Investment Forum "Russia Calls!"

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

28 November 2018 · Moscow, Russia

Context
Putin addressed the tenth annual 'Russia Calls!' Investment Forum in Moscow on November 28, 2018, outlining Russia's economic performance and development plans.
Main themes
Russian economic growth, investment climate, labor productivity, digital economy, infrastructure development, business confidence, macroeconomic stability, budgetary policy, export capabilities, structural reforms, foreign investment, vocational education
Duration
~58 min
95th percentile
Words
6,982
95th percentile
Sentences
408
97th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%53%
  • Geopolitical 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Social 2%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

408 sentences in 161 paragraphs

Good afternoon, dear friends! Ladies and gentlemen!

I am very glad to welcome all of you to Moscow – participants and guests of the traditional forum "Russia Calls," which is gathering for the tenth time.

This year, the forum has once again brought together leaders of major Russian and foreign companies, investment funds, and authoritative specialists and experts who connect their work, at least part of their activities, with work in Russia and show interest in our country.

Before moving on to the discussion, I would like to briefly characterize the situation in the Russian economy. Overall, it is developing steadily. According to estimates, in the first three quarters of this year, Russia's GDP increased by 1.5 percent.

At the same time, industrial production shows higher, leading growth rates – plus three percent, including manufacturing, which has increased by 3.2 percent.

Key indicators such as inflation and unemployment are at low levels: unemployment is at 4.7 percent, inflation is around 3.5. According to the Central Bank's forecasts (perhaps Ms. Nabiullina has already mentioned this), we planned for around four, and now it is 3.5, as far as I know.

Despite attempts at external pressure and known internal difficulties, domestic businesses are building long-term plans and increasing investments in development.

The volume of investments in fixed capital has grown by 4.1 percent over the past nine months. This business optimism among investors, their positive outlook is an important indicator of business confidence. We highly value this and will support such sentiments.

Of course, it is clear that the current pace of economic growth is insufficient for a radical improvement in the living standards of our citizens. We talk about this, we understand it, and in order to change the situation, we are building a comprehensive development program.

As I have already mentioned, we set ourselves the task of achieving growth rates above the global average and securing a place among the top five largest economies in the world. A solid foundation for such breakthrough dynamics must be provided by addressing structural issues.

First, this involves increasing labor productivity, primarily through the introduction of modern, more efficient technologies in non-resource sectors of the economy.

We will improve the system of vocational education, ensure continuous development of competencies, and effective retraining of personnel.

Second, we will concentrate vast resources and provide all necessary support to private companies for infrastructure development. Roads and railways, seaports and river ports, air transport, energy, communications – in all these areas, we plan to significantly, indeed multiply our efforts to enhance the connectivity of the country with convenient and safe communications.

I want to emphasize: this is important for more active participation of Russia in international economic relations and for increasing our country's export capabilities.

Third, in the coming years, we will do everything necessary for the accelerated growth of the digital economy segment. We will form a regulatory and technological framework for the widespread implementation of digital solutions in public administration (we have already started doing this, and we are moving quite rapidly), in the utilities sector and urban management, in industry, transport, education, and healthcare.

We will create fundamentally new industries and business platforms based on "digital," stimulating the emergence and development of Russian companies that are global leaders of the "digital age."

And of course, to ensure investment growth and attract capital to the Russian economy, we will continue to improve the business climate, reduce the administrative burden on entrepreneurs, and offer investors new, more convenient mechanisms for expanding their businesses.

Undoubtedly, the implementation of plans to develop the country's economic potential will require large-scale investments from the state; you have surely heard these figures. I would just clarify that from 2019 to 2021, it is planned to allocate 2.3 trillion rubles from the federal budget for these purposes.

At the same time, I would note that despite the objective increase in expenditures, we have not opted for a loosening of budgetary policy and will maintain a responsible approach to financial management in the future, ensuring the necessary balance between the revenues and expenditures of the state treasury.

Such long-term predictability of macroeconomic, financial, and currency policy is, of course, extremely important for both domestic and foreign investors.

This is what I wanted to say at the very beginning, dear ladies and gentlemen. We still have a small discussion planned – I am at your disposal.

A. Kostin: First of all, thank you very much for coming to us. We indeed have a jubilee, the tenth forum. And if you allow me, I will take two minutes of your attention to remind you how it all started ten years ago.

The creation of this forum is directly linked to the establishment of an investment bank called "VTB Capital," which we created ten years ago during a very unusual period, during the global crisis when many investment banks were reducing their activities.

And of course, we consulted with management and leading specialists. I had a conversation with the head of Deutsche Bank, Joseph Ackermann, a well-known investment banker, and he told me: "Andrey, when you see Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, tell him that there is no great country without a powerful national investment bank."

And when I came to Vladimir Vladimirovich after that (he was then the Prime Minister) to report, first of all, Vladimir Vladimirovich approved this initiative, and secondly, he said: "How can I help?"

I, like in a fairy tale, thought to order three wishes, but then I remembered that the more wishes, the worse the ending of the fairy tale, and I formulated one wish: "Vladimir Vladimirovich, can you come to our conference (because in those years, any self-respecting investment bank held conferences), and not go to others?" He did not say anything about the others, but he positively said that he would come.

And of course, in even my most optimistic dreams, I did not think that ten years would pass, and every year, regardless of the weather, the political climate, or his busyness, he would come to us. This has made the forum what it is today – I consider it the leading financial forum in our country, and of course, you all come primarily to listen to and talk with Vladimir Vladimirovich.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, I recalled the numbers. At our first forum, where you spoke, there were 300 investors present; now we have 2,200, and more than 500 of them came from abroad, from 63 countries around the world. And I still hope that your efforts have not been in vain, because for the great country of Russia, it seems to me, there is today a reliable national investment bank. And so, thank you very much for this support all these years.

Colleagues, we will now move on to questions. You know, we have democracy, questions from the audience. Vladimir Vladimirovich often chooses the speaker himself, but while you prepare, the first question.

We do not have our prepared question, but the Wall Street Journal, it seems to me, asked an interesting question: "One of the key economic tasks of your Government is to increase the share of investments to 25 percent of GDP. Similar goals you set in your previous election manifestos, but without much success. What has changed this time? Why do you believe that this task is more realistic today?"

I can say that we discussed this topic a bit in the morning, and then Mr. Alexey Kudrin said that, in fact, when specific orders from the President or the Government are not fulfilled, there are consequences, but when, he says, we set strategic tasks that are not fulfilled, it seems that no one is held accountable. So who will be held accountable for this? My additional question. Who will you ask for the fulfillment of this indicator?

You know, first of all, I think that colleagues come not to look at me and listen to me; I am not the main attraction in Moscow. They have things to do, to communicate with each other, and that is very important, to talk with colleagues from the Government, the Central Bank, to feel, so to speak, what Russia is breathing.

First of all, there is a difference between 2008 and 2018. There was a crisis then, and now it seems we are going through difficult times, and these crisis phenomena are caused by different circumstances.

Now, in my opinion, there is an understanding that, despite any crisis phenomena and even artificially created difficulties, the Russian economy is adapting to these challenges, feels confident, and creates conditions for its own internal development, and this, in my opinion, is the factor I mentioned from this podium.

We have GDP growth of 1.5 percent, which does not seem like much, but investments in fixed capital are outpacing GDP growth – 4.1 percent. This indicates that investors are confident about the future; they understand the policy being pursued by the financial authorities of the Russian Federation. It is stable, reliable, and predictable, and the economy has adapted to external shocks, as many factors I mentioned indicate.

As for accountability, as it always happens (you know this expression), based on the results of anything, "the uninvolved are rewarded, and the innocent are punished." We should not go down that path and think about whom to punish. We need to think about what additional steps to take to implement the ambitious plans we have set for ourselves. We have such a plan.

A. Kostin: Colleagues, please. You have the opportunity for direct dialogue. Please.

A. Tolga: Dear Mr. President!

I represent Turkey and would like to ask: Is there a discussion about moving away from the dollar to achieve greater diversification in making payments for various foreign trade goals?

One of the obstacles on this path is the governments themselves. They sign agreements that provide for payment in dollars, including in bilateral trade, and still retain this currency for reserve management. Russia is no exception here. What can governments do to support this process of diversification?

Thank you very much.

We do not have the goal of moving away from the dollar; the dollar is moving away from us. And those who make the corresponding decisions are not just shooting themselves in the foot, but a bit higher. Because such instability in dollar transactions creates a desire for many economies around the world to find alternative reserve currencies and create systems of calculation independent of the dollar.

It is not just about us, believe me; we see what is happening in the world. Look at how the gold and foreign exchange reserves of countries, including the closest allies of the United States, are shrinking. Dollar assets are decreasing; look at the reports, especially from the largest holders of dollar assets. This is the result of this policy of applying sanctions, including using the dollar.

I think that sooner or later this realization will come, but as long as the world faces such phenomena in the economy, there will be a search for alternative options for calculations and accumulation of reserves. We are also doing this, as are many other countries.

The market has formed for certain types of goods, for consumer goods, oil, for example, but still, when people think about solving one problem or another, those problems are resolved; solutions are found. For us, for example, already 70 percent of our exports and 30 percent of imports with the EAEU countries are serviced in rubles.

With some countries, we are now actively working, with our largest trade and economic partners, to create systems that would be independent of SWIFT. We are working to ensure the movement of goods.

I just spoke with the President of Turkey, your leader, just half an hour ago. We discussed a number of specific issues, but I will remind you of our deal in the field of military-technical cooperation regarding the supply of S-400s. We understand that if we conduct transactions in dollars, those transactions will not go through.

So we came up with another option, and the deal still happened. And this will be the case for any type of goods; this is just one of the examples that is on everyone's lips. The same will happen for other goods.

Therefore, we do not have the goal of moving away from the dollar; we are forced to do this. And I assure you, we will do this. But this is not because governments do not want to; we simply do not want to do anything drastic that would harm us.

But in order to make the global economy more resilient, more predictable, and to make transactions more effective and reliable, of course, alternative paths will be found.

A. Kostin: Please, who else?

R. Zakaro: My name is Raymond Zakaro, I am a senior investment specialist working in the United States. We work with global markets. I studied history before, and when I think about your country, I constantly think that, naturally, Russia is a great power that has done a lot for the whole world.

At the same time, as an American citizen, I always think about the fact that we have a lack of mutual understanding, and the world does not understand very well. I was given this gift from "VTB Capital," which mentions your meeting with Mr. Trump in Helsinki. It was printed in the United States, and there are certain errors in Russian.

My question to you is: What would you say to the leaders of my country to achieve better mutual understanding, so that they better understand the history of Russia, your viewpoints, in order to improve the relations between our two countries in the future?

As a historian, you know: to know history, you need to study it, you just need to read. There is nothing complicated about this, and then the motives of the partners you work with will probably become clear.

This is actually a useful thing, and history is a very interesting science. We know these clichés: to understand the future, you need to know what happened in the past. Today, you know, it is difficult for me to give any advice, and in general, it is a thankless task to advise.

You said that Russia is a great country. America is also a great country, with over 300 million people, the largest economy in the world. Essentially, the only universal reserve currency so far is the dollar. Huge advantages. The United States spends 700 billion dollars on defense.

We spend 46, while America spends 700 billion. This is more than the combined defense spending of all countries in the world taken together. Of course, it is a great country. We treat it that way. We need to treat each other with respect and demonstrate that respect in concrete actions.

We have just been talking about various kinds of restrictions, including in dollar transactions. Or various kinds of sanctions, or customs tariffs that are imposed on certain countries, for example, against China.

According to estimates from the World Trade Organization, the mutual restrictions imposed by the G20 countries recently have led to a reduction in global trade of nearly 500 billion dollars. Is anyone interested in this? Including such a major economy as the U.S. economy.

For us, this only creates certain windows of opportunity. For example, we will supply soybeans to China. The U.S. used to supply in huge quantities, and now we will supply as well. We have agreed with our Chinese friends that we will now supply poultry meat and some additional agricultural products.

In essence, the Americans are voluntarily refusing to participate in this colossal market, a huge one. Why? It seems to me that we need to strive for a positive outcome for ourselves, without trying to harm our partners, but rather seeking joint areas of activity for more effective cooperation in the end.

And everyone will benefit from this. But from unilateral politically motivated and illegal measures from the standpoint of international trade law, everyone will only lose.

What advice can be given here? To abandon this policy and seek points of contact. We are ready for this, we want this, I have said this many times. I hope that if I manage to talk with the President of the United States in Argentina, we will discuss this as well. As far as I understand and feel, he has mentioned this to me himself; we had lunch together in Paris, sitting across from each other, and talked for about an hour with each other and with other colleagues who were sitting nearby.

In principle, as far as I understand, President Trump is generally positively inclined. We need to find these points of contact that I mentioned (but this depends not on me, but on the administration), to find some common consensus within the United States itself that would set the entire American elite on such work with their partners.

M. Basaatni: Good afternoon! My name is Mohammed Basad. My question is related to the relations between OPEC and Russia.

In recent years, there has been active cooperation in the field of oil production cuts. And of course, the main question here is that many people believe that this plays into the hands of shale oil producers. I would like to know your point of view.

In addition, in connection with the reduction in production, some may say that this also affects technologies and innovations in the Russian oil sector. What is your point of view on the long-term strategy of the Russian Federation to respond to the decline in oil production?

You know, we have built cooperation with OPEC countries – 15 countries that are part of the organization, and 12 countries that are not part of the organization – we have agreed on joint work in global markets to balance supply and demand.

And I must say, I think for the first time in the history of this organization, we managed to do this; 100 percent of all agreements have been fulfilled. This has never happened before in the organization. I must admit that this happened largely thanks to the position of Saudi Arabia. This is essentially the merit of Saudi Arabia and the Crown Prince; he was the initiator of this work. It has led to positive results.

Regarding shale oil. We have not had, do not have, and I hope will never have, at least Russia will not have the goal of undermining anyone's business, including those engaged in shale oil. But it was necessary to balance the market and raise the price to a level where the industry itself becomes viable and where investments return to it.

After all, what was the danger? That investments in the industry would stop. In fact, this was already beginning to happen. And then, a price spike would be inevitable, but it would be significantly destructive for both producers and consumers. Therefore, our task and goal were to make the work joint, soft, in the interests of both producers and consumers. We succeeded in this.

As far as I remember, in 2013 the price was just over 43 dollars per barrel, and currently it is 72 for the first 10 months. Now it has fallen, then it has risen a bit again. In my opinion, around 60 is an absolutely acceptable figure; we are quite satisfied with it.

We are satisfied because we form the expenditure part of the budget from just over 40 dollars, and for the next year we have just over 43 dollars laid down in the expenditure part. I mean that the price will be 43 dollars per barrel. And the point at which shale oil production is profitable is somewhere between 35 and 45 dollars.

There are different options; we know it can go under 60, but on average, it is somewhere between 35 and 45. So this price I am talking about is balanced and fair. And if necessary, we are in contact with OPEC, and we will continue this joint work.

R. Ruiya: Your Excellency! Friends!

My name is Ravi Ruiya. I am the co-founder of the SA Group in India along with my brother Shashi Ruiya.

Your Excellency, this group is engaged in various business directions. We are involved in oil refining as well as oil field development. We are also engaged in electricity production, port infrastructure, as well as metallurgy and mining.

Your Excellency, over the past two years, with the active cooperation and support of VTB Bank, we have helped Rosneft invest in India. India has a very large market, with 1.25 billion people.

This is the largest volume of investment that a Russian private company has ever made in the private sector in India. I believe that perhaps Russians could also continue working in our market.

We would also like to consider how we can attract new Russian investments to India. This would contribute to both the development of the Indian market and the improvement of the quality of life of Indian citizens, and it would also benefit Russian exports.

For example, Russian power generation units could be exported to India. This would be in the interest of our group.

Your Excellency, my question is this. Economic growth in India is currently 1.5 percent. Despite rising oil prices, what do you think could contribute to increasing GDP growth to three percent?

A. Kostin: You mean – in Russia?

R. Ruiya: In Russia.

First of all, I want to say that we have indeed established very good, constructive relations with India. This is facilitated by our, of course, friendly personal relations with Prime Minister Mr. Modi, who is a very serious politician and a reliable partner in the full sense of the word.

Thanks in large part to his efforts, we are developing our relations in many areas. But we are not satisfied with the level we have today. It does not correspond to the capabilities of either India or the Russian Federation. We can multiply, indeed multiply, the volume of our trade and economic ties and mutual investments.

One of the investments, which you mentioned, is indeed the largest foreign investment in the history of the Indian economy – the acquisition by our company Rosneft, I believe, of 12 billion dollars, which entered the ownership of one of the largest oil refineries in India. I hope this is not the last investment. I hope it is not the last of its kind.

Of course, we will welcome Indian investments in Russia. We know how effectively and on a large scale Indians work in the pharmaceutical industry. We will welcome further expansion of this work. But not only here, but in other sectors as well.

You mentioned electricity. Our electrical engineering is very well developed and traditionally strong. In certain market segments, we still have a lot to do, to add, to establish the production of certain products, but overall we have good technologies, good quality, and we have the workforce and the educational system. In this area, we can certainly work actively.

As for achieving higher rates of economic growth, I have already spoken about this, including from this podium today. We have a whole program in place to achieve these higher growth rates. First of all, it is necessary to achieve an increase in labor productivity based on the latest technologies, including digital technologies – this is the development of infrastructure, the development of education and healthcare.

For example, speaking of infrastructure. We plan to significantly increase the capacity of our roads. And significant resources, both public and private, will be allocated for this over the next five to six years.

We plan to significantly expand the capabilities of the Russian railways, considering the need to export part of our export goods: coal, oil, and so on, when it comes to pipeline transport, and gas.

We will expand port facilities, especially in the Far East and Eastern Siberia. We will continue to develop seaports. For example, I will say that if in 2013, I believe, our total transshipment volume was 300 million tons, then last year we reached a transshipment of one billion tons for the first time in our history.

And this is clearly not the end of the road; it will all expand. We will significantly increase investments in healthcare and education because without healthy and educated people in the modern economy, it is impossible to achieve the final results we need.

We will expand the internet, of course, so that it reaches every, even small, village, and so on. This is a huge set of tools that we have planned within the framework of the so-called national projects. I very much hope that this will give us the necessary results.

Y. Thompson: You spoke about plans to expand investments in the Russian economy. How do you assess the capabilities of the Russian banking sector, and what role can banks play in stimulating economic growth?

We are fully aware of the potential capabilities of our banks, our banking system as a whole, how this compares with leading global banks, what resources they have today, what opportunities they have, what they can do, and most importantly, how they are developing.

We have leading banks, one of which is VTB Bank. We see the challenges they face, as well as their achievements and successes. The Central Bank has been consistently working for several years on the rehabilitation and strengthening of the Russian banking system. Sometimes this is painful and affects people's interests, but ultimately it is done in the interests of the citizens of the Russian Federation, so that the banking system, the financial institutions where people keep their savings, are reliable and stable.

We have adopted a number of legislative acts, a number of laws that protect the interests of depositors. Recently, we decided to further divide licenses. There are now two types of licenses that require different capital from banks. There is, I believe, a billion and 300 million, this is, so to speak, conditionally, as it is called (Nabiullina is sitting with you; she will tell you), let’s say, a general license and the second one.

They differ in that in the second case, these banks, which are usually regional banks, should have less burden related to reserving and other requirements from the regulator. We believe that regional banks should have the opportunity to operate more flexibly. I hope that this will be the case. And governors are precisely asking us for this, suggesting this way of behavior.

Overall, the banking system is developing successfully, steadily, and the profits are quite substantial. Now their total capital is, I believe, 90 trillion rubles. In the first nine months of this year, they made a profit of almost 1.5 trillion rubles. Therefore, we see what is happening here and know what to do next to strengthen our financial system.

J.-P. Toma: I am an advisor to former French President Nicolas Sarkozy on cooperation between Russia and France, and I am now the chairman of an investment fund.

Mr. President, my question concerns the recent sanctions. Finally, is there still a positive side to these sanctions for the Russian economy, as we are interested in learning about the successful story of import substitution in the agricultural sector, as well as in other sectors of the Russian economy?

I believe that any politically motivated, illegal (I want to emphasize this, illegal) restrictive measures from the standpoint of international legal norms, WTO norms, are harmful to everyone, including those who impose them.

You represent France and have dealt with and are dealing with issues of cooperation with the Russian Federation. There are obvious things, objective ones, confirmed by statistics. Our trade turnover with the European Union, which was our largest trade and economic partner at one time, and is still the largest, was 450 billion dollars; now it is 236, I believe. Is there a difference?

And according to estimates from the European Parliament, the under-delivery of European products to the Russian market has led to a reduction of 400,000 jobs in enterprises in the EU countries. But isn’t this a blow to the economy of the EU countries and to people, to social issues? After all, these are families, their incomes, children! This is what such things lead to. Of course, this negatively affects us as well.

But there are also positive aspects, but overall this has a negative impact on us, on the Russian economy. However, after the Russian economy has, quite obviously, adapted to this kind of behavior from our partners, and this has become clear to everyone, the benefits for us at the moment seem to be even greater.

First of all, you are also an investor, you understand that in such conditions, with such macroeconomic policy in place, and with the stability of the economy that Russia is demonstrating today, it is possible to work and make a profit.

Many are doing just that, and some of our partners, for example, Kirill Dmitriev sitting in front of you, they automatically co-invest with our Russian Direct Investment Fund in any project that our Direct Investment Fund takes on for production and work.

So, when the Direct Investment Fund takes on a project, its partner automatically invests money in any project that the RDIF takes on. What does this indicate? It indicates trust not only in the Fund but also in the Russian economy.

And how much higher is their profit margin compared to usual?

K. Dmitriev: Three to four times.

And the profit margin for such investments in the Russian economy is three to four times higher than in other markets. That’s the result. Do you understand? And that’s concrete work.

As for import substitution. We did this not out of a good life, but it turned out that it’s not so bad. You already mentioned agriculture as an example. Our agricultural production has increased several times. If there are any Russian agricultural producers here, they will stand up and cheerfully tell you: just don’t lift the European sanctions.

Because that would create additional competition in the domestic market of Russia for them. Although internal competition is now developing in place of external competition, and overall it is playing its antimonopoly role quite confidently.

You just mentioned agriculture: our agricultural product export volume in 2013 was just over 13 billion dollars. That seemed a lot to us, very much. In the first ten months of this year – 21 billion in agricultural product exports from Russia. For us, these are decent figures.

We have become the largest country in the world in wheat exports, not grains, but specifically wheat. Other sectors in agriculture have also grown. We currently have the most difficult situation with vegetables. That is also growing, gradually.

Money is needed there for a number of types of vegetables that are not grown in open fields. And that’s it, we have provided these loans, everything is developing. But it’s not just about agriculture.

Look, in the field of transport engineering, 95 or 98 percent of the products are already domestically produced. Previously, you bought a significant part, now we make it ourselves: 98 or 95 percent of domestic production – transport engineering. In the automotive industry – 85 percent. But this is also the result of such deep localization that we agreed upon with our partners, primarily from European countries.

In the field of oil and gas equipment, it’s currently 48 percent, but the process is increasing, and if restrictions are imposed, we will solve this problem and, just like in the field of transport engineering, we will also have domestic products at around 90 percent, if someone wants to close the Russian market with their own hands.

I’m not even talking about military equipment. There we have practically moved away from imports altogether. We are dealing with this regularly, steadily; I monitor it, meeting with representatives of the defense industry and the Armed Forces twice a year for a week. We spend a week in Sochi discussing all current issues, so to speak.

Last year, 600 billion rubles were invested in import substitution programs in total, of which 120 billion rubles came from the state budget. All of this is not bad, as you can see, but we would like to move away from such forms of relationships as quickly as possible and restore a normal mode of economic life and world trade.

M. Henry: My name is Michael Henry, from Boston. Thank you very much for being here with us today.

I have a question. Obviously, you are the most dominant, well-known figure in Russia and in the whole world. I would like to ask, what do you think Russia will look like the day after Mr. Putin leaves the political scene in Russia?

Why are you in such a hurry? I’m not going anywhere for now. But I can tell you this: Russia already feels confident and self-sufficient, but it is open to cooperation with all our partners, including the United States. I hope that this understanding will come someday, and the necessity to solve common tasks and problems will encourage us to work together effectively.

As for how Russia should develop – I just spoke about this both from the podium and now, in response to the question. We have a whole range of national projects. I hope that all of them will be implemented to a lesser or greater extent, but these are large-scale, very ambitious tasks. But if we confidently move along the path of solving them, the country will change for the better.

J. Grapengisser: I would like to ask you about relations with Ukraine, primarily about the incident in Kerch. I would like to know why these ships were seized by the Russian side. Additionally, there will be elections in Ukraine next year. I would like to know if there will be any information and propaganda campaigns from the Russian side? This could lead to increased tension with Ukraine. How do you assess the long-term relationship with Ukraine?

Regarding the incident in the Black Sea. This is undoubtedly a provocation organized by the current authorities, I think, by the current president, ahead of the presidential elections in Ukraine in March next year.

The rating of the current president, in my opinion, is somewhere around fifth place; he has a chance of not even making it to the second round, and therefore something needs to be done to escalate the situation and create insurmountable obstacles for his competitors, primarily from the opposition.

Why do I think this and why am I even sure that this is exactly the case? Look. An incident occurred – I will talk about this separately – in the Black Sea. But this is just a border incident, nothing more. And what happened in 2014 when Crimea decided to join Russia? That is a completely different story – a large-scale one.

Or the serious events of the civil war in the southeast of Ukraine – in Donbas, Luhansk region – with the use of tanks, heavy artillery, and even aviation by government troops. A war, in essence, but no state of war was declared.

And now there is a small incident in the Black Sea, and a state of war has been declared in the country. This is clearly being done ahead of the presidential elections. An absolutely obvious fact!

Now regarding this incident itself, or rather, the provocation. And this is definitely a provocation. Look, in September of this year, a similar caravan of Ukrainian military ships passed through the Kerch Strait, under the Kerch Bridge, into the Sea of Azov.

They fully complied with the agreements and requirements, reported on the composition of their convoy, who was going where. We provided them with a pilot and calmly guided them to their destination in the Sea of Azov.

What happened now? They did not respond at all to the requests of our border service. They entered our territorial waters. I draw your attention to the fact that they entered our territorial waters, which were such even before Crimea joined the Russian Federation. That is, in the place where these territorial waters have always been recognized as Russian territorial waters.

Without responding to our border guards’ requests, they began to move directly towards this bridge. They did not respond to offers to anchor. They did not respond to offers to take a pilot – even after violating our state border, they were still offered to take a pilot – silence, no response at all!

And how should the border guards act? Military vessels invaded the territorial waters of the Russian Federation and are not responding; it is unclear what they intend to do. How should they act? If they had acted differently, they would all have to be put on trial. They fulfilled their military duty, an order; in fact, they were performing their lawful functions to protect the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation.

I think that in your country, they would act exactly the same way; this is an absolutely obvious thing. Moreover, it turned out that among the crew members were two employees of the Security Service of Ukraine, who were actually leading this special operation. And they admitted that they were employees of the Security Service of Ukraine. Clear signs of a premeditated provocation, designed specifically to use this as a pretext to declare a state of war in the country.

This has nothing to do with attempts to resolve relations between Russia and Ukraine. This is a game of escalation, a dirty game within the country aimed at suppressing its political opponents. Sometimes, you know, it’s strange to watch…

In fact, I have gotten used to a lot, but today’s authorities in Kyiv are successfully selling anti-Russian sentiments; they have nothing else left to sell. It seems that whatever they do, they get away with it. If they demand babies for breakfast today, they will probably be served babies. And why not, they will say, they want to eat, there’s nothing to be done about it.

But this is a very shortsighted policy. It will lead to nothing good because it relaxes the current Ukrainian leadership, in such a way that it does not encourage them to engage in normal political work within the country, to conduct a normal economic policy.

There are problems with the economy, social issues are dire, and with finances, they are always standing with a hand out, begging for money from the International Monetary Fund. And someday, they will have to pay it back to future generations! And from the perspective of organizing interaction with neighbors, nothing good is happening either.

As for long-term prospects. No matter who is in power in Kyiv today, the Russian and Ukrainian peoples have always been and will forever remain brotherly, very close peoples. This "political foam" will subside, will recede. And the Ukrainian people will someday evaluate the current leadership, just as the Georgian people evaluated Saakashvili’s activities.

A. Kostin: Colleagues, thank you. We are concluding.

Let’s not end on that note; one more question.

K. Grenville: My name is Christopher Grenville, from TS Lombard. I am also a board member of the British investment company Baring Emerging Europe, which has about 120 million dollars invested, primarily in shares of Russian public companies.

My question concerns the accumulative part of the pension system.

You can stop there. I understand what you mean; I know what you are referring to.

K. Grenville: This is very important for everyone. The decisions of the Government and the Central Bank regarding the scheme, if I’m not mistaken, "individual pension capital," can benefit everyone: future millions of Russian pensioners, companies, issuers of shares, corporate bonds, and other participants in the Russian market, which will become more liquid, less volatile, with better corporate governance, with greater demand for placements, and so on.

It’s been five years without accumulations. We know that the Central Bank and the Government have a plan from the previous panel of our forum. Anton Siluanov mentioned this project; it was nice to hear. But so far, there are no concrete actions. But there is a chance; this is a real project that could be implemented in a year.

Yes, this is a topic that we always discuss as well. We are not closing the topic of pension funds, both private and state. We believe that these funds – their work should be organized in such a way (you just mentioned where these advantages are) that these advantages are clearly felt by those people who contribute their funds to these pension funds, so that nothing falls apart, so that they are managed effectively, so that people feel the benefit of saving in these funds, so that inflationary processes do not affect them in such a way that this money disappears, so that they conduct a balanced, realistic, and effective economic policy. This is related to the necessity of ensuring the interests of citizens of the Russian Federation who trust their money to these pension funds.

As for specific questions related to the continuation of this work, you can discuss them with members of the Government and the Central Bank.

A. Kostin: Pensions – is it a good topic to end the forum?

Pensions will grow. That’s for sure; this issue is resolved.

A. Kostin: Thank you very much.

I think, colleagues, we should say on behalf of everyone gathered: thank you very much, Vladimir Vladimirovich. And I would ask, as we did ten years ago, in the next ten years, please come to our forum, if possible, as regularly.

Are you currently debating with your colleague from Boston?

A. Kostin: No, no, I’m just.

Thank you very much!

Thank you very much for coming.