Joint press conference with President of the Government and President of the French Republic, Emmanuel Macron

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

23 June 2018 · Paris, France

Context
Sánchez held a joint press conference with President Macron in Paris on 23 June 2018 ahead of a Brussels EU summit, marking his first official presidential visit abroad.
Main themes
EU reform and relaunch, Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, migration challenge, economic and monetary union, Eurozone budget, European unity, climate and environment, future EU summits, Meseberg agreement, Spain's new government foreign policy
Duration
~53 min
95th percentile
Words
6,414
95th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
35
25th percentile
Grade
17.4
91st percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

172 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, I believe that this first meeting has been very fruitful and that it is the firm intention of our two countries to act together to reactivate Europe. Mr President of the Government, dear Pedro, thank you for having taken the initiative and having accepted my invitation to come to Paris today for this friendly exchange of opinions and joint work before seeing each other again tomorrow in Brussels as well as at the end of next week in Brussels.

Thank you very much for your visit and this exchange of opinions.

President of the Government .- I wanted, firstly, to thank the President of the French Republic for his kind words, his interest in meeting up and holding this first official visit of my presidency at the head of the Government of Spain in a neighbouring country, a partner country on a great many policies that the President of the French Government put on the table and, of course, an ally. I believe that this is the most important thing I wanted to say to you about a meeting that has been very fruitful - as the President of the French rightly pointed out - and a meeting we intend to repeat, and which we will repeat very shortly and, in this regard, I would like to thank the President of the French Republic for accepting to hold a similar meeting to the one we have held here in Paris, on 26 July, in Madrid between the two of us before attending the meeting that we will also hold with the Portuguese Prime Minister to talk about interconnections. Hence, President of the Republic, it is a pleasure and an honour for us to host a meeting with you in Madrid on 26 July and, of course, to continue talking about many of the questions raised here by President Macron.

I would like to convey the firm commitment of the Government of Spain to the European cause and to many of the policies that President Macron has announced to us during the press conference. President Macron has spoken on some occasions about the need to re-launch the European Project, about the need to build a Europe that protects its citizens at an economic, social and employment level, and also in relation to the environment. And, the Government of Spain could not agree more with this vision, with this goal, with this political intent set by President Macron. We want to see a stronger Europe, we want Europe to respond to many of the global challenges that you will most likely raise in your questions following this press conference and which have obviously been the subject of debate between the French and Spanish delegations here today.

The first issue, logically, is related to the challenge of migration; the second is related to the challenge of how to integrate our economic and monetary policies and how to tackle or, at least, how to prepare our continent and the EU to address potential economic crises that may break out in the future and subsequently we addressed bilateral relations between our two governments. Hence, we firmly believe in Europe and the attitude that the Government of Spain will adopt - the new Government of Spain - at the Summit to be held in Brussels tomorrow and also in Brussels at the end of next week, will be proactive and constructive, it will revolve around underlying those elements on which the Member States are united and hold a common position. We are not going to underline the differences which public opinion has become all too aware of in recent years. We want to underscore where there is agreement and be aware of and send out a clear message to European public opinion that it is only by being stronger and more united that we will be able to respond to these global challenges. Hence, unity makes us stronger whereas the breakdown of countries makes us weaker when it comes to trying to respond to these global challenges.

In this regard, President Macron is aware of this but I would also like to state this, the Government of Spain firmly supports the Meseberg agreement signed between the Governments of France and Spain. We believe, and we have been asking the European Union for this for many years now, that all of the EU Member States need, and the Economic and Monetary Union needs, not only the monetary pillar but also the fiscal pillar, we need a European Budget, we need a budget for the Eurozone, we need a fiscal response as well as a monetary response in order to address a potential crisis, and consequently, President Macron can count on the support, not only vocally, but also privately, as well as publicly, in relation to a step which, in my opinion, has been late in coming but which, logically, was necessary to take and, in this regard, I greatly thank President Macron for his leadership and also the German Government which managed to sign this important agreement for the European construction project.

We - you are aware that for many years we have supported the creation of this Eurozone Budget - also ask the President of the French Republic and the rest of our European colleagues not to forget the Banking Union; the Banking Union is also important. We must continue taking steps on this matter but clearly what I would like to convey to European public opinion as a whole is that the Government of Spain, on the eve of this Euro Summit to be held next week, will try and work hard and intensely to ensure that there is a clear, firm, unequivocal mandate from a political point of view for bringing the agreement signed between the French and German Governments into force sooner rather than later.

I have asked the President of the French Republic for a country as important as Spain, that wishes to take part and deserves to play the part that falls to it within the European Union, to also be included in drafting more technical and specific issues that will undoubtedly be important in the coming weeks.

As regards migration, President Macron summed this up well. Of course, for our part, we have expressed our gratitude publicly, I did this in Madrid, we have publicly thanked the solidarity and responsibility with which the French Government has acted and the help it has provided the Government of Spain in the decision taken on the vessel 'Aquarius'. I want to thank President Macron for his solidarity; we have always felt in Spain that the phenomenon of migration is a challenge that affects our countries as a whole, not only border countries and, in this regard, it has been fundamental to receive and sense the support of the French Government.

I agree that migratory policy must be common, I agree that migratory policy should be based on solidarity, on responsibility, on respect for human rights, for human beings who unfortunately need to flee and leave their countries in search of a better future; hence, for the Government of Spain respect for human rights is fundamental. And we must also clearly strengthen bilateral cooperation with the countries of origin and transit and, in this regard, we have spoken over the course of our working lunch and we clearly support, as is only fitting, the joint proposal by France, Spain and Italy to resolve the question of the vessel that is currently off the Italian coast.

And finally, and President Macron said this earlier, I want to reaffirm that the Government of Spain is committed to all the policies related to defence, which this Government of Spain is currently heading up in the Sahel and in Africa. Secondly, and I have said this to the President of the French Republic, it is the Government of Spain's intention to sign up to this European intervention initiative. And thirdly, we have spoken about interconnections, the President of the French Republic and I even joked about the energy connections between France and Spain that we have been talking about for decades. Let's hope we can start to resolve this question which is key; the truth is that I have found the President of the French Republic to be someone with an indubitable executive ability and, consequently, I have no doubts that he will help us, not only Spain but also Portugal, to guarantee and improve energy security and the President of the Republic said something very important, which I will mention by way of closing, and that is the importance of this energy interconnection, this energy inter-connectivity, and it is also important to boost renewable energies, and to comply with the goals set by both our countries in relation to climate change and, in short, with clean energies. This is obviously the goal of the Government of Spain, our goal of boosting this commitment to renewable energies, and compliance with our commitments on climate change, and I know that here in Paris and, furthermore, upon a proposal from the French Government a Summit was set up to monitor the Paris Agreement and, in this regard, I also want to underline the undoubted commitment of the Socialist Government.

In short, I believe that many issues were on the table today, the political agenda that I believe the Governments of Spain and France share is extensive and, I hope, of course, President Macron, that this is just the first of many meetings we will hold in the future - the next will be on 26 July in Madrid - and hence I would like to thank you for your disposition.

Mr. Macron .- Thank you very much, President of the Government. Any questions?

Q .- My name is María Caru, from Radio Nacional . I wanted to ask the two of you whether you are in favour or not of the proposal made by the European Council to set up migrant centres or disembarkation platforms outside of the European Union to manage their asylum rights. The President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, has told us that he hopes Italy will accept his proposal, and the proposal from Italy, France and Spain on the vessel 'Lifeline' which is looking for a port at this time. Could you specify what this specific proposal entails?

And for the President of the Government, many rafts have arrived in Spain in the last few hours with hundreds of migrants aboard. Have you, or has someone in your government, spoken with the Moroccan Government to try and stop this phenomenon?

Mr. Macron .- Perhaps returning to these recurring themes encourages us to make a statement on the proposed external platform, as the proposal by President Tusk is called, under conditions which, if I remember rightly, have still not been debated by the Member States, based on the proposal drawn up today which will also be on the agenda of tomorrow's preparatory conference, which is also different from another proposal that has been made by some ministers and Heads of State or Government of other EU countries which was called the cornerstone some time back.

We have spoken a great deal about centres and platforms but they are two different concepts. What the President of the Council, Donald Tusk, proposes is to have platforms in countries of transit outside of the European Union. This is an issue we hope to make progress on tomorrow and which seems very important to me. This echoes the proposal of the High Commissioner for Refugees (HCR), who proposes this type of solution, as I also did a few weeks ago; this was even echoed in a meeting held here on 28 August last year. It is a question of setting up platforms with the presence of the High Commissioner for Refugees, that is, the United Nations, with the additional presence of the UN organisation for migration - the IOM - which would allow migration to be analysed while protecting those people in a country of transit and in collaboration with all those agencies tasked with asylum procedures, particularly European bodies. This would thus allow asylum to be guaranteed, with asylum protection for these people to then be taken to another European country, while all those who are not entitled to asylum would return to their country with financial backing. That is what we did at the end of last year when we found ourselves with this unacceptable situation, this terrible situation in Libya when you will remember that we saw refugee camps with situations of modern-day slavery. So, we not only denounced this but we also acted based on the nine points drawn up at the Avillar Summit between the African Union and the European Union, making a one-off analysis with the High Commissioner.

I am in favour of us having this type of organisation for situations in those States affected - Libya in this case - but any other State that finds itself in a similar situation, when they are ready and operational, because you must respect the sovereignty of each country whilst always respecting, or also respecting, the recommendations of the High Commissioner and thus fostering European solidarity. This is the most suitable way of managing the situation we find ourselves in now, even from an EU perspective, but also from a humanitarian perspective, because if we want to protect these people from the risks they are facing, we cannot only protect them when they are in the territorial waters of a European or EU country since these people are put at risk as soon as a raft leaves Libyan waters, in the case of Libya.

This is, hence, the best way to prevent this situation, to avoid this situation, and the first pillar mentioned earlier in our response is this, and I believe that we must make headway down this path. However, I am not in favour of the proposal that I have read made by others about setting up rejection centres- that is how they would be called - where people are placed that are waiting for their papers to stay in a European country - which would be located in third countries that have nothing to do with the route out of their countries of origin, even while they are waiting for their asylum applications to be processed.

These are proposals we have heard in recent weeks at a European level but which cannot be accepted because they do not respect our values at all, our fundamental rights, and in the case of France, even our Constitutional Law, because here asylum is protected.

The proposal we want to draw up and which is also in line with the talks we had with the German Chancellor and with other European countries and which we have also debated a great deal here today to cover future situations, is a solution that seeks to set up closed centres on European soil, which is different yet complementary to the proposal from president Tusk in its provisional conclusions, and which can be outlined as follows: we are in favour of setting up closed centre following the rules of the High Commissioner with European resources whereby humanitarian rules and principles on aid are valid in the event of disembarkation, in other words, in the safest, closest port on European soil. This allows, firstly, European financial and economic solidarity whereby each country can take in those people entitled to asylum, which is what France is doing, for example, at a bilateral level in the case of the 'Aquarius', although the question here is to implement a widespread system and that there is European solidarity in the future to return those who are not entitled to asylum to their countries of origin.

That is the proposal we advocate in terms of reception and solidarity. I apologise for going on for so long but I prefer to be clear and accurate on these two proposals, the one made by President Tusk, the one we will support in tomorrow's debate. The other proposal which personally, and I believe that this is also the case of President of the Government Sánchez, we disagree on because this is not in line with our values.

President of the Government .- Regarding Morocco; I would like to pick up on some of the points mentioned before by President Macron. It is clear that migratory policy must be based on these three pillars: One, on cooperation and dialogue with the countries of origin and transit; two, to strengthen the Frontex policy - the common border policy; and three, reorganisation based on the principles of solidarity and responsibility.

It is clear that Spain has also been the target of migration over recent years and I believe that firstly we need to acknowledge the role of the State law enforcement agencies in Spain, the NGOs and also other public institutions, from the smallest local authorities to the regional governments, in relation to the reception and processing of all those migrants arriving on Spanish shores.

What is our approach that we shared with President Macron? Quite clearly that the European Union must strengthen its position, not only in bilateral terms between the Government of Spain and the countries of origin and transit, but also this dialogue, this necessary dialogue, on the part of the European Union as a whole, that we need to structure properly and conduct, which is in fact being done, with the countries of origin and transit. In fact, this is not the first vessel that we have seen arrive off our coasts over the last few years but, at any event, I can assure you that the position that will be maintained by the Government of Spain, both this Sunday and next Thursday and Friday, is a European position in response to this migratory reality which, for a country like ours, is affected as a border country. At any event, I can tell you that the Government of Spain will obviously place great emphasis on bilateral cooperation, on stepping up cooperation and dialogue with those countries of origin and transit.

Mr. Macron .- The second question from the French side and then there is another second question on the Spanish side.

I answered your colleague in great detail. I answered the question very specifically explaining what we propose. I can repeat that, but I think I have already gone into enough detail and been very specific. In French, that is. But I can say it again.

The proposal we make to the Italians is the following: we want to apply humanitarian rules, in other words, the nearest and safest country and we propose to take on the format of the High Commissioner with closed centres, with European resources implemented in the nearest and safest country for disembarkation. And for this to include European financing so that each case can be studied, each application, and for European countries to undertake to study the cases of those people entitled to asylum to distribute them throughout Europe. And that at these closed European centres in the closest disembarkation point we have teams that can accompany those people who are not entitled to asylum back to their country of origin. That is the proposal we make for those countries that are the point of first arrival, as we call them.

Second question.

Q .- A very good afternoon, President of the Government Sánchez, Mr Macron. Just one question. After the Meseberg Declaration, together with Chancellor Merkel, you stressed the need for a common European solution to resolve certain problems, particularly the political situation due to the present migratory crisis. But we can see that Germany is pulling away from this. Yesterday the Government Spokesperson remarked that no solution would be reached at tomorrow's Summit or at next week's European Council, even pointing out that it would be better to foster bilateral and multilateral solutions at this time. I wanted to know whether, against this backdrop, we will still be able to find a positive solution for everyone next week at the European Council meeting. And secondly, given that you are standing next to President of the Government Sánchez today, will this new alliance between France and Spain be able to overcome the Euro-sceptics springing up on the continent?

Mr. Macron .- I don't want to be the spokesperson's spokesperson but what the Chancellor reminded us yesterday was that there would be no formal agreement on Sunday and she did this for one simple reason, which is that a formal Council meeting will be held some days later. It is simply a formal occasion to avoid any misunderstanding on the German debate, which could leave some to think that there would be written conclusions with a formalised agreement at a meeting that will be a working meeting in Brussels on Sunday, no more and no less.

When we talk about European solutions, what does that mean? It means that there may be EU solutions, there may be solutions between many governments, or bilaterally or multilaterally. It means that we reject any idea of a purely national solution to close off borders or of an approach that is not cooperative. What we have spoken about today with President of the Government Sánchez, and with the Chancellor the other day, and what we will talk about tomorrow is just that, and I have been addressing these issues for a year now and can say to you that national solutions can satisfy someone's ego now and again, they can make people believe that they are more effective, but in the end they don't lead anywhere.

Some Member States are islands in Europe, they are isolated, but that is not the case in general, we are all inter-dependent, particularly on migratory issues. Hence, we need European approaches between governments and multinational cooperation. In the case of the 'Aquarius', there has been cooperation between governments to address the issues and the asylum applications. On those issues we have raised and the proposal we are making, this would thus be a European inter-governmental solution which could perhaps be raised to the level of a European solution at some time, but we do not need that, this is not a European rule that the Commission and the EU-27 are managing, and we propose to any country that wishes to join up with our proposal to do so and join together to send out teams to these closed centres in the country of arrival, to study the cases at hand. This is a cooperative solution that respects the law, it is European and inter-governmental at the same time, and it is exactly the same as we did in the Meseberg Declaration with the German Chancellor on this matter.

You are right to recall that there is scepticism and the winds are blowing against us in some parts of Europe, but the key is efficiency and humanity. Public opinion has been affected by what has been happening close to Europe for many years. We have to persist with our principles and not allow ourselves to be moved by extremists that use social sentiment to propose the worst, but we also have to offer specific solutions. I believe in a Europe that protects and offers specific solutions, which may be EU-based, inter-governmental or bilateral, but this must always be based on the same principle, which is the principle of cooperation and what we have proposed with the German Chancellor and what we also propose today with the President of the Government is precisely that. That is the point we are at, because we are united, Heads of State and Government - here there are two of us - but it could be the German Chancellor because she would agree with everything we have said and I know that because I spoke about this with her just three days ago, and we will also see that at tomorrow's debate. What I would like to see now are concrete solutions to deal with this matter.

And, then, I would like everyone to be well aware of this phenomenon, because this can sometimes get lost in the group debates we have. The reality is that Europe is not going through a migratory crisis of the magnitude it went through in 2015; that's not the case. Those who are saying this are not telling the truth, even a country like Italy is not under the same migratory pressure as it was last year, because, through European cooperation and, particularly, our cooperation with Libya, we have been able to reduce flows by 80%. The present crisis in Europe is a political crisis, just look at the figures; political crises related with secondary movements between European countries and which France is well aware of. In France in 2017, asylum applications were at an all-time high, and we are not a country of first point of arrival, but rather we have this because these secondary movements are dysfunctional and this creates a political crisis in Europe between those countries of first arrival, countries with secondary movements and those extremists that play on the fears around Europe. In this context, we must maintain a cool head and not lose all the benefits of cooperation, stand our ground in terms of our principles and not give way to the spirit of provocation, of simplification which we see appear from time to time.

We must thus act to ensure that the response to this crisis is, above all, political, effective and humane.

President of the Government .- As well as this whole issue, let's say, and the proposal made by the President of the French Republic, President Macron, on the inter-governmental and bilateral European response to the different problems, I would also like to convey something that we spoke about during our working lunch.

The Government of Spain has made a very detailed analysis of the proposal made by President Macron on the re-industrialisation of the European continent. We have studied the proposal made to boost industrial policy until the year 2030 throughout the European Union and one of the issues we agreed on at this working lunch is to set up a working group between our two governments, between our two ministerial departments. The Spanish Ministry of Industry will be represented on this working group to propose lines of political action at a European level to re-industrialise our continent and to do so, furthermore, based on the parameters proposed by President Macron. Innovation must be one of these, together with support for entrepreneurship, of course. We are going to take part in this working group, we are going to set it up jointly with the French Government and I hope that this will also be one of the issues we address at the meeting to be held in Madrid on 26 July.

Q .- Juan Antonio Nicolai, from Noticias Cuatro . Good afternoon to the two presidents. It seems inevitable, Mr Sánchez, to have to ask you about the image we saw yesterday, when we saw you sat next to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, Quim Torra, even talking together. We would like to know what value you ascribe to this image and also if you were able to perceive from this talk, or chat, some glimmer of hope regarding redirecting events in Catalonia and, above all, how this could be done.

President of the Government .- I believe that whether this is possible and how go hand-in-hand and are indeed related to dialogue. I feel that the most important aspect of relations between the Government of Spain and a regional government, in this case of Catalonia, is normalising institutional relations. The very fact of this dialogue taking place, which would seem to make the news, already shows the abnormality of a political reality that has led to a breakdown in trust and of loyalty that must be rebuilt.

And, of course, it is the Government of Spain's intention to normalise these institutional relations with the Regional Government of Catalonia and to start to resolve many of the problems that, whilst being political, affect, above all and most particularly, the citizens of Catalonia. These are related to infrastructures, which in turn are related to appeals against the un-constitutional nature of laws that were approved by the Regional Parliament of Catalonia and which may be perfectly well examined by the Government of Spain within a framework of bilateral dialogue that must inevitably take place between the Regional Government of Catalonia and the Government of Spain.

That is the goal with which the Government of Spain will act, aware that we are facing a crisis of trust that must now be re-established but which will not be re-established overnight, or even in a period of several weeks but whereby, at some given time, we need to go back to the beginning and start to rebuild these levels of trust that have broken down as a result of everything that has happened over these last few months.

I believe that the fact, not only of yesterday's dialogue, of yesterday's talk, but also that the head of State, the Government of Spain, the Regional Government of Catalonia, the City Council of Tarragona, were all representing the will of the people, the Spanish people, regarding holding the Mediterranean Games, says a great deal, in reality, much more than this mere exchange of words and phrases that I had with the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, it says a lot more about the intention by all parties to try and normalise relations and to truly try and resolve and project a very different image of what Catalan society is and also of what the whole of Spanish society is. I would also take advantage, given that you have paved the way for me to do so, to thank the President of the French Republic and the French people for their support for territorial integrity, national sovereignty and, in short, the support of the whole country for Spain because, we have clearly felt this at this critical time, Mr President, and I wanted to thank you for this in person and in public.

Q .- Good afternoon. France Press Agency. I would like to go back to the proposal for closed centres on European soil which I am sure, since you are very pragmatic, you already have an idea of how to implement, but I would like to know how you propose to convince the countries of origin or transit to take back those migrants that have been expelled. I don't know if you plan to impose sanctions or reduce humanitarian aid in order to pressurise these States. And following on to the how, how do you intend to convince other European countries to share out those individuals entitled to asylum? I don't know where there will be incentives or financial compensation; I am not referring to those who oppose this, but rather those that have said nothing for the time being, and I particularly refer to those migrants in Italy and those who are in the streets of Italy and are stuck there because France won't let them cross its border, and perhaps Germany would even reject their entry. Have you raised the issue of how to do this with them?

Mr. Macron .- There are several questions there. The first, in short, is the ability to convince those countries of origin or transit. Return policies do not involve countries of transit, even European ones. This is one of the grounds for disagreement we have with the proposal from other States, In short, migrants are returned to their country of origin, in the situation in which someone, after studying their individual case, is not granted asylum, someone whose country of origin we know because we have studied their case file.

On this issue, it is possible to be effective, and Spain is an excellent example of that. Spain, some 14 years ago, had a genuine migratory crisis with Senegal of flows close to the Canary Islands, and it found a very pragmatic and practical way to manage this with development and association policies and through dialogue that allowed these people to return to their country. That is the way to do this and we have also started to do this in France, which explains why the rate of acceptance of consular visas has improved with many countries. We will continue down this path but this would be even more effective if it were done at a European level or, at least, by several European States.

We will then debate the ways to do this, we are not going to discuss now something that has still not been debated on a widespread basis, which will happen tomorrow and next week, but obviously there will be incentives and perhaps also solutions with those who are uncooperative, which will allow our relations to be improved. It is true that we need to be very pragmatic and this is possible, there are examples that prove this and it is so much easier if we do this between several European countries in the case of people returning to their countries of origin, and this is normal because we cannot protect people if we do not have an effective return policy for those who are not entitled to asylum. This is the philosophy of the Government of Édouard Philippe in France since the outset, although sometimes with certain confusion among commentators, but well, someone who arrives on French soil will be taken in unconditionally but this is not a unique situation. It is normal for us to study their case file to see if they are entitled to asylum or not, and if this is an economic immigrant who has crossed into the country through unofficial routes or paths, we have no problem whatsoever in returning them to their country of origin. That is what we do in France and this can also be done at a European level.

Second point - Europe. What we propose is that each country has the possibility to take in people entitled to asylum. We are not talking about tens of thousands of people; in other words, those people who are entitled to asylum on our coasts in recent months are not that many when you look at their case files because, while many people apply for asylum we are talking about those who have actually been granted asylum, which is a reasonable figure, not a very large figure, who can perfectly be distributed among several countries and this would be a legitimate distribution of this burden because it is in line with our principles.

A few weeks ago I proposed to the European Parliament to establish a grant which would allow different regions and local authorities to take in 10, 20 or 30 asylum seekers. That is how we will do this, that is how we can have a genuine integration policy, since I want us to have the most open policy possible.

You also asked me about the sanction systems and mechanisms that could be used in the absence of solidarity. This is a debate we will hold within the framework of financial perspectives. Personally, I am in favour of this type of mechanism. We cannot have countries that hugely take advantage of European solidarity but which, at the same time, hugely rely on national ego in relation to migrants. So, yes, I am very much in favour of establishing financing conditions, for example, structural elements and that this enters into the debate. In the short term, if we want to have an effective instrument, this must depend on the mobilisation of each country.

I repeat, this is a very limited number of people we are talking about, but if we can guarantee to those countries of first arrival that by setting up these centres and this organisation, firstly that people can stay on European soil - and this is a great many people - we are talking about some 10% of those who arrive are entitled to stay, then these would be shared out among several countries and all those who are not entitled to stay would come under a coordinated European policy that allows them to return swiftly and efficiently.

And then, you ask about those who are in the streets in a dubious situation. I wouldn't use that word but anyway, throughout Europe there are people who left their countries in terrible conditions, who on occasions have seen the very worst of what goes on in Africa or in the Near East, and then cross the Mediterranean and now find themselves in our territories. These people follow procedures and I consider that we owe them a quick examination of their case files, which is what we are doing in France, thus improving levels of effectiveness which is one of the main grounds for the draft bill going through the Upper House at this time. Now, when someone is not entitled to asylum, we should be able to accompany them back to their country as quickly as possible, and the only solution to the problem you have raised which creates a great deal of tension between Member States is to develop a collective policy on returns. And one of the worst trials and tribulations that Italy is suffering from is not so much the direct arrivals from Libya - which has fallen by 80%, as I said - but rather the people who arrived earlier, at the start of the Mare nostrum, that is, of the crisis, the majority of whom are not entitled to asylum and who now find themselves in a situation of clandestine foreigners, in an unregulated situation on European soil, particularly in Italy.

This situation obviously calls for European solidarity on a return policy; European solidarity cannot mean accepting all these clandestine people in one country, who would be equally clandestine in another country. We must get our ideas and principles straight. So we also have a European mobilisation policy there to accompany them back to their own countries.

Pedro, I don't know if you want to add anything.

President of the Government .- You said it perfectly, Mr President. I don't know if there are any more questions.

Mr. Macron .- Very well. We will end there then. Thank you, President of the Government.

Non official translation