Speech at the City and Security Symposium

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

2 January 2020 · City and Security Symposium

Context
Erdoğan addressed the City and Security Symposium on January 2, 2020, organized by the Police Academy and Union of Turkish Municipalities to discuss urban security challenges.
Main themes
Urban security, city and civilization, urbanization in Turkey, neighborhood culture, historical cities, Göbeklitepe discovery, technological complexity of modern cities, public safety methods, cultural heritage, security institutions
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,867
74th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 49%44%
  • Geopolitical 18%16%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Economic 3%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 11%

170 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Esteemed Managers of the Police Academy and the Union of Turkish Municipalities,

Valued Members of Our Academic World,

Dear Guests,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I greet you with my warmest feelings, with longing and affection. I pray that the City and Security Symposium will be a harbinger of good for our country, our cities, and all our people. I congratulate all our friends who contributed to the realization of the symposium, especially on behalf of myself and my nation.

I extend my heartfelt gratitude to our academics and institutional representatives who will ensure that the symposium achieves its purpose with their evaluations and proposals.

Ninety years ago in our country, less than a quarter of our population lived in city centers. Today, however, more than three-quarters of our population resides in provincial and district centers. In such a period, the issues of city and security need to be discussed, debated, and developed more.

In fact, the concept of the city holds a very important place in human history. In our civilization, the city is even a part of the conception of Paradise. Classical historical theory states that humanity transitioned to a settled order and built cities to meet security and food needs. However, this acceptance has been fundamentally shaken by the discovery of Göbeklitepe in Şanlıurfa. Göbeklitepe, which reveals that people transitioned to a settled order not for security and food but for worship, also takes the known history of cities back 12,000 years. This discovery is significant not only for its archaeological importance but also for demonstrating the purpose of human creation and capabilities. The fact that Göbeklitepe, which illustrates the depth of the relationship between the city and humanity, is located on our soil is also a sign of the vast cultural and civilizational treasure of our ancient geography.

The cities established by our ancestors – as I mentioned earlier – were shaped around a mosque and the bazaars lined up around it, which is likely a result of this ancient understanding of our geography. I have been following with appreciation the recent steps taken to strengthen neighborhood culture. One of these is the re-establishment of the watchman institution. I know that thanks to our watchmen, whose numbers have reached 20,000 today, our citizens in neighborhoods can lay their heads on their pillows more peacefully at night. As our Minister just stated, this number has now reached 30,000. Inshallah, we will revive the other elements of our neighborhood culture and pass this great heritage on to future generations. The site culture is not our culture. But unfortunately, a site culture understanding has begun to dominate in our country.

Dear Friends,

All civilizations that have shaped the course of history have been built in cities. Each civilization has developed cities within the framework of its own beliefs, morals, art, and philosophy, identified its problems, and produced solutions. The security of cities is among these issues. In the early days, the need for security, which generally stemmed from external threats, has diversified over time. In the face of potential attacks from outside, humanity has sometimes tried to take precautions by building walls around the city, and sometimes by digging moats. Today, there are many cities famous for their still-standing walls, such as Istanbul, Jerusalem, Diyarbakır, and Dubrovnik. Of course, there have been times when walls thought to be insurmountable, as in the conquest of Istanbul by Fatih, were breached, and moats deemed impassable were crossed. The security problems of cities have sometimes also stemmed from internal troubles. It is not as easy as it seems to live and let live in peace, security, and prosperity in a relatively small area with a large population. The chaos experienced in cities for various reasons has resulted in significant human and physical costs. Natural disasters such as earthquakes, fires, and diseases have also seriously shaken cities. There are many settlements that have been completely abandoned due to economic reasons, security issues, and natural disasters.

In today's world, there are cities in many different countries that host millions, even tens of millions of people. In fact, the number of cities with populations over 10 million in the world has approached 40. Along with this crowded population, the development of technology has made the infrastructure and superstructure networks of cities quite complex.

Of course, the meaning of security services has changed in such large cities. The larger the city, the higher and more numerous the security issues. Indeed, when I look at the topics of our symposium, I see this diversity. We have now reached a point where we cannot protect the external security of our cities with walls and moats, nor can we maintain internal order solely with law enforcement. Therefore, we need to develop new approaches, new ideas, and new methods in response to this new situation. I believe that such studies will contribute to the establishment of the security order we need for the future of our cities.

Each country and society must produce solutions suitable for its own needs. Otherwise, we will have to use solutions that are products of other societies' needs. This brings along many adaptation problems. As in every field, we will examine all examples in the world regarding the security of our cities, but in the end, we will cut our own umbilical cord.

Dear Friends,

The elements threatening cities in today's world have diversified significantly. Today's cities must simultaneously combat many issues such as traffic, environment, infrastructure, urban planning, energy, food, health, human trafficking, and drugs. Political crises, terrorism, unemployment, poverty, human rights, and along with all these, human rights violations, ethnic and religious tensions, and environmental pollution are common problems of humanity that are centered in cities. Cities, which have become crowded with the coming together of different elements, are growing larger every day. In addition to known criminal methods such as murder, theft, drug dealing, gambling, and prostitution, other threats are also emerging that cities must face.

In our recent history, waves of chaos that have caused serious damage to cities have occurred in many places around the world, including our country. For example, the major street protests in England in 2011, in Istanbul in 2013, and in Paris in 2018 – and of course they are still ongoing – have clearly revealed a significant danger that cities face. The centers of social movements that have led to very serious consequences in North Africa, the Middle East, and South America have always been cities. Let us be aware of the fact that organized groups, which can be considered quite small in relation to the city population, can carry out actions that paralyze all life.

In our country, there have been attempts in the past to separate our cities sometimes by physical, sometimes by sociological differences. When we look back, we could see this reality in many of our cities in Turkey in the 1960s and 1970s. There were significant differences in infrastructure and superstructure between slum neighborhoods and historical or modern districts. Similarly, political, ethnic, and sectarian fault lines were sometimes a deep cause of division that could turn bloody. Our cities have also taken their share from the great transformation that Turkey has experienced in every field. Especially thanks to the significant investments we have made in the last 17 years, Turkey has now reached a quite advanced level in terms of physical infrastructure, while also achieving a more democratic structure sociologically. You can take this from the Southeast, you can take it from Eastern Anatolia, and while fighting terrorism, we also saw this in places that constitute the infrastructure of terrorism, in urbanization. What did we do there? We uprooted, demolished, and went on the path of rebuilding and revitalizing the cities. In our country, there is absolutely no new construction of slums, and a significant portion of the old ones has been eliminated through urban transformation projects, and this continues. We have both improved the quality of housing for our existing population and met the housing demand of the constantly increasing population. Our municipalities and the private sector have also embraced this significant transformation led by TOKİ. Until yesterday, our people, whose only concern was to find a roof over their heads, are now presenting us with demands for housing at much higher standards.

Now let me open a parenthesis here. I see that some of our esteemed mayors are among us. But I have a request: especially in the construction and revitalization of urbanization, the whole issue is in your hands. There should be no concessions from here. If we make small calculations, believe me, we will betray our cities. A determined stance is essential here. What if elections are coming, what will happen, will we win the election, will we lose, what will happen?

Dear Friends,

I always say, look, we would betray our cities with vertical architecture. With horizontal architecture, we would both build our own civilization and find the opportunity to show the world what urbanization truly is. We need to take these steps with determination and, if necessary, collaborate with TOKİ and Emlak Konut to create model projects and take these steps accordingly. If we do not take these steps, then it will be too late. And we must succeed in this. We cannot get anywhere with buildings stacked like matchboxes. It is essential that we take these steps inspired by our past, which is fitting for our civilization, and this will serve as an example in the world. We need to strive to be closer to the ground rather than the sky. After all, isn’t that where we are ultimately headed? We will go there. Therefore, through the common denominator of one nation, one flag, one homeland, and one state, we will also prevent the social differences from becoming a source of tension.

If Turkey's national projects can find a truly broad and sincere support base, it is thanks to this. Inshallah, we will continue to work with determination and resolve until we reach our 2023 goals within this beautiful atmosphere. We will fully realize this great vision that includes the security of our cities.

Dear Friends,

The balance between democracy and security is increasingly becoming an equation that we encounter in today's world. Although Western countries act as if they are the ones who set the rules of democracy and are its rightful owners, when they are in trouble, they experience the greatest upheaval themselves. You can see what is happening in France right now, you can see the state of the streets of Paris. You can see what has happened to London in England. Similarly, you can see what has happened in Berlin and Düsseldorf in Germany.

Look, I say this openly and clearly, believe me, these are the good days; much greater calamities await. Why? Because all the drug-related incidents that threaten security are working together with the barons of the terrorist organizations we have here. And we are continuing our struggle against these terrorist organizations with determination. Turkey has been subjected to bloody attacks by terrorist organizations almost every day for a long time, especially in its cities. Thanks to the measures we have taken within the framework of the rule of law and the heroic struggle of our security forces, we have thankfully left this troubled period behind.

When an event that happens to us every day occurs randomly in a Western country, a completely different picture emerges. In such a situation, a security order is established where democracy, law, and human rights are almost shelved. Western cities, which are supposedly symbols of rules, order, and freedom, suddenly turned into open-air prisons. Forget about legal rights; even the most basic human rights have been violated, and the panic caused by security concerns has overshadowed everything. We saw this more recently in the Netherlands, we saw it in Paris, how police dragged women on the ground, how they beat women with their batons, how they beat people. All of this happened there, and we watched it on screens. But if Turkish police were to do something similar, they would raise the world in uproar. We will see these realities and we will explain them to our people. This distorted situation has been repeatedly experienced throughout the entire Western world, from America to Europe. In America, they force people to put their hands on the car, they shoot from behind, and we see these too. Can our police do such a thing? No. We need to see all these realities. It is ruthless; they have no mercy at this point. But the trial of these in the world or placing them within a series of values is not something that just anyone can achieve.

Today, all the possibilities of technology in the world have been mobilized, especially for the security of cities. Now a concept has emerged, what is it? Smart city. With this approach, the aim is to facilitate human life, but the technological infrastructure developed for this can be used in the opposite direction when security risks come to the forefront. Of course, security is important; taking all kinds of measures against terrorism and crime is the most important responsibility of states towards their citizens, but acting with principles in this matter should be as important as the struggle itself. While standing alongside those who try to drag the streets of Istanbul into chaos, if you do not show any compassion when the same actions occur in Paris, London, Berlin, or New York, no one will believe in your sincerity. The greatest dilemma that Western democracy has fallen into today is this double standard. They show the same lack of principles regarding refugees. While Turkey has opened its arms to over 5 million people, including nearly 4 million Syrians scattered across its 81 provinces, the humanitarian sensitivity of those who do not want foreigners in their own cities loses its credibility. However, they have far more material means than we do to support these oppressed people. Why don’t they open their doors, why don’t they welcome them? It does not suit their interests. But we, as I just mentioned, have opened our doors in accordance with the command of our civilization and our faith, and we are currently hosting those fleeing from barrel bombs.

And alongside this, what is happening in Idlib continues in the same way; currently, 200,000 to 250,000 refugees are on the move towards our border. As of now, we are trying to prevent this with some mutual measures, but it is not easy, it is difficult. Who is in front of you? It is human beings. We cannot create barriers or barbed wire against humans as the West does at this point. The same thing could happen to us; when it does, we must do what is much more just and humane. Recent events have shown that; their pockets may be full, but their hearts are barren, know this well. The Turkish nation has given a lesson in humanity to all of the West, and even to a significant part of the Arab world, with its richness of spirit. Why do I say this? The Arab League came together and made exclusionary decisions against Turkey. Who are we hosting? Almost the overwhelming majority of the 4 million refugees currently in our country are Arabs, Arabs coming from Syria. Among them, there are also 350,000 Kurds. Those who claim to represent my Kurdish citizens in Turkey have no connection whatsoever to being the representatives of my Kurdish citizens. It is we who are currently clothing, feeding, and providing health services to them. The same goes for our Arab brothers. But they can shamelessly make this decision in the Arab League. Why? Because their concerns are different; I will not go into those details.

Dear Brothers and Sisters,

You are safe to the extent that you value your own people and those who seek refuge with you. Today, despite having over 5 million foreign guests in Turkey, including these others, thank God, we have not experienced any significant security issues in our cities. We provide this climate not through pressure and coercion, but through the power of conscience and compassion. Of course, we have our difficulties and challenges. But thank God, we have the faith and the means to overcome all of them. Because we are Turkey; even this title alone is enough to provide us with a strength and superiority that no one else has.

Dear Friends,

Belonging to a city requires taking responsibility for both the material and spiritual wealth of the city and ensuring peace and security sustainably. We cannot achieve our goals without establishing this chain of responsibility uninterruptedly, from citizens with no titles to the President. I believe that this symposium has been organized with such an understanding.

I wish for the program, which will last until tomorrow evening, to be successful and to lead to good outcomes. As is known, just as the law between Mecca and Medina is, I believe that the law that will emerge in this symposium will be the same.

I congratulate everyone who contributed once again. I greet you with love and respect; stay healthy.