Interview with the President of the Government at the EFE Agency

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

20 January 2021 · EFE Agency

Context
Sánchez was interviewed by EFE Agency on January 20, 2021, discussing Spain's use of EU recovery funds and economic modernization amid the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
European recovery funds, COVID-19 pandemic response, ecological transition, digital transition, modernization of Spanish economy, EU solidarity, single market, social and territorial integration, welfare state, labor market transformation, tourism vulnerability, public investment management
Duration
~81 min
98th percentile
Words
9,683
98th percentile
Sentences
388
97th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

388 sentences in 134 paragraphs

INTERVIEW WITH THE PRIME MINISTER

GABRIELA CAÑAS: Thank you very much, Prime Minister, for being here with us. EFE is delighted to participate in this and to contribute its bit to such an essential topic. I believe we are living through historic moments; I think the solidarity effort made by the European Union was unthinkable four or five years ago. Spain has been one of the countries most affected by the pandemic, and also because of that, or perhaps because the negotiations have been well conducted, we are among the most benefited from the European funds. Therefore, I think it is very important for people to understand this issue well and in depth. The first question I would ask is whether we are prepared for this, because the challenge is truly enormous and the work is immense. Are we well equipped for this battle?

PRIME MINISTER: I would say a resounding yes, of course. For example, in the 1990s, the famous structural funds represented around 8 billion euros in a management process that lasted six years. And now we are talking about 140 billion euros over six years. Those 8 billion euros represented a leap in competitiveness, a leap in the modernization of the Spanish economy, and now, these 140 billion euros will do the same. Therefore, I believe that Spain is capable. Spain not only has the companies, but it also has highly qualified public officials, public servants who are knowledgeable about the European funds to manage them optimally.

Of course, here, indeed, some reflections have been mixed, both by Hilario and by you, Gabriela, and before that, I would like to thank the EFE agency for allowing us to have spaces for dialogue, as the president of KPMG mentioned earlier, to raise awareness and educate about such fundamental instruments for the modernization of our country.

Evidently, the response that Europe has given to this crisis is completely different from the one provided in 2008, probably because the nature of the crisis is different.

Back then, it was a financial crisis closely linked to a specific sector that then extended to the real estate sector, from a real estate bubble that we had been dragging for some time until it burst in 2008-2009, and today we are talking about a health emergency, a pandemic that is the worst pandemic in the last 100 years of human history and that has indeed affected those countries that are international transit hubs for travelers.

Spain, let us not forget, used to receive around 83 million, 84 million international tourists, and that, evidently, is one of the great strengths of our economy, which became a vulnerability in the face of the pandemic.

We have given a different response. For example, there are the massive debt purchases made by the European Central Bank, which is different from what happened during the international financial crisis of 2008, and from the perspective of the executive power of the member states of the European Commission, what do we think? We think that we had to give a positive response to this pandemic because, indeed, this pandemic has not only called into question our welfare state model, our redistribution policies, fundamentally linked to public health, but secondly, everything related to a process of acceleration as a consequence of the pandemic, of transitions that were already quite evident, especially for the private sector before the pandemic. The ecological transition, to address the climate emergency. Let us not forget that our government’s first decision taken in the Council of Ministers after the investiture process was to declare a climate emergency in our country… so we can see the magnitude of this challenge. Therefore, ecological transition. And secondly, the digital transition: with all the effects it will have on the training, the education of our children, the labor market, the companies…

P: Because it is not only about saving the economy from this bump. It is also about creating a new model of growth, something that we had pending…

PRIME MINISTER: And more integrated and more comprehensive, because I believe that is the key. The key is not only to address the ecological transition and the digital transition, but that those groups that may be more vulnerable, for example, with the digital transition and the automation of jobs, see that this can represent a huge opportunity for progress and employability for themselves. Therefore, the approach of social and territorial integration is fundamental.

One of the things that is not said or that goes a bit under the radar of public debate is that the recovery fund, the agreement from July, is unequivocally a commitment to defend the single market, which is one of the main achievements of European construction. What no country could accept, not only those most affected by the pandemic but also those that were less affected in the first wave, was to have a single market where we had first, second, or third-tier countries. The same happens in Spain. This pandemic cannot serve to create greater social divergence and greater territorial divergence. We have the duty to incorporate, in addition to those two vectors of change, which are of enormous significance, such as the ecological and digital transitions, a perspective of social integration.

That is why we talk about that, in addition to the ecological and digital transitions, three other vectors that will explain all the policies in which we will invest the economic resources linked to the recovery funds will be social cohesion, territorial cohesion, and gender equality. Think, for example, of the gap in representation of the female population, which represents 51 percent in our country, in new technologies, in science, in everything related to STEM disciplines.

I believe that today in Spain that perspective of integration has been incorporated into those two transformation processes, which I think is very relevant. And therefore, indeed, I think that the most important thing, to summarize, is that we give a positive response to a health crisis, first of all, but then, evidently, economic and social.

P: Yes, but notice that you mentioned the 1980s, when the European Union contributed 1 percent of Spanish GDP for years, and this country experienced immense development, and now, however, our capacity to absorb the funds is being questioned. And there is a certain concern about that. What has happened? What have we done wrong lately to reach this situation?

PRIME MINISTER: Well, notice that we are talking about other administrations, not the administration that I currently have the honor of leading, but I want to break a lance in favor of the autonomous governments, also of the municipal governments and public servants. It is true that it is said that we only absorb 38 percent of the funds. It is a half-truth. In reality, it is true that Spain executes all the funds. We have not returned a single euro that has been transferred to us from Brussels because in the end we have been executing them.

It is true that they are not executed in the period that is marked for us, but it is also true that there is a famous terminology called N+3, which is a tail period in which Spain indeed does its homework and absorbs all the resources.

But indeed, as you say, Gabriela, there is a challenge of absorption and also of success in the execution and definition of the projects that we are going to finance.

Evidently, the challenge is that in six years we have increased our potential growth capacity. Therefore, we make sustainable the levels of public debt that we are currently assuming, not only in Spain but in the entire global economy to face the pandemic. Think of the ERTEs, for example, that we signed yesterday and that will entail an additional cost of 5.5 billion euros by May to sustain and protect the jobs of more than 700,000 workers.

Therefore, we are talking about a real capacity for absorption on the part of the institutions, of the Spanish institutional architecture. But evidently, this fund is new, it has characteristics different from the cohesion funds, from the structural funds, from the CAP, which we will also have to manage during this period, because the agreement is not only about the recovery funds, the 140 billion euros over these six years, but also the CAP. Also the programs related to the overall financial framework.

That is why we, what have we done? We have defined a governance structure that has been known with the publication in the BOE of the Royal Decree that we approved on December 30 last year. The decree we are talking about is, well, a true revolution of public administration, and what we do is, in addition to removing bottlenecks that have sometimes hindered the absorption of economic resources from Europe, we establish a governance structure, in some way very linked to civil society and to companies, to the private sector.

First, an inter-ministerial commission where not only members of the Council of Ministers will be present, but also different bodies dependent on Moncloa and other ministries, precisely linked to the Recovery Fund and its management. Secondly, we defined a technical commission made up of senior officials of the General State Administration, precisely…

P: I wanted to ask you about that…

PRIME MINISTER: Later, later… precisely to advise that inter-ministerial commission. We created a sectoral conference led by the Ministry of Finance, precisely to talk with the autonomous communities and define with them other programs linked, for example, to rehabilitation, urban renewal, etc. What we also do is create high-level forums in each of the ministerial departments for dialogue and conversation with the private sector in specific areas: digitalization, ecological transition, artificial intelligence, health, science… And we also create a dialogue table with social agents that met at the beginning of this week and last week, precisely also to identify and explain what not only the funds are, the projects we have in mind, but also the structural reforms we need to address over the next six years.

In short, a complex governance structure, because our state is complex, and looking at the private sector, being very aware that the success in managing these funds will be explained by our public-private collaboration and with a degree of ambition that I believe is maximum regarding the challenges we have ahead and the projects we need to launch.

P: I was asking if we are up to the task; I was referring in general to all public administrations. The perception that citizens may have is of a permanent disconnect, for example, between autonomous communities, between parties. We have seen it during the pandemic. Now it seems that we are not capable of reaching an agreement on closing times, etc. We are already seeing, for example, that in the distribution of funds there is also a small political quarrel. Does this concern you, or do you think it will not be important for us?

PRIME MINISTER: There are several observations I would like to make. The government, what has it always asked for and what has it always practiced? Unity.

We have always said that unity saves companies, saves jobs, and undoubtedly saves lives. And therefore, those political parties that have used the pandemic as an element of confrontation with the government, trying to wear me down or even questioning their own existence, I believe they have found not only the rejection of the parliamentary majority in the Congress of Deputies but also the rejection of the social majority in the country.

Unity has been practiced; it has not only been declared, and I believe it has been reasonably positive throughout these very difficult years, these very difficult and complex months we have had. Notice that, for example, there has been unity in Europe. There is the agreement from July, the recovery funds.

There has been unity with social agents. Just yesterday, the new agreement to extend the ERTEs until the end of May. There has also been, therefore, agreement with social agents. There has been agreement with the autonomous communities; the state of alarm that we are currently extending until May structures what we call governance and also places at the heart of that governance the Interterritorial Policy Council in the field of health.

Today, the Minister of Health is traveling to Seville to hold that meeting with the health counselors. Indeed, there are autonomous communities within the ranges, for example, with the curfew, which have anticipated it to ten at night, while others have had it a little longer.

What I want to say with this is that from the point of view of unity, there has been real and effective unity, much greater than what citizens have sometimes perceived. Even in the Congress of Deputies, there was a commission for Reconstruction where great agreements were reached regarding what the political and economic orientation of that recovery should be, and precisely what has also done is to nourish the work of the ministerial teams around the recovery funds and their definition.

Therefore, I believe that there has been unity. A different question is that, indeed, in this case the main opposition party, but even before the pandemic, has questioned the legitimacy of the government and has not accepted, well, that it is in a parliamentary minority and that it will probably, no, it will surely have to redefine its strategy to make its opposition and its eighty-some seats that it currently has in the Congress of Deputies useful. But there has been unity. You see, sometimes we are our worst ambassadors.

I am referring to the Spaniards. I was just talking with the Minister of Health.

I remember at the beginning of this year, that is, just a few weeks ago, when there was talk of vaccination and there were even difficulties and doubts about what the vaccination rate would be. Well, already, in just a few weeks, almost a million doses have been administered.

We are the second country in the European Union in the administration of doses of the Pfizer vaccine and also of Moderna. Therefore, I believe that Spain has, that is why I say, not only the raw materials but also the sufficient institutional architecture to successfully face this challenge that the pandemic represents in its triple aspect. The health, the economic, and the social.

Q: Don’t you think that adjustments should be made in the power structure or in governance or even in the central government? A government was formed in January 2019 with very different perspectives. Do you think it needs adjustments?

PRESIDENT: With very different perspectives, but more than with perspectives, I would say that with a very different situation, but with perspectives that this pandemic claims.

The investiture program that I presented before the Cortes Generales spoke of a strengthening of the Welfare State, which I believe is one of the main lessons we must draw from this pandemic, that healthcare must be public, free, and universal, that we must strengthen, for example, science, the contribution to science, public contribution, science. We were very clear that we had to address the ecological transition, I reminded you earlier, for example, of the declaration of climate emergency that we approved in the first Council of Ministers of this legislature.

This week we are already about to approve in the parliamentary process the Climate Change Law. We were already talking about the digital transition. We have created a specific State Secretariat for the digital transition. There are two vice presidencies linked before the pandemic, already with the ecological transition and with the digital transition. Therefore, we had a clear perspective. And I also believe that what we have to do is strengthen the institutional architecture that we already have.

That is why what have we done? That governance structure that I described earlier, we have reinforced, also inspired by the case of Singapore, with a unit for monitoring the execution and definition of those recovery funds in the cabinet of La Moncloa, led by Manolo de la Rocha. We have created a general directorate in the Ministry of Finance, precisely for the recovery mechanism.

We have created this technical commission where there will not only be, let’s say, a single body of the General State Administration and senior technicians, but it will be, let’s say, a multidisciplinary committee where there will be experts in bidding, where there will be experts in European funds, where there will be experts in some of the fundamental areas, digitalization, ecological transition.

Q: That Committee would be federal, let’s say…

PRESIDENT: No, no, it will not be a committee that will advise the inter-ministerial commission in which the president of the government or the ministries of all the ministries of the Council are part, and also some secretaries of state or general secretariats linked to the definition and execution of these recovery funds.

The federal part rests in that sectoral commission that will be led by the Minister of Finance and that will logically meet with the counselors designated by the Autonomous Communities.

In that technical commission, we leave the door open to the private sector, that is, that there are expert individuals in certain areas, that it is necessary to count on them so that they can join us and help us in this complex but also exciting challenge to make that leap of modernity that I believe our country needs.

Q: I invite you, Mr. President, to listen to Pepe Álvarez, who is the general secretary of UGT and who also reflects on the improvement in management, because in the end we are risking a lot.

"This is a great opportunity for Spain. The funds for reconstruction after Covid are a fundamental instrument to change the productive system of our country, both from the point of view of digitalization and from the point of view of improving and quality of employment, as well as trying to improve our public services. That is why we demand from the Government transparency, clarity, and participation. That trade union organizations participate in the processes, both in the projects that can be presented by companies and by public administrations, as a guarantee that we will achieve those objectives."

PRESIDENT: No, I cannot disagree with what the general secretary of UGT has said. In fact, in these budgets that we have fortunately already pushed forward for the year 2021, we recognize the contribution of social agents by incorporating a specific item to finance their participation in the management and definition of these recovery funds. I believe that one of the main, let’s say, of the main lessons we have drawn in these long twelve months of pandemic is the responsibility and sense of country and commitment to the common good that social agents, trade unions, and employers have. Just yesterday we saw it again precisely with this extension of the ERTEs, this extension of the ERTEs until the end of May.

Therefore, I can only share what the general secretary of UGT says, and allow me to also claim that the Government of Spain believes it not only in words but in action. We have created different social dialogue tables. One of the social dialogue tables is precisely the one that has to do with the recovery fund. Last week they met, at the beginning of this week they have also been meeting to announce what the reform plan presented yesterday to the European Commission is. A reform plan that incorporates around 170 structural reforms, that is the level of ambition that the Government of Spain has in all areas.

It is true that the media rightly focus on the labor area or on the pensions area, but we are making reforms linked to training, education, public administration, digitalization, artificial intelligence, and ecological transition.

During these twelve months, if one looks at what the legislative and executive balance has been, for example, in the area of ecological transition, I believe that the turnaround has been an unprecedented 180-degree turnaround in the area of ambition, with the circular economy strategy, with the climate change law, with all the reforms we are making in the energy sector, with the defense of biodiversity.

In short, I believe that we have a very compact, well-thought-out, and well-elaborated reform agenda, as the general secretary of UGT, Pepe, says, with them, because I believe that the approach that reforms must have the greatest possible consensus to endure is, I believe, the best of approaches.

And notice the European Commission, as we have talked with them in this almost daily dialogue about the definition of the fund and structural reforms, one of the issues they always raise is that they should not be imposed reforms, but reforms that have a prolongation over time and therefore count with the greatest possible consensus. And this is what we are promoting.

Q: I would like to get a little more down to earth. You talk about driving policies, right? For this, it is necessary to launch projects so that others benefit from European funds, very specific projects. What would be your project or a couple of projects if you can mention them, that you think are ideal, that align very well with what Brussels wants or what we want?

PRESIDENT: Well, the important thing is to first know that the Government of Spain believes that there are a series of horizontal vectors to any type of policy that we are going to implement or projects that are going to be financed within the framework of the recovery fund.

I said it at the beginning of the interview. First of all, the ecological transition. That is, the perspective of the impact it may have on climate change is fundamental. Secondly, what has to do with digitalization, therefore, everything that promotes the training of workers in digitalization, the push for digitalization within companies, all of that will logically also count with, let’s say, a plus.

And thirdly, that integrative perspective to which I referred earlier. For us, this is fundamental. The ecological transition does not involve four companies; it involves the whole of society. The digital transition cannot benefit a minority in the elite; it must benefit the entire population. It cannot be perceived as a risk, as it is right now for many workers with low or intermediate qualifications as a consequence of the automation process.

Therefore, we will give a very important priority and prevalence to the perspective of social and territorial integration and gender when evaluating and qualifying those projects. Projects that will compete in a competitive bidding process, if I may say so. That is to say, we will not reward one company or another, but it will be that technical committee that filters, that evaluates based on these parameters that I have explained.

Therefore, those are the four or five horizontal axes, and from there, if you ask me about sectors that need that transformation, just yesterday I was at the Council of the World Tourism Organization, a very competitive sector, but one that also needs to gain in competitiveness. Incorporating perspectives linked to sustainability and digitalization, and obviously the tourism sector, which represents around 12% of our Gross Domestic Product, will be a sector that we will logically bet on.

The automotive sector in a much broader concept, which is that of sustainable mobility. It is evident that the mobility sector is transforming, not only in the area of digitalization but also in the energy of electrification and electric vehicles. Everything related to green hydrogen, everything related to 5G technology, everything related to electric vehicles, with lithium batteries, which by the way, we have natural resources linked to that. All of that is what we are going to bet on. There will logically be emblematic projects, as all countries will do, for that we have created a very specific figure of public-private collaboration called, in its acronym, PERTES, and there will obviously be other types of projects that will also be specifically chosen with these four or five vectors to which I previously referred.

Q: There has been a certain debate about the PERTES, precisely because some believe that the initiative should come from the private sector and others believe that it should come from the public sector and even accuse the Government of actually going more towards the latter, that is, that the public sector should guide the projects. How do you see that debate?

PRESIDENT: A few months ago, before the end of the year, I had an opportunity in Alcobendas, in the city of Alcobendas, to present the Country Missions, the Country Missions that are within the framework of the CDTI, are missions linked, for example, to artificial intelligence, linked to biomedicine, linked to scientific research. Both the country missions and the PERTES are inspired by the idea of Mariana Mazzucato of the entrepreneurial state, that there is a market failure and that market failure is that there are some changes in our economy that will have a high impact both on our potential growth and on job creation and therefore, the progress and prosperity of our countries that take into account or suffer, rather, to use a much more precise verb, from underinvestment in the private sector. Think, for example, of green hydrogen or batteries for electric vehicles or 5G technology or microchips or satellites.

There are a series of issues that we need to address, such as the cloud, for example, which is another of the projects being proposed at the European level. We need to tackle it with a public-private collaboration, where the contribution of public investment is also significant.

That is why we believe in the philosophy of the entrepreneurial state, as proposed by Mariana Mazzucato. We present it with these Country Missions and we present it with the PERTES. The PERTES are basically a public-private collaboration instrument, which will consist of three steps.

The first is the determination of which projects the Government of Spain wants to get involved in as a, let’s say, leading actor before citing some examples, such as electric vehicles, batteries, or to mention another, everything related to green hydrogen.

Therefore, the determination of which are those, let’s say, projects or plans that we want to join as a leading actor together with private companies. Along with that determination, the identification of the companies that may be interested in co-leading those projects with the State, and finally the materialization of those projects.

The materialization of the projects will be public-private collaboration formulas, investment vehicles, agreements, partnerships of companies, in short. Then we will see along the way what precisely the vehicle we use is. But the central idea is that there are projects that will define the degree of competitiveness, potential growth, and massive job creation in certain sectors where there is a market failure, because there is underinvestment from the private sector that needs to be covered and complemented by the public sector, and we are willing to get involved, and that is a bit the philosophy of both the Country Missions that we are doing through CDTI, which are having an extraordinary reception in the private sector, and I believe that this formula will also have an extraordinary reception in the private sector when we put it into action.

Q.- Mr. de la Rocha also mentioned the other day a very interesting, very original formula, which was the State as a co-investor with private companies. Would it be only for certain products or for the long term?

PRESIDENT.- For certain projects and also with that idea of competitive bidding. That is to say, when we determine those projects and then identify the companies, we are obviously covered by a legal framework that we must comply with, which is the competition policy dictated by Brussels. But within that framework, I believe there is enough space for us to identify companies that, in free competition, decide to compete and support this type of projects.

Indeed, then, in that materialization of how we can, let’s say, implement that public-private collaboration, what we are going to do is co-invest. We will co-invest both the public sector and the private sector.

And I believe that in that collaboration, we all win. The private sector wins, especially the companies and the workers, and the public sector also wins, because the public sector innovates, learns from those innovation processes, and can incorporate them into its day-to-day operations, both in the present and in the future.

Q.- You spoke earlier about tourism. Are we doomed to a total reconversion of tourism? We have seen that we have suffered so much from the pandemic because of this. Right now, as we are in the pandemic, it seems impossible for us to recover such an important sector, you yourself said, 12 percent of GDP. What can be done? Diversify, for example, the risks as a country, promote other sectors that really are, let’s say, counterbalance these losses?

PRESIDENT.- Well, I believe that when we talk about ecological transition or reduction and adaptation to climate change or we talk, for example, about digitalization, we are not talking about abstract facts; they have to materialize and land. That is why, for us, ecological transition or digital transition are not sectoral policies; they are transversal policies, like the approach to social, territorial, and gender integration of those two transitions in sectoral policies.

And the tourism sector, well, it is evident that when we are talking, for example, about mitigation and adaptation to climate change, tourist destinations will also have to adapt to that climatic reality, to adverse climatic phenomena like those we are experiencing in a good part of the Iberian Peninsula this week with the storm Filomena or to high temperatures as they are accustomed to, or the DANAs, as they are unfortunately accustomed to in many provinces and regions in the Mediterranean basin.

Of course, all of this means that promenades, to make it clearer for citizens, may have to be retracted as a consequence of the rise in sea level. That even the very materials with which we build communication infrastructures, such as railways, are more resilient to the adverse effects of climate change.

Tourist destinations that were built and were very successful in the Spanish Levante during the period of development and even during the dictatorship, in the 60s and also the early democracy in the 70s and 80s, were built with materials that did not take into account the effects of climate change.

All of this is what we have to do, because the change in the culture of tourists and the degree of demand from tourists regarding comfort and respect for the environment is fortunately increasing.

And I believe that these are issues that we have to logically incorporate into our sectors, because in the end, they will define the competitiveness of sectors that are so important for our economy, such as the tourism sector.

Q: I would like to talk about reforms. We also have the participation through a video from Antonio Garamendi, who is the president of the Spanish employers' association, who precisely touches on this topic.

(Video intervention by Antonio Garamendi. "We must also keep in mind those reforms that must go hand in hand with the arrival of funds as our European partners ask us. Therefore, I believe it is very important to keep that duality in mind, that work we have to do in Spain, in the sense of aligning the reforms, those practically 170 reforms that the Government has proposed, which it is working on, with those recovery funds that have to come to Spain. There, we entrepreneurs want to be present. We believe that Spanish companies can contribute a lot in this field. Of course, within the four areas of digitalization, sustainability, inclusion, and also all the area of equality. Therefore, I believe that this is something important, but we are also very clear that we would like to work especially on investment. Europe itself tells us that those funds that go to investment have a much greater trajectory, practically double that of those funds that may go to current spending.")

PRESIDENT: Well, I absolutely agree. I believe that the great opportunity we have... recently, precisely the Economic Department of Moncloa sent me a report from the International Monetary Fund on the level of public investment that Spain has had over the last fifteen or twenty years. And it is quite symptomatic to see how many of the difficulties our country has faced in addressing the pending transformations are highly related to our scarcity of resources for public investment.

To give you an idea, since the financial crisis, public investment levels in our country plummeted, and that ultimately has tied our hands to make these major transformations to which I previously referred, whether it is ecological transition, digital transition, and giving it that inclusive perspective.

Therefore, I fully share the president of the CEOE, to whom I also thank for his work, as well as that of CEPYME, and of Comisiones Obreras, and UGT logically, the approach he makes. What we want is for these investments to serve to increase our potential growth, because if we increase our potential growth, we will be reducing one of our main Achilles' heels, one of the problems we have, which is the lack of productivity, low productivity in our country. And we will also be equipping our economy to make the level of public debt sustainable, which unfortunately we have had to address over the last twelve months to deal with the pandemic.

One of the perspectives we have always taken into account is that, since we are going into debt because we have to protect the private sector, as a consequence of the lockdowns we have had to implement or the closures of sectors we have had to make due to the contagion curve, we have said, well, if we have to go into debt, let future generations who will pay this debt with taxes be the result of an effort we are making today to leave a much more sustainable planet and a much more competitive economy in the medium term.

This is also a bit the philosophy from the perspective of intergenerational justice that we incorporate into our economic policy. And indeed, I believe that the president of the CEOE puts it correctly. I believe we need to make reforms. The Government of Spain has proposed 170 reforms to the European Commission. That is not a small number. In six years, 170 reforms, from vocational training that the Minister of Education and Vocational Training is already addressing, to everything related to the energy sector, ecological transition. And undoubtedly, also rebuilding consensus.

I believe that one of the lessons we need to learn from the previous crisis is that reforms or rather, counter-reforms were imposed against social dialogue. And I give an example now that we are talking about the public pension system. Notice that the reform imposed by the absolute majority of the Popular Party in Mariano Rajoy's first legislature, with 186 seats, was a reform that broke social dialogue because it was done against part of social dialogue, in this case, the representatives of the workers. It had an absolute majority from a single parliamentary group, which was the Popular Party, but when we moved to the next legislature, the second legislature of Mr. Rajoy, and therefore he no longer had that absolute majority, in the end, they themselves had to suspend the application of that reform. The sustainability factor they introduced, the famous 0.25% to approve the budgets, they had to suspend the application of that factor. Why? Because the rest of the parliamentary groups did not want to apply that reform. Therefore, I believe that the concession made by the European Commission that reforms should have as much social and parliamentary consensus as possible is fundamental, because it will ensure that reforms endure. Otherwise, we will be at the mercy of changing parliamentary majorities depending on what citizens vote.

I believe it is important to generate those consensuses. I believe that there is a broad majority in the Congress of Deputies and also in social dialogue, at least we saw it in the previous legislature, to make modifications to our current labor framework. And also to leave behind a pension reform from 2013 that did not have social agreement, nor does it have the parliamentary majority to move it forward.

Q: The problem with these reforms is that there are opposing interests, right? For example, in labor reform, I don’t know if we could delve a little more into that, since we are in the short and medium term, what to do. There are three issues that I believe are substantial in these reforms that Brussels is also asking for. One of them, for example, the ERTEs. You have mentioned that they will be in place until May. Is the Government really considering proposing that ERTEs be a permanent tool for times of crisis?

PRESIDENT: Yes. And before answering this, Gabriela, allow me to speak in favor of, because it gives the impression, it is true that we come from another crisis, the financial crisis, which left us with a residue of disbelief, I would even say distrust. The reforms that the European Commission asks of Spain and all countries are public reforms, that is, they are known reforms. They are recommendations that countries make annually and that are linked. To give you an idea, for example, the Minimum Vital Income that we have approved. That is a structural reform, applauded by the European Commission, long recommended by the European Commission to Spain for many years; that we had to improve the levels of social protection for the most vulnerable groups, that the autonomous approach that was being made was not working except in some regions, particularly in the Basque Country and Navarra, and that, therefore, it was necessary to make a structural reform that would address this problem of social exclusion, which is very serious in our country. Remember that in our country, unfortunately, we have two and a half million children suffering from child poverty. And the Minimum Vital Income is closely linked to fighting and eradicating child poverty.

Therefore, that is a structural reform that Brussels is asking of us. I say this because it gives the impression that it is a room, a room without windows, where the European Commission tells us what we have to do. No, no, this is a process of dialogue, where they make their recommendations, they are published every year and are known by the media, by political parties, and by private operators. Therefore, there is no secret in this.

And secondly, in relation to the labor sphere. I believe that one of the great lessons we have to draw from this is that ERTEs have come to stay. I think it is one of the great innovations that we have incorporated in the response to the crisis by the current Government, inspired by the example of other economies, such as the Danish and the German, to name two examples.

We have fought at the European level, and in this I want to recognize the work of Vice President Nadia Calviño in the Eurogroup for creating a fund, let's say, for unemployment reinsurance. Right now we are financing ERTEs precisely with those resources that come to us from Europe. Thanks to that agreement that, among others, Nadia Calviño led in the Eurogroup, and therefore, I believe that what we have to do is be aware that this is a structural reform, that it is an alternative to dismissal, which is what has generally been opted for when things have gone wrong in our economy.

Let us remember what happened in the previous crisis, in the financial crisis, and probably what we have to do is clearly define what the financing instruments are, the contributions from companies, the public sector, the workers themselves, and also training. That is to say, how during the time that workers remain in ERTE, they can be retrained to continue being or guaranteeing employability in the sector in which they are employed.

Q: Perhaps there are two topics that are a little more contentious, which are that the sectoral agreement is above the company agreement or the "ultra activity" of the agreements. There, companies and workers are more involved. Do you also want to touch on that? Do you think it is important to tweak that? You promised to withdraw what was most harmful to workers.

PRESIDENT: I think that institutionalizing and reinforcing the institutional architecture linked to collective bargaining is always good, always good. It is good for social peace, it is good for labor stability, and also for the certainty of companies.

Those countries that we look to as examples precisely have very consolidated collective bargaining structures, very consolidated, for example, Germany or, for example, the Nordic countries. And therefore, this is a government that clearly bets on collective bargaining, bets on reinforcing the institutionalization of collective bargaining, for balance in negotiation between workers and employers.

I believe that these issues, when one goes into detail and speaks precisely with employers, the differences are not so wide. On the contrary, I believe that there is a very broad territory of consensus. I am convinced that we will be able to achieve it.

Q: The pension reform, which does directly concern public money, let's say. Are you really considering extending the years of computation for retirement?

PRESIDENT: Today the Minister has denied this issue again. I believe that regarding pensions, first, we must recognize that this is a transcendental debate. This is a debate I would say is central to our coexistence in the social sphere. We are talking about a keystone of our welfare state. We are talking about instruments of intragenerational and intergenerational justice. When we talk precisely about the public pension system, we are talking above all, not about today's pensioners, but about how to guarantee a dignified retirement for today's workers and tomorrow's pensioners. Therefore, we are talking about a central issue that requires broad consensus.

That is why I reminded you earlier of the reform that was imposed in 2013 against the social agents and against many political groups, including the Socialist Party at that time.

And also, when the absolute majority that the Popular Party lost occurred, in the second term of President Rajoy, it was unable to apply it because it no longer had parliamentary groups to support that reform that it imposed with its 186 seats in the first term.

Therefore, what we want is to guarantee the greatest possible consensus and, in fact, that consensus has been achieved, it was achieved in the Toledo Pact a few months ago, where the lines of reform of that public pension system were already indicated: the commitment to guarantee the purchasing power of pensioners, the commitment also to equate real and effective retirement, something that is still a pending task in our country, the commitment to improve the contributiveness of the pension system, because evidently right now in Social Security there are policies that Social Security pays for, but that are not specific to Social Security, the commitment also that self-employed workers contribute based on their real income, the commitment also to maternity, in parental and maternity leave. In short, I believe that there is broad consensus around which we want to work, and I think it would be good to have the greatest possible consensus from all political forces. I believe that Minister Escrivá is working in that direction and I believe that with considerable solvency and empathy.

Q: Could it be a phased reform, over time, and making changes there?

PRESIDENT: Well, I think that is what has happened in recent years, except, indeed, for this reform imposed in 2013, right? Let us remember that there was another reform in 2011 that had the agreement of the social agents, right? That was, indeed, a reform made by another administration, in this case by President Zapatero, right? But previously there have been other reforms that have been made, right? If one looks at what has been the work that has been carried out regarding the updating and reform of our public pension system, we have been, by far, much more ambitious than other countries. There are countries that are now debating the integration of special regimes. We have already done that work, in fact, we are currently considering how to incorporate self-employed workers into this dynamic, with this commitment to adjust their contributions to their real income.

Notice that if one looks at what percentage we allocate to our public pension system in terms of GDP, we are talking about 12% of our GDP, therefore, it is reasonable for, let’s say, the number of retired people we have and in comparison with other countries, we are relatively much better off.

I believe that we have room, that we have things clear. I mean, not only the government but also the social agents and political actors about what the keys should be to guarantee the sustainability of pensions. And well, this is another of the debates we have.

But notice, this is a debate that we were going to have with or without a pandemic. What seems important to me to emphasize is that the pandemic… we cannot focus the debate only on pension reform, there are many other reforms that we have to implement, in addition to a reform that is always pending to be updated recurrently as a consequence of the demographic evolution of our country.

Q: Yes, well, these are other forms that are more complicated, more complex. Well, we know that Brussels has conditioned the money to that and as Mr. Garamendi has said, it will somewhat be aligned with the reforms with the release of funds, and so it makes sense, right?

PRESIDENT: Yes, but I insist, the reforms are multidisciplinary. The reform of our public pension system is something that we had to do, that we are going to do, that we have to do with social and political consensus. And that is the, let’s say, the premise and the attitude with which the Government of Spain starts, right?

Q: I invite you, finally, to listen to Unai Sordo, who is the Secretary General of Comisiones Obreras, who speaks of the concern about returning to austerity, of the concern about whether this could have a setback at some point.

(Video Unai Sordo: The European reconstruction funds can be a magnificent opportunity for Spain. They can be because they allow our country to implement expansive spending policies over the next six years. And this is very important to get out of the serious economic crisis that the coronavirus has led us to. And, on the other hand, because they are linked to conditions that have nothing to do with those that existed in the previous crisis and that caused an internal devaluation. They are conditions linked to the energy and ecological transition, to the digitalization of the economy, and to the strengthening of our public services. From this point of view, they are a magnificent opportunity, if used well, and the greatest concern that we at Comisiones Obreras have with these funds has to do with their being used in a biased, tortuous way, to seek a conditionality that serves to maintain the austerity reforms, which is not what they say. European institutions must serve to improve our productive fabric. They must serve to improve the quality of our jobs. They must serve to get out of the crisis with inclusive growth that without these funds would have been much more difficult).

PRESIDENT: I totally agree, I believe that competitiveness, and this is one of the great lessons of the financial crisis of 2008, can only be guaranteed if a perspective of cohesion and integration is given to our society. One cannot have sustainable growth over time by expelling and excluding people from that growth and that prosperity. I believe that this is something that makes sense, especially after what happened in the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009, the consequences of which we are still suffering in terms of inequality. Spain, unfortunately, is still a very unequal country, and the most eloquent example I mentioned earlier is that of child poverty. But I think it is also important to be aware that we have to channel and direct those resources into investments that allow for the growth potential of our economy.

That is what we have to do, improve our potential growth, improve our productivity, reduce the very high levels of unemployment that we have. And for that, we obviously have to strengthen in terms of competitiveness, the driving sectors of our economy, the tourism sector is one, the automotive sector is also one, promoting the digital and ecological transitions, from a perspective of social and gender integration and territorial, which is what we want.

Notice that when we talk about recovery funds, you mentioned it earlier, there are autonomous communities that talk about their projects and I always tell them that the Government of Spain will have competitive bidding in this. Now, the perspective of territorial integration and therefore the territorial structuring of the country and the European Union will be crucial. Those projects that we can design in collaboration with other countries or between regions will logically cover that perspective of territorial cohesion to which I referred earlier.

And then there is an element that Unai incorporates and that I share, which is indeed that of austerity. Let's see, in economic policy what we need to do are counter-cyclical policies. When the economy falls, what we need to do is boost public investment. And when the economy grows vigorously, we hope, moreover, that this year will be the year of great recovery, thanks to that great transformation, which will come from the recovery funds, it is evident that we will have to address, well, the debate on the sustainability of public debt in our country and its reduction, logically addressing the public deficit and continuing to strengthen our welfare state. Does it seem like an impossible equation? It is not. For that, we will need to ensure a much more solid, much more vigorous potential growth than we have now. And secondly, I believe that when the time comes, when the time comes, which is not now, but when we recover the levels of GDP and growth prior to the pandemic, it is evident that another of the structural reforms we will have to make will be tax reform. We will have to carry out a tax reform. And look, that tax reform will also have to promote tax harmonization in European terms.

If we are in a single market, it cannot be that there are countries that clearly engage in fiscal dumping against other countries. And those are the pending debates we have in the European Union and that, logically, the Government of Spain is willing to lead. And again, it is evident that with digitalization, debates arise, even, with the confinement we are seeing and the pandemic, debates about the contribution that digital platforms make to the contribution and sustainability of the welfare state.

We are one of the first countries that have implemented the financial transaction tax, as well as taxation on digital platforms, platforms that do not pay taxes in the countries where they operate.

And I believe that this is a debate we need to clarify and materialize at the OECD level and if not at the European level, and for Spain to be at the forefront of those debates, well, it also seems to me that it says a lot about our society, that what it also wants for there to be social justice is for there to be fiscal justice, that is, that not only the self-employed pay taxes, that not only small and medium-sized businesses pay taxes, but that also, well, within the restrictions we have in this global economy, the large digital corporations contribute, because evidently, if one looks at the evolution of the stock market, the values, the levels of capitalization that large digital platforms have, especially after this pandemic, well, it evidently has to lead us all the governments of the world to a reflection.

Q.- Thank you very much, Madam President. Before finishing, if you allow me, I would like to ask you a couple of current questions. The first one about the elections in Catalonia. The Catalan government has just said that it fears that participation, if the elections are held on February 14, will be very low and therefore they will be delegitimized. What do you think about this issue of postponing the elections? Do you think it is really important? Do you think it should be done now, in February?

PRESIDENT.- What is the objective of any government? The Catalan, the Spanish, the Madrid government. Any government right now in the world. The first is to vaccinate, vaccinate, and vaccinate. That is what the Government of Spain is doing and what the regional governments are doing. And secondly, the recovery and the transformation and modernization of our economy.

I believe that Catalonia has a great opportunity. It has a great opportunity to become, to establish itself as one of the leading regions of economic recovery in our country and of the modernization of our country. But for that, Catalonia needs as soon as possible a government with full powers, with full competencies. That is what the unions have done, that is what the employers in Catalonia have said, and that is what some Catalan political forces have said.

Therefore, I as president of the Government, what I would like is for this crisis of governability, which also opened with President Torra in statements he made a year ago, last year, when he said that the Government was exhausted in Catalonia, well, for this crisis of governability to be resolved as soon as possible. That the Catalans can elect a government that can address the task of economic recovery with full competencies and the task of the reunion to which both the Catalan government and the Spanish government are called.

Unfortunately, this decision made by the Generalitat has not had the consensus of the political parties, also with the opposition of employers and unions in Catalonia, has ended up in the Superior Court of Justice of Catalonia and I believe that what we have to assume is the decision made, in this case, by the Superior Court of Justice of Catalonia.

Q.- Today there is a change in the White House, a nearly historic change. What do you expect, what are your perspectives for the Biden era?

PRESIDENT.- I believe that the year 2020, if you allow me, Gabriela, has been a year that has left us very few good news.

I believe there have been three very good pieces of news. The first, the vaccine. The second, the European response, which we have been talking about at length today, the agreement from July on the recovery fund. And third, the elections in the United States.

I believe that Biden's victory represents the victory of democracy over the far right and its three methods, which are mass deception, national division, and the trampling, even violently as we have seen in the scenes at the Capitol, of democratic institutions.

And I also believe that we must draw a conclusion in the form of a warning for all democrats in the world. And that is that the far right finds roots and social support, probably due to confusion, without a doubt also due to the social exclusion to which I previously referred that all governments must address.

Five years ago, we probably all thought that Trump was a bad joke, but five years later we have realized that he has put at risk, questioning, nothing more and nothing less than the most powerful democracy in the world. Therefore, I believe that this is one of the lessons we must draw for all democrats in the world.

And certainly, one of the reflections I made at the beginning of this week publicly is that we are willing to participate in that call made by President Biden to all democracies in the world around a great reflection in the form of a convention on how to articulate and strengthen what are the foundations of our coexistence, which is tolerance, respect, and clean rules of the game as those that evidently President Trump has called into question after the elections last November.

Q.- Yes, to finish, are you going to miss Merkel?

PRESIDENT.- Well, I must say that she certainly has my respect and admiration. I believe that Merkel... Look at what has happened in this semester of German presidency, right? The Brexit agreement has been closed positively. The recovery fund agreement has been closed. We faced a very important veto from Poland and Hungary to approve the same. The multiannual financial framework has been approved, where the agro-industrial sector, for example in Spain, livestock and fishing, the CAP in short, is essential, but also for the financing of universities, of Erasmus programs, in short, all of that. And well, we have also articulated a common response from all member states to negotiate with the large pharmaceutical companies and guarantee equitable access for the entire European population to vaccination against the coronavirus. So I believe that if Merkel has demonstrated anything, it is precisely the foundations of a leadership I would say is cooperative and also transformative.

And as a conclusion, I would say that if Helmut Kohl at his time represented the chancellor of German unification, I believe that we can say that Merkel has been the chancellor of European unification.

Q.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.