting is very wrong, said Johnny Blood. Fighting is good, said Rough Peter and killed him.'

Ladies and gentlemen, end quote.

For you may have already understood: these are not my words, but those of Dirk Stikker, one of the founding fathers of the VVD, who, as Minister of Foreign Affairs in 1949, was closely involved in the establishment of NATO and later became the 3rd Secretary-General of the alliance. The quote comes from his memoirs, published in 1966, in which Stikker talks extensively about the early years of NATO. I wasn't even born when that book was published, so this is really old history.

The birth certificates of NATO, of course, lie in the Cold War, which dominated international politics for 40 years. Based on the Truman Doctrine, NATO had to come into being after the war to contain the communist threat from Russia and the countries of the Warsaw Pact for Western Europe. And it was also inevitable that the Netherlands said goodbye to its pre-war neutrality policy after 1945.

Looking back, we did that with conviction, especially within NATO. Because in those 70 years, a Dutchman led this important alliance for more than 2 decades. First Stikker, then Luns, and later De Hoop Scheffer. That says something.

You all know the history. After the fall of the wall, the world was able to live for a few years in the illusion that the old security structures had become less important forever. Even in 1999, at the 50th anniversary, there was a plea within NATO for close cooperation with Russia – I am not making this up.

That thought is far behind us. Today we are dealing with an assertive Russia at the eastern external border of the European Union. A Russia that is slowly but surely trying to expand its sphere of influence, with both political and military means, also in this direction. Since the events in Crimea in 2014, it has become clear that peace and security do not come from the East.

Also at the southern borders of our continent, Fukuyama's end of history has become very distant. With the civil war in Syria, the unrest in North Africa, and the potential threat of Iran's nuclear program. And due to the position of countries like China, new questions arise, for example in the field of cybersecurity, to which NATO must also formulate a careful response. A response in which security, economy, and the importance of international dialogue are well balanced.

In short, a different perspective and a different playing field than 70 years or 20 years ago. And yet the words of Stikker have lost none of their meaning after all these years. As long as the ideal world does not exist, we must be realistic. We must be willing to invest in our security, thus in the transatlantic bond and thus in the relationship with the United States.

You undoubtedly heard the King say it in the Throne Speech: transatlantic cooperation is and remains a cornerstone of our foreign policy. I would like to make a few remarks about that today before we engage in conversation. To begin with, NATO still enjoys remarkably strong public support, both in our country and in the U.S.

For the Netherlands, I base this on research that your own Atlantic Commission presented this spring. Almost three-quarters of all Dutch people find NATO membership important for our security. An American scientific study, also from this spring, shows that more than 8 out of 10 Americans support NATO membership. During the Cold War, that public support was taken for granted, as the communist enemy had a clear face and the threat of nuclear war seemed very real for decades.

In today's multipolar world, the threat is much more hybrid. Stikker had really never heard of digital hacks, hypersonic missiles, or jihadist terrorism.

In our time, danger comes from many sides, it changes in character and location, and in this digital age, it is not always easy to recognize or grasp. And that is precisely why it is so important to maintain that support.

That support is closely related to the fact that we need NATO. People seem to realize that. There is no alternative. The Netherlands, Europe – we cannot guarantee our own security. The new President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, recently stated in the European Parliament that for her it is a foregone conclusion that the EU's collective security policy is unthinkable without NATO. She said literally:

'We will stay transatlantic and we have to become more European.'

And I endorse that.

Because NATO is indispensable for the security of Europe and for the protection of everything that has been built since 1945. But in the cooperation between the EU and NATO, Europe can and must do more. A concrete example – those of you in the know will recognize it – is the improvement of military mobility in Europe. In crisis situations, it is crucial that troops, European and American, can move quickly through Europe. Another example is the mutual cooperation and pooling of forces in the military field, as has been taking shape for years between the Netherlands and Germany and the Netherlands and Belgium. With the hybrid threats of today, mutual coordination, division of tasks, and pooling of forces are becoming increasingly urgent. In short, even without a European army, Europe can and must do more to ensure its own security, in closer cooperation with NATO.

And yes, security comes with a price tag. Those who are members of a club must pay dues. We may not like it, but the time when Europe could shelter under the American security umbrella for a minimal amount is over. That movement had already begun under the previous American president, and the current one makes no secret of the fact that the disproportionate cost distribution within NATO is a thorn in his side. I can honestly only have a lot of understanding for that.

The fact is that soon, after Brexit, about one-fifth of NATO's total military spending will be borne by the remaining EU members. No more than that.

That is not sustainable in the long term. You undoubtedly know that in 2014 in Wales, we agreed that all countries would work towards a defense budget of 2 percent of national income by 2024. With the coalition agreement and the latest spring memorandum, we have added billions to the defense budget. But to be honest, we will not reach 2 percent by 2024.

But, ladies and gentlemen, let us also keep in mind that the transatlantic bond encompasses so much more than just the military alliance. Military strength has never been an end in itself, but always a means. The establishment of NATO was not an isolated event after the war.

In the same period, the Marshall Plan laid the foundation for the economic reconstruction of our shattered and demoralized continent and simultaneously for European cooperation. And these were also the years in which, under American leadership, the UN, the World Bank, and the IMF were established, because the world had learned from past mistakes. In other words: an important goal after the war was a peaceful, prosperous, and stable Europe, closely connected to the U.S.

That was and is a mutual interest. Because when Europe does well, it is good for the U.S. and vice versa. And a stable Europe between Russia, the Middle East, and Africa is a strategic interest for the U.S. And that is precisely the point I try to make in my conversations with President Trump and on stages in the U.S. time and again: transatlantic cooperation is a domestic interest – also for America.

To begin with, because of the values we share: democracy, the rule of law, freedom of expression. 75 years ago, our country was liberated, and American soldiers played a significant role in that. We remain grateful for that, and anyone who has ever visited the military cemetery in Margraten knows what that gratitude looks like.

We have already heard it a few times in recent weeks, and I predict that it will come up even more often in this commemorative year: 75 years of freedom, democracy, and the rule of law are not a given. For a long time, we in the West implicitly assumed that these values were so logical that it was inevitable that the rest of the world would eventually adopt them. A matter of economic development, the formation of a middle class, and political awareness – we thought.

Now we know that this thought was quite naive, and that countries like China and Russia really look at the world through a different rule of law lens. Regarding democracy, human rights, but also intellectual property. This means that after 75 years of liberation and 70 years of NATO, there is still reason to defend those shared core values, which are the thick ice layer beneath our way of life. That is also what transatlantic cooperation is about.

And there are, of course, the shared economic interests. Roughly 1/10 of the world's population lives in the United States and the countries of the EU. But together we account for nearly half of the world's GDP. That is enormous. And the mutual transatlantic trade and investments are also significant. For example, Americans invest three times as much in the EU as in all of Asia. And looking ahead: by 2050, China and India are expected to be the 1st and 2nd economies in the world, with over 3 billion inhabitants. So what could be more logical than that the U.S. and Europe, with an estimated combined population of still less than 1 billion, continue to hold on to each other and work together? A rhetorical question, you understand. That is also what transatlantic cooperation is about.

And it is about something else: the multilateral world order. Let me be very clear.

The importance of multilateral international cooperation, as it has grown since 1945, cannot be overstated. Certainly not by a medium-sized country like the Netherlands, or as some say: a great power in pocket size. I have little patience for grandiose idealism and airy-fairy notions, but I do care about hard interests, and the Netherlands truly benefits from a multilateral system in which not the law of the strongest but the strength of the law prevails. Hugo Grotius knew that in the 17th century.

The UN is, of course, the flagship of the system. NATO and the EU are important pillars.

And the World Trade Organization is one of those structural, regulatory bodies with an important role in the better functioning of world trade. However you look at it, through international rules, mutual agreements, and sanction mechanisms, the world has become incredibly better since 1945. With more prosperity for more people, less poverty, fewer wars and violence, and more rule of law.

And no, the system is not perfect, and no, the world is still not a Garden of Eden, but I dare to assert that the post-war multilateral world order is a success from which many people and countries have benefited. And that certainly applies to an open and internationally oriented country like ours, which benefits from international stability.

That comes with responsibility, as the Netherlands continually takes within NATO and other international bodies. Also financial responsibility. Not because the Americans ask us to, but because it is in our own interest. And that system is under pressure. It took shape in a time when the world could still be simply divided into communist versus democratic and poor versus rich.

That world of yesterday no longer exists, and that constrains the way the system works. For example, look at the decision-making in the UN, especially the Security Council, which still operates as if the world has not changed since 1945. Or look at the World Trade Organization, where a country like China still has the status of a developing country, with all the financial benefits that come with it. Or look at the Human Rights Council, where the condemnation of Israel is a major agenda item, while serious human rights violators like Syria, Eritrea, or North Korea often go unpunished.

The criticism of this from President Trump – but not only from him – is strong, that is true.

But at its core, much of that criticism is also justified. And I believe that we should see President Trump's actions as an opportunity to push forward and improve and modernize the international system. Not by canceling memberships and treaties, not by throwing away old shoes before we have new ones, but by working together to advocate for modernization and improvement of the system. That is also my ongoing appeal to the United States, arguing that it is also in their interest. Reasoned from our shared values and our shared economic interests, I say: that is also what transatlantic cooperation is about.

The eminent American historian Robert Kagan uses a beautiful metaphor for this in a recent book.

The jungle grows back."

, that book is called. In short, Kagan's argument is that the natural state of international relations has historically resembled a jungle. Chaos, then. Think of the background to World War I, with the patchwork of alliances and the nationalist diplomacy of those days, which inevitably led to a devastating world war.

Or rather two, if we extend the story to after the Treaty of Versailles. After World War II, America took the lead out of idealism and well-understood self-interest to civilize that jungle, says Kagan. As a result, peace, freedom, and prosperity have been achieved for more people than ever before. The danger that Kagan now sees is that the multilateral world order is under such pressure that the jungle is growing back, and at a rapid pace.

It seems to me that it is an essential transatlantic interest to ensure that this does not happen, but that we work together to strengthen a multilateral world order that can last for a while. For ourselves and for the collective.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In the preface to his memoirs, Stikker wrote that – and I quote:

‘(…) my experiences have led me to believe not only in the desirability but also in the essential existence of an Atlantic community – a community that truly encompasses Western and Southern Europe and North America in its current form. I belong to those who believe that the Atlantic Ocean is a main road that connects us, not a barrier that separates us.’

End quote, from 1966, then.

It is written in the language of the time and against the backdrop of the bipolar relations of that era. Today, the world looks different, and NATO looks very different as well. But at its core, one thing has not changed, and that is that we need each other desperately. We feel that even more so 75 years after liberation and 30 years after the fall of the wall. And it is crucial that we continue to realize this and act accordingly.

Thank you.