29. Speech at the Meeting of Mukhtars

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

26 October 2016 · 29th Meeting of Mukhtars · Presidential Complex

Context
Erdoğan addressed the 29th Mukhtar Meeting at the Presidential Complex in Ankara on October 26, 2016, hosting elected village heads from fourteen Turkish provinces.
Main themes
Mukhtar (village head) meetings, grassroots democracy, wisdom of the nation, servant leadership, Turkey's security doctrine, Syria and Iraq operations, political legitimacy, national identity and culture, leader-people relationship
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,106
92nd percentile
Sentences
306
95th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.3
6th percentile
Syntax
2.68
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
34th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 55%54%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

306 sentences in 71 paragraphs

Dear esteemed village heads,

My precious brothers and sisters;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings and affection. Welcome to the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation.

We are together for the 29th Muhtar Meeting. We have held 28 so far, and today is the 29th. Today, we are hosting you, our esteemed village heads from the provinces of Adana, Ardahan, Balıkesir, Bilecik, Çorum, Erzurum, Kars, Kırklareli, Mersin, Rize, Siirt, Sinop, Tekirdağ, and Tokat.

Last week, I met with our village heads here again, celebrated their October 19th Muhtar Day, and shared our views on the issues in our country and region with them. After a week’s break, we will again address these issues with our village heads at a time when significant developments are taking place in our country and region.

Of course, as we discuss such critical issues with our village heads, some people become uncomfortable. Because in their eyes, a village head is someone who has no other qualifications or duties beyond issuing a certificate of residence; that is how they see it. However, we view our village heads as the foundation of democracy because they form the first link of duties that come through elections; that is our difference. It is not their place to belittle our village heads, who would not be able to gather three votes among their own family members.

We take great pleasure in discussing and consulting on the issues of our cities, our country, our region, and the world with our village heads.

What those who do not understand the nature of our relationship with our village heads overlook is this: While I speak from the podium about issues related to our country and the world, the looks, gestures, objections, rebellions, silences, and approvals of the village heads sitting in front of me, whom I will later meet with at dinner, tell me a lot. The message I receive from this communication is often much more important, much more accurate, and much more enlightening than the information I would obtain by speaking individually with dozens or hundreds of people.

This is what we call the wisdom of our nation; the wisdom of the nation is something very different. You may possess knowledge, but if you lack wisdom, you are nothing. This is where the wisdom of the nation lies. You cannot acquire or measure this wisdom through education, position, or resources.

From time to time, especially foreign media representatives ask me about the secret of my success in politics and how I have managed Turkey for 14 years. This secret is right here in front of me. I owe my successes to my sincere affection for my nation and my commitment to understanding and adhering to the vast wisdom that belongs to my people. What does the late Neşet Ertaş say: “If help does not come from a friend, one cannot reach their destination, / The rose of a garden cannot be picked without its consent. / There is a path from heart to heart that cannot be seen, / It goes from heart to heart, oh, the path is hidden, the path is hidden.” Those who do not see this affection between the President, who represents all of Turkey, and our village heads coming from all corners of our country, are blind in heart. May God grant healing to those with closed hearts. I cannot find anything else to say.

Look, throughout my political life, I have seen this: If we take a step to serve our nation, our nation has come to us three steps, five steps. Therefore, you should not be a master to the nation; you should be a servant to the nation. This applies to you and to me.

You should never act arrogantly towards the nation. If you act arrogantly towards the nation, they will bring you in one election and send you away in the next; that is how it works.

Those who take a step away from the nation, or even run away from it, become angry with the people because they do not respect them. Why are you angry with the people? If they stop fighting with the values, culture, and history of the nation and submit to the nation, the problem will be solved. Simply saying ‘sovereignty unconditionally belongs to the nation’ does not make sovereignty belong to the nation. Sovereignty belongs to the nation by adhering to the rights of the nation; we need to understand this well. That secret path from our nation to us, that is the source of our strength, our energy, and our motivation. If there are those who are curious about what this path is and what it looks like, they are welcome to join one of our village head meetings, sit among us, and observe the surroundings; I am sure they will understand much better what I mean then.

Dear brothers and sisters;

In the meeting we held with our village heads last week, I emphasized Turkey’s new security understanding and stated that we will no longer wait for threats to knock on our door; we will eliminate threats at their source. In fact, this new security principle is the clearest expression of why Turkey is present in Syria and Iraq and why it wants to be more actively involved. The time for intervention after the threat has reached our doorstep is over; we are now in a process of drying up the swamp. Where is this happening? Right here, there, everything will be finished. We should not wait patiently for them to come here and then intervene; that time has passed. When did it pass?

Let me tell you; did we start a process of opening related to democracy? We did. Did we say National Unity? We did. Did we say the solution process? We did. Did we achieve results? We did not. What were all these? In fact, all of these were steps. But they did not understand us. The incident in Gaziantep, where 56 of our brothers were martyred by a suicide bomber and 100 people were injured, marked the end of this process. And we immediately said, since this terrorist organization called ISIS took such a step here, we will enter from Cerablus after our preparations in Syria, with the Free Syrian Army in the lead and logistical support from us.

So, who settled in Cerablus? The people of Cerablus settled there; now the people of Cerablus have come to settle in their lands. We have provided almost all services there, including schools and hospitals, and on one side, our Red Crescent and on the other, all the infrastructure and above-ground works are still continuing rapidly, but now children can go to their schools, places of worship, all mosques, and prayer rooms have been prepared, and everyone can go there.

Then we entered El-Rai, and from Rai, we immediately moved towards the famous Dabik, which they sanctify. Of course, ISIS showed serious resistance there, but Dabik was overcome. ISIS had to leave there as well. And now, where are we heading from Dabik? We are heading towards Al-Bab. In the meantime, we are also fighting against a terrorist organization, the PYD, YPG, wherever necessary. Now we are moving from Al-Bab towards Manbij...

We currently have no problem regarding Aleppo. However, we have objections regarding Aleppo, and we communicate this to our counterparts. I discussed this with Mr. Putin as well. I said, ‘Let’s bring peace to the people of Aleppo. Let’s fight together against the terrorist groups in Aleppo, but Aleppo belongs to the people of Aleppo; we need to make this clear.’ It would not be right to enter into an account over Aleppo because we have historical, cultural, and familial ties with Aleppo. And if such an occupation were to take place in Aleppo, there is only one place for these people’s future; Gaziantep, Kilis.

Right now, where are 2 million 750 thousand Syrians and 300 thousand Iraqis? They are in our territory. The care of these people, everything belongs to us; we are doing this right now. We are doing this because we consider it a humanitarian, moral, and Islamic duty, not because someone ordered us to do so. Is the West providing any support at this point? No. They are giving it to other places; but there is no serious support for Turkey, despite promises made. The European Union has promises, but there is nothing substantial. Similarly, you see that the United Nations Refugee Agency is constantly holding donor meetings, etc., money is being collected, but nothing is coming to Turkey; it will not enter my budget; it will go to our Syrian brothers here, and still, there is nothing. Right now, we have spent about 13-14 billion dollars in documented expenses, and there is an equal amount spent by our NGOs and municipalities. Whether it comes or not, we will definitely provide this support to our brothers under these bombs. In fact, we said that we would open the door to citizenship for those currently in tent cities and container cities if necessary. Our Ministry of Interior is also carrying out the necessary work regarding this.

Turkey has been a country seeking ways to cope with separatist terrorist threats centered in Iraq and Syria since 1984. Unfortunately, until recently, we always tried to take precautions against these threats on our own territory, even after the actions had taken place.

We struggled to fight with our soldiers and police who were trapped in police stations. However, terrorist organizations freely train their members in their bases both within the country and in places like Iraq and Syria, build logistical stockpiles, and establish areas of dominance. We need to speak frankly; these are not problems that have been identified for the first time by us or articulated for the first time by us. But for some reason, the issue has not been pursued, and necessary precautions have not been taken.

As you know, since the elections of November 3, 2002, I have been at the forefront of the cadre that has taken on the responsibility of governing the country. As Prime Minister and President, I have fought hard and made great efforts to change the security understanding of the country, just like other issues. Each time, different obstacles were put in our way, and different excuses were presented to us.

Of course, mistakes were also made, such as the rejection of the government motion that blocked our active participation in the operation that would start in Iraq on March 1, 2003. Because I particularly believed in the necessity of our participation there, I expressed to my friends that it was a very big mistake at that time. Of course, when such a will emerged in the Parliament, we were left out of the developments in Iraq. The reason why things have become so unmanageable in Iraq today is that Turkey did not take an active role in that operation.

Later, during my tenure as Prime Minister, the Parliament allowed this, but this time our brothers in Iraq said, ‘We do not want Turkey to enter here.’ Mr. Bush told me, ‘They do not want it.’ ‘You brought me this offer. Since they do not want it, we will not enter where we are not wanted,’ we said, and we withdrew our soldiers.

When the Syrian crisis began, we again tried to take an active position. However, for years we were kept out of this process. Moreover, we had to bear the burden of millions of refugees coming to our country all by ourselves. In the end, we realized that no one was of any help to us, and we decided to implement our own projects.

Dear brothers and sisters;

We made this decision, but we did not have a very comfortable area to operate in front of us. We were being besieged from both outside and inside. Since the early years of our government, we have faced provocations, bureaucratic and political obstacles at every significant step we took. We have not forgotten, nor will we forget, the problems caused by certain factions nested within the military and judiciary in the years 2005, 2006, and 2007, as well as the injurious language of the political opposition. Similarly, we are well aware of how attempts were made to corner Turkey to keep it out of the regional calculations since 2012.

We all witnessed how our efforts to rid ourselves of the separatist terrorist problem, which we initiated as a democratic opening, advanced with the national unity and brotherhood project, and aimed to achieve results with the solution process, were sabotaged. The concerns of those who worked to exclude the terrorist organization from the process were neither this country nor this nation. They were concerned with squeezing Turkey from within. The terrorist organization and its supporters revealed their true faces by using the opportunity presented to establish peace and brotherhood for preparations for new terrorist actions. The call to ‘go out into the streets’ lies behind the martyrdom of 53 Kurdish brothers. The deceased were our Kurdish brothers, and those who killed them were also Kurdish. They claimed to represent the Kurds; how could they be representatives? We have lived through all of this; we have seen all of this.

If you pay attention, since that time, as a state and a nation, we have not engaged with the organization or the political institutions under its control. I have never engaged with them, I will not, and I will not in the future; I want this to be known. Because our interlocutor is now the people of the region who do not have a direct connection to terrorism and the terrorist organization; we will look at it this way. I believe that all my village head brothers should also look at it this way. If you do not look at it this way, I apologize.

Look, during those times, the Gezi events were attempted to be turned into an opportunity to overthrow the government by some people within a few days. We saw this insidious game even then and determined our stance accordingly. In fact, the issue was not about trees or greenery. I had planted 2.5 million saplings and trees in Istanbul during my tenure as mayor. No one can declare a person who is so passionate about greenery and has made such efforts to be an enemy of trees. And during our time in power, thank God, our struggle for greening throughout Turkey is exemplary in the world; we are taking such a step. However, some fools, whether they realize it or not, were consciously trying to occupy the streets and squares in various cities, especially in Istanbul and Ankara. But my nation knew how to stand against them. With our clear stance, this insidious plan was thwarted before it could reach its goal.

Immediately after that, they took a second step. What was that? The December 17-25 police-judiciary coup attempt came; they wanted to do this together. Those who tried to market Gezi as a ‘tree-green issue’ also packaged this coup attempt as ‘law-justice’ to the nation.

They tried to deceive us. Thank God, our nation did not give in to this. Together with my friends, we immediately took the necessary measures and swiftly eliminated the members of the organization within the Security and Judiciary, rendering this coup attempt fruitless.

In March 2014, as you know, local elections were held, and we witnessed the confirmation of our nation's rejection of this game. My party, which received 40 percent of the votes in 2004 and 39 percent in 2009 in local elections, broke a record with 46 percent in 2014. Subsequently, in the presidential election, we were once again endorsed by our nation with 52 percent.

Dear brothers and sisters;

We have thwarted these games time and again by joining hands with our nation; however, at the same time, we have had to continuously postpone our projects for establishing influence in the region due to ongoing developments, which have cost us time. The consequences of the developments in Syria, Iraq, and even places like Egypt and Libya, as well as Palestine, are directly related to our future. No one should deceive themselves by saying, "These are the internal affairs of those countries." Every event occurring in our region is directly related to us.

In the past, when our compatriots in Bulgaria, Greece, and Macedonia faced difficulties, did we turn our backs on them by saying, "It's their internal affairs"? Could we? When events began in Ukraine, did we ignore the troubles of our brothers in Crimea by saying, "It's a matter between Ukraine and Russia"? Could we? When conflicts arose in Georgia, did we say, "It doesn't concern us, it's their internal affairs," and turn our heads the other way? Could we?

When our Azerbaijani brothers shed tears for Karabakh, did we look after our own comfort? Could we? The same situation applies even more profoundly to Syria, to Iraq, to all of North Africa, and indeed to all of Africa downwards.

Just yesterday, I hosted the President and his wife; as they were passing through here to China, we sat down for lunch and shared some concerns. Their perspective on Turkey is, of course, very different; but their expectations are also different. Therefore, our burden is heavy, and we cannot set this aside.

Look, xenophobia is rising in European countries, and we are the first and most vehement to respond to it. Why? Because there are over 5 million people of Turkish origin or citizens of our country living there. We should also include our brothers who have come from distant geographies like Turkistan, Afghanistan, and Central Asia to settle in Europe; it is our moral duty to protect their rights and find solutions to their troubles. Moreover, while discussing the issues of Iraq and Syria, we must also take into account our historical and legal rights alongside our moral stance.

Now, when we mention historical and legal rights, when we say Lausanne, some people immediately say, "Do you have your eyes on the lands of Iraq and Syria?" Today, I saw some newspapers saying, "Erdoğan mentioned a National Pact and stirred up trouble." I did not say that; history recorded it this way. Are we to forget such a reality that has been recorded by history? Are we not to discuss these matters? We have no eyes on the lands of any country. On the contrary, we are against those who have eyes on the lands of these countries, who want to drag our brothers living in these countries into new conflicts based on ethnic and sectarian divisions; we are trying to prevent this.

As I always say, our physical borders are one thing, but our emotional borders are entirely different. Our brothers in all geographies, from Europe to the depths of Africa, from the Mediterranean to the vast steppes of Central Asia, are within our emotional borders.

For us, the Balkans are one side of our heart, and the Caucasus is the other. Given this situation, can those who insist on keeping us outside the developments in Iraq and Syria be well-intentioned?

You will come from thousands, tens of thousands of kilometers away, intervene, and say you have the right. What is it? "The Central Government there invited me, called me, that's why I came." Okay, but I have a 911-kilometer border on one side and a 350-kilometer border on the other, and my borders are under threat; hundreds of my people have been martyred in the meantime, but I will say, "You can come in freely." Is that possible? How can I see Aleppo as separate from Gaziantep, Hasakah from Mardin, Mosul from Van?

We cannot account for such a distorted perspective to our ancestors or our descendants; let it be known.

Dear brothers and sisters;

Let me express once again that Turkey will definitely be involved in every development taking place in Iraq and Syria. We are determined to stand by our brothers there with our diplomatic and military power if necessary in the fight against terrorist organizations. We are present in Syria; we started from Jarabulus with the Free Syrian Army, descended from Rai to Dabik, and now we are heading to Al-Bab. Some insistently want to keep the Free Syrian Army and Turkey away from Al-Bab. Of course, we know the intentions behind this insistence. We will continue this struggle against the terrorist organizations DAESH, PYD, and YPG. The aim behind this effort is to establish a terrorist corridor that could not be created along our borders, even if it is from a little further down; we will not consent to this.

In fact, we are determined to cleanse Manbij of the PYD terrorist organization as soon as possible. They will either leave, retreat, and go east beyond the Euphrates; if they do not, we will take the necessary action.

We tell our American friends, "Is it a fight against DAESH? Let's do it together; we do not need the PYD or the YPG; we can do this together." Why should we include a terrorist organization? Is there a good or bad terrorist organization? If you say DAESH is an enemy, then Al-Nusra is fighting against DAESH. But then you declare Al-Nusra a terrorist organization; how does that work? To us, they are all terrorist organizations; is there a good or bad one? My terrorist is good, yours is bad; such an understanding cannot exist.

Look, we have taken the issue of eliminating threats to our country from the region extending from Kilis to Kırıkhan onto our agenda, if necessary, to cleanse that area of terrorist organizations. Are we going to turn a blind eye to terrorists coming from that region carrying out actions in our country and fleeing to Syria? Let it not be forgotten that this issue is a matter of survival for us. We will no longer allow terrorist organizations to operate within our borders at the cost of the blood and lives of our security personnel and citizens. What will we do? We will solve the problem at its source.

Every terrorist zone being attempted to be established in Syria is a direct threat to us. Whether it is called DAESH, PYD, or PKK, it does not matter what name it has. In Turkey's eyes, they are all terrorist organizations that need to be crushed as soon as possible.

On the other hand, we are also present in Iraq, and we will continue to exist more effectively. We will not leave our brothers in Mosul and Kirkuk alone. We have historical and cultural ties, and we have kinship bonds. We will not allow Iraq to be pushed into a sectarian war before our eyes.

DAESH exploited the Sunni interpretation of Islam to massacre Muslims. Now, other terrorist organizations are being attempted to be deployed in Iraq to again massacre Muslims through the exploitation of the Shia interpretation of Islam; we are fighting to disrupt this game. We do not want the same people who have been shedding Muslim blood in the region for over ten years under the pretext of DAESH to continue this work through other organizations.

Dear brothers and sisters;

As you can see, Turkey has every valid reason to be effectively present in both Syria and Iraq. Despite this, we are constantly subjected to accusations and attempts to block us. So I ask, why are the obstacles placed in front of us not placed in front of other countries involved in the DAESH operation? Let them answer that. They will come from thousands, tens of thousands of kilometers away and have a say in Iraq and Syria, while Turkey will not have a say in such a struggle with its neighbors; can such a thing be possible? There is no such thing. This scheme could have worked in old Turkey, but today's Turkey cannot accept such a situation.

The understanding that has been undermining, regressing, and rendering Turkey unable to seek its rights for 200 years has been buried in the dark pages of history by our nation through the struggle it has been waging for 14 years, culminating in the final decision announced on July 15.

From now on, if necessary, we will fight eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth in the field, and if necessary, we will pound our fists on the diplomatic table to protect the rights, law, and future of this nation. If there is a price to pay for this, we will pay it. We know that if we do not take this risk, they will present us with something much bigger tomorrow.

Now I need to say a few words about July 15. Recently, there has been a narrative of victimhood going around. Dear brothers and sisters, those who are currently detained are said to be victims. There may be some exceptional cases among them. But I want you to know who the real victims are. Now, of course, there are new martyrs; we have 246 martyrs. These are the martyrs of July 15. Otherwise, we have martyrs in the struggle in the Southeast and the East; I mention them as well. You know we had 2,194 veterans.

Are not the families of these martyrs victims? Are not the families of these veterans victims? Did not my nation experience this victimhood with what they lived through that night?

Whoever is making a narrative of victimhood related to these matters because of the members of the FETÖ terrorist organization, let them not be offended; they are in betrayal, I speak this clearly. No one should come and give us advice on this matter; they should keep that advice to themselves. When you do not have your wife, husband, child, or whatever, and then when you go inside, you say, "My child is a victim, my daughter is a victim..." You will collect all this money at the fundraising meetings, and then you will pour it somewhere; and then, you are a victim. What victimhood? Excuse me, a betrayal network will come together and say everything up to cursing the President of this country, and they will be applauded there; those who applaud are the victims... How are they victims? One of them cannot even say, "What are you saying?" They cannot say, "How can you insult our President?" This President is, yes, a President who has become the land for his citizens; you will rise up and insult him there.

My fellow mukhtars;

We have not been subservient to anyone. They went and became subservient to FETÖ, saying, "He is closer to us than our jugular vein." Our God is closer to us than our jugular vein. Who is this FETÖ? How can he be closer to us than our jugular vein? They are in shirk, they are in disbelief. And then they all run away. Why did you run away? If you are right, seek your rights.

Brothers and sisters;

No one should be offended; do not make this narrative of victimhood. Whether they are my closest brothers, friends, or those from different places, whoever stands with those who make this narrative of victimhood is in serious trouble; let them weigh themselves on a scale. We are tired of this. Because for the peace of my country, we must display this resolute stance, and we will do so.

Look, do you know what the plan was in Germany during the East-West reunification? It was to remove 2 million civil servants. In the end, they removed 600,000 people from the state. Why? To establish today's Germany. We will take whatever steps are necessary; we are obliged to do so. In which department? The legal department is currently working on this. Those who came to kill me and my family, those who came to abduct us, you know, days later they were caught in the forest. Our security forces who caught them in the forest could have killed them there; look, they did not. What did they do? They arrested them, brought them to the police, and then took them to court. We are taking our steps while protecting the law of the matter to such an extent. They do not kill those who come to kill the President; pay attention, they arrest them and bring them to justice. We have an understanding that protects the law of the matter to this extent. We did not act out of self-interest; we acted sincerely. Our self is not the issue; our issue is the nation, our issue is the homeland; we pay attention to this.

Dear brothers and sisters;

The issues of Iraq and Syria may be an energy issue, a petroleum issue, a regional interest issue, or an issue of expanding the area of influence for others; for us, this issue is a matter of life and death. My advice to those who stand in our way is to reassess the issue from this perspective. Those who equate Turkey with terrorist organizations should not forget that they are subjecting themselves to a similar comparison. There is an Arab saying, "men dakka, dukka." Those who knock on our door today will also knock on your door tomorrow; do not forget that.

We have no animosity, prejudice, or complexes against anyone. We hold the hand of everyone who extends a friendly hand to us. Just like many friendly countries and peoples in the Balkans, Central Asia, South Asia, and Africa... At the same time, we do not hesitate to tear out the claws of those who show their fangs at us; let it be known. Here is the Battle of Gallipoli, here is the War of Independence, here is Cyprus, here is July 15... We are in pursuit of increasing friendships and reducing hostilities; we are ready to walk together with everyone who shares the same approach until the end. I pray that the coming days will bring good developments for our brothers in Iraq and Syria.

With these feelings, I once again express my gratitude to each of you for honoring the Presidential Complex, this gazi place. You know, 29 people were martyred around this complex, and 36 people became veterans; that is why this Complex became a gazi Complex.

I ask you to convey my heartfelt regards and greetings to my brothers in your neighborhoods and villages.

We will be together again at dinner shortly. For now, I greet you with love and respect, and I say may God be your helper and supporter.