Speech at the International Symposium from the State Council to the Council of State

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

24 October 2018 · International Symposium from the State Council to the Council of State

Context
Erdoğan addressed an international symposium in Ankara marking the 150th anniversary of Turkey's Council of State on October 24, 2018.
Main themes
Presidential government system, Council of State 150th anniversary, Turkey's governance reform, separation of powers, national will and democracy, executive duality, judicial accountability, parliamentary to presidential transition, rule of law, administrative efficiency
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,967
75th percentile
Sentences
137
77th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%58%
  • Geopolitical 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

137 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Esteemed President and members of our Council of State,

Valuable representatives of our judiciary community,

Esteemed professors,

Honorable guests;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, with affection and respect. I wish for the ‘International Symposium on the Council of State to the Council of State in its 150th Year,’ organized under the leadership of our Atatürk Culture, Language and History High Institution, with the contributions of our Council of State, to be successful.

I express my gratitude to everyone involved in the execution and implementation of the symposium, especially to our Atatürk Culture, Language and History High Institution. On this occasion, I once again congratulate our Council of State, which is celebrating its 150th anniversary this year, and wish them success in their endeavors. I welcome our guests who have come to Ankara from both domestic and international locations to participate in the symposium and thank them in advance for their contributions. I am, of course, considering the points raised by our esteemed President of the Council of State in his earlier speech with sensitivity, and I wish them success in the work that will be carried out in line with this vision, purpose, and ideals.

This symposium does not only take place during the time we are celebrating the 150th anniversary of our Council of State; it also coincides with the immediate aftermath of the June 24 elections, in which our country signed one of the largest and most profound reforms in our history. I believe that the presentations our esteemed professors, each an expert in their field, will make today and tomorrow are of great importance in this regard, because nothing in Turkey can continue as it did before.

As of the June 24 elections, our country has entered a completely new path by abandoning the parliamentary system as its governance model. The name of this new model, which we took the first step towards with the April 16 referendum and implemented with the June 24 elections, is the presidential government system. The presidential government system is, in fact, one of the most important reforms that the Council of State has witnessed and implemented throughout its 150-year history in the discussions about Turkey's governance system.

This change, which our nation has stamped with its free will, also signifies a new stage in our country's journey towards democracy. Thus, Turkey has freed itself from the tutelary structure that has held the national will captive for many years and has taken a historic step towards genuine democracy.

The most important feature of the new system is that it guarantees the complete reflection of the will expressed at the ballot box in the governance of the state by ending duality in the executive. I believe that the distorted understanding, which could not truly implement the separation of powers and aimed instead to hinder the national will through anti-democratic institutions and organizations, will finally be corrected; but I ask myself, has it been corrected? I see some practices that unfortunately indicate a process leading not just to duality, but even to multiplicity.

And I am struggling with the definitions of some concepts. Indeed, in today’s concept, especially the title is very beautiful, the meaning of the Council of State is truly beautiful, and its content is magnificent. The Council of State, that is another matter. If we were to ask those who understand these matters well, what is the Council of State, what is the Council of State, I assure you they would not be able to make sense of it. Because the Council of State is the advisory body of the state. Well, whose decision, whose execution is this? This is, in terms of appropriateness, the responsibility of the administration; we need to understand this well. If we cannot understand this well, do you know where the situation leads? I speak from experience.

We are conducting the tender for the İzmir Port, and the tender for İzmir Port has been waiting at the Council of State for 2 years; at the end of 2 years, the person who was to take it gives up, and we lose 1 billion dollars. Now, how will the Council of State explain this to me, for God's sake? Who will account for the 1 billion dollars? You can come and tell us whatever you think in a series, and then we will make our decision. But no one has the right to make this nation pay the price of 1 billion dollars. When such a thing happens in the administration, all judicial bodies pounce on the administration; but when the Council of State unfortunately delays such a decision, who will hold them accountable? There is no authority to hold them accountable. Look, this is just one example, that’s all. Are there no other examples? There are, but I do not want to delve into them in such a meeting; however, I have experienced many of these during my 16 years as Prime Minister and President, and I speak from experience.

In the last constitutional amendment, we even made changes in the advisory point, but it seems that this has not yet penetrated the Council of State. The Council of State has not yet implemented this, even though this change was made. In the presidential government system, which guarantees political stability, the separation of powers has been fully established for the first time in our country’s history, if adhered to.

With the April 16 referendum, the independence of the judiciary, along with its impartiality, has been constitutionally framed, which is of historical significance. For the judicial power, independence and impartiality are two key concepts that complement each other. Independence provides a guarantee against external influences and interventions in the judiciary, while impartiality expresses a reasoning activity free from ideological molds, political attitudes, and individual prejudices. The judiciary's ability to fulfill its role as an arbitrator is possible by adhering to the framework defined by these two concepts.

The painful experiences we have had in both the December 17-25 coup attempt and the July 15 coup attempt have shown us how essential and vital these two concepts are in establishing justice. Those who place ideological bigotry above reason and conscience when making their decisions, and those who act according to the orders coming from the leader of the FETÖ terrorist organization instead of independence and impartiality, have brought Turkey to the brink of a great disaster. It was the resolute stance of the political will and the determination of our noble nation to protect its democracy at all costs that saved us from the destruction that the FETÖ treason gang wanted to drag our country into. Just as in the War of Independence, our nation and our state stood shoulder to shoulder to repel the invasion attempt, thus opening the doors to the April 16 referendum and the presidential government system.

On this occasion, I once again pray for the mercy of Allah upon our martyrs who shielded their chests against the bullets of the coup plotters that night. I also thank the members of the judiciary who have shown extraordinary effort for the establishment of justice from the very first moments of the coup attempt until today.

Dear friends;

The existence of an effective and swiftly functioning judiciary system that signs decisions that reassure the conscience of the nation is an integral part of the rule of law. In a state that upholds the rule of law, the judiciary serves as an arbitrator. The judiciary's ability to fulfill this duty depends on its capacity to resolve the issues it faces objectively, fairly, and within the limits set by the constitution and laws. The judiciary's adherence to the legal framework is far more important than the attitudes of all other institutions, organizations, and individuals. Any small negligence or violation in this regard will not only undermine our nation's trust in the judiciary but will also cause irreparable damage in governance.

Just as the independence and impartiality of the judiciary are indispensable conditions for democracy, juristocracy is equally a significant threat. The most important factor that will prevent the judiciary from falling into the trap of juristocracy, which primarily endangers its own reputation, is the self-restraint it will show in not exceeding its authority when making decisions. It is never correct to act like a legislator instead of applying the law, or to expand the boundaries of legal compliance control to include appropriateness control; we must emphasize this.

Now I am curious, is the duty or right of appropriateness belonging to the administration or the judiciary? We have been fighting this battle for 16 years, and we are still fighting it. Then let the judiciary come and take on the duties of the administration as well. On one hand, we talk about their separation, while on the other hand, we see that the judiciary is also exercising the authority of appropriateness; such a thing cannot be. If we say Council of State, and if we evaluate it as an advisory body, then it must express the duties of an advisory body. If it claims to be a decision-making authority, then why are we here?

Especially now, before preparing presidential decrees, if we are going to ask the Council of State about this and seek permission from there, then I should not stay in this position; I should withdraw and leave. Can such a thing happen? I apologize, but there are so many legal experts, constitutional law experts, criminal law experts, civil law experts, all of them are here. Why does the state pay these people such salaries? It is not to have them lie around there. Provide the necessary support to the President in these preparations, prepare them in the most ideal way, and take these steps accordingly; this is what we are doing.

Therefore, we need to apply the definition of the separation of powers exactly as it is; if we apply it as it suits us, we will not reach a conclusion. Then two years pass, and you lose 1 billion dollars there. This is not always the case; sometimes it takes 5 years. Now, the Council of State is making a decision regarding the oath after 5 years. Where were you in 2013, and where were you from 2013 to 2018? Why was no decision made on this matter until 2018, and why is it being made now? Did it just come to your mind now?

I apologize, but it is our right to ask this. We applaud our judiciary when it deserves applause, but we must also speak up when it is wrong, because when the nation needs to give a slap, it gives it to me, not to you. When we go out to the squares, when it needs to boo, it boos us, not you; we are the ones who are held accountable, and that is the essence of democracy. Therefore, we expect fair decisions from you without delay.

Turkey is a country that has suffered greatly from such wrong steps, especially during periods when the law and the constitution were suspended. From the Yassıada courts to the legal absurdities experienced during the February 28 process, both our citizens and our judiciary community have paid the price for the politicization of the judiciary. I believe that none of us will allow such an atmosphere to form in our country again.

We must never turn a blind eye to the resurgence of the tutelary mentality that has diminished the quality of our democracy, which has victimized all of us or made us all victims at one time. Undoubtedly, the judiciary community itself will show the greatest sensitivity in this regard. I believe that the Turkish judiciary, which has achieved significant successes in eliminating those infected with FETÖ, will not allow the mentality that subordinates the law to the status quo to resurface. In this context, I believe that some of the recent discussions will also be resolved within the legal process. I hope that no one will remain indifferent to the regression of the standards of Turkish democracy.

Valuable friends;

Turkey has made historic reforms in every field from the judiciary to the economy over the past 16 years, while at the same time reinforcing its power, position, and reputation in international politics. We have transitioned from a country that observes regional and global issues from the sidelines to a country that directly intervenes in events with its army, businessmen, civil society organizations, diplomats, and public officials. We have moved from a Turkey whose direction was determined by policies imposed by others to a country that takes risks and assumes responsibilities for its survival when necessary.

Today, Turkey has become a country that is the voice of global conscience on the international stage. There is a Turkey that advocates the indispensability of justice, law, human life, and democracy in every corner of the world. In the midst of all troubles, conflicts, and instabilities, there is a Turkey that stands as a bastion of stability and security. In defiance of those who make dirty calculations and only look out for their own interests, we strive to elevate conscience, humanity, sharing, and solidarity.

As much as we see, protect, and care for those in need next to us, as a requirement of our historical responsibility and belief, we also extend our arms to our brothers around the world. Wherever there is oppression, suffering, or injustice, from Syria to Iraq, Afghanistan to Somalia, Palestine to Arakan, Yemen to Egypt, we are fighting to alleviate these with the means at our disposal. We are striving for peace, tranquility, and stability not only in our country but also starting from our region to the entire world. We seek justice for everyone, not just for ourselves. We advocate that the values that make a human a human should not be sacrificed for material interests.

We have once again demonstrated our conscience, law, and human-centered foreign policy in the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, which has occupied the world's agenda for 22 days. We ensured that this sui generis incident, both in terms of diplomatic history and international relations, was handled with the seriousness and sensitivity befitting the Republic of Turkey. Without casting suspicion on anyone, we made efforts to clarify the incident based entirely on the evidence obtained. We never turned a blind eye to the black propaganda produced in certain centers that sought to obscure the truth.

We shared the findings and documents obtained so far by our security, intelligence, and judiciary units, all of which have been confirmed, with our counterparts and the international community during our Group Meeting yesterday. However, some people are disturbed by this sharing. And unfortunately, we receive questions like "Where were you for 3 days, 5 days?" Why? They have no burden on their shoulders, no responsibility, and they ask comfortably. There is a flow to this matter. If you ask them what the Vienna Convention is, they have no idea about it. All of this has a flow. Where will what happen, how will you do what, they are completely unaware of these. And with this step we have taken, we have dismantled this piece by piece, we have extracted it, and the work is still not finished; we are still dismantling and extracting, and now the world has started to closely follow this issue. Creating the international atmosphere for this is actually a title of this process.

We see that the sensitivity, determination, and of course transparency demonstrated by Turkey in this process are appreciated not only by the family of the victim but by the entire world. As a country, we are determined not to allow the cover-up of the murder and the evasion of justice by all those responsible, from the one who ordered it to the one who executed it. This is not only a requirement of our responsibility towards the late Jamal Khashoggi, who fell victim to a brutal murder within our borders, but also towards the international community, law, and justice. Turkey's entire effort is for the realization of justice. As we reach new evidence that will illuminate the dark sides of the murder, we will continue to share this transparently with our counterparts. God willing, we will successfully manage this sensitive process and make the necessary efforts for the perpetrators to be held accountable.

Dear friends;

Turkey owes its achievements over the last 16 years to its reform and democratization will. It is this reformist spirit that will carry our country to the 2023 goals and lay the groundwork for the visions of 2053 and 2071. We will continue the democratic transformation we initiated with the April 16 referendum and the June 24 elections without losing momentum. We are determined to eliminate all the outdated habits that have shackled Turkey.

We will achieve this not with an understanding that destroys, eradicates, or renounces heritage, but with a perspective that draws from tradition. We see our reform efforts as a bridge built from tradition to the future. Just like our Council of State, which is celebrating its 150th anniversary this year, we are preserving our ties to our roots on one hand while laying the groundwork for a brighter, freer, and more prosperous Turkey on the other. I consider the International Symposium from the Council of State to be an important step for both the revival of tradition and the construction of the future in light of our new governance model.

As I conclude my remarks with these thoughts, I once again congratulate those who contributed to the organization of the symposium and wish them success in their work. I would like to once again welcome our guests from abroad to our country and extend my heartfelt greetings to all participants.