Meeting with schoolchildren

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

1 September 2021

Context
Putin addressed Russian schoolchildren and educators on September 1, 2021, in a meeting marking the start of the new academic year.
Main themes
Education and knowledge, history as foundation of learning, September 1 school year start, first-graders and new beginnings, information quality and internet literacy, Society Knowledge organization, future career aspirations, role of specialists and experts, humanities and interdisciplinary learning
Duration
~93 min
98th percentile
Words
11,111
98th percentile
Sentences
677
99th percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
8.3
6th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Russian

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

677 sentences in 222 paragraphs

Dear friends, good afternoon!

Before we start talking about anything on September 1, it goes without saying that I want to congratulate you, all schoolchildren, all students, all educators and teachers on this wonderful holiday – the new year, the new academic year. After all, some of the most beloved holidays in our country are Christmas and New Year. But September 1 is also a new year, a new academic year.

First of all, I want to congratulate the little ones, the first-graders, who will be going to school for the first time – them, their parents, mothers, grandmothers, and caregivers. We always do this, and we do it right, in fact. Why? Because for older students, everything is already more or less routine, and they meet friends, peers, continuing the learning process to which, starting from the 2nd or 3rd grade, everyone more or less gets used to. But for first-graders, this is a new page in their lives, the beginning of their destiny in terms of acquiring knowledge and choosing their place in life, the path they will follow throughout their lives.

This is a very important period in the lives of little ones. Therefore, I want to ask all the other schoolchildren in the country, as bureaucrats say on such occasions, to warmly welcome the little ones in schools and support them at every step – in the literal and figurative sense of the word. That is the first thing I wanted to say.

Secondly. You know that some time ago we revived the Soviet, then Russian society "Knowledge," the goal of which is to help people in general, and young people in particular, to find themselves as well. To find that interesting direction that captivates a person and with which they would like to connect their entire remaining life.

Of course, in the modern world, there are many so-called information resources: the internet, the RuNet – there is everything! You can dive in there and seemingly learn everything: from stars to the center of the Earth, from nails to diamonds – everything. But there is a problem, and the problem lies in the quality of this information. There is a lot of informational garbage that is often presented as the ultimate truth, and one cannot believe it because it is not the opinion of real, true specialists, but often of people who present themselves as such.

And the society "Knowledge," its work is precisely related to the fact that it turns to the opinions of real professionals in each narrow field of knowledge, and they can undoubtedly be trusted; one can build their own understanding of a particular phenomenon, its future development based on their information and see how interesting it is personally to oneself, whether it will be something to which one is ready to dedicate their entire life.

We have a formal lesson today, right? If this were a real lesson, then I would have to choose a topic. My basic education, as you know – probably you know – is legal education. This is a basic education; I studied at the university for five years. We had a very good pedagogical, professor-teaching staff; one can only be proud of the people who taught us. And in this sense, I can consider myself a specialist to some extent, and I defended my thesis there. Or, for example, in the field of economics, which I deal with almost every day; I defended my thesis on the reproduction of the mineral resource base. An extremely important thing for our economy; here I also feel like an expert and a specialist. And one could speak in such a way that, as they say, it would roll off the tongue; wake me up at night, and I will tell you everything about both domestic and foreign policy. One could talk on this topic as well.

But I chose history as the topic. In this sense and in this area, I do not consider myself a specialist or an expert, and therefore we will have not a lesson but a conversation on the proposed topic. A joint conversation.

But why did I turn my attention to this area of knowledge? First of all, it is very interesting. Secondly, it is very important and encompasses all spheres of knowledge, all of them. Essentially, history is the core, the foundation of all humanitarian knowledge: it includes literature, music, philosophy, natural sciences, and so on. And all of this is extremely important not only because it is interesting to see what and how it was before, but it is important to understand the conditions in which we live today and what awaits us in the future.

Look, I already said that history encompasses or touches upon, in one way or another, all areas of knowledge. Today, which spheres are the most relevant, significant, which are in the spotlight? What do we most often talk about or hear in the same mass media?

Let’s proceed like this. I know that my question has been conveyed to you: what would you like to become? And from this, we will now take off and look at these spheres of activity and areas of knowledge, and then we will go further along the plan that I have kind of drawn for myself internally.

But what would I like to say? Every lecture, every lesson, or every conversation, like ours today, must undoubtedly have a goal. Why are we doing this? Why am I dedicating my time, taking your time for this conversation? What is the goal? The goal is simple. If I were some narrow specialist, I would "drill down" something about history that you do not know or might not know. But since I am not such a specialist, my goal is simpler – to awaken your interest in history, to encourage you to study it. And why this should be done, we will now discuss in more detail after we get acquainted with your answers to the question: what would you like to become?

Do we have this information somewhere? Will it be displayed on the screen?

Look: the larger the letters, the more people answered that they would like to be, say, a teacher, a diplomat, a translator, a journalist. A public servant, an architect, a philologist, a psychologist, a journalist, even a dentist, an employee, a sports coach, a biotechnologist, an engineer, an urbanist, an ecologist – such a variety. This indicates that you have different and very advanced, in this case, one can surely say, interests.

I mentioned ecology myself just now. We will certainly return to the teacher because it is at the center. Let’s say, ecology – we hear about it every day: about the need to preserve nature, to protect it, and so on. We also hear, of course, about climate change. It is changing at such a pace that it causes shock and horror among some specialists. The year 2020 was the second warmest year on record, 2016 and 2020, and climate change in Russia is occurring in some regions at a rate twice as fast as in other regions of the planet. This opens up both opportunities and challenges before us.

What am I getting at? We are talking about history. As one of the ways to study what has happened on the planet. I will share with you what specialists have told me. They drill and extract what are called cores from the earth. They drill deep, pull them out, and the deeper they go, the further back in time it goes. Then they study the rock they extract, using modern analytical methods to understand what was happening on the planet with the climate 100, 200, 300, 1000, many thousands of years ago. Then they build such a sinusoidal curve of how it all developed on the planet up to our day, and then extend this sinusoidal curve further. And this is an analysis of what may happen on the planet in the next 1000 years.

We have had serious catastrophes many times in the depths of centuries when almost all life on the planet perished, and not only dinosaurs went extinct, which we constantly talk about. Tens, hundreds of millions of years ago, events occurred that led to the near-total extinction of all life: both reptiles and ocean dwellers perished, and those who found themselves on land – there were losses of 20, 30, 50, up to 70 percent of all living things. Why? Various hypotheses and different reasons are named: possible bursts – the birth of supernova stars close to Earth, powerful volcanic eruptions that created some semblance of a nuclear winter, the fall of meteorites up to 10 kilometers in size that created a similar effect, and so on. After all, this is all history, the history of our planet.

And to understand how much anthropogenic emissions today affect real changes, one must take into account all these factors, not just count what is happening with us. One must look at what is happening in the galaxy, in near space, what is happening in the depths of the earth.

You know, I was in the Far North, and there is permafrost, an ice cave, solid blue ice. And you can count, there are such slices, to determine which slice belongs to which century. And suddenly, somewhere down there, quite deep, and this means these events occurred about a thousand years ago – well, approximately, I don’t remember now, but many centuries ago – a stable, clear black trace, and then again blue ice. Where did it come from? There were no emissions, no cars. Most likely, it was volcanic eruptions. To understand what is happening now and what may happen in the future, one must know all this, of course. And this is history. Undoubtedly, this is part of a specific science, but this is also history.

Or, if we move away from this component of history, we can transition to others. After all, history is not just a collection of numbers, names, events, but, as I said, it is the foundation of humanitarian knowledge itself because based on everything I just said, we can look at what is happening today and how we need to behave in the future.

In our country, throughout the last century, the 20th century, Russian statehood collapsed twice: after the revolution of 1917, the Russian Empire ceased to exist. Russia lost colossal territories in the west, in the north, gradually recovered, and then there was also the collapse of the Soviet Union. But why? It is necessary to analyze all this carefully: what was the trigger, what was the starting point for these dramatic events? If they had not occurred, we would have had a different country. Some specialists believe that our population would now be around 500 million people. Just think about it! We currently have 146. If these tragedies had not happened, there would be about 500 million people. Is there a difference? And this is the cumulative power of the state, which is constantly increasing in geometric progression, creating an ever more powerful foundation for development, existence, and well-being. We need to look at what lay at the root of these tragic events to ensure that nothing similar happens in the future. How do we strengthen ourselves, in what way, how do we build relationships with our neighbors?

Or take, for example, what is also in the spotlight; you surely see this both on the internet and for those who watch television programs, the events that are happening not far from us – far from you, but not from Russia – I mean Afghanistan. What happened there? For 20 years – 20 years! – American troops were present in this territory and for 20 years tried – one can say this without offending anyone – to civilize the people who live there, essentially imposing their norms and standards of life in the broadest sense of the word, including in the political organization of society. The result? Only tragedies, only losses for those who did this, for the United States, and even more so for the people living in Afghanistan. The result is zero, if not to say that everything went in the negative.

But why? The answer is actually very simple: if someone does something in relation to someone else, they must start from the history, culture, philosophy, in the broadest sense of the lives of these people, and must approach with respect to their traditions. One must understand that nothing can be imposed from the outside. The situation must mature. And if someone wants it to mature faster, better, one must help people. Yes, it can and should be done, but it must be done in a civilized manner, carefully, supporting positive trends, without rushing. One must be patient. And what is happening now? Without taking into account all these factors, including historical ones, it is practically impossible to achieve anything positive. Of course, we must consider this primarily for ourselves.

You have the profession of "journalism" on your board. Of course, it is a very important thing, and certainly, every person has the right to their own opinion, has the right to express their position, but still, the role of the mass media is primarily to convey to their audience, to the listener, to the user through some informational resources the objectivity of information and to give a person the opportunity to come to their own conclusion about what is good and what is bad and where to move.

In this context, keeping in mind that we are still celebrating a holiday today, September 1, the role of the teacher and educator, who stands at the center of this board, is extremely important, and the overwhelming majority choose this profession.

Today, there is a lot of discussion about what education should be: should it be implemented online or should it be offline – directly, in direct contact. Of course, modern methods of delivering and transmitting knowledge must be used, without any doubt. But there are some circumstances; this is not my opinion, this is the opinion of the overwhelming majority of experts: the effectiveness of a person's work, one of the criteria for the effectiveness of work, is the ability to work in a team. How will you learn to work in a team if you are always engaged online? It is impossible. So, here is one of the most important criteria for success that should accompany a person will be lost.

You have a teacher, and there is an educator. And this is extremely important because it is not just important to transmit knowledge; nothing is more important, probably. But it is also important how to do it. I won’t tell you anything new; a scalpel can be an instrument that saves lives, or it can be used as a weapon of murder, bringing only grief. The same goes for knowledge. There are atomic bombs, and there are nuclear power plants. There is a big difference, right? And the role of the educator is precisely that all this knowledge, all the skills that a person acquires, are used not only for their own benefit but also for the benefit of other people, of society as a whole, of all humanity.

And it is not by chance that I was very pleased to see that this profession is at the center of your work – the profession of a teacher, an educator. And we will certainly strive to combine both direct teaching and the use of modern methods. That is, modern ways of presenting material. And wherever possible, we will do this.

The history is very important, not only for our entire country, which is undoubtedly extremely important, but also the history of one’s small homeland and family history is very important. This is important because it emotionally and spiritually connects each person to the land on which they live. They begin to realize themselves as part of a vast country. When studying family history, information inevitably arises about someone among our ancestors who participated in some of the most significant events. And, as a rule, all of them were quite young people.

Now we are celebrating the 800th anniversary of Alexander Nevsky, who was a statesman, a military leader, and a saint; the Russian Orthodox Church has canonized him. And this year we are celebrating the 800th anniversary of Alexander Nevsky. His first battle, as we say in films, against the dogs of the knights, against the Crusaders, which he brilliantly won, was when he was how old? At 19 years old, he led the Russian army, at 19 years old. And his brother, who fought alongside him with weapons in hand, was, if I’m not mistaken, 16. Can you imagine what that is? And our military leaders during World War II, the Great Patriotic War? They were very young people, many of them were not even forty, commanding regiments, divisions, and later armies. And the builders of the Trans-Siberian Railway, the BAM? And those who developed the territories of the Far East? As a rule, they were mostly young people. They were passionate about their work. And of course, knowing this is extremely important and highly beneficial in order to understand what happened, who achieved success and how. Understanding and knowing this is necessary in order to be successful oneself.

Here, there are mainly people from the Far East, right? No. Well, good, but we are nevertheless in the Far East. Who knows what about those people who developed these colossal territories? Can anyone tell us something about this?

Please take the microphone.

N. Tolstykh: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Nikanor Tolstykh, I am from the Komi Republic, from the city of Vorkuta, that is, from the very Far North.

I am passionate about history, but I do not know the history of the Far East well enough to speak freely. But I do know, in any case, that these were brave people; they ventured into complete uncertainty because, so to speak, only the European part of our country was developed, and beyond that… What is beyond that? Beyond that is emptiness. Therefore, it is worth recalling Yeryofey Khabarov, who is considered the founder of the city of Khabarovsk.

This is the 17th century.

N. Tolstykh: Yes. And Captain Nevelskoy, who was simply sent into some unknown territory, and in his diaries, he himself admitted that he was “sailing into the unknown.”

Correct. And Bering, who was the first to pass through the strait that separates Chukotka from Alaska? And so on. Then there was the Governor-General of Siberia and the Far East, Muravyov-Amursky. There are many interesting people. And, as I repeat once again, they and their associates were quite young people.

But I want to return once again to the history of the family, the small homeland – the native land and the Fatherland as a whole. All of this is undoubtedly closely interconnected, and it is very important to feel oneself as part of this history.

We have now created information resources about those who were in one way or another involved in the victory of the Soviet people in the Great Patriotic War, and there is already information collected on 34 million people. This is practically everyone who was mobilized in one way or another: either fought at the front or worked in the rear. It is a very interesting history. Almost every family can find their relatives, their ancestors there and feel connected to these victories that created a future for us.

After all, why has the "Immortal Regiment" movement become so popular? It is on a subconscious level. First of all, it is a tribute of respect, it is a memory of those people who, without sparing themselves, fought for us. And also, you know, on a subconscious, genetic level, it is also a sense of belonging. After all, if my grandfather or great-grandfather was like that and could do this, then there is something in me that gives grounds to believe that in a critical situation, I can also show my best qualities, serve my family, loved ones, and the Fatherland. It is an extremely important and very interesting thing, educational and significant for today and for the future.

Those who developed these territories – it is also an interesting story. After all, there were Great Russians, Little Russians, and Belarusians here. All people who considered themselves, and for the most part still consider themselves, a single people, they all developed these colossal territories.

When I spoke about how history helps us understand the present day, I can share with you that, not being a professional historian, I still had to refer to historical events twice in order to analyze the events before the start of World War II, to see how the situation developed during World War II, including within the framework of World War II. What is especially important for us is the Great Patriotic War, the war of the Soviet people against Nazi Germany. And it should be said that the victory over Nazism is probably one of the most vivid, significant events of the entire 20th century, that is undoubtedly so. If this victory had not taken place or, God forbid, the Nazis had won, the world would have been completely different, and the fate of the Russian and other peoples of Russia would have been absolutely different; there would have been no fate at all. Because in the documents of the Reich, this is not idle talk; it is written in the documents: part of the Slavic population of Russia should be used for labor, those who can work; part, who cannot work, are not needed, beyond the Urals, to the north, to uninhabited regions – that is, to extinction, to be clear – and part should be completely destroyed in gas chambers. The fate of the Russian and other peoples of Russia would have been different from the fate of the Western European peoples enslaved by Nazi Germany. Those peoples were perceived more or less as genetically their own and were expected to coexist with them. With our peoples – no, with the Russian people – no, the Russian people were subject to liquidation, extermination. We must never forget this and must never allow any chatterboxes to say: why did we need to fight for Leningrad, it could have been surrendered, then there would have been fewer victims? Yes, perhaps there would have been fewer victims, but then you would not be here, those who speak about this today in such a way.

Or I had to refer to another component, going back centuries – perhaps you noticed this, perhaps you did not, I wrote an article about the unity of Russians and Ukrainians.

I did not mention by chance that Little Russians, Great Russians, and Belarusians developed these territories. There are many descendants from the territory that is now called Ukraine. And they, along with the entire people, moved forward and developed these colossal territories. Not for themselves. For the future of the country, a common country, for our common future. And we must all know this and treat with respect those people who did this.

I will repeat once again: many young people always participate in interesting, pivotal moments or in fateful projects. This is happening today as well. We are starting to work on the so-called Eastern Polygon. This is a new life, a revival of the BAM, the Trans-Siberian Railway. Who built it, as I said? Young people. The Crimean Bridge, too, was built by quite young people.

Many other areas in science, in defense. When I met a small team of developers of one of our newest systems, honestly, I was so surprised; I said: where did you come from? They were very young people. Entire groups came to a research institution right after university and created one of the newest – still unmatched – missile systems in the world to protect the interests of the country. Very young people. So what am I getting at? That knowing all this, you should not limit yourselves in dreaming and achieving the goals you set for yourselves, and you will definitely succeed.

As for the Far East, if we return to the study of the small homeland, the regions, there is much to see. I think that the people from the Far East know this. And those who have come for the first time should certainly get acquainted with the Museum of the Far East: there, like a matryoshka, there is another component – this is the Vladivostok Fortress, and within it sits Fort No. 1. I won’t go into details now, but we can definitely include this in the program, and I would ask your teachers, leaders, to show you and the other guys who came to "Okean" all of this. If you have come to Vladivostok, you need to clearly understand where you are and what Vladivostok means for our country, for Russia.

And I want to wish you success, congratulate you on September 1, on the fact that you are meeting it right here, in such a wonderful, cool, I would say, place in Russia, like the Far Eastern region, like Vladivostok, and express hope that you will achieve everything you dream of, not only this year but in life as a whole.

Thank you very much.

If there are any questions, let’s talk about this topic.

M. Tolkacheva: Good afternoon, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Tolkacheva Maria, I am a teacher of the Russian language and literature at the year-round school of the VDC "Okean."

Today we are present at a truly unusual event, as students from different regions of our country have come to our All-Russian open lesson. In our class, there are representatives from 17 regions, 19 populated areas. If we add up all the kilometers that the students traveled to get to Vladivostok, it would be enough to circle the globe twice.

All our students are very different, with different interests: some are passionate about science, some about culture, some about ecology, but they all care deeply about their region, their schools, and they would surely like to discuss some questions with you. Right, guys?

Response: Yes.

Please, any suggestions, ideas, questions – let’s go! I said that we have a conversation, so let’s make it easy.

M. Tolkacheva: Let’s start with Nikanor. Nikanor represents the northernmost region we have. Please.

N. Tolstykh: Once again, hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Let me introduce myself again. My name is Nikanor Tolstykh, I am from the northern city of the Komi Republic – Vorkuta. Today you have shown us what a modernized history lesson looks like, and I think my classmates will agree with me. Right, guys?

Response: Yes.

N. Tolstykh: I want such a lesson to be in every school, that is, the history lesson in modern schools should be modernized and improved. I have a few suggestions for this, and please allow me to voice them.

I believe that all history textbooks from the federal list should include interactive QR codes. How does this work? An ordinary student takes out their phone during the lesson with the teacher's permission or at home, scans this QR code in the history textbook, and in front of them appears, for example, an interactive model, a 3D talking model of a tsar, an emperor, who tells about their domestic and foreign policy, or perhaps an interesting fact from their life. Also, primary sources, historical documents can be uploaded into the QR codes, so that students can get an idea of how people lived in the past thanks to historical documents. And various works of historians can also be added there, so that the students’ horizons expand in the historical sphere, and they become historically literate.

I also believe it is necessary to add to the methodological recommendations for history teachers the mandatory conduct of lessons in the format of debates for certain topics. That is, we divide the class into positions for and against, and the students present arguments to refute or confirm a historical era or historical event. I believe that when we see such a format of interaction, it develops communication culture, the ability to think critically and creatively, as well as the ability to express one’s thoughts and position clearly and competently. This will also be very useful for us, for the students, for me as well, especially for those students who take the Unified State Exam in history, because there is a task that requires presenting arguments to refute or confirm some historical event.

This is how I envision my dream lesson; for me, this is my dream history lesson.

And I would like to ask you, Vladimir Vladimirovich. We all dreamed in childhood. What childhood dreams of yours have come true, and what did you dream about? Since there is a parallel between history and dreams.

Thank you.

Let’s start from the beginning. The idea, first of all, is very interesting, that a historical character appears on the screen and tells about themselves, about what is happening and how. You said it would be clearer how people lived, what they lived on, and so on. First of all, that’s great, and of course, it should be implemented. First.

Second, if you allow me, I would like to add a few words to what you just said. The thought is wonderful, but it is important, as I have already mentioned, that history is not just a collection of numbers, names, and a list of events; it is necessary to know this, as it seems one cannot go without it, but still, it is not the main thing. You know, mathematicians tell me: higher mathematics is not counting, it is not "six in the mind, seven in the madness," it is imaginative thinking, higher mathematics. So it is here — a collection of numbers, names, dates, and events is very important. When you said that some sovereign comes out and tells something, what is very important, in my opinion? It is important to understand what the conditions were in which people lived, on the basis of which decisions were made, what guided people in making decisions, and what this led to, what the result was. And then these events of the past will help us to really assess, objectively assess what is happening today, and moreover, they will help us make the right decisions so that in the future everything turns out properly. This is serious work, this is serious analysis of what happened.

What, did Peter I start the Seven Years' War? Did he fight the Swedes for seven years? And the battle of Poltava… Can you imagine where Poltava is? Where is Sweden, and where is Poltava? And the decisive battle between the army of Peter I and Charles XII took place near Poltava. Excuse me, what the heck were they all doing near Poltava? This all matters.

And this will allow us, I repeat once again, to use all this knowledge of the past for a better understanding of the present day and for making decisions that will affect the future. That is what is important.

Did you want to say something else?

N. Tolstykh: Don’t take my… Well, it was not called the Seven Years' War, but simply the Northern War.

But since we have a history lesson, I want to quickly tell the kids. The Northern War lasted from 1700 to 1721. Imagine, the war lasted 21 years with one of the most advanced naval powers. Well, that is very serious. And just as Vladimir Vladimirovich mentioned the Battle of Poltava. At that time, the Russians after three, four… In general, we lost four times, and on the fifth we won. Just like that!

Yes, yes, yes, it is the Northern War, of course, thank you for the correction. But the first time we lost near Narva, and we won, in the end, near Poltava. But still, the question arises: how did they end up near Poltava? And there is a very important interaction between different states, between Charles the Strong, who led the Saxon-Polish state, between Russia and Sweden, and Sweden was not only a naval power; it was a global superpower. And Poltava was not so far from its state borders. This is an interesting matter. But it is important for us to understand how the situation developed. And once again, for the third time, I repeat: it is better to position ourselves today and make the right decisions for the future.

As for your question about what I dreamed of and what I achieved, in this sense, I can consider myself a happy person because at different periods of life, a person relates their dreams to the level of their development and vision of the surrounding world. And goals appear — short-term, more distant, strategic. But in any case, like many boys, I wanted to be a sailor, then a pilot, then a scout. I wanted to be, and I realized this plan; that’s how life turned out. Sometimes I even wonder: how did it happen? It is a complicated matter; you cannot just come and say: I want to be a scout, and they take you into intelligence. It doesn’t seem to work that way, but it happened for me.

But that is not the main thing. The main thing is that school education, upbringing in the family, the environment — everything was aimed at dedicating oneself — you know, I am forced to speak grandly in this case — to serving the Fatherland. After all, when I worked in the security agencies, the officers of the security agencies — look at how the guys work now, sacrificing themselves if necessary. All of this was aimed at serving the Fatherland, and today I am engaged in exactly this and believe that in this sense I have managed to achieve what I dreamed of.

N. Tolstykh: Thank you very much.

M. Tolkacheva: And now let’s move to Primorye, as we are in Vladivostok. And a question from Sofia.

S. Sokolova: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Sofia Sokolova, I am from the city of Vladivostok, I am a semifinalist of the first and second seasons of the All-Russian competition "Big Change," and I am also the coordinator of the regional team.

I am also interested in history, just like you, so I cannot help but suggest introducing an additional history course alongside the school program, which will include familiarizing children with working with archives and historical sources. After all, history is supplemented with new facts, and there are practically no living witnesses to these events anymore. That is why it is important for us to preserve the memory of this and to be able to use it correctly.

The most active children can be encouraged with trips to historical and archaeological camps, participation in international conferences and festivals dedicated to certain historical events. In addition, I think this project could also be implemented together with "Big Change," as we have the challenge "Remember."

Thank you very much.

Of course, I have nothing to respond with; I completely agree, this needs to be done. I will definitely tell my colleagues to try to combine and connect everything into one.

A good idea. Thank you very much.

M. Tolkacheva: Guys, who else has questions?

Vladivostok is very rich in talented kids, and maybe Sergey can also ask a question?

Please, Sergey.

S. Dubovoy: Vladimir Vladimirovich, good afternoon!

My name is Sergey, I study at the "Technical" Lyceum in Vladivostok, in the 11th grade. I am currently studying at the Far Eastern Federal University in the Department of Biotechnology. This is indeed a very important and interesting topic for me. And probably all the guys who were with me in the squad are already qualified biotechnologists because I have talked so much about it that it’s just awful.

I became interested in biology at the age of four when I planted my first bean with my grandmother, who is a botanist.

Is she a botanist in the literal sense of the word, not in the figurative?

S. Dubovoy: No, she is a botanist by education, she is passionate about plants, just like me.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, you touched on such an important topic as climate change. Unfortunately, just like in the whole world, the climate is actively changing in Russia as well. This leads to climate incidents such as droughts, floods, and crop failures. Unfortunately, this causes enormous harm to agriculture.

I believe that in my field, genetic engineering and the latest technologies and breakthroughs associated with it can change this situation, making plants more resilient, more adapted to various factors, and helping us minimize the damage currently inflicted on agriculture.

What do you think, can genetic technologies really help agriculture, and in that case, should federal legislation be changed to accommodate new emerging technologies in this area? After all, for example, we currently have Federal Law No. 86, which was adopted in 1992, and it very strictly regulates this area.

Thank you very much.

I am very pleased that young people have gathered here, but I did not say this by chance; young people have driven progress and achieved outstanding results. Here on the right is Nikolai Lobachevsky, who became the rector of Kazan University at the age of 35, and, as far as I remember, was already the head of the department at 28. This just shows once again how effectively young people can work. They achieve the greatest results both in history and in other fields.

What is our attitude towards genetics? Unfortunately, we remember that there was a period in Soviet history when genetics was called "the whore of imperialism," and our geneticists were, unfortunately, mostly repressed. And the main thing is, it is unclear why. What the political subtext was — it is not clear. It would be interesting, by the way, to figure this out. But apart from some departmental scientific intrigues, nothing is lying on the surface.

But as for today’s research, especially in the context of a changing climate, it is certainly an extremely important direction; it is important to understand the human genome. This is important not only for agriculture but also for medicine, for finding the most effective ways to fight for human health, combating so-called genetic diseases. But this is a very responsible matter. To intrude into the genome, to correct something, even while trying to help people, is a very responsible thing.

As for agriculture, we face many problems with climate change. As I have already mentioned, our country is warming faster than other parts of the planet, twice as fast. We have many populated areas located on permafrost, and how are houses built there? Those guys from the north know. I have been to Komi several times, I worked there in student brigades, I know what it is like. The climate is harsh, and the permafrost is a little further north. They drove piles — actually, they still do it almost the same way — into this permafrost for meters, and houses are built on these piles, including apartment buildings. Now this is starting to wash away little by little. The question arises: what to do with these residential buildings, how to protect people, ensure their safety? This is a big challenge. That is the first.

The second. Climate change also leads to changes in agricultural production. Somewhere desertification occurs, somewhere it is constantly flooded, but somewhere, indeed, the amount of land suitable for agricultural use is increasing. All of this needs to be compared and responded to in a timely manner, including applying genetic research in agriculture.

We do indeed have a law that restricts the use of genetically modified products so that they reach the human table. But there are no restrictions for work in this area for scientific purposes. We have no restrictions on this issue.

The question of using genetically modified products is indeed very complex, and, as specialists believe, it is still not ready to be widely used as it is done, for example, in North America, where legumes, soybeans, and corn are grown in huge quantities, then used for animal feed, and then this meat goes on sale just like the products themselves. What the long-term consequences for humans are from using these products is still unclear, according to specialists. And in this regard, we have decided to limit the entry of such products into our food market. But studying these issues, without any doubt, in order to apply this research in medicine and agriculture, can and should be done, and it is not prohibited. On the contrary, we will support it in every possible way.

S. Dubovoy: Thank you very much. I sincerely believe that work in this area will be conducted. I will also actively participate in this and hope that this area will become clearer for everyone.

This is one of the key directions, just like artificial intelligence. This is very delicate, very dangerous work in terms of possible consequences. To make it clear — specialists know this: genetic engineering can ultimately lead to the creation of special biological entities. If applied to humans — an athlete, a runner, a weightlifter, a scientist, and so on, and so forth, a mathematician. That is, with the help of genetic engineering, one can, in principle, shape the qualities of future biological objects. This is a very responsible matter. The consequences, if humanity goes down this path, are difficult to predict. This must be kept in mind. There are both scientific and moral considerations. This is a very important question.

But that development will proceed in one way or another is absolutely clear. And creating artificial barriers is pointless. When gunpowder was invented, no matter what was tried to prevent it from becoming the property of all humanity, it still became the property of all humanity. Just like nuclear energy. No matter how much it was hidden, nothing worked; it still emerged and is used. Humanity must develop common criteria for working in this direction, make decisions, and ensure that these decisions are balanced, scientifically justified, and implemented. There is probably nothing more interesting than this today.

So we will undoubtedly support this research.

M. Tolkacheva: So, guys, who else is ready to ask questions?

Let’s move to the west of our country. Yegor from Moscow, maybe you can ask a question?

E. Batkin: Hello!

My name is Yegor Batkin, I am from Moscow, I am 17 years old. I am the winner of the first season of the "Big Change" competition.

Today is September 1, Knowledge Day, but today also marks the beginning of the "Pushkin Card" project. This card can be obtained by anyone aged 14 to 22. It has money on it, which can be spent on visiting museums and exhibitions. Together with other guys — participants of the "Big Change" and "Your Move" competitions, I took part in the development and advertising campaign of this "Pushkin Card." We gained an enormous amount of unforgettable experience, we tried ourselves as copywriters, we worked with experts. Just recently, there was a presentation of this project, and it was very pleasant to realize that you became part of such a large-scale, truly important project that will help people, teenagers, become more cultured.

I have already registered for this Pushkin Card today, I looked at how it all works, and I have already chosen my first museum during our conversation. You inspired me to go to the State Historical Museum. As soon as I have free time, I will go there right away.

Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

I have a question, or rather a suggestion: what do you think about regularly, on a permanent basis, possibly using some platform to invite children and teenagers to participate in the development and creation of large projects? Because the "Pushkin Card," the advertising campaign, is one of many examples where young people helped and became co-authors of significant projects. For instance, recently there was a State Council on education, where young people also participated. The semifinals of the "Big Change," which will take place this year, were also developed by teenagers. The advertising campaign for the "Big Change" competition was also created by young people. What do you think about this?

Positively. This applies, as you mentioned, to the "Pushkin Card," but in general, in any area of activity, it is always necessary to involve people who are related to certain problems in solving various issues.

For example, when we consider various solutions, prepare various regulations at the level of the Government, even laws in the field of the economy, we always involve representatives of business and their associations, always. Only in dialogue with them can we find optimal solutions from the perspective of the interests of society and the state, as well as from the perspective of the interests of specific entrepreneurs and specific industries. And find the optimal solution, the so-called golden mean.

The same is happening in what seems to be a modest area, at first glance, like housing and communal services. We have been running a program for improving courtyard spaces for many years. And this is done with people who form small working groups, local residents who propose ideas and projects to the leaders of their municipalities that they consider important. But who, besides the people living in the yard, knows better what they need than they do?

Thus, we even create what is called a people's budget, where the funds allocated for these purposes and their expenditure essentially fall into the hands of these working groups made up of local residents. The same applies to the development of solutions for this "Pushkin Card." It is very good that this idea was suggested and born in the Government of the Russian Federation, and I gladly supported it. And if the organization continues in this way, then this is the most correct thing. And in other areas, we need to act in exactly the same way. That is what we will do.

E. Batkin: Thank you.

M. Tolkacheva: I suggest we give the floor to our youngest student, Yegor.

Please.

E. Sotnich: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

I am Yegor Sotnich from the Republic of Buryatia, the city of Ulan-Ude. I am 10 years old.

You have probably heard that in our Buryatia there is the great Lake Baikal, which contains the largest amount of fresh water in Russia. And right next to my house, literally two meters away, is the embankment of the Selenga River, the main tributary of Lake Baikal.

You may have also heard that the water level is rising, and the left bank has already been flooded, with water completely in the basements. But what worries me is that the garbage that was on the left bank has gone into the water, and now it is floating in Baikal. I clean up; I live on the right bank. And I would like to tell you that our embankment is not in the best condition. Whenever I clean up, everything is clean. Then you can come in the evening, after a few hours, and it will already be dirty. And the treatment facilities are such that a large anchor or a washing machine will certainly be caught, and they will not get into the water, a plastic bottle will also be caught, but what has dissolved in the water will be removed a little, but it will still remain.

I would like to ask you how you view the allocation of funds for the construction of treatment facilities for this great lake.

Thank you.

Baikal is undoubtedly a treasure not only for Buryatia, not only for the Irkutsk region, which is located on the other side of Baikal, but a treasure for all of Russia and all of humanity. Here, the kids are well-prepared, they probably know, I’m afraid to be mistaken, what percentage this is of all fresh water reserves in the world. Do you know?

E. Sotnich: 20.

In Russia.

E. Sotnich: 90 in Russia and 20 in the whole world.

In the whole world. Well done. That's right. In my opinion, it’s a little less in the world, about 10 percent, but it doesn’t matter. A lot, in any case, that is very much.

And our task is to do everything to preserve this unique natural object. A lot has been said about this since the times of the Soviet Union, including about the Baikal Pulp and Paper Mill, to close it. The process is ongoing and is generally positive, but there are things that are quite difficult to fight against, they are of a completely large scale. It is not about any specific enterprise; the main threat to Baikal is the runoff from agricultural activities when fertilizers are used, and then the rains come, and the runoff goes into the lake from these fields, and the runoff from housing and communal services.

As for housing and communal services, we have certain decisions on this matter that have been made, and funding has already been allocated for the reconstruction of housing and communal services facilities in Buryatia. So such a decision has already been made, funding is being allocated. We just need to check the volumes of this funding and the timelines for the allocation of the corresponding resources once again, and I will do that.

E. Sotnich: I also have my own show; the first episode is already on my YouTube channel "Red Fork." Please subscribe; I would be very happy. And please help preserve this great jewel of our planet.

Yes, but I already said that funds are being allocated.

E. Sotnich: Thank you.

And what do I need to sign, Yegor? I didn’t understand what I should sign.

E. Sotnich: YouTube channel, a social network, YouTube.

Ah, okay, okay, fine.

E. Sotnich: Subscribe.

Alright, fine, to your channel.

M. Tolkacheva: It’s called "Red Fork."

Alright, fine, I’ll think about it.

M. Tolkacheva: Who else is ready?

Let’s hear from Alena.

A. Velbik: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Hello!

A. Velbik: My name is Alena, I am from Vladivostok, and I am an 11th-grade student at the University School of the Far Eastern Federal University.

As far as we know, there have been friends and enemies in Russian history. My question is about what qualities, in your opinion, a true friend should possess.

A true friend?

A. Velbik: Yes.

That is a philosophical question.

As for relations between states, this is a completely different substance than friendship between people. Friendship between states is very pragmatic in nature and is always related to the interests of the country, because even personal relationships between leaders are important here, but they cannot be decisive. Decisive for any person who heads a small or large country, it doesn’t matter, are the interests of the people who entrusted him to lead the country. And first and foremost, he must be guided by the interests of his people.

As for relationships between people, that is a different matter. You know, it seems to me that we can talk about true friendship when we not only respect another person, we recognize that he is better than us in something, smarter, more experienced, braver, something else, but better in something—this is the first point. And the second very important component is that we are ready not just to support him, but we are ready to do everything to ensure that the person is well, that he develops, that he moves forward, and under certain circumstances, we are even ready to make certain sacrifices in relation to the person we consider our friend, and he considers us his friend.

While I was speaking just now, I remembered something—since we are talking about history—my family’s history. My father was a participant in the Great Patriotic War, he fought, among other things, on the Leningrad front, in the so-called Nevsky Patch. This is a small piece of land on one of the banks, about two kilometers deep, four kilometers wide, well, approximately. And all around it were fascist troops, while our main forces were on the other bank of the Neva River. In general, it was a meat grinder there. And the German troops were stationed a little higher, and they easily shot through this small patch. And our soldiers held it to use this foothold for the future lifting of the blockade, for breaking the blockade of Leningrad. And there, of course, it was very difficult to survive. My father was wounded. But in order for him to stay alive, he had to be transported to the hospital. The hospital was on the other side of the Neva River, and to get him there, one had to risk their life. And, to be honest, there were not many volunteers because even at night, if one crawled to the other side of the Neva River on the ice—and it was winter—a person doing this was in mortal danger because the searchlights easily illuminated everything, and any target was easily destroyed. And it turned out that his neighbor from the house, from the apartment, a friend, was fighting next to him. He took him and dragged him, risking his own life. He dragged him to the other side of the Neva River, delivered him to the hospital, handed him over, hugged him, and said: well, goodbye, you will live, and I am going back, I am going to die. That is friendship and a sense of duty, both to a specific person, to his friend, and to the Motherland. And he went back to that Nevsky Patch.

But since we have already started talking, I will finish this story. Somewhere in 1962, my father came home with tears in his eyes. He met this friend of his in a store, by chance. It turned out he was alive.

So these powerful impulses often not only save people but also elevate them, help them to win.

M. Tolkacheva: Thank you.

Guys, who else is ready to ask a question?

Let’s hear from a representative of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia). Vlad, you have the floor.

V. Burnashev: Thank you very much.

Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Vladislav, I am 16 years old. I am proud of my region, my people, our rich resources, and of course, our unique culture.

Before I ask my question, I would like to thank you. The summer of 2021 in Yakutia was remembered for large-scale forest fires. We see your support, we see how you help our republic in solving this problem, and we thank you. Thank you very much.

And moving on to my question, I would like to say that I am from the Mirny district, where our entire life is connected with the diamond mining company "Alrosa." Our fathers, grandmothers, grandfathers, parents—all work or have worked in this company.

Currently, the global market is actively developing the direction of creating and developing synthetic diamonds, which outperform the diamonds mined here in Yakutia in many respects. This includes easier extraction, relatively low cost, and better quality. But it can be noted that the public joint-stock company "Alrosa" provides 40 percent of the budget of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia), and 65 percent of the budget of the Mirny district. Because of this, our entire life is connected with our native company.

Also, in the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia), there is a regional technical college in the city of Mirny, which is trying to develop training in the oil extraction industry. But we, the youth, still do not see real participation from the oil companies operating in the territory of the republic in inviting and employing local residents. Perhaps this is related to the fact that we do not yet have a system for training personnel for the oil extraction industry.

We, the youth, want to stay in our native republic, in our district, in our city, with our families. But due to the fact that we do not yet have such a system for training personnel, we believe that it is necessary to create a modern educational institution or a specialized faculty for training personnel for the oil industry.

What do you think, should this direction be developed in our republic?

Of course, it should. And it is not only a matter for Yakutia. The fact is that we have a certain imbalance in the number of young specialists prepared by the leading universities of the country, not only in Moscow and St. Petersburg but also in Siberia: there are many, including Tomsk and Novosibirsk, it doesn’t matter, there are many, both federal and so-called scientific centers based on universities are being created. But the problem is that when people from the periphery come there, very few want to return. And we need personnel in the places, that is for sure. And therefore, we have already made a decision that the overwhelming majority of new budget places for education in higher, and not only higher but also secondary educational institutions will be allocated to regional universities. In this way, we will raise the level of teaching and create appropriate conditions for people who want to get an education and stay in their homeland.

And, of course, we need to develop new methods and forms of education. I mean creating network forms of education, where a person, living and studying in one territory at one higher educational institution, can easily take advantage of the opportunities, quality, and level of teaching at other specialized higher or secondary educational institutions. Modern technology and modern means of communication can certainly organize this. Right now, we are working on this. And I am confident that it will work out.

Now, as for Yakutia. I want to take this opportunity to thank everyone who made maximum efforts to fight the fires, I mean not only the employees of the Ministry of Emergency Situations or forest protection but also the volunteers, of whom you had many, and people have shown and continue to show their best qualities, working in very difficult, dangerous conditions and solving problems for the sake of their republic and for the sake of the whole country. We will do everything to support them in the future, we will improve the regulatory framework to increase the role, significance, and responsibility of federal authorities in this area. And, of course, we will do everything to help the people who have suffered.

V. Burnashev: Thank you very much.

We should probably wrap up.

M. Tolkacheva: Let’s.

Darya, please.

D. Osherovskaya: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Daria Osherovskaya, I am from the city of Kaluga, which is the cradle of not only domestic but also global astronautics. And that is why I have been fascinated by space since the very moment I first saw the bright starry sky in early childhood. Therefore, I am concerned about the issues of our astronautics, especially its private side. I am also an activist of the Russian Schoolchildren's Movement.

At the beginning of your speech, you mentioned the Russian Society "Knowledge," which started giving its master classes this May. I participated in one of those, and it was thanks to "Knowledge" and RDSh-science that I was able to communicate with Mikhail Valentinovich Kovalchuk and Elon Musk live on air. I also attended a science camp where we built drones, I assembled my own cubesat with my own hands, and I met other kids who are genuinely interested in this. And yesterday, our activists launched a drone show for September 1 as a gift to all schoolchildren.

But when I returned to Kaluga, I faced a small problem. The thing is, science has not developed as rapidly here as it has in Moscow, where festivals were taking place.

In this regard, I have a proposal. For each scientific circle or some kind of association, we should introduce scientific mentorship or supervision from educators from universities who can help us implement our projects. We have ideas, we have motivation, we have time, but we lack the conditions for conducting any complex experiments or confirming theories. Such assistance would also help us immediately determine the project topic and so on. This could help us get noticed by interesting companies. And just today, Yegor was talking about the development of the "Pushkin Card," such projects could also be directed towards the scientific side with the involvement of such associations.

Thank you.

We just spoke with a resident of Yakutia, and I mentioned that it is possible to organize the educational process using modern technologies and attract the best specialists in various fields without going anywhere and receiving education locally, in college or in a higher educational institution. The same way can be used to organize the implementation of the idea you just formulated. Let's try to do this; I have noted it for myself. Colleagues are surely writing, there is probably some record of our conversation. We will not forget this and will try to implement it.

D. Osherovskaya: Thank you very much.

The girl here raised her hand. Please.

A. Sadrieva: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

Hello!

A. Sadrieva: My name is Sadrieva Aisha. I am 14 years old, and I came from the city of Bor in the Nizhny Novgorod region.

What region?

A. Sadrieva: Nizhny Novgorod.

I really love animals, and I am concerned about the problem of homeless pets. Together with my friends and sister, we rescued a pigeon, but unfortunately, it died from internal bleeding. I have a cat at home that we picked up from the street. My grandparents have a cat that they rescued, and my aunt has a cat that we found near our house and also rescued. When I go for a walk, I take animal food with me because I often encounter homeless, drooping animals and feed them.

Almost all the kids who came to the lesson today are volunteers, and that is why I propose to create a common nationwide map of animal shelters. Since I have been dealing with this problem for quite some time, I have already managed to study all the shelters for homeless animals in my region.

I propose that each child from their region create their own map, marking the points of shelters for homeless animals. And I want this to be done by children because I believe that love for animals should be instilled from childhood. And I would like you to help us later combine all our pieces of the map into a common nationwide one and give such an order so that our initiative is noticed and does not go unnoticed.

Thank you.

In fact, this is not just a noble activity, but a very important one. I will tell you why now, and you will immediately agree with me.

Yes, homeless animals are a big problem for our smaller brothers; they suffer. You know, when people leave their dachas, many simply abandon their pets—cats, dogs, and so on—who are not guilty of anything but really suffer. And a modern civilized person cannot just walk by and watch an animal suffer. That is the first point.

But, on the other hand, there is another equally acute problem—stray dogs. How many cases do we know of stray dogs attacking people, children! It is a dangerous thing. And therefore, we need to solve these issues in a civilized manner. We recently passed a law, and it has quite serious provisions on how to treat animals. I will not reproduce this law now.

But your proposal is absolutely in the right direction; we need to look at these shelters for homeless animals, see how they are organized, and unite all this, at least in virtual space, exchange information, experience, and improve practices and regulatory frameworks. Therefore, the idea is good; we will try to help you.

A. Sadrieva: Thank you very much.

I have long dreamed of shaking your hand, and may I do that?

You may.

A. Sadrieva: Thank you.

So, shall we wrap up, or is there something else?

M. Tolkacheva: Maybe a couple more questions related to your life? The kids would also like to know a lot about you.

Please, sure, a couple.

M. Tolkacheva: Kirill, maybe you can ask.

K. Meshcheryakov: Hello, Vladimir Vladimirovich!

My name is Meshcheryakov Kirill. I am from the city of Dmitrov in the Moscow region.

In conclusion of our meeting, I would like to ask you this question: what would you wish for yourself at 16?

I can hardly remember… No, I will say this now. I have already said that every person is searching for themselves, choosing, choosing their path. I was also engaged in this, starting from 16-17 years old, I thought about it, made all sorts of plans. The most important thing is to determine the goal.

Today, when we started our meeting, I said that for any lecture, for any conversation, for a lesson, the most important thing is what? The goal for which it is done. But what can we say about the goal in life! This is an extremely defining thing—if the goal is clear, understandable, then there are all chances to achieve it; then a person begins to look for ways to implement this task, to solve these questions related to achieving this goal.

Therefore, the most important thing is to find yourself, your goal. And the second most important component is not to be afraid to dream, to believe in yourself, and success is guaranteed.

K. Meshcheryakov: Thank you very much.

M. Tolkacheva: Vladimir Vladimirovich, thank you very much for taking the time for us, for taking the time for the kids, for answering their questions. I think this meeting will stay in their memory for a long time, not only for our class but also for the kids who watched us live.

And of course, we cannot let you go without a group photo.

Yes. And I wanted to thank you, everyone gathered here. It is clear that you seem like ordinary girls and boys, and at the same time, how can I put it, as it is fashionable to say now, advanced, literate, goal-oriented, focused. You are interesting. I sincerely wish you good luck from the bottom of my heart.

Happy holiday, Knowledge Day! Happy September 1!