Replies from the President of the Government to Members of the European Parliament

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

16 January 2019 · Replies to Members of the European Parliament

Context
Sánchez addressed the European Parliament on January 16, 2019, responding to MEPs' questions on migration, EU reform, and Spain's budget priorities.
Main themes
Migration policy, European solidarity and responsibility, Common European Asylum System reform, Schengen defense, multi-year financial framework, far-right influence on European discourse, Spain-Africa bilateral cooperation, integration policy, border policy, EU budget, cohesion and agricultural policy
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,078
86th percentile
Sentences
155
82nd percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 34%33%
  • Institutional 25%25%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

155 sentences in 67 paragraphs

President of the Government: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Thank you to each and every one taking part. And thank you too for the tone of the debate which has become more urgent as each new contribution has been made and developed.

If the spokespersons of the different parties will allow me, I would like to answer their questions together and not individually because I believe that otherwise we would extend this debate for too long.

Well, the core idea of my remarks is of course that we have to protect Europe so that Europe can protect us. This has clearly been behind many of the contributions made here, at least by the main parliamentary parties.

We all agree that we have to strengthen Europe, whatever the ideological discrepancies between us. The question is, how? In what sense? I would like to refer first of all to migration.

I would like to tell Mr. Weber that it is good that he has finally transferred the vision of the People's Party to Spain, but it would also be good if he downloaded and checked this information, because migration did not arise with the Socialist Government in June. To give him an idea, in 2017 there was an increase of migratory flows in Spain of 137%; 137%. So what came with this Government of Spain was not migration, but migratory policy, which did not exist until then. Which did not exist until then.

What I will say to you, and what I will also say to the rest of your colleagues is that we have always been aware - and because of that we also took the decision to accept the Aquarius , to offer Valencia as a port of safe haven - we have always been aware that the challenge of migration requires all the countries, all the Member States, to have a shared position. A position based on two core elements: the first is responsibility; and the second, solidarity.

And there is no doubt that we and the Government of Spain support a foreign policy such as that proposed by the Vice-President of the European Commission. It supports the idea that we have to use financial resources for the development and regeneration of Africa. It supports bilateral cooperation with many of the countries of transit and origin of migration.

We have in seven months strengthened bilateral dialogue with Morocco, with Mauritania, with all the countries in the Sahel; not only in Spain's interest, but the interest of the European Union as a whole.

To give you an idea, Spain has for many years had return policies in place with Morocco, with Mauritania and with other Sahel countries in Africa. In fact, only a few days ago I was in Mali, where we promoted to a certain extent the re-establishment of a policy on voluntary return by Mali nationals now living in Spain. So return policies are being fostered by the Government of Spain.

We are also strengthening our border policies. And without any doubt, what we are doing is also to strengthen policies on integration, because we believe it is important to strengthen these migration policies for all migrants who are on our continent.

And what I would certainly like to pass on to you in this respect is that the Government of Spain is of course in favour of a reform of the Common European Asylum System, and that doubts should not be raised about Schengen. In fact it is of some concern to me that this should not be done by minority parties. It has been done by groups that do not form part of the major parties in the European Parliament, as the People's Party does. And I believe that in this regard we cannot take any step backwards.

That is why I am concerned, talking about and referring simply to the far right, what concerns me is not so much the presence of the far right, ladies and gentlemen. What concerns me is how the far right is subtly making use of the discourse and political agenda of parties who were once European and who wanted to strengthen the European project.

This Government - and I recognise your rhetorical brilliance, Mr. Verhofstadt - this Government undoubtedly supports the approval of the multi-year financial framework. We have also done so in the European Council. We have supported, and I have supported specifically, and not only I, the previous Government did so as well, with President of the Government Rajoy at the helm, which had to approve the multi-year framework before the elections. Because we consider it is key for the essential policies in Spain, such as Agricultural Policy, Cohesion Policy, but also important policies such as Migration Policy and the policies linked to science and innovation.

In fact, Mr. Weber, don't worry because we are going to pass the General State Budget, probably in April. The previous Government, with Mr. Rajoy at the helm, presented the Budget in the Lower House of Parliament in April. So what I would like to say here is not that we are making progress on time and following normal procedures, but that in fact we are going to anticipate what the previous Government proposed as a draft budget presented to Parliament.

And I believe that we are going to push it through, because I believe that it is a good Budget, not only in the social area, with a considerable increase in the items linked to redistribution; but it also presents some innovative matters, from the point of view of tax fairness, such as the taxation of large technological companies, the creation of a tax on financial transactions, which are undoubtedly some of the measures that you have proposed here in this chamber, and in which we are also leading the way in Spain.

But allow me also to talk for a moment about Catalonia, because this has been mentioned by the spokesperson Ms. Keller. Look, in Catalonia since 2014, since the year 2014, there have been five votes; five votes in three electoral processes: regional and then two referendums contravening the Constitution and the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

Well, what has the result of these referendums and votes been, also within the Spanish statutory framework? At most, 48% of Catalan society supported the pro-independence parties; and 52% did not support pro-independence parties.

So the first conclusion is: the pro-independence movement does not have a social majority in Catalonia. It has a parliamentary majority, which is a product and result of the Electoral Law, but it does not have a social majority. I repeat: 52% of society in Catalonia does not support independence. It does not support independence.

So, what the independence movement therefore has to recognise is that there is no social majority in Catalonia, and that it cannot therefore support, impose a political project on a majority that has made clear on repeated occasions since 2014 that there is no move towards independence, that it does not support such a move. That is first of all.

Second, it is clear that in Europe, not only in Catalonia, there is territorial tension: if we look for example to Germany, in Bavaria; or if we look to Italy, in the Veneto; or if we look to France, in Corsica. There are territorial fragmentation movements, movements for the decomposition of what were once nation states.

What is the difference between what has happened in Catalonia and what has happened in Veneto, for example, or in Bavaria, when a number of different political parties have supported the independence of Bavaria from Germany, or the independence of Veneto from Italy? Well, when the Supreme Courts passed judgement in Veneto, or rather in Italy, in the "Veneto Case", or in Germany, with the "Bavaria Case", these independence movements have said that they abide by these judgements.

In Spain this has not happened. In Spain, despite repeated rulings by the Constitutional Court, what the pro-independence groups have done is unilaterally breach the Statute of Autonomy, in other words the regional constitution of Catalonia, and the Spanish Constitution.

So the problem is that in some way the constitutional mandate has not been complied with, or not been obeyed, by the pro-independence groups, because these regional and national constitutions have not been recognised.

Third. It is clear that since 2010 Catalonia has a regional constitution, a Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, which was not voted on as a whole by Catalan society. So this is a problem that has to be resolved. The Spanish State is aware of it.

One thing is also true; for the last 10 years it has been clear that there are political parties which, when they are in opposition, use Catalonia as a territorial grievance to oppose the Socialist government in power, and when they are in government, they call for loyalty, in this case from the Socialist Party. We are always going to do it. We are going to be loyal with the Government in power, when we are in opposition; or rather with the State.

Spain is a great country. Spain is a country that has a certain level of economic decentralisation with respect to social and cultural matters, in the recognition of languages. In terms of the educational approach for children who live in regions that have a very significant sense of nationhood. There are indices in this area in the international community, which are significant and fairly reliable in fact, that position Spain as the second most decentralised country in the world.

So I believe it is clear that the independence movement in Catalonia has to open up a sincere dialogue and recognise the other side, which is in a majority in Catalonia, which is not nationalist; so Catalonia has to talk with Catalonia. And what Spain, the Government of Spain, has to do is facilitate this dialogue between the two, let's say, dimensions that there are today in Catalonia: the nationalist and the non-nationalist.

Of course, what I can guarantee is that this Government of Spain, unlike in the past, does have the firm will to resolve the situation in Catalonia through dialogue, but always respecting the Constitution and the Statute of Autonomy. But before anything else what the independence movement in Catalonia has to do is recognise, first, that it does not have a social majority; and second, that it has to talk with the majority of Catalan society which wants a new agreement in order to emerge from this endless loop it has been stuck in for more than 10 years.

To sum it up in a very summary way, very simply, in Catalonia the problem is not independence; it is coexistence.

Finally, finally, Mr. Weber, you have alluded to the no confidence motion. The no confidence motion had a mandate, which was the democratic regeneration of our country. What has happened in Andalusia between the People's Party, the liberals, the allies of the National Front in France, is involution. It is questioning the rights and consensus assumed and consolidated over these years, such as for example, gender equality and the fight against gender violence.

So what has happened in Andalusia, ladies and gentlemen, is that a frontier has been crossed in Europe; because the fact is that there can be no agreements with the far right. Of course, we, as social democrats, will never reach agreements with the far right, as has been made clear by the proposals made.

In any event, ladies and gentlemen, I would like to tell you that the Government of Spain's proposal is to make Europe strong. Look at the proposals we have put forward, in what is represented by the strategy for gender equality, or what equality, or to put it better, the fight against precarious jobs, as represented by the youth guarantee. In short, in all those aspects that are related to the strengthening and protection of Europe so that it can protect us. And above all, those who are most vulnerable can find support from the Government of Spain. And without a doubt, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, which is also represented here.

And finally, Mr. Verhofstadt, I will also say one thing to you. You have been in the European Parliament for more years than I, who have been heading the Government of Spain for seven months. I am sure that you can share with me your frustrating experience.

I will also tell you one thing. I believe that in my answer I have pointed out some ways out for this, let's say, lack of speed in many of the decisions made that are needed in the area of economic and monetary union; in the area of foreign policy, which has to do with the change in the decision-making procedures in the Council, in Parliament and in the Commission. And that is undoubtedly where we are going to be. That is what I have said from this tribune, defending in some cases not unanimously in matters as essential as those I have referred to before.

Some of them will need a modification to the Treaty, but others won't. There are the gateways that the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Mr. Borrell, reminded me of. We can perfectly well use these gateways to strengthen, let's say, the overall nature of our continent, of our Union in the matter of foreign policy.

Thank you very much Mr President of the Government.

SECOND RESPONSE BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE MEPs

President of the Government: Thank you, Mister Speaker.

Thank you to each and every one of the MEPs who have made their points. First, I would like to thank them for their tone. Second, I would also like to thank them - and why not say so? - for the feeling that underlies their contributions, because I believe that this also animates the debate, above all after having to listen to a great many presentations, a significant number of contributions from different sides and with different leanings.

If it's all right with you, what I will do is answer you as a whole, not individually. I will also do so based on two core elements that it appears that can be summed up, not only in the spirit of my first intervention, but also the spirit and content of the answers in this round of responses to the contributions from each of the MEPs.

First of all, multilateralism; and second, as you a Spanish Socialist MEP have mentioned correctly before, federalism.

With respect to multilateralism, I said in my first round of answers, ladies and gentlemen, that the Government of Spain believes in, supports, the 2030 Agenda. Not only from the point of view of a political agenda of transformation at national level. We also believe that in the next decade, the European Union has to be the great ambassador, the great activist for the 2030 Agenda in the multilateral system. For example, this 2030 Agenda, which makes a firm and unambiguous defence of gender equality, is absolutely part and parcel of the proposal I have made to all of you in relation to the European strategy for gender equality; or also, what we are doing at Spanish level, with the approval of a series of measures linked to the fight against gender violence, but also with compliance with the cross-party agreement against gender violence; or the approval of laws that reduce the wage gap between men and women and employment equality between men and women.

In this matter, I would also like to tell you one thing: Some speakers have talked about the fact that unemployment is still totally unacceptable in Spain, in terms relative to other countries in the European Union, and in terms of the average of the Eurozone, and of the European Union. But I will say one thing to them: Right now, there are around 19 million affiliates in the social security system, and it is the first time in its history that 48% of this total is women. More than eight million women have found work, and are affiliates in the social security system and part of the labour market.

I will also tell you something else. The measure passed by the Government of Spain to increase the minimum wage by 22%, the biggest rise in the history of our country since 1977, in the democratic history of our country, benefits in the case of 70% of the total, above all women, who are unfortunately being paid low wages and are therefore recipients of the minimum wage.

So, there is gender equality. Then there is child poverty. The fight against child poverty is also one of the core elements of the 2030 Agenda. In this case we have not only presented to this house the need to strengthen this proposal for a children's guarantee, but we are also doing the same in Spain.

The General State Budget, which we proposed and presented to Parliament on Monday, makes a decisive commitment to the fight against child poverty, strengthening it and linking much of it to the child guarantee, if we can call it or translate it as such in the sphere of Spanish politics.

With respect to climate change, some of the speakers have talked about what the Government of Spain's commitment is with respect to this issue. We are shortly going to approve in Parliament, I hope, but above all the Government of Spain will present, a Law on Climate Change, a plan or a national strategy for ecological transition, where if you allow me to say so, one of the basic questions, at least for the Government of Spain, is that the transition should be fair. In other words, that the mining communities, that those parts of Spain where there is a major presence of thermal power stations, can find opportunities; and that of course that the victims, those most affected, can understand the need to make this transition.

And finally, there has been a reference to a broad package of rights, freedoms, that unfortunately during the seven years of conservative government were implemented by the last Administration.

There has been mention of the "gag" law, and there was also talk about everything that has to do with the labour reform and labour rights of workers in our country.

I would like to say simply two things. First, in relation to the "gag" law. It is now at the stage of amendments, presentations, in the Lower House of Parliament, and I hope that this may be resolved and approved by Parliament in the period of sessions that will begin in February. And second, linked to labour rights, I would like to tell you that the Government of Spain has boosted social dialogue. What it has done is to approve in seven months, only seven months, a Youth Employment Plan that in three years will reduce, in three years, the rate of youth unemployment by 10 points and mobilise 2 billion euros.

We have also approved a plan to fight against labour exploitation. A plan to fight against precarious employment, as a result of which over 50,000 jobs have emerged that didn't, let's say, comply with the legislation in our country, and are right now permanent contracts.

And finally, I would also like to tell you in this respect that you know that self-employed workers, those working for themselves in our country, who number more than three million people, men and women, thanks to an agreement we have achieved with the trade unions and employers in only seven months, have seen all their social guarantees linked to unemployment benefit improved, and also their cover in the case of work-related accidents, etc., etc. And we have done this of course hand-in-hand with the social partners and also the employers.

So we have multilateralism, a clear social agenda by the Government of Spain, not only at European level but also at national level; and I would like to make two additional reflections that have arisen as a result of the contributions.

With respect to foreign policy and linked to Venezuela, I would like to tell you that the Government of Spain, but also I as leader of the opposition before becoming President of the Government, did not recognise the legitimacy of the Venezuelan elections, and we have also not recognised at all the Maduro regime. Proof of this can be found in the fact that we were not present at his inauguration.

We have asked the Maduro regime systematically, on repeated occasions, that it should free the political prisoners (and there certainly are political prisoners there). Thanks to the good offices of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, we have also enabled some political prisoners to travel to Spain, the last being a young person whom I was able to meet. And, without a doubt, the Government of Spain's approach to the question of Venezuela is that of trying to forge an alliance, a facilitation group for dialogue, among both European countries and the countries in the Lima Group.

I would also like to point out that France has not participated in the decision promoted by the Lima Group, and I can also guarantee that Spain does not share this idea. The Government of Spain is trying to construct a facilitation group that will in fact allow a transition based on consensus to resolve once and for all the Venezuelan crisis.

I am surprised that when we talk about Venezuela, we do not talk about the migratory crisis suffered by Venezuela, of which our Asylum Offices in Spain are also, we could say, one of the main victims, because there are many Venezuelans who are looking for asylum in our country. But there is also the migratory crisis that exists in the whole Latin American continent, and in particular in Colombia, in Peru, in Brazil, in Chile and in many other countries, with which I have had the opportunity to meet over these seven months as President of the Government.

I have to tell you that in the Foreign Affairs Committee, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, and also the Government of Spain as a whole, has supported the release of financial resources to help these countries manage the huge amount of migratory flows arriving there in a way that is at least, we could say, reasonable. And specifically, there is Colombia, which of course can count on our full support.

With respect to the Canary Islands, I would simply like to tell you that the Government of Spain and, thanks to this Government, in little more than seven months we have processed the Statute of the Canary Islands, and all the agreements pending signature have been signed in time and as required.

So it's not that we believe in ultra-peripheral regions; it's not that we believe in the opportunities and rights of the Canary Islands. We are in fact acting with the conclusion, for example of an agreement on roads worth 1.8 billion euros, no more and no less, to be managed by the Regional Government of the Canary Islands.

And finally, I would like to make an overall reflection on some of the remarks most closely linked to the People's Party and also, to the question of Catalonia.

I have said this in the Spanish Parliament. I would also like to say it to the colleagues in the European People's Party who share my nationality, who are Spanish. I would like to tell them that right now the right-wing agenda is being set by the far right. And it is being set by the far right in two fundamental matters that are typical when the right is in opposition.

The first is territorial grievances, and using Catalonia, in other words territorial coexistence and cohesion, as an element and a tool for opposition to the Government of Spain.

The Government of Spain is, and the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party will always be, loyal to the Constitution; we are loyal in opposition, and we are loyal in government. And I would also like the People's Party to do the same when it is in opposition.

And secondly, if I had to look to find a form of governance that provides stability, whether in the region or the countries, I would prefer the Swedish example to the example that we have just seen in Andalusia.

Thank you very much.

Non official translation