Speech by President of the Government at forum organised by Reuters News Agency

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

27 September 2018 · Forum organised by the Reuters News Agency · New York

Context
Sánchez spoke at a Reuters-organised forum in New York on 27 September 2018, discussing his first 120 days in office, European affairs, and migration policy.
Main themes
European Union integration, migration policy, pro-European stance, border control, FRONTEX, migrant integration, Spain's government first 120 days, Catalonia, populism and far-right, development cooperation with African countries, public deficit and macroeconomic stability
Duration
~52 min
95th percentile
Words
6,258
95th percentile
Sentences
289
95th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 35%34%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

289 sentences in 101 paragraphs

Q.- Hello and welcome. I am here on behalf of Reuters and it is a great pleasure to welcome the President of the Government of Spain.

Today, I believe you have now held office for 120 days and hence, I hope that we can talk about how these first 120 days have gone and what you expect from the future. And since we are in New York, perhaps we could start with some more global issues and then I promise to return to the subject of Catalonia and issues affecting Spanish politics, and how long you could last until elections are called. But let's start with international affairs.

Starting with Europe, you are clearly perceived as a much more pro-European President of the Government than some of your recent predecessors. But what does that mean in practice? What does greater involvement in Europe mean? How may this be positive for Spain?

President of the Government.- Firstly, I would like to say that for me it is a great honour to be here. Secondly, and as regards the European Union, I would say that Europe is very important for the people of Spain. Traditionally, when you ask them, above all, those people over the age of 45 or 50, they identify with the ideals of the European Union, with democracy, with freedoms. That is why our country is so pro-European, because it represents very many things for the Spanish people; very positive things.

And well, I believe we conveyed a very clear message when we formed this new government, in the sense that we were going to comply with all our commitments with the European Union, in terms of the public deficit, the public debt, and all the macro-economic stability parameters. But we also sent out a very clear message on the matter of the vessel Aquarius , in that the migratory crisis must also be managed from a European perspective, that it is a common challenge that requires joint responses. That is why a country like Spain which is, shall we say, on the front line, because we are very close to North Africa, is prepared to provide a joint and effective response, maintaining European values and respect for human rights. And I truly think that this is a fundamental difference in relation to the attitudes of some other government leaders of EU countries.

And if we think about what may happen in the European Union in the coming months, after elections to the European Parliament, I think that there will perhaps be a greater presence of less pro-European representatives in the European Parliament, but even so, I believe that we will have a majority of pro-European MEPs in Parliament and on the European Council.

Q.- Talking about migration, although this was an issue I was going to bring up later, you are, as you mentioned, right on the front line, and you have been considerably more receptive to taking in emigrants, above all, from North Africa, than other countries, but do you have the necessary resources to cater for and take in all these emigrants?

President of the Government.- We are clearly under a great deal of pressure and we must give over far more public resources to effectively respond to the challenges posed by migration in Spain.

But I would say, firstly, that when these political parties, these populists and radical right wing parties talk about migration, they only focus on border control which, of course, is important. But it is clearly also necessary to have a global perspective on what this migratory policy means, firstly, and above all, to strengthen cooperation and dialogue with the countries of origin and transit, something which the Government of Spain is working on, and which we would call for the EU institutions to continue working on as well, as indeed they have been doing very effectively to date. This means, of course, collaborating, contributing to the economic development of these countries so that they can offer opportunities, and also to supply them with materials, with the necessary infrastructures so that they can effectively control their borders, which is something that we are doing at this time, with these countries that are so close to Spain.

And secondly, of course, you have the issue of border control. And in this regard, I believe that at the next European Council an agreement will be reached to increase the resources and capabilities of FRONTEX, which is the European Union agency to manage issues related to border security.

And thirdly, and something that is very important in my opinion, you have integration policies. When we had a migratory crisis back in the years 2004-2006, with the arrival of a great many emigrants from Senegal and Mauritania, above all, to the Canary Islands, we carried out a very exhaustive integration policy with these migrants. And that is something that the European Union is currently doing. Unfortunately, the previous Government of Spain did nothing in terms of integration policies, and that is something we are going to rectify.

Q.- And do you have domestic support to take in more emigrants because I know that in other countries there has been a great deal of tension, such as Germany and Italy?

President of the Government.- Traditionally, Spain was a country of emigrants. During the dictatorship, it had its own refugee crisis, whereby a great many Spaniards had to flee Spain because of the civil war and subsequent dictatorship. They went to Venezuela, Argentina, Cuba and many other Latin American countries. That is why, let's say, we feel this solidarity with emigrants and those who are displaced in our historical conscience.

Secondly and unfortunately, we have many young people who, due to the economic crisis, have been forced to leave our country because they couldn't find the right opportunities in our country. And that also leads us to feel great empathy with those societies that are taking in our younger generations.

Furthermore, we have an economic structure which, in certain specific sectors, needs legal emigration. Hence, we are in favour of legal emigration. We are opposed to illegal emigration, but this is something that we are clearly still debating and negotiating with the European Union institutions so as to be able to offer legal emigration opportunities to certain sectors that require a large labour force, sectors in which a great many emigrants could be contracted to meet the demand of these sectors.

And as I said before, when I spoke about the need to step up cooperation and dialogue with the countries of origin and transit, I believe that a great opportunity also exists through new mechanisms for legal emigration to help prevent illegal emigration.

Q.- One of the trends in Europe over recent years has been the resurge in populism. There are increasingly more far-right governments. And you clearly don't favour this approach. What do you feel you can do as the President of the Government of Spain? Or what do you believe can be done to reverse these trends?

President of the Government.- Well, I believe that we have to be very clear, forceful and state to our societies, to our citizens, that this is a fight between those who believe in an open society and other parties that believe in closed societies.

We believe in diversity; we believe in social inclusion and in progressive policies for a 21st Century society. And this is something which is absolutely fundamental and defining for us.

We absolutely believe in legal immigration. And we also believe in gender equality and in equal opportunities for everyone, and we believe that there must be a fair tax system and we believe in human rights, and we believe that climate change is a threat that transcends all ideologies, and that we must work to protect the environment, all fighting climate change together.

I think that this type of attitude of denial that we see in different parts of the world must be tackled in a very clear fashion, an approach which, in my opinion, is shared by the vast majority of our societies.

And the problem is that these parties and these groups make a lot of noise, but I firmly believe that they are in a minority. They will clearly try and influence politics, and this is already the case, above all when you have to talk with these far-right parties that are influencing politics in Europe, but I feel that major opportunities also exist for progressive politics and to claim back the core values of the societies we defend and in which we believe.

Q.- That leads me to ask you about the United States, since you are here and taking into account what you have just said. Have you spoken much with President Trump? And how do you see relations between Spain and the United States at this time?

President of the Government.- The truth is that I have not had the chance to speak with him, just a brief greeting at the last NATO Summit in Brussels, before the summer, but I think that he is committing certain errors in his relations with the European Union. I think that a stronger Europe is clearly interesting and benefits the US Administration and the United States. We are talking about peace, economic prosperity, democracy, which are all core values of the European Union. I believe that a strong EU is interesting and beneficial for the United States and its administration. Hence, although there may be some ups and downs in relations, which have traditionally been excellent, between Europe and the United States, what I can tell you is that the Member States of the European Union want and intend to continue strengthening and maintaining trans-Atlantic cooperation despite any differences, despite any problems and despite having different approaches on many global issues, such as trade or climate change, or in terms of the ideal concept of multilateralism. What I have seen to date on the part of the European Union is a clear willingness to continue strengthening our relations with the US Administration and with the United States.

Q.- And what is your reaction to the speech by President Trump at the United Nations?

President of the Government.- I wasn't greatly surprised, because it is not the first time that I have heard him say such things. I respect his opinions. I remember when I attended my first international meeting at that NATO Summit in Brussels and well, I said to him that I understood his demands for NATO Member States and allies to increase their defence budgets, but I think that if we are very clear and honest, which is necessary between allies, when you look at and evaluate the contributions from the Member States in terms of defence, this cannot only be measured through this 2% of GDP; you must also take into account the participation of our troops, of our capabilities on NATO mission in Iraq, Latvia and Turkey, on all those missions we are taking part in, and also clearly how military resources and capabilities are shared in the south of Spain, which contributes to the security of the United States in a highly positive fashion.

I believe that he is making a tremendous mistake when he says that the European Union is a rival, or an enemy. I believe that the European Union is not an enemy in any way whatsoever to the United States. The European Union is very clearly an ally of the United States. And, I repeat that a strong Europe contributes a great deal more to the prosperity and security of the United States. And this is something in which I firmly believe and which, moreover, seems like a question of pure common sense to me, and this is an idea we share with the other Member States of the European Union.

Q.- Well, let's put that mystery aside. You have announced that you will make an official visit to Cuba. I think that you will be the first President of the Government of Spain to visit Cuba in more than 30 years. Why is this visit important and what do you hope to achieve? By the way, no dates have yet been announced. Can you give us a general idea of when the visit will take place?

President of the Government.- We are trying to firm up this visit to Cuba before the end of the year. Let's see if we manage to achieve that. Firstly, we clearly have very important historical ties with Cuba. Secondly, it is a little strange that politics always come after the reality of things, because there are a large number Spanish companies, of Spanish citizens, our cultural sector, ties that have been established with Cuba for many years now, and yet, the Spanish Government has had no presence whatsoever in Cuba. And, to some extent, what we are going to do by making this visit is normalise these relations that we have traditionally had with so many sectors and at so many levels. So, I am very excited about making this official trip, which I believe will open up new channels for collaboration between our two governments and I would obviously like to strengthen these ties and this collaboration with Cuba in the medium term.

Q.- Does that mean stepping up economic ties.

President of the Government.- Yes, of course. In fact, there are a great many Spanish companies, above all in the tourism sector that are already established on the island and that have been working there for many years now and are developing projects in Cuba, and I think that there are a great many opportunities in Cuba for investment and to implement this commitment and this closeness we feel with Cuban society.

Q.- Let me ask you a question which is a bit tricky for Spain, which is about Venezuela. What should the government's approach be towards emigrants from Venezuela? What should the approach be on this question, taking into account humanitarian issues?

President of the Government.- Well, when I was the Leader of the Opposition, not long ago, 120 days ago to be precise, we did not recognise the latest elections held in Venezuela, because we are against bans on politicians in Venezuela, and against all those situations that the opposition is suffering in Venezuela. We have shown our solidarity in this with all the opposition leaders of the Maduro regime, and our support for them.

The first week after becoming President of the Government, we held a European Council at which we showed our support for the actions of the EU against the Maduro regime; against the government and the leaders of Maduro's government. Let me be clear about this. The Socialist Party has always defended rights: human rights, liberties and democracy. In other words, there are two dimensions. Firstly, you have the refugee crisis, and we have met to discuss this with the Presidents of Colombia, Bolivia, Chile and Costa Rica.

And I have also had the chance to speak with many other political leaders by phone in recent weeks. And I have said the following to them. If we want to effectively manage the refugee crisis in Venezuela, we must respond at a regional level. We must organise and gain the support of the Inter-American Development Bank, the United Nations, and of course, the support of many countries in the region and outside of the region. And Spain, of course, has very strong ties with Venezuela and with the Latin American community, and we are willing to help. We offer our aid to help out this country, and the surrounding countries. That is the most pressing issue for Venezuela.

And you then have the second dimension - the political solution. And on that matter, I must confess that I am pessimistic. Maduro's regime is not opening any windows to dialogue with the opposition. And in my opinion, the opposition must also reflect on how to present a common front. How to be united in tabling this dialogue with Maduro's regime.

So if you ask me about the role Spain can play with regard to Venezuela, my answer is as a facilitator. We can facilitate, we can provide knowledge, firstly, to effectively respond to this refugee crisis, and of course, from a political point of view, to help step up this dialogue and help forge a definitive political solution

Q.- So you feel that the main issues cannot be resolved with the present government.

President of the Government.- I would very politely say that this would be very difficult.

Q.- Well, going back to domestic affairs. One of your first commitments was to exhume the remains of [Francisco] Franco, and that was approved by Parliament a couple of weeks ago. Why is this so important? And do you believe you are running the risk of opening up old wounds in the country?

President of the Government.- Well look, some of the leading press in Spain have said that this exhumation is like closing off the political transition 40 years on, after our Constitution was enacted and democracy established. And I believe that this is something good, because no democracy should have a mausoleum dedicated to a dictator. And yet this is something that exists in Spain, which I believe is an anachronism. And I think this is something that needs to be resolved.

Even the right-wing parties didn't vote against this; they abstained. Because they know that this is something that goes beyond mere ideologies, beyond party debate. This is a question of vindication and of strengthening our democracy. Of demonstrating that we can do positive and good things to strengthen our democracy. So I can tell you that I am very proud of having been a part of this government that has taken this historic decision, and that has taken this step forward for our country and for our democracy.

Q.- Let's come back to Catalonia now, which is the point on which most interviews with you begin. So, after the referendum it seems that there is still a great deal of support for independence. There was a demonstration in Barcelona recently. How would you like to see this issue resolved?

President of the Government.- Legally and through dialogue. It seems to me that there is also a political crisis that must be resolved with political responses and means. I think that this government's priority is to normalise our institutional relations, something I feel that we are doing.

Two days ago, we reached an agreement for the first time in 10 years with the Regional Government of Catalonia to resolve some economic situations that we inherited from the previous government.

One month ago, a series of bilateral committees started to meet that are included in the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia, but which had not met under the previous government. In other words, to a certain degree, what we are trying to do is normalise institutional relations and also normalise the social situation in Catalonia. That is our obligation, that of the Central Government.

In my opinion, the obligation that the pro-independence forces must comply with - the Regional Government of Catalonia - is to open up dialogue with the rest of the people of Catalonia, with those Catalans that are not represented by this regional government. When we see election results, they are always the same in Catalonia.

I have had a very complex political career, as I am sure you are aware. I became General Secretary of the Socialist Party in 2014, and since then, I have taken part in many electoral processes in Catalonia. And they always end up the same. Around 42 to 45% of voters, that is, quite a high percentage, vote in favour of independence, while the rest do not support independence.

I believe this means, to some extent, that the obligation on the Regional Government of Catalonia is to commence dialogue with the other party - the non-nationalists in Catalonia - who are prepared to bring an end to this problem of co-existence that exists in Catalonia.

Q.- We will come back to the political situation in a moment. Some of the secessionist parties are among your government backers. How can you explain the fact that these parties are vitally important for you holding on to power?

President of the Government.- Well, they know that we defend the Constitution. They know that we defend inter-territorial unity and the sovereignty of Spain, and they also know that we recognise territorial diversity and the Catalan identity. Hence we feel that with the Constitution in one hand and the Statute of Autonomy in the other we can resolve the problem. We have the means and the forums for resolving this problem.

Of course, politics is always a game of priorities and if you prioritise conflict instead of cooperation, well we will end up with elections. This legislature will be seen out. And if we place cooperation first to resolve social policies and other types of issues, then I think we will be able to see in the year 2020.

That was my idea, my aim, and I truly believe we can settle many issues in Spain. We are transforming Spain, albeit with a parliamentary minority, but we are carrying our many transformations in the public sector, in education, in gender equality, in the fight against poverty, in liberties. And of course, we are trying to normalise the situation of the crisis in Catalonia. And I believe that most people in Spain want a government that implements the policies we are pushing through.

Q.- One of the things I know is that there will be a series of trials against political leaders and that these trials may turn into the spark that ignites a conflict. Can anything be done to try and avoid this conflict? How do you see these trials? What do you believe will happen in the future? Do you think that a compromise will be reached in Catalonia?

President of the Government.- Well, this will clearly have a political impact. No-one can deny that. This is a situation which, very possibly, isn't very smart, but my role as President of the Government is not to make guesses, it is to stick to reality. We must take a step forward and, in the short term, what I am going to do, and what I must do, and what I believe we are doing, is to normalise our relations with the Regional Government of Catalonia.

What I can tell you is that I believe that they have also understood that whilst they are a very large minority, they are still a minority, and what they have to do is open up a channel of dialogue with the other part of Catalonia

Q.- You are an economist, and we have seen some figures on the economy in Catalonia, in Barcelona, regarding companies that have fled. Tourism has fallen. What can you say about the economic impact of this dispute?

President of the Government.- Well, if we look at the main public and private institutions in Spain, the impact has been quite small. We are seeing the same as what happened during the crisis in Quebec. Many companies left Quebec and moved to Toronto or other cities in Canada. That is something that is happening in Spain, particularly companies moving to Madrid or Valencia. But, in my opinion, my government's goal is to help the Catalan economy in providing security, certainty, confidence in the Catalan economy, because this represents around 20% of our GDP.

Q.- Well, you have spoken about the start of your government, and we will come back to that later. Firstly, let's talk about the Budget and the difficulties you are facing in approving it. Is that a bad sign as regards the coalition you need? And then, will you call snap elections? When would these elections take place?

President of the Government.- The problem is that politics, even in Spain, also have a slightly irrational component, because we reached an agreement with the EU institutions to ensure the deficit could be maintained, whilst increasing the ceiling on spending by 0.5%, which is important, because our Budget must be defined by taking three factors into account. Firstly, the situation of our public accounts, and, as I said before, we are absolutely committed to meeting our obligations on the ceiling on the public deficit and the public debt. And I have confirmed this to our allies.

Secondly, you have the economic and social situation. We reached an agreement with the European Commission, where most of the European Commissioners are representatives of the centre-right, of the European People's Party. Spain also has two conservative parties: Ciudadanos and the People's Party, which say that they are against raising the ceiling on spending by 0.5%, and they want to continue under the terms of the previous agreement which was much more difficult and much tougher for Spain, because it required more austerity measures in the National Budget which, in my opinion, could not only harm our society, but also our economy and its potential growth.

What we want to achieve is more opportunities for economic growth through this 0.5% rise in spending under the public deficit. But if, in the end, we are forced to present the draft National Budget with these previous limits, then we will do so. I believe that the other Member States are aware that we are trying to meet all our commitments, but that if we don't manage to achieve that, then it will be necessary to adapt the targets by returning to the previous ceilings.

What we are going to do is present a draft Budget to the European Commission in mid-October. We are also going to present an agenda for change in many areas to the Commission, from education to the job market and, of course, the Welfare State and our tax system, and we will then present the Lower House with this proposal, this draft Budget, in November. This is the calendar we have at this time and the goal is to make this happen.

Q.- So, if I understand you correctly, you won't call elections even if forced to return to the terms of the previous Budget?

President of the Government.- No, because, at the end of the day, those two parties will have to explain to the Spanish people why they are going to vote against having more resources for education, public health and pensions.

Q.- Do you believe that the government of Mariano Rajoy managed to get Spain out of the crisis? Do you believe that these austerity measures really served to recover the economy or not?

President of the Government.- In all honesty, I am very critical of the legacy left by the previous President of the Government. I think that many of his economic policies were ideological, and I think that what we should learn from this decline we have suffered in Spain is that you cannot have sustainable growth without strengthening the social pillars of well-being, improving labour market conditions, raising the minimum wage. And as regards other issues which, for us, as a progressive government, are fundamental, such as gender equality in the labour market.

Q.- 11 of your 17 ministers are women, are they not?

President of the Government.- Yes, indeed, and I am very proud that this is the case, and I can say to you that the main portfolios are in the hands of women: Economy, the Ecological Transition, Industry, Justice, to name but a few. And I believe that attitudes have changed a great deal in Spain since 8 March, when women took to the streets to advocate equal rights. And I believe that my government, to some degree, is also a reflection and a consequence of this demand for gender equality at a political level.

Q.- One of the things that brought you to power was corruption, and the scandals that affected the People's Party. Has corruption gone away since the new government took power? And is there any policy in your manifesto to fight corruption so that it no longer remains a problem?

President of the Government.- I said during the vote of no-confidence that I would not describe the People's Party as a corrupt party. You have to distinguish between a political party and some corruption cases that involve some of its leaders, which is what happened for many years in the People's Party, But I do believe that in Spain, although we have seen these corruption scandals over recent years, political parties are now taking many measures to resolve and prevent these problems of corruption. This obviously includes the Socialist Party too.

And when we analyse what happened at the vote of no confidence, to some extent, I believe that this is a very positive reflection on the quality of our democracy because we have, on the one hand, the judiciary that has been handing down very forthright rulings in these cases of the illegal funding of the People's Party.

And then, furthermore, the previous government did not take on its political responsibilities, but, for the first time in the history of our democracy, Parliament took on these responsibilities through this vote of no confidence and the toppling of the government. So, what happened over those days, which were very, very intense, were also a vindication of the health of our democracy.

Q.- I will now move on very briefly to the economy before taking any questions from the public, and I hope to be able to field some of them before our time runs out. But first, I wanted to ask you about tourism, which is the sector creating the most jobs in Spain. The latest statistics seem to show its growth is slowing down, it is falling somewhat. Are you concerned by the path this sector is taking? Do you think that it has hit its peak and will not continue growing?

President of the Government.- As regards tourism, I would say that we are facing an incredibly positive situation, with very high figures, although there has been a slight decline in recent months. In my opinion, we have a highly competitive sector and what we want to do from the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Tourism is help it to further improve this competitiveness which I feel is key. And of course, everything related to the fight against climate change, and environmental protection which is also something essential for improving the quality of this tourism. And this offer. I believe that the basic characteristics of our economy and of this sector are very sound.

Q.- Don't you feel then that the sector has reached maximum growth and that henceforth it will start to fall?

President of the Government.- No. I believe that if you look at the metrics, for example, employment and the automobile sector, or if you look at the general competitiveness of our economy, we have reached a fairly good balance that allows us to forecast a continuation in the economic recovery, even though the rate of growth is aligning with that of our European neighbours. I am reasonably optimistic in relation to the economic parameters, and the growth forecasts for Spain.

Q.- Well, let's now move on to the questions from the public to also given them a chance to participate. We have a question about NATO. Where do you believe the future of NATO lies? What should the priorities be and to what extent are you concerned by the threat of Russia to the European Union?

President of the Government.- Cyber-security. The fight against hybrid threats and attacks will be among the major challenges for NATO. And secondly, the 360 strategy which is clearly very important for NATO, its relations with Russia and maintaining security along the whole border. And the whole region of the Middle East and North Africa, and the Sahel is also very important, as major challenges lie there. And, in this regard, I believe that we have taken a very positive measure at this latest NATO Summit to strengthen our commitment and our strategy in relation to the situation in Africa.

Q.- And so you feel that Spain is in line with the NATO priorities.

President of the Government.- Indeed

Q.- An interesting question on pollution, which is one of the main coastal problems of the Mediterranean. What plans does Spain have to tackle the global problem of plastic contamination in the oceans?

President of the Government.- Well, I have some figures here, but I would like to state that we are totally committed to environmental protection, and we have set up a whole new ministerial department - the Ministry of Ecological Transition - in which we have merged the former Ministry of Energy with the Ministry of Environment. Yesterday, at the 'One Planet' Summit, organised by Bloomberg, we shared and made public some clear and specific commitments to join up to the coalition to decarbonise our economy. So we are very committed.

Q.- A question on the interest rates of the Euro. The question is, to what extent can the rise in inflation that we are seeing in the labour markets affect Spain and other European countries? Do you think they will change the interest rates in Spain?

President of the Government.- No, I don't think so. In fact, it would clearly seem that monetary policies are going to change, but that this will not be a harsh or major change that affects this economic solution.

Q.- In other words, will the interest rates remain stable?

President of the Government.- Yes, indeed. That is the feeling I have.

Q.- Here is a question I love. The press are criticising you around the world and you are under a great deal of pressure. Do you feel it is important to have freedom of press? And what is your opinion on the anti-press sentiment springing up around the world?

President of the Government.- I think that the press does an extraordinary job and I obviously defend the freedom of the press. But I also believe that the press should make a very specific reflection on its needs, because sometimes they report fake news that, to some extent, contaminates public debate.

Q.- Do you think that the press should not interfere with that?

President of the Government.- Clearly, what we must do is not play this game and allow this fake news to affect public debate in different countries. But of course, I respect and support the press. I think it is very important. But I also think that, to a certain extent, the fake news we are seeing in public debate is not helping strengthen democracy. That is something we should think about.

Q.- I am now going to try and ask two quick questions. What do you think about the roles that [José María] Aznar and [José Luis Rodríguez] Zapatero are playing?

In that I mean the role that Zapatero is playing in Venezuela and the responses given by Aznar to corruption in the PP.

President of the Government.- Well, quite clearly, I respect both former Presidents of the Government. And I hope that in the distant future I will also be a former President of the Government, and hence I respect them. But what I can say is that when I became President of the Government, they all called me and gave me a series of advice in order to perform my role more effectively. So of course, I am grateful. I have ideological differences with some of the former Presidents of the Government, such as Aznar, but I respect all of them, and they have all my due consideration and respect in whatever they may be doing. As regards the work by former President of the Government Zapatero in Venezuela, that is a personal decision. That is not the position of the Government of Spain, which is something we design internally. I feel that every effort that is made to reach a political and a peaceful solution is welcome.

Q.- And my last question. Your personal history has a series of dramatic successes and failures. Do you want to say anything about this? Do you have any experiences to tell us?

President of the Government.- Yes, lots. The other day I was joking that progressive leaders need to be very resilient. Resilience is one of the key qualities.

And then you have the fact that our public debate is very media dominated. We often lose as politicians because we don't focus on the medium-term goals. Many of the problems we face in politics are because we are working on concrete, specific issues that are not always the most important instead of focusing on questions that are really going to transform our society. So, to a certain extent, we must be more focused, particularly on specific medium- and long-term goals for our countries.

Those, at least, are the lessons I have learned in these years heading up the Socialist Party, and in these days in government. People may sometimes disagree with me on certain decisions I have taken as a political leader, but when they see you have a clear goal on the horizon, I believe that they will ultimately follow your lead.

Q.- And with that we will draw to a close. Thank you very much for being here with us.

President of the Government.- Thank you.

Non official translation