Address by the Prime Minister via video conferencing at the National Conference on Tourism, Culture, and Sports

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

20 January 2017 · National Conference on Tourism, Culture, and Sports

Context
Modi addressed a national conference on tourism, culture, and sports via video conferencing from Kutch on January 20, 2017, urging inter-ministerial collaboration.
Main themes
Tourism development, sports promotion, inter-departmental coordination, youth demographic dividend, cultural exchange, government silos, state-centre collaboration, human resource development, regional diversity of India
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,242
92nd percentile
Sentences
290
95th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.79
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 50%49%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

290 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Many of you may be here for the first time on the land of Kutch, and perhaps you have come to Kutch, but who would go so far into the desert near the border of Pakistan? But today you have the opportunity to go there as well. For those who have come from the valleys of the Himalayas, the desert will be a different experience. For those who have spent their lives amidst the lush greenery of the North East, the experience of the desert is something else, and I am confident that this environment will have a positive impact on your contemplation camp.

It is very necessary in the government that we understand our work by sitting together and understanding the creation of our work. How the world is changing, where we stand in that changing world, where we want to reach, and how far we can reach. We should continuously evaluate these matters. Unfortunately, there is a tendency in governments to work in silos. Sometimes there are even silos within a single department, where there is concern that what is happening at one table should not be known to another table.

One department does not coordinate with another department, and as a result, when one department thinks of a program, the other department thinks completely opposite. Sometimes it is surprising that within the court, two departments of the government fight against each other by hiring lawyers. Now this situation is not a healthy one; there should be a change, and the way to bring about that change is that we should sit together and think in detail about what our role will be under a broad vision, what the role of our department will be, and what results we can bring. Some departments, despite being separate, are like-minded. They have some coordination with each other.

Here, mainly the people from four ministries have gathered. In a way, there is some connection among all of them, and therefore it would be good for us to sit together and share our experiences. They are experts; we should listen to them. We should try to understand how we have found solutions to our difficulties, what experiments we have conducted. If during these three days, apart from the formal sessions, you spend time talking openly with each other, during meals, while coming and going, and in tent life, then perhaps many of you will have the opportunity to experience this for the first time. It may feel hot right now, but as evening falls, it gets much cooler, so amidst these difficulties, there is a joy in living together. So apart from the official sessions, share the experiences of your respective states with your colleagues, and ask about other states. This will be a great treasure that we can carry forward in our policies and our journey of development.

There are some tasks that we need to do beyond the department, beyond the central and state governments. Today, the nature of the work of the four departments gathered here is such that the decisions made by people sitting in Kashmir or Kanyakumari will have a central thought. Depending on resources, there may be more or less quantity, that is possible. Now, which government in India would not want our youth to excel in the world of sports? The implication is that all states in India want this. If all states want this, can they not sit together and think about this demographic dividend we have?

Today, we confidently say to the world that we have 800 million youth under the age of 35. India is young. Sixty-five percent of the population is under the age of 35. Is it not our responsibility, whether at the central or state level, to think about what a country with such youthful wealth can give to the country and the world? How can we channelize the powers of our youth? What policies should our governments create, what kind of road maps should we develop so that the maximum use of our youthful strength can benefit the country and the world? If we start thinking about these issues seriously now, even though we should have done so in the last century, we may still be able to lead things towards very positive outcomes. What will our human resource development look like? What will be the identity of our youth power in front of the world? In what form do we want to shape our youth power, in what form do we want to advance it? Whenever there is an international sports competition, there is joy when an award is received. If it is not received, it feels like we have to think again for the next time.

We have all seen this during our student days. Our nature is such that when exams come, we think that we will start studying only when the school or college opens next year. Gradually, the first semester goes by. During vacations, we then decide that this time as soon as the school opens, I will start studying. Then gradually the exams come, and we think that now we have to study late into the night. When sleep comes at night, we think we will wake up early in the morning to study. We even tell our mothers to wake us up early because we have to study. We keep changing our own timetable and adjusting ourselves. We keep finding ways. Is it not necessary that if we create an institutional arrangement for sports competitions, our players continuously get opportunities to participate in competitions? Whether it is at the tehsil level, district level, or between schools and colleges, until there are continuous sports competitions, players do not get prepared. Just building infrastructure alone will not make families aware; there may be one or two players who live their lives and excel, but unless we create an environment in the country, we do not get good people. This has been somewhat established in cricket. In every street and neighborhood, people play cricket, and small games keep happening. Players emerge from that, and a very large mechanism has been established, but our country has many skills beyond cricket, capable people, and along with physical fitness, talent in the international sports world is equally important. One has to prepare oneself within those rules and regulations. The more we think about these matters and can make decisions, the more we will start seeing results.

In the world, government programs for sports are few. It is connected to the general public, and corporate houses are associated with it. Each state can identify itself with each game and take advantage of it. Have we ever mapped within our state that there is one district that plays football well? There is one district that excels in volleyball. There is one district that perhaps excels in archery. Until we do the potential mapping at the district level, we will continue to have people from every corner of India playing every type of sport, but we may not be able to achieve anything. Therefore, it is necessary that we bring about change.

How will our youth power be useful in nation-building? Have we ever thought in that direction? Good debate, good leadership qualities, and their efforts to understand the problems of villages—how can our youth power be utilized? Today, there is a digital movement in the country. The youth society has a nature of capturing these things very quickly. With all the systems, organizations, and government mechanisms connected to our youth, can we engage them in such work? You must have seen the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan. Many youth organizations in several states and cities have given so much strength and prestige to the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan through their initiatives, providing a great opportunity to channelize and mobilize their creativity.

You must have seen that recently many railway stations have been beautified by local artists and youth. The railway stations of the past and today, where people have come together. The railways did not spend anything. They came with their colors and talents and gave their railway station the identity of their village, so when passengers come, they see the entire railway station. How can we engage our youth power in creative works? How can we utilize their capabilities? We should continuously think in that direction and create new plans for it.

We have NSS, NCC, and all these organizations. Even then, why is our youth lagging behind in adventurous activities? Why should the desire for a courageous life not awaken in them? Why should they not spend some of their time, their vacation time, there? Sometimes we see that in our country, there is a mindset that only white-collar jobs are good, and everything else is worthless. When our children go abroad, they do not hesitate to work in hotels on Saturdays and Sundays because they see the culture there. The youth of India should also have respect for labor; doing manual work should not be seen as bad. It is not bad to drink water with your own hands. How do we develop this culture and tradition? Can these small organizations that are working bring about this change? There is a need to make efforts in that direction. Our cultural heritage is invaluable. We can have an impact on the world; we have such a rich cultural heritage. But we have not been able to present it to the world in the way we should because we have lost confidence within ourselves. What kind of country can it be that does not take pride in its ancestors, its old traditions, its culture, and its heritage? If we do not take pride in it, what will we show the world? The feeling of pride in what we have should be a part of our education, a part of our youth movement, and we should continuously strive to present our cultural heritage to the world as a unique legacy. If we think that this is the work of only a few art troupes, it will not work. It should be a part of society. If we move forward with this as a part of society, we will definitely see a different outcome, and we should make efforts in that direction.

If countries around the world have developed tourism, they have had to create arrangements for artificial recreation where there are entertainment facilities, where people can come from outside, stay, and use technology. We are the ones who have thousands of years of old things available, and there is a large segment of the world that is interested in this. But this is only possible when we present our cultural heritage to the world with great pride. Just as we talk about the Taj Mahal with pride, we should talk about our various forms of music, our instruments, our traditions of instruments, and our musical ragas and compositions with equal pride; they are wonders for the world. In other words, how do we present our heritages, our cuisine? Can anyone imagine how many types of cuisine there are in India? We, who were born in India, if we start eating a new dish from a new state every day, perhaps our lifetime would not be enough. There is so much diversity. We have introduced the world to these diversities. Our country is not such that there is a Pizza Hut in one corner and another identical Pizza Hut 2000 kilometers away. The process of making pizza in one corner is the same as in another corner. The ingredients there will be the same as here. Here, if we start in the south, we begin with rice, and as we go up, rice ends, and we switch to wheat. These diversities have the power to be presented to the world. But we have not paid attention to what we have. Why should there not be an identity for every state?

Until we create an identity for a state, perhaps there are some areas within the state that can be identified. Now, when you go to Himachal, if you go towards Solan, there are boards that say—towards Solan, this is the Mushroom City. My experience when I worked in Himachal was that they made it popular as a Mushroom City. If you go to Surat, the people of Surat have made it popular as the Silk City. We do not consciously make special branding of our heritages, our areas, and our cities. You people are sitting here to discuss; perhaps many issues will emerge from this.

Today, tourism is a rapidly growing commercial sector in the world. It is growing at the fastest pace. The bulk of the world's middle class and upper middle class is increasing. The upper middle class and middle class are also ready to spend their money abroad. Can we think of a country like India as our target group for world tourism? What does the world want? What is there in our country, in which areas? Have we ever analyzed the psychology of tourists from 50 countries around the world? If a tourist from Europe comes, what are the things he likes to see? What are the things that are present in this corner of India that we should attract European tourists with? We have neither mapped our potential in India nor have we seen what tourists from around the world like. Every class of the world has its own choice, and until they see those kinds of things, they will not be satisfied. Bird watchers, perhaps the people who spend the most money in the world are bird watchers. They go wherever they go, carrying their cameras, and spend a month just focusing on one bird. They are people who spend a lot of money. Do we have mapping for this?

If you want to see such birds, go to this state, go to this area, go in this season. Do the clubs for bird watchers in the world know that there are places for bird watchers in this corner of India? Have we linked both? And if it is found out that there are four hundred places in India that can be a good destination for bird watchers, what infrastructure do bird watchers need? What kind of facilities do they require? Are we making efforts in the direction of targeted development? If we work towards targeted development, we can develop a system that yields more outcomes with less expenditure.

You may have noticed that those who have just arrived might not have seen it; but those who came yesterday or arrived this morning would have seen how a large tourist destination can be created in this desert. The reason for holding this workshop in the Kutch desert is also to see how, if we make an effort, we can bring our things to the people. The people living in Kutch, perhaps they did not know that they have such a vast white desert. When the Kutch Rann Utsav started, it became a huge event with a business turnover of nearly 5,500 crore rupees in a single district. Handicrafts are sold. You can see how establishing a system can attract tourists from around the world. Today, we are witnessing it ourselves.

We have seen that we have tourist destinations, but there is no arrangement for signages in the appropriate languages. If more Russian tourists come to Goa, the traders in Goa want to learn the Russian language, and you may have seen that the small traders in Goa learn to speak broken Russian. Why? Because the maximum number of Russian tourists started coming, and they felt it was necessary for them. But what do we try? If more European tourists come to Kullu-Manali, are there any signages in the European languages there? We have not done this carefully. And the result is that we are unable to create a tourist-friendly environment. Consequently, we do not receive the benefits we should.

You people are sitting in Kutch, and from where you are, Dholavira is about two hundred to two hundred and fifty kilometers away; this is a five-thousand-year-old city structure from the Mohenjo-Daro period. If you have planned a visit there, you will see that even five thousand years ago, there were signages in that city indicating places to go, that this way are the places, after 500 meters that place is there, if you go left, this is it; all these signages were there. This means that in that era, five thousand years ago, there must have been a lot of movement of people coming and going to Dholavira, which is why the need for signages arose. Dholavira is considered the first system of signages in the world. Have we ever thought that there could be some common elements in the signages of our tourist destinations? So that those who come from outside feel that yes, this is written, it means this. Here I will find this.

To develop our tourism scientifically, I gave this small example so that we realize that to develop tourism, even our literature should be in the right language. If more English-speaking people come to my tourist destination, but all my literature there is in Hindi or my local language, then even after spending, I am unable to market it. We want to develop websites for tourist destinations, but most of our websites are in our own language, while if we want to capture a global market, do we create our websites in their language? And I do not believe that it requires much expenditure.

Let us decide that yes, we want to promote tourism, and you will see it will happen. Sometimes, there is a major concern in tourism about why people do not come? They say there is no infrastructure. Why is there no infrastructure? Because people do not come. This is a dilemma that you have to muster the courage to overcome.

There are people from the HRD Ministry sitting there. Can state governments decide this? Let’s say, in your state, decide that students of this class should go for tourism once a year to different places in their own village. When they reach this age, they will go to the tehsil, when they reach this standard, they will go to the district. When they go to that standard, they will go to the state. If we set up such work for them, they will gradually learn what is there in their village, what is there in the tehsil, what is there in the district? By the time they reach tenth grade, they will know everything. We do not do this; here, a fifth-grade student may not have seen Udaipur, but if the teacher has not seen Udaipur, the teacher will take them to Udaipur. What have they seen in their village?

We need coordination between the HRD Ministry and our Tourism Ministry. Let’s say we decide that there are ten places in our state that need to be developed as tourist destinations. Let’s all decide together. You know that at those ten places, there are no hotels, no restaurants, no food arrangements, but the destination is good. Have you ever thought that you will first mobilize the resources of your state? Decide that all our universities should go somewhere as tourists for five years, so they must go to these ten destinations that the state has decided, and they must stay for two nights. That expense will be for tourism, but this will be the type of investment.

Let’s say every day ten buses of college students come; the people of that village can decide that tourists are coming; let’s set up a shop to sell chickpeas and puffed rice, let’s set up a shop to make fritters, let’s bring water because people need water. Gradually, it will develop. But we should not send our tourists first to develop our own destinations. If every state in India decides on five destinations, I am not asking for more; five destinations, and with the intention of creating an international-level destination, for the first two or three years, whether anyone comes or not, let the students of their own state start going. There will begin to be a change there, and tourists will start coming.

In the Kutch desert where we are sitting, initially, only people from Gujarat came; more and more people from Mumbai started coming, but today online booking has started a year in advance. We need to make such efforts first, and then the necessary infrastructure for tourist destinations will be established, and then we should think about human resources. Unfortunately, at our tourist destinations or religious places where tourists go, there are no courses for skill development or human resource development for guides. Why shouldn’t the youth working as guides in that city be trained? Why shouldn’t there be competition among them? Why shouldn’t their costumes be prepared? Guides should have uniforms, and why shouldn’t they have identity cards? Until we bring professionalism, we cannot develop the tourism sector.

India needs to focus on developing two types of tourism; one is traditional tourism; every son wants to take his parents for a Ganga bath at some point; every son wants to take his parents on a Char Dham Yatra at some point; every son wants to take his parents to the place of Lord Shiva, to the place of Lord Ganesha; this is natural. This traditional tourism will happen, whether there is an arrangement or not, whether there are difficulties or not.

This is also a huge market of 1.25 billion countrymen. Have we ever addressed them? And our 1.25 billion countrymen who want to travel easily, if we prepare infrastructure scientifically, it can also become an attraction for global tourists.

The second type of tourists will come from abroad, who want to see our other things. They will be interested in beach tourism, adventure tourism, sports tourism, they may want to go to the snowy places of the Himalayas, they may want to see the Taj Mahal or Qutub Minar, so these are a different category. Until we think about what arrangements we can make for our tourists, we cannot strengthen tourism.

You all are sitting there. There may be a discussion about a program there, "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat." The officials of the HRD Ministry are also sitting there. "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat," for a country like India to move forward, we need to put in a lot of effort. What happened is that we told people that it is either this or that. In such a large country, it does not work to say either this or that. If a boy in our country knows the French language, we proudly say look, this is our neighbor, their son knows French too; if our child knows Spanish, we say look, our child knows Spanish, but we do not create an environment in the country where a child from Haryana should also learn Telugu; a child from Gujarat should also feel like learning Malayalam, and if he knows Malayalam, he should feel proud.

We are not proud of our heritage within the country. A country with more than 100 languages and over 1,700 dialects is so rich! Have we ever thought about connecting our youth with this heritage? Sometimes we know what is in some other country, but we are ignorant about what is in our own country or our own state. India is such a vast country; we should familiarize our upcoming generation with India, connect them well, and for this, on the occasion of Sardar Patel Jayanti, the program "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat" has been initiated. Initially, two states sign an MoU with each other, and the effort is to see how two states can develop their relations. We can do this with many states and cities around the world, but we do not do it within our own country. For example, Haryana has done it with Telangana. Why shouldn’t the youth of Haryana go to Telangana as tourists for a year? Why shouldn’t the youth of Telangana go to Haryana as tourists for a year? Why shouldn’t there be sports programs of traditional sports from Haryana and traditional sports from Telangana in each other’s states? Why shouldn’t there be a Telugu film festival in Haryana? Why shouldn’t there be a film festival of Haryana in Telugu? Why shouldn’t there be a Telugu drama festival in Haryana? Why shouldn’t there be a drama festival of Haryana in Telangana? Naturally, children from Haryana can learn 100 Telugu sentences in a year, conversational sentences. Children from Telangana can learn 100 sentences in Haryanvi or Hindi.

You see, without trying, in every tenth or eighth position, someone must be able to speak the language of some state. If someone comes, they will feel, oh, someone from Tamil Nadu has come, let’s start with "Vanakkam." It starts immediately. Therefore, my request is that states should come forward for the "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat" program. The HRD Ministry, Youth Services and Cultural Department, Culture Department, and Tourism Department are departments that can play a significant role as catalytic agents.

You can consider a quiz competition; these days our Ministry of External Affairs has started a quiz competition for the Indian community spread across the world. The children of those who are in the second or third generation abroad know that their ancestors are from India, but they do not know what India is. So, they have started an online quiz competition. Last year, five thousand children from different countries who are of Indian origin but were not born here; nor have they ever seen India, participated in this competition, trying to gain knowledge about India, and a program to award them was also very successful on October 2nd.

Can there be an online quiz competition for different states of our country? If Gujarat has signed an MoU with Chhattisgarh for "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat," then the children of Chhattisgarh can answer five thousand questions about Gujarat in the quiz competition, and the children of Gujarat can answer five thousand questions about Chhattisgarh, how many districts there are, how many communities there are, what dialects there are, what food there is, what attire there is, where certain items are located. You see how much integration will happen naturally. And if that child participates in quiz competitions of ten such states gradually, how much knowledge will he have about India.

I want all states to create a quiz bank; two thousand, five thousand, seven thousand questions and answers, and if possible, photographs related to the topics; create an online platform and have an MoU with the state, and there should be a speech competition among the children of that state.

These days we have told the police forces that on August 15th and January 26th, police forces from one state should go to another state. The people of that state will have a parade, and there will also be a contingent from another state. These are things that bring us closer to each other. These are simple tasks, and we are emphasizing them. We should make efforts to make the "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat" program successful, and India is filled with so many diversities; even if we take on the responsibility of encompassing our own country, one lifetime may not be enough for such a vast country; it is a country filled with so many diversities; and knowing every new thing will bring joy.

As I mentioned in "Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat," let’s say Haryana will be with Telangana. Can every school in Haryana have five Telugu songs memorized? Can the people of Telangana sing five songs from Haryana? And this will be enjoyable; they will find joy in it, and it will not require any extra effort. Naturally, we should recognize and understand the diversities of our country, and this will greatly strengthen tourism as well.

Our youth power has a work that fills us with consciousness. There is an opportunity to connect India and take it to new heights. No matter how small a thing may be, we can see how it can bring about a big change. So, you are here to reflect and contemplate for three days, having come from so far; I hope that especially those who are part of the council will definitely sit down, share their experiences with all the states, share their vision, and when you go to the desert in the evening; I have a deep attachment to this land. I want to give you a piece of advice, when you go to the desert this evening, as far in as you can go, allow the security forces to take you there, but if possible, leave your companions behind and go 25 or 50 steps away, and stand there alone for ten minutes. Look at that vastness, look at that blue sky, look at that white sheet; perhaps such an experience in life is very rare, and yes, if you keep chatting with friends, then that feeling will not be there. For 15 or 20 minutes, everyone should go 20 or 25 steps away and stand alone; you will definitely have a new experience, and you will surely share that experience with everyone. This place is such that if you wanted to come here ten years ago, it would take three to four hours in the desert, but today you might have reached here in 50 or 60 minutes.

You have seen how much change comes after an earthquake. And this is the last village of Hindustan where you are sitting. There is no population beyond this. At this last point of the last village, you are contemplating the future of India. You are reflecting on promoting tourism in India. You will rise with some resolution to inspire India's youth power.

I am confident that your deliberations will play a significant positive role in policy-making in the coming days. I wish you all the best on this occasion. I will be closely observing everything you discuss over the next two to three days, as this is an area of my interest.

And there is a lot of potential in this area; we need to take it forward. So, I want to benefit fully from the hard work you will be doing, so that I can gain as much as possible; please ensure that you do such work. You do work that benefits the country, but my knowledge will also be enhanced through your experience. So, I look forward to it.

Now, I am also waiting to partake in the nectar that will emerge from your discussions over the next three days. I wish you all the very best. I also congratulate Vijay Rupani ji and his entire team for this, because they have so much tourism rush there, so providing tents for a conference like this can be a bit economically challenging for them, but they are doing it, and because of this, people from all over the country have come, so they will also promote your festival. It is possible that in the coming days, more and more people from their side will start coming, so this is an investment for you. So, I also congratulate the Gujarat government and commend them.

Thank you.