"Neither coalition nor elections, there is another way: common progressive program."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

1 September 2019

Context
Sánchez outlined his 'third way' proposal at La Moncloa on September 1, 2019, seeking to break Spain's political deadlock without new elections or a formal coalition.
Main themes
Coalition government negotiations, common progressive program, political deadlock in Spain, PSOE and Unidas Podemos relations, investiture failure, avoiding new elections, parliamentary cooperation, independence of ministers, Catalan secessionism, right-wing opposition abstention
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,073
86th percentile
Sentences
214
90th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%69%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

214 sentences in 55 paragraphs

The acting president considers that one of the reasons Iglesias wants to enter the Government is because he does not trust the Socialist Party. And he asks: "Can anyone imagine a football team where the defenders are more concerned about their own forwards than the opposing team?"

Sánchez maintains that there is time until September 23 to negotiate the essential points of that common progressive program and recalls that in his Government there have always been effective independent ministers. He emphasizes that the 12 months of parliamentary cooperation with Unidas Podemos were very positive. He has no hope that the right will abstain: "The PP and Cs say they do not want elections. But, well, I insist, and I underline it, not with one line but with five: I expect nothing from the right."

The acting president of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, hopes that the deadlock in Spanish politics will be resolved without the need to call new elections. In a conversation held on Friday at the Palacio de La Moncloa, Pedro Sánchez firmly defends a "third way," a Government based on a common progressive program, which allows not only for the investiture but also for a stable legislature, and which he will present in Madrid next Tuesday. Sánchez argues that the 12 months of parliamentary cooperation with Unidas Podemos were very positive and demonstrated that this collaboration translated into significant improvements for the lives of citizens. They even led to a budget supported by both formations. "The elections of April 28 were not the result of disagreements between the Socialist Party and Unidas Podemos, but were anticipated by the decision of the PP, Ciudadanos, and the Catalan secessionist groups, who voted together against that budget," he explains. The acting president maintains that there is time until September 23 to negotiate the essential points of the common progressive program and recalls that in his Governments there have always been independent ministers of proven effectiveness. He does not believe it is possible to return to a coalition government proposal, as Unidas Podemos currently maintains, because that incorporation has been completely ruled out due to the conviction, resulting from previous conversations, that it would be a Government lacking cohesion. Sánchez defends a progressive Executive that does not depend on the independentist forces and recalls that right now we are at the lowest level of support for secessionism since 2017. "We do not have to go to elections," he insists, but warns that it does not depend solely on the PSOE. And if it comes to that point, he believes that voters will choose stability, and that stability can only be provided, for now, by the PSOE.

Question. Why was it impossible to form a Government in July?

Answer. In the failed investiture of July 25, it was demonstrated that the coalition proposal was unfeasible. On April 28, the Spanish people were clear in their verdict at the polls, and they reaffirmed it on May 26 in the municipal, regional, and European elections. They want a progressive Government led by the Socialist Party, which does not depend on independentist forces. The coalition Government with Unidas Podemos proved unfeasible for two essential reasons. The first, due to the distrust that became evident when they explained why they had to join the Government of Spain, and secondly, due to their conception of the coalition, which was more a coalition of governments than a coalition Government. The failed investiture has passed, and I believe we need to find a third way to avoid elections; a different option than the one initially proposed by the Socialist Party and Unidas Podemos.

Q. What is that option that would allow avoiding the deadlock?

A. Between elections and a coalition Government, there is an alternative, which is a Government with a common progressive program. That is what we have been doing during this last month of August. Next week we will present that program to civil society as a whole and specifically to the parliamentary group of Unidas Podemos to find the necessary support for the legislature to get underway and for us to have that progressive Government that the Spanish people voted for.

Q. When do you foresee the meeting with Unidas Podemos?

A. We are going to hold that meeting as soon as possible. The important thing is that the negotiating teams meet and that we learn from the mistakes that occurred on July 25. At that time, the discussion was first about the structure of the Government and not about the contents. I believe it is important to talk about the political program. Unidas Podemos says that the cooperation during these last 15 months, especially after the motion of censure, was not sufficiently positive. But I believe it was very positive. In fact, it was possible to do many things with a left-wing bloc of 151 seats. Today we have 165 seats. Why should we not be able to implement many other things during this legislature, when the Spanish people have precisely recognized with their vote that effort of cooperation by both political formations? The budgets, the result of the cooperation between the Socialist Party and Unidas Podemos, would have been very positive for Spanish society as a whole. That is the fundamental proof. I claim that it is perfectly possible to cooperate over the next four years with an option different from the coalition Government proposed by Unidas Podemos.

Q. Would the trust, broken at this moment, be built on the contents of the agreement?

A. The contents, the policies. The sectoral policies linked to the recovery of rights, of freedoms, with their expansion. And also with the major transformations we need in the educational field, in the area of ecological transition, in the reconstruction of the welfare state. We have many coincidences with the parliamentary group of Unidas Podemos. Fundamentally, where there are more discrepancies is around the two reasons that Mr. Iglesias puts forward to defend the coalition Government. He says he needs to enter the Government because he does not trust the Socialist Party. Can anyone imagine a football team where the defenders are more concerned about their own forwards than the opposing team? The second problem is his conception of the Government, and that is a much deeper discrepancy. A disunited Government is a misgovernment, and Spain has to address important challenges over the next four years.

Q. What challenges?

A. Some challenges are inherent, reflecting seven years of total absence of transformations in our country, such as a new educational law, ecological transition, digitalization, reconstruction of the welfare state, and tax reform, or also territorial coexistence and our participation in the European project. To these challenges, we must add others that are circumstantial and that have to do with resolving the crisis of coexistence in Catalonia, which will have a quite important episode in October, when the sentence of the procés is expected; that have to do with Brexit, or even with the signs of cooling in the global economy and consequently in the European and Spanish economies. Challenges resulting from the trade battles being posed by the great superpowers, China and the United States. In other words, we need a strong Government. It is not just about saving the investiture and forming a Government, but that this Government is coherent, consistent, has a single direction, and is effective in responding to the challenges facing Spanish society and European society as a whole. I am very hopeful that we can come to an understanding with Unidas Podemos in this regard. What we are going to put on the table is a common progressive program for a progressive Government. I insist, between elections and coalition, there is a third way, the one I will advocate this coming week.

Q. What have you done to avoid new elections?

A. Since April 28, the Socialist Party has made five offers to Unidas Podemos. They have only made one, a coalition Government. We proposed a solo Government with external support, a cooperation Government, a Government with recognized independents from the orbit of Unidas Podemos, and a coalition Government, which was dismissed by Mr. Iglesias's party. Now we are going to propose a common progressive program for a progressive Government. I believe it is time for everyone to also assume their responsibility, in the sense that it is quite strange for a party that calls itself leftist to prevent the formation of a leftist Government. Especially when that leftist Government will not have an absolute majority and therefore I will not be able to impose my electoral program; on the contrary, I will have to weave alliances with different political forces in the Congress of Deputies to be able to carry it out and implement it.

Q. The new offer can avoid, according to you, a return to the polls.

A. I believe we can avoid elections, but it does not depend solely and exclusively on the Socialist Party; it depends on three other political forces. It depends on Unidas Podemos, which we have said is our priority partner. And it also depends on two other political formations: the Popular Party and Ciudadanos, whether it is true that they want a Government not dependent on independentists. I, for my part, expect nothing from the Popular Party and Ciudadanos. I expect absolutely nothing because if there is one thing they have made clear during these last months, it is that between a socialist Government and a Socialist Party Government with the independentists, they will always prefer the latter to the former. And I believe that also demonstrates the hypocrisy and irresponsibility, not with the Government, but with the State, of both the PP and Ciudadanos.

Q. Pablo Iglesias has now said that if you put the July offer back on the table, they could agree again in hours. Why can’t you put it back on the table?

A. In politics, as in life, facts have consequences. And on July 25, not only was an investiture prevented. Trust was broken. It is evident that Spain cannot afford more instability after five years of confusion caused by the PP's poor response to the economic crisis, with anti-social measures, systematic cuts to the welfare state, tax increases on the middle class, and cases of corruption that led to institutional disaffection. What we cannot afford is to have a Government that does not last four years. Can that Executive come from a coalition Government? Well, if one looks at Italy, it does not seem that the coalition is synonymous with stability. Just yesterday, Mr. Iglesias said that we had only offered him a ministry that represented 10% of the budget. Excuse me. I put in the hands of Unidas Podemos nothing less than the public management of health in this country, which represents 6% of the Gross Domestic Product. But it not only represents that in quantitative terms, but it represents something much more important for Spanish citizens, which is cohesion, redistribution.

Q. What produces more instability, a repeat election or a poorly cohesive Government?

A. It does not have to be posed that way. The Socialist Party won the elections on April 28 with 28.5%. The second political party had 16%. The PP had four and a half million votes. Why don’t we start the legislature? Why can’t we, as I said before, weave a relationship of trust through that parliamentary collaboration with the monitoring and oversight mechanisms that Unidas Podemos wants to lift a common progressive program? We have done it during these last 12 months. We have done great things for this country: we have recovered the subsidy for those over 52 years old, we have raised the minimum interprofessional wage, we have demonstrated that this does not destroy jobs. We have done things that were unimaginable for a good part of Spanish society. I do not understand why they renounce those 12 months. There is no alternative. When the PP and Ciudadanos say "we are going to vote against," what do they offer other than blockage and a repeat election to the Spanish people?

Q. Would you accept independents in the Government?

A. I have always been open to the incorporation of independents. In fact, one of the proposals I made to Unidas Podemos was precisely the incorporation of recognized independents from the orbit of Unidas Podemos. I have already had independents in my Government who have not formed or do not form part of the Socialist Party.

Q. What are the main lines of that progressive proposal that you make, not only to the other parties but to the citizens?

I would say five objectives, plus one. One, with the ecological transition; two, with the sustainability of our pensions and the creation of decent jobs; three, digitalization and the impact it will have on work and education; four, the reconstruction of the welfare state and the fight against inequality, and there to logically incorporate the inequality suffered by women. And fifth, territorial coexistence, the strengthening of the questioned autonomous state, not only by the independentist forces that want to break it, but also by others that want to recentralize; and Spain's participation in Europe. The "plus one" is education, which must be the substratum of each and every one of those pillars.

Q. Can you elaborate a bit more?

A. In relation to decent employment and the sustainability of pensions, we need to open a debate on the approval of a new Workers' Statute and rebuild social dialogue around a fundamental pillar, the keystone of our welfare state, which is the public pension system. We need to talk about updating our seniors' pensions according to the CPI, but we also need to discuss other sources of funding to sustain our public pension system. The next legislature will be the one of educational revolution, vocational training, a new educational law, and a new university law. Equality of opportunity, if it is based on something, is precisely on the equality of the educational system, which must be, without a doubt, of excellence but also of equity and financial sufficiency.

Q. Progressive measures need resources...

A. Without a doubt.

Q. And where do they come from?

A. Economic resources must come from three things. The first, from economic growth. Therefore, from greater revenue in relation to our current tax system. Secondly, it is evident that we need to carry out a reform to guarantee fiscal justice, which in turn guarantees social justice. And, thirdly, I believe we need to manage public economic resources better. Efficiency in managing public resources is also a value of the left. For example, active employment policies linked to vocational training need to be reviewed because we are subsidizing Social Security contributions for certain groups that are then not hired. The right does not believe in the welfare state, and the left cannot have a conservative vision of what the role of the public sector should be in stimulating the economy and creating jobs.

Q. What is the possibility that, if an early election occurs, the right will gain?

A. I insist. We do not have to go to elections. First, because there is a broad majority in the Congress of Deputies around the Socialist Party. Secondly, because there is no alternative. Neither to the right nor to the left of the Socialist Party. That is to say, any investiture goes through the Socialist Party. And, thirdly, because the Spaniards on April 28 and May 26 already said they want the Socialist Party to govern. From there, I am convinced that Spanish citizens, if there are elections eventually, will always opt for a progressive government, because only the Socialist Party can respond - and, moreover, we have seen it over the last 40 years - to the challenges, to the modernizations that our country needs.

Q. If there is a repeat election and the right gains, would you assume your part of the responsibility?

A. I understand why you are asking me this question, but I am not in that plane because what I want is for there to be no elections, but I will tell you one thing: if in the end on November 10 we have to go to elections because we have not been able among all the political formations to resolve a labyrinth that is quite easy to resolve, if we apply a little reasoning and think about the general interest, I am convinced that the progressives in this country will bet more strongly on the PSOE. Because they will not only bet on a progressive program, but they will want four years of stability.

Q. So there is not an unmanageable situation, a labyrinth with no exit?

A. No matter how many turns we take in this crisis of ungovernability, I believe it is very simple to get out of the labyrinth. First, all political forces must accept the electoral result. From the first - which is the Socialist Party and is aware that it does not have an absolute majority, and therefore cannot govern solely with its electoral program - to the last political force, which is Unidas Podemos - I discount the far right - which must be aware that its contribution involves shouldering a progressive government with a progressive program. For the PP and Ciudadanos, their responsibility is to be aware that if there is no alternative majority that they can implement, what they will have to do is abstain. We are seeing two political forces that reproach me for a supposed support from independentist forces when they hold the key to having a government without needing to depend on independentist forces.

Q. When do the new conversations start? There is little time.

A. There is plenty of time. If what is important are the contents, there is plenty of time. The contents of the political proposal that we will put on the table on Tuesday, the 3rd, are not only a consequence of dialogue with social groups, but also of political proposals from Unidas Podemos that reconcile perfectly with those of the Socialist Party.

Q. To go to a new investiture, do you need a public commitment from Unidas Podemos that they will support that government?

A. I not only need Unidas Podemos; I need other political formations. By the way, just a reflection. When Esquerra Republicana says that after September 11 their position to facilitate the governability of Spain becomes more difficult, perhaps the rest of the political actors - I refer to the PP and Ciudadanos - should take that statement into account to be aware that the stability of the country cannot rest on political formations that have a calendar alien to the general interest of Spain. It is my obligation, at least my hope, that this can happen. That is why I say and speak of a progressive government that does not depend on independentist forces. Does that mean that I do not want to talk about Catalonia? That we do not have to resolve the Catalan issue? Of course not. Look, the other day I read the CEO survey, the Catalan CIS, which said that 80% of Catalans want dialogue. Only 9% support the unilateral path defended by Puigdemont, unfortunately, the current president of the Generalitat of Catalonia. We are currently at the lowest level of support for independence in Catalonia since 2017. Something must have to do with the policy that the Government of Spain has made in relation to Catalonia. Of de-escalation, of not confrontation, which does not mean not being forceful on those issues that we consider to be susceptible to being illegal.

Q. It is now, before October, when you could gain the support of ERC.

A. Yes, but what governability is that? For Brexit, to resolve the crisis of coexistence in Catalonia, to make the necessary reforms and transformations that allow for continued job creation and sustained economic growth, we must appeal to the sense of state of the Popular Party and Ciudadanos.

Q. It seems complicated.

A. No. The labyrinth is not that difficult. We are going to propose a common progressive program next week. That would imply, if Unidas Podemos agrees to this third way that we are proposing, that they would move from abstention to affirmative voting. It would also imply that the other nationalist political forces, in this case the Basque Nationalist Party and others, could also potentially move to an affirmative vote. What ERC and Junts per Catalunya are going to do depends on parameters and issues that have nothing to do even with the general interest of Catalonia because they rejected a budget that was beneficial for them. Their vote is not necessary. With the abstention of the Popular Party and Ciudadanos, there is a government.

Q. Why will they abstain?

A. The PP and Ciudadanos say they do not want elections. I am not asking them to support the Socialist Party. I am asking them to facilitate the formation of the government that the Spaniards have voted for. But, well, I insist, and I underline this not with one line, but with five to make it clear: I expect nothing from the right. After what they have said and done, it is more than evident that they will vote no to an investiture of the Socialist Party.

"The proposal of Spain Suma is, above all, confrontational"

Q. Is the Popular Party led by Pablo Casado interested in new elections?

A. I don't know. I have my doubts. I don't know if they are interested or not. What we have heard from the right during this August is that they want to create a platform called Spain Suma. From a conceptual point of view, after what the Popular Party, Ciudadanos, and the far right have done in many regional and local governments, it makes sense. It is coherent. There is no difference, there are no fundamental discrepancies between the three political forces. There are none from an ideological point of view. They have come to an agreement. There it is. Even with elements that are not known because they were agreements made without light and shorthand, as the far right itself acknowledged. From a political project point of view, there are no nuances. But what does this platform denote? First, the inconsistency and betrayal of Ciudadanos to its own electorate, which is centrist and which they have abandoned. Secondly, the Popular Party shows that it has no political project because it is capable of hiding its initials and renouncing them. And, thirdly, the victory of the far right, which in the end has imposed its postulates. And their postulates, beyond being serious, as is the approach they make regarding women and their participation in society, the issue of migration, or Spain's participation in Europe, those postulates are, above all, confrontational. The proposal of Spain Suma is not a constructive proposal; it is a proposal to go all against the Socialist Party. And that is anything but a country project.

"The G7 summit ended with positive signs"

The acting Prime Minister attended the closing dinner of the G7 summit last Sunday, invited by the President of the French Republic, Emmanuel Macron. It was a particularly intense meeting at a time when international uncertainty reaches levels unknown since the end of the Cold War.

Q. What impression did you get from the meeting with the G7? Are there reasons for the concern perceived in Europe?

A. I believe that the French presidency has been outstanding in relation to the G7. We cooperated with the French government to ensure that the summit developed positively, and I believe there have been important positive elements. One, that the American administration recognizes that it will sit down with the Iranian government to resolve the crisis, seems to me a very hopeful advance. Secondly, proposing a support fund for Brazil to fight against deforestation in the Amazon is also a positive step. And, thirdly, I believe that the tone maintained by the Trump administration regarding the trade war with China and the increase in tariffs was lowered. These are three very important achievements for the global economy in the coming months. It is evident that Brexit and the trade war are affecting especially the industrial sector, and particularly Germany, and that is a strong element of concern for the Spanish economy.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of El País.