Speech by the President of the Government of Spain at the closing ceremony of the presentation of the Digital Rights Observatory
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez spoke at the closing ceremony launching Spain's Digital Rights Observatory at Red.es on 5 February 2025, urging stronger regulation of digital platforms.
- Main themes
- Digital rights, online harm and abuse, social media regulation, Digital Rights Observatory launch, algorithmic accountability, platform neutrality, disinformation, digital freedoms, economic impact of digitalisation, youth vulnerability online, public debate quality, technological optimism and its limits
- Duration
- ~24 min
- Words
- 2,931
- Sentences
- 126
- Readability
- 45
- Grade
- 12.6
- Syntax
- 3.09
- Vocabulary
- 2.09
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other126 sentences in 35 paragraphs
Thank you very much and good morning to you all; Ministers, Secretaries of State, Secretary General of the Hermes Foundation, ladies and gentlemen.
And above all, many thanks to Natividad, Alicia and Juan for your testimonies: I believe that if the Government of Spain was already convinced of the need to act, after listening to you, we are even more so. And we are going to take steps in the direction you have indicated. Because we cannot, of course, allow the digital space to become the Wild West, where people are insulted, threatened, swindled and abused with impunity, as is the case.
I believe that this situation forces us all to reflect on the following: Why do we accept as normal in the digital world what we would never allow in the physical world? Why don't we apply the same rules, the same laws, the same rights, the same duties, the same obligations? Earlier on, Minister Óscar López put it differently - he said that no one would accept a plane taking off without it meeting the strictest safety standards, or a medicine being sold without it first undergoing rigorous testing. Yet we have inexplicably allowed digital products and services to go to market without controlling their risks and without knowing what the potential harms are.
I believe that faith in technology and its promises has blinded us to its worst consequences. And that is why the Digital Rights Observatory we are launching today at Red.es, with the backing of 48 companies, institutions, foundations and universities, and with the special support of the Hermes Foundation, was created with this vocation: that the rights and freedoms we defend in our daily lives reach the digital world, and that we protect them with the same rigour and with the same vehemence; that we prevent, that we fight, that we eradicate once and for all the manipulation and misuse of digital environments, so that testimonies such as those we have heard cease to be the norm and become the exception.
I am aware - I think we are all aware - of the scale of the problem we are facing, especially when we talk about social networks.
And I would also like to share a reflection with you in this regard, because at the moment all of us, I believe - the administrations, the media, the citizens themselves - sincerely trust in the virtues, and in the fact that the networks would serve to transform the world for the better. We did. We trusted that they would give voice to the voiceless - indeed, they have done so - we trusted that they would help us to learn, to create, to speak without constraint in a more integrated and cohesive world. And to a certain extent, let's face it, this has been the case.
First of all, the digital revolution has transformed our lives, indeed transformed the way we work, the way we live, the way we love. For many teenagers and not so teenagers, social networks are a space for connection, a refuge in difficult times, and also for half of young people dating apps are the place where romantic relationships begin.
Second, digitalisation has turned our economies upside down and they are becoming increasingly dependent on each other.
And there is hardly any professional activity today that is not in one way or another affected by its digital dimension. Every euro invested in the technology sector has generated almost three euros in economic growth.
And last, the digital world has also transformed the physical space, and of course, the way we participate in politics. Social networks have broken down the barriers of traditional media; they have allowed more people, more voices, to feel part of transformative movements from a collective point of view - think, for example, of the MeToo movement and Fridays for Future. Not only did they emerge in social networks, but through them they managed to mobilise millions and millions of people for just causes. They contributed, in short, to transforming the public debate, to putting on the table and raising the profile of problems that the traditional media or the political establishment, in one way or another, had kept entirely invisible.
Well, that is the good stuff, which is no mean feat, let's face it. But we also know that under the aura of the economic, social and cultural miracle much misery is hidden. Are our lives fuller, as promised by the digital revolution? Are our economies more egalitarian? Do we have the most cohesive societies? I think the answer is obvious, and therefore the question we have to ask ourselves is why is this the case? Because the algorithm does not distribute opportunities; because the big technological platforms are not neutral, and because lies travel on social networks much faster than the truth. The immediacy of the click has reduced the complexity of information and public debate to 280 characters. The obsession with lik es distorts reality, impoverishes public debate and - most worryingly - forces us to choose sides.
Social networks today are veritable battlefields where there is no discussion; what is done is attack; there is no argument, there is only disqualification; and the aim is not to understand, but to impose. And there is nothing wrong with being witty or brief. But when someone is shouting or being shouted at, the shouting matters more than what is being said; the shouting replaces the words. And the main consequence of all this is that very often, unfortunately, what goes viral on social media is not the truth, but lies.
Every day our social media walls are filled with false data, modified images and fake news that distort our own perception of reality. We do not have to go very far. It happened during the DANA in Valencia on 29 October: thousands of bots tried to multiply the damage by spreading fake news, much of it scams. And the matter is that what was being sought was society's demoralisation and profiteering from the pain at the expense of the victims of the DANA.
So what I mean by this is that what happens in the networks, what happens in the digital world, of course has consequences in real life. We have seen it here today with the testimonies we have heard. And, of course, if we look at the data, digital crimes already account for one fifth of all criminal offences; one in four young people receive unwanted sexual solicitations, and online hate crimes have grown by 32% in the last year.
We naively believed that the platforms would help level the playing field, but they have done just the opposite. They have made the playing field much more unfair, because a third - a huge third - of the profiles on social networks are bots that generate almost half the traffic on the Internet. The searches, the content, the news we consume are totally biased, and therefore virality is worth much more than the truth.
And the reflection we have to make is that this is not the fruit of chance, it is a designed plan, it is a pre-established plan, systematically chosen and thought out. First, by foreign powers like Russia, which seek to weaken our coexistence, our democratic institutions. But it is not only foreign powers like Russia; there are other anti-establishment forces that seek to create chaos and disaffection in our societies, either to gain power or to take advantage of the most vulnerable.
And now, unfortunately, we have seen an elite of millionaires - or billionaires - who do not pay taxes, for whom it is not enough to have more money than 150 countries put together. They also want political power, political and democratic power. What they want is to sit directly in the councils of ministers, without masks or mediators. To control our laws, our lives. To condition what we think and what we see, even our memory as a society, if necessary by encouraging authoritarianism and hatred, as we are seeing not far from here, in electoral processes that are going to have a major impact in Europe in the coming weeks.
But let no one be fooled. Their main motivation for controlling this democratic power is none other than money. It is all for money. Everything has always been about money. So, we are witnessing a ruthless technological race between the technocast and authoritarian powers that wage a battle without rules or principles in the digital world and have an impact on real life.
The new AI developed by a Chinese company has eliminated any reference to any element of opposition to its government. At the same time, when asked, the leading US AI company casts doubt on Biden's victory in the last election. And the most famous geolocation provider is about to make the Gulf of Mexico disappear from its maps to ingratiate itself with the powers that be. Technology at the service of power and ideology. They want intelligence to be just that, intelligence without dissent.
That is why, ladies and gentlemen, in the face of this reality we have to rebel and put an alternative on the table, because there is one. There is an alternative. And from this Government, from Spain, which is a profoundly democratic society, which has suffered the consequences of authoritarianism and autarchy in our history, we are willing to promote it in Europe, which is our environment, our political, social, economic and democratic context.
In the face of those who promote absolute deregulation for the technocast; in the face of those who seek to turn technology into yet another tool of censorship, I believe that Europe must consolidate a model of technological development that contributes to economic growth while fully respecting citizens' digital rights. Therefore, a human and humanistic digitisation.
We must transform the digital environment into a public good for citizens. We can only do this by promoting regulation that protects citizens, and by encouraging the development of European technology that respects our values. Which, by the way, are the human rights values of the UN Charter.
With regard to the first area, regulation, a few days ago at the World Economic Forum in Davos, I put three measures on the table with European implications aimed at protecting citizens and taking back control of the platforms. And some have been echoed here by the speakers.
First of all, we must put an end to the anonymity that poisons social networks. We need to end anonymity. Nobody walks down the street without their ID card or wearing a mask. We do not drive cars without number plates. Therefore, we cannot allow people to act with absolute impunity on social networks, hiding behind a mask. Just as it is not possible, as I have just said, to drive a car without a licence plate or board a plane without identifying oneself, we cannot allow those who accuse or harass other citizens to spread lies and hatred, and do so with impunity. Anonymity cannot be an excuse for impunity. The first proposal, therefore, is to end anonymity.
Second, we must go further in defending citizens' digital rights. And we need to deepen the transparency of the algorithms. Platforms should be obliged to share the information necessary for monitoring. We are seeing how these big technology companies, this technocast, is eliminating all the elements of moderation previously mentioned from the content, and therefore from the fight against disinformation, which obviously cannot be optional. If I may say so, we must make that restraint and self-restraint a requirement, a legal requirement. And to fulfil this purpose, we are working at European level, and in this regard, I would also like to announce that we are going to strengthen, both materially and in terms of personnel, the capacities of the Centre for Algorithmic Transparency that the European Commission and the European Government have located in the city of Seville. In addition, in the coming weeks, we will approve the designation of the National Commission for Competition Markets, the CNMC, as the coordinator of digital services, and we will provide the material and human resources to supervise the activity of digital platforms.
And third, let's see, we need the CEOs of these companies not to shy away from their obligations, but to do as businesspeople do, as any self-employed person does, as any worker does. And when they do so, they should be held accountable for the damage their platforms cause, with their responsibility. We must ensure personal responsibility in the digital age. I think it is easy to understand that if the owner of a restaurant is responsible for the good condition of the food he serves to his customers, these techno-billionaires, these technological giants, must also have to answer for their actions, shouldn't they? Or should they be able to avoid the consequences of the damage caused by their algorithms? I believe that we cannot allow those who design, those who benefit from these platforms, to completely disregard the impact they have on society. Because disinformation, hatred, harassment can be faceless externalities. Because in a democracy, power without accountability is not compatible with justice.
And so to achieve this, we are studying mechanisms to ensure the legal responsibility of these managers with regard to the operation of the platforms, guaranteeing that they can be held legally accountable for the violation of rights and freedoms that may occur on these platforms.
And the second front must be to promote digital and technological sovereignty. Both the European Commission and Spain are moving in this direction. Europe clearly cannot depend on others to define its digital future. I believe that technological sovereignty is not only a question of economic competitiveness - which it is, and we always focus on it - but it is also a question of security, of rights, of strategic autonomy, and so we cannot allow our data, our infrastructures, our communications to remain in the hands of foreign powers or companies without any kind of democratic control.
So we need to invest in innovation, develop our own technologies, develop our own infrastructure, strengthen the regulatory framework that protects the rights and freedoms of our citizens - in short, democracy in Europe. And I believe that Europe is in a position to lead this digital transformation with clear rules, firm values, and an ambition to be a world reference in ethical and responsible technology. I believe we should develop our own browsers; social networks, public and private, European; messaging services using open protocols, and so on. To this end, we have recent examples that show that with resources and talent, it is possible to enter this race. And it is in this spirit that we are going to defend in the European Commission and in the European Parliament the drawing up of an Investment Plan to promote public-private infrastructures.
And from Spain, we are obviously already developing a national digital infrastructure. You know it well. This month we have launched the first 'Alia' model, which is the new AI family in Spanish and in the co-official languages. We are also already mobilising €150 million to accelerate the adoption of AI in Spanish companies (€20 million of this €150 million will be spent on applications and the development of AI in small and medium-sized companies).
I will conclude with something that the secretary general of the Hermes Foundation said earlier, which I think is very important because these are not words, they are deeds. Spain was one of the first countries in the world, I believe the first, to have a Charter of Digital Rights, which we drew up in a participatory manner in 2020, in the midst of the pandemic. It was a text that was a pioneer, a vanguard, a reference for subsequent debates that took place in the EU - and also in the Latin American community - on the regulation of technology, with a people-centred approach, and a true source of inspiration for the European Declaration on Digital Rights and Principles, and also the different directives on the subject that the minister mentioned earlier. There was also - and here I would also like to acknowledge the work of the Hermes Foundation - the Ibero-American Charter of Principles and Rights in Digital Environments, adopted in 2023.
What am I saying with all this? That we have a track record of European and multilateral leadership (and in the UN, we have taken part in and financed the debate on the regulation of artificial intelligence) in digital transformation with democratic values. And I believe that, in this regard, the Digital Rights Observatory shares the same philosophy: These rights must be real, tangible and effective in the lives of everyone. And we must make them effective, moreover, through public-private collaboration, because it cannot be otherwise; with the participation of the academic world and the business world, civil society, and of course, public institutions.
Today, ladies and gentlemen, I wanted to share a reflection that goes beyond the scope of this forum. I wanted to raise this point here and now because we are facing a very decisive moment, which is forcing us to choose between two very clear alternatives: Either we follow the lead of others and go with the flow, or we take the lead in defining a new way of understanding, designing and building technology. I believe that we have to opt for the latter route. To be masters, in short, of our own destiny.
Thank you.
Original speech in Spanish