Reply of the President of the Government to all parliamentary groups, in the Plenary of the Congress of Deputies.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

24 October 2018 · Reply of the President of the Government to all parliamentary groups in the Plenary of the Congress of Deputies · Plenary of the Congress of Deputies

Context
Sánchez addressed the Congress of Deputies plenary in October 2018, responding to parliamentary groups following government appearances on European Council meetings and Saudi Arabia.
Main themes
Parliamentary debate and opposition dynamics, Catalonia and constitutional issues, Brexit and Spanish citizens in the UK, Saudi Arabia, Article 155 and Article 113 of the Spanish Constitution, Popular Party and center-right politics, constructive motion of censure, political moderation and radicalization
Duration
~65 min
96th percentile
Words
7,796
96th percentile
Sentences
361
97th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
41st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 36%30%
  • Institutional 27%23%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Economic 13%11%
  • Social 7%6%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

361 sentences in 116 paragraphs

President.- Thank you, Madam President. Thank you to each and every one of the speakers in this debate, which is undoubtedly important.

I will respond to each of them in the order they spoke. First of all, I will respond to Mr. Casado, as the leader of the opposition and leader of the Popular Parliamentary Group.

And I would like to first convey a reflection to you, Mr. Casado. I believe that, well, this is the first time you have spoken from the podium during the Government's appearance, and therefore, I think it is necessary to lay the groundwork, at least for the relationship and parliamentary dialectic, which, without a doubt, at times, is difficult. I understand that the fervor of the moment may lead you, well, to say more words per minute than usual, or even the tone, but some of the things you said in your speech, I believe, are not acceptable: accusing me of being a participant and responsible for the coup d'état that is being perpetrated in our country is not something acceptable, Mr. Casado.

You have a huge opportunity now, in your rebuttal, to withdraw this statement. I explain to you why you should do it. I believe that, of course, we will have substantial differences in multiple areas, and we will reproach each other for many things. Well, that is part of the game, and it is acceptable. But you cannot reproach me for being a supposed 'coup plotter' or a supposed collaborator of the coup. Therefore, what I ask you, Mr. Casado, is to withdraw that statement here, when you come up to the podium, which only serves to fill your parliamentary group with ignominy.

In any case, all articles of the Constitution are important; you repeatedly point out Article 155 of the Spanish Constitution. Article 113 of the Spanish Constitution is also important, which establishes and constitutionally recognizes a constructive motion of censure, which is what this Government did when it was in opposition: proposing a constructive government option that is precisely doing many of the things you did not do when you were in government.

In any case, Mr. Casado, what I can tell you, at least as a recommendation, is to do opposition. To return to moderation, and to abandon the tension, the radicalization, because after all, I believe that is not, precisely, what the center-right voters of this country expect. They expect a renewed Popular Party. And to renew is to evolve, not to devolve. It is not to return to past theses that, precisely, have led you to be in opposition right now.

In any case, of course, I have difficulties in responding to some of the issues, because the object of the appearance was clearly the different Councils that have taken place, the Council of Article 50, the ordinary Council, or rather, the Euro Summit and, subsequently, also, logically, what has to do with the issue of Saudi Arabia.

You have not addressed any of these issues. Therefore, the reflection I would like to make to you, and I hope that perhaps you will clarify it for me in your second round of interventions, is whether you truly care about or are concerned with Brexit, the Spanish citizens living in the United Kingdom, the citizens of the United Kingdom living in Spain. The Spanish companies that have commercial interests and investments in the United Kingdom, because you have not referred to any of that, Mr. Casado.

You have come here to talk to us about everything except the objective of the appearance. Perhaps it is because you do not care. Perhaps it is because you are not interested. Perhaps it is because you are unaware. Well, but I am obliged to address some of the issues you have raised, because logically, if I do not respond to them, I would evidently not be fulfilling my duty.

Look, I have told you many times, in relation to Catalonia and the position that the Popular Party has maintained over the last 15 years. I see you many times now walking around with Aznar, presenting books, and making references to Aznarism. Well, you will have to see where you position yourself ideologically, whether in the center-right or in the right, or in the far right. But remember one thing, Mr. Casado: José María Aznar won the elections speaking Catalan in private. Remember what I have told you.

Because, of course, you come here and it seems that you have not been governing for the last seven years. You come here and it seems that you have not been in a party that, when a political proposal was made to resolve the Catalan issue, such as the Statute of Catalonia, set up petition tables in Andalusia, in all parts of Spain. I even remember ads made by the then president of the PP, Mr. Arenas, warning Andalusian children and families that as a result of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, they would end up learning Catalan in Andalusian schools.

Well, what I want to remind you, Mr. Casado, is your irresponsible opposition when Mr. Rajoy was president of the Popular Party, and Mr. Zapatero was president of the Government of Spain regarding the Statute of Autonomy. The unconstitutionality appeal before the Constitutional Court, which, by the way, when she was vice president of the Government, Ms. Soraya Sáenz de Santamaría said it was a mistake to have presented that unconstitutionality appeal. The two non-referendums that were held and proposed in Catalonia, the unilateral declaration of independence, the situation that led, last year, precisely, to the unprecedented application in the democratic history of our country of Article 155 of our Constitution.

Well, you should not come to a reflection that, perhaps, if what you are doing is again calling for the application of Article 155, it is because you have no discourse, no solution for Catalonia.

Moreover, it is striking that you said the other day in an interview in a digital medium that the first decision you would make would be the application of a hard Article 155. That is your political proposal to resolve the problems in Catalonia. A hard Article 155, as if there were a soft Article 155, a medium one...

Look, Article 155, Mr. Casado, must be taken with extraordinary responsibility. Look, I have heard you say in interviews that you would be willing to apply Article 155 even without the support of other parliamentary groups, particularly the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party.

Well, let me tell you, Mr. Casado, you are absolutely irresponsible. You are. You are. I do not know, honestly, Mr. Casado, you make it very easy for me, really, think about it when you get home. Reflect on the opposition strategy you are pursuing. You make it too easy. And, of course, do not break institutional consensuses.

If, unfortunately, we have to find ourselves in a situation similar to the one experienced a year ago, with a Government of the Popular Party that had, precisely, the firm support, safe, and even at times, biting our tongues, because there were issues that were not being sought, need a broad parliamentary consensus, Mr. Casado.

And, of course, that path you have chosen, I do not know where it will lead you, but reflect on one thing. Everything you are saying about territorial policy, everything you are saying about migration policy, does not benefit the Popular Party, it benefits Ciudadanos and Vox.

Venezuela. Venezuela, which, well, with Mr. Rivera is usually a common topic in control sessions, and in appearances when the left governs.

Look, I have to tell you, Mr. Casado, and I will also tell Mr. Rivera this with all due respect and without acrimony. You are unscrupulous politicians. Yes, yes. I will tell you why. Yes, listen to me. Do you know why? Because you are using the pain and suffering of the Venezuelan people for domestic consumption.

Of course, what do you care, that as the leader of the opposition I did not recognize the elections in Venezuela? What do you care about the meetings we have held with various leaders of the Venezuelan opposition? Tomorrow I will meet with another one that we have just freed in Venezuela, a student who has remained for many years in prison in Venezuela, as a result of the Maduro regime.

What do you care, Mr. Casado, that we supported in our first Council of Ministers of Foreign Affairs of the European Union all actions to tighten sanctions against the leaders of the Venezuelan regime, as this Government has precisely done? You do not care about that, because what you are trying to do is to convey and translate a political position, sensible, full of common sense, which is to maintain sanctions against the leaders of the Venezuelan regime, but also, from the point of view of the European Union, to facilitate a dialogue that is necessary to resolve a deep political crisis that Venezuela is experiencing, you do not care about that, because what you are trying to do is to capitalize on the crisis and the suffering and pain of Venezuela to reproach the Socialist Parliamentary Group and this Government for the support of Unidos Podemos.

Really, let’s speak clearly, if you do not care about Venezuela. What you care about is reproaching the support of Unidos Podemos to the Government of Spain, and that is to have no shame, Mr. Casado. That is to have no shame.

You also have a bad memory, Mr. Casado. Of course, you come here to say almost that when the Popular Party won, everything was advantages. There were commitments in all areas that were fulfilled by the Government of Spain towards the European Union.

I remind you, Mr. Casado, that under your government, the deficit targets were not met in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015. Yes, Mr. Casado. I must remind you, moreover, that the Government of Spain received, not from a general director, but from commissioners and the Vice President of the European Commission, at least two letters in 2016 and 2017 warning about the deviation of the deficit targets of the budgets you sent.

Well, I also do not want to fail to mention that you put Spain at the back of the line for the transposition of many community directives that this Government is now trying to push forward.

Therefore, the objective, or rather, the European commitment of your Government is not, by far, what this Government has. We are doing everything you did not do, and, by the way, I also tell you one thing, and to Mr. Rivera as well, because it seems that you do not remember that the objective or the forecast of public deficit you presented in 2018 was more than 4.6 billion euros. And even then, precisely, the European Commission warned that you were not going to reduce the structural deficit.

The response of the Government of Spain reduces the structural deficit by 0.4%. That is the degree of commitment that the Government of Spain has regarding what you proposed.

Well, it is also true that when you talk about the General State Budgets, there is one thing that seems to at least hold some hope, and that is that you will then stop blocking. We will be able to talk about the Budgets. Will you stop blocking in the Congress of Deputies, in a spurious manner, the modification of the Budgetary Stability Law that enjoys broad consensus and an absolute majority in this Parliament? That is respecting Parliament, Mr. Casado.

Well, I also tell you one thing to your colleagues in the Popular Parliamentary Group, and also in the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group, because as Mr. Rivera has appealed to socialist voters. Well, these Budgets are Budgets, gentlemen, loaded with common sense. Common sense. Or is it not common sense to recover the unemployment subsidy for the unemployed over 52 years old?

Or is it not common sense to recover the Social Security contributions of non-professional caregivers, who are mostly women, relatives of dependents?

Or is it not common sense to increase investment in R&D+i, and in Science in this country by 6.7%?

Or is it not common sense to raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage to 900 euros, in a country whose labor reality is dramatic, with six million workers earning less than 600 euros a month? Is it not common sense?

I am convinced that there are voters of the Popular Party and Ciudadanos who consider this to be common sense.

So, you must approve the General State Budgets, Mr. Casado.

But, well, of course, you talk about Gibraltar. Look, Mr. Casado, I will tell you one thing, because the position that the Government of Spain has maintained, which the Government of Spain is maintaining in the negotiation with the United Kingdom is the same that was maintained by former minister Dastis and Mr. Rajoy.

No, no, look, talk to Mr. Margallo and speak with Mr. Dastis. Believe me when I tell you. Talk to Mr. Dastis and also talk to Mr. Rajoy. Talk less with Aznar, and talk a little with Rajoy, you will see that the position that the Government of Spain has is the same that the previous Government maintained regarding Gibraltar.

If the matter is very clear, Mr. Casado. Inform yourself well.

Let's see: one thing is the Withdrawal Agreement and another thing is the political declaration on the future relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union. What we are dealing with now is the Withdrawal Agreement, in what is the transition period. And that is what the previous Popular Party Administration foresaw, and which we have continued. We have inherited it, and as it is a matter of state, we are following the same line, which is to agree on a protocol, a protocol of relationship on such a fundamental issue as Gibraltar. Nothing more. It addresses issues related to citizens' rights, air transport, taxation, the environment, fishing, judicial cooperation, customs. That is what is inscribed in the protocol. From there, there are logically, as the spokesperson for the Socialist Parliamentary Group has said before, four memorandums of understanding that we are currently negotiating with the United Kingdom.

One is a much more precise aspect of citizenship rights. Another on police and customs cooperation. Another on the environment and fishing. Another on tobacco. And another on cooperation and the tax treaty. And I must tell you that we have practically reached agreements on the first three, and where we have, obviously, difficulties is in those related to tobacco and the tax agreement.

Now, do not misinterpret my words. Do not twist my words. Do not manipulate them. I am not saying that if there is an agreement, fine, and if not, that’s fine too. What I have said is that there is already a protocol, which has been agreed upon, which has the support of the chief negotiator on behalf of the European Union, Mr. Barnier. That is the protocol. An agreement has been reached that is consistent not only with the position maintained by this Government but also the previous one. And that we are negotiating four memorandums with the United Kingdom in relation to Gibraltar.

If we reach those agreements, then good. And if not, then it’s no big deal, because we have already signed and reached an agreement regarding the protocol. And I think this is important because Brexit cannot be stopped because of this, but, logically, Brexit cannot happen without taking into account the aspect of Gibraltar as we have considered from the very beginning.

In short, Mr. Casado, I would like to have a much more fruitful debate, less of chest-thumping, --I have to tell you--, less of tension, more moderation, more future, with the Popular Party.

In the first and last meeting I had with you, Mr. Casado, I offered you four agreements, five agreements, I believe I remember, one of them was on migration. You dismissed them, you rejected them. You have not spoken about science, nor about infrastructure, nor about Europe; you don’t care. You spread and export your irresponsibility throughout Europe. No problem.

I also tell you one thing, Mr. Casado: the Spanish are taking note. Believe me, they are taking note. They are taking note and I tell you one thing, you did not know how to govern and you do not know how to oppose. And at the rate you are going, you will be in opposition for many years.

Regarding Mr. Iglesias' intervention, I would like to raise a preliminary point, and it is precisely in relation to the comment he made, with the digression he made about Brexit and Catalonia. I believe that, well, he was speaking first of all about the form, and also about the substance. About the way of doing politics that has led to Brexit. And, precisely, he was calling on everyone, all parties. He was not only reproaching that some forces are currently defending the independence of Catalonia without looking at the political consequences that are being suffered and that will be suffered much more intensely when Brexit materializes. And he was also talking about us, about that part that is not in favor of that segregation, of that separation, that defends the unity of Spain, that defends that there can be territorial diversity, a recognition of the territorial diversity of our country, without undermining equality among Spaniards, and that if there was a point of union, if there was a common denominator, it was precisely the strengthening of the European Union.

And I regret to disagree with Mr. Esteban. I did not say that the independence forces are anti-European forces; on the contrary. They are forces that defend another type of Europe.

What I say is, after Brexit, the European Union must be strengthened, and if the European Union must be strengthened, --and that is the great opportunity that Brexit presents-- for those of us who remain in the European Union. What we will have to do will not be to centrifuge, what we will have to do will be to open processes of federal integration. And I believe that this is the great way, the great avenue that we can also take as a lesson to resolve the Catalan issue on a national level.

And, of course, not only to them, but also to us, I believe we must take note of what has happened in Brexit and be very aware that if Brexit won, even if it was by 51%, probably, no, surely it had a lot to do with the lack of reform of the European Union. And also the lack of reforms in the United Kingdom on issues that later translated into a vote against the system, whether it be the British or the European one.

Therefore, I believe that what I was doing was reflecting on the reform, the transformation, and the need for both sides to be aware of what we are risking. Because we are already living the historical mistakes.

And, look at what Brexit is costing a country, which is the United Kingdom, that had its own currency, its own Central Bank. What it will cost, well, imagine, in something much closer like a potential segregation of a part of our territory with which we share not only a Central Bank but also currency, culture, history, and multiple issues.

This is simply the approach I wanted to make. The reflection I wanted to make in relation to Brexit, to translate it into a domestic political context.

I cannot agree with you, Mr. Iglesias, that we are having a low profile in international politics. On the contrary, I believe that, --and I want to convey this to you--, being at the United Nations General Assembly and conveying the commitment that this Government has to feminism, to gender equality, or conveying the commitment that this Government has to an approach to the phenomenon of migration that respects human rights. Or conveying that Spain has returned to the path of environmental commitments, and that we take the 2030 Agenda very seriously, and that we take the commitments linked to the Paris Agreements very seriously, which have been reproached by some interveners to whom I will refer later. I believe that it is precisely the opposite, that we do not have a low profile, we have a profile in line with the size and importance of our country.

Therefore, both on the climate issue and on the 2030 Agenda issue, these are two references that we, as a Government, defended incorporating into the resolutions of the European Council, and there they are.

I share with you the reflection you made about security. It is striking that the one who has drawn attention and reprimanded the European Commission is a Government that includes some extremists, with whom the Popular Parliamentary Group ideologically collaborates.

Mr. Casado, can you tell us what essential values you share with Vox?

Mr. Rivera, can you tell us why you do not reject Vox's participation in the event you are going to propose and celebrate in Navarra?

But I believe that, indeed, one of the great messages we have conveyed to the entire European Union is that, precisely, two leftist forces, such as Unidos Podemos and the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, can implement expansive policies, policies for the reconstruction of the welfare state, labor rights policies, with such an important increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, as is included in the agreement, without having to question, as the Italian Government does, the path of stability, and the stability and growth pact of the European Union.

And, in that sense, I believe that the appreciation you have made, certainly, has my support, and I fully share it. In fact, other issues that we have also raised in this European Council and that, unfortunately, have found little success in the various interventions have been the Spanish Government's proposal to create a Security Fund for Unemployment. Not only to talk about Banking Union, not only to talk about the need to finish and complete the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), but why not start talking about Fiscal Union. And why not start talking about the need to stabilize, through public investments, at the European level, such as, for example, a community unemployment fund.

On the issue of Saudi Arabia, Mr. Iglesias, ladies and gentlemen, because it has been touched upon logically in each and every one of the interventions, I will say the following: let’s see, we as a Government must respect the contracts of the Administration. That is legal certainty. This is a contract that was signed by the previous Administration, and consequently, the only thing we can do is ensure that it is fulfilled. From there we must be aware that our relationship with Saudi Arabia is not limited solely and exclusively to the sale of defense material, or to the sale of arms. It encompasses multiple areas related to business investments, with commercial investments that provide for many people in Spain. That create jobs.

And, therefore, in that sense, I, in the intervention, what I have come to say is that of course we reject any violation of human rights; of course we reject and condemn, as we have made public, as the Government of Spain at the level of the European Union, and also, at the level of the United Nations, because we have aligned ourselves, precisely, with their proposals for concluding the investigation, for those responsible to be held accountable, in accordance with the legislation and justice for those who may have committed this terrible crime against Jamal Khashoggi and, of course, from there, we will have to take note. We will have to take note in relation to Saudi Arabia.

What have we proposed? Well, we have proposed that we can strengthen our ex-post verification controls of the arms that may be sold to third countries, such as, in this case, to Saudi Arabia.

But, in any case, we must combine that respect that, logically, the Government of Spain has for multilateralism, peace, freedom, and the defense of human rights, with, of course, the fulfillment of contracts from previous administrations, which is what this Government has done.

I also tell you one thing, we are willing to talk with all parliamentary forces and with all institutions about the need to reorient the arms industry in our country, but we must be aware that we cannot do this in one day, or in two days, or in three days. Nor in the short term. Therefore, if we want to protect jobs, as I am convinced we all want to protect those of us present here, and, consequently, also reorient, at the same time, the arms industry, let’s do it, but let’s set deadlines. In this regard, I can guarantee that the Government of Spain is open to your suggestions.

I share with Mr. Esteban that, indeed, what we need is a European position on arms sales, because there is, indeed, some hypocrisy here, there is no commercial equity. And, therefore, the impact that certain positions may have, which are not European, as community ones, affects some more than others. And, we, logically, must be aware of everything that this implies, everything that would come behind it.

And, fourthly, I also share with some other speakers that arms sales require an international awareness and also global legislation. And, in that sense, as a Government, we are willing to participate in that reflection.

What I would say to Mr. Iglesias, as well as to Ms. Martina, Mr. Bustamante, and Mr. Gómez, and it is something I said in my first intervention, that no one questions the pacifist commitment, nor the anti-militarist commitment of mayors, also from your party, from the Bay of Cádiz, because they are aware of what the implications are in labor terms, in social terms that any breakdown in relation to Saudi Arabia may have.

You yourself, Mr. Iglesias, said on one occasion that you understood that 'Kichi', the mayor of Cádiz, put the contracts of the workers first. Well, all I ask is that you also take that consideration into account when addressing this Government and myself.

Logically, what I have to do is balance both interests, but do not doubt that we are with peace, with freedom, that we are absolutely dismayed, that we reject what has happened in the Saudi Consulate in Turkey, but that, logically, we also have to defend Spain's interests. And I believe that they are perfectly compatible within the framework in which I have tried to develop our position as a Government.

Mrs. Martín has made a reflection that I do not share. First of all, Trudeau did not say what you commented. Simply, the Prime Minister of Canada did not say what you mentioned to me, just so you have it as information.

And, secondly, there has been no change in position, I say it again. I have said it in previous appearances, but I also say it again today: there has been no change in position regarding the 'Aquarius'. Moreover, it was precisely the 'Aquarius 1' that brought the 'Aquarius 2' and the 'Aquarius 3'. And right now, what the Government of Spain is focused on is precisely trying to articulate a mechanism of solidarity and co-responsibility for the migrants who are currently at risk of drowning in the Mediterranean.

So much so, so much so, ladies and gentlemen, so you can see that the position of the Government of Spain on this matter has not changed at all, that we are taking care not only of the migrants who arrive on the shores of Spain, but we are also taking care of migrants who are at risk of drowning in the Mediterranean. There is no government in Europe that is assuming the burden of solidarity and responsibility that the current Government of Spain is.

Regarding Mr. Rivera, I reiterate the proposal on the issue of Saudi Arabia. I mentioned it before in my first intervention. Also, now, in response to Mr. Iglesias. The proposal is to implement a post-sale verification system for arms sales. That is what we want to do. Of course, Spain's position is the defense, as I said before, of human rights, but also to take responsibility for the contracts made by previous administrations.

I will also tell you one thing, ladies and gentlemen from the different parliamentary groups. Also, in relation to Mr. Tardá's intervention. At this moment, there is no pending arms sale by the Ministry of Defense; the only one that has occurred was for 400 bombs, signed by the previous Administration, and this Government as such has not sold any type of arms to Saudi Arabia, and there is nothing pending, neither in process nor signed. I insist. There has been no sale during these more than three months that I have been at the head of the Government of arms to Saudi Arabia. There is neither anything pending, nor anything in process, nor anything signed. Therefore, I believe that the commitment of the Government of Spain is quite clear, quite firm, and unequivocal. The only thing we are doing is respecting a contract signed by the previous Administration.

Mr. Rivera, you always hold up President Macron, the President of France, as a fetish. I must tell you that you should inform yourself a little more and better about the things that Mr. Macron says, because, evidently, Macron has completely separated himself from Germany's position. Yes, there was a three-way declaration between the United Kingdom, France, and Germany, indeed, on Saturday. On Sunday, what happened was a distancing by Chancellor Merkel. By the way, 'in voce' because there is no official statement in writing from the Government of Germany. And just yesterday, Mr. Macron completely distanced himself from Merkel's position.

So, I simply ask you to inform yourself before telling us or expressing your opinions because, on some occasions, you slip up, to use a colloquial term.

Come on, Mr. Rivera, I would be a bit humble. I would recommend a bit of humility. No, because, come on, you go around giving lessons to other parliamentary groups about your supposed brotherhood with other political formations. You who associated with Libertas, Mr. Rivera.

Of course, you also criticize. It doesn't matter what you do, because it is, of course, subject to criticism. "All to stay 15 more minutes at the head of La Moncloa," this is the tagline you are going to repeat until the date of the elections, Mr. Rivera. Perfect. No problem. You will have to use it for quite some time. I have to say it.

But, of course, you criticize me even for going to Cuba. But three Popes have gone, Mr. Rivera. You also show a lack of understanding of the implications and the deep meaning of our relationship with Cuba. Don't you find it reproachable that for more than 30 years there has been no Prime Minister who has gone to Cuba? Don't you find it reproachable? I mean, what do you think about Obama, Hollande, who have gone, three Popes? Do you find all that reproachable? All just to criticize the evil Mr. Sánchez who wants to continue 15 minutes at the head of the Government of Spain.

Mrs. Rivera, please, it's like when you talk about constitutionalists. Allow me to tell you, we are the constitutionalists who are sitting here. Each and every one of us, the 350 deputies, Mr. Rivera.

Yes, yes, they are. Do you know why, Mr. Rivera? Because they present themselves under the rules set out in the Spanish Constitution, yes, under the Organic Law of the Electoral Regime. That which you want to modify, precisely. Also, Mr. Casado, to illegalize all those parties that do not think like him.

And then, well, we obviously enter the territory of modernity. Mr. Rivera always comes here and tells us what is modern and what is not modern. So, it is not modern to defend, ladies and gentlemen, the feminism, what can we do? It is not modern to mobilize on March 8 with the women of this country in favor of labor equality. What is modern, Mr. Rivera, is to defend surrogacy. That is modern.

It is not modern to raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, unless Mr. Rivera asks for it, which he did in 2008, --one thousand euros--, and, on the other hand, it seems that if we propose a raise of 900 euros from Unidos Podemos and the evil socialist government, then it is simply an improper caciquism of these times.

What is modern, as I told you before, and reminded Mr. Casado, is that six million workers earn less than 600 euros a month in our country. That is what is modern for Mr. Rivera.

In short, Mr. Rivera, the reflection I would like to make to you, of course, one sees what Mr. Casado says, and what Mr. Rivera says and says, well, we have twins on the Spanish right. Now it turns out that a triplet has come out. Has that triplet not come out by feeding the far-right discourse that you, irresponsibly, and Mr. Casado are feeding?

Regarding Mr. Tardá, I believe that in everything that represents Saudi Arabia, I have set the position of the Government of Spain and I do not want to extend much more on it, I just want to remind you that this Government has not sold any type of arms to Saudi Arabia. We have neither done it, nor is there anything pending, nor in process, nor signed. I insist, the only thing we have done is respect the legal security and respect contracts that were signed by previous Administrations.

You referred to the censure of the King that took place in the Parliament of Catalonia; yesterday I had the opportunity to respond to a senator from Esquerra Republicana on this issue, and what I tell you is the following, Mr. Tardá: you have overstepped the scope of competencies of the Parliament of Catalonia. You are questioning the form of the Spanish State and that is debated in the Congress of Deputies, not in any autonomous parliament. And, therefore, the obligation of this Government is to appeal this decision to the Constitutional Court, as we are going to do.

And, in relation to Quebec, well, I had the opportunity to be in Montreal, precisely with Prime Minister Trudeau, and there I reflected on Quebec, and the reflection I made on Quebec is that, regardless of what path Canada embarked on or what path we may take here to resolve the Catalan issue, certainly, the lesson we must draw from Quebec is that, of course, if we believe in politics, we will find a political solution to the conflict in Catalonia.

I believe that if one looks at what the agreement reached in Quebec was, it is difficult for some of the independentist leaders to be willing to transfer it here to Spain.

But, in any case, I will tell you one thing, Mr. Tardá: I was very struck by the reflection made by Mr. Maragall, the Minister of Foreign Relations, in an interview on the BBC. I was very struck because he precisely said that while independence in Catalonia did not have 50% support, it was very difficult to defend a referendum in Catalonia.

Well, we are making some progress, because, evidently, you are already recognizing that you do not have a social majority in Catalonia to impose that self-determination referendum on the other side.

Therefore, I return to the same point, Mr. Tardá. What is important? What is important is that you open a dialogue process with the non-nationalist part of Catalonia. When you carry out that dialogue process with the non-nationalist part of Catalonia and we all find an agreement that represents 70% or 80% of Catalan society, I am convinced that we will be able to give course and solution to the political crisis being experienced in Catalonia, also here, in the Congress of Deputies.

To Mr. Esteban, I would say, as a representative of the Basque Nationalist Party, that I can only agree that sometimes when one goes to these European Councils, one realizes that, indeed, things could go faster, but they are going excessively slowly on issues that are urgent for the entire European citizenry, migration, the Economic and Monetary Union, without a doubt, are, or, for example, Brexit.

I believe that in relation to Brexit and the digression I made linked to Catalonia, I have already responded to you before. In relation to Gibraltar, I believe I have also done so. And, in relation to migration, I will tell you several things. The first, regarding unaccompanied foreign minors. You know that we made a budget modification to put 40 million euros on the table and help the Autonomous Communities that are currently receiving those minors, to be able to support them. Because, indeed, as we often say, first they are minors and then they are migrants, and therefore they have a series of rights as minors that must be safeguarded and recognized by the different administrations.

And, I will also tell you that in this Council of Ministers we are going to approve a Royal Decree where those Autonomous Communities that have already shown their willingness to be supportive in the distribution of those unaccompanied foreign minors will start to be given a channel.

Therefore, what we have to do is tell the other Autonomous Communities that are still not doing it, that have not yet shown that willingness, to do so, because I believe that it is precisely in the interest of all. But what this Government is doing, certainly, in the area of unaccompanied foreign minors, I believe is what we must do, and what we must do is put economic resources to bring them to the municipalities and the Autonomous Communities and also enable this system of distribution of minors to all Autonomous Communities. We would like all Autonomous Communities to participate, but in any case, I leave the announcement there, Mr. Esteban. This Friday's Council of Ministers will approve the Royal Decree that will start to materialize that distribution mechanism among Autonomous Communities of the so-called MENAS.

You have indeed recalled the words of Tusk. To clarify, I never defended regional platforms. What I have been able to propose together with President Macron are reception centers on the European continent. Regional platforms are something that any North African country, or practically all African countries, if not all, have completely rejected, and I understand it. I understand it because, in the end, it is externalizing the management that we now have to do daily on our continent. And, in reality, they would again have the same problems with those regional platforms that we currently have regarding migratory flows, regarding return policies, and regarding integration policies.

We, I conveyed this to the President of the Council, do not believe in regional platforms. Of course, in conclusions that represent and have the pen of 28 member states, there are things in which we recognize ourselves, and in others in which we do not recognize ourselves. Or we do not recognize ourselves as much. This, for example, is one of those issues. But, of course, we are not in favor of those regional platforms.

And I must also tell you, based on the impression I got from the debate that took place at the European Council, that fewer and fewer countries believe in this type of solution. And those who do believe are very much linked to political positions regarding migration and Europe that have nothing to do with us.

We do defend, and I said it in my first intervention, that Africa-European Union Alliance. I must tell you that in December there will be, precisely, a meeting between European countries and African countries to talk not about migration, but about economic development, and Spain will participate in that. And, of course, also, following the speech of the European Union by Mr. Juncker, there were two elements that he raised and that we are willing to discuss with them. One has to do with something you mentioned, and that is precisely the asylum directive. I must tell you that many countries are also very attentive to the reform. We would like it to happen as soon as possible.

I must tell you that I, within the European Council, defended that this reform should be completed before the end of the year, but unfortunately we ended up with a "as soon as possible," that is, as soon as possible, which, logically, did not satisfy us, but we did not want to block the agreement over this issue.

Another issue has to do with Mr. Juncker's proposal regarding the reform of the Return Directive. And, in this, we have indeed expressed our doubts, although, logically, we will see what the European Commission proposes in this regard.

Mr. Xuclà has also spoken to me about Catalonia, and I believe I have responded previously. Regarding the resources before the Constitutional Court, we will examine this issue that you have mentioned to us. I must also acknowledge that, well, I think that we will be satisfied with the parliamentary groups that agree on reducing the level of conflict, that everything related to the recovery of public universality has implied, among other things, that we desist from that unconstitutionality appeal; and from others that have to do with energy matters. And I believe that this is the line we should follow.

In relation to North Macedonia, I must tell you that the Government's support is unequivocal. We certainly support the resolution of the Parliament. We regret, unfortunately, what happened in the outcome of the referendum, but, in any case, I believe it is an extraordinary opportunity for both the European Union and NATO, that we can resolve this political crisis.

I must acknowledge, of course, the leadership and courage of the Greek Prime Minister, Alexis Tsipras, and also of the Prime Minister of North Macedonia because, precisely, by facing the radicals, confronting the radicalism of their countries, what they have done is offer a horizon of concord that I believe is worthy of applause.

Mr. Bataller has also spoken to me about Saudi Arabia. I believe we have already explained what the Government's position is. I will also tell you one thing, ladies and gentlemen, we are with the European position. Just yesterday, it seems to me, when Ms. Mogherini intervened in the European Parliament regarding this issue. And we are supporting the same position that the High Representative of the European Union is defending on the issue of Saudi Arabia. The same position.

To Mr. Matute, well, I think the important thing is to maintain that balance that I have expressed from the podium, in what represents respect for human rights and what represents the responsibility we have with the fulfillment of certain contracts from previous administrations.

To Mr. Allí, I would say the same reflection I made to Mr. Rivera, we are all constitutionalist forces, even those forces that want to break with the Constitution are constitutionalists because they present themselves through laws that stem from the Spanish Constitution.

In short, I take note regarding the levels of budget execution for Navarra before calling general elections.

And, in relation to Mr. Martínez, I would like to convey that nothing could be further from our reality. Complying with the law is not fundamentalism, Mr. Martínez, it is not. Defending labor rights is not fundamentalism. Defending our climate and environmental commitments is not fundamentalism. What I believe it is, is responsibility. And the irresponsibility was precisely what you and the previous Government manifested without providing a solution or a horizon of improvement for the mining basins of Asturias, as a consequence of the abandonment they were subjected to during the last seven years. I believe that we, it seems to me, tomorrow, Madam Minister, or today, will sign an agreement for mining in Asturias with the main social agents, and I believe this will be very important for the well-being and prosperity of Asturias.

Two more issues, to Mr. Quevedo and Ms. Oramas. To Mr. Quevedo, I must say that it is true, we would like things to move faster in the European Union regarding migration issues. I will also tell you one thing: one of the main agreements that will be reached, --if it has not already been, we practically have it completed--, is to increase Frontex by 10,000 personnel, and I believe this is important for everything related to border control.

And, secondly, to Ms. Oramas, I would like to acknowledge the request you made to convene the Autonomous Conference for European Union Affairs, the CARUE, we will do it. I believe it is important to do so in the context of Brexit, I take your proposal into consideration. I would like to convey that, regarding the financial perspectives, the Government of Spain is defending two issues. The first is that these financial perspectives be approved before the European elections. That is, that the Union's budgetary horizon be clarified as soon as possible. I must tell you that this is the position of the Government of Spain. There are also other governments that defend this same position, but unfortunately, I fear that it will not be possible. But that is the position, at least, of the Government of Spain.

And, secondly, within that debate, and I know that the Government in the Canary Islands has spoken with the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, we are clearly defending the interests of fishing, the interests of the Common Agricultural Policy, and the interests of the Cohesion Funds.

That is the position of the Government, that there should be no regression in economic resources for the CAP and for cohesion policies that are so fundamental for many territories in our country.

Ladies and gentlemen, I hope I have responded, if not satisfactorily, to many of the issues you have raised, but yes to establish a position on elements that are fundamental in Spanish politics such as Brexit, migration policy, and what has to do with relations with third countries, in this case, with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

I remain at your disposal to answer other questions. And I hope those questions are about what concerns us. What concerns us today, in this debate. On these issues and not on domestic politics where there will be an opportunity to talk about those and other issues in other appearances.