Press conference by the President of the Government of Spain, Pedro Sánchez, after the Extraordinary European Council meeting
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez held a press conference on 1 February 2024 following an Extraordinary European Council meeting, summarising outcomes on the EU budget, Ukraine, Gaza, and farmers' concerns.
- Main themes
- EU multiannual financial framework review, support for Ukraine, Gaza conflict and two-state solution, European migration policy, farmers' protests and agri-food sector, EU defence industry, climate change adaptation, Spain's EU presidency legacy, international humanitarian law, technological reindustrialisation
- Duration
- ~30 min
- Words
- 3,543
- Sentences
- 154
- Readability
- 51
- Grade
- 11.8
- Syntax
- 3.12
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
154 sentences in 83 paragraphs
Good morning, or should I say good afternoon.
Well, if you agree, Carmen, director, we will begin. As you know, we have dealt with three important issues in this Council.
The first of these is the completion of the review of the multiannual financial framework, which as you know was left unfinished at the last European Council of the Spanish presidency. The issue, as you know, was difficult, it was complex, but I am happy to say that we 27 member states have reached an agreement that respects point by point the agreement reached under the Spanish presidency last December on the basis of the Spanish proposal, introducing a possible revision milestone in the negotiation of the next framework.
Today, we have succeeded in ensuring that Europe continues to move forward together in dealing with the great challenges of our time, including the war in Ukraine and Europe's solidarity and support for this country, migration, climate change, and the technological revolution.
I think this is very good news for Europeans. It is also good news for the Spanish people, because it will allow us to devote more resources to managing a phenomenon we know very well because it is a daily occurrence, namely migration, as well as to offer support to the population suffering from natural disasters and to promote our technological reindustrialisation.
And this is good news for Europeans as a whole, because it shows that at key moments the EU is capable of reaching agreements and rising to the occasion.
It is also good news for the Ukrainian people. We had the opportunity to contact President Zelenski by videoconference, because the €50 billion from the Ukraine Facility is going to be used to fight Putin's authoritarianism, to protect our democracies and to help all the staff, the civil servants in Ukraine during this war.
Continuing to support Ukraine through the European Peace Facility, the strengthening of our defence industry, is in fact the second issue we addressed.
We will continue to provide Ukraine with the military equipment necessary to defend its territory, institutions and population against Putin's aggression, and we will continue to do so for as long as necessary.
And last, we addressed the extreme and grave situation in Gaza. Together with other member states, Spain has defended the need for Europe to speak out forcefully on this issue to demand that Israel respect international humanitarian law, in order to set in motion as soon as possible a constructive dialogue, as the High Representative has asked us to do, which will lead to a just and lasting peace based on the two-state solution.
There are, of course, discrepancies on this issue within the member states, but "Spain will continue to work to ensure that Europe acts in a coherent manner". Spain will not abandon the millions of Israeli and Palestinian citizens who want and deserve a future of coexistence in peace and security.
Additionally, and outside the agenda, we talked about the situation of European farmers, and in this respect, I would like to say three things.
The first is in response to a criticism, unfounded in my opinion, by the former French minister Ségolène Royal, criticising Spanish tomatoes. I believe that Mrs Royal has not had the good fortune to taste Spanish tomatoes. I invite you to come to Spain, to try any of the Spanish tomato varieties, and you will see that the Spanish tomato is unbeatable.
Going further into these matters, I would first of all like to say that we obviously respect the right of farmers to demonstrate peacefully.
But we must condemn, and we do condemn, the attack on our hauliers and on Spanish producers who are doing their job legally and who, with their efforts, are supplying European markets and homes.
We have made this known to the various authorities, both French and EU institutions.
And second, we are very aware of the challenges facing the Spanish countryside and, for this reason, this Government has dedicated the most extraordinary financial and economic resources to modernising and adapting agricultural holdings to this climate context, which is completely different to the scenario some years ago.
We have also achieved a peace agreement that has been very positive for the Spanish countryside, and during the last legislature we approved a major and important transformation, the Food Chain Law, which obviously incorporates transparency and therefore fairness in the distribution of benefits throughout the entire agri-food production chain.
Consequently, what we have done is to approve very ambitious, transformative legislative reforms that incorporate the principle of social justice to promote a more transparent and fairer price system for farmers.
We have done all these things. And we will continue to do more. Spain has one of the most powerful agri-food sectors in the world, one of the most competitive in Europe. And it will continue to be so.
So, Director, I think I have briefly summarised the issues related to this Council, and I am now at the disposal of the media to answer your questions.
Q.- [Carlos Cué, El País]. Yes, with regard to what you were saying about farmers, I wanted to ask you whether you have spoken to President Macron about this issue. The president, not only Ségolène Royal, has said that there is unfair competition from Spanish and Italian farmers.
Have you spoken to Macron about this? Have you given any explanation or are you going to change the discourse of the French government, and are you going to do anything about the lorry issue in particular? What if the Mercosur agreement is defunct, what with France's position on agriculture?
On national issues, I wanted to ask you, how long can the government hold out if the Amnesty Law is not passed? There is fear that we are heading for a short legislature, and what can the Government offer Junts so that it will go from a "no" to a "yes" on this law?
President : Thank you very much Carlos for the question.
On the first, I have of course had the opportunity to speak to President Macron about this, and I think that what I said earlier is very important, that we respect all peaceful demonstrations made, in this case, by the French agri-food sector, but what we must do is strongly condemn any kind of violent action that has nothing to do with these legitimate demands that can be made from a peaceful point of view.
I would also like to say that Spanish products do not have a competitive advantage over any other products in the internal market, and that the same rules apply in France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, the Netherlands and the other member states.
And what I do want to emphasise is quality and competitiveness, based on innovation and on the efforts of the agricultural sector in our country.
Spain ranks ─I was just reading this data, which seem to me to be sufficiently indicative of the power, competitiveness and quality of Spanish products─ Spain ranks among the top ten producers in organic farming, in terms of surface area, at both European and world levels, to cite just one case.
And, behind these figures, there is obviously a process of adaptation by our farmers, who gain market share based on this, on innovation and, of course, on the efforts of the farming sector.
And the Government of Spain has played a part in this transformation. And I would like to give you a few facts that seem to me to be sufficiently indicative.
Our commitment to the agricultural sector has meant that in 2022 and 2023 - because now we are talking about drought, both in Andalusia and unfortunately also in Catalonia, because unfortunately we have been suffering drought in Spain since 2022 - we provided extraordinary aid to the tune of €4 billion.
I remember what the first royal decree law we passed in 2022 was, precisely because it was against drought, the effects of drought and aid to the agri-food sector in our country.
We are talking about the fact that in two years we have made available €4 billion in direct aid, in fiscal, labour and social measures, and in the insurance sector, as you know, in the field of drought, fertilisers, water - in short, an unprecedented volume of economic resources, which we have also gone hand in hand throughout the last legislature and this legislature with other very important measures.
You know that we are going to maintain the hydrocarbon tax rebate for diesel for agricultural use. We are going to mobilise more than €2.1 billion by 2027, a historic figure, to modernise Spanish irrigation and to take advantage of every drop of water, which is now, unfortunately, becoming an increasingly scarce resource.
In short, our commitment to the countryside is total, it is resounding, it is absolute.
The Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food is going to have another meeting with the sector, and obviously the Government is accompanying the agri-food sector in its demands and its causes.
On the Mercosur agreement, remember that it is in the hands of the European Commission. Trade policy is a common policy, it is a policy that is in the hands of the European Commission, which negotiates on behalf of all the member states, and also knows what the position of the Government of Spain is.
I remember yesterday, in the tribute paid to Delors, Portuguese president and president of the European Commission, talking about his legacy, saying that it was indeed he who, as President of the Commission, was the driving force behind the internal market. It was Enrico Letta, in fact, who raised and shared the reflection that Delors made a few months ago about the challenge now facing the EU when defending its internal market now being to also project itself abroad and, therefore, to build bridges with the regions with which we have a political and cultural affinity and also economic complementarity, such as, in this case, the Latin American region.
The Government of Spain, you know what our position is. Thanks to the presidency, but above all thanks to the good work of the Commission, we were the ones who fought for this agreement to be concluded with Chile, and also with New Zealand. We have tried to push as hard as possible and move positions in Mercosur, but unfortunately, we have not been able to conclude this important agreement.
We held the summit between the European Union and CELAC, with an investment agenda, with a biannual commitment to meet, to continue monitoring which... In short, what I want to say is that, for Spain, Mercosur is obviously key in this geopolitical and economic relationship that we must have with a continent with which we are united by so many things.
And, in relation to the last question, I would first like to reflect on the historical context, because I believe it is relevant. For five and a half years we have been trying to resolve a constitutional and territorial crisis that I did not cause, because I was not President of the Government at the time. In 2017, we suffered a serious constitutional and territorial crisis, probably the most serious in the 45 years of our democratic history.
Over the last five years, what we have done is use all means to try, through dialogue, negotiation and agreement, to overcome the collective trauma that we suffered in 2017.
We did this first with the reprieves linked to pardons. I received then the same kind of attacks from the opposition that I am receiving now. But, in fact, now even political rivals and opponents do not reproach me for the reprieves.
Why? Because they have seen that they have had a very positive result in terms of coexistence for the citizens of Catalonia.
And that's how I have summed it up, on many occasions, when I'm asked: "Is the situation in Catalonia better today than it was in 2017?" Definitely, yes. Therefore, the pardons have been an important step, I would even say a very important step. And the Amnesty Law is the final step.
A definitive step which, by the way, has a broad consensus in the society that has suffered most directly from this territorial crisis of 2017, which is Catalan society. Whatever they vote, the majority of Catalan society is ready for this total reunion.
I want to make this contextualisation because, as I have said many times before, Catalonia's total normalisation will not come overnight, but my will to normalise the situation in Catalonia is total.
Now I will say that, as everyone knows, Catalan independence is not terrorism. And it isn't. Therefore, with this bill, I am convinced - and this is what the courts are going to conclude in the end - that all Catalan pro-independence supporters will be granted amnesty, because they are not terrorists.
And, therefore, if this is the conviction of a bill that has been extremely laborious, that we have worked on in Parliament, that has been agreed with six different political formations, with two other members belonging to the Mixed Group... If we have done all this work that has resulted in a law, in my opinion, that has three very important conditions, three very relevant characteristics: one, then it is a brave law, because its main objective is the total reunion of Catalans, and also between Catalans and all their Spanish compatriots; it is a restorative law, and it is a constitutional law. If we have achieved this courageous, restorative and constitutional amnesty law, the fundamental objective is for it to come out of the Lower House in the same way, equally courageous, undoubtedly restorative, and with the legal guarantees and legal certainty for it to be applied. And that is the Government of Spain's position.
Q.- [Irene Castro, El Diario.es] Hello, President, good afternoon. You have just said that you want the law to come out of the Lower House in this way. I understand that you are one hundred percent against making changes, against making the changes that Junts asks for.
And second, I want to ask you: In the event that you do not make these changes and Junts still says "no", where does that leave the Government? I mean, is it a failure for the Government? How long would the legislature last in that case?
And a last question. In recent days, the German chancellor has called for more bilateral aid to Ukraine. Spain is one of the countries that has contributed the least bilaterally. In this debate, does Spain intend to contribute more? Thank you.
President: Thank you very much, Irene, for your questions.
With regard to the first question, in a negotiation, it is not necessary to measure who gives in and who does not give in. In the end, we have all given ground to achieve, I repeat, a courageous, restorative and constitutional amnesty law.
So I think the key is to be temperate, but also to be firm. Temperate in terms of restraint in trying to reach an agreement, and the firmness of knowing that everything we have advanced so far, even for this political party which has voted in favour of the amnesty bill on four occasions, is sufficiently rigorous and solid to achieve the objective we set ourselves, which is, effectively, to end up beating that judicial block that 2017 caused.
I often hear about the complexity of the legislature and whether the legislature... Let's see, I have never hidden the complexity of the legislature. I said so on 24 July.
Now it is also true that, having not hidden this complexity, it is quite clear that we are the only ones capable of governing and managing it.
Is this legislature more difficult than the last one?
Well I'm thinking about the previous one. We are in the wake of a pandemic, the beginning of a war, an inflationary shock as a result of Putin's war in Ukraine, even a volcano!
And here are the results. We are leading growth among the major European economies; we have employment and job creation rates of 738,000 new jobs created by 2023, with almost 21 million people in work. We have the lowest unemployment rate in 15 years. We have the lowest levels of household indebtedness since 2002, as reported yesterday.
Well, I believe that we have performed well, and that Spain is therefore moving in the right direction, in the direction of creating employment, advancing in rights and resolving a problem of coexistence that, I repeat, I did not create. What I am doing is trying to resolve this crisis of coexistence.
Those who criticise me, like the opposition, are not putting an alternative on the table. And when they do, unfortunately, it makes you shudder, doesn't it? The outlawing of political parties, imprisonment, a permanent 155; back to 2017 or worse.
Well, I believe that we are now at a point where we are facing a whole-hearted reunion between Catalans. and between Catalans and Spanish society as a whole.
We have come this far. And all together, more than five parties, some of them pro-independence. We have made an effort of generosity, of dialogue, of agreement, each and every one of the political formations.
I believe that the time has come to take the step, a transcendental step for our democracy, but one that I believe will be positive for Catalan society and, therefore, for Spanish society as a whole, because we will gain in terms of coexistence.
So, let's look at complexity, if I may, Irene. Complexity is not an excuse for not moving forward.
The complexity is the day-to-day work during this legislature, as it was during the last legislature.
[Inaudible question]
I repeat, I think it is a question of knowing what we have done so far.
And, as I said at the beginning, I think I've been pretty clear. With the bill we have right now, independence, which I do not consider terrorism, is going to be amnestied, and so we are going to be able to overcome all the legal cases and the legal consequences of the mistakes they made.
And about Germany. Sorry, Irene, I didn't answer you.
About Germany. Well, I have conveyed both in private and in the Council our full and unequivocal support for Ukraine, in the light of the capabilities of the Armed Forces and the Spanish Ministry of Defence.
Q.- [Jorge Valero, Bloomberg]. Good afternoon, President. I also have two questions .
First, before this summit, we were told here in Brussels that record levels of frustration had been reached among leaders with regard to Prime Minister Orbán, Hungary's Orban.
Do you think this agreement serves to restore ties, or are we still at the mercy of a new Orbán veto in the future, be it on Ukraine or on any other issue? And second, on Mercosur, since Spain is one of the countries that most supports this agreement, and before this crisis with the farmers we were so close, do you think there needs to be another round of negotiations as soon as possible before the elections, or do you think there should be a pause so as not to stir things up even more before the European elections? Thank you.
President: Well, thank you very much.
I believe that, with regard to the second, the Secretary of State will correct me if I'm mistaken, but I believe that there will soon be another round and, therefore, from our point of view, there should not be a break before the European elections.
And, with respect to the first, well, I am not the one who should comment on the negotiating strategies of one or the other prime minister in this respect, am I? But the fact is - and I believe that this also reaffirms for us the good work we did during the last six months of the Spanish presidency - that this agreement, which was very difficult because 26 member states had to agree on it, is what came out in the end, and that is what has been respected. And I believe that this is very important for Spain and also says a lot about the Spanish presidency of the Council.
And, by the way, when I speak of temperance and firmness, since I have not been asked, I also speak of temperance and firmness with Mr Feijóo, right? Because I hear you say that you are once again making excuses and placing conditions on compliance with the Spanish Constitution in relation to the meeting that took place yesterday between the two representatives of the Socialist Party and the Popular Party with Commissioner Reynders, and I would remind Mr Feijóo that to comply with the Constitution we have to do so without any kind of excuse or any kind of argument.
There is no excuse for not complying with the Constitution. And that is what I would like to ask the Popular Party once again. Given that it claims to be a constitutionalist party, then let it comply with the Constitution, even if it is five years later.
Thank you very much.
Non official translation