Closing speech by Acting President of the Government at 33rd Digital Economy and Telecommunications Meeting

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

4 September 2019 · 33rd Digital Economy and Telecommunications Meeting

Context
Sánchez delivered the closing address at the 33rd Digital Economy and Telecommunications Meeting in Spain on 4 September 2019.
Main themes
Digitalisation and the digital economy, 5G technology, artificial intelligence and robotics, employment and job transformation, social justice and digital inclusion, education and personalised learning, innovation and economic progress, industrial revolution and societal change, smart cities and sustainability, Spanish companies and digital innovation
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,354
88th percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
14.7
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 31%31%
  • Economic 26%26%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

150 sentences in 75 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

No-one now doubts that digitalisation, if we do things right and know how to run them well, will bring about one of the best periods in the history of mankind.

We will be freed from mechanical tasks that we don't want to do, and it will revolutionise, as is already happening, medicine and mobility. It will help create smart and sustainable cities that are better suited to our needs and it will undoubtedly transform our daily lives by making them more comfortable, safer and more efficient.

I am sure that many examples will have been shared over these three days of the event, and there are many examples in Spain already, by both large and small Spanish companies. A 3D printing company from Vitoria is capable of manufacturing ultra-customised medical prosthetics that can save human lives.

Another Spanish company has created smart mattresses that gather information on how people rest, analyses this and advises them on how to improve this rest.

And a wine producer from Ribera del Duero uses big data, artificial intelligence to be precise, to improve the harvests with smart decisions on irrigation, manure, pruning and the optimum time to gather in the harvest.

In short, what I mean by this is that no human activity, not even the most creative - cultural activities, by way of example - music, will be immune from digitalisation and the tremendous potential and opportunities that will open up to each and every sector.

In summary, the future is the present in our time. But allow me to underline something that the Chairman of Santander and the President of AMETIC clearly said, when stressing the importance that this may have for education, exponentially multiplying our capabilities to see the world and to create more progress and prosperity.

Thanks to 5G, as we have precisely seen over recent months due to issues that have nothing to do with the positive potential which it may bring in leaps and bounds, and also to the daily lives of our citizens, students will be able to make virtual visits to the human body, and with augmented reality they will have contextualised information. And thanks also to 5G we are going to achieve absolutely personalised teaching, specific teaching for each pupil, at their pace and with their personal conditions. We often talk about the student/teacher ratio, well, with this type of technology, and specifically with 5G, we are going to be able to transcend this debate, which is important, not only for politics, but for parents now that the school year is starting.

This will clearly have immediate consequences on human development, which will obviously have been addressed at this event, and also on social and economic development. Digitalisation allows us to make progress. And the question, and this was also conveyed by my two predecessors on this stage, is that if we want this progress it must go hand-in-hand with social justice. If we want this progress to be integrated or exclusionary. Because on some occasions, on many occasions, this is the main challenge when we speak and address the digital era in which we live.

Perhaps, for the first time ever, we are aware in advance of the changes that we will face. We have more data, we have more information, we have more experience of previous industrial revolutions and consequently we can glimpse, albeit only superficially, the changes that we will face, some of which we are already dealing with.

We are aware, for example, of robotics and artificial intelligence. I prefer to call this machine-aided intelligence, because we are yet to see whether or not we will be replaced by this. But, at any event, they are going to completely transform our societies.

And this awareness should serve to forewarn us; it is important to anticipate, to plan in many sectors, as the Chairman of Santander said before, even in politics, and not even four years in advance, but 12 years in advance, don't you think? Why don't we have fluid annual budgets each year in Spain, for example, when we talk about innovation or re-industrialisation? Well, this is a debate that we will set in motion when we have a government. Hence, forewarn and channelling these transformations towards the common good.

Employment is obviously one of the most criticised issues, is it not? Quite clearly when we speak about employment and the impact of digitalisation, all our ears prick up. Not just because of our own interest, but also because of the interest of the ones we love, don't you think, and of the interest of the society in which we live? Of course, it is thought that, over the next decade, machines will take over some 20 million manufacturing jobs around the world. Well, I am an economist and on many occasions when I listen and read some OECD reports that state that the impact of digitalisation on certain sectors will mean the loss or replacement of 10% or 30%, we are obviously speaking about very broad margins.

But clearly, we must anticipate and there will be a major impact from robotics and artificial intelligence in terms of replacing many jobs that exist right now, since they are low or low to intermediate skilled jobs. In other words, that is where this will first be felt.

In the past, technological change - as I said before - always went hand-in-hand with global production and also an ensuing improvement in the quality of life of society, to quote the case of the automation of the automotive industry, since it meant cheaper cars, access to more citizens of this particular commodity and the creation of new factories that maintained and created more jobs.

The mechanisation of agriculture and the computerisation of banking led to the creation of jobs in new sectors. And this dynamic of the economy is experiencing a new variation, which we are witness to practically minute by minute.

In the next two generations sectors will still exist in which employment will have a great net impact that will allow us to maintain the social structures in which we live. And that seems key to me.

A clear example - mentioned before by the Chairman of Santander - affects the ecological transition, and what it can contribute to digitalisation, precisely to this ecological transition in which Spain is immersed and of which the Government of Spain is a fervent supporter.

In the National Energy and Climate Plan that we approved during the two short months of the legislature prior to the elections on 28 April, we not only proposed an unprecedented mobilisation of financial resources for this ecological transition, in which the financial sector, which I thank, will clearly be called on to play an active role, but this will also involve the creation of around 300,000 new jobs between 2020 and 2030.

These will be quality jobs with a future because they will be lasting, in competitive sectors with a great future ahead. And when we speak, for example, about territorial cohesion or about depopulation or repopulation, well then digitalisation and the ecological transition go hand-in-hand.

But artificial intelligence and robotics, in almost all labour sectors, also help us think of the near future, in which the power of work will cease to be the foundation for the creation of wealth. That is what the figures are telling us and we have to shape all our public actions around these figures, when talking about taxation, since clearly we are taxed based on our payslip, based on capital but not on the figures. And this is one of the main debates that we will have to open up not only at the level of the OECD, but also at the level of the European Union and at a national level.

In the digital world, intangible assets have a growing importance and it is much easier to replace work, which will potentially lead to the risk of a generational, business and human gap which, in my opinion, is unacceptable, since progress must be inclusive and not exclusionary.

We are not talking now about economic transformations; we are talking about far-reaching social transformations which will clearly have transformations and responses in our public systems. We are already seeing some of these. If you analyse, through the surveys that have been published recently by sociological research centres, but also by public and public-private institutions, what we are seeing is that a large percentage of the population is starting to become afraid, probably due to the lack of information of the consequences of digitalisation and robotics on their productive sectors. And this, of course, will have an economic and social transformation, and a political response that we will also need to take into account.

Why do I say this? Because that is where politics, together with civil society, and when I say civil society I am not only referring to the large corporations, such as Santander, but also to important associations like AMETIC, which is why I am proud to be here, Pedro, and to be able to share my thoughts on this matter with you. And, above all, to convey the commitment of the Government of Spain. We also take this matter very seriously.

In short, politics, together with civil society, I wanted to say to you, must occupy the space that corresponds thereto. Not only in terms of regulation, and it is clear that we will have a problem in terms of regulation which is why what you say, Pedro, is very suggestive. I don't say by legislating because clearly our national sovereignty and representation is parliamentary. But one of the main problems in politics, and in the public authorities, for example, is vocational training, let's quote this case - and you referred to this earlier - and how to update legislation to a large degree, and how to predict the regulations that will prevail on this matter, not in four or five, or even 20 years' time, but next year. That is why, for example, vocational training is important, the steps that have been taken on specialised courses. Because this gives us greater scope to modernise in line with what the private sector demands.

But if we talk about 5G and if we talk about the potential impact this may have on cyber-security, or on the security of…, of course, the problem is that we are still not sure of the exact potential of 5G until it is set in motion. And hence, the dilemma is what to do. Should we throw ourselves into the fray or stand on the side-lines?

Well, I believe that what we have to do, and there you have the State Secretary, and also the Government of Spain, is start to set these pilot projects in motion in the big cities, because we believe that we must not miss the 5G train in our country, with the … that we will clearly have, but also with learning, with learning about what the rollout of this important technological network may represent.

Hence, not only in regulating, but also in facilitating opportunities geared towards growth, which by itself would be very significant as well, and above all, propitiate, advocate and renew something that I believe is very important for all those of us present here, above all for those who head up different institutions, whether public or private, which is the social contract, which is what is being questioned at this time.

Today, if you work, or study rather, then you will have the chance to find a job or set up your own company. And if you work or set up your own company, then you will receive a decent wage with which you will not only be able to develop your professional career, but also clearly help out your loved ones, principally your sons and daughters.

So, I believe that this social contract is what a common project that Spain, or Europe, or any other geographic region in the world, should be based upon; I believe that this is something that we should also bear in mind when addressing the challenges of digitalisation.

If the circumstances change so radically, as I am convinced they will, as has already been seen here, then we must precisely strengthen this social contract. And to achieve that we must do something that was mentioned here, Pedro, and which I agree with, and which I can assure you I will sign up to even more fervently than you: Spain needs a government as soon as possible. And we need a government as soon as possible to guarantee stability, because the challenges we face - digitalisation, the ecological transition, the creation of opportunities, social cohesion - require a government that puts these five years of instability behind it and that addresses the next four years guaranteeing these transformations that our country needs. Some of these are structural and have been addressed here. Others are circumstantial but threaten to become structural. I am referring to the economic slowdown, but also to a political decision of great importance, which is no more and no less than the United Kingdom leaving the European Union, and worse still, potentially without a deal. You are aware that we have approved a contingency plan in recent months that we have precisely drawn up with the private sector and also with the European Commission. Tomorrow we will convene a meeting of the Inter-ministerial Committee to have everything ready in case the United Kingdom, with its new Prime Minister, decides to unilaterally leave the European Union on 31 October without complying with the agreements we have reached, because they have not been ratified by the British Parliament. And this is no small matter, because it will have enormous consequences for our common project of the European Union, and also for the European economy. The Government of Spain is prepared, and that is something that I would like to stress at this event, with your permission Pedro.

We must thus anticipate conflicts, consequently, before they arise, because it is not acceptable, in the 21st Century, with all the history we have behind us, for us to allow that this progress is made at the expense of part of society, and hence we must ensure that no-one is left behind. We must ensure, as I said before, that this development is inclusive.

That is why, and I want to tell you Pedro that I will take this proposal that you have made to me of the architecture of the government seriously, albeit with some modifications, but something similar will come out of it, I want to put a human face on this digital re-industrialisation.

No economic outcome will be satisfactory if it means greater inequality and hence, greater exclusion.

No progress will really be progress if it entails a risk that part of our society is detached from it. Because precisely what happened to us in 2008 is related to this, since we had not propitiated an inclusive, integrating, cohesive economic model. What's more, we now have a second aftershock because this whole economic model of exclusionary development has passed on to the main institutions and governments around the world, to people, institutions and governments around the world who have precisely the social ills and lack of opportunities caused as a result of this economic model.

That is why I believe that, unlike other industrial revolutions, this one needs engineers, but also philosophers; scientists to contribute science to industry and to politics as well, and also humanists, if you will allow me, and on this I wish to praise what Banco de Santander is doing. We need engineers, scientists, philosophers and the government is committed to ensuring that the gender perspective is present in all these disciplines, and we know that we can count on a leading ally in this battle, which is Santander.

Because what is at stake for the first time since the French Revolution, if you will allow me to be somewhat hyperbolic, is our definition as a society.

We must now decide whether we still believe in these principles of the French Revolution, in liberty, equality and fraternity or whether, in contrast, we accept that technology governs us, without any kind of heart or soul.

We must now decide whether the principles and the values that we have always advocated remain valid and are worthy of us fighting for them, in other words, that we unite and form a team and are aware that progress for one means progress for us all.

This historic moment, as I said at the start and as I am sure has been repeated on many occasions in the workshops here, is a great opportunity for mankind to make progress, and consequently for our country as well; I don't see this as a risk, a threat or a challenge, but rather as a tremendous opportunity. But only if we are able to maintain our commitment to co-existence in place, and renew it in accordance with the new circumstances since we have a horizon to progress towards.

Hence, we must never lose sight that well-being, the prosperity of human beings, as a whole and as individuals must be at the heart of this.

And I want, in this regard, to advocate something, which we may sometimes lose sight of, although many of you present here who travel outside of Europe will have seen this particularly harshly, which is the European model of economic development and redistribution of this economic development.

In April, the European Commission, and Pedro mentioned this earlier, published the guidelines for the development of artificial intelligence at the service of mankind, which is safe and transparent, safeguards privacy and avoids discrimination.

I believe that Europe, once again, must set the course for rights and values, as the Chairman of Santander rightly said earlier, since logically the European Commission will have to address this over the next five years.

As well as the challenge of employment, there are many ethical questions on the table at this time that we must find a response to as soon as possible, because for a long time now algorithms decide many of the recommendations we find on the Internet, those that the Chairman of Santander mentioned earlier; it is an algorithm that tells us where we must go, where the petrol station is, in short, all these matters we are well aware of.

Our digital window to the world is conditioned by our own historical search data, which, instead of broadening our vision of reality, as was thought would happen at the dawn of the Internet, converts it into something far narrower.

Algorithms tell us what music we like, and hence which recommendations to make to us about books, genres and hotels.

But it is also true that we select the news we should read coldly and scientifically, and the web sites we want to consult if we are interested in a subject, and hence run the risk of creating certain bubbles that we are also seeing in terms of communication and the shaping of public opinion.

The Internet has our data that define us, and increasingly more accurately. And I am not only referring to private data, to data extracted from our search history and from our public behaviour.

A literary, gastronomy or music recommendation on Facebook may seem innocuous to us, but this algorithm is also starting to decide if we are offered a job, if we are accepted as an insurance policyholder, if we are given a loan and if we are to be given a certain type of medical operation.

And none of these matters are any longer innocuous, they never have been, but particularly not now.

Because they all affect our possibilities as human beings to develop a life project within the society in which we live.

Because they all radically disrupt the idea of equal opportunities, which was the foundation of our social contract that I mentioned before.

We still don't know to what extent and with what effects. We still don't exactly know the benefits and the harm caused by these algorithms. But we know that we cannot stand by and watch them with our arms folded.

We know that the transformations associated with this are so colossal and of such great importance that it is necessary to change the rules of the game.

And these changes - it goes without saying - cannot only be debated or exercised at a national level. Nations, in this regard, have lost their regulatory exclusivity. Digitalisation, as the Chairman of Santander mentioned before, is a good example of this in relation to tax systems, and we have also seen the approach taken at the G7 by the world's main economies. Digitalisation and globalisation are self-fuelling, and some large companies in the sector end up with as much power and similar resources to some countries, as Pedro said before, and so logically they are going to invest as much as some countries with the resources they have and how they compete.

We must now unreservedly address issues that are not only related to the creation of this wealth but to how to redistribute this wealth and the impact it may have on vulnerable groups.

Let's talk about a new Workers' Statute in which somewhat classical concepts must be restructured such as what an "undertaking" is, an "employed worker" or an "independent contractor", and included therein.

Let's talk about the contribution of science, as I said before, to politics and to the economy and to this re-industrialisation process.

Let's build a new tax model based on data, because data are new productive factors in the economic system in which we live. Let's reinvent and boost our education system, with vocational training, with a new Universities Act, something we want to push through. We have spoken with the universities and I believe it is important to push this through and I understand that the State Secretary is on the case.

In short, let's decisively regulate many of the aspects involved in everything we are talking about. All of this is in the field of politics and we cannot detach ourselves from that. Times of great transformations are the best times to correct endemic and structural imbalances, and to try and build the society we want to see between all of us.

The digital transformation of the economy is a source of progress, but also of social progress, but we may also run the risk of increasing inequalities, or of reducing them, and that depends on us.

That is why I believe and I will end on this note, that we must make a fair call on this; for digitalisation to serve to reduce inequalities, to improve public services, to establish fairer taxation, to protect more than ever the right to privacy and to honour. We are going to use all the capabilities of digitalisation to tackle challenges that are pending, such as rural depopulation and also offer opportunities from a territorial point of view in our country.

The European Union has recently approved the "Start-Up Village" programme, which precisely seeks to boost rural entrepreneurship, changes in work habits and the integration of different regions so that no differences exist between rural and urban life in relation to digitalisation.

It is clear that the challenge is huge because we have agglomeration economies and that means a great deal of political commitment, but we must do this because we have to guarantee these equal opportunities throughout the country. For the first time ever, Spain has arrived at an industrial revolution ready to play a leading role and the figures are out there: fibre optic coverage of up to 77%. We are the fifth leading country in the European Union and the eighth in the world in terms of the most inclusive Internet coverage.

Large cities like Madrid and Barcelona are leaders in the creation of start-ups. And the National Entrepreneurship Strategy is pending implementation, as an entrepreneurial nation. What we must do is ensure that this is not only Madrid and Barcelona, but also Santander, Oviedo, Gijon, Vigo, Seville and Jaen. We must expand this capacity to create technology in many other parts of our country.

In short, as on so many other fronts, I believe that the digital transformation must be one of our pillars of priority action and we have some challenges that were unfortunately left pending on 28 April that we were unable to set in motion but which we will do before the end of the year as soon as a government is formed, such as the approval of the National Intelligence Plan.

Let me end with a thought. Series have been fashionable for some time now, we have all seen Black Mirror and also recently Years and Years on HBO. All of these series present the recurring theme of a dystopian future which frightens us to some extent. You go to bed somewhat uneasy after seeing one of these episodes.

They convert the digital world into a threat that brings inequality, disenchantment, totalitarianism or personal unhappiness.

Aside from their artistic virtues, which are unquestionable, I feel that they are wrong, and this is the last call that I will make to you. We must make them wrong. And it is precisely these series, and these episodes, that provoke us to prove them wrong and ensure that we do not have this dystopian future that they plot out for us.

The digital transformation can serve to allow us to create fairer societies, that are less unequal, with opportunities for everyone, and more concerned about what is truly human. We will all work to that end.

And in this sense, I want to end my words by thanking AMETIC, and obviously Santander, but also quite clearly all those speakers that I have not had the privilege of listening to for the contributions that you are making because between you all you are making a better Spain and a better world.

Thank you.

Non official translation