Meeting of the Valdai Discussion Club

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

3 October 2019 · Valdai Discussion Club annual meeting · Sochi, Russia

Context
Putin addressed the annual Valdai Discussion Club meeting in Sochi on October 3, 2019, speaking on Asia's growing role in global affairs and multipolarity.
Main themes
Rise of Asia in global affairs, multipolarity and world order, Russia-Asia relations, economic growth of Asian states, sovereignty and globalization, cultural heritage of Asian civilizations, international law, geopolitical shifts, integration and regionalism
Duration
~178 min
99th percentile
Words
21,363
99th percentile
Sentences
1,225
99th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.4
24th percentile
Syntax
2.89
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 50%46%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 7%

1,225 sentences in 465 paragraphs

Your Majesty King Abdullah! Esteemed Ilham Heydarovich! Esteemed Kassym-Jomart Kemelevich! Esteemed Mr. Rodrigo Duterte! Friends! Ladies and gentlemen!

I am very pleased to welcome all of you to Sochi for the annual meeting of the Valdai Club. As is customary at this venue, we strive to set aside current political issues, even diplomatic discussions, and aim to reflect, so to speak, "in the long term" – in a historical, cultural, philosophical context, to look into the future and outline its contours.

This time, the organizers have proposed a truly inexhaustible and, I would say, fascinating topic – the East. The role of Asia as the largest and most populous part of the world in global affairs. The relations between Russia and Asian states, which have always been important and held special significance for us, I believe, are of interest to all. And the nature of our, Russian relations with Asia is dictated not only by today's realities but also by history.

India and China, Egypt and Iran, Turkey and Japan, the countries of Central and Southeast Asia – heirs of great ancient civilizations that have gifted humanity with unique knowledge and technologies, achievements in medicine, mathematics, culture, and art.

Among intellectuals and creative individuals, Asia has always awakened special feelings, seeming somewhat mysterious and mystical, renowned as a source of spiritual strength and wisdom, perhaps not always fully understood, but invariably evoking interest.

In Russia, the bright colors of the East have inspired many of our writers, poets, artists, and musicians. I mean Pushkin, Rimsky-Korsakov, Arsenyev, Vereshchagin, Kandinsky, and Roerich. The Russian audience, and not only the Russian one, knows these names.

Today, Asia across its vast expanse from the Maghreb and the Middle East to East and Southeast Asia is reclaiming its natural place in global affairs, commensurate with its great heritage and today's, undoubtedly, immense and growing potential.

The strengthening of the positions of Asian states is evident in all spheres. Especially, of course, in the economy. The region is already forming more than a third of the world's gross product. Living standards are rising, outpacing global averages. The most advanced technologies are being actively implemented. Unprecedented in scope, integration processes and globalization are literally attracting both individual external players and entire neighboring subregions to Asia.

Asian countries, demonstrating impressive examples of progress, while preserving their uniqueness, safeguarding traditions, remembering their roots, and in their movement forward, prove that the principles of state sovereignty do not contradict openness and globalization, that sustainable development is possible based on independence and self-sufficiency, and does not necessarily require renouncing them, that the growing economic and humanitarian potential of a state demands political subjectivity.

It is natural that having effectively and wisely utilized the fruits and benefits of globalization and the technological revolution, and having entered the ranks of economic leaders, Asian states seek to play a more significant role in global politics. This is an absolutely natural process. They advocate their own opinions on key issues of the international agenda, value their independence, and expect that their objectively growing influence will be recognized. In our view, this is fair and fully corresponds to today's and future realities.

By the way, at one time, the so-called awakening of Asia, the national and cultural renaissance of the countries in the region played a huge role in the democratization of international relations. And today it is evident that global problems cannot be solved without Asia. Of course, one can try to do this out of inertia and old memory. But the legitimacy, and most importantly, the practical sense, the value of such solutions claiming to be global and universal, is highly questionable.

The world, largely thanks to Asian states, has objectively become multipolar and, as a consequence, undoubtedly more complex. But multipolarity itself – I have already spoken about this – is not a panacea, nor does it mean that acute issues and contradictions in international relations will be resolved overnight by themselves.

The authors of the annual report of the Valdai Club assert, and we have just heard this, that we have entered an era in which there will be no world order at all. This was just said practically. Yes, indeed, such a scenario is possible. But it harbors many threats, we all understand this. We hope that no matter how difficult relations between states may be, no matter how dangerous legal gaps may be, for example, in the field of nuclear and missile weapons – the world order, based on the key role of international law, will transform but will remain. We will all work to protect it. The other path is undoubtedly fraught with global catastrophes for virtually all of humanity.

Of course, the world system is diverse and complex and at the same time unprecedentedly interconnected. Each has its own objective interests, which do not always coincide with the interests of others, this is also evident. But there is also a sense of common responsibility. Finally, I hope, I do not actually doubt that there is also common sense, a desire for security.

Therefore, a systematic world order is indispensable. But flexibility is undoubtedly needed, and I would add, non-linearity, which would mean not a rejection of the system, but the ability to organize a complex process based on realities, which implies the capacity to take into account different cultural and value systems, the necessity to act together, stepping beyond stereotypes and geopolitical templates. Only in this way can we effectively resolve tasks at the global, regional, and even national levels.

And we have such examples before our eyes. Those of you who attended the Valdai Club meeting in 2015 may remember: practically at that time, the decision was made to begin the Russian operation in Syria. I will say frankly, not everyone, including the experts present in the hall then, believed that this could end positively. On the contrary, they were quite skeptical about it, and many asked questions about why this was necessary, inquired whether we understood what hornet's nest we were getting into, and some foreign partners, I mean, of course, not the experts present, but simply foreign partners with whom we work on the international stage, were also, frankly speaking, trying to interfere and counteract.

But I want to draw your attention to the main thing that was done, and primarily, of course, I mean what was done for our country, as I represent its interests. We dealt a blow to the terrorist international that was practically winning on Syrian territory and prevented the return, the infiltration into our country and into neighboring states, with which we, by the way, have no visa regime, we have transparent borders with them, we prevented the infiltration of hundreds, and perhaps in the future thousands, of armed thugs.

In just a few years, the majority of Syrian territory has been liberated from terrorists, and the level of violence has drastically decreased. Together with partners in the Astana format, with the support of the UN, we managed to launch an intra-Syrian political process, establish close working contacts for this with Iran, Turkey, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, other countries in the Middle East, and with the United States. Esteemed colleagues, agree that such a complex diplomatic arrangement involving very different states, with very different emotions towards each other, was difficult to imagine just a few years ago. But now this is a fact that we have managed to achieve.

And in our view, the Syrian settlement can become a kind of model for resolving regional crises. Moreover, in the vast majority of cases, it will be diplomatic mechanisms that will work. The use of force here is an extreme, forced exception. After all, in Syria, we faced an attempt to create an entire terrorist quasi-state, with a real – I say this without any exaggeration – with a real terrorist army.

Sometimes it seems that many new and chronic, old problems and crises are too tangled, even the approach to them is not defined. But, I repeat, now is the time for extraordinary, non-standard steps and actions. And in the Syrian direction, Russia, together with partners – of course, we could never have done this alone – precisely with partners, adhering to and following the norms of international law, respecting sovereignty, thinking primarily about the lives, safety, and interests of people, has nevertheless accomplished a great deal.

I am convinced that it is on the basis of such approaches that we can address other existing problems in the world, including in Asia. Among them, for example, the situation on the Korean Peninsula, which has long been "in a clinch."

In this regard, I note: as soon as the United States decided to have a direct conversation with the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, without preliminary formalities and conditions, abandoning the usual, sometimes quite rude, even insulting rhetoric, hope for a peaceful settlement immediately emerged.

Of course, we understand and see that there are still many unresolved problems, a long way ahead. But still, there is movement in the right direction. Here we must give credit to the courage and ability for extraordinary steps of President Trump. For many decades, American presidents ignored the DPRK, perceiving it as nothing more than a pariah. Mr. Trump was able to take a historic step, overcome the "demarcation line" of misunderstanding and alienation, meet with Kim Jong-un, and start the negotiation process.

I will repeat once again: it is on the principles of mutual cooperation, respect, recognition of the interests of all parties, and the rejection of various kinds of shackles and bloc philosophy that we need to untangle the most complex conflict knots. Such as, for example, the Palestinian-Israeli, Afghan, and the situation surrounding the Iranian nuclear program.

In this regard, I want to remind you that it is in this logic that Russia presented the Concept of Collective Security in the Persian Gulf region in July of this year. I believe that given the current acute and unpredictable situation in this region, the idea is more than relevant to this day.

We propose to set aside accumulated prejudices, mutual claims, and to attempt to create a security and cooperation organization in this region from a clean slate, in which, in addition to the Gulf states, Russia, China, the USA, the EU, India, and other interested states could participate as observers.

Esteemed participants of the meeting!

The foundation for building equal, future-oriented political relations, including between Asian countries, is undoubtedly economic partnership, which opens real prospects for sustainable and long-term development for all.

As an example, I will cite transport interconnectedness. Without the creation of modern road, maritime, and railway infrastructure, it is impossible to develop trade, industrial cooperation, and establish mutual exchanges in any other spheres. We need to think together about how to accelerate the formation of such a Eurasian transport framework, a true network of latitudinal and longitudinal trade routes.

Undoubtedly, Russia is open to such joint work and is already implementing a number of joint projects here. One of them – the North-South trade route – will pass through our territory from European countries through the Caspian region to Central Asian states, Iran, and India. Another – Europe-Western China – will connect Russian ports in the Baltic with ports in the Yellow Sea.

Another promising route – the Arctic-Siberia-Asia. Its essence is to connect the ports of the Northern Sea Route with the ports of the Pacific and Indian Oceans through Eastern Siberia – the center of Eurasia – via transport highways. To realize this idea, to form the missing links, we intend to accelerate the construction of railway approaches to the port of Sabetta – this is in the far north of Russia, on the Yamal Peninsula – we intend to accelerate and complete the implementation of the entire complex of projects of the "Northern Latitudinal Route," as well as the construction of the railway line Kuragino-Kyzyl, this is the Republic of Tuva in the east of the Russian Federation, with its subsequent connection to the railway network of Mongolia, China, and other states in the region. We are ready to work on this initiative, which has a pan-Eurasian significance, with all interested partners.

In our view, transboundary, transnational transport arteries serve as the key, the stimulus for building relationships based not only on natural competition but also, which is very important, on solidarity. Because if there is no political or economic stability in one of the countries through which the route passes, the entire chain will not work. And therefore, neighbors should naturally strive for each other's prosperity.

It is precisely by adhering to the principles of joint, common progress that we, together with partners, are building the Eurasian Economic Union. This integration association is based on equality, pragmatism, and consideration of each other's interests. At the same time, our union is not a closed market.

The EAEU is actively developing international ties. Agreements on a free trade zone have been concluded with Vietnam; just recently, literally in the past few days, we signed a similar agreement with Singapore. A temporary agreement on a free trade zone has been signed with Iran. Negotiations are underway with Israel and Egypt, and the first round of negotiations with India is forthcoming. The Eurasian Union has concluded an agreement on trade and economic cooperation with China. The implementation of the cooperation program between the Eurasian Commission and ASEAN for 2019-2020 has also begun.

All these agreements are important for forming a large Eurasian partnership with the potential participation of the EAEU countries, the CIS, the SCO, ASEAN, and a number of other states.

One of the "cornerstones" of Greater Eurasia is intended to be the integration of the Eurasian Economic Union project and the Chinese initiative "One Belt, One Road." We have agreed with our Chinese friends to intensify this work.

In bringing all these examples, I want to emphasize a very simple and, in my opinion, obvious thought, namely: building such types of relations between states, based on pragmatism and consideration of each other's interests, is not a matter of good wishes and dreams, nor is it a question of a distant future. It is possible and, moreover, is being realized right now.

Dear colleagues!

Russia, from the very beginning, by the way, of its creation and formation, is a multinational, multi-confessional country. In a certain sense, it is a civilization-state that has organically absorbed many traditions and cultures, preserved their distinctiveness, uniqueness, and at the same time maintained unity, which is very important – the unity of the peoples living in it. We are very proud of this harmony of individuality and common destiny of the peoples of the Russian Federation and we cherish it greatly.

It is obvious to us that diversity within a state is the norm. And it teaches both patience and tolerance in the true sense of these words – as the ability to understand and accept different points of view, traditions, ways of life, rather than imposing one's model as an axiom. We believe that this experience of ours can be useful to many of our partners.

If we talk about the world as a whole, since all states are undoubtedly different, uniformity and universalization are impossible by definition. A system is needed in which different values, ideas, and traditions coexist, interact, and enrich each other while preserving and emphasizing their characteristics and differences.

In the 19th century, in relation to diplomacy, there was a certain image... Here my colleagues – good diplomats – are present, and today, in this sense, I can say that our Minister of Foreign Affairs prompted me, it can be said, that today is MGIMO Day, because among my colleagues are the Presidents of Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan – graduates of MGIMO, and the other two colleagues – President Duterte and the King of Jordan – are honorary professors of the university [MGIMO], which has traditionally been, from the very beginning, the leading university in the field of training personnel for the diplomatic service.

So, in due time, they spoke in the 19th century about the "concert of great powers." Today it is time to talk about a global "concert" of development models, interests, cultures, and traditions, where the sound of each instrument is important, irreplaceable, and valuable. And for the "music" to be played without false notes, without cacophony, but rather to sound harmoniously, it is important to take into account the opinions and interests of all participants in international life. I repeat: it is precisely between independent, sovereign states that truly mutually respectful, pragmatic, and therefore predictable and durable relations can be built.

Russia is sincerely committed to such approaches and implements a positive agenda. We advocate for strict adherence to international law, strengthening mutual trust and respect. We build inter-state relations and communication on fair, democratic principles, focusing on the provisions of the UN Charter.

Our country is focused on strengthening security and stability, combating international terrorism, and other challenges and threats. We are working towards creating – including in Asia – a system of equal and indivisible security based on broad collective efforts.

By the way, in three weeks, right here in Sochi, the Russia-Africa summit will take place, during which we are ready to offer our African colleagues and friends an extensive agenda for equal cooperation covering a wide range of areas: economy, energy, transport, education, and ecology.

And in conclusion, a small digression from the topic, but still related to our main theme. Here is what I want to say: almost twenty years ago, on the eve of the year 2000, my article was published, titled "Russia at the Turn of the Millennium." The analysis made in it at that time regarding the state of the world, the prospects for development, seems to me to correspond to reality as a whole.

Russia indeed went through one of the most difficult periods in its history in the 1990s. Alongside acute domestic political, economic, and social crises, we also faced aggression from international terrorism. Russia approached a very dangerous line at that time, beyond which the worst could happen for any people, any nation, and any country – the collapse and disintegration of the state. This threat hung in the air, and for the most part, people felt it.

We could have, of course, it was absolutely real, plunged into the abyss of large-scale civil war, lost state unity and sovereignty, and found ourselves on the periphery of world politics. And only thanks to the exceptional patriotism, courage, rare patience, and hard work of the Russian people and other peoples of Russia was our country pushed away from this dangerous line.

Over these twenty years, something could certainly have been done differently, better. But we gained a unique experience, and I believe it is in demand in the world. We, along with our colleagues, before entering this hall, discussed one of the most important problems – terrorism.

We still have many unresolved problems in Russia. At the same time, thanks to political stability and the efforts of the entire nation, Russia has not only recovered and continues to strengthen economically and socially, but also confidently occupies a place among the leading, influential, and responsible powers on the planet. Our country fully fulfills its obligations as one of the guarantors of the existing world order. I am confident that this will continue. This will be especially effective if we work together.

Thank you very much for your attention.

V. Naumkin: Thank you, Vladimir Vladimirovich.

Now the floor is given to His Majesty King Abdullah II ibn Al-Hussein of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.

Abdullah II: My dear friends, President Putin, my brothers, the Presidents of Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and the Philippines!

Thank you for the warm welcome. I am glad to be in Russia and to see so many friends, including my friend for almost 20 years, Mr. Putin.

Mr. President, you are a supporter of my region, you support us, and I thank you for your unwavering cooperation and partnership with Jordan.

Today, Russia's role is key in many regions and on many fronts: economy, security, and diplomatic issues, even inter-religious relations, which are so important for our future. And this is of unique importance for the Valdai Discussion Club. You have earned a reputation as a forum where important issues are discussed, but you also open doors for Russian partners. It is a great pleasure for me to join your dialogue today.

In 2009, Jordan hosted the Valdai Discussion Club when we discussed the future of the region. That was ten years ago. And as you know, over the last ten years, we have seen the emergence of new issues to discuss. But some realities have not changed. Jordan and Russia continue to share an understanding of the need for close cooperation to achieve regional and global peace. Russia and Jordan remain committed to the key values that unite us, and we act in their spirit. This is the most important weapon we have against extremism and division. Jordan and Russia continue to strive for peace and stability in the Middle East. There are numerous challenges, but there are also opportunities. We have a role in achieving a new positive world order. This is Jordan's vision, that is, ensuring sustainable growth.

Despite economic difficulties, the stability of our country, mediated by our young active population, has allowed us to establish partnerships with the whole world. Our partners also share key interests in resolving the crisis in the Middle East, countering the terrorist threat, the crisis in Syria, and also the denial of Palestinian statehood. These are not just regional issues; they are issues of global significance.

ISIS has suffered a crushing defeat. A ceasefire agreement has also been reached, and Jordan, together with Russia and the United States, has contributed to stabilizing the situation in Syria.

We continue to bear a certain, significant burden of the influx of refugees, but the situation with refugees remains a costly endeavor. To end this crisis, we need to reach a political solution, preserving the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Syria, and also ensuring the safe and voluntary return of refugees. Jordan supports the Geneva process and also additional measures, especially the Astana process in accordance with UN resolutions. In fact, all this would have been impossible without Russia's role.

Next is the terrorist threat. Regional victories over those who use Islam for their terrorist purposes should not mislead us. In fact, we are talking about the fact that threats also come from Islamophobia. This is a danger that is perceived by every region.

And various initiatives. We are working with various countries from Asia to Africa, from Europe to other countries, so that we can develop a comprehensive approach, an all-encompassing approach. We must ensure that young people have hope and a subject of that hope.

I want to touch on the heart of the crisis in our region – the denial of Palestinian statehood. We all supported the two-state solution. This solution would actually ensure security. If only the Palestinian conflict ends, and it can only end through a two-state solution, only then can we ensure peace in this region in accordance with UN resolutions, only then can we put an end to this conflict.

And in accordance with the borders of 1967 with Jerusalem as its capital, this state could live side by side with Israel in peace and harmony. We are deeply concerned about those who advocate for the preservation of Jerusalem as a capital, valuable to both Muslims and Christians. All this raises certain concerns for us, its future. But all countries bear the responsibility of preserving the heritage of this holy city, so that it becomes a city of unity, a city of peace.

After seven years, it has become clear that peace cannot prevail in this region through violence. It cannot be imposed from above on this land or through the construction of walls. This can only be achieved by ensuring human rights, and the alternative solution is only the two-state solution; otherwise, it will be an undemocratic regime. We need to take more effective measures.

Ten years ago, when Valdai held its first meeting in the Middle East, the theme of the meeting was "The Middle East – 2020: Is a Comprehensive Solution to Conflicts Possible?" And my answer is: yes. Despite all the difficulties, such a comprehensive peace is indeed possible, and not only is it possible, but it is also necessary, but this will only happen with your help. Allow me to wish the Valdai Discussion Club all the best in achieving its goals, and thank you very much for leading us in resolving these key issues.

Thank you very much.

V. Naumkin: Thank you.

Dear colleagues, we have given the floor to our guests. We are moving from west to east, so that the principle by which we give the floor is clear.

Now the floor is given to the next speaker, the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan, Ilham Heydarovich Aliyev. Please.

I. Aliyev: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Esteemed heads of state! Ladies and gentlemen!

First of all, I would like to express my deep gratitude to Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin for the invitation to participate in the next meeting of the Valdai Discussion Club.

I would like to note that Azerbaijan is following the activities of the club with great interest. It has transformed into one of the most important international platforms where pressing issues of the modern world are discussed and recommendations for deepening cooperation are provided.

I listened with great interest to Vladimir Vladimirovich's speech. I agree with him on everything. The only thing he did not mention when talking about the situation that arose in Russia at the turn of the millennium is that the main factor in Russia's honorable exit from the most severe trials is the factor of Vladimir Putin. This is the truth, and everyone should know it. And it is precisely thanks to his courage, determination, wisdom, and patriotism that Russia emerged from the most severe trials and today is a leading world power.

Today we had a meeting with Vladimir Vladimirovich. Our meetings are regular, and even a small break of a few months is already perceived by us as a pause.

The relations between our countries have strategic significance. We do not call each other strategic partners by chance. Today we walked through a very extensive agenda of bilateral relations and outlined paths for further interaction.

There is a very active political dialogue between our countries, and regular meetings of heads of state and other officials contribute to deepening our cooperation. We actively interact within international organizations, traditionally supporting each other on the most important and pressing issues.

At the June session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, where the issue of Russia's return to this organization was discussed, the Azerbaijani delegation voted in full for Russia's return to PACE. And I would like to congratulate our colleagues on this achievement.

There is a positive dynamic in the development of trade and economic relations. We are increasing trade turnover every year. It is becoming increasingly difficult to do this, because last year we are talking about approximately a 20 percent increase, and this year even more. And the definition of priority areas for cooperation within the framework of the five "road maps" will undoubtedly lead to further growth in trade relations.

In Azerbaijan, there are about 700 companies with Russian capital. Azerbaijani investments in Russia amount to 1.2 billion dollars, while Russian investments in Azerbaijan total 4.6 billion. We are lagging behind here, but there are objective reasons for this.

I would also like to note that Russian banks are very helpful to us in the process of industrialization, having allocated loans of nearly one billion dollars for projects in the real sector of the economy.

Military-technical cooperation is actively developing. Today we agreed to continue working in this direction, despite the fact that the contracts recently signed between us for the acquisition of Russian equipment amount to five billion dollars, of which three billion have already been implemented. As I said, we intend to continue working in this direction.

Another important area of our cooperation is the transport sector. In 2018, the volume of cargo transported through the "North-South" corridor was eight times greater than in the previous year. The volumes are still small, but the dynamics are impressive.

I would like to point out that the "North-West" corridor is now operational. Cargo from Russia through the territory of Azerbaijan is directed not only southward but also westward, largely thanks to our agreed tariff policy, and due to the significant investments made in Azerbaijan's modern transport infrastructure recently.

One indicator of our relations speaks most vividly about the spirit and character of the relationships not only between countries but also between peoples. Last year, 880,000 Russians visited Azerbaijan. This year, their number is already higher. And it is no secret that tourists come not only to see the sights and try the national cuisine, but they go where they feel safe, comfortable, and at home. I believe this is precisely the case that illustrates the rapid growth of tourism.

I would like to highlight significant achievements in the field of education. For many years, there has been a branch of Moscow State University in Azerbaijan, as well as a branch of the First Moscow State Medical University. All state universities in Azerbaijan have departments in the Russian language. A total of 25,000 students in our country study in Russian, and 130,000 schoolchildren are also educated in Russian in 338 schools with Russian instruction.

One of the topics of ongoing discussions is the resolution of the Armenian-Azerbaijani Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. Russia is a co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group, which has a mandate to mediate. I must note that for more than 25 years, Nagorno-Karabakh and seven other territories of Azerbaijan have been under Armenian occupation.

Nagorno-Karabakh is historically Azerbaijani land. During the Soviet era, the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast was created. I must say that there is a wide range of opinions regarding the conflict, often not reflecting reality. To clarify, I must state that in 1921, the decision of the Caucasian Bureau was, word for word, to leave Nagorno-Karabakh within Azerbaijan, and not to transfer it, as is often interpreted by the Armenian side.

Before the conflict, the population of the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast of the Azerbaijan SSR consisted of Azerbaijanis and Armenians in a ratio of 25 to 75 percent. As a result of the conflict, all the Azerbaijani population from Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as from seven other regions of Azerbaijan, was expelled. In other words, ethnic cleansing was carried out, and to this day, there is no Azerbaijani population in the occupied territories, and the majority of the occupied territories are scorched earth, with destroyed houses, schools, and public buildings. As a result of the conflict, Azerbaijan faced a humanitarian disaster: more than 700,000 internally displaced persons from Nagorno-Karabakh and other occupied territories of Azerbaijan, plus 250,000 Azerbaijanis who were expelled from their historical lands in present-day Armenia.

The UN Security Council adopted four resolutions, including resolutions demanding the immediate and unconditional withdrawal of Armenian forces from the occupied territories. For more than 25 years, they have not been implemented. Here we come to the important question of the implementation of the adopted decisions. The UN Security Council is the highest international body, and if for more than 25 years the decisions made by the Security Council are not implemented, it raises many questions about the effectiveness of this organization.

We in Azerbaijan are concerned about the selective nature of the implementation of the resolutions. Sometimes they are implemented within days, while at other times they are not required at all for certain military actions; in our case, the resolutions remain on paper. The resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict must be within the framework of Azerbaijan's territorial integrity, as recognized by the entire world, the UN Charter, the UN Security Council resolutions, and the Helsinki Final Act.

I must say that recently the Prime Minister of Armenia has often stated that the resolution of the conflict must be acceptable to the people of Azerbaijan, the people of Armenia, and the people of Nagorno-Karabakh. I must say that the concept of "the people of Nagorno-Karabakh" does not exist. There is a population of Nagorno-Karabakh, which before the conflict consisted of Azerbaijani and Armenian populations with equal rights.

As for what solution is acceptable to Azerbaijan, it consists of restoring Azerbaijan's territorial integrity, recognized by the entire world, the return of refugees and internally displaced persons to their ancestral lands, including Nagorno-Karabakh. This corresponds to the UN Security Council resolutions and the Helsinki Final Act.

I must say that Armenia's military aggression against Azerbaijan continues to this day. Yesterday, an Armenian sniper killed a civilian, a resident of the Gazakh district, located far from the conflict zone, on the border of Armenia with Azerbaijan. I must also say that during the military provocation in April 2016, six Azerbaijani civilians, including a child, a girl, were killed.

I would also like to touch upon the surprising statement made by the Prime Minister of Armenia – a surprise not only in Azerbaijan but also a corresponding reaction was given by the Russian Federation during the Valdai Forum – the statement was almost word for word: "Karabakh is part of Armenia, period." First of all, this is, to put it mildly, a lie. Karabakh is recognized by the whole world – both the plain and the mountainous – as an integral part of Azerbaijan. Armenia itself does not recognize this illegal formation. Karabakh is historical, ancestral Azerbaijani land. So, Karabakh is Azerbaijan, and that is an exclamation mark.

Despite the occupation and the humanitarian disaster of the early 1990s, when every eighth person in our country was a refugee, Azerbaijan has come a long way in development and creation. With the exception of the first years of independence, when the country was ruled by a puppet, anti-people, corrupt regime of the Popular Front, Azerbaijan has lived in a stable environment for 26 years, and the main credit goes to President Heydar Aliyev, who managed to prevent a civil war, stop the occupation, overcome chaos and devastation, and set Azerbaijan on the path of creation. Thus, for 26 years, the Azerbaijani people have lived in conditions of stability and development.

The international positions of our country are strengthening. One indicator of this is the election of our country as a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council several years ago, which was supported by 155 states. It was not easy; it took us three days and 16 rounds. But justice prevailed. I would also like to note that we received significant support from the Russian Federation and all other 154 countries.

We are pleased that Baku has been chosen for several years as the venue for meetings of the top military command of Russia and NATO, and we see this as an expression of trust in us. This month, at the end, a summit of the Non-Aligned Movement will be held in Baku, and Azerbaijan will chair this organization for three years.

In addition to the international agenda, we are primarily focusing on internal issues related to economic growth. In this regard, significant results have been achieved in recent years. Azerbaijan is a country with a low external state debt; in this regard, we rank ninth, with external debt amounting to 17 percent of GDP. For reference, Russia ranks sixth. We are not competitors, but we always aim for the best results.

A great deal of work has been done to reduce poverty, which has decreased from 49 to 5 percent since 2003. Economic growth also allows us to address social issues. This year, the minimum wage has almost doubled, and the minimum pension has increased by 70 percent.

We are investing in modern technologies. About 80 percent of our population are internet users. Azerbaijan is a country with three satellites, two for telecommunications and one for Earth observation.

As a result, I would also like to support the thesis of Vladimir Vladimirovich that transport projects not only contribute to increasing trade but also serve as a bridge between peoples in this regard. The "North-South" and "East-West" projects that pass through our country are indeed steps and projects in that direction, expanding international cooperation and reducing risks.

Thank you for your attention.

V. Naumkin: Thank you very much.

And now I give the floor to the next speaker, the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Kassym-Jomart Kemelovich Tokayev.

K.-Zh. Tokayev: Ladies and gentlemen!

First of all, I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to the President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, for the invitation to such an authoritative forum. The issues of the forum are close to me, as I have spent more than 11 years working in Asia and, of course, observing the evolution of this mega-continent.

As for Kazakhstan, as you know, this country is essentially and geographically Eurasian. Of course, a large part of the territory is located in Asia, but we must not forget that 4 percent of Kazakhstan's territory is located on the European continent, which is about 120,000 square kilometers.

We are located at the crossroads of Islamic, Confucian, and Eastern Christian civilizations. The Great Silk Road, the Golden Horde, and Eurasianism are important links in the cultural code of the Kazakhs. An informed audience such as the current one does not need lengthy discussions on the topic of the Asian century. This is a fact confirmed by the growth rates of population, gross domestic product, trade, industry, and high-tech production.

Sixty percent of the world's population lives in Asia, and 21 of the 30 largest cities in the world are located there. According to estimates, by next year, half of the representatives of the global middle class will be from Asian countries. Today, Asia accounts for 36 percent of global production, compared to 26 percent at the beginning of the 2000s. In 2018, 210 of the 500 largest companies in the world by revenue were Asian. Asian companies today are among the world leaders in digital technologies. In terms of patent applications received, Asian countries far outpace other regions. As a result, the countries of the continent account for more than 50 percent of global GDP growth, stimulating international trade and investment. It is necessary to fully utilize the new opportunities that are opening up. A lot has already been done on this path.

As for Kazakhstan, we have an infrastructure program called "Nurly Zhol," or "Bright Path," which is closely linked to the Chinese "Belt and Road" project, not to mention that we view this program as part of the Eurasian economic space and work in this area in close proximity to Russia.

We reasonably position ourselves as a transit and trade bridge between Europe and Asia. Over the past decades, Kazakhstan has invested more than 30 billion dollars in transport infrastructure. More than two thousand kilometers of railroads have been built, seven thousand kilometers of highways have been reconstructed, and port capacities on the Caspian Sea have increased to 27 million tons. As a result, today, five railway and six road international corridors pass through Kazakhstan. By 2025, we plan to invest an additional 20 billion dollars in transport and logistics projects. We advocate for the openness of our space to new viable transport and logistics solutions.

In the modern world, in addition to the development and sale of natural resources, transport and logistics services are becoming a priority. Kazakhstan plans to receive more than five billion dollars additionally in the budget specifically in this area over the next two years.

You know that Kazakhstan is an active participant in a number of Eurasian structures, including the OSCE, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, and the Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia. Every three years, we hold a congress of leaders of world and traditional religions. This is our modest contribution to the global dialogue between religions and civilizations.

Our first president, Nursultan Nazarbayev, is the author of the idea of Eurasian integration. This year we celebrate the 25th anniversary of its proposal.

Unfortunately, against the backdrop of the positive factors mentioned, there are also trends that are alarming and even intensifying.

First: throughout the East, geopolitical time bombs are scattered, so to speak, in the form of numerous conflict points. I mean the Korean Peninsula, the South China Sea, Kashmir, Afghanistan, Yemen, Syria, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict zone, and the situation around Iran. The intensity of confrontational rhetoric, the intensity of proxy-hybrid wars, and the arms race, including nuclear weapons, have reached a critical point. They are fraught with full-scale cataclysms with severe consequences for the entire world.

Second: this situation is a consequence of a severe deficit of trust and dialogue among the main regional players. We are anxiously observing the revival of the Cold War era. Confrontation, sanctions, distrust – this is a blow primarily to the global economy.

It is appropriate to recall that there have never been solid agreements on borders in Asia. In Europe, however, at one time, they agreed to create the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe based on agreements on the inviolability of post-war borders and the status of West Berlin.

What happened next? Germany was reunified, the Soviet Union collapsed, Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia also disintegrated. Nevertheless, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe not only survived but transformed into the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe. With the accession of Mongolia, the OSCE became truly a Eurasian organization.

As for the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, it is also located in Asia, and in my opinion, I think you will agree, it is an example of successful cooperation and interaction. What is the secret? The secret is that this organization has mutual trust and common goals, as well as a desire to achieve a positive outcome regarding the universal agenda of this organization. Therefore, it is necessary to seek effective formulas against the fragmentation of security in Asia. Today, we see, unfortunately, a "patchwork quilt" of various bilateral alliances, regional and sub-regional institutions. As they say in China, in Asia, people sleep in the same bed but dream different dreams. Therefore, as the chair of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia for the next two years, Kazakhstan intends to intensify contacts with other multilateral institutions.

Third: if the confrontation of the Cold War era was based on ideological motives, today it has been replaced by more practical considerations, cloaked in the form of national interests. This is the promotion of trade interests and the struggle for levers of influence over the future economic order. These interests and levers include breakthrough technologies, artificial intelligence, big data, 5G, the Internet of Things, and so on.

The main arena of confrontation is once again becoming Asia. Here, no one is particularly discerning or fastidious. Methods of sanctions, trade, currency wars, investment restrictions, technological espionage, and brain drain are actively employed.

Fourth: during the 74th session of the UN General Assembly, dedicated to the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals by 2030, pressing issues of climate change were discussed in detail. The rise in global temperatures is leading to accelerated glacier melting, desertification, and soil erosion. In this regard, the focus of confrontation in Asia may shift to the control of freshwater sources. It is well known that this issue is among the potential destabilizing factors in the Central Asian region. In other words, fair distribution of water resources and access to clean water is, in fact, one of the security challenges in the Central Asian region. In this difficult situation, Kazakhstan is betting on consistent joint work with the relevant states in the region and with international organizations to prevent conflict situations. At the same time, we proceed from a sober assessment of our capabilities and international resources.

We continue to work on promoting a businesslike, pragmatic agenda specifically for Central Asia. Central Asia is becoming an important factor, a player in pan-Asian cooperation and security. You know well that it is this region that attracts the interests of the leading states of the world, and here Russia, in my opinion, should play a leading role, because historically Central Asia was part of the Russian Empire. It is quite natural for the long-term presence of the Russian Federation, whether in politics or economics, in this region.

Kazakhstan intends to work constructively within the framework of the Eurasian Economic Union. Despite the difficulties associated with the worsening situation, our integration association is becoming an authoritative economic organization. A clear sign of this is the expansion of the network of trade partnerships of the Eurasian Economic Union from Singapore to Serbia.

Kazakhstan is a proponent of honest mediation in the resolution of regional conflicts. For example, within the framework of the Astana process, 13 rounds of intra-Syrian negotiations have already taken place, where the positive role of the Russian side is absolutely evident and cannot be questioned. The Syrian issue is an element of the overall dismal situation in the Middle East. Therefore, from the podium of the UN General Assembly, I expressed my readiness to support efforts to find viable solutions for this region, based on Kazakhstan's international resources.

We pay close attention to Afghanistan and provide the necessary assistance. In recent months, the situation there has unfortunately seriously deteriorated. We hope that the intra-Afghan process, with the assistance of all interested parties, will bring the long-awaited peace to this country.

Kazakhstan has always been and remains a proponent of preventive diplomacy and disarmament. The Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia can play a useful role, having proven its relevance as a platform for developing collective approaches to security issues. I believe it is time to think and discuss the issue of transforming this forum into an organization. Achieving a world free of nuclear weapons remains a key priority of my country's foreign policy. We have come a long way to global leadership in nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation. We intend to continue this work.

It is well known that the risks of modernity are interconnected. Without a comprehensive solution to the multifaceted security challenges, the Asian economic miracle may turn out to be a colossus with feet of clay. Without collective efforts, instead of an Asian age of prosperity, we may face an Asian time of troubles with dire consequences for the entire globe.

Building an effective security architecture in the East is impossible without interaction with the West. Kazakhstan has repeatedly proposed to establish interaction between the Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia and the OSCE to harness the potential of these forums for a good cause.

The main element, in my opinion, of our collective work in our region can be the fight against terrorism, extremism, organized crime, illegal migration, and drug trafficking. The constructive agenda can include: the development of human capital, the implementation of best practices in public administration, the enhancement of innovative potential, and the effective and rational use of water resources.

And in conclusion, I would like to say a few words about Russia. Russia, in my opinion, is a great state. No one can deny the fact that in the modern world, without the constructive participation of Russia, no key problem, whether global or regional, can be resolved. In this, of course, the key credit goes to the President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin.

Today we held bilateral negotiations. We reaffirmed our desire and intention to develop strategic partnership and allied relations. I assure this audience that on the part of Kazakhstan, we will consistently fulfill our obligations under bilateral agreements, as well as agreements that we have signed within the framework of integration processes.

Thank you for your attention.

V. Naumkin: Now, allow me to give the floor to the last speaker, the President of the Republic of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte.

R. Duterte: Esteemed President Putin! Heads of state! Participants of the Valdai Discussion Club! Distinguished guests! Ladies and gentlemen! Hello!

For nearly two decades after the end of the Cold War, the foreign policy of the Philippines has hardly changed – Russia remained somewhere on the periphery of our diplomacy. And I believe this was a strategic oversight, a result of bureaucratic inertia, blind adherence to old principles, and an inability to seize the winds of change and take advantage of new opportunities. Of course, the Philippine state and people deserve better. When I became president in 2016, I promised to rectify this situation.

In 2017, I came to Russia for the first time, although I had to cut my visit short. I am convinced that our relations are developing positively, but I had to return home because the city of Marawi on the island of Mindanao was attacked and became a site of violence.

We intend to continue this path, and that is why it is a great honor and pleasure for me to come to Russia for the second time. I want to thank President Putin for reaffirming the commitment to reliable cooperation between Russia and the Philippines.

I am also grateful to the Valdai Discussion Club for the great honor of speaking before you and discussing a topic of utmost importance to all of us. When we discuss the world order and changes in global politics today, we are talking about justice and equality, about a stable world order.

The liberal world order established after World War II was essentially Pax Americana. And today it is facing problems. As the 21st century began, the legitimacy of this world order is being questioned, it is weakening, and its influence on countries is declining.

There are several factors that can explain this situation. First and foremost, we are talking about exceptionalism and double standards, which are repeatedly manifested by the proponents of this current world order. The great Russian writer Leo Tolstoy wrote: all happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way. The same can be said about countries.

Developing countries like the Philippines, with their own histories, face their own unique challenges and problems that require their own solutions. And so-called friends begin to behave as if they know all the answers to our problems and impose certain socio-economic and political conditions.

They create rules and norms for practically everyone. Yet they do not always follow them themselves. Take the issues of the Paris Agreement on climate change. Even the issue of human rights is used as a tool, and they do not notice the consequences for those people they are trying to protect.

Look at what is happening in Libya and Iraq, at the chaos and instability following military intervention in these countries. Some of our partners sometimes criticize my government for using too much force in the fight against drugs. They try to justify their own prejudices and do not want to understand what is really happening in our country. Is this how friends treat each other?

They withdraw from defense contracts, assuming that we are supposedly ready to use weapons to violate human rights, while the same countries supply modern weaponry to parties that have shown complete disregard for human rights, and their achievements in this area leave much to be desired.

We are trying to protect our republic and defend ourselves from those who want to tear it apart. We are fighting against criminals, crime that undermines the structure of governance. We are merely trying to defend ourselves against those who may encroach upon our territorial integrity.

Do not all countries have the right to such protection? Do democratically elected governments not have the right to this? And this weakens the government's ability to protect law-abiding citizens from criminals, limits our ability to stop the vicious cycle of internal conflicts and developmental lag. They clip our wings, weakening us, complicating our ability to change anything for our people.

Let me ask you this: in what universe can this be justified? Of course, in some self-sufficient "bubbles" of certain societies, where luxury comes first, it may be different. But we are tired of these crusades, and it is time to challenge them.

I want to be very clear: I am not against the United States or the West. The United States is a close friend of the Philippines, our only treaty ally. We have deep ties with the American people. We share a common history and common values. Of course, America can offer a lot.

And I want to emphasize again: I am not against liberalism in politics and economics. Liberalism, in my view, is the best path to a just society. And for emerging democracies like the Philippines, there is no better alternative than a philosophy that celebrates the freedom and dignity of the individual.

We are not against the current world order; we are against the actions of certain subjects of international law that violate the very principles that underpin this world order.

The Philippines does not demand any special treatment from its partners; we do not seek any exceptions to the rules and principles that have supported peace in the world for many decades. We strive, in my opinion, for the same things that the Russian people and other nations strive for: justice, equality, and mutual respect.

We want the world order to be based on certain rules, where both small and large countries are equal and treated the same. We want unrestricted freedom guaranteed by the Constitution, including the right to govern our country as we see fit. We want to maintain friendship, and we want our friends and partners to respect our independence in making sovereign decisions, just as we respect their corresponding rights.

The principle of respect for state sovereignty, non-interference, and peaceful resolution of disputes must be upheld at all times; otherwise, the world order collapses. This is especially important today, as we watch the power of new countries begin to rise while the strength of some other countries declines.

Today, we also face geopolitical challenges. I have three years left in my term, and we want to make efforts in Philippine diplomacy to engage more closely with Latin America, Africa, and Central Asia. It is time for the Philippines to look at the Middle East with fresh eyes, to see it not only as a source of oil or a destination for migrants from the Philippines.

The Philippines must also take responsibility for the development of its own country and for helping other developing countries on their path to progress. We will strengthen our economic ties with these regions, open new markets, and ensure the free exchange of ideas, technologies, and innovations.

It is necessary for the horizons of the Filipino people to expand, so that we enrich our cultural traditions with what the American continent, Central Asia, the Middle East, and so on can offer. There is no place for isolationism in the modern world. We must collectively embrace a common destiny if we want to overcome the existential threats that exist today.

But please remember: while we recognize the independence of other countries, we also value our own independence. Openness and cooperation without preconditions is the answer to the serious threats we face today, from terrorism to climate change, from migration issues to the refugee crisis, from epidemics to the use of vital resources. This multifaceted problem is important, and it affects international identity and sovereignty.

We have no choice but to act together for survival and prosperity, rather than using these issues to maintain the status quo, where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, which is exactly what some wealthy countries want. We want to help each other. If we strive for sincere cooperation, we must choose development and environmental protection.

We must also remember to maintain diversity and uphold national identity, to respect certain rights and maintain order in our countries. These seemingly contradictory goals will help us solve problems. It is in this context that the UN must strengthen global efforts towards constructive solutions that will help us address our complex local issues.

But this must be done while adhering to the rules, principles, and ideas that are necessary not only for individuals but for entire countries. And those countries that choose non-alignment must also have their voice. We want our voice to be heard, especially on issues that are important to all. And we must act together.

Your Majesty! Your Excellency! Ladies and gentlemen!

We need a stable world order. In our time of fluctuations, we must expand our own self-perception to include others and use persuasion rather than coercion to follow the path of peace, in order to respond to the aspirations of our peoples. We only wish for peace for all humanity.

Thank you very much for your attention.

V. Naumkin: Now, allow me to move on to questions. And I will take the liberty of being the first.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, you vividly described the successes that Russia has achieved in the fight against terrorism in Syria. The war is now practically over, and the situation is stabilizing. But what should be done next regarding the Syrian issue?

We have answered this question many times or questions of a similar nature.

Military actions, large-scale, I want to say, because local pockets of terrorism still remain, but large-scale hostilities have indeed ended. And with military actions, no matter what result is achieved, a final solution cannot be reached.

Therefore, we now need to address the issues of political settlement, which we are persistently doing. In any case, we are creating conditions for the most profound issues to be resolved through political means.

We have done a lot to form the Constitutional Committee, the idea of which, by the way, was born here in Sochi during a large-scale event that involved both representatives of the Government and practically all opposition forces.

The Syrians themselves agreed to create a Constitutional Committee for the possible adoption of a new Constitution or amendments to the existing Constitution. Then there was quite a long period of forming this committee.

I must say that we and our Iranian partners, Turkish partners, made tremendous efforts to finally have it formed. And now we are expecting the start of this constitutional process, the work of this committee in Geneva under the auspices of the UN.

V. Naumkin: Now questions for His Majesty King Abdullah bin Al-Hussein.

Your Majesty, you are a direct descendant in the male line of the Prophet Muhammad in the 42nd generation. Could you share your perspective on the problem of international terrorism and extremism, considering that extremists often hide behind the name of the Prophet, claiming that they are fighting for the true faith, embodying his teachings? What could you say about this?

Abdullah II: I believe I have openly stated several times that we are witnessing a kind of third world war, but in a different form. This is a challenge that will require us the next ten years to overcome.

And we are observing a kind of civil war not only within the Islamic world. But we are united not only by Syria or Iraq, Libya, where there are problems. Organizations like Al-Shabaab, for example. We are working with our colleagues in the Philippines, and there are problems in Europe.

To solve this problem, it is necessary for all religions to unite together. And there is a principle that unites all monotheistic religions: love God and love your neighbor. President Putin and I have long talked about how we – religions and peoples – can come together to fight against this scourge. And of course, there is another challenge – Islamophobia, which also threatens all of us.

Rational people around the world know that we must unite and develop these common principles. I ask myself this question: can we solve this problem together? How will we unite to overcome this problem? So far, the world, it seems to me, has not fully realized the scale of the problem, and this is problematic, of course.

And lastly – Jerusalem. For Muslims, Christians, and Jews, Jerusalem should unite us as a symbol of the problem that lies before us and will remain for the next ten years. And therefore, I am very pleased with the role that President Putin personally and Russia play in strengthening the connection between Christians and Islam in protecting Christians in the Islamic world.

And of course, Russia and the Russian Orthodox Church play an important role in this process, uniting and promoting rapprochement.

V. Naumkin: Now a question for President Aliyev.

Integration projects in the economy involving our countries, including the trade route "North-South," the transport corridor "North-West" you mentioned, create unique prerequisites for establishing a regional security system.

How do you see the parameters of such a system from Baku, and to what extent do Russian-Azerbaijani security ties contribute to its construction?

I. Aliyev: Certainly, these issues are interconnected, and I mentioned in my comments that transport projects not only create opportunities for shippers or additional income for transit countries, but they also make countries interdependent.

Any transit country must have good relations with its neighbors; otherwise, this transit simply will not happen. And regarding Azerbaijan, we have long invested both in the creation of modern transport infrastructure and in creating an atmosphere of trust in our region.

I believe that through the joint efforts of partner countries, we have managed to create a unique format of cooperation that today serves the purpose of enhancing the well-being of our peoples, as well as strengthening security. Interdependence and complementarity, I believe, are one of the important factors of stability and security in international practice as a whole.

Azerbaijan has invested significant funds in transport infrastructure. We have commissioned the largest trading port near Baku. Railways connect us with three of our neighbors, and roads also contribute to increasing cargo flow.

Geographical location, of course, depends on the geopolitical situation; it can be both positive and negative. I think it is the task of every government to transform its geography positively. I believe we have succeeded in this.

Azerbaijan is an active participant in the "One Belt, One Road" project and participated as the only country in the South Caucasus in the conference in Beijing this April. We are also an important partner in the "North-South" project.

And Azerbaijan is the only country that participates in both the "East-West" corridor and the "North-South." I said today that we are also pleased that the "North-West" corridor is already operational. Thus, these projects will naturally contribute to strengthening regional security.

As for the second part of your question, how relations between Russia and Azerbaijan contribute to strengthening security, I think it is enough to look at our region to see that in a raging sea of clashes, chaos, civil wars, conflicts, and religious extremism, Russia and Azerbaijan are countries with a stable socio-political situation and countries that closely interact, including in the fight against international terrorism and extremism.

Both Russia and Azerbaijan are Caucasian countries. Naturally, we are united by the Caucasus, we are united by the Caspian. I must note that the signing of the Convention on the Legal Status of the Caspian Sea in August last year in Aktau played a significant role in strengthening security and cooperation. Thus, Russian-Azerbaijani relations have long gone beyond bilateral, becoming an important factor of stability in our region.

V. Naumkin: The next question is for President Tokayev.

Your country is situated between two major powers – Russia and China. You mentioned your participation in the process of linking your projects with the "One Belt, One Road" project. You mentioned your active role in the development of Eurasian integration.

So you are simultaneously involved in projects promoted by both Russia and China. How do you manage to harmonize your relations with these two major countries?

K.-Zh. Tokayev: This is quite natural.

As you said, Kazakhstan is located between the largest Asian states. The length of the border with China is 1,700 kilometers. As for Russia, we have the longest land border in the world.

Therefore, speaking about our infrastructure program and the Chinese megaproject "One Belt, One Road," as well as the Russian Federation, which is developing its own programs, I think we can talk not only about harmonization but also about the synergy of these projects.

All of this is beneficial for Kazakhstan, as without our country's participation, the Chinese megaproject "New Silk Road" is essentially unfeasible. And it is quite understandable, and not coincidental, that Chairman Xi Jinping first announced the concept of the Great Silk Road in Kazakhstan in 2013.

We believe that this concept, when linked and subsequently synergized, is absolutely beneficial for our country. In my speech, I provided figures: in 2018, an additional three billion dollars flowed into the budget. We expect an increase in revenues from participation in this megaproject.

Overall, in the modern world, the extraction and sale of natural resources certainly occupies a prominent place, but in the very near future, transport and logistics may very well take the lead in terms of revenue.

It is transport and logistics that will ensure the prosperity of the respective states, as they will contribute to the development of industry, and most importantly, they will promote the development of small and medium-sized businesses in the involved states. Therefore, Kazakhstan will continue to increase efforts to participate in these megaprojects.

And regarding the Eurasian Economic Union, in my speech, I said that this is also a very important integration association that, in principle, harmonizes, naturally harmonizes with the concept of the "Silk Road."

V. Naumkin: And finally, a question for President Duterte.

Mr. President, you mentioned that the United States is your traditional ally. At the same time, we see that your country has fundamentally restructured its system of foreign relations from a nearly one-sided orientation towards that country to a multilateral system, in which Russia has taken, as we see, a significant place. You have also managed to improve and strengthen your relations with China. How do you manage to do all this?

R. Duterte: First of all, we were a colony of Spain, then under the rule of the United States. We were under Spanish rule for three hundred years, and then for almost a hundred years under the United States. All of this is in the past, and we are ready to determine our own destiny.

For many years, I saw that the foreign policy of the Philippines always followed the wake of the Americans. And then we could not simply, for example, turn to communist countries to establish trade or economic relations; no, the American government would look very, very unfavorably on all of that.

And at some point, I was confused; I did not know where to look, whom to turn to; I had no contacts. And, to be honest, I did not even think that I would come to power, that I would be able to win. I was in fourth place a week before the elections. But then suddenly my rating jumped up, and I achieved a significant victory. I was striving for something that could give us not just one single country.

Yes, of course, we received some good things from the United States, and some not so good – products and assets that were provided to us, but mostly everything we received came from NATO. For example, we bought three aircraft, two of which crashed almost immediately and were lost. In addition, we were constantly criticized for human rights violations, for instance, from the United States Congress, such criticism was voiced.

You know, let's say, the United States of America itself told us that if we are not careful, our country will simply be engulfed by the drug problem. This was said to us by two presidents ago. And mayors of cities, heads of local organizations – all of them faced this problem.

And when I finally came to power, I even learned that nine generals were involved in drug trafficking. In other words, I came to power and began to fight not only against corruption but also against drug trafficking, and I had to fight these two problems even within the government itself. And therefore, I needed to do something radical.

Some claim that my statements incite people to kill drug lords. Frankly, I would be glad if that were happening. I established a rule when I became President. To be honest, I adhered to this rule while serving as mayor for 21 years.

I said back then, when I was still mayor, that I wanted to make the city safe, comfortable, where one can live freely. And I told the police: ask your wives, children to walk the streets at night, if they can return home safely – that would be wonderful.

That is how it should be, they should feel safe. They should not become victims of robbery, violence, as very often happens. I said that this is the goal, this is the environment I strive for.

And so I ask the international community: is there anything wrong with the President saying that he is appealing: do not destroy my country, otherwise I will destroy you! I said this to the armed forces and the police. I will tell you, I flew here and learned that two more generals are still involved in what I was talking about.

I repeat, I have already made an appeal, I said: do not destroy my country. Many families simply stop functioning because of this problem. It only takes one drug addict in a family for the entire family to collapse, to be disorganized from a social point of view. Of course, this requires decisive measures.

Meanwhile, human rights defenders accuse me of killings. These people, the human rights defenders, they protect, one could say, the corpses of these drug dealers, drug couriers. They wonder why they were destroyed, despite the evidence of their crimes.

For example, one of the mayors cooperating with drug traffickers was killed. And do you know that instead of wallpaper, money was simply glued to the walls inside?

And I said back then: I warned you, do not do this, do not engage in such activities, otherwise I will destroy you. And I appeal to the armed forces and law enforcement agencies, I ask them to destroy the system that supports drug trafficking. Of course, if they are in danger, if it is either them or the lives of drug traffickers, of course, I tell them that they must shoot, because their lives are also at risk.

The drug problem is everywhere for us, yet human rights defenders still do not see that something is going wrong. The criminal network must be dismantled. If you have to kill in the process – well, then it must be done. I take full responsibility for all the consequences of this drug war. And only I bear this responsibility.

And if someone needs to be hanged, then I will volunteer, I will even put the noose around my own neck. I think that the main thing is to restore normalcy. It would be an honor for me to die in this struggle. But I do not aspire to that. I am just an ordinary citizen, a government worker, and I will do everything necessary to protect my country. This is what I have faced: they have always threatened me that they would put me on the gallows, but I am ready for that.

In our country, judges are independent and prosecutors do not communicate with them. And if there are problems, I said: I will take responsibility for everything, but you nevertheless need to deal with this.

However, we still had a problem of corruption that was destroying the very foundations of justice. I said that I would fight not only against criminals and drug lords, I had to fight against the employees of my own government and against the corruption that thrived there.

I can tell you that drugs do not lead to prosperity. And only the police and the army can allow drug dealers to feel free in the country. I tell them that they should not do that.

If you, for example, have been to the Philippines, do not just look at organized crime, you better look at those families that have suffered losses and can no longer function, you better look at them, think about them.

If you have a drug addict in the family or someone in the family, a daughter or son, who uses drugs, then that is a tragedy. But for some reason, they think about the rights of criminal drug dealers.

I do not have a universal right to destroy families. I do not allow our army to exceed its authority. But I think that drug dealers and drug addicts will only become a threat to you when you feel a threat to your own life, so shoot first before you are killed. Because if I am at the crime scene, if I see that you have been killed, then I will hit you again, because you acted foolishly. Do not allow yourself to be weak.

Indeed, this problem worries me, the government.

I can only speak for two minutes. I would like to ask for another two minutes for my speech.

We have a problem with insurgents, and many soldiers of our army have died, and the rifles have been fired so many times that they no longer function properly, they have lost their combat qualities.

I wanted to buy 24,000 M-16s for my police in the USA. And one congressman stood up and said: do not sell this weapon to the Philippines, especially to this mayor, because he will use these rifles to kill the citizens of the Philippines, his subordinates. And this is indeed a paradox.

And I would ask the U.S. Congress: please, first understand the situation, you have the CIA. Even now, there are CIA officers present here listening to us. I think there is no problem conveying your message to the higher echelons.

Before you accuse someone, you need to conduct an investigation. And before you make any conclusions, let us speak. This is a divine right given to every person, wherever you live, in an autocracy, under tyranny – every person has the right to be heard. This is a basic human right.

The U.S. did not supply us with these rifles, they stopped supplies during the uprising in Marawi. I was here then, in Russia, and I wanted to discuss trade, economic issues. I had many meetings scheduled, but that schedule fell through. The President had just flown to Moscow specifically to meet with me. And it took five months for the situation to fully normalize.

This only happened when Russia and China supplied us with the necessary weapons, very high-quality weapons. And now we can fight from long distances, and there is no need to approach the enemy closely. This weapon can shoot two kilometers, there is no need to get close. And this is indeed very good weaponry. And this is the path we are taking.

I also tried to buy helicopters. I looked into the possibility of purchasing such helicopters from South Korea, Russia, and Israel. They said: no, buy from us. And when "Canadian Helicopters" made me an offer, but said that I could not use these machines against my own citizens, I told them: listen, idiots, I am buying these helicopters to kill insurgents, I want to arm my army and my police. They wanted to sell me these helicopters and said that I could not arm them, but use them only for transportation, for example, for humanitarian missions or for transporting wounded soldiers.

But these insurgents are rising up because they want to overthrow the government. And there were both ISIS militants, and we really tried to defeat them, they were blowing up churches in our country, they were blowing up military camps. I do not know who they were, but they looked like white people, I do not know what their racial background was.

F. Lukyanov: Mr. President, I am not a very polite person. I am sorry to interrupt you, but perhaps we can continue the discussion and then return to you.

R. Duterte: Yes, two minutes have already passed. One more minute, please.

In conclusion, I want to say that this is indeed a serious problem in the Philippines. But I want to say that, despite all this, they say that terrorists have a religion. But religion does not play a major role in this issue.

I want to invite the Russian Orthodox Church, missionaries, to come to the Philippines and perhaps establish their Orthodox Church there instead of that religion. There is already a church there, it was built in 1922, then it was destroyed.

V. Naumkin: Excuse me, Mr. President, there is still a minute left, but it is already coming to an end.

R. Duterte: I would like to talk about freedom of religion. Unfortunately, I will have to finish, because otherwise I am taking too much of your time.

I am not a killer. Some say so. But you all are engaged in killings. And I have not killed anyone yet. However, I often say "I will kill you," but that is just exaggeration, of course. I have not killed anyone yet.

Do I still have half a minute?

V. Naumkin: We have questions from the audience.

R. Duterte: Okay. I will be happy to answer these questions.

V. Naumkin: Thank you.

Now let’s move on to questions from the audience.

Who would like to ask a question, please state to whom you are asking the question, and introduce yourself if possible. I see many hands here, but I think our friend Dr. Nandan from India was first. Please, go ahead.

N. Unnikrishnan: I am from India. I want to thank you for giving me the opportunity to ask a question.

My first question is to President Putin.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, the world is going through very big problems after the end of unipolarity. And during this process of transition to a new world order, various new concepts arise: Eurasia, Greater Eurasia, and so on.

And there is one concept that encompasses the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean, called the Indo-Pacific. Many say that this concept was developed by the U.S. to contain China, although Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently said that this is not the case and the Indian Indo-Pacific concept is completely different, it is a completely open system, any countries can join.

What is your opinion on this concept?

You see, there are already different interpretations of this concept. May I speak about our concept? Our concept is to avoid creating new blocs like Europe or North Atlantic after World War II.

Today, in Asia, I think the central organization is ASEAN, after all, and the structure of various organizations and platforms around this central organization ASEAN. There is "ASEAN+1" and so on, the meeting of defense ministers of ASEAN countries.

If a network structure of various organizations and their interaction is created, then it can be called whatever you want.

But if there is an attempt to create some bloc organizations, in my opinion, first of all, this is alien to Asia in general and to the current state of affairs in Asia. Secondly, and this is unlikely to succeed, because I know the mood of many of our friends in Asia: they do not want to join any blocs against anyone. They want to create a network situation of cooperation in various directions, and as I said in my speech today – in order to seek compromises, find them, and move forward together, taking into account each other's interests. They do not want to be involved in confrontations between any states, and even more so, they do not want to participate in any blocs. That is the first part.

The second, regarding attempts to contain China. I think that this is, by definition, impossible. And if someone attempts to do so, he – the one who will do it – will understand that it is impossible, and in the course of these attempts, he will undoubtedly cause himself harm and damage.

In any case, I consider such a possible development of events to be destructive and harmful, while uniting efforts to create an atmosphere of friendly cooperation and seeking common security systems for all is what we should work on together, including, of course, one of the closest countries to us in the world, and especially in Asia – India.

V. Naumkin: Thank you.

Now, I think Mr. Galib, please, you. And then, perhaps, prepare from this side. I saw several hands, I will choose. Let’s go to you later. Okay? Get ready.

G. Dalai: Hello!

My name is Galib Dalai.

I want to ask my question to President Putin. In your speech, you talked a lot about the Syrian settlement and the Persian Gulf. Recently, you even presented a concept of collective security in this gulf.

One of the root causes of instability is the rivalry between Iran and Saudi Arabia. How does Russia intend to solve this problem, especially in light of the fact that previous attempts have ended in failure?

And, secondly, do you see a possibility of a connection between reducing tensions in the gulf and the Syrian settlement? Is there such a connection?

Let’s start with the second part of your question. There is such a connection, in my opinion. Because the confrontation between the largest and most influential countries in the region cannot but reflect on the entire complex of the situation in this region of the world, including the situation in Syria.

And I know that both the leadership of Saudi Arabia, where I am going for a visit in the near future, and the leadership of Iran – we are in constant contact with our Iranian partners, I literally met with the President of Iran just a few days ago – they want good and peace for the Syrian people.

And we urge them, guided by this noble impulse, to do everything to not use the territory of Syria as a platform for confrontation. And I very much hope that when and if this understanding comes and our partners act in this way, they will see that besides confrontation there is also the possibility of cooperation to achieve common goals.

But, in my opinion, there are also other motivating factors to change the situation between Saudi Arabia and Iran and to move from confrontation to interaction. Because in both cases, the first and second countries sometimes face common threats: radicalism, separatism, and terrorism. There are common goals, and above all, these are development goals.

You asked how Russia intends to overcome these disagreements? Russia cannot overcome this. Only our friends in Saudi Arabia and Iran can do that. We can only facilitate this, create conditions, and offer various options for solving the problem. But the solution is up to Saudi Arabia and Iran.

V. Naumkin: Please, we give you the floor.

Lan Jing: Thank you very much. I also have a question for President Putin.

I came from the East. My question relates to what was said by my colleague from India.

Prime Minister Abe presented the concept of an open Indo-Pacific strategy. The goal, the idea is interconnectedness. That is why I am very pleased to hear that you mentioned this interconnectedness in your speech, Mr. President.

The Japanese approach is mainly focused on economic connectivity, which is a somewhat different approach. Russia is a major player in the Indo-Pacific region, particularly strengthening its ties with India.

And therefore we are also waiting for the Russian side to present such an Indo-Pacific strategy, because France has already even presented one. So do you have a vision of such a Russian Indo-Pacific strategy?

You say: even France has presented one. I do not understand such a remark. Why "even"? France is a great power, a permanent member of the Security Council. It thinks globally and offers global solutions to global problems. There is nothing surprising about that.

As for Russia, I can clarify our position once again. Look: Japan proposes an Indo-Pacific development strategy. Russia and other countries are actively developing contacts within the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, which has proven itself very well.

It started its work with rather primitive tasks, solving simple tasks – border demarcation after the dissolution of the Soviet Union with China. Everything went very well, and we moved on. Now new members are appearing there and many countries in the region want to join the work of this organization.

The Chinese project "One Belt, One Road" has already been mentioned here. We also talked about the Eurasian Economic Union. All of this is very close to each other in spirit and objectives. And we see that all of this is feasible and compatible.

In my opinion, if we combine the efforts of various already established structures, organizations, even concepts, and create such a network structure for the interaction of all these directions and already existing structures, then we can come to what I have repeatedly talked about – a large Eurasian partnership.

Should it be institutionalized in the near future? In the near future, hardly. But creating favorable conditions for cooperation is quite possible. Then we can develop some forms and formulas for joint behavior and organizational cooperation.

But if we strive for such democratic interaction, taking into account each other's interests and respecting each other's peculiarities, then I think we will achieve the necessary result for all of us in terms of development.

V. Naumkin: Please do not be offended if I may not be able to give the floor to everyone. But we will try.

Now Sergey Luzianin.

S. Luzianin: Sergey Luzianin, Institute of the Far East of the Russian Academy of Sciences.

Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

We all know that this year is a jubilee year for us and for China, 70 years since the establishment of the People's Republic of China, 70 years since the establishment of diplomatic relations between our countries. We have already congratulated our Chinese friends and partners within the framework of the Valdai Club.

Our partnership has reached a very high level. In this regard, the question is: what opportunities, which are already successfully being implemented within the framework of the partnership, do you see as beneficial for both countries? And what areas of our partnership? Perhaps, there is still not a complete alignment or, for objective reasons, not a fully complete format of cooperation, what we need to do. That is, successes and what could be the opportunities for the future.

Thank you.

As for successes, they are obvious. First of all, we have an unprecedentedly high level of trust and cooperation. These are allied relations in the full sense of a multifaceted strategic partnership. This is reflected in the economy.

We are increasing trade turnover at an accelerated pace. As you know, last year it reached 108 billion dollars, although we planned to achieve this in a couple of years. Now we will move towards the mark of 200 billion.

The structure is diversifying. Yes, of course, over 70 percent from our side are energy resources and so on, but that is natural. We have this product, and China needs this product. This does not mean that we are not engaged in other productions, other areas of economic cooperation.

We have already built four blocks of the Tianwan nuclear power plant, this is high-tech cooperation, and we are also working on four more blocks. This is a serious, large, simply colossal volume of work.

We are working on a wide-body long-haul aircraft, on a heavy helicopter. And all of this will be done, I have no doubt. We are actively working in space, expanding in agriculture. We cannot even meet China's needs, say, for soybeans. They are ready to buy from us as much as we can produce, but we are not ready for that ourselves.

So, partially answering your question: where have we not yet worked enough? We could have set up, and I apologize for the simplicity of the expression, our agrarians could have earned on this. But we are not yet capable, we are not ready for such a volume: there are no prepared areas and the corresponding investments have not been made.

We will continue to work in the field of space, in the field of military-technical cooperation. I do not know, I probably will not reveal a big secret, it will become clear anyway: we are currently helping our Chinese partners create a missile attack warning system. This is a very serious thing that will fundamentally enhance the defense capability of the People's Republic of China. Because now only the USA and Russia have such a system.

We are very closely and deeply engaged in humanitarian cooperation. I will not list everything now.

And regional interaction is at a very high level. I am not even talking about the infrastructure that is developing, joint infrastructure, but the border provinces of China and the corresponding subjects of the Russian Federation in the Far East interact very well with each other. Therefore, this is a whole complex, a set of interactions.

At the same time, I want to emphasize this especially, we have never done and do not do what? We do not befriend and do not work together against anyone. We always work positively, in the interests of each other.

F. Lukyanov: Vitaly Vyacheslavovich, can I make your job a little easier at least?

We understood when we prepared that there would clearly be more questions than opportunities, so we collected and grouped some questions in advance at the Valdai Club. I will just ask some of them then occasionally to save time.

You have talked a lot about this topic, but nevertheless, it seems there is still demand. Over the past year, there have been a number of events in the field of nuclear stability, they are quite diverse. On the one hand, the United States withdrew from the INF Treaty, there has been a lot of discussion on this topic, and Russia was accused.

On the other hand, after that, Mr. Bolton, who was the main proponent of the withdrawal, lost his job, and President Trump, in general, seemed to indicate something else. The discussion on the START Treaty is ongoing, but it is still unclear in which direction.

A year ago, we were sitting with you on this stage, and you then said a very vivid expression that in the case, God forbid, of nuclear aggression, the aggressors will die, and we will go to paradise. So, over this year, have we become closer to paradise?

We are all always equally close to the Lord, and He will determine where we will be after the end of our earthly journey. But the situation has not improved, of course. It has worsened due to the United States' withdrawal from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty. This is obvious to everyone. Now we are waiting for the next decision.

Moreover, I think that the fact that very quickly after the announcement of the withdrawal, the United States tested such a ground-based medium-range missile indicates that they had been working on this for a long time. Such tasks are not solved technologically in a couple of months. This means they had been working on this for at least several years. And everything else...

A pretext for withdrawal was sought, and it was found. I think it was not very successful, actually, because there were no grounds to accuse Russia of violating anything. On the contrary, we were always told that Aegis systems could not be used for launching ground-based medium-range missiles – the Aegis systems that are now already in Europe: in Romania, and soon will be in Poland.

We were told that no, it is impossible to use them. And then – boom, and they themselves announced that the Aegis launch systems had been used to launch these medium-range missiles. They could have at least made the pause a bit longer. It is clear that we were being deceived or they were trying to deceive us. Then they admitted it themselves.

Well, never mind, that is not the point. The point is that the situation has not improved. We, considering such an escalation, immediately said, I said right away, that we would do the same, but we announce in advance that we will not deploy medium-range ground-based missiles in those regions and for as long as American-made systems do not appear in those regions.

I have said this five times – no one reacts: neither in the States have they reacted so far, nor in Europe. It is as if they have gone deaf, they do not hear! There are many specialists here, I think it is unnecessary to explain to you again: I said once, twice, five times – how many more times? Silence, no reaction.

Then suddenly we heard from the American military that the first step in this direction would be taken precisely in Asia. But it also affects us, because it is necessary to understand: where in Asia, will it reach Russian territory or not?

By the way, it is immediately clear what the primary cause of the withdrawal was: not Russia and not mythical violations by us of the Treaty. If they are going to deploy in Asia, then Asia is the primary cause of the withdrawal from this Treaty. I think experts understand this, and no matter how much the press tries to downplay it, it is an obvious fact.

We are discussing problems in Asia today. We will watch for further steps: where in Asia will they appear, how, who will they threaten? Is this good or not? Very bad. Because there will certainly be adequate mirror responses.

Will this improve the situation in Asia or not? No, it will not. It will only worsen, it will create new threats. But I very much hope that while final decisions have not been made, there are still certain opportunities for resolving this situation.

V. Naumkin: Kassym-Jomart Kemelevich, if I redirect this question to you, could you say a few words on this topic regarding Fyodor Lukyanov's question?

K.-J. Tokayev: Who will be closer to God?

F. Lukyanov: This is also interesting, but in general, you mentioned in your speech about Kazakhstan's global leadership in nuclear disarmament, which certainly relates to this.

K.-J. Tokayev: Indeed, we have both the moral and political right to speak about this, because by the decree of the President in 1991, the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site was closed. And since then we have been talking about the importance of nuclear disarmament. At the same time, we understand that, of course, this problem is very complex.

In essence, the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons from 1968 is not working, de facto nuclear states have emerged, and so-called threshold states have appeared. But in any case, we must strive for a nuclear-free world. And therefore, Kazakhstan has been and remains committed to such a world.

Well, everything else is, of course, up to the members of the nuclear club, to those states that want to become nuclear. But possessing nuclear weapons in the modern world is not a guarantee of security and especially economic prosperity.

Sometimes it is better not to have nuclear weapons, but to attract more investments to your economy, to maintain and develop good relations with all states of the world, which Kazakhstan does in practice.

Saddam Hussein thought so too.

V. Naumkin: It would probably be right if we now give the floor to our Ukrainian guest – colleague Pogrebinsky, because this topic is very interesting.

M. Pogrebinsky: Thank you very much.

We have already slightly deviated from the agenda. I will continue this topic of deviation.

I am from Ukraine, and our country is going through difficult times. I want to ask a question to Vladimir Vladimirovich.

We all know that this year there has been a large electoral cycle, our legislative and executive power has been "rebooted." Based on these elections and surveys, it is clear that public opinion has formulated a stable demand for a peaceful resolution in the east of the country.

And already the new authorities are trying to take their first steps, such timid steps in this direction of seeking peace. But they are so timid that they raise doubts about their readiness and ability to reach a logical conclusion of this process.

As you see, are there any political forces in Ukraine that could act as drivers of this political settlement process?

And a second, short half-question: in Ukraine, Russian federal channels are watched, especially various political talk shows that used to be very popular, and there are complaints that Ukraine is portrayed on some channels, on some programs, not in a very flattering light. This temptation seems to have also affected the popular program of Vladimir Solovyov. Do you not think it is time to change this editorial policy or line?

If you believe that our channels, television channels, as strange as it may seem, even state channels, are conducting an independent editorial policy, that they portray, as you said, Ukraine in an unfavorable light, I agree with you.

If this is the case, then it is wrong; we should not portray our neighbor, our closest neighbor and fraternal people, without any exaggeration, in an unfavorable light.

We may be talking about the policies of the current authorities, but not about the country, not about the people. If you interpret it this way, then something is lacking in our programs; they should always emphasize this.

Now regarding the efforts of the new leadership of the country in connection with the settlement in the southeast of the country. I do not know how strong those who oppose the settlement are today, especially based on the Minsk agreements. Thus, the public demand for a settlement is obvious.

I think that primarily based on this demand, Mr. Zelensky convincingly won the elections. People are waiting for a resolution of this issue in Ukraine. And if he has the political courage and strength to see this through to the end, I think he will establish himself as an honest politician, brave and capable of achieving the decisions made.

I believe that he sincerely wants to do this; it is his sincere conviction, his aspiration, at least. Whether he can do it or not, whether he can withstand those who oppose this process, it is difficult for me to say now, but we certainly see certain fluctuations.

This seems to be inevitable; he must seek some compromises, must negotiate with all members of society, with all the people, regardless of their views, but he must still fulfill his electoral promises made to the majority of the Ukrainian people.

V. Naumkin: Thank you.

I think we have a bit of gender inequality happening, so I suggest we give the floor to Ms. Kastueva.

Please.

T. Kastueva-Zhan: Good afternoon!

Tatiana Kastueva-Zhan – expert at the French Institute of International Relations in Paris.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, I have a question for you. At the very beginning of your speech, you suggested outlining the contours of the future and talking about it. One of the topics that naturally comes to mind is global warming, climate.

Russia recently ratified the Paris Agreement on climate, and you know that this topic is very dear to President Emmanuel Macron; it is one of his priority topics. By the way, it seems to me that you and President Macron are entering a new stage of relations, which would also be interesting to discuss.

But I will return to my question. In France, in principle, and in Europe, there is some basic consensus on climate change, although recently, the girl Greta Thunberg has brought a lot of polarization even to this issue, where there was, in principle, a consensus.

What has she done?

T. Kastueva-Zhan: She has introduced some polarization into this debate. As for Russia, it seems to me that there has always been a duality in relations even in doctrines, because the Doctrine of Environmental Security of Russia states very correct things, while the Doctrine of Economic Security until 2025 states that the development of a "green" economy is one of the threats and risks to the Russian economy, and it is clear why: because the share of oil and gas is very high in exports.

The same duality exists in the explanations for climate change. Is it a result of human activity or global cycles of the Earth?

The same duality exists at the level of enterprises. Is this some kind of chance for the future? We talked in the first morning session about how perhaps Russia can take a very interesting place in the new global "green" economy. Or is it a risk, a loss of margin, a loss of profit for enterprises?

And the same applies to global competition – we also discussed this at the Valdai Club meeting – that the environmental tool can also become a means of economic, trade, and financial warfare in the hands of strong players.

And by signing and ratifying this agreement, do you think Russia has put an end to all these doubts, fluctuations, dilemmas? Will there now be some new socio-economic development paradigm at the national level and in the global external context? Will this topic be a unifying measure or a topic that will create another dividing line?

As for the uniformity of approaches and assessments, it probably will never exist. And indeed, specialists in various fields who try to answer the question of the causes of climate change do not provide unequivocal answers to the causes of climate change. There are different points of view; I have heard them myself.

There are those who say that these are some global changes in space in general, and this affects the Earth, and periodically such colossal changes occur on our planet. I personally was on the Lena River, where there are huge high banks, and there are clearly deposits of tropical mammals, of tropical origin, from tropical seas – on the Lena, which is in the Far North. This means there was such a climate. And what, were there any anthropogenic emissions then? No, of course. You see, there is no answer.

Nevertheless, my position is that if humanity at least somehow influences climate change, and these changes lead to severe consequences, even if we can do anything to slow down at least this process, to avoid its negative consequences, we must do this to the maximum. This is our position. Despite all the contradictions, we will support this process in the world in the fight against climate change.

We have indeed ratified the Paris Agreement and intend to implement it. You said we have doubts or disputes. They will always exist. But look at what obligations we have taken on ourselves and what obligations other partners have taken. We have committed to reduce anthropogenic emissions into the atmosphere by 70-75 percent by 2050.

The European Union, by the way, has committed to reduce such emissions by 60 percent. We have adopted a whole national program in the field of ecology. And it is simply outlined point by point what we must do and by when. We have adopted 12 federal programs within the framework of the national project to combat the changing situation in the field of ecology. Emissions in our 12 major megacities, where emissions affect people's lives and have a negative impact on the environment, must be reduced by 20 percent.

We have adopted a whole program for landfills – not only for primitive landfills but also for hazardous waste. We have adopted a program to increase specially protected areas by five million square kilometers. We have a whole set of measures that we are not just intending to implement but are already implementing, and these measures are already enshrined in Russian law. So we are determined to move along this path, which is outlined in the Paris Agreements, together with our partners.

As for hydrocarbons, I think I mentioned yesterday that we have one of the "greenest" energy structures in Russia, one of the "greenest." Our nuclear energy and hydropower account for one-third of our entire energy, and the rest, 50 percent, is gas. We have the "greenest" energy, one of the "greenest" energy structures in the world, plus the carbon absorption capacity of our forests. Therefore, we understand the threats that everyone, including us, is exposed to. After all, the pace of warming in Russia is 2.5 percent faster than in the rest of the world. We understand this.

And this: in one place, our forests are burning, in another place, floods are occurring nearby, droughts, and so on. We are fully aware of this and proceed from the understanding that we will join the whole world, all of humanity, to make maximum efforts to do everything in our power to preserve nature and ecology.

Perhaps our partners will say something, our friends and discussion participants will say something on this matter?

F. Lukyanov: Environmental issues probably concern everyone. Perhaps they will indeed express their opinions?

Ilham Heydarovich?

I. Aliyev: I fully support the theses of Vladimir Vladimirovich.

From my side, I would like to say that in Azerbaijan, we also use gas and hydro resources for electricity production. And in this regard, we are also fulfilling our obligations regarding emissions.

This topic has a global character, and of course, the main, decisive word should be said by those countries that are the main "contributors," so to speak, to climate warming. Our country is territorially small and has a small population, so we do not significantly influence global processes.

But as a responsible member of the international community, we are taking the necessary measures to improve the environmental situation both in our country and in the Caspian region, because this concerns not only us but also other coastal states and the region as a whole.

V. Naumkin: Anyone else, perhaps, from the speakers?

Kazakhstan is also an oil-producing country.

F. Lukyanov: Kazakhstan – it would be very important.

K.-J. Tokayev: The energy balance of Kazakhstan has developed in such a way that 74 percent is coal. For some reason, there is an understanding that we mainly live off oil and gas. Yes, indeed, in terms of budget revenue, oil certainly occupies a leading position. But in the energy balance, it is coal. We are now bringing gas to the capital, working on the issue with the Russian Federation regarding the construction of a gas pipeline to the northern cities: Petropavlovsk, Pavlodar, Kokshetau, and others.

Therefore, as for "green" technologies, they account for no more than one and a half percent in Kazakhstan's energy balance. This is a reality. Nevertheless, of course, we must strive to develop "green" technologies, so-called renewable energy sources.

But it must be understood that this is a very expensive thing, and to switch to "green" technology overnight – even in Europe, it is very difficult to do, let alone us. Therefore, we must approach such issues realistically.

As for climate change, one very well-known scientist told me that this issue was discussed 300 years ago, 200 years ago, and 100 years ago. This, so to speak, if I may express it figuratively, is a chip that has been discussed for many, many years. The climate indeed changes in one direction or another. Therefore, I would not think to exaggerate what is happening with the climate now.

But as for the Paris Agreement, of course, this is a universal document; we have joined it and will fulfill our obligations. But again, I repeat, we should not harbor illusions regarding renewable energy sources; we must rely on what we have.

Thank you.

F. Lukyanov: The most important thing is probably that this issue is discussed even 300 years after us. Otherwise, if suddenly there is no one to discuss it, then we have made a mistake.

If I may, I will intervene – as in the show "What? Where? When?" there is a person who represents the team of viewers, I want to stand up for our disciplined Valdai members who proposed their questions in advance. I will summarize part of them, and part, if possible, from the audience.

There is a group of questions – Angela Stend, Jill Doherty, for example, ask Vladimir Vladimirovich, and this can actually be asked of all participants: right now, the internal situation in the United States is quite complicated, especially in the last week. It is somehow difficult to understand what is happening there; domestic political issues are clearly dominating. How can relations be built in such a case, or perhaps it is better to wait?

Another question from the same category is from Professor Wan Wei from China. He asks: can you share your experience with the Chinese leadership because they do not understand how to deal? Perhaps you have some secret – you, Vladimir Vladimirovich, or all present?

I do not think the Chinese need our advice. If they say they do not understand something, they do not want you to know that they understand. Perhaps it is beneficial for them for you to think that they do not understand.

In fact, I assure you, I have very close, I am not exaggerating, friendly relations – we publicly say this all the time, but also privately – we have developed friendly relations with the leader of China, Mr. Xi Jinping. I see what level, world level, this policy is. They understand everything, they know everything, and in principle, they are ready to react to any development of events.

As for the development of the situation in the States, how to deal with them when they are so engrossed in domestic politics… It is clear that this happens during election campaigns in any country, including the States. But there, all this internal political struggle has taken on, of course, extreme forms. I do not think there has ever been anything like this in the history of the United States.

But life goes on; we must take into account what is happening inside. But it is impossible not to work with such a global power as the United States. We intend to do this as much as they themselves are ready for it.

F. Lukyanov: Your Majesty, you also have a very rich experience of interaction with the United States. What are your impressions now?

Abdullah II: I believe that His Excellency President Putin has answered for both of us.

F. Lukyanov: Then a follow-up question, although on a different topic. Professor Boniface from France – I don’t see where he is sitting, but he sent a question – asks: President Macron, speaking recently to diplomats, said that the so-called deep state, that is, some deep structures within the administration, are hindering the development of relations with Russia, obstructing it. He would like to move faster, but he is being hindered.

And the question is: why, in fact, do these deep structures in France, and perhaps elsewhere, hinder relations specifically with Russia? What is it that Russia represents to them?

In which administration – in the American administration?

F. Lukyanov: In France.

In the French administration?

F. Lukyanov: Yes.

So who is the President of France – me or Macron? Let him put things in order. Why ask me? First of all, I haven’t heard what he said, I’m not aware. But if someone is hindering him from his subordinates, he should put them in their place. Or change them. Then bring in your supporters and like-minded people into the administration, and everything will work as a single team with high results.

F. Lukyanov: Here sits Professor Mohan, he has a very good question on your favorite topic, Vladimir Vladimirovich.

Please give the microphone to Professor Mohan.

S. Mohan: Mr. President, two years ago you said something about artificial intelligence, you said it would change world politics. You said that the country that becomes a leader in this area will achieve world hegemony. After two years, how do you see this situation? This is the first question.

The second: now the US and China are striving ahead. Does Russia have its own national policy that could contribute to the development of this area and in partnership with other countries? And in the long term, can Russia somehow contribute to the development of new norms that regulate artificial intelligence, as Russia, for example, did in the 20th century regarding nuclear technologies? In civilian applications and in military.

Regarding what I said two years ago. You know, I must admit, I was just plagiarizing; this is not my statement, this is what specialists around the world say, that artificial intelligence will radically change the world and our approaches to solving pressing problems and future issues.

Entire industries will simply change, some will cease to exist, new ones will emerge, new jobs will be required. Old professions will die out, and we will need to understand how to address the social problems associated with the released workers, and so on, and so forth.

Medical issues will change radically. Artificial intelligence will affect the defense capabilities of states because those who will possess these technologies will gain advantages that may be incomparable to nuclear weapons.

What has changed during this time? The speed of changes is increasing.

Can Russia make any contribution to the collective efforts to develop artificial intelligence or, say, genetics? Of course, it can. Our programmers work all over the world and work very successfully. We have a historically, traditionally developed mathematical school, and the foundation of artificial intelligence is primarily based on developments in mathematics, deeply. The technologies are there, but the mathematical developments are still at the core.

So what are we doing? We have a whole state program created for the development of artificial intelligence, just like in China, just like in the United States, and in some other countries. We are ramping up our efforts. We believe that here we not only cannot lag behind, but we have every chance to succeed in this direction.

But it would be best if humanity's efforts were united and common rules for working with new technologies were developed. Common rules for communication in this area are extremely important for ensuring a stable world.

F. Lukyanov: Another good question – I will ask Alexander Rar to please ask it.

A. Rar: Vladimir Vladimirovich, there is a rather strange question, but let’s move to Europe. In Europe, the European Parliament has adopted, in my opinion, an inadequate decision – a resolution that seeks to equate fascist Germany with communist Russia. And they insist that both Stalin and Hitler started World War II together.

I believe that this will legitimize further NATO expansion, lead to a new division, greater problems, and, most importantly, a lack of understanding among the youth and people in Europe. What can be done to somehow stop this?

I do not want to characterize the Stalinist regime right now. You know, we all know what is associated with repression, camps, losses among our people, our citizens during these repressions. This is a dark page in the history of our country.

But to say that Stalin unleashed the war is the height of cynicism. As if at four o'clock in the morning on June 22, the Soviet Union attacked Germany, rather than the German troops crossing the border of the Soviet Union and, despite the existing non-aggression pact, violating this pact and unilaterally attacking the Soviet Union without declaring war.

Let us not forget the sad result, the tragic result, tragic for the people of the Soviet Union: 25-27 million dead – no one can even count that to this day – about 10 million dead in Germany. This is a tragedy!

Let us not forget that it was the troops of the Soviet Union that stormed Berlin. Here, all sorts of speculations arise about the contribution of various countries to the fight against fascism.

I just said: the losses of the Soviet Union – 25-27 million people, the losses of the United States – half a million people, and the losses of the United Kingdom – in general, I think, 350-400 thousand people.

All German troops, mainly – not all, but the most elite forces in terms of both quantity and quality – were concentrated on the Eastern Front. All of this is being mixed up for some reason, hidden, distorted.

It seems to me that the threat lies in one thing: the threat is that in the process of these manipulations, the main thing may be lost – people may stop fearing the repetition of such tragedies. That is the issue. And, in my opinion, we all, sane people, must resist this.

F. Lukyanov: Another question that brings us back to the big theme of the entire conference. I will take the liberty of asking it; Tim Colton sent it, and I will read it myself for speed.

We keep talking – and at this conference, in fact, too: East-West, this opposition. Meanwhile, more and more is being said in the world about the dichotomy of North-South. And essentially, we see that problems are grouping a little differently.

So it turns out that East-West is, on the one hand, some very old colonial legacy, this division, and on the other hand, a legacy of the Cold War. Perhaps it is indeed time for us to change our optics, our views on the world?

And I would like to understand, Vladimir Vladimirovich, you, President Aliyev, President Tokayev, and King Abdullah, it would be very interesting to understand why we still stand in this stereotypical picture?

We always, when discussing the world, oppose East and West. And the question is, why do we do this? Perhaps it is time to abandon this geographical division altogether or, for example, to look from completely different positions?

Ask the President of the Philippines how he thinks, can we equate East and West? Seriously, I’m not joking.

Mr. Duterte, can we equate East and West? Just like in unisex clothing: everything that is for men is also for women. So East and West, is this division something that has come down to us from the past, or is it still a natural division – East and West among themselves?

R. Duterte: There has always been this division between East and West, and in financial terms as well. There were various dynasties, various processes. Many countries faced colonial experiences, and therefore it cannot be said now that we can equate East and West.

Indonesia was under Dutch rule, the Philippines – under Spanish rule, then America, and Malaysia was also a colonial country. Therefore, any attempts to force them to adapt to Western life are wrong.

We must talk about other social processes, and all this should not be limited exclusively to diplomatic channels. There should also be exchanges between people. This will allow for some exchanges, and people from Southeast Asia can travel to the West and see how people live there.

It is very difficult for us to imagine a situation of equating the West and the East. We have our own course. Not that we want to present an alternative course of relations with America; we want to understand the course we have pursued since gaining independence in 1947.

We must understand what we should do now because for a long time we did not have concrete relations with the Eastern bloc and with Russia. At that time, Russia and the Eastern bloc were portrayed as enemies of democracy, while democracy embodied the Western world.

And they said that the rest of the world consisted of authoritarian rulers, various despots. And this gives us food for thought. And we still see this propaganda in the US.

And perhaps the future generation will deal with this; I am the last representative of my generation, I was born in 1945. And the Western path, the Western ideology still exists. But with education and new positions, we can change this, but it will take time.

It is difficult for the people of the Philippines to understand this ideology, the ideology of democracy that the US promotes; it is all American propaganda. When Berlin was liberated, this division into East and West emerged, this ideological division. And now we are exchanging opinions and trying to understand each other, but that is not enough.

There is also a financial component. They always look down on us; we always eat only the crumbs from their table. But America is the country that does not fulfill its obligations as a former colonial power. And we remember how we were under the rule of others.

This colonial question is indeed acute in Southeast Asia: Malaysia, Indonesia, and other countries, and in the Philippines as well. And all this pain cannot be forgotten in a short time. It takes two or three generations to fully overcome this so that Asians are accepted by the rest of the world as partners.

We remember the "Opium Wars," the imposition of ideologies, opinions. We always remember that our history was a struggle, and this is part of our history when we were under colonial power, under violent power; this is a common part of our paradigm.

F. Lukyanov: We have understood that our hypothesis is incorrect, that between East and West, everything remains as before. So I withdraw my question.

K.-J. Tokayev: May I say just a few words?

Of course, Asia is Asia, Europe is Europe. But there is a concept called Eurasianism. For example, Kazakhstan is not only territorially, geographically, but also mentally a Eurasian state. But the classic Eurasian state, in my opinion, is Russia.

Being the largest European state in the world, at the same time, Russia is also an Asian state. And the corresponding mentality of our countries, of course, influences both politics and lifestyle.

In 1940, this is a historical fact, Stalin received the Japanese Foreign Minister. At that time, there were fears that Japan might attack the Soviet Union. Stalin then told the Japanese Foreign Minister: we, Asians, must stick together. Therefore, in principle, I am not a fan of Stalin, of course, but the very formulation of the question, especially since Asians – today’s topic of this forum, Euro-Asians, we must stick together.

V. Naumkin: Dear colleagues!

The head of our state has a very busy schedule. I think the other leaders present here do as well. I apologize that I cannot provide the opportunity for everyone who raised their hand to ask a question.

Therefore, as we approach the end, I would like to ask the last question, and then I will also give Fedor Lukyanov a chance to say a few words on behalf of the club. And the question is addressed to Vladimir Vladimirovich and His Majesty the King.

We have been discussing various issues related to the current state of the world order here for four days. And, in general, the conclusion has been unequivocal that it is currently in crisis, and the future world order will be shaped with the increasing role of Eastern countries.

How do you see the future world order?

Abdullah II: Undoubtedly, the Middle East is at a crossroads right now. I hope that in the near future we will see positive developments. Certainly, we have to overcome huge obstacles not only at the borders of Jordan but also in other parts of the region.

And the future problem that we will see in the coming decades is the problem of struggle, which will move beyond the purely military dimension. And the President understands that the international community still does not understand who our enemy is, who our common enemy is.

If we do not understand what challenge we have here within Islam and within other religions, then we will see a situation of insecurity for the entire world.

I have a colleague from India here, and we all see how India has fought against radicalization in Syria and Iraq. Because in these countries, there is a large proportion of the Muslim population, and only a hundred militants went to Syria and Iraq. In Bulgaria, for example, no one went from there to Syria or Iraq. For instance, a small country sent 177 of its militants there.

Therefore, until we understand the threat of radicalism, there will be no stability in the world, and there is no stability in the countries that represent Boko Haram and Al-Shabaab.

And there will be no stability in the Balkans. There will be problems in the Philippines, and possibly problems will arise in Indonesia. Because if we do not name our common enemy – radicalism, then global problems will only worsen.

That is why the relationship between Russia and Jordan is so good. We understand this threat. We have not always agreed on Syria, but we have always spoken honestly with each other in order to resolve all existing problems.

From our point of view, if we do not understand that we are all on the same side, and do not recognize the common threat, then it will take us a very long time to stabilize the situation in the world.

The existing system of international relations, international institutions, and structures was formed after and as a result of the Second World War. The situation in the world is changing radically both in Europe and on the American continent, where new rapidly growing, developing players are also emerging, as well as in Africa, and especially in Asia.

The existing system with its institutions, if it wants to survive, must correspond to the realities of a changing world. I proceed from the premise that we should not break anything that has been created in previous decades, but rather gradually transform and adapt it to the realities of today's world, taking into account the growing power and development prospects of Asia as a whole and individual Asian states in particular. They certainly have the right and should take their rightful place in the global system, in global politics, and in international affairs.

F. Lukyanov: Thank you very much.

Today is undoubtedly a historic day for the Valdai Club, because we have never had so many heads of state at our final session before. We have been enriched by the wisdom and knowledge from different parts of the world.

This is very valuable; it is, in fact, in the spirit of what we are trying to do. But, of course, as is now customary, our main source of inspiration is still Eurasia, so the Valdai Club takes as a guiding principle what President Tokayev said.

He quoted a proverb to us – a Chinese one, I understood, that they sleep in the same bed but see different dreams. We are advocates of the inviolability of sovereignty and non-interference in anyone's affairs, so we will not interfere in what these communities do in the same bed.

Well, the Valdai Club will engage in harmonizing dreams, because, as we understand, the most important thing is that these dreams and visions of the future coincide and do not contradict each other. In fact, we will try to contribute to this with our work.

Thank you very much, everyone.