"Torra must move from proclamations to real dialogue."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

28 December 2018 · Council of Ministers · Barcelona, Spain

Context
Sánchez gave an interview on December 28, 2018, discussing the Council of Ministers held in Barcelona and ongoing dialogue efforts with the Catalan government amid the independence crisis.
Main themes
Catalan dialogue and political crisis, institutional cooperation between Spain and Catalonia, autonomous state and territorial diversity, Article 155 and self-government, PSOE progressive values, constitutional framework, Pedralbes meeting, normalization of relations with Generalitat
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,875
74th percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
84th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%53%
  • Geopolitical 35%35%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

160 sentences in 69 paragraphs

- Did you foresee four months ago that holding a Council of Ministers in Barcelona could be seen as a provocation, as a member of the Govern described it?

- In reality, no. I believe that the great task we have as both governments is to normalize what is normal and take it out of exceptionalism. Holding the Council in Barcelona is a show of appreciation and respect towards Catalonia, towards the autonomous state, which is being called into question, and the defense of decentralization. I have always believed that Spain is and will be strong by recognizing its territorial diversity.

- Shouldn't it be easier for a meeting between the president of the Generalitat and the president of the Government? It is something that should be part of democratic logic.

- Without a doubt. After seven years of lack of communication, creating spaces for dialogue and trust and recovering a certain institutional loyalty seems key to me. The fact that more than thirty meetings have been held in six months, that the bilateral State-Generalitat commission recognized in the Statute has been launched, that resources have been withdrawn before the Constitutional Court by the Government of Spain against laws of the Parliament, or that basic issues for the daily life of institutions such as infrastructure or the agreement for the financing of the Mossos d'Esquadra have been agreed upon, proves that dialogue and institutional cooperation between the Generalitat and the Government of Spain, despite the noise, is advancing and functioning. The task we have as both presidents is to consolidate those spaces. I insist, we will not be able to reach a political solution to the crisis that Catalonia has been going through for more than a decade without creating those spaces of trust and institutional loyalty.

- At the end of the meeting in Pedralbes, two ministers and two consellers attended the meeting. In the Generalitat, they call that a mini-summit. Is that a good definition?

- What there has been is a meeting between the president of the Government and the president of the Generalitat. Then there is the dialogue that we have always maintained with the consellera of Presidency and the vice president of the Generalitat. I wouldn't give it more significance than that.

"We are not in the same situation that led to 155"

- Is there some fatigue in your Government due to the efforts made to dialogue with the Govern without it having lowered its rhetoric?

- No, I assure you.

- But it is evident that there are barons of the PSOE who are not comfortable and criticize it.

- Well, the PSOE is a well-diverse organization, but that also responds to the territorial diversity of our country, where one can have a nuanced view of what Spain is. But the PSOE and this Government defend a progressive Spain, which looks to the future and does not want to repeat the mistakes of the more recent past, which wants to recognize rights and freedoms. A progressive Spain against the attempts of democratic regression that occur in the conservative space questioning an essential element of our constitution such as Title VIII and the autonomous state.

- Former President Aznar does not consider the PSOE to be constitutionalist.

- Listening to Aznar or some leaders of the conservative space say little less than those who do not defend their theses are not constitutionalist parties is something we have to combat with arguments. Disagreeing with the PP does not mean being against the Constitution. We defend a Constitution that, if it has had one success, has been to show that democracy and territorial diversity always go hand in hand.

- What you offer to Catalonia is to recognize that diversity?

- In the Council of Ministers, two measures with very important symbolic weight for Catalonia and Spain have been approved. Tarradellas and Companys are two presidents of the Generalitat who had to face very different historical circumstances, but the Government of Spain wants to highlight their names in the history of Catalonia. They defended coexistence, understanding, and dialogue. For me, dialogue must always be conducted within the Constitution and the Statute of Catalonia. Outside, there will only be monologues.

- When some media attribute to you a "surrender" in the meeting in Pedralbes, what do you think?

- Those are headlines that were already written. There is a space of political and media conservatism that does not want progress in dialogue. What we need to ask them is what solution they propose to resolve the crisis in Catalonia.

- The response seems to be the application of 155.

- Those whose only proposal is perpetual 155 aspire to perpetuate the crisis in Catalonia. It is always important to remember one thing: 155 was applied to recover the self-government in Catalonia that had been violated by independence after the disconnection laws of September 6 and 7 of last year and 27-0. I said it then, those who applied 155 were those who violated the Statute and the Constitution. It was the independence movement, and right now we are not in that situation.

"The solution to the Catalan crisis will take years; now we need to build spaces of trust"

- Does your strategy help or complicate that the only alternative from the right is the intervention of autonomy?

- It does not help me at all, among other things because it breaks something that had been good at such a difficult time as applying 155 in 2017, as a result of the declaration of independence of October 27. I have always reproached the lack of state opposition from the right, which has confused wearing down the Government with wearing down the State. Between perpetual 155 and the unilateralism that others proclaim, there is a space where the social majority of Catalonia and the whole country is found. And that is where we want to be, offering dialogue, agreement, and a commitment that guarantees coexistence in Catalan society.

- For that, you need the cooperation of the Catalan Government.

- That is why I encourage the Generalitat of Catalonia to move from the will for dialogue to real dialogue. This means that the Government is willing to dialogue with the Catalan institutions, but also, and the agreement of Thursday in Pedralbes reflects this, that a broad social majority is needed that does not currently exist in Catalonia. That is why I think it is a good initiative to have created that dialogue table that transcends the block dynamics that have prevailed in Catalonia over the last decade, and that is where the broad agreement referred to in yesterday's joint declaration must be forged.

- You have bet on lowering the tension with independence, but many Catalans reproach you for not having a concrete proposal to solve the fit of Catalonia. You have talked about a reform of the Statute, but with the composition of the Parliament and even of Congress, this is an unviable option at this time. Are we condemned not to face the round of the question for several years?

- I have always said that the solution to the Catalan crisis will take years. I said it in my speech during the motion of censure. The task we have for this legislature is to try to build spaces for dialogue, agreement, and institutional trust after a crisis in which positions have moved far apart. But if we go to the maximums, it will be difficult to find a minimum common denominator that allows us to start building the solution.

- For now, on Thursday, you decided to launch a stable dialogue space between governments.

- From that point of view, the attitude of the Generalitat to set up that bilateral commission to start talking about issues that affect the daily life of Catalan society is appreciated. It is also true that many of those agreements will only be able to materialize if we have state budgets. Without them, obviously, the fulfillment of commitments regarding the Mossos will not be able to materialize, but that is another debate.

- But where do you place the solution?

- We have always said that within the Constitution we can find a solution to the political crisis in Catalonia and that, evidently, it also has to go through the referendum of Catalan society. But the problem is not independence; it is coexistence.

- So, wouldn't it be necessary to reform the Constitution?

- The first thing we need to do is articulate a reform of the Statute that could be the solution.

- There was a time when you advocated for a plurinational state, but you have not raised it again. Is Spain ready for such a debate?

- I have always said that what differentiates me from sovereignty is that they identify nation with state and, therefore, with the exercise of self-determination. That is the discrepancy. We have always recognized the territorial diversity of the country, but with a single state, decentralized, but unique. The independence movement also has to see what is happening outside our country. The case of Scotland is evoked, when a second referendum is being requested and the debate has not been closed. The United Kingdom has subjected its citizens to decide whether they are British or European, and the situation we have is an implosion of its political system and an inability to materialize something that will evidently only bring poverty to British society.

"Spain needs social budgets; I want to fight for them to be approved"

- There have also been serious mistakes here.

- I believe that it is as important for Spanish politics to engage in self-criticism of the mistakes made in the past as it is for independence in Catalonia to do so. It is important to insist that the Govern must move from the proclamation of the will for dialogue to real dialogue around a table with the rest of the parliamentary forces.

- You have sought not to rule out a pardon for the independence prisoners. Do you think it is possible to seek a political solution if they are convicted?

- Politics cannot be judicialized nor can justice be politicized. One cannot pardon someone who has not been convicted. Let us respect the judicial process and not interfere.

- Wouldn't it be positive for the prisoners to be in a situation of conditional release to prepare for the trial?

- As president, I owe myself to the scrupulous respect of the separation of powers and I respect the decisions of the judicial power.

- This week you managed to get ERC and PDECat to support the new spending ceiling in Congress. Are we in the preamble to the approval of the budgets?

- I hope so. Spain needs social budgets that leave no one behind. Budgets that consolidate economic growth, job creation, that bet on science and the reconstruction of the welfare state. They are a determined commitment to the national dependency system, to the fight against child poverty, the increase of the minimum wage, and the revaluation of pensions at 1.6% for 2019.

- If you do not manage to approve the budgets, you have said that it will be difficult for you to complete your mandate in 2020. Do you not fear that the positive effect in the polls for the PSOE generated by the victory of the motion of censure may fade?

- If we take stock of the legislative production of the Government, it has been spectacular. More than a dozen royal decree laws have been validated, 11 bills will be approved this year, and more than thirty European directives have been transposed. The legislative production and the action of the government are irreproachable. This Government governs. And then it has support in Parliament, not only from ERC and PDECat, but also in some cases from Ciudadanos and the PP. From there, it is evident that the budgets are very important for any government. I want to fight for them to be approved in the first quarter of the year.

- If there were no budgets, do you rule out a super Sunday of elections?

- When elections are called, it will not be for the interest of the party, but for the general interest. And my vocation is to complete the legislature.

- The relationship between you and Pablo Iglesias seems to have improved. In contrast, there seems to have been a certain deterioration in the relationship with Albert Rivera, with whom you had reached agreements. There are those in your party who advocate a shift to achieve an agreement in the future with Ciudadanos...

- I believe that Rivera and Ciudadanos are following the path that the right has traditionally followed, which is to live off territorial grievances. They do not want to solve the crisis in Catalonia but to live off the crisis in Catalonia to try to scrape more votes in other parts of Spain. And it is a historical mistake. Ciudadanos bet on institutional and democratic regeneration in its early days, and with that Ciudadanos, I reached agreements. That Ciudadanos said it could not invest Mariano Rajoy because of corruption, but ultimately ended up supporting him. They are two very different Ciudadanos. I believe that Ciudadanos has chosen to understand itself with the Popular Party and Vox, and it is a historical mistake because one cannot call oneself a Europeanist while siding with anti-European forces such as the far right. I regret it, and I hope they can rectify in the future.

"The right attempts a democratic regression and questions the autonomies"

- Why does Vox suddenly appear? Why does it gain parliamentary representation? What has happened in Spain?

- Authoritarianism is a trend that is starting to become characteristic of global, European, and also Spanish politics. I am not so concerned about Vox, but rather its influence on the discourse of the PP and Ciudadanos. These parties are mistaken if they believe that the pact with Vox will moderate Vox. What it will do is radicalize the PP and Cs. Listening to some statements from Mr. Casado disqualifying his political opponents, talking about an illegitimate president, an unconstitutional president, a coup plotter, or what he says about the civil war and the shedding of blood are hyperbolic statements that demonstrate a significant degree of nervousness from the PP in relation to its ideological competition with Vox.

- What has happened in Andalusia? Why has the PSOE not been able to attract more votes at a time when it governs all of Spain?

- There are elements of a dynamic specific to Andalusia that have weighed in. One of them has to do with 36 years of government. Nevertheless, the PSOE won the elections; it is the first force in the Andalusian Parliament. What exists is the will of two forces that want to base the government on the far right. That is what is concerning, and that this situation could be transferred to other autonomous communities.

- There are people within the PSOE who attribute it to the fact that they did not talk about Catalonia during the campaign...

- Catalonia has influenced Spanish politics for decades. I believe since the beginning of democracy. I was young, and Felipe was already criticized for his understanding with Jordi Pujol and the famous 15% of personal income tax. Catalonia has always been a key element in the Spanish political debate. The crucial thing in Catalonia is to find points of trust, of loyalty, to guarantee coexistence, which is what is at risk. And that is what the Government will work on.

- Does the renewal of the PSOE in Andalusia involve a change in the leadership of Susana Díaz?

- I believe that Susana has to work to be the president of the Junta. She has the full support of the Government of Spain and the PSOE. Because we are interested in stability in Andalusia. In any case, it will have to be the party colleagues in that territory who make the appropriate decisions.

- Could Josep Borrell be a good candidate for the PSOE in the European elections?

- Borrell is doing a magnificent job as Minister of Foreign Affairs.

- So you rule him out?

- Borrell is a heavyweight in the Government of Spain. He would be an extraordinary candidate, but I tell you, he is also an extraordinary Minister of Foreign Affairs.

- Finally, have you arranged to meet with President Torra again?

- Yes, we will meet again. One of the things I mentioned to him is that we should have a more fluid relationship in communication and not just call each other when there is a disagreement.

- What is your opinion of President Torra? Some define him more as an activist than as a politician. Is that perceived?

- I believe he defines himself that way, but in terms of manners, although he is a person of strong convictions, he is someone who likes dialogue and shuns conflict. And that is to be appreciated.

- Will we see you often in Catalonia?

- I would like to.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of La Vanguardia.