Viktor Orbán at the Qatari Economic Forum

Hungary Viktor Orbán · Prime Minister of Hungary

23 May 2023 · Qatari Economic Forum

Context
Orbán addressed the Qatari Economic Forum on May 23, 2023, discussing Hungary's stance on the Ukraine war and signing an agreement with Qatar.
Main themes
Ukraine-Russia war, ceasefire and peace negotiations, Hungarian foreign policy, ethnic Hungarians in Ukraine, NATO limitations, European Union aid, diplomacy failure, Hungary-Qatar economic relations, sovereignty and occupation, escalation risks
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,108
87th percentile
Sentences
293
95th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
7.8
4th percentile
Syntax
2.61
8th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from Hungarian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 53%50%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

293 sentences in 86 paragraphs

Viktor Orbán, the Prime Minister of Hungary and the longest-serving leader in Europe – we just spoke about it – has been in office for 17 years. Thank you for speaking with us! You have just signed an agreement with Qatar, and we will return to that. But we could start with the other reason your country is currently in the news: Ukraine. The fundamental point regarding Ukraine is that it is a sovereign country that has been occupied by Russia – just as Hungary was occupied by the Soviet Union in 1956. Just last night, I watched a video about this – heroes like Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Reagan, and Pope John Paul II were the ones who supported Hungary at that time. Yesterday, your foreign minister said that they would block the aid that the European Union would provide to Ukraine. I am curious why a country like yours – which, you know, was once occupied by the Russians – would do such a thing?

First of all, thank you for the opportunity to talk. I would make a small remark: 17 years in government and 16 years in opposition. Both are equally important. Back to the question of war: you must know that Hungary has a very unique position regarding the war because Ukraine is not a distant country; Ukraine is our neighbor. Secondly, we have a 200,000-strong ethnic minority living in Ukraine. And they are also part of the war: they are conscripted into the Ukrainian army and therefore die. So we are losing Hungarian lives every day. Therefore, we do not belong to the European mainstream position. My position, that is, Hungary's position from the very first moment of the war, has been that this war is a failure of diplomacy. It should never have broken out. So if we look at what is happening on the front line, it is clear to us that a military solution does not work. So whoever is right – you correctly described the situation that Russia has occupied Ukraine – but the question is not who occupied whom, but what will happen tomorrow morning? The facts show that by tomorrow morning even more people will die, and there is no chance of victory on either side. So this is a war that deprives many people of their lives without any result.

We can certainly agree that diplomacy has not been successful. But there is a big difference between failure and the fact of occupation. What interests me is that for someone like you – since this was one of the main reasons you started to engage in politics, 1956 is important to you…

Yes, I am a freedom fighter.

…and the fight for freedom – you have a neighbor that has been occupied by Russia, the same country… you know, you grew up with the sight of tanks arriving in Budapest… Why do you oppose European aid?

No, no, emotionally this is very tragic. We stand with Ukraine wholeheartedly. We understand how much they are suffering. But here I speak as a politician whose job is to save lives. The most important task of the international political community is to save lives – especially if, like me, you are convinced that this war cannot be won. Therefore, we need to invest much more energy in convincing everyone: the only solution is a ceasefire. After the ceasefire, peace negotiations must begin. After that, we can return to the question you raised, do you understand?

Do you really think that Ukraine has no chance of winning?

This is my…

Obviously, they have very little chance of victory without the support that you are currently blocking…

No, no, my position is that if we look at reality, if we look at the numbers, if we look at the circumstances, if we see that NATO is unwilling to send troops, then it is clear that there is no victory for the poor Ukrainians on the battlefield. This is my position. I have always suggested to everyone that instead of getting more deeply involved in the war, we should stop the escalation and argue for peace and negotiations.

Essentially, you…

Do not forget the facts: there are 140 million people living in Russia, in Ukraine… 30?

It is interesting that you say that. As far as I know, your foreign minister did not refer to Ukraine being unable to win, but rather that this is a matter of how a bank is rated… that the Ukrainians are treating them poorly – which seems really insignificant compared to the larger issue.

No, it is not. This is a matter of principle. The foreign minister was therefore right. If a country, such as Ukraine, wants to receive financial support from you, which is essential for them, then they cannot blacklist your companies. These two things cannot be done simultaneously. So if they need our money, they should respect us and not sanction our companies. It is that simple.

You spoke about NATO. I would be curious to know how you see… Let’s imagine there is a ceasefire. Let’s imagine peace is established with Russia. Perhaps you have heard Henry Kissinger, who was previously quite skeptical about Ukraine being part of NATO, now sees that Ukraine has ceased to be a buffer state – something that lies between the West and the East – and therefore believes that as part of the peace settlement, Ukraine should join NATO. What is your position on this?

This is an interesting speculation. It is good for intellectuals, by the way. But I am a decision-maker. As an actor, we need to focus on what should be done. My opinion is that first and foremost, we need a ceasefire. Once the ceasefire is established, we should start negotiating a new security system for the European continent. In my view, only a peace negotiation and peace agreement between Russia and the United States can close this entire conflict. What is at stake? Ukraine is certainly very important, but in the long term – from a strategic point of view – the future security of Europe is at stake. It is clear that without the United States, there is no European security system, and the war can only be stopped now if the Russians can reach an agreement with the United States. As a European, I am not happy about this at all, but this is the only way out.

One more thing regarding NATO. You have also opposed – or it seems you are less fond of – Sweden becoming a NATO member. I know you might say that this is a matter for the parliamentarians, but you, as we have established, are a very successful politician. Why do you oppose Sweden joining NATO?

Because the political relationship between Sweden and Hungary is terribly bad, and it needs to be improved first. We do not want to bring conflicts into NATO. So first, let’s address the disagreements between the two countries, and then we are ready to support them. On principle, we support it anyway. And we like the Swedish people… but the political relationship between the countries is currently quite unpleasant.

Can we talk about the European Union? The EU is currently rejecting or delaying, I believe, the transfer of 30 billion dollars in aid and loans to Hungary. You have protested against this, but I would be curious if you have set a deadline for when the EU should give what you consider to be your own money?

No, no, but you need to understand the nature of the disagreement: it is not about the money.

Okay.

The money is important, but you know, Europe is strong, Hungary is strong, so we can manage our economy even based on our own resources. But we need to understand that there are two fundamental strategic questions where we disagree with the mainstream position of the European Union. The first is the debate about “decoupling” or separation on one side, and connectivity on the other side. And more and more European countries are on the side of decoupling or separation, while Hungary is firmly in favor of connection and connectivity. The other strategic difference is related to the war, as there is a war psychosis in Europe. The mainstream and the majority think they can win the war and that there is a military solution. Hungary does not agree with this. So these are the two main strategic differences. And the inclusion of financial, funding issues is merely a consequence of the two strategically different approaches.

I just realized, these are very big differences. If you look back at your other difficulties with the European Union, for someone coming from Great Britain, it might feel like the road to Brexit. Many of your role models – Roger Scruton, whom we spoke about earlier – supported Brexit. You also seem to be pro-Brexit.

No, no, no…

Why does Hungary remain in the European Union?

The answer is very simple: 85 percent of our exports go to the European Union. We are not strong and powerful like the British in terms of security and economic assistance…

It may be a bad decision…

It may be, but that is not on the agenda anyway. You know, we have a fundamental difficulty in the European Union, which is the question of leadership. The question of leadership in the European Union is approached from an intellectual direction. They think that leadership means that we are led by the institutions, and the politicians' job is to make the institutions work well. Which is a nice idea when everything is going well. But when there are difficulties, it does not work; the institutions are not effective: we need leaders, human beings who make decisions, take responsibility, and so on, and so forth. So we are now living in a difficult time, and the European Union does not have such leadership.

But British leaders have complained for years about the Brussels leadership, “the octopus,” as they called it. Surely you share this view?

Yes, the bubble is terrible, especially in Brussels. The entire European Union is over-bureaucratized and too centralized, that is undeniable.

You mentioned decoupling, and I see that you have made several agreements with China, and I will try to generalize this for the audience. You have tried to adopt the same attitude towards China as you have towards Russia, namely that instead of belonging to the Western side, you want to be one of the leaders of the others. You want to be among those who try to connect China with the West. Is this reasonable?

No, we are not that ambitious. The reason is that a good relationship is a good thing. We are a country of 10 million, exports account for 80-85 percent of GDP, so we are a very open country; we need trade and political relations. So we believe in connectivity. And China is a huge opportunity; why not take advantage of it?

As many claim, China could be a rival to the West in the long run.

Or a partner.

Or a partner.

We decide that.

It may be, for example, an area where you would not agree with Donald Trump.

It may be. Let’s wait for him to return and discuss it.

In the end, we return to American politics. I am curious if the applause is for Donald Trump's return or non-return…

Understandable.

To return to why you are here, yesterday you signed an energy agreement related to gas purchases with Qatar, and you said it is better to stand on multiple legs than just one. This, I suspect, was a reference to Hungary's dependence on Russian gas. Could you say something about what the outcome of the agreement will be? How much gas will you buy from Qatar?

First of all, the negotiations are still ongoing. Secondly, Hungary is a landlocked country, which means we cannot neglect the energy coming from Russia through pipelines. Half of Hungary's energy needs come from Russia, based on long-term contracts; we need to find partners for the other half. We are looking for partners all over the world, and Qatar is one of our potential partners. But everyone is queuing at the Qatari's door, so it is not easy to get here and sign an agreement. Even if we succeed, it cannot start before 2026 because the Qataris are booked until then. So we hope for cooperation. Qatar is a country we respect very much; without it, Europe would have been in big trouble last year. We are trying to establish a broader strategic cooperation with them, not only in energy but also in agriculture, IT, and security issues.

Do you think you will acquire… In Budapest, it is said that some believe you will convince the Qataris to help buy back the Budapest airport, which you have already planned to purchase.

Hungary's main value from your perspective is probably its geographical location because we are in the middle of Europe, in the center of Central Europe, and every road passes through Hungary in the north-south and east-west directions. The airport is strategically significant for us. Qatar is interested in it. There is no decision yet. We are still negotiating. We would welcome them. They are still present in Hungary as investors.

So you would like to receive Qatari money to help buy back as investors.

Yes, yes. But we are also ready to participate, so we need strategic investments in Budapest regarding the airport. Not just for the buyback, but for a large-scale plan to develop it into one of the competitive airports in the European market.

Critics would say that you may be moving more slowly to end your energy relationship with Russia than others. You have made agreements with Gazprom, and similar things. Just one example: the Russian state nuclear energy company, Rosatom, is still building your nuclear power plant. No matter how you look at it, it is not going very well – partly due to sanctions and delays. Surely this is a place where you could simply drop the Russian company and move on.

In this regard, we are not in a hurry. Hungary has had a nuclear power plant based on Russian technology for 60 years, which works very well, and the Russians have always been reliable partners. And we would like to expand this nuclear power plant. And expanding it based on something else, another technology, is very risky. So if we want to expand on the same site, we need to use Russian technology. So we continue to do this, and I hope we can continue. Building a nuclear power plant is a complicated process. There are certain delays, but I am optimistic that we can finish according to the plans.

You may not agree with them, but at least you can understand that other European countries, when they look at you, see: you still cling to the Russians regarding your nuclear power plant, you still do business with Gazprom, you are still the one who talks about Ukraine not winning, and you stand for peace. Do you understand why they think you are too much on Vladimir Putin's side?

For obvious reasons. But now in Europe, if someone stands up for national interests, they can easily be accused of being pro-Russian. But the fact is that my compass always points towards Hungarian national interests. I do not deal with other leaders; I deal with my own country. I stand up for Hungary, you know? So whatever accusations I may receive or will receive, I will continue to receive them. And you are right that Hungary is a country that thinks if we do something ten times – for example, we introduce sanction packages – and it does not work, then it is not reasonable to do it eleven times – you know, we do it again, hoping that the result will be different. This goes against common sense. So the European Union's sanctions policy, in our view, simply does not work.

But isn't that the essence? When you talk about it being only about national interests, isn't that the whole point of being part of a contractual alliance? The essence of an alliance like the European Union is that yes, we take our national interests into account, but ultimately we support our neighbors, we support the broader, greater goal: in one case, the containment of Russia, in another case, the promotion of the European Union.

No, no, these are two separate issues. The first is, of course, that we need to agree with the Russians on the future of European security. That is one thing. The other question is, what is the future of the European Union? And in this regard, there are two schools in Brussels. The first is the United States of Europe, or as the Brussels language puts it: "an ever closer union." We do not like that. We do not want to belong to an empire. We want to preserve our national sovereignty. So the other concept – the second school – is the maintenance of national sovereignty and the vision of Europe as a union of sovereign states, as a system of cooperation. I belong to the second school – we belong to the second school. This is now a significant difference, and this causes the debate within the European Union. But the only way to move forward is to discuss it.

In terms of friends, obviously, the Qataris are here. In the Arab world, in general, in some respects, many are asking, many are wondering why you are here. You are someone who – to put it politely – has had quite a strong opinion about Muslims in Hungary. You have talked about Hungary being a Christian country. You do not want the Islamic civilization to "occupy" Europe. So why are you here now? Why do you want money from them?

No, no, it is not about money. We are here for much more political reasons than economic ones. But I think the main dilemma of the future is not whether it is Muslim or Christian. The main dilemma of the future – as with migration, gender propaganda, state sovereignty – is normality or abnormality, as we say. Christians and Muslims can cooperate in the defense and preservation of traditional values: God, homeland, family. This is the most important thing, not "Christian or Muslim." This is why we can cooperate with Muslim countries on a principled basis. Erdoğan – whom I like very much – is a good friend of Hungary, a good friend of the Hungarian government, despite the fact that our government has a clear Christian identity. So religion does not pose a difficulty in cooperation.

So your position is that you are happy to meet with Muslims here; you just do not want them to come to Hungary?

No, no, it is about migration. Migration is a different issue. The question is, who decides who can enter your country, who can stay there, and with whom you have to live. Who is the authority that decides this – the nation-state or someone else? Hungary insists on deciding who can come into our country and who can live here; this is our exclusive decision, it cannot be Brussels' or anyone else's decision. So this is a question of migration, not a cultural question. This is another dimension that has no place in Hungary because Hungary has a clear, non-threatened Christian identity. We are strong in our identity.

I was wondering, regarding what we talked about earlier… Donald Trump's name came up. You generally seem friendlier with him, if I may put it that way, than with other European leaders. Do you think he will win the next elections?

I hope so.

However, DeSantis, with whom you were somewhat close… Well, it seemed there was some kind of friendly approach.

Yes. He is also a very good leader, but I belong to the club of veterans, and veterans support each other.

A veteran who is very much in the spotlight: no one would certainly call Joe Biden young. What is wrong with Joe Biden?

Well, it is not my job to criticize the leader of the United States – that is not a good business idea anyway.

But would you be happier if the United States had a different leader?

I would rather say that American Democrats are much more driven by ideology than Republicans. And Democrats always like to convince – and sometimes force – others about how to live. And I do not like that. We have our own culture. Culture defines how we live. Do not interfere, please. Do not educate us. Do not tell us what is good, what is bad, what is freedom. We do not like that. It is not their business. It is not the business of Americans or other nations; it is the business of Hungarians. It is that simple.

But there is…

Donald Trump understands this. That is important.

But there is a big, very big difference that Donald Trump sees issues like China in black and white. He is the one who started this – he is not the first, but he is certainly the one who accelerated – America's decoupling from China. It is hard to imagine that he would not continue to push this. Isn't this the main area where you automatically come into conflict with those right-wing people whom you otherwise support?

I would not call it a conflict, but we must calmly state that the interests of the United States and the European Union, the European countries regarding China are decidedly different. So that is the starting point. Therefore, to align our policies or cooperate on this issue, negotiations between the United States and the European Union are needed. And even if the President of the United States is Trump, we need to seriously discuss this. This is a complicated, difficult topic, but I believe that Europe must represent its own interests regarding China.

And do you see any signs that European leadership is changing towards people who would be more sympathetic to your position? Currently, you have somewhat few direct allies in Europe, if I may put it that way, within the European Union.

Time can help. There are not many now, but time can help.

Speaking of time, you have been the leader of your country for a very long time. Is there a set date when you might plan to move on?

That will be decided by my wife.

So it is a democratic vote.

A democratic vote at home. Basically, that is why we are here, because I was first elected Prime Minister in '98. So I started cooperating with the Qatari government in '99 anyway, when the Qatari Foreign Minister first visited Hungary. So our relationship with Qatar – the economy is important, but it is not solely economic. Money is important, but investments are also important. But our cooperation is more political than economic in nature. To go back, personal relationships matter, personal loyalty matters, leadership relationships matter.

In the video I saw of you, you said you would meet with Margaret Thatcher at that time. I am curious – and I ask you this question again – the Orbán Viktor who first emerged, for whom the Russian occupation was a turning point – obviously, I only know this from hearsay – did you stand up for what you thought, or were people let down by Hungary at that time?

No, I was the first Central European leader to publicly call for the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Central European countries. That is true.

But the Orbán Viktor who emerged, whom many on the right, many across Europe saw as a natural partner, someone who could be part of the larger, broader picture you embarked on. The new Orbán Viktor is a completely different creature.

No, no, we are talking about the Ukrainian war again.

Yes.

Let us save Ukraine as much as we can, and the only good thing we can do for the Ukrainian people is to achieve a ceasefire and peace, and save lives. This is Orbán Viktor's position.

Has your overall political philosophy changed?

No, it is not about philosophy; it is about the war and the fact that we are losing human lives every day. This must be stopped!

Mr. Orbán, thank you very much for talking to us.

Thank you very much!

Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, thank you!

Thank you!