Congress of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

9 February 2018

Context
Putin addressed the Congress of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs in February 2018, discussing economic development, sanctions, and technological change ahead of federal elections.
Main themes
Business climate and investment, technological transformation, economic sanctions and trade restrictions, macroeconomic stability, labor productivity, international business relations, vocational and higher education reform, infrastructure development, Russia-France business ties, Eurasian Economic Union
Duration
~49 min
94th percentile
Words
5,848
94th percentile
Sentences
335
96th percentile
Readability
58
82nd percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%52%
  • Institutional 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Environmental 2%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

335 sentences in 101 paragraphs

Dear colleagues! Russia is entering a complex, tense, and very important period of development. The success of how we navigate this period largely depends on the efforts of businesses and the results we achieve.

We are aware of the external constraints, and I will not dwell on this in detail now. I will only say that our position is well known: the policy of artificial restrictions in international business relations is a dead-end path that leads everyone, including the initiators of such policies, to lost profits and direct losses. I must say that, in conversations with your colleagues from other countries, I see that they share this point of view.

Just recently, as you have seen, there was a meeting with representatives of large French businesses. I just spoke with the President of France about this on the phone. We generally have a positive attitude towards what we can do together not only with France but also with other countries to develop our business ties.

The policy of restrictions has been in place for a long time, essentially always. The Jackson-Vanik amendment was repealed, and immediately, almost on the same day – not "almost," but on the same day – the so-called Magnitsky Act was adopted, simply without any grounds. And this was long before the events in Ukraine and Crimea. Simply because this is how they want to work with us.

And I repeat: I think that those who are doing this will soon get tired of it. Still, I hope that we will find a way to normal relations.

We need to talk not only about this but also about the fact that a new technological wave is seriously changing the landscape of the global economy. This is the most important thing. If I may say so, the cards are being dealt anew today: fundamentally new markets for goods and services will be formed, and new leaders will emerge. Naturally, competition will intensify now. In such a situation with competitors, including in the global business environment, it must be said directly that there will be no ceremony. Any forms of pressure and competitive struggle may come into play.

It is obvious that the sanctions challenge is of a non-temporary nature and will most likely persist for some time. But I repeat: I still hope that common sense will prevail and, in the interests of the entire global economy, we will move together with all our partners in the right direction.

I believe that the necessary foundation for such development has been created. I am also talking here about macroeconomic stability. Thanks to the joint actions of the Government and the Central Bank, we have managed to achieve low inflation, maintain the necessary level of state reserves, and enter a downward trend in interest rates. It is important to take full advantage of the opportunities that the current situation provides.

I have said many times that the key factor for growth is increasing the efficiency of the national economy, raising labor productivity based on modern technologies and competencies. Here, the leading role, of course, belongs to you – the business community.

We will continue to improve the business climate in Russia, create comfortable conditions for investments in new production, in the creation of quality jobs, eliminate barriers in regulation, and develop infrastructure. And of course, we will align the system of vocational and higher education with the needs of domestic industry, agriculture, and other sectors.

I plan to talk in more detail about all this in my Address to the Federal Assembly. And today, of course, I will be happy to hear your opinions, your assessments, and proposals on how we should work together.

Thank you for your attention. Thank you very much.

A. Shokhin Shokhin Alexander Nikolaevich President of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Allow me, on behalf of the delegates and guests of the congress, to thank you for participating in our work. For us, your participation in the congress is not only an assessment of our contribution to the development and implementation of socio-economic policy but also an opportunity to discuss the Government's action program for the medium term, which is currently being actively discussed and will be ready for implementation in the coming months. We are not only participants in this process – the preparation of documents in dialogue with the Government, as you mentioned – but we also expect that the implementation of this strategy will be our joint endeavor.

As part of the Russian Business Week, we held eight forums, several round tables, a meeting of the Federal Council of the RSPP, and the Business Council of the Eurasian Economic Union. The forums were dedicated to priority areas of our dialogue with the authorities: this includes the tax forum, financial forum, forum on supervisory and control activities, environmental forum, international forum, social forum, forum on technical regulation, and digital transformation.

Today, in our discussions within the congress with key ministers of the Russian Government, we discussed priority areas for the future and conducted a survey, which took place in two stages. During the registration of our colleagues for various forums, about three thousand people, we asked them about key problems or priorities for the future. From this, we identified the most important topics and today, in an interactive mode, we offered the ministers of the Russian Government to assess these areas.

I would like to mention several topics from those voiced today and identified as priorities. In discussing key directions for improving the investment climate, we primarily focused on the problem related to the accessibility of borrowed financing. One-third of those surveyed believe that this is a real problem.

Thank you to the Central Bank: today the key rate was reduced by another 25 basis points. But, of course, the key rate is an important driver for improving the situation in this area. We still have much to do, including in terms of reserving systems and various support mechanisms, such as project financing, and so on. However, the successes in reducing inflation allow us to expect further reductions in the key final rate for borrowers.

In discussing key directions in fiscal policy, primarily tax policy, colleagues highlighted the predictability of fiscal policy as the most important direction. This means that it is not only about not lowering rates, although that is certainly important, and the stability of the fiscal burden level is the second most important priority; nevertheless, predictability, meaning the adoption of certain tax decisions with a lead time, so that one can adapt or even participate in the assessment of regulatory impact. By the way, the regulatory impact assessment does not yet apply to tax rates. This issue is of primary concern to businesses.

In discussing key directions in industrial policy, we divided ourselves between such areas as the implementation of best available technologies. And this is not only in the environmental context. It is certainly about modernization. By the way, in this context, we talked a lot about removing the tax on movable property from the tax system, which is essentially a tax on modernization. Support for non-resource exports has become one of the key directions, as well as increasing the efficiency of development institutions and tools.

In discussing key directions in regulatory policy and the system of supervisory and control activities, the delegates of the congress and participants in the surveys identified the need to reduce the number of inspections as a key problem. Although the process is progressing very actively, the reduction of inspections is currently happening quickly, and it is planned to reduce the number of scheduled inspections by another 30 percent this year, while the situation with unscheduled inspections has not changed significantly over the past four years.

In this regard, what you did a year ago at the request of small businesses (namely: replacing fines with warnings for the first violation), we propose to extend to all businesses, as this practice allows us to focus on the prevention of certain violations rather than on punitive sanctions.

Key directions of work in the social and labor sphere. Here, the modernization of the vocational education system, which you mentioned in your speech, and the liberalization of labor legislation come to the forefront. In discussing the state priority program "Increasing Labor Productivity" at the Council for Strategic Development, at the Ministry of Economic Development, and at the Ministry of Labor, we have already come to a whole list of restrictions that need to be lifted in order to increase labor productivity and liberalize labor legislation, while naturally taking into account the interests of workers.

Of course, these are just the topics that we managed to voice in the public space before your arrival at the forums I mentioned. And today, in your presence, colleagues may still raise a number of questions.

I would like my colleagues Alexey Alexandrovich Mordashov – Chairman of the Board of Directors of Severstal, and Vladimir Sergeyevich Lisin – Chairman of the Board of Directors of Novolipetsk Steel, to continue this conversation. They will talk about the program for increasing labor productivity and the role of large companies in this process, as well as about the conditions for investment and how they have changed over the past 5-6 years.

I would like to thank you once again for participating in our congress and express hope that we will be reliable partners in shaping the action program of the authorities for the next medium-term period and will actively implement it.

A. Mordashov: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Dear colleagues!

I would like to say a few words on the topic of labor productivity. It is obvious that this topic is extremely relevant for all of us. It is no secret that in this indicator we lag behind a number of leading countries in the world. According to OECD data, labor productivity in our country per hour of working time is about one-third of the American level.

And we know that this is a key factor for ensuring our competitiveness. Much has been said today, and will continue to be said, about the tools that can increase labor productivity. And, of course, macroeconomic factors are very significant. It is extremely important to continue economic reforms, ensure macroeconomic stability, and ensure the availability of capital.

But I would also like to mention a somewhat different aspect – the microeconomic one, which, it seems to me, is beginning to play an increasingly important role due to the technological changes that are being widely discussed today, of which we are witnesses. I am talking about the measures and tools that exist at each enterprise aimed at reducing costs, increasing productivity, improving product quality, and ensuring overall competitiveness and efficiency of enterprises.

At Severstal, we devote a lot of time and effort to this issue, and we have what we call the Severstal business system. According to our internal assessments, this system gives us additional efficiency, additional earnings of about two billion rubles a year.

I know that many company leaders, many companies represented in this hall, also pay great attention to this issue. And we already see that a certain experience has accumulated in our country among leading companies – as a rule, these are large companies, but not only – which, firstly, allows us to increase our efficiency, and secondly, if it were available to all companies in our country, it would raise the overall level of labor productivity in Russia.

It seems to me that this is especially important given the changes we hear about today in technologies: the digitalization of the economy, the emergence of STI 4.0, undoubtedly provide us with new opportunities and pose new threats. And perhaps something at the level of Russia as a whole, at the level of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, something supported by the Government to accelerate the exchange of these best practices would be very useful.

I would generally see this in the form of some kind of public-private partnership, some database, some analytical center that would collect data from everyone, where one could register, present information about their achievements and best practices, make it accessible to others, and receive information about what best practices exist in this center, brought by others. I think this would be very useful and very interesting for all of us.

We know about the initiative of the Ministry of Economic Development led by Maxim Stanislavovich Oreshkin. By the way, we happened to be on the same working group in Davos, discussing labor productivity issues, and we generally put forward very similar proposals on how to solve this issue.

There is a federal state program for labor productivity. It seemed to me that such an initiative could be very beneficial for all of us. Moreover, I repeat, there are many good practices in various companies, and this micro-focus, it seems to me, is very important for all of us not to lose sight of, and state support in this matter would be very useful.

But here I want to emphasize one thing again. It is not about the state spreading best practices. It is about us, each of us, driven by our commercial interests, perhaps paying more attention to this. But all of us together can help each other and each of us with the support of the state.

Once again, I would like to say thank you very much and urge us to pay attention to all this, especially considering the technological changes of which we are participants.

Thank you.

V. Lisin, Vladimir Sergeyevich, Chairman of the Board of Directors of PJSC "Novolipetsk Steel": Dear colleagues! Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

While you were away, we had a rather long period of time during which we discussed various issues. I do not want to speak now about the great optimism that prevails in the room. Nevertheless, there are things that, in my opinion, should answer the question that was posed at the very beginning of my speech.

How to bring investments back into industry? One cannot embrace the incommensurable; this is a clear and banal thing. However, perhaps, by coming down to earth, stepping away from macroeconomic indicators, or what is happening today in the world, and how the wave of expectation of a new crisis or, after all, not a crisis, but a downturn is unfolding, we must ground ourselves in this situation and look at this industry.

In industry, there is actually a simple cycle. If we do not talk about making investment decisions, the first question is – we need to design. The second question is – we need to build. The third question is – we need infrastructure. The fourth question is – it is the regulation that shapes this entire process.

I will try to touch on several points regarding what has actually happened. A lot of useful things have been done in the recent period. But, in general, if we are asking the question "how to improve?", then, accordingly, there are points that simply need to be addressed. Or they are glaringly curious, and any investment process, including in our company, when we undertake it, we look back and examine our mistakes, what actually hindered us before. And we do not repeat them next time. It is probably worth sometimes looking at some of our processes from this perspective.

The tax system. I will start with it because, on the one hand, it is somewhat simpler. Indeed, the tax system itself, the direct tax burden is quite stable. We have nothing to complain about. In general, what the Tax Code states is stable for us. There are some amendments, but they are not fundamental. We must give credit here; we have indeed managed to hold steady in this regard, and the Government, the President, and the Ministry of Finance have helped us to maintain this. These promises have been fulfilled.

However, we have also managed to play a bit here, if we talk about industry or the investment cycle and modernization. We started playing in 2013 by first canceling the amendment related to payments for real estate, then in 2016 it was reintroduced, then in 2017 it was halved, and just in case, it was handed over to the regions, let them decide how to grant or not grant this amendment.

We understand perfectly well what has happened today: about five regions agreed and granted this to businesses, while the other regions simply cannot do this because there is still the issue of budgetary provision. And therefore, it is clear that if the state does not simultaneously support this region by granting such a benefit, then it is clear that the region simply physically – I will not say financially – cannot provide such a benefit for modernization.

And we understand that modernization is still modern and expensive equipment, and no matter how much we want, it costs money. And how to make an investment decision when we understand that it can be changed basically every one and a half to two years, playing this game? This concerns the Tax Code today.

We probably do not have problems with the tax authorities today. Perhaps, maybe, we need to finish the story a bit, carrying around papers with seals when documents can be transmitted electronically from customs. Everything else, for the most part, has probably indeed been done well by the service so that we do not have to talk about it too much. And, in my opinion, we are not heavily burdened by tax audits because we have learned to see this today in digital form quite quickly.

Now we are adopting a good decision – accelerated VAT refunds. We made a decision in 2016 that it should be expedited… But there was just a small question about whom we would give it to. Let’s draw this line: which sector will be raw material, which will be non-raw material, and which non-raw material sector will result from the accelerated VAT refund?

As a result, for the second year now, we have been running around with papers from one agency to another. Guys, either give everyone this accelerated refund finally, or say: here we have the scoundrels, the raw material oilmen, we will not give it to them. Can we do something? Although, in my opinion, we should give it to everyone; enough playing this game, delaying money. If we are talking about stimulating exports, in my opinion, the best thing is to take and resolve this issue definitively, rather than trying to agree on which sectors to give it to and which not to.

We have introduced many stimulation mechanisms: RIPs, TORs. You have all heard, many governors have spoken on this topic before us. Well, fine, they have been introduced. In principle, the factor itself is quite normal; it works somewhere. And, by the way, these are targeted investments, targeted projects, and if, on the whole, they also have limitations: in one place – it is not allowed, in another place – again at the discretion of the region, in the third case – only greenfield. That is, if you are building a plant from scratch in the field – yes, but if it is modernization – it does not fit, and so on, they have imposed these restrictions themselves. Maybe we should not be doing this anymore? On the one hand, we are doing a good thing – and then we regulate it in this way ourselves.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, may I tell a joke on this topic about how things happen with us? An old Soviet joke. A collective farm, a meeting is taking place. The chairman stands up and says: "You know, we have a problem: the sowing season is approaching, and the blacksmith is drunk. We need to do something. What are the suggestions?" The most advanced one stands up and says: "Let’s send him for treatment." He says: "What treatment? The sowing season is approaching, and who will do the repairs? One blacksmith! That’s it, we’re done; there are no others. What other suggestions do we have?" Someone says: "Let’s deprive him of his quarterly bonus." He says: "Well, yes, three children. He will just go to the neighboring collective farm, and we will lose him too; he is just one person, what are you thinking? Let’s come up with something better!" Someone says: "Let’s beat him up!" – "Guys, what are you thinking? The man is forty years old; if we beat him up, he will just turn around and quit all work. That’s not an option either!" A hand goes up, and says: "Let’s rape him!" The chairman throws up his hands: "What are you, out of your mind? What kind of suggestion is that!" A second hand goes up and says: "Let’s rape the tractor driver?" He says: "Why the tractor driver?" – "We have two of them!"

Sometimes we make decisions like that. I will now tell you a specific example from our practice.

Vladimir, you should have mentioned the milkmaid at least! Where are you going?

V. Lisin: I didn’t get to that!

Everyone knew perfectly well: we are building pipelines. A clear topic, a strategic issue – we are building pipelines. I think we all understand that the amount of oil that goes into the pipelines will certainly not reach the Russian Railways. It is clear, nothing terrible; the tank cars are just standing. In principle, it is not that terrible; no one is losing significantly.

Now, at the same time, the Presidium of the State Council, Vladimir Vladimirovich, with your participation, makes a decision that it is necessary to develop waterways and create an alternative to rail transport during the shipping season – river transport. The esteemed Ministry of Industry, represented by Denis Valentinovich Manturov, First Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation, finances the refinancing rate for the construction of vessels; you make a decision – the narrow bottleneck of the Gorodetsky node is being unraveled, 180 billion rubles, to expand traffic along this highway.

That is, accordingly, the river is ecologically clean; during the season, this is quite a normal phenomenon. But what next? Next, more than 100 vessels have been built at our shipyards, including 60 tankers, and leasing companies, banks – all participated because there is a normal process of state support.

And then, at the same time, last year, our esteemed Russian Railways gives a discount specifically for this season, specifically for river transport, of 25 percent off the transportation of liquid products. They took away a million tons from the river fleet; accordingly, what happens next with investment projects? Two billion dollars were taken away from the river fleet, and Russian Railways made a profit of 600 million rubles.

It seems we need to think about what to do next. Nothing of the sort; this year, it is proposed to make another 37 percent discount. Accordingly, who will build the ships then, why did we invest in all this? First, we will undermine river shipping, and then we will undermine shipbuilding again. Wait, this is the second blacksmith!

Just don’t touch the tractor driver, okay?

V. Lisin: Another story about the so-called non-market surcharge. You make a decision that yes, probably, in order to reconstruct the outdated thermal capacities of thermal power plants, it is necessary to introduce a surcharge for the industry for all working, so that this reconstruction can be carried out. Correctly, you make an amendment that is not higher than inflation. And, by the way, we have not yet recouped the previous ones; they are already close to inflation.

Well, immediately, a decision comes to this question: let’s add a nuclear power plant here too. Now the question arises. We will all now receive a surcharge to our tariff, which will exceed inflation several times. I may think that, of course, there should be a reconstruction, but not in such a barbaric way.

I am building a thermal power station at my own expense. Then the state returns the principal of this loan, the interest on the loan. And I also, accordingly, earn in the market. Such sweet conditions, there is no better. Why have we suddenly become so kind? It is also unclear. And, accordingly, we impose all this on the industry, on tariffs, and want in this situation to again achieve further tariff growth. This is where inflation comes from; it starts from this.

Regulatory environment. Construction. A new requirement has appeared – avalanche collapse. Probably, the calculation of avalanche collapse during design and construction is needed where civil construction is involved, where many people live, where sports facilities are, where there is a load. How can we calculate a blast furnace on three legs? What nonsense is this? And all this is in industry. This is a completely different sector. All this has been introduced into the building codes, and now we are told: guys, calculate for us if we cut one leg of the blast furnace.

We understand what this may be related to. But you cannot force all these calculations to be done in the same way! And, in fact, this will certainly increase construction costs. Here we need to selectively understand that this norm is completely for another sphere. At the design stage, it is necessary to determine many things. At the design stage – up to finishing.

First of all, everyone who has designed knows perfectly well that when it comes to working documentation, it is clear that amendments are made to the project: electrical wiring, lighting, communications, water, gas, and sometimes equipment is even rearranged. Now they have come up with the next thing that every time we must re-approve this at the construction stage, go get permission; this extends all these stories by about 200 days. And if you do not do this on time, your construction stops. Thank God, it has not been stopped yet, but why introduce such norms and try to think that this somehow will allow us to accelerate investments?

Another amendment has appeared – environmental expertise. Previously, it seemed everything was in "one window." They came, showed in "one window," and were given approval. Now it has been decided that it is necessary to undergo expertise additionally in another "window." The same environmental one.

Do we have problems with environmental expertise? Have we built something so dirty recently that we are starting to extend the cycle? And this is design, which means that in this situation, the investment project will start with a delay of 180, 200, 300 days.

We calculated this whole story, looked at it retrospectively. Exactly five years ago, for 100 billion rubles of our investments just in facilities, we paid approximately 40 billion for all regulatory, additional things, and so on. Now it is 54. Here, in fact, is the increase in such a volume of additional investments. Of course, the competitiveness of the industry will fall in this case.

We are in a good position, of course, in the Doing Business ranking, but when we look at this ranking from the perspective of construction, we are in 115th place.

What would I like to say? In principle, in order to somehow weigh…

A. Shokhin: A bit of optimism.

V. Lisin: Yes.

It seems to me that perhaps the time for optimism has come, associated with the fact that it is time to move from targeted adjustments in the tax situation to national issues. Well, we have gained experience, we understand. Perhaps we should just move away from all these targeted things and move to nationwide ones. After all, the investment climate, this understanding, we are now receiving information that the discussion is about reducing the tax burden on profits, and in the UK, the profit tax is being reduced. Everyone understands that something will happen in this regard. We are not demanding, perhaps, a reduction, but certain preferences that we would like to receive for GDP growth and industrial development should, of course, be made already, probably, on a national scale.

There was a monitoring system, as you remember, quite decent. For some reason, it was stopped. It seems to me that, first of all, it needs to be restored, and, in fact, further expanded to investment projects. It seems to me that we all received quite decent data, which we could rely on. It is a pity that we lost them.

From the perspective of tax burden and non-tax burden. A decision was made a year and a half ago by the Chairman of the Government that until the law is passed, the non-tax burden should not be increased. You all understand that the non-tax burden continues to rise. The law is still under consideration, for a year and a half. The burden is growing, the law is not being passed. Until the law appears, there should be no increase! These are things that, in my opinion, need to be done quite promptly and quickly.

As for the things I mentioned. The DPM or the things that we are adopting. Still, sometimes, before making a final decision, the Government should conduct an economic assessment in this situation: what was done by the previous DPM, analyze it, and clearly show where we want to increase or, let’s say, reconstruct additional capacities. Because we know very well: in the surplus central region, we currently have two blocks of a nuclear power plant under construction. Where we have a surplus today, who needs help – this should still be targeted and precisely indicated.

General regulation, of course, I absolutely agree, most people here have said that for every new act, two previous ones should be removed. Recently, we tried to count how many of these acts we have: 30 percent of all the several thousand recent "regulations" pertain to business. It seems to me that the figure should be much higher for the adoption of a new act and the elimination of previous ones.

The rest we understand that everything that is happening today is not for us if we are not optimistic and do not move forward, and in this situation do not pay attention to what is happening around us. Sometimes, it may even be upsetting from the perspective of foreign policy situations and so on, but business has always been structured in such a way that we only achieve success when we move forward. I know that in this situation, everyone who is achieving success today is indeed focused in this direction.

Thank you for your attention.

A. Shokhin: Thank you, Vladimir Sergeyevich.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, if you would like to comment… You have already commented on the blacksmith and the tractor driver.

First of all, both Alexander Nikolayevich [Shokhin], and Alexey [Mordashov], and Vladimir Sergeyevich [Lisin] raised questions that we constantly discuss.

As for best practices, we need to find – in fact, we are trying to do this – a mechanism that would work effectively. By the way, associations – including RSPP and primarily RSPP, with which we are in contact – can certainly play a more noticeable role.

Vladimir Sergeyevich raised a number of questions. You know, from this, I draw several conclusions. We meet quite regularly, but I see that there are too few substantive meetings; this needs to be corrected. Why do I say "substantive"? Because what Volodya said are things that can actually be easily resolved. We just need to be concerned about this, we need to engage with it. And it can be done in a timely manner.

Vladimir Sergeyevich said many things. One of them is quite obvious. We built river vessels, and then Russian Railways made a number of decisions to lower tariffs for rail transport, and everything collapsed. An agreement should have been concluded with the Government when building the vessels. The Ministry of Economic Development should have such a mechanism: for the payback period of these investments, the tariff should have been maintained. Government representatives in Russian Railways should have said this. And everything else is roughly the same. Different mechanisms, but they need to be created. It is very unfortunate that we have not yet formulated such elementary things that are generally on the surface. This must be done.

As for our overall intentions for the near future, I think that both the Government as a whole and the Ministry of Economic Development, the Ministry of Finance, and the Central Bank will still work properly with associations, with large enterprises separately, and with associations of small and medium businesses.

I assure you, we have a very serious, determined attitude – I have already mentioned this publicly – to clear away everything that hinders us from moving forward.

We very much hope that the effect obtained from this work will be invested, and invested here. Because although we are distracted by various foreign policy absurdities, these absurdities, while they may have an empty ring on one side, on the other hand, they are beneficial to us. Because we communicate directly with many sitting here in the hall, and I see the concern that arises regarding what will happen there. Therefore, it is better to invest here. And our task is to create conditions for these investments, to protect them.

It is still too early to talk about this, but the set of measures is basically clear. It is on the surface; the question is only how to prioritize these measures, what to do more of, what to do less of, how to adjust the tax system that Vladimir Sergeyevich spoke about.

Of course, we understand that the most important thing is for it to be stable. But we will try to make it not only stable; we will also try to make it effective from the perspective of business operations. Indeed, and I think everyone understands this, the state must ensure the fulfillment of its social obligations in any scenario. But still, the priority for the near future will be to focus on the accelerated development of the economy.

I want it to be understood that we not only have a desire, but we also have an understanding that we cannot achieve radical success, including in the social sphere, any other way. We will strive for this in every possible way.

I hope that in contact with you, we will adjust some elements, including those that Vladimir Sergeyevich spoke about today with irony and pain.

I will try to organize my work in such a way that we can meet more often not for ritualistic purposes, but for substantive, deep conversations.

A. Shokhin: Thank you.

Dear delegates of the congress, guests! The agenda of the congress has been exhausted. Allow me to declare it closed, to thank Vladimir Vladimirovich for participating in the work and for the invitation to continue the dialogue on many working issues.

Thank you.

I would like to congratulate Alexander Nikolayevich on his election for a new term as the leader.

A. Shokhin: Thank you.