Speech by Viktor Orbán at the Hungarian Entrepreneur Day (VOSZ)

Hungary Viktor Orbán · Prime Minister of Hungary

1 December 2023 · Hungarian Entrepreneur Day (VOSZ)

Context
Orbán addressed Hungarian entrepreneurs at the VOSZ Hungarian Entrepreneur Day on 1 December 2023, discussing cooperation between government and the business sector.
Main themes
Government-entrepreneur collaboration, public interest vs. private interest, role of entrepreneurs in national economy, job creation, tax contribution, capital strength and economic resilience, Hungarian economic policy, COVID and war crisis management, market economy vs. communism, national ownership of business
Duration
~39 min
89th percentile
Words
4,632
89th percentile
Sentences
176
86th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 67%65%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

176 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Good day, ladies and gentlemen! Dear presidents! Dear Lidike! Dear entrepreneurs!

Thank you very much for the invitation. For me as a politician, it is always exciting to meet with entrepreneurs together with some of my ministerial colleagues, as I agree with my two predecessors who pointed out the necessity of collaboration between government and entrepreneurs. I would like to say a few words about the fact that it is not so simple, as they are two different worlds, and a certain intellectual conviction and a certain fundamental attitude must develop, certainly on the part of politicians, and I do not speak for the entrepreneurs, as I cannot speak for them, but on the part of politicians, an intellectual fundamental attitude must develop if one wants to establish cooperation with the economy. After all, entrepreneurs are motivated by profit, and to make a profit, they must do business, and thus profit is generated, so they expect private benefits from these businesses. And that is a good thing; it is called the market and private property. In contrast, the politician approaches the world of the economy from a different perspective. Our motivation is to get the economy running for the benefit of the entire community, the country, the nation. Therefore, we do not deal with business issues, but with economic and macroeconomic issues, and this is true even when it concerns the same topic. For example, it is clear that the withdrawal of the airport is a business question for entrepreneurs and a macroeconomic question for the government. It is our task, ladies and gentlemen, and the task of the government, to ensure that your private interests as entrepreneurs are pursued in such a way that the public good is ultimately achieved, and that private benefits are combined in such a way that public benefits are achieved. The question is whether this is possible. It is a question that has occupied people for centuries, whether it is possible, or whether it is the case that private benefit and public benefit, private interest and public interest are necessarily opposed to each other. According to communist economic theory, they are necessarily opposed, and this is the source of a good little class struggle, under the banner of which state economy and communism can then be introduced. According to bourgeois economics, however, they are not opposed to each other, but rather presuppose each other. Bourgeois economics states that public benefit can only arise from private benefit and public interest can only arise from private interest. This then leads to cooperation and thus class peace instead of class struggle, to put it in the language of the other side.

Now, my dear ladies and gentlemen, your private interests and your business interests, your private benefits, contribute to the public interest in four ways. The first is that you provide people with jobs. There is no greater public interest than that everyone who has the skills finds a job. If you are not entrepreneurial, people will not have jobs. Therefore, the most important contribution you can make to the common good of the country through your own private efforts is to provide people with jobs. The second contribution for which I must thank you is that you pay taxes. That is a nice and good habit. The Minister of Finance has expressly asked me to remind you at the end of the year to maintain this nice habit, as there are common expenses, and you can easily see that you are better off, you are better off, when you pay taxes and a proper police force, for example, ensures public order, than if you had to maintain your own private army to ensure your own private security. The third way in which you contribute to the public interest of the country through your own profits is your capital. Because you have capital, a lot of money, a lot of wealth, a mass of assets, you can use this to stabilize the Hungarian economy. Capital strength is an important thing, and an economy is better able to withstand the strong winds of crisis when it has capital strength, when it has capital weighting, than when it does not. The difference between what I consider to be the success of the COVID and the current war crisis management and the failure of the financial crisis management of 2008-2009 is not only that the government at that time was different from the current one – I will refrain from qualifying that now – but also that in 2008-2009 a less capital-rich economy had to bear the brunt of the crisis. The economy that faced COVID, that is struggling with war, sanctions, and inflation, this economy, the economy of 2023, is not even comparable in terms of capital strength to the economy that tried to overcome the difficulties of 2008-2009. And finally, there is a fourth way in which you contribute to the Hungarian common good: If you did not run businesses, someone else would. This would largely be foreigners, and then most of the profits from the value creation generated here would leave the country. The reason it does not go abroad is that you are the entrepreneurs, and you are Hungarian people, Hungarian entrepreneurs, and you keep these profits here. We should not fall for the nice-sounding fairy tale that money does not stink – but the owner certainly does. And it is also true that money has no nationality, but the owner does. Therefore, it is not at all indifferent to whom the money, the capital, the capital assets belong. I learned in 2008-2009 that although supposedly money neither stinks nor has a homeland, as soon as the banks in Europe began to dry up, foreign banks immediately began to withdraw their funds from Hungary to finance their businesses at home, and we were left with nothing. This led us to the conclusion that 50% of the Hungarian banking system must always be in national hands, because we will not be able to prevent crises like this, just as we could not prevent them in 2008-2009. All in all, ladies and gentlemen, I say this not out of politeness, not out of hypocrisy, but I sincerely wish every Hungarian entrepreneur every personal success! Your private successes are a prerequisite for the public successes of the country. Therefore, the government and its members are not envious of your capital and what it brings with it – it brings not only good but also a lot of problems – but quite the opposite: the members of the Hungarian government and the Hungarian government wish you all even more success, even greater business profits, and ever-increasing capital. I hope you have such years ahead of you. If you are successful, all of this will lead to the rise of the country, that is, to an increase in the public good. It is our responsibility, in the responsibility and work of the politically responsible, to shape this so that your private successes become the success of the whole country. And we have a government that believes that a rising tide lifts all boats.

My dear ladies and gentlemen!

If we were at a meeting of another party, I would say whether I had anything more to say, Ildikó, but since we are not there, but here, and here sitting with members of a generation that still understands what that means, I would not risk it in the company of young people, but of course I have a few things to say beyond that, mainly because of Sándor Demján. As I prepared to come here, I looked at the calendar, and it is a year ago, except for two days, that we celebrated the twentieth anniversary of the Széchenyi Card together. And at that time, we also mentioned the heroic figure of the great heroic era, Sándor Demján, with whom we invented the Széchenyi Card twenty-one years ago and who initiated the celebration of Entrepreneur's Day twenty-four years ago. How time flies, he has not been with us for five years! Everyone has a personal story about Sándor Demján. This also shows that he was a serious man, as President Parragh said. I learned two things from him, because everyone learned something from him or copied something from him. I will spare you the personal stories now, especially since they are rather rural in pace, as we come from the same region, he from Etyek and I was born in Alcsútdoboz. So I will not bore you with personal stories, but I will tell you that I learned and copied two things from him, as probably many others learned this and that from him. First, I learned that there is no Hungarian success without national self-respect. The story of President László Parragh was exactly about that. And this leads to something, because Sándor Demján was – as is well known – a man with leftist, social democratic sentiments in his political philosophy, and through him, I learned that there is such a thing as leftist patriotism. And that if there is leftist patriotism, the right, which defines itself as patriotic, can work together with leftist patriots in the interest of the nation – provided that there is agreement on important issues, as was often the case with Sándor Demján. The other thing I learned from him, and this is also the story that President Parragh told earlier, is that it is only worth undertaking the impossible. This is not a silly statement, so impossible does not mean what is physically impossible, but it means undertaking what others consider impossible. That is the real enterprise. Those are the two things we learned from Sándor Demján, and if you look at how the current government operates, it regularly does impossible things, things that seem impossible. Just to remind you: in 2010, when we had to plan the response to the crisis and I spoke with the president, we agreed that we had to simultaneously grow the Hungarian economy, increase employment, reduce public debt, and lower the tax burden – and all liberal economic textbooks state that all these things are possible individually, but not together. Sándor Demján always advocated for the government and said: “Yes, we may not be able to cite many examples from economic history, but here and now in Hungary, it is possible, if done correctly, to do this together and simultaneously.” We tried it, and we succeeded! I want to remind everyone that the gross domestic product has tripled nominally since 2010: we started from 27.5 trillion forints, and this year it will reach 77-78 trillion forints. At the same time, we have increased employment, one million more people are working than before, 4.8 million: this means, in employment terms, a jump from 57 percent to 75 percent. The tax system has already been discussed before me. The tax burden has decreased from 54 percent in 2000 to 41 percent in 2022, and we need to continue to lower it to remain competitive. Thanks to Mihály Varga, we have already managed to reduce public debt to 65% in 2019. Then we turned around because of COVID and the war, but now we are back on the right track, and the trend shows that we are on a declining path and by the end of the year we will reach a level of about 70 percent and perhaps even go slightly below that. In terms of public debt, we have never been at such a low level as today. In 2010, at the time of the discussion cited here, 4 percent of public debt was held by the population, let’s say in the form of government bonds, but now the population holds 22 percent, not 4 percent. Sándor Demján always said that it is best when the state owes money to its own citizens; if it owes money to someone, it should give it to Hungarians. That is why it is good for Hungarians to be able to buy government bonds. With this 22 percent, by the way, we are the leaders in Europe. And now I am not even talking about investments, foreign operating capital, or economic resources from outside Europe. The much-criticized policy of opening to the East today, which Péter Szijjártó has tied to the self-confidence of his youth, is actually the idea of Sándor Demján, who personally persuaded me in 2009 – I will still bring in a story here, we were still in opposition at that time – that we should get on a plane and fly to China, and that we should build political relations with the Chinese leadership from the opposition, which we could later turn into something productive from a government position, and that this would become a business, an economy, and an investment. And when I said that the opposition party was poor, he said he would pay for the flight, and he took us to China. The financing of the entire opening to the East is essentially tied to him up to the value of a flight.

Ladies and gentlemen!

What I want to tell you is that there were three traps we had to avoid and must continue to avoid in the coming period. The first is the debt trap, the second is the energy price trap, and the third is the consumption trap. We have avoided the energy price trap for the population because we defended the reduction of utility costs. For entrepreneurs, it is a burden. We are not used to talking so openly about it, but perhaps this is possible in this circle, that the higher energy price that entrepreneurs pay partially subsidizes the lower price that citizens pay. That is not good, but the right way is not to raise costs for the population, but to find a way to lower costs for businesses. At the government meeting yesterday or the day before, we decided on a price reduction of 10 euros; you will soon see the measures, and we want to bring about further energy price reductions for entrepreneurs next year so that they can remain competitive. We cannot avoid the debt trap on our own, even if we try here and there to lower interest rates with methods that touch on the powers of the central bank, rather only touch from the outside, but that cannot change the fact that the setting of interest rates in Hungary ultimately lies in the hands of monetary policy and its owner, the central bank and the central bank president. In the classic debate that takes place in every modern market economy about whether the economy should have higher or lower interest rates in the interest of security to enable investments and the necessary lending, the state is of course generally always on the side of entrepreneurs and the economy, because it is interested in growth and lending, and that means lower interest rates.

Ladies and gentlemen!

And if we cannot achieve results because the central bank keeps interest rates high, we try to help entrepreneurs with all possible credit programs. You can surely remember the programs for reindustrialization, for saving factories, and for export promotion, in which Hungarian entrepreneurs could participate.

Ladies and gentlemen!

Perhaps I should also say a little about consumption, that I agree with President Parragh, who said that consumption will return to its old level more slowly than the government or the leading members of the government expect. This is not a debate that needs to be decided, because life will decide, but I also think that Hungarians are reasonable people, and when we see that they are not consuming, it means that they are saving. And since money is present in the economy, even in this year, which was more difficult in terms of real incomes than previous years, new income is still being generated that people are not consuming but saving, and this is clearly evident from the accounts. Behind this lies a healthy instinct for life. It is not the state's job to divert people from the path of normal thinking with artificial means, but if such difficulties can arise in an economy, as they did, caution is warranted. However, it is also not good if people's caution is motivated by unfounded fears that need to be dispelled so that people can realistically assess the risk of increased consumption. I think that today there are more unfounded fears about the future of the economy than reality justifies. Therefore, the government must send a cautious but clear message to the Hungarian public that 2024 will be a year of hope. In 2023, we all worked, all 10 million Hungarians worked to protect what we have, and in 2024 we will work to live better than in 2023 or before. We must convey this message to the Hungarian voters, to the consumers.

Ladies and gentlemen!

I have something important to tell you that I hope you will appreciate. There are also fetishes in the economy, these totem poles and myths, and it is worth checking from time to time whether they are still valid. One of these myths in the European economy is, in my opinion, that a member state of the European Union cannot do without EU money. I humbly report that this myth has been debunked. Because the fact that we have avoided the year 2023 in such a way that we are visibly returning to the growth path of 2024 and that Hungary has not received a single cent of EU funds in the meantime shows that it is possible to organize economic life in such a way that we can build economic growth solely from our own resources or from market-mobilized resources, with or without the usual financial transfers in Europe. This does not mean that we will not collect the few billion they owe us in euros; of course, we will do that, but it is important that the Hungarian economy has the confidence that we are now in a period, 2022-2023, in which the Hungarian economy has proven that it can achieve results without financial transfers, without politically based financial and development transfers. This is a serious achievement, which of course does not prevent us from the fact that we must receive the funds that are due to us.

And finally, ladies and gentlemen, there is another peculiarity of this crisis that we are now slowly overcoming, which entrepreneurs with a long-term perspective should consider. Because the essence of this crisis is not cyclical. It is not about the fact that in a capitalist economy or in a market economy it is natural that all sorts of cycles alternate, which bring with them booms and busts, and since we believe in the self-healing or at least self-correcting ability of the market economy, the economy always reacts to these cycles according to its own logic. That is correct, I think, but this crisis is not of that kind; rather, it is related to a major realignment of world politics and the world economy. And I think you should also consider this dimension. It is about the fact that what we have been used to, our “business as usual,” will not function in the future as it did before the crisis, even if the economic cycles change. Therefore, we must understand the demands that the restructuring of the world economy places on you and on the world of politics.

As the economic power dynamics in the world shift, this means that new technologies are also emerging, and in the new technology industries, the traditional civilizational advantage of the West has disappeared. You are open-minded people, you have also been to the places where I have been, and you see that there is simply a shift in the world economy towards the new industries. Even here in Hungary – we do not even need to travel far – we can see that Eastern technology is challenging Western technology. In Hungary, for example, not only Hungarians, not only Westerners, but also the Chinese are building buses. Electric buses. And they will, we hope, also produce cars. And we see the technological competition that is taking place in these sectors. This means that the technological transformation will bring about a new era of information technology, a challenge for automation, a challenge for digital transformation, a challenge for infocommunication, a new energy era, where we get our energy from and how we can store it will be fundamentally different in the future than it has been so far. All of this shows that the world economy is becoming more balanced in these new industries, with East and West competing with roughly equal strength, and when you add the fact that the West often produces in these technology sectors in the East, you can see that the competition is indeed fierce. And that a part of the resources of the world economy, which always flows from one channel from somewhere to somewhere else, has been diverted from the West, and therefore a large part of the profits generated in the world economy is flowing to the East. This means that in this great change, of which I have only highlighted some aspects – the political and technological aspects – we must find Hungary's place in this situation. So it is not about cycles, and then the economic downturn passes, and then the economic upturn returns, and we can continue our work and make profits in the same industries as before the crisis. Other branches are gaining importance, other branches are generating higher profits, other branches are where the competition is coming from. In order to be among the winners in this change, we must – with your help, as you will do the actual work – establish connections, your companies must connect with the new technology, and your network must be complemented by the existing Western and Eastern networks.

Then it is of course also our task, the task of politicians, to adapt Hungary's foreign policy and foreign economic relations to this new situation. This is not a simple situation, as there is also a tendency in Europe that says the rise of the East can still be halted, and that we can stop its development if we do not trade with it and do not cooperate with it. One can find arguments for this position, but I think there are more arguments for the other position, which says that it is too late for that. Perhaps we could have done something like that ten, twenty, or thirty years ago if we had not allowed the Eastern upstarts into the, let’s say, modern world economic system. But we not only let them in, we invited them, we taught them how to navigate it well, and now they are insisting on doing so in a good way. So I do not believe that we can still stop them here by breaking off relations with them, but if we do not cooperate with them, we will miss the economic opportunity that their economic rise means for the entire world economy. That is why we believe that it is not about isolation, not about decoupling, not about derisking, not about blockade – to use these Brussels buzzwords – but about connectivity, about networking, about building connections, about trade and mutual support of investments. That is the path that Hungarian foreign policy is taking. But it does so because we believe that this is the best for the Hungarian economy. So it is not in the self-interest of politics to open up to the East and maintain balanced relations, but it is in the interest of the Hungarian economy and the entrepreneurs who operate it that Hungary pursues a foreign policy that focuses on cooperation, networking, and connectivity.

But it is also true that we can only pave this way, but not walk it, because the Hungarian economy is not a state economy, but a private economy. In order to take advantage of the opportunities that arise here, you must walk this path and succeed in doing so. There has been and is also a great debate in the government about how to identify the major industries that will be the most profitable industries of the future. One of them we have already covered quite well, and perhaps most of the work is already done, and that is the question of the green economy and its offshoot in the energy sector: green energy production, green energy storage in cars, homes, and factories. We are launching one tender after another worth billions of euros for you, for companies, and for families to create their own energy storage capacities at the household level and at the level of industrial sites.

After green energy – which of course also includes nuclear energy – the second area we need to address and prioritize is logistics. So I would like to draw your attention to the fact that the great opportunities of the Hungarian economy will open up in the next decade alongside and after green energy in logistics. Participating here, investing here, gaining market shares here seems to us to be sensible in the next ten years. And then we will also define other industries in the near future because we want to direct resources, regulations, favorable regulations into these sectors.

This does not mean that we are giving up the others; we just believe that these industries will be the most important for the national economy in the next ten years and will offer growth opportunities. We believe that this will be the information and defense industry. You can see what investments we are making in the defense industry. We believe that we have the necessary skills and talents, so we must emphasize support for the food industry. In the automotive sector, where the logic of electromobility is changing, we are on the right track. And the pharmaceutical industry also seems to be an area where we can make significant profits, where we can achieve large gains.

Ladies and gentlemen!

I just wanted to tell you that the people who spoke before me and said that it is worth working with the government are right. Also because you may learn more about the future if you work with us, if you can perhaps influence the regulations, which you have done well in recent years, and we look forward to initiatives and proposals from you. Many good decisions have been made, not because a minister had the idea, but because we received proposals from the chamber or from VOSZ. So I ask you to continue to provide us with these proposals and bombard us with them. And thirdly, it is also worth working with the government because since we will not have the money to develop everything in the same way, there will be priority development directions. And the budgetary resources, the state-managed funding sources – the development bank, the Eximbank – will also work primarily in these directions. And this is of course related to having this knowledge and wanting to be active in these areas, an option that should be considered. So I would like to encourage VOSZ, and I would also like to thank the VOSZ board for continuing the cooperation that has gone so well in the past.

Ladies and gentlemen!

I wish Hungarian entrepreneurs fat profits, high revenues, many employees, and successful sailing in new, uncharted waters. Through your personal success and with the help of the government, we can transform what you can achieve as private winners in the world economy into a public good.

Happy birthday! A beautiful Advent season and Merry Christmas to you all!