Speech at the Local Governments Symposium within the Presidential Government System

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

9 January 2019 · Local Governments Symposium within the Presidential Government System · Presidential Complex

Context
Erdoğan addressed academics and local government officials at a symposium organized before the March 31, 2019 local elections, held at the Presidential Complex in Ankara.
Main themes
Presidential government system, local governments, governance reform, inflation history, coalition governments, AK Party economic performance, March 31 local elections, ethics in local governance, Turkish political history, municipal administration
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,710
90th percentile
Sentences
270
94th percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%31%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Environmental 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

270 sentences in 86 paragraphs

Dear guests,

Esteemed academics,

Ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my warmest feelings and affection. Welcome to the Presidential Complex, the house of the nation, this revered place.

I hope that our meeting organized by the Union of Turkish Municipalities and the Presidential Local Government Policies Council will be a harbinger of good things.

I would like to thank those who organized this symposium on local governments within the Presidential Government System, as well as all our friends who will contribute to our meeting with their presentations and discussions. I would also like to extend my gratitude to the Public Officials Ethics Board for their support in this process with their work on ethics in local governments.

I find it very appropriate that this symposium is being held before the March 31 Local Administrations Elections. I see that the session titles will shed light on both the academics and policymakers interested in local governments, as well as the mayors in executive positions.

It is very difficult to predict where paths not illuminated by the light of science will lead. The local government symposium is, in fact, a light ignited for everyone who knows how to benefit from it in their field. It is also very important for our institutions to show sensitivity in implementing the discussions and results of the symposium, as it ensures that the efforts put forth are rewarded. Once again, I thank you all for your participation in our meeting.

Valued guests;

Turkey has experienced many historical events in the last five years, and the transition to the Presidential Government System is undoubtedly one of the most important among them. In fact, discussions about Turkey's governance system are not new; they date back a long time. Our search for a governance system, which began with the declaration of constitutionalism during the Ottoman period and underwent a sharp change with our War of Independence and the Republic, continued after the transition to a multi-party life. The years spent under coalitions within the parliamentary system have had a very heavy cost for our country. During these periods, which are remembered for constant crises, chaos, coups, juntas, and instabilities, every responsible state and intellectual has always said that our governance system needed to change.

We have also consistently expressed that our governance system needs to change, especially since 2011.

I have a table in front of me regarding the periods spent under coalition governments. Except for three periods or three years, the others were all coalitions. And within these periods, I wanted to extract the inflation data for the last 30 years. The average inflation for 14 of those years is 70.3. However, when we look at the opposition now, they say, "The highest inflation period is during the current government's term." I am speaking with official figures, not throwing around numbers; we have our professors among us, we have our members of parliament, and my ministerial colleagues, all of whom can research this.

Look; in 1989, inflation was 64.3, during the single-party period, the Motherland Party.

In 1990, inflation was 60.4, under the Motherland government.

In 1991, inflation was 71.1, during the Motherland period.

In 1992, DYP-SHP, inflation was 66.

In 1993, inflation was 71.1, DYP-SHP.

In 1994, this was a disaster, inflation was 120.3, the government was DYP-SHP.

In 1995, inflation was 76.1, again under DYP-SHP.

In 1996, inflation was 79.8, the government was Welfare-DYP.

In 1997, inflation was 99.1, Motherland-DSP.

In 1998, inflation was 69.1, the government was Motherland-DSP.

In 1999, there was a tripartite government, but inflation was 68.8.

In 2000, we see that for the first time during the coalition period, it drops a bit to 39, still a tripartite government.

In 2001, inflation was again 68.5, a tripartite coalition.

I come to 2002, where the point where this tripartite coalition fell is 29.8.

The average inflation for these 14 years is 70.3. And then, with our coming to power, the coalition period ends, and we have been in power alone, with an average inflation of 9.54 over 16 years.

The reality is clear; we are in power alone in all of them. Here, we also see; in 2003, it was 12.7, in 2004, 9.4, in 2005, 7.7, in 2006, 9.7, in 2007, 8.4, in 2008, 10.1, in 2009, 6.5, in 2010, 6.4, in 2011, 10.5, in 2012, 6.2, in 2013, 7.4, in 2014, 8.2, in 2015, 8.8, in 2016, 8.5, in 2017, 11.9, the highest in 2018 was 20.3, but the average is 9.54.

Now the main opposition comes out and says, "The highest inflation has occurred during the AK Party governments." In other words, when politics is based on lies, when local government is based on lies, you cannot escape from garbage, pits, and mud.

Dear friends;

When I became the Mayor of Istanbul, I took over Istanbul from the CHP mentality. Those who live in Istanbul know very well what kind of Istanbul I inherited. An Istanbul with mountains of garbage, severe air pollution, and some media outlets distributing masks. In fact, as a result of the explosion of the wild garbage dump in Ümraniye, 39 of our citizens lost their lives, and the Mayor there was also from the CHP, but of course, the metropolitan municipalities handle garbage disposal, and there was a Mayor at that time too, and now he defends himself, saying, "There was a strike, what could I do?" Well, if there was a strike, it was due to your incompetence, or there are ways to prevent a strike; you should have solved it.

Look, right now there is a strike in İzmir at İZBAN; we saw that they could not agree, they could not resolve it, so we had to postpone the strike for 2 months with a Presidential Decree, as my authority extends that far, and then it will go to an arbitration board. Why? We have a problem; we are concerned. Do we have the right to leave our citizens destitute in the streets? We must solve this. The state has done 50% of İZBAN, and the municipality has done 50%. Why were these done? To ensure that our people can travel peacefully. And as of yesterday, the strike there has been postponed for 2 months.

The decision to transition to Turkey's new governance system, as you know, emerged after a series of severe crises. With the Gezi Events, you know the streets, with the December 17-25 coup attempt through the police-judiciary, our government was targeted through bureaucracy, and the pit actions have shown what has happened to the unity of our country, especially my brothers living in Southeastern Anatolia know well how it has been affected. We have been subjected to multi-faceted and multi-dimensional attacks targeting our borders due to threats originating from Syria and Iraq, especially during the elections we experienced consecutively in 2015.

The last coup attempt on July 15 showed us that we needed to act immediately to secure the future of our country. Thanks to the consensus we reached with the Nationalist Movement Party as the AK Party, we first registered this change in the Parliament and then through a referendum with our nation. The executive organ of the new system will remain entirely under the President's authority, while legislative powers will belong entirely to the Parliament, and the judiciary will be structured to work independently and impartially. Thus, we created a structure that truly implements the separation of powers, which previously existed only on paper. In this way, Turkey has attained the new governance system it has long sought and yearned for, as this discussion is not new.

This system was established during the late Türkeş's era, and similarly, it was persistently emphasized by the late Özal, the late Demirel, and the late Erbakan; this governance system did not start to be discussed in our era; it has been discussed since then. But there is even more history to it, where? The Ottoman Empire. This system already existed there. With the elections on June 24, we began to implement this system in all its components.

Of course, in the meantime, those who are disturbed by the peace and stability of our country did not remain idle. Immediately after our transition to the Presidential Government System, we faced an economic attack. Thank God, we quickly neutralized this attack. By restoring balance to our economy, we once again demonstrated our determination to achieve our goals to both friends and foes. We prepared and implemented very important support programs for all sectors, from industry to tradesmen, from farmers to exporters, to quickly remedy the problems experienced in the triangle of exchange rates, interest rates, and inflation.

In the meantime, we continue to resolutely reflect our policy of eliminating terrorist threats directed at our country, especially from Syria, at their source.

Both the level we have brought our country to in democracy and the economy over the last 16 years, and the capabilities of our new governance system have ensured that we can respond to the attacks we have faced more quickly and effectively. Inshallah, with the year 2019, Turkey will enter a new and strong period of rise; no one should have any doubts about this. In this process, as in every field, we will need new perspectives, new horizons, and new tools in local governments as well. I believe that the local government symposium we are together for the opening ceremony will constitute an important turning point in this regard.

And on this occasion, I would like to address one more issue, which is that I advocate for local governments to be very determined and persistent regarding the Zero Waste Project, which my wife has particularly spearheaded. What is it? Recently, you know we have launched a war regarding plastic bags and many similar products. And as you know, it takes 500 years, 750-1000 years for the soil to do what? To decompose it. This is a war against that.

Now we have started this war resolutely. I remember my mother used to weave shopping bags at home; perhaps yours did too, right? We would go shopping with those bags and come back. But you don't just throw the bag away; if necessary, you wash it again and go shopping again. And it has a friendship with the soil; even if you throw it away, it is because of that. And back then, these were made from hemp, and we destroyed hemp in our country.

In my hometown Rize, we had hemp. And they used to weave fabric from hemp, making undershirts because it absorbs sweat very differently. However, those who seem like friends to us took the hemp from my country, from Rize. Hemp is no longer produced in Rize, and now we import hemp from abroad. And if there are some things that need to be done based on hemp, we do them with those imported products. But now, hopefully, our Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry is entering into a study in this area, and we will take these steps to produce it again, inshallah.

I told my friends that in this campaign, the March 31 campaign, we should use shopping bags, we should use cloth bags, and we should carry out our campaign with these cloth bags. We will never use plastic bags. And someone needs to start this work; who is more suitable for this? If we are defending this, it suits us. And right now, we are working on this. It will be beautiful, it will be stylish. It may happen that someone else might come out with plastic bags again. It is important to distinguish these from each other.

Dear friends;

The March 31 local elections are of great significance in this regard. Our local administrations play a very important role in the development and progress of Turkey, especially in the provision of services that directly touch the lives of the people. Let it not be said that it cannot be done; we solved the garbage issue in Istanbul, thank God, in 1.5 years, and we stopped wild dumping and moved to modern disposal. We have taken steps from electricity generation to compost fertilizer production. Now some of our metropolitan municipalities have further developed this and have reached a better position. In Ankara Metropolitan, this has also reached a very different position now. Other metropolitan cities also have similar developments; it continues. And when we are determined and resolute, there is nothing we cannot achieve.

Because if we do not make this separation, that is, if we cannot separate metals, if we cannot separate plastics, if we cannot solve organic-inorganic, then we cannot succeed in this municipal governance. But if we succeed in this, then what will we do with recycling? We will have achieved it; the matter is that simple. A mayor should know this. Therefore, when forming municipal council members, you should not just make anyone a council member; you should take those who know the job. Among them, there will be environmentalists, lawyers, civil engineers, architects, financial advisors, and so on, those who know the job. If a municipal council is formed with them, and if we form zoning commissions with them, then vertical architecture will not exist in our cities; we will not only remain with horizontal architecture, but we will also take steps that align with the local characteristics. We always talk about local architecture, Safranbolu houses, Beypazarı.

But can you now create new Safranbolu houses? That is the issue; we need to do this. We need to start with ourselves. Why? As TOKİ, I have been fighting this issue for 16 years; we have built 860,000 housing units. If you ask, "Did you succeed, brother?" believe me, I have not succeeded. Why? You will do this with people; you will do this with contracting firms. We have been partially successful in some places, but unfortunately, we have not succeeded in others.

In this regard, I also address all the mayors watching us on their screens; I also call out to TOKİ, and I call out to members of the private sector; please, let us not destroy our country. They say, "We have no land, no place, what can we do?" What do you mean there is no place? Build as much as you can.

Human beings should live close to the land, not far from it; we need to ensure this. If we evaluate the lands well, there is plenty of space. And you will see that then the peace and happiness of the citizens will be very different; we need to take these steps.

For the last year, I have particularly focused on the People's Gardens, on the People's Libraries; why? Because everything is for people, and that is why I focus on it. What is the number one problem of municipalities? It is investment for people, for Turkey, for our cities. If we expand our people's gardens, then the green area per person will also increase.

From time to time, when we go to Istanbul, you see families playing in the parks prepared by the seaside, having picnics, and so on. But now, with these national gardens, what will happen to these picnic areas? They will increase. And mothers and fathers will spend their weekends there much more comfortably with their children. Additionally, when we establish National Libraries in the National Garden or in different places, the places where our youth gather and read books will increase. And what will we have done with National Libraries to save our youth from illegitimate habits? This is very important in that regard. The services provided by municipalities and special provincial administrations are essentially complementary to the work of central governments.

The priorities of municipalities and special provincial administrations, which are the executive units of the principle of local governance, can be shaped according to the needs of our settlements due to their administrative and financial autonomy.

Of course, another issue that I consider at least as important is the historical function that local administrations have undertaken in the development of democracy in our country. The process that starts with the election of muhtars and goes through the mayorships of towns, districts, provinces, or metropolitan municipalities is essentially a laboratory of our democracy.

However, it is necessary to express one thing particularly; especially here, regarding urbanism or intercity migrations, I am now going down, to districts and towns. In our town, our cousin's son needs to win, or someone from our tribe needs to win. What should we do? Let's migrate from Ankara or Istanbul.

Dear friends;

Such a thing cannot be. This is a different kind of occupation. From now on, we will closely monitor such matters with our Ministry of Interior, because this is not called democracy; there cannot be such a democracy. Let's carry them and win elections with imported troops; this cannot be. Those who live there should conduct the elections, and everyone should bear the consequences. Whoever has settled there should conduct the elections there.

We cannot attribute either municipal governance or democracy to such a misunderstanding. These are not correct things. Therefore, I want to particularly express that we have not forgotten our determination here.

Dear friends;

Many people's paths in national politics, including my own, have been opened thanks to the work and successes in municipalities. The same situation applies to society as well.

Our nation, which has the opportunity to directly elect and supervise its managers related to local services, is gaining the opportunity to use this experience more effectively across the country.

Of course, the phenomenon called globalization has not diminished the importance of local administrations; on the contrary, it has strengthened them even more. In our country, the scope and diversity of the services provided by local administrations are gradually increasing. With the metropolitan application that we have extended to all our provinces with populations over 150,000, Turkey has almost transformed its face in the field of municipal governance.

Municipalities have now gone beyond being institutions that only deal with roads, sewage, water, waste, and cleaning; as mentioned earlier, they have become the executors of many social, cultural, and artistic projects. Today, everything related to human beings falls within the scope of municipalities' responsibilities. I believe that the presidential government system will take this understanding of local administrations, which is already developing in our country, to a much higher level.

While establishing the institutional structures of the new system, we have created a Local Government Policies Board within the Presidency. As the AK Party, we are determined to lead our country in this regard by sharing the main headings of our new understanding of local administrations with our nation in the election manifesto we prepared for March 31.

We will continue to do our part to ensure that municipalities, which are our starting point in politics, continuously advance according to the needs of our age and our country.

Dear friends;

I just touched on this partially, but I will also say, ‘et tekraru ahsen velev kane yüzseksen.’ That is; a city means civilization. Medine means city, and medeni means civilized. The rise and fall of societies are always proportional to their relationship with civilization and related to it. Some see civilization only as physical structure and cultural climate, whereas the essence of civilization is faith and morality. The collapse of civilizations where faith and morality have fallen silent occurs either spontaneously or any external influence leads to this inevitable fate.

The problem of the modern world is due to its attempt to elevate civilization without faith and morality. We will not fall into this mistake, insha'Allah. While building our civilization on the accumulations of our history and culture, we will never neglect faith and morality. The reasons for the troubles experienced in our cities are precisely these neglects. We will start by reviving our civilizational values that have been overlooked due to urgent needs arising from past neglects. In the new era, we will shape the construction and development of our cities with this understanding.

It is impossible for any work that does not center on humanity to yield beneficial results. As you have been following, for a long time now, I insist on horizontal architecture in all our settlements, from the smallest to the largest. I believe that we can only achieve settlements that enable mutual interaction and solidarity among people in every area of life in this way. Otherwise, the social cost that will arise will far exceed the material burden that this model will impose.

We cannot say, "It has always been this way, and it will continue to be this way." In the new era, we will make every effort for an understanding of urbanism that is suitable for our civilizational accumulation and longing to develop and spread.

Look, I will give an interesting example here; there are those who are trying to turn our coastal areas and forested areas into concrete and soil. This money, you know, is capable of many things; this capitalism is capable of many things. They cut down and throw away whatever is in the forest; they say, "Let me build a vertical structure there and take the goods from there." This is what is being done. Nature has become irrelevant to them. They give us examples, saying, "Look at Manhattan." Let your Manhattan sink; what does our civilization say? Let's look at that and do this work accordingly. As if those living there are very happy; they are not happy. Therefore, we must know how to be civilized, and we will find that in our architectural understanding of being close to the ground, not in those concrete elevations.

For this reason, our mayors, along with their architects, construction engineers, and environmentalists, must pay great attention to this matter and take these steps with this sensitivity. I also tell my Minister of Environment and Urbanization at this point; you should not look at anyone's tears; if it is to be demolished, we will demolish it. But if they have previously obtained permission, we have nothing to do there; they have legally completed this work. However, if there is no such thing, there is absolutely no permission; we must proceed this way. Because we believe that such a profound change is only possible through the cooperation of central and local administrations.

I invite all our mayors, regardless of their party, to actively participate in this process, which I see as the construction of our future. If necessary, we can also carry out this new urbanism initiative under the roof of the Union of Turkish Municipalities. Our aim is to realize change simultaneously in every corner of our country with a work that embraces all 82 million of our citizens. I thank everyone in advance who will contribute to this great civilizational leap.

Dear friends;

As the Turkish nation, we have never walked on thornless, stone-free, or effortless paths throughout history. Every moment of ours has been vigilant, and every day has been spent in struggle; today, we are in the same situation. Look, Mimar Sinan has approximately 780 projects in his lifetime, and these are projects that have been realized. Centuries have passed, but what do we still do with Mimar Sinan's mosques, caravanserais, and madrasas? We boast. Well, can we boast about the same thing now? Will we be able to see such works centuries later? Of course, we will not be alive; that is a separate issue, but there is a visible reality; now we must achieve this. Let us create works that our grandchildren's grandchildren will hopefully see.

We are also fighting day and night against many factions of discord, from terrorist organizations to their supporters, both inside and outside. As a nation, we do not fear the enemy that we see, know, and confront courageously. For us, the real great threat is the enemies that have been infiltrated under different identities and appearances.

Recently, we have been subjected to the attack of the most insidious, vile, and dangerous of these enemies, which is the FETÖ terrorist organization. They attempted to open the door from the inside to those who plotted to occupy our country by exploiting our nation's religious values, sense of charity, and sensitivity to education.

With our nation, we successfully halted the moves of FETÖ, which sought to hand over the people and resources of this country to our enemies, first on December 17-25 and then on July 15, thanks be to Allah.

When we called for a fight against these scoundrels on December 17-15, some tried to make this issue, which is a matter of the survival of the country and the nation, a subject of their daily politics. In fact, for some, even the July 15 coup attempt was not enough to bring them to their senses. These circles, which are so devoid of understanding that they call the measures we took against FETÖ's attack on our nation a coup, are still reheating the same old narratives. The members of the terrorist organization, emboldened by their lack of foresight, dare to challenge the state in courts and prisons.

As the courts reach the decision stage, the members of the organization, seeing the bitter end awaiting them, resort to unimaginable methods to prolong the trials, discredit the courts, and intimidate state officials.

Our judges, prosecutors, gendarmerie, and police forces are patiently, steadfastly, and resolutely carrying out this process as if they are digging a well with a needle. For members of the terrorist organization, every election and every significant event has turned into a source of hope. They hope to regain control by causing my foot and, in this regard, my Party to stumble. However, our nation has seen, recognized, and rendered its judgment on them to the core.

From here, I call out to all FETÖ members inside and outside our country; your end has come, you have no place to go, no step to take. I do not know how long those behind the man called FETÖ will stand behind him, but sooner or later, he will come.

Some of your leaders have literally fled to places where they think they can live comfortably by selling you out, and they are still fleeing. But they should not get their hopes up; we are gathering them all and will bring each one of them to justice, finding them in the holes where they are hiding. Do you know what the actions of the organization members who are still raging in prisons resemble? It resembles whistling in a cemetery. Fear does not help against death.

They will pay the price of their betrayal to our nation behind iron bars in prison, and after they are released, they will pay it under the hateful gazes of our people for the rest of their lives. Because we are especially with our 251 martyrs, yes, although we are watching their bodies in the state of martyrdom, if they are watching us from that state of martyrdom, we are with them. We have never left our 2,193 veterans alone, and we will not. The guarantee of all public officials who dedicate their lives to this struggle is our state with all its institutions, our nation with all its individuals, and myself together with all of them.

We have largely purged FETÖ from the public sector, and we are gradually eliminating its connections and resources in the business world. We hope that the last remnants in municipalities will also be eliminated by our nation by March 31. We receive calls for cooperation almost every day for operations and actions against FETÖ members from another country. We will pursue them until they have no place to hide in the world.

On this occasion, I once again remember our martyrs of July 15 with mercy and wish our veterans health and well-being. I sincerely believe that our nation will once again give a lesson to those who have the shadow of FETÖ behind them on March 31.

Once again, I wish the Local Governments Symposium of the Presidential Government System to be successful and congratulate those who contributed to it. I extend my love and respect to you all.

Stay healthy.