Interview with the acting Prime Minister on Antena 3 News

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

7 October 2019

Context
Sánchez gave a televised interview on Antena 3 News in October 2019 during the pre-campaign period ahead of Spain's November 10 general elections.
Main themes
Political blockade, November 10 elections, PSOE electoral position, progressive government formation, multiparty fragmentation, Catalonia question, poll data analysis, political stability, PP and Ciudadanos positions, Unidas Podemos, pre-campaign dynamics
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,886
91st percentile
Sentences
242
93rd percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

242 sentences in 85 paragraphs

President.- Good evening.

P.- Thank you for being on Antena3 Noticias.

Well, we have been discussing the data from the polls. Data that is roughly explained because, logically, each one provides different details, but it is clear that the PSOE maintains its position, its first position, but, in principle, it does not manage to advance much beyond its current position. The PP is advancing, although not enough to catch up with the PSOE. Ciudadanos is falling. Podemos is also falling, although not as much. Vox is falling very little. Más País is gaining some seats that it seems Podemos has been able to lose.

What summary do you make at this beginning of the pre-campaign regarding this data? We saw yesterday, for example, the Vox event in Madrid with a lot of people. What is your opinion?

President.- Well, let's see. I think we are at the starting point. There are still five weeks until the elections on November 10, and therefore, what we see are two quite clear things. The first is that the only guarantee of avoiding a blockade on November 10 is the Socialist Party because, clearly, it is the leading political force, according to all the demographic studies. And, secondly, the only force that can guarantee what was voted on April 28 and also on May 26, which is to have a progressive government, is the Socialist Party.

In any case, as you rightly point out, the main political problem that the country currently faces is that there has been a blockade during these last months. And we hope that on November 10 that blockade will be a thing of the past and that, therefore, we can have a period of stability that ends the provisionality and interim nature with which Spanish politics has lived in recent years. P.- But are you not surprised that after many weeks, even months, of you sending that message that the country needs to be unblocked, at this beginning of the pre-campaign there is not a certain rise of the Socialist Party to achieve a position of predominance that could allow it to govern more comfortably? I say this, for example, as your Portuguese colleague achieved in yesterday's elections; although he did not achieve an absolute majority, he got very close.

President.- I insist. I think we first have to frame the entire campaign. We are at the beginning of it. And I believe that, indeed, we have the blockade of the political problem. Today I have been listening to leaders of the Popular Party, also to leaders of Ciudadanos, saying, well, we do not know if they are going to unblock or if they are going to unblock us; if they will finally allow the Socialist Party to govern or not.

I would like -- and I think this is one of the main questions that needs to be answered by the different political actors and, specifically, by the PP, by Cs, and by Unidas Podemos, who have been the ones who have blocked the formation of the government after the elections of April 28 -- the question they need to answer is whether on November 10, once they know the electoral results, whether the Socialist Party has more seats or fewer seats, they will continue with the political blockade. And I believe that this question has an easy answer: yes or no. Because it is important for citizens to know what position these parties will have after November 10.

P.- The feeling is that perhaps what you understand by unblocking is not exactly what the other political leaders understand by unblocking. Because both the PP and Ciudadanos, in recent hours, have even offered to unblock based on agreements, not on the basis of "we give you the seats."

President.- Well, besides, I have never wanted that. I mean, I think I have always proposed the same thing: a progressive government, a government that would guarantee a certain stability; that is to say, that would not be dependent on independentist forces that do not share the governance agenda that Spain needs. And, thirdly, a coherent government, a government that is not divided in two, for example, on an issue like Catalonia. Imagine a government where one part defends the Constitution, the constitutional order, and the Statute of Autonomy in Catalonia, and the other part defends that there are political prisoners in Catalonia.

Therefore, I believe that what the Socialist Party and I have always proposed has been the same: a progressive government, a government guaranteed with a certain stability. And, undoubtedly, also the coherence in the formation of that government.

I will also tell you one thing. I believe that right now there is a lot of talk about partisanship, about multipartyism. Well, what does it matter to have five, eight, ten, fifty, a hundred political parties if after citizens vote in the electoral processes what we have is a blockade and there is no formation of a government in Spain? I believe that this is what we need to resolve and respond to on November 10. And, I insist, in all demographic studies, the sentiment of the street, as also happened on May 26 and April 28, is that the Socialist Party is the only one that can guarantee a way out of this political blockade that our country is experiencing.

P.- The Socialist Party is the one that has won the elections, but when a party, the most voted, achieves 123 seats, it cannot be said that citizens have granted it the possibility to govern just like that.

President.- That's right. In fact, that is what...

P.- I say this because you, yesterday, sort of cleared the ball of offers from both the PP and Ciudadanos by saying "I have nothing to discuss with these parties," and now you talk about a progressive government. Does that mean you will direct your eyes after the elections towards Podemos and Más País to reach an agreement?

President.- Let's see. What do citizens choose with their vote on election day? First of all, the political orientation of a government. A progressive government, a conservative government. Obviously, on April 28, they voted for progressives. On May 26, they voted again for progressive governments three times.

P.- So, we rule out Ciudadanos always...

President.- Yes, because there is now a lot of debate about the grand coalition that, in reality, the grand coalition is the trick that Unidas Podemos and also the Popular Party use before the electoral processes, in the electoral campaign, to say, more or less, that the Socialist Party wants to, let's say, betray its progressive principles. But, look, Unidas Podemos does this precisely to hide that in four years it has voted four times against the formation of a progressive government led by the Socialist Party. And, also from the Popular Party and Mr. Casado to hide their pacts with the far right.

Look, yesterday you and I heard, like many Spaniards, what the leader of Vox, the far right in Spain, said. He accused the Socialist Party of being a criminal party. Just a few days ago we also heard other leaders of that far right disqualifying and criminalizing 13 women who were murdered, who were executed for having committed no crime; simply for having defended freedom at that time in Spain. And I have not heard any leader of the Popular Party disqualify and distance themselves from that type of disqualifications and also from criticisms and outbursts from the far right. What do I want to say with this? That one cannot pretend to be moderate and negotiate with the far right. That the Socialist Party will always defend the same thing, where we have been: a progressive government, a government that does not rest its stability on independentist forces, and a government that is coherent and, therefore, not divided in two.

P.- We have already heard Podemos leaders say two things. To reach an agreement with the Socialist Party and invest you as president, there has to be a coalition government and you cannot veto the leader of Podemos, Pablo Iglesias. Will you fulfill those two conditions?

President.- But, look, I offered Unidas Podemos, during these five months -- and it is even a political party that did not guarantee the necessary stability, because we did not add up to an absolute majority and, therefore, it made governance depend on independentist forces -- I offered that party a coalition with a vice-presidency and three ministries. Specifically, the Ministry of Health and Consumption, the Ministry of Culture, and the Ministry of Housing and Social Economy.

P.- And will that happen again?

President.- No, let's see. I insist. Those are the three axes, ideas around which I have always proposed a coalition government or sharing the government in multiple ways: progressive, stability, and coherence. And, well, listening to Mr. Iglesias and listening to Unidas Podemos during these last weeks, what is evident is that, as they conceive the coalition, that coalition is unfeasible.

P.- President, it is then hard to know how you will achieve the investiture unless you achieve an absolute majority because...

President.- No.

P.- ... because if you cannot with the right, because you want a progressive government, and you will not offer anything to the left of the Socialist Party that you have not already offered them because that chapter, let's say, is closed, how will you achieve it? What do you expect, that they will simply vote for you, for free, to unblock the situation?

President.- Look, during these months I told the party of Unidas Podemos, I offered, as I said before, a coalition government. To the Popular Party and Ciudadanos, I said: hey, I understand that it is difficult for you to go from "no" to abstention, tell me exactly what you need, what we can agree on so that we can allow and facilitate a government in Spain and, therefore, not be forced into elections on November 10, as we are now.

What I want to say with this is that we have always been willing to reach agreements. In this case, for abstention and facilitating the government by the PP and Ciudadanos and, in the case of Unidas Podemos, to reach programmatic agreements and even the formation of a government.

P.- Is that what you maintain?

President.- But look, Mr. Vallés, let’s look back over these 40 years. What has happened in our democracy? There have not been many absolute majority governments. There have been minority governments.

P.- But there were not so many national parties to share the seats.

President.- Of course, but, indeed, this is the issue. If multipartyism exists to create a blockade, then, let’s say, what sense does this political system we have make? What I say is that multipartyism is good insofar as it facilitates the stability and governability of our country. I will not doubt multipartyism because it is what citizens choose in each electoral process. What I ask for is a dose of responsibility from the other political parties to recognize, at least, if there is no parliamentary majority alternative to what the Socialist Party represents, at least, to allow governance by forming the only possible government, led by the Socialist Party.

P.- Allow me one more question on that topic before moving on to other important matters. You have referred to the four times that Podemos voted against you. In investiture votes. Indeed, you are going to present yourself for the fourth consecutive time as the Socialist leader in the elections and you have already presented yourself in four votes in two investiture sessions: in 2016 and in 2019. Does the fact that you have presented yourself before the Parliament of the nation four times and have been rejected by the Parliament of the nation all four times give you any reflection, beyond the criticisms of the other parties for not supporting you?

President.- Well, I think the reflection we all need to make is that on November 10 we need to open a new stage, as we need to open it in every electoral process. That is to say, the electoral campaign ends on the day of the elections.

Look at what happened in Portugal. In Portugal, the Socialist Party won and for a few minutes the governability of the country was resolved. Because the rest of the political formations and, specifically, the left-wing political formations recognized the victory of the Socialist Party, said they would not block the formation of a Socialist government, and what they said was that, logically, they would facilitate governance in Portugal based on a programmatic negotiation, based on, as you have said in the news, for example, increasing the Minimum Interprofessional Wage or, perhaps, pensions.

P.- Now I am going to ask you about that, precisely. To begin with, I will read you something that your Minister of Economy, Nadia Calviño, just said in recent hours, I quote: "Nothing suggests a crisis," close quote. Spaniards, when we hear this from a member of the Government, do not know whether to tremble or to be satisfied. I say this because of the experience of other occasions when the same was said and that was not what happened afterwards.

President.- It shouldn't. It shouldn't. I believe that we from the Government of Spain what we have done during these last months is clearly alert to the threats that the international economy, the European economy, and consequently, the Spanish economy had, which has a lot to do not with our factors of the European economy or the Spanish economy, but, well.

P.- But we suffer it just the same as if it were ours.

President.- Yes, yes, but the origins are different. The origins are: the trade war, the struggle between China and the United States, and that has an impact on economies that are important to us because we export to them, such as the German economy. But, having said that, it is also evident that, if one looks at the data, there are no elements of complacency nor of catastrophism. We continue to grow more than double, or rather, double, the average of the Eurozone. The forecasts for economic growth and job creation are being met; over the last 12 months, we have created around 480,000 new jobs. That is to say, the forecast that the Government of Spain had.

Q.- It has slowed down, and you know well, job creation has slowed down a lot. We are going down in that sense.

President.- We have said that economic growth is slowing down and, consequently, can job creation be slowing down? Yes, but look at one thing. In year-on-year terms, the GDP growth rate is lower than the job creation rate. That is to say, we are creating more jobs than the economy is growing. And that also has a lot to do with the resilience and strength, let’s say, of the fundamentals of our economy. And, on the other hand, we are reducing public debt, we are reducing the public deficit.

And then, I believe that we have, first, the project, the ideas, and we have the teams. We have an economic team, I believe, with a person of extraordinary reputation at the national and international level in the economic world, such as the Minister of Economy, Nadia Calviño.

Q.- Today, she has offered 35 social measures in a preview of what will be the electoral program of the Socialist Party. And indeed, you mentioned it already, there is, for example, an increase in pensions, which you have promised for the month of December. In December, there is a possibility that you will still be president in office.

President.- Let’s hope not.

Q.- But if that were the case, are you in a position to raise pensions to the CPI while in office?

President.- We will raise them, and I hope that already with a Government in full capacity. That is why I believe it is important that we have a Government as soon as possible, stable, that gives us a parliamentary majority wide enough to have a four-year legislature and not just an investiture.

I believe that during these last 15 months, 16 months, that we have been in Government, the pensioners of this country have seen a behavior and commitment radically different from the previous Administration. We have revalued pensions and, with that, not only have retirees guaranteed their purchasing power in 2019, but they have also recovered that of 2018, which had been lost, and that of 2017.

What is my commitment? My commitment is, logically, that we can rebuild the Toledo Pact during the next legislature. That we can guarantee the sustainability of the Public Pension System. I have also committed that in five years we will reduce to zero the public deficit that currently exists in the Social Security System.

Q.- By raising to the CPI every year?

President.- Well, but that is where we need to open the debate. And that is where we need to substantiate the debate in the Toledo Pact Commission. I tell you one thing, Mr. Vallés. For example, the much-criticized measure of raising the Minimum Interprofessional Wage has led to an increase in the contribution bases to Social Security and, consequently, also an increase in Social Security revenues.

In the last twelve months, for example, in September, if you look at the data, you see that more than 70% of the contracts that have been signed are indefinite contracts, full-time contracts; that is to say, stable contracts, it also does.

Q.- Only 12%, Mr. President, of all contracts that have been signed in September.

President.- Yes, of course, but you have to look at it in year-on-year terms. That is to say, from September to September how many contracts have been signed that are stable contracts. What I want to tell you with this is that stability in employment, quality in employment, the increase in wages as is happening in recent months, is also allowing Social Security revenues to become increasingly positive. And, consequently, reduce the Social Security deficit. And, with that, we not only have to open that debate on the need to improve the quality of employment, but we will also have to open the debate on how to complementarily finance our Public Pension System.

And do one more thing that I think is fundamental: there are some items linked to Social Security that do not correspond to Social Security and that have to be charged to the General State Budgets.

In short, I believe that there is a lot of capacity to guarantee the sustainability of our Public Pension System without having to reduce the pie and, therefore, reduce the pension for our elders.

Q.- You have already promised in some previous electoral programs that you would eliminate the most harmful parts, as they have been qualified, of the Labor Reform. That has not yet happened because you have been practically in office, but from Brussels they are asking not to cut reforms, but to make new reforms to ensure the sustainability of our economy. What reforms does the Socialist Party propose?

President.- In relation to the Labor Reform of 2012, proposed by the Popular Party, I believe that there will be many employers --and I have also spoken with the main business associations in this country and I have also spoken with the unions-- who agree that, for example, subcontracting is leading to greater precariousness and greater wage devaluation of workers. I believe that there is much to gain there. And there is broad consensus within the Congress of Deputies, both on the left and the right, to resolve the current problem of subcontracting and labor precariousness through those contracts.

When we talk, for example, about strengthening collective bargaining. Well, I believe that if one looks at what happens in other European countries, it is evident that collective bargaining, social peace, if it exists, is positive for the economy, because it introduces certainty and, consequently, I believe that it can improve the capacities for economic growth and job creation of an economy. Or if we talk, for example, about everything related to wage levels and the growth of those wages.

Therefore, what I want to tell you is that we want to look forward, not backward. We not only want to repeal the most harmful aspects of the Labor Reform of 2012 but we want to approve a new Statute of Workers.

There is right now a new economy --the riders, who are a bit the paradigms of that new economy-- that needs to be regulated. And right now there is already enough jurisprudence in the Social Courts to know exactly whether they are employees or self-employed workers. On all these issues, I believe that the current framework of labor relations does not provide answers and, therefore, we will have to provide them with a new Statute of Workers. That is, at least, the commitment we have.

Q.- We do not have many minutes left, but I still want to raise some issues. To begin with, the territorial issue, the territorial question, the situation in Catalonia. Today a motion of censure has been presented and voted on in the Catalan Parliament against the Government of Joaquim Torra. Your party, the Socialist Party of Catalonia, has abstained. You say that you did not want to support what you see as an electoral motion, proposed by Ciudadanos.

President.- Not only that. In the end, motions of censure cannot allow strengthening, in this case, those who are going to be censured. And there are also quite a few reasons for them to be censured. Notice that Mr. Torra today achieved a parliamentary majority that he has not had throughout this legislature.

Q.- But you can be accused of, precisely, having an opportunity to censure Torra and not doing so.

President.- Well, we have done it. What happens is that, I insist, I believe there are two very important elements. A motion of censure cannot be made to strengthen those who are in Government, which is what Ciudadanos has done. And, secondly, a motion of censure cannot be made without first talking to the parliamentary groups that, logically, you have to ask for support, and knowing, moreover, that the numbers do not add up for that motion of censure to prosper.

On this issue, I believe it is very important --even though we are in an electoral process, and although it is true that Ciudadanos is a political party that has used territorial confrontation, the same as the Popular Party, to try to scrape a series of votes outside of Catalonia--, it would seem very important to me, and I say this as the president of the Government, that we set aside all these partisan issues and that we set aside all these initiatives that are electoral, that do not obey the general interest. The only hope that a political project like the independentist one, which is failing, has is that the constitutionalist parties divide us.

Therefore, what I hope is that height of vision, in this case from the Popular Party and Ciudadanos, and that they do the same as the Socialist Party did when it was in opposition: support the Government of Spain.

Q.- Do you have 155 prepared for the circumstances that may arise after the Supreme Court ruling is known?

President.- We do our homework. We contemplate all scenarios. I have said this many times and I reiterate it. The response we will give will be a response of democratic firmness. It will be a response, consequently, to guarantee coexistence in Catalonia and legality. It will be a proportional response to the challenge that, hypothetically, the independentist forces may pose. And it will be a united response. That is to say, it will be a response that I hope can count on the support of Ciudadanos, the Popular Party, and Unidas Podemos.

Q.- Do you really think that Unidas Podemos would be willing to support the application of 155? I say this because it could happen that if, finally, the parties to the left of the PSOE support the Socialist Party for you to be invested as president and you have to apply 155, you would have to rely on the opposition and not on the parties that made you president.

President.- Well, this was a bit the paradox of the previous legislature. And that is also why we are going to elections on November 10; because it is evident that, in the face of the challenge we have as a result of the ruling that will be known soon about the Catalan independentist political leaders, we cannot have a Government where there is a part, I insist, the Socialist Party, that defends the Statute of Autonomy, the Spanish Constitution, coexistence, the constitutional order and, consequently, national sovereignty and territorial integrity, and another part of that Government, in this case Unidas Podemos, that defends that there are political prisoners in Catalonia.

I believe that this is a fundamental disagreement that we have with Unidas Podemos. There are other similarities, resemblances, coincidences that we have with that political party, especially in the social sphere, and that is why we have always defended that the most reasonable thing would have been a minority Government with support from Unidas Podemos from outside the Government.

Q.- You have spoken of law and dialogue for Catalonia.

President.- Yes.

Q.- Dialogue based on what you call "plurinational Spain"? Will that be the offer you make to the independentists who, as you already know, do not accept anything other than an independence referendum?

President.- But, look, if I have always said the same thing. What is the fundamental disagreement we have with independence? That they defend a Catalonia outside of Spain. They defend tearing, extirpating Spain from Catalonia. And that is a very dangerous process and political project.

Moreover, the other day was October 1. And I have said this many times. Let’s take the data from the independentists themselves that I put, let’s say, in question --in terms of participation, I mean. About 43% of the census participated. Of that 43% participation, 38% voted in favor of independence on that October 1, 2017. A few months later, on December 21 of that same year, there were regional elections where almost 80% of the census participated; that is to say, practically double, and independence did not win. Political forces that defend staying in Spain in one way or another won, but staying in Spain.

Therefore, when they talk about a democratic mandate, when they say that there is a majority of Catalans who support independence, they are lying. A minority is a minority, and it will remain a minority for all time. No matter how broad it is, it is a minority.

In Catalonia, there is a problem of coexistence because the majority of Catalan society does not want independence from Spain. What they want is to live within Spain, some in a way different from what they currently do, but to live within Spain.

Therefore, I believe that what is important is for Catalan independence to be aware that it has failed, that it has lied in its postulates and in its political project, to recognize the non-independence part of Catalonia and, let us say, to build those bridges for coexistence that have been fractured as a consequence of this challenge for more than a decade. Q.- One last question, President. Do you already have a date for the exhumation of Franco? Do you at least have it in mind?

President.- Well, we are already preparing it. I believe that the Supreme Court has been unanimous in its ruling. I think it is a great victory for Spanish democracy. I believe that, contrary to what the conservative parties say, this strengthens our democracy; because dignity, memory, justice, and reparations do nothing but strengthen, not weaken, our democracy. And I hope that in October we can exhume and reinter the remains of the dictator.

Q.- And do you think this could have an electoral effect? Beyond whether that is the reason or not, you facilitated the exhumation of Franco's remains. Do you think it could have an electoral effect when what needs to be done, the exhumation and everything else, takes place this October, just before the elections?

President.- I do not see it in those terms. And, truly, I say this with all sincerity. I see it more in historical terms. I believe that the day that happens, the day the mausoleum of the dictator is closed, the day the remains of the dictator stop resting with the remains of the victims, I believe that Spain will have changed. That Spain is going to change, that the circle of the Transition will be closed and that, consequently, we will be facing a democracy that has been strengthened based on principles that I believe are very positive, such as dignity, memory, reparation, and justice.

Q.- Pedro Sánchez, acting Prime Minister and candidate of the Socialist Party for the elections on November 10, thank you for being with us. Good night.

President.- A pleasure.

(Transcript reviewed by the State Secretariat for Communication).