Speech Delivered at the International Ombudsman Conference

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

25 September 2017 · International Ombudsman Conference · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed the International Ombudsman Conference in Istanbul on September 25, 2017, welcoming ombudsmen from East and West and promoting Turkey's public oversight institutions.
Main themes
Ombudsman institutions, public oversight, citizens' rights, administrative accountability, Turkish public ombudsman, Organization of Islamic Cooperation, Mediterranean Ombudsmen Union, Ottoman governance tradition, reconciliation and compliance, state-citizen relations
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,176
87th percentile
Sentences
228
92nd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 49%48%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

228 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Mr. Speaker of the Assembly,

Valuable ombudsmen of the Republic of Turkey and friendly countries,

Ladies and gentlemen;

I greet you with my heartfelt feelings, with affection and respect. I wish for the Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference, which brings together ombudsmen from the East and West, to be filled with successes.

I also wish for the Union of Ombudsmen of Member States of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, whose establishment has been completed and whose secretariat will be undertaken by our country, to be beneficial. It is an important development that the decision taken at the meeting in Pakistan in 2014 will today be concretely realized.

I am also pleased that the Board Meeting of the Mediterranean Ombudsmen Union, which will be held on the occasion of this conference, will be successful. I would like to thank the Turkish Public Ombudsman Institution, our very valuable Chief Ombudsman, and their colleagues for their contributions to the execution of these important meetings. I welcome all our esteemed friends participating in our meeting to our country and to Istanbul.

I would like to recommend that you explore the beauties of Istanbul with the following expression of the poet:

"This City of Istanbul, which is unparalleled and priceless

One of its stones is worth a whole Persian kingdom

A single jewel between two seas

If weighed against the sun of the world, it would be equal."

I hope that the views, thoughts, proposals, and experience sharing that will be presented here over the next two days will be beneficial for our future.

Dear friends;

The understanding expressed as ombudsman or public oversight in our country has various applications in our history, as was just mentioned, with examples given by both our Speaker of the Assembly and our Chief Ombudsman. We know that there are institutions aimed at this purpose, such as the 'Divan-ı Mezalim' and 'Dar-ül Adl' in the Turkish state tradition. The most important duty of positions such as the Imperial Council, the Kazasker, the Sheikh-ul-Islam, and the Qadi in the Ottoman Empire was to listen to the complaints of the people and resolve them in a timely manner.

Not by waiting five or ten years like now. The country's administrators also have a tradition of listening to the citizens' grievances, especially after Friday prayers. One of the reasons our historical states were strong, successful, and long-lasting was their ability to establish mechanisms that would allow them to listen to the voices of the people across a wide geography.

Therefore, this practice is not foreign to us, nor are we foreign to it. Despite being continuously discussed in our country in the past, we took the first step towards the establishment of the Public Ombudsman Institution, which was not possible before, during my tenure as Prime Minister in 2006. At that time, our initiative was unsuccessful due to the Constitutional Court's annulment of the relevant regulation. After the constitutional amendment in 2010, we established the Public Ombudsman Institution in 2012 in accordance with the spirit of the work, under the Turkish Grand National Assembly.

Since the Public Ombudsman Institution became operational in 2013, there have been over 36,000 applications made to it. As the level of public awareness of the institution increases, the number of applications is also increasing and will continue to do so. I find it significant that, as of September 15 of this year, 1,286 of the 11,348 applications made to the institution have been resolved through reconciliation, that is, through amicable solution decisions.

It is also gratifying that the compliance rate of the administration with the institution's recommendations has risen to 50%. Our goal is to raise both the amicable solution path—these are firsts, thus they are important—and the compliance rate of the administration with the decisions to the highest possible level. I hope that the applications concentrated in institutions such as the Presidency, the Turkish Grand National Assembly, and the Prime Ministry will eventually be directed entirely to the Public Ombudsman Institution.

The more effective and reliable the avenues for seeking rights between the administration and the people are, the more our understanding of "let the person live so that the state may live" will materialize. In our belief, only Allah is flawless, complete, and perfect; beyond that, institutions and individuals can have mistakes, shortcomings, and wrongs. What is important is that the solutions to such problems are open.

The people's ownership of the state can only be possible through the strong bonds they establish with it. Our Public Ombudsman Institution is one of the most important tools to strengthen these bonds. We will continue to support the work of our Public Ombudsman Institution, in which we have invested effort at every stage since its establishment.

Dear friends;

I see our Public Ombudsman Institution as a symbol of Turkey's historic reforms in the last 15 years aimed at strengthening democracy and expanding rights and freedoms. We are a nation that has lived through the pains of periods when the state interfered with the people's beliefs, dispositions, origins, appearances, and speech, attempting to produce a uniform human type.

Thanks to the great transformation we achieved with the support of our nation, we have left behind those troubled days that we do not even want to remember or talk about, and now we look ahead. The regulations that Turkey sincerely and swiftly implemented during its European Union membership process may not have been enough to make us a full member, but they significantly raised our democratic standards. For this reason, when the European Union adopted a contradictory stance, we said, "If necessary, we will make the name of the Copenhagen Criteria the Ankara Criteria, and we will continue on our path."

I say openly and clearly, the current direction is there, let me say that. As long as they continue to delay us like this, the time is approaching, there is no other way. Just look, the elections in Germany are a lesson, because people are now seeing everything very clearly and distinctly.

We have said many things, but they turned them upside down, and now the truth has emerged. We have no problem regarding standards related to democracy, peoples, rights, and freedoms; we cannot have a problem with the people of any country; our problem can only be with the administrations there, with the style of governance of those administrations.

Because if something is done against us, there is no situation where we will remain silent; we must respond as necessary. Even if the European Union or another institution does not demand it, we were determined to implement these reforms for ourselves, for our nation, and indeed we did so. In other words, we did not implement these reforms because someone wanted them or ordered them; we did these reforms because our nation deserves them.

Dear friends;

Do you know what our objection is? It is to the changing of the rules while the game is being played. The rule of the penalty is clear; while the match is being played, the rules of the penalty are changed; how can such a thing happen? This is what they did to us. The rules of the European Union are clear, the number of chapters is 15, and leaders participate in summits; we are negotiators, and we participate as well. However, I will not name names now, in two countries the leaders change, and they say, "Let's remove the leaders' summit once." Well? "Let's also increase the chapters to 35." Now, will you not object to this? Secondly, they are doing open-close, meaning the chapters were both opened and closed. They said, "No, it cannot be." What will happen? "Only the chapter will be opened, but it will not be closed. And also, the leaders' summit will not be held from now on." Now, will you not object to this? We are doing this and will continue to do so.

We did not accept the rules that are not even brought up in relation to other candidate countries being invented when it comes to Turkey. Turkey has strictly followed the timetable for full EU membership; we have no deficiencies or problems regarding chapters or legislative compliance. We are only facing the problem of the European Union not fulfilling its own obligations.

By not closing the chapters, the European Union has virtually seized our right to free movement, and by not fulfilling its obligations regarding refugees and violating many other promises, it has destroyed its credibility. We do not know how long a union built on protecting the rights and interests of member states can survive in such an atmosphere of distrust. Just look at Brexit in the UK; they held the vote and left. More will follow.

But let everyone know this; in this struggle, which has now turned into a theatrical play between the European Union and Turkey, we will not be the ones to throw in the towel. The party that needs to make a decision and announce it to the whole world is the European Union. Let them make their decisions; they can make their decisions, and we can easily make ours, they need not worry; we will wait patiently until we hear this decision.

Dear friends, the humanitarian crises occurring in our region and various parts of the world confront us with responsibilities towards all humanity along with ourselves. Unfortunately, Western countries are far from demonstrating the sensitivity they show regarding the safety and welfare of their citizens for the rest of the world. Yet, we are living in an era where we talk about globalization and the world turning into a village. We have seen and experienced many examples of events occurring outside our borders inevitably knocking on our door one day.

Currently, the United States ranks first in providing aid to oppressed and victimized people in the world, followed by us in second place and the United Kingdom in third. However, when we look at it in terms of national income, Turkey ranks first. And right now, we need to fight together against threats that undermine humanity's peace, from terrorism and drug trafficking to all individuals and institutions that fight without rules, yet there is a world that leaves us alone and is trying to abandon us.

Dear friends;

If you allocate resources only for yourselves and load all the burdens onto others, this will cease to be a sustainable order. The current order of the world is not sustainable. I have expressed this at the United Nations General Assembly, I am doing so, and I will continue to do so. In a sense, the United Nations and similar international institutions, which we could call a global ombudsman, have unfortunately failed to protect the rights of the oppressed.

Well, we said, our request regarding the Rohingya Muslims was accepted, and we held a session on it at the United Nations. But do you know what is important? Only one president attended that session, from Iran. Two prime ministers came as prime ministers, from Pakistan and Bangladesh, and the Vice President of Indonesia came; the others were at the level of foreign ministers. Is this how you support Arakan? Tens of thousands of people are dying, 600,000 people are leaning miserably into Bangladesh from their lands, and as we watch on television while crossing those streams and rivers, no one is speaking up. All that is said is, "We condemned Myanmar." That is what is said. "We condemned it, and we did so in the strongest way." Well, what else did we do? Is there no sanction? These sanctions need to be presented in a very different way so that they can also put themselves in order.

There is a clear genocide here. I say openly, they may be uncomfortable; do those who speak of "Islamic terrorism" say "Christian terrorism," "Jewish terrorism," or "Buddhist terrorism"? They do not. They always portray Buddhists as goodwill ambassadors. No, we see it; look, there is currently a Buddhist terrorism in Myanmar. They will attack Erdoğan now; let them attack. You cannot brush this aside with yoga or whatever; there is a case at hand. There is a case at hand, and all of humanity needs to know this.

If we do not explain to those who do not know what we know, many thousands and hundreds of thousands will perish, and we cannot allow this. I have sent my wife, I have sent my Foreign Minister, I have sent my child, I have sent my Minister of Family and Social Policies, and we are currently continuing our aid and will continue to do so. Now, God willing, our Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister, along with our Minister of Environment and Urbanization, will go together as a team to examine where we can set up camps.

The slowness and financial burden of the bureaucratic mechanisms of the United Nations in humanitarian aid give the impression that the system was established for the functioning of these institutions rather than to assist the victims. Similarly, the fact that all the strings in the Security Council, which constitutes the operational power of the United Nations, are handed over to five countries effectively locks the system. Today, we cannot clearly see the presence of the United Nations in almost any of the crisis regions where people genuinely need help.

The operations that need to be carried out are constantly postponed because they touch the interests of one of these five countries. This situation emboldens oppressive regimes, increasing their pressure on the oppressed and spreading their painful practices. In Syria, where more than a million people have lost their lives in the last seven years, and the country has turned into an arena for power struggles between various states and terrorist organizations, the United Nations has not lifted a finger and is not lifting one. Have you seen the United Nations in Syria? Have you heard its voice? No. We are in it, we are living it.

More than 3 million Syrians fleeing war and oppression are in our country, while 5 million have sought refuge in other countries. It cannot be said that the United Nations has made serious efforts to facilitate the lives of these refugees. For example, do you know what has come from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees for the refugees in our country? 520 million dollars. Well, how much have we spent? 30 billion dollars. The European Union is not speaking the truth either; they promised, "We will send 3 billion euros by July 1, 2016." They said, "We will give another 3 billion euros by the end of the year." And do you know what has come from the European Union? That too is 820 million euros.

We see the same things regarding the tragedy and humanitarian drama experienced by the Arakan Muslims. Unfortunately, the world is still very foreign to that region. We have not even been able to fully learn the number of people who have lost their lives in the attacks and escape routes in Arakan. We are also deeply saddened by the reluctance to participate in international initiatives made under Turkey's pressure. The world cannot bear such oppression. The cry of the oppressed is such that it does not go unanswered; it shakes the throne.

For this reason, we have said, and we continue to say, that international institutions, which should find solutions to the common problems of humanity, need to be restructured on the basis of justice and fairness, and we will follow this demand to the end. I want to particularly emphasize that I expect support from you, the ombudspersons, for our call to restructure international aid and intervention organizations.

Let us make the world a better place for everyone, a more livable planet. Let us expand our mediation regarding the relationship between the administration and citizens to encompass the entire humanity within the global system. And let us say, "the world is bigger than five," and let us do this. Let us say, "the fate of the 196 countries in the world cannot be left to the lips of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council," and let us do this. Let us say, "what they say cannot be the only truth."

All countries should take their place here as permanent members in a rotating system; there should be no distinction between permanent and temporary members; they should all be permanent members. But let there be 20 permanent members, and let 10 of them change every two years, and with this change, let there be no country left that does not have a place in the United Nations Security Council. This is my simple proposal, and I have also addressed it in my speech at the United Nations General Assembly. I will continue to address it this year as well, and I will keep saying it. The world is no longer living under the conditions of the Second World War; those days are behind us. Now we must establish a new world, a new planet. Otherwise, let us not forget that we will all be left under the collapsing system.

Dear friends;

The crises and conflicts in our region are becoming even more inextricable with the new steps being taken in Northern Iraq and Syria. The regional government's decision for a referendum in Northern Iraq is an opportunistic initiative, especially considering the situation the country is in. It is absolutely unacceptable to take steps towards separation at a time when Iraq needs unity, solidarity, and integration more than ever, both as a society and as a country.

We respect the rights, laws, security, and demands for a prosperous life of our Kurdish brothers in Northern Iraq, just like everyone else. Indeed, we have always stood by the Northern Iraq Administration in their efforts. During their most difficult times, when no one was by their side, we provided them with the necessary services and support to keep them standing. However, we also have Arab brothers in Iraq, Turkmen brothers, Yazidis, Chaldeans, and Assyrians; we respect their rights as well. Northern Iraq is the common living space of all these peoples. It is not just the living space of one person or one tribe; this must be understood.

The attempt to bring this region under the control of a single group will only herald new conflicts, new sufferings, new oppressions, and new massacres that will last for many years. The distrust towards the current administration, which has not shown a good example in sharing the power and resources they control with other groups, will increase significantly after the so-called declaration of independence. No one can expect us to turn a blind eye to the emergence of a new crisis and conflict area just 350 kilometers away from our borders; our stance on this matter is clear. Nevertheless, we consider the referendum that has been conducted, which is also not in accordance with the current law in Iraq, null and void, and we say it is illegitimate.

From the very beginning, we have said that we will continue to work towards Iraq's territorial integrity and social unity. And I had a meeting with the President of Iran last night; we talked for a long time. We had extensive discussions with the delegation he sent a day earlier. And as a result of these long discussions, I say clearly and unequivocally; they are holding a referendum today. The federal structure of Iraq does not accept the referendum they have conducted. The Constitutional Court has already made its necessary decision; it is pointless, meaning "the rope ties the yellow, the girl plays, the bride cries"; this is what they are doing.

Right now, I want to emphasize that we are taking and will take all steps politically, economically, commercially, and in terms of security. The Armed Forces have not taken the necessary steps in Silopi for nothing. There is no concession. Right now, Iran is in the same situation. At the same time, our Air Force is currently in the same situation. And at the border, only passage to the Iraqi side is allowed. We will announce other measures within this week, and those steps will also be taken. And from now on, these entries and exits will also be closed. We have different measures, separate ones, and we will activate them as well. And along with all this, let’s see where the Northern Iraq Local Administration will channel or sell its oil from now on. The valve is in our hands; the moment we close the valve, that job is over.

Dear brothers and sisters;

The state must think about all these matters from A to Z. We have always said that we do not make emotional decisions; we think ten times and take one step, and we have done this by operating international diplomacy. Look, apart from Israel, there is no other country supporting the decision taken by the Northern Iraq Local Administration; only Israel. I had a meeting with the Jewish Committee in America, and I told them as well. I said, "Tell Mr. Netanyahu that our relations with Turkey are not going well." How can they? Right now, no one else recognizes the Northern Iraq Local Administration except for him. We are in a very different position with the Northern Iraq Local Administration, while Netanyahu is in a different position. One country, only himself. Tell him to give it up. We have also told them to do what is necessary.

We will continue to take our steps decisively. And the Northern Iraq Local Administration must take a step back from this move; it is a must. The Federal State absolutely does not accept it, and the Parliament does not accept it either.

Of course, we will not allow the establishment of one or more terrorist states in Syria either. They say they will establish a state in Northern Syria with the PYD-YPG; all of this is just a dry dream for them, nothing more.

I reiterate that while these developments are merely strategic moves for others, they are a matter of survival for our state and nation. We have a 911-kilometer border with Syria. We will never allow such a formation here. As I said, we can come unexpectedly one night; we will come. We did this during the Euphrates Shield Operation. Now, we cannot allow such developments here either. Regarding Iraq and Syria, which hold significant importance above politics and diplomacy, we have all options and choices on the table that we will not hesitate to use when it comes to issues that pose a threat to our country.

Just as we cleared the 2,000 square kilometers extending to Cerablus, Rai, Dabık, and El-Bab from ISIS, we are now taking another step with the same purpose, and we will not hesitate to take such steps in Iraq if necessary. We are determined to continue our struggle until our region achieves peace, tranquility, stability, and prosperity.

Dear friends;

Changes are generally painful; but they are also inevitable. Turkey is a country that has experienced this reality through the events it has lived in the last 15 years. We are aware that the changes occurring in our region are of a kind that happens only once in a century. The tools used to corner our country in the last century have largely lost their validity today. It is clear that many of the events we encounter both domestically and internationally aim to guide us during this process.

Our nation, except for a small segment that insists on complacency, sees all that is happening and supports its state and government by tightly holding onto its unity, solidarity, and cooperation. You saw the vote in Parliament; a small group, but what happened with a large majority? Immediately, our Parliament gave the decision to allow the Armed Forces to go abroad for any operation. Our duty as administrators is to provide the best services to our nation in all areas in return for this sacrifice.

Turkey is a country capable of both fighting crises and implementing its projects. In this way, while we confront terrorist organizations and withstand the attacks we face on an international level, we are also resolutely moving forward in all areas, especially the economy, in line with our goals. In this context, we are also striving to elevate the relationship between our citizens and the administration to the highest level. Our Public Ombudsman Institution is a candidate to be our greatest helper in this regard with its increasing effectiveness every year.

With these feelings, I once again wish the Istanbul International Ombudsman Conference, the establishment of the Union of Ombudsmen of the Member States of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, and the Board Meeting of the Mediterranean Ombudsmen Union to be fruitful. I congratulate once again those who contributed to the organization of these beautiful events on behalf of myself and my nation. I extend my love and respect to you. Stay healthy.