Viktor Orbán's speech on the parliamentary debate day

Hungary Viktor Orbán · Prime Minister of Hungary

13 December 2023 · Parliamentary debate on Ukraine's accession to the European Union · Hungarian Parliament, Hungary

Context
Orbán addressed the Hungarian Parliament during a plenary debate on Ukraine's EU accession candidacy, ahead of the December 2023 European Council summit in Brussels.
Main themes
Ukraine's EU accession, European Union enlargement process, Hungarian parliamentary debate, EU institutional rules and standards, Hungary's national interests, accession conditions and criteria, fast-track membership concerns, comparison with other candidate countries, EU institutional credibility, national parliament role
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,396
66th percentile
Sentences
105
65th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Hungarian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 43%41%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

105 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Thank you very much, Mr. President!

Considering that we will be discussing this issue in the European Council today, tomorrow, and the day after tomorrow, it is appropriate for the government to speak here in the plenary session after yesterday's meeting of the European integration committee and the grand committee meeting.

First of all, I would like to state on behalf of the government that we welcome and consider it important that a substantive debate can take place in the Hungarian Parliament regarding Ukraine's accession to the European Union. We believe that this is not a trivial matter. This debate, which will continue in Brussels either in parallel with or following this discussion, will influence not only Hungary but the future of the entire European Union. In this context, I see that although this is a question of European destiny, instead of a real debate, we are rather heading towards a wall in the European Union. This underscores the significance of the debate taking place here.

I would like to inform the Honorable House, I would like to remind the Honorable House that Ukraine submitted its application to join the European Union on February 28, 2022, and in June 2022, just four months later, it was granted candidate status. Candidate status is not a title that can be granted; it has conditions, fixed conditions. Despite not meeting these conditions, an exception was made, and four months later, Ukraine was granted candidate status.

As the faction leader has done, it is worth examining how much time elapses in the case of other countries when they choose a similar path. I can say that since the first enlargement in 1973, it has generally taken more than three years between the submission of the application and the granting of candidate status.

In the case of the Central and Eastern European enlargement, it took an average of four years, not four months. North Macedonia submitted its application in 2004, had to wait one and a half years for candidate status, and formal accession negotiations began in 2020, six years later, although they have not been substantively ongoing to this day. Montenegro submitted its application in 2008, had to wait two years for candidate status, not four months, and an additional one and a half years was needed to start the accession negotiations. Serbia and Albania are particularly cautionary examples. They submitted their applications in 2009. Serbia had to wait two years for candidate status and an additional one and a half years to start negotiations. Albania had to wait five years for candidate status and another six years to start accession negotiations. Ukraine waited four, that is, four months.

This is an unabashed bias. Unabashed bias necessarily undermines the authority of European Union institutions. At such times, the role of national parliaments is elevated; it is at such times that we need national parliaments to discuss the question substantively, whether it is a good idea to start accession negotiations with Ukraine or not. In other words, in this debate taking place here, we need to find an answer to whether the start of negotiations and Ukraine's rapid EU membership would benefit Hungary and Europe.

I would like to summarize the government's position in one thesis statement. The government's position – although this debate may naturally convince us of the opposite – is currently that Ukraine's rapid accession to the European Union would have unforeseeable consequences; Ukraine's joining on a fast track does not serve the interests of either Hungary or the European Union.

Ladies and Gentlemen!

After this, I would like to say a few words about European rules. I am convinced that Europe, the European Union institutions must take their own rules seriously, because it is a specific form of integration that is held together precisely by these rules. If these rules are not taken seriously by the European institutions, then the European Union will simply cease to exist.

However, if I observe correctly what awaits us in the coming days in Brussels, the European Union institutions will precisely ask us, the member states – including Hungary – not to adhere to our own rules with Ukraine's rapid accession. The situation is that the European Commission has set seven conditions for Ukraine to obtain candidate status. This alone was a deviation from all previous cases, as it was expected that the conditions for candidate status had to be met before the status was granted. Here, an exception has already been made; we have started down a bad path: Ukraine was granted candidate status without meeting the stipulated conditions, but the Commission was satisfied with Ukraine fulfilling these conditions afterwards. The European Commission set seven such conditions: the reform of the selection of constitutional judges, the vetting of the High Council of Justice, enhanced action against money laundering, guaranteeing media freedom, action against corruption, action against oligarchs, and the enforcement of national minority rights.

If we look at how Ukraine's case stands from this perspective, even the biased Commission claims that only four of the seven conditions have been met. Therefore, candidate status should not have been granted to Ukraine, let alone starting negotiations. The question is, after this, who can take any proposal from the Commission seriously? According to the Commission, three out of seven conditions have not been met. But if we look at the four that the Commission claims have been met, we will see that in reality, not a single condition has been fulfilled.

International analyses available to the government claim that there have actually been setbacks in the four areas accepted by the Commission. The situation is that the law on the reform of the selection of constitutional judges has not been implemented, and the law on the procedure of the Constitutional Court has not even been adopted. The criteria for the selection of judges and the High Council of Justice are unclear, and even according to the Commission, the further development of the judicial administration system is justified based on an external and independent audit. No necessary decisions have been made in the fight against money laundering, and no one has been held accountable. The implementation of the adopted regulations has simply lagged behind. I will not repeat the words that our faction leader has already brought up, which come from Jean-Claude Juncker, the former President of the Commission, and pertain to Ukraine.

The issue of media and press freedom, which the Commission allegedly claims has been fulfilled, is such that despite formal guarantees, citing national security concerns, the Ukrainian government has practically dismantled freedom of opinion and press. In my opinion, this cannot even be criticized in the case of a country at war. I would like to reiterate: according to the Hungarian government's position, in the case of a country at war, the dismantling of freedom of opinion and press cannot be criticized. But this does not mean that we, Europeans, should make ourselves ridiculous by claiming that press freedom is upheld in Ukraine. Yet the Commission claims this.

Honorable Ladies and Gentlemen!

And there are three areas where, according to the Commission, the conditions have not been met. These are corruption, action against oligarchs, and the issue of national minorities. I agree with the previous speaker: we do not have a clear view of what the law recently adopted in the Ukrainian Parliament, supposedly favorable to minorities, actually contains; we are currently analyzing this. One thing I can say to you now, at this early stage of analysis, is that in 2015, the rights that belonged to Hungarians and other national communities living in Ukraine were taken away from them. Neither the Hungarians living in Ukraine nor we, Hungarians living in Little Hungary, want anything more than to have those rights returned that the minorities living there enjoyed until 2015. We are not asking for a new law, we are not asking for new solutions, we are not asking for new, complicated procedures; we are simply asking for the law that guaranteed the rights and conditions of community life for Hungarians until 2015 to be restored.

In summary, therefore, Honorable Ladies and Gentlemen, I must say that Ukraine is as far from meeting the conditions for EU candidacy and starting negotiations as Makó is from Jerusalem.

This is how things look from Ukraine's perspective, but there is another, broader context to consider. I might phrase it as what Ukraine's membership would mean for the European Union and Hungary. First of all, let us take ourselves seriously and admit that today, no one can say this precisely. No one can say it precisely because Ukraine is currently at war, and the end of the war is not in sight. There has never been a precedent for the European Union to accept a country or even to start negotiations with a country while it is at war, with all the inevitable uncertainties that entails.

Mr. Kocsis, the faction leader, is right: it is unknown what Ukraine's borders will be: will the occupied territories enter the Union or not? We also do not know what the population of Ukraine will be, and the basis for all financial, agricultural, and other support calculations – beyond the national gross product – is the population. Alongside the losses, we know – at least according to estimates – that at least 6 million people have left Ukraine. It is unclear whether they will return. Are they to be counted as part of the entering Ukraine or not? In other words, I want to tell you that Brussels wants us to say yes to something without either Brussels or us being able to assess precisely what it means for us.

However, we already have some experience regarding the economic impacts, as the Commission has implemented partial market opening towards Ukraine. We have experience in two areas: one is agriculture, and the other is transportation. In both areas, the Hungarian government sees that national interventions, defensive interventions were necessary to prevent irreparable and irretrievable damage in agriculture and transportation. So we are not even talking about Ukraine's full accession, just two areas, and we can already see the disruptions that threaten to ruin Hungarian livelihoods by the tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, due to this step, not to mention its full Central European context.

Honorable Ladies and Gentlemen!

Regarding the budgetary impacts of Ukraine's membership, while we cannot know for certain, there are estimates and calculations. We fundamentally work from the calculations of German institutions, and Hungarian institutions also base their work on these. German economic researchers provide the following figures for those interested in the matter. In the case of Ukraine's full membership, the seven-year budget will have to bear an extra cost of 190 billion euros, or 70 trillion forints. Thus, over seven years, 190 billion euros will have to be paid from the European Union budget. To illustrate the proportions, this would represent 17 percent of the total framework of the current seven-year budgetary period, 2021-2027, which would be consumed by a single country.

We also have calculations regarding agricultural support. Ukrainian farmers could claim 93 billion euros in agricultural support during the seven-year budgetary cycle. To place this in the sea of numbers, I can tell you that France, the largest beneficiary of EU agricultural policy, currently receives 65 billion euros. Ukraine would receive 93 billion euros! The amount due to Ukraine in the Hungarian context means that it would receive ten times more than Hungary is currently entitled to.

And I do not want to divert the debate in another direction, but I find it important to note that a significant portion of this money would actually flow into the pockets of Americans, as the Americans have heavily invested in the Ukrainian agricultural sector. The U.S. Secretary of State recently did not hide his opinion, clearly stating that 90 percent of every dollar that goes from America to Ukraine comes back to the United States, creating jobs and growth. The U.S. Secretary of State declared this a win-win situation. This, of course, is an American opinion and American calculation, but I do not believe that the numbers would show anything different in a European context.

Honorable Ladies and Gentlemen!

In other words, Ukraine's membership, for which negotiations are now to be initiated, would mean that every other EU member state would become a net contributor, or 20 percent of agricultural support would have to be taken from everyone. Let us ask the Hungarian Agricultural Chamber about this possibility! If we finish with agriculture and move on to the area of cohesion funds, I must say that in the case of Ukraine's membership, 87 billion euros would have to be given to Ukraine due to cohesion funds. This is three times what is officially due to Hungary.

Therefore, I must say – taking the numbers into account, analyzing the economic contexts, and seriously considering the idea that the negotiations are indeed aimed at granting membership – if we do not want to make a political gesture, because membership is not meant for that, and we start from the premise that anyone truly takes membership seriously, then I must say that this idea is currently absurd, ridiculous, and unserious, and the Hungarian government does not intend to support it.

I would like to ask the representatives, including the left, not to consider the issue of Ukraine's EU membership as a party matter. I ask the left, of course, as well as the national side, to consider this a national, cross-national issue. Ukraine's EU membership, in this form, stands in sharp contrast to Hungary's interests. Ukraine can and should be helped. But no one should want to ruin Hungary in the process.

In summary, I can say to you that Hungary is under pressure, but we must not deviate from being the voice of European reason. We are interested in a peaceful and prosperous Ukraine, but for that, the establishment of peace as quickly as possible and the thoughtful deepening of strategic partnership are necessary, the result of which, in a few years' time, could even be Ukraine's membership in the European Union, if the actual time for that comes. Everything has its appointed time, and the time for Ukraine's membership in the European Union has not yet come.

Thank you for your kind attention!