Plenary session of the International Arctic Forum

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

9 April 2019 · International Arctic Forum, plenary session · St. Petersburg, Russia

Context
Putin addressed the fifth International Arctic Forum in St. Petersburg on April 9, 2019, outlining Russia's Arctic development priorities and Northern Sea Route ambitions.
Main themes
Arctic development strategy, Northern Sea Route expansion, transport and infrastructure investment, environmental sustainability, Arctic Council chairmanship, liquefied natural gas and energy projects, icebreaker fleet modernization, indigenous peoples of the North, international cooperation in the Arctic, socio-economic development of Arctic regions, port and coastal infrastructure, cargo transportation growth
Duration
~141 min
99th percentile
Words
16,873
99th percentile
Sentences
1,059
99th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Russian

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

1,059 sentences in 311 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Niinistö! Dear Mr. Johannesson! Dear Ms. Sulberg! Dear Mr. Löfven! Ladies and gentlemen, friends!

I sincerely welcome all of you to St. Petersburg, the Northern capital of Russia, a city whose history is closely linked to the organization of legendary Arctic expeditions, to the industrial development of this unique region, and to the preservation of its nature and distinctive culture.

For the fifth time, the International Forum "Arctic – Territory of Dialogue" serves as a platform for broad, open discussions on the Arctic agenda. We are grateful to our foreign guests, representatives of the Arctic Council states, for their willingness to partner with us and for their understanding of our shared responsibility for the future of the Arctic, for its stable and sustainable development.

In 2021, Russia will assume the chairmanship of the Arctic Council. We invite all countries participating in this organization, as well as other states, to cooperate in the Arctic. The priorities of our chairmanship are vital topics for the development of the Arctic: promoting nature-saving technologies in all areas, in industry, transport, and energy.

It is precisely on the basis of the most modern environmental standards that we are implementing our projects in the Arctic today, including those of global significance. It is enough to mention the liquefied natural gas production complex in Yamal, the development of the Bovanenkovo and Kharasavey gas fields. Currently, the Arctic accounts for more than 10 percent of all investments in the Russian Federation. I am convinced that the significance of the Arctic factor in the country's economy will only grow.

This year, we intend to prepare and adopt a new strategy for the development of the Russian Arctic until 2035. It should unite the activities of our national projects and state programs, the investment plans of infrastructure companies, and the development programs for Arctic regions and cities.

By key socio-economic indicators, by the quality of life of people, all Arctic regions must be brought to a level no lower than the national average. I would like to emphasize: such a task must not only be clearly defined in the new Arctic development strategy but also serve as a guideline for the work of all federal agencies and regional authorities in Russia. It is essential to take into account the specific issues concerning the indigenous small-numbered peoples of the North.

Particular attention must be paid to the development of transport and other supporting infrastructure. We understand well that this is the foundation, the necessary base for future investments and business initiatives. Among the key infrastructure projects is the construction of the Northern Latitude Route. This railway will enable the effective development of the natural resources of the Polar Urals and Yamal, and in the future, the north of the Krasnoyarsk Territory of the Russian Federation. And of course, we will continue our work on the development of the global transport corridor, including the Northern Sea Route, which will operate smoothly and year-round.

In the Address to the Federal Assembly in 2018, it was already noted that our goal is to significantly increase the volume of cargo transportation here. Only along the Northern Sea Route – up to 80 million tons by 2025. Just 10-15 years ago, this figure seemed absolutely unattainable. Now it is a realistic, calculated, and concrete task. According to last year's results, the volume of transportation along the Northern Sea Route has already reached 20 million tons. And this is three times – I want to emphasize this – three times higher than the Soviet record set in 1987. Back then, the Soviet Union transported 6.5 million tons along this route. And now – twenty.

In order for this global transport corridor to operate at full capacity, we will develop communication and coastal infrastructure, including port facilities, navigation means, meteorological monitoring, and ensuring the safety of commercial navigation.

We invite our foreign partners to work together on the creation of hub ports at the endpoints of the route. I mean the Murmansk transport hub and the port infrastructure in Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky. In addition, we intend to modernize the ports along the Arctic coast, including the capabilities for organizing "river-sea" transportation.

We will continue to renew our icebreaker fleet and increase the production of ice-class vessels. Here, where we are with you in St. Petersburg, three new nuclear icebreakers are being built: "Arktika," "Sibir," and "Ural." By 2035, the Arctic fleet of Russia will consist of at least 13 heavy linear icebreakers, including nine nuclear ones.

I want to emphasize: the task is to make the Northern Sea Route safe and profitable for shippers, attractive in terms of both service quality and price. In particular, the fee for icebreaker escort of vessels must be competitive and justified. The state invests its resources in this area to minimize the tariff burden on carriers and businesses.

Dear friends! To increase capital investments in the region, to launch new projects, we intend to use all investment support tools, including those that we have already successfully tested within the framework of the development programs for the Far Eastern regions of Russia. I am primarily talking about preferential profit tax rates, reducing coefficients for the mineral extraction tax, and the application process for value-added tax refunds, as well as the simplified procedure for providing land plots and the stability of the conditions for implementing investment projects.

At the same time, of course, taking into account the specifics of the Arctic – the preferences for investors must be and will be, as they say, even more advanced, more sustainable.

The Government of Russia – here I am already addressing my colleagues – together with experts and business representatives has been instructed to develop a draft special federal law on a special system of preferences for investors in the Arctic zone. And I ask you to carry out this work promptly so that the law is adopted by the State Duma of the Russian Federation in the upcoming autumn session.

And one more point I would like to draw your attention to, dear colleagues. We know that the powers of the Ministry for the Development of the Far East have been expanded: now its sphere of responsibility includes the Arctic. In this regard, I believe it is logical to extend the work of the development institutions of the Far East to the Arctic, if necessary, to ensure the recapitalization of the Far East Development Fund for targeted financing of Arctic projects.

Next. For the comprehensive development of the region, to solve unique, non-standard tasks in the high latitudes, we need a strong scientific, personnel, and technological base. We have already begun to create scientific and educational centers in the regions of the country that integrate the capabilities of universities, research institutes, businesses, and the real sector of the economy. Such a center will certainly be established in one of our Arctic regions and must ensure both the development of fundamental science and the solution of applied, practical tasks for the development of the Arctic.

At the same time, we believe that the future lies in active academic and university exchanges, in the creation of international research teams, alliances of high-tech companies. And we invite all interested colleagues to work together in the field of shipbuilding, communications, maritime safety, ecology, mineral extraction, and bioresources.

The Arctic presents us with colossal challenges. And we can respond to them – effectively, at least respond – only together. One of these challenges – as I have already mentioned – is to ensure a balance between economic development and the preservation of Arctic nature, the conservation of its unique, fragile biosystems, and, of course, the elimination of the damage accumulated during sometimes extensive, consumer-oriented economic activities in past decades. For several years now, we have been conducting what is called a general cleanup of Arctic territories. Since 2012, more than 80,000 tons of waste have been removed and disposed of.

In the coming years, as part of the federal project "Clean Country," we will eliminate six major sites of accumulated environmental damage in the Arkhangelsk and Murmansk regions, the Nenets Autonomous Okrug, Karelia, and Yakutia. We also plan to clean up the waters of the Kola Bay over an area of more than 200 square kilometers.

We will develop the system of specially protected natural areas, reserves. First and foremost, this refers to the Russian Arctic National Park. It is important to provide for additional measures to develop civilized ecological tourism here and to create the necessary infrastructure.

In conclusion, dear friends, I would like to thank all participants and guests of our forum. I am confident that our constructive dialogue will serve to strengthen good-neighborly relations and trust in the Arctic region, and thus to the peaceful and sustainable development of the Arctic.

Thank you for your attention. Thank you very much.

J. Fryer: Mr. President, thank you very much! If I may, I would like to ask you a very short question in continuation of your speech before the next speech. You spoke about the development of the Arctic. I would like to know more about this.

First, allow me to ask a broader question regarding the political landscape of your relations with the European Union. Here, the leaders of Sweden and Norway, you are meeting with them for the first time in a long time. Do you think this is a kind of breakthrough moment? Perhaps the poor relations that Russia has had with the European Union over the past few years are now improving, and a "thaw" is beginning.

Unfortunately, in the Arctic, there is a thaw, that is true, and it is a thaw in temperature change. In the Arctic, it is happening at a faster pace than in the rest of the planet. Four times faster, can you imagine? That is, the temperature in the Arctic is rising four times faster than the planet as a whole.

But as for political relations, this is undoubtedly a positive process. Although, you know, I mentioned in my speech that we have not interrupted our contacts on Arctic issues. Just now, we held a bilateral meeting with the President of Finland and recalled that we regularly hold these meetings.

Finland currently chairs the Arctic Council and has done a lot to raise, discuss, and achieve solutions to key issues of Arctic nature conservation, constantly paying attention to the problematic issues that we must solve together.

Well, the fact that Arctic issues help us understand the necessity of cooperation and solving common tasks is, of course, very good.

J. Fryer: Thank you. We will talk about politics, about regional policy later. And now I give the floor to the President of Finland. Please.

S. Niinistö: Dear colleagues, ladies and gentlemen!

It is a great pleasure for me to participate in the work of this forum for the third time. I want to thank you, Mr. President Putin, thank the Russian Government, and all the organizers for holding this event.

After Salekhard in 2013 and Arkhangelsk in 2017, holding the forum in St. Petersburg means that this forum is moving closer to the North. And I am particularly pleased to be on this stage today with my colleagues from the northern countries.

We live in uncertain times regarding international relations. Confrontation and hostility seem to be on the rise. As a remedy, we always talk about the importance of dialogue. And in our speeches, we now consider dialogue as a means of reducing tension, addressing risk-related issues, and restoring trust. But too often, that is where it ends. We simply talk about dialogue instead of engaging in it. It is difficult to have a dialogue if you do not meet with your counterpart.

I sincerely believe that Arctic issues must be discussed at the level of heads of state and government, sitting face to face and engaging in dialogue. And this is the rational kernel that underlies the Finnish initiative related to convening the first Arctic summit. Last year, we expressed this idea, and we received a promising response from all sides. Nevertheless, the tension that exists far from the Arctic interfered with our plans. At least it is good that the tradition of these forums continues. Although, of course, these forums do not replace the idea of a summit.

Ladies and gentlemen!

The main concern related to the Arctic is undoubtedly climate change, in my opinion. On the other hand, in the North, we are the first to feel the warming. The Arctic is warming twice as fast as the rest of the planet. And the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change last year in its report showed that the Arctic is one of the most vulnerable systems on our planet. On the other hand, what happens in the Arctic directly affects the rest of the world. The melting ice in the Arctic accelerates climate change on a global level, and we must break this vicious circle. We have waited too long and done nothing. The good thing is that we know what needs to be done. And, in general, the other two parts of the global solution are very simple.

First. We must rapidly reduce new CO2 emissions into the atmosphere. The Paris Agreement is a great foundation for this, although we still need to expand our ambitions. Recent information from our Russian organizers indicates that they plan to ratify the Paris Agreement, and this can only be welcomed. That was the first.

Second. We must remove old CO2 emissions from the atmosphere. We need to improve the use of carbon from combustion, and we must conduct our forest policies on a sustainable basis. Besides CO2, there are other factors that influence climate change. Among them is soot, which directly affects the fate of Arctic ice. When soot lands on the ice, it immediately accelerates the melting of the ice. By reducing soot emissions, we will achieve a quick positive result. At a separate event that Finland held this morning, experts representing government, science, and business identified two opportunities to address the issue of soot emissions in the Arctic.

The first is the modernization of outdated power plants, and the second is investment in clean and sustainable shipping. These approaches will not only have a positive impact on the climate and health, but they will also be beneficial for the economy.

Ladies and gentlemen! As you well know, over the past two years, Finland has chaired the Arctic Council. During this time, as chair, we have done everything in our power to ensure that the Arctic remains a region of opportunities. Based on our priorities (which are environmental protection, connectivity, meteorology, and education), we have sought pragmatic cooperation in the common interest. Our chairmanship will end in four weeks when the foreign ministers of all eight Council members meet in Rovaniemi. After that, we will pass this responsibility to Iceland, and two years later, Russia will take over the chairmanship. Together, we must continue to make the best use of these exceptionally important frameworks.

Thanks to its existence, the Arctic Council has been a forum for constructive dialogue, and this spirit is by no means a characteristic of the current situation in the world. Nevertheless, we have managed to maintain this spirit in the Arctic Council in recent years, and this is a significant achievement, as well as a wonderful goal for future activities.

Tensions beyond the Arctic should not affect the work of the Arctic Council. But if we want to move forward in our ambitions, we must do more than just protect the work of the Arctic Council from external uncertainty. We must use this work as positive advice for others. We should use it as a model for reducing tensions in other regions. We, the Arctic countries, know that small practical steps in the common interest in various areas help build trust, even if there may be disagreements in other areas.

And this example can gain even greater strength if we can consolidate cooperation between the Arctic Council and other regional structures. The Barents/Euro-Arctic Council, the Arctic Coast Guard Forum, and the Northern Dimension Partnership all positively contribute to work in the Arctic. Information exchange between them and the Arctic Council can be beneficial for all.

Ladies and gentlemen! Undoubtedly, the Arctic region itself is not free from tensions. It is clear to everyone that economic and strategic interests in the Arctic are growing. The climate, both natural and political, is changing, and many actors see new opportunities precisely in our region. And not all of these actors are Arctic countries. This does not automatically mean that all new actors coming into the region have only narrow self-serving interests and intentions, but the risk of confrontation is increasing as the number of participants grows. First and foremost, I mean confrontation and the possibility of disrupting the fragile natural balance in the Arctic. Unfortunately, we cannot rule out the possibility of confrontation in terms of politics and power. Security and military security issues have always remained outside the Arctic Council's agenda.

We have done this intentionally, and it is part of our success. And there is no reason why we should change such a mandate for the Council. However, simply excluding these issues from the Council's agenda will not allow us to brush them aside. Together, Arctic countries must find another opportunity to responsibly address these issues. Again, dialogue is key. Reducing tensions, managing risks, restoring trust—this can only work if we talk to each other.

Thank you.

J. Fryer: Thank you.

A brief question. Indeed, climate change is a megatrend, and it runs like a red thread through all issues. We are talking about reducing CO2 emissions in the Arctic. Of course, Russia is the largest economy in this region. Do you believe that Russia is doing enough in this regard?

S. Niinistö: We need to see the whole picture. The climate is changing, CO2 emissions are part of the picture, they are a constant and very dangerous part of this picture. But we also need to talk about soot. This is an immediate risk. Even this is a greater danger for the Arctic than global warming. Who is heating our world? I fear that everyone is. That is my answer.

Who is responsible for soot emissions, especially the soot that comes to the Arctic and settles in the Arctic? It is those who live nearby. Russia—yes, a large country, but also the USA, Canada, and all the rest of us. And, as I said, soot is an immediate threat, but it is also a positive immediate threat. That is, if we eliminate this influence, this threat, we will feel it immediately.

J. Fryer: We will return to this later and talk more about climate change.

President Jóhannesson, your turn, please.

G. Jóhannesson: President Putin! President Niinistö! Prime Minister Löfven! Prime Minister Solberg! Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed guests!

It is an honor for me to be here with you today in St. Petersburg. This is a territory of dialogue. And it is a great honor for me to represent the Republic of Iceland. We are here to emphasize the Arctic. In a couple of weeks, Iceland will take on the responsibilities of chairing the Arctic Council. Finland will pass this responsibility to us. I want to say that Finland has been a wonderful leader, has done a great job, I assure you of that, Mr. President.

The Arctic is a key priority for our foreign policy. In 2011, the Althing, our parliament, developed and adopted an Arctic policy with the support of all parties. Believe me, this does not happen very often in Iceland. The current government of Iceland places a high priority on Arctic issues and our chairmanship of the Arctic Council in its policy. And we approach Arctic issues both from the perspective of a territory of dialogue, with our "Arctic Circle," and with other organizations that serve as excellent forums, but the Arctic Council stands out due to its character and its long and quality history of implementing quality projects in environmental protection and sustainable development.

In the Arctic Council, our team will work under the slogan "Together for a Sustainable Arctic!" Along with this, Iceland will focus on three main areas. The first is the marine environment of the Arctic. The second is climate and energy-saving solutions. And finally, the third is the people living in the Arctic.

But this will hardly be a surprise to you. Undoubtedly, the oceans are close to our hearts. We have 350,000 people living here, we are located in the middle of the North Atlantic, surrounded by oceans full of fish, and we are just a rock where few people live, but many happy tourists come. But the sea is the foundation of our economic prosperity in the last century and in this century.

Our success in the last century was directly tied to the development of a modern sustainable fishing sector, which in turn depended on how well we could control our exclusive economic zone. And we are often told that we, a small country, clashed with a powerful opponent. This happened more than once in the last century, and interesting stories were told about how Icelandic coast guards used peaceful means to prevent foreign fishing vessels from catching fish in our waters.

We were then the smallest country, I was a small boy, I heard these stories. Then I learned how multilateral cooperation influenced this and how it helped us resolve these disputes and solve these problems. The Convention on the Law of the Sea was ultimately adopted.

As President of Iceland, I am deeply interested in all issues related to the oceans. They play an important role in our pursuit of a sustainable future and prosperity worldwide. I also want to say that here in St. Petersburg, this summer, we intend to hold a global fishing forum.

Iceland supports the work of the Arctic Council, and an international scientific conference on Arctic and Arctic Ocean pollution by plastics will be organized as part of the action plan to reduce ocean pollution. It will take place in April next year. This is regarding the ocean. The ocean is at the center of our attention when it comes to the marine environment.

So, climate and nature-saving technologies.

We will focus on the blue bioeconomy. This will positively impact pollution reduction, strengthen the economy, and support societal development.

Furthermore, in this way, we can emphasize the importance of cooperation in the Arctic region. I can confidently state and even repeat that we look forward to Finland passing its powers to us so that we can lead what we believe is the most representative organization for this region—the Arctic Council. After that, we will be happy to pass this honorable function to Russia. In two years, Russia and President Putin will take the presidency in the Arctic Council.

So, the third stage, the third part of our program is dedicated, of course, to the indigenous peoples of the Arctic. As part of our chairmanship in the Arctic Council, Iceland intends to continue cooperation on such important topics as ensuring connectivity in this region, ensuring social well-being, and, of course, this includes quality of life. This is an absolute priority of Iceland's policy. And, undoubtedly, this is a universal principle and a fundamental human right to a comfortable existence.

Let us not forget the extreme importance of cultural and academic exchanges.

Of course, we must not forget the voices of the indigenous peoples of the Arctic. This is their home, this is their nature, and of course, we must listen to what they say. They know how high the stakes are. The Arctic is such a remote region, and suddenly it has found itself at the center of the world's attention. Indigenous peoples often say that all the problems of the Arctic began when the world started to notice and take an interest in it. Let us not forget about the Arctic region. But we must be a positive force that brings about positive change in the region.

Dear friends! I first came to St. Petersburg in 1990. At that time, the city was still called differently, it was 1990, it was a different world, and it was then that I became fascinated with Russian history, Russian culture, and this fascination is still with me. I learned the Russian language, which turned out to be somewhat more difficult than I had anticipated. I probably would never have started learning it if I had known how difficult it was. But still, if we try, if we try to understand each other, if we try to start a truly open dialogue, then the risk of conflicts and misunderstandings will be significantly reduced.

(I speak in Russian.) And therefore, dear guests (a little in Russian at the end), I speak poorly in Russian, please forgive me. But I learned it many years ago, I have forgotten almost everything, but this I remember, this I can say, and this I want to say: there is nothing more precious on this earth than true friendship.

Thank you very much.

J. Fryer: Mr. President, thank you very much for such warm words.

If I may, let us touch on the issue of daily politics and daily risks. We have already heard from the President of Finland that the Arctic Council is a unique organization that allows for addressing issues and managing the region.

But what do you think, we are now seeing increasing political tension around the Arctic. Do you think it may be time to expand the activities of the Arctic Council and work on strategic issues of tension?

G. Jóhannesson: Thank you very much for the question.

I would agree with President Niinistö's statement. Indeed, the Arctic Council is not a platform where hard security issues or military security measures are discussed. It is extremely important that the Arctic Council is an effective platform for dialogue.

Hard security measures are intentionally kept aside; we seek ways to peacefully resolve conflicts, but most importantly, it is important for us to openly express our concerns. If we see complexity, we need to find ways to resolve it, and, as Mr. Niinistö rightly pointed out, there are other ways to discuss hard security measures.

I can also assure you that the government of Iceland, as part of its chairmanship, will remain true to the principles and spirit of the Arctic Council.

J. Fryer: So, you do not plan any serious changes?

G. Jóhannesson: We will see.

J. Fryer: Thank you very much.

Madam Prime Minister, the floor is yours.

E. Solberg: Esteemed Presidents, Prime Ministers, ladies and gentlemen! Dear friends of the Arctic!

I am very pleased to be here today with you. Today we are discussing the most important issues—the issues of the Arctic. We will also discuss the opportunities that lie before us today, and above all, these are opportunities for cooperation in the region.

But, of course, we have reasons for concern. The recent report on new record-high temperatures in Canada and around the world is alarming. The fact is that temperatures in the Arctic are rising twice as fast as in the rest of the world. These rapid changes certainly raise concerns and, moreover, have the most immediate impact on the environment and life across the planet. And, of course, it is the indigenous peoples who are primarily affected. We cannot afford to lose a moment. We need more dialogues, more cooperation. We must rely on international law and work effectively with risks. At the same time, we must seek opportunities.

Ten percent of Norway's population lives in the Arctic. That is why this issue is a key national priority. We need to develop a clear vision for ensuring a sustainable and comfortable life in the North. We understand that this must be a sensible process of managing the region, based on knowledge and experience. Yes, of course, Norway does not have answers to all questions, but we have a relatively successful track record, and this success is primarily based on consultations with the international community and expert opinions.

Another important point is the so-called "green thinking" or "green philosophy." Furthermore, it is very important to involve scientists and experts, politicians, and society in this dialogue.

People who live and raise children in the Arctic deserve to live in a comfortable, modern society. That is why we must invest in infrastructure. We need to create comfortable kindergartens, good schools, and universities. But equally important are football fields, concert halls, and hospitals.

I know that Russia has always shared this philosophy. But now we need to adapt this thinking to create a "green" future for the Arctic. And, of course, in this regard, political leadership is important. It is important to develop and implement new, modern, "green" technologies, defined by political will. "Green thinking" is part of this solution, and it must certainly be framed as business opportunities.

Sometimes we hear that the Arctic is a hotspot of geopolitical tension. We see the Arctic differently. We know that the Arctic is a region of peace and stability. But we cannot take this for granted. It is the result of political decisions and practical cooperation among Arctic states.

We are pleased that there is an effective legal regime, and certainly, the most important tool in this regard is maritime law. It is based on respect for legislation, international law, and regional cooperation that we can ensure peace in this region. And, of course, the Arctic Council is an important platform for dialogue and practical cooperation. It is indeed a crucial venue for discussing issues of mutual interest in this region.

One reason for success is that the Arctic Council brings together key actors, including indigenous peoples. It is thanks to the Arctic Council that we can find joint solutions to these regional challenges, as well as ensure stability and development in the region.

The ministerial meeting in Rovaniemi in May will mark the successful conclusion of Finland's chairmanship in the Arctic Council. The Arctic Council has conducted extensive, grand work in documenting climate change in the region. And we want the ministerial meeting to send a serious message to the public – climate change. And we hope that all participants in the meeting will agree on this.

Norway and Russia are neighbors, and we have always successfully cooperated and shared interests in the North. Agreements on preventing incidents at sea, on cooperation between the coast guards of the two countries, as well as joint initiatives for environmental protection, and the existence of a direct "hotline" between the Norwegian military staff and the Russian Northern Fleet are effective mechanisms that work for the benefit of both states.

But we must ensure that our cooperation is not just about meetings and agreements; above all, it is about the relationships between our people, between our countries, which is the foundation of strong bilateral relations. We take pride in the fact that our swimmers and wrestlers from Russia and Norway train together in Murmansk, that there are Norwegian-Russian orchestras, and that Norwegian students study in Arkhangelsk. This is truly the most valuable.

And, more importantly, cooperation between our countries is based on respect and understanding of mutual, sometimes different, cultures. And the main platform for such contacts is, of course, the Barents/Euro-Arctic Council. In October, Norway will take over the chairmanship of the Barents/Euro-Arctic Council, and we will work to make the Barents Sea region safer. We will pay special attention to health issues, people-to-people contacts, and knowledge.

The ocean is at the heart of every Norwegian, it is a way of life, it is a constant that has always been present in Norwegian history. The sea is the ocean in peace for Norway, and, of course, the ocean economy will always remain very important for Arctic states in the future. Healthy oceans are a prerequisite for achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.

Managing and maintaining the ocean ecosystems, based on knowledge and science, cooperation among coastal states are key factors for ensuring stability. And, of course, all maritime states, especially Arctic states, bear a special responsibility to protect our oceans and keep them healthy and full of life and resources. Norway and Russia have always actively cooperated in this area for 60 years.

Over 40 years of joint fisheries management, we have managed to protect the environment while also achieving good fish catches in the Barents Sea. We ensure sustainable development, and as a result, the cod caught in the northeastern Atlantic, particularly in the Barents Sea, is in excellent condition. This is truly a wonderful example of successful cooperation between the two countries that should be followed by others.

Another important issue is, of course, marine litter. Norway and Russia are now joining efforts to protect the Barents Sea from litter. And, of course, all Arctic states must combat these threats and protect the vast potential of the oceans. We must make the most efficient use of ocean resources and unite the efforts of coast guards and, of course, the people who live on the coast.

Our task is to protect the oceans and optimize their value. That is why I have created a high-level group on sustainable ocean economy, which includes leaders from 14 coastal states and a number of experts. In October, Norway will host the seventh ocean conference. Thus, we want to emphasize the importance of ensuring sustainable development of the ocean economy and the responsible use of marine and coastal resources.

Ladies and gentlemen! In conclusion, let me once again emphasize the importance of dialogue and cooperation.

And now I would like to thank the Russian side and the organizers for inviting all of us to this platform and providing the opportunity to discuss the opportunities and challenges of the Arctic. Thus, we will all become a little wiser. It is wisdom that we all need to create a sustainable future for our generations.

Thank you very much.

J. Fryer: Thank you very much, Madam Prime Minister.

At the very beginning of the panel discussion, I mentioned that it has been a long time since there were contacts between the Prime Minister of Norway and President Putin. Why did you come now? Has something changed?

E. Solberg: I was just invited now.

Seriously, I believe that this discussion – about the Arctic and the oceans – is more important than ever. These are the issues that unite countries. They are key issues on which we have cooperated for a long time. Most of our bilateral cooperation is focused on these issues. And therefore, of course, this is a key issue. And perhaps it is the most important issue on our international agenda – the connection between the oceans and the Arctic. So this is a very timely invitation.

J. Fryer: Thank you very much.

Prime Minister Löfven, the floor is yours.

S. Löfven: Mr. President Putin, Mr. President Niinistö, President Johannesson, Prime Minister Solberg, Your Excellencies! Ladies and gentlemen!

It is a true joy for me to be here at this wonderful forum. First of all, let me thank President Putin and the Government of the Russian Federation for gathering us here in St. Petersburg once again. This is a stunningly beautiful city on the Baltic Sea.

This city has great historical significance for Swedish-Russian relations. It reminds us of both peaceful and not-so-peaceful times in our long shared history. I will quote the great Pushkin: "From here we will threaten the Swede, here a city will be founded in spite of the arrogant neighbor." End of quote.

Today, St. Petersburg provides us with a wonderful platform for dialogue on the Arctic. The Arctic is a region that has always been characterized by peace, stability, and constructive international cooperation based on respect for international law.

Let me emphasize that one of Sweden's key interests is to maintain such a position in the Arctic. So far, we have succeeded in this, largely thanks to the successful work of the Arctic Council, which has created a political environment that allows for solutions beneficial to all.

We have concluded a number of legally binding agreements that allow us to work together on search and rescue at sea, preventing oil spills, and scientific cooperation. The working groups of the Arctic Council continue to prepare high-quality scientific reports on the issues facing the Arctic.

Let me also highlight the work of the Barents/Euro-Arctic Council. Sweden is currently chairing there. I would like to emphasize the focus this organization places on regional projects, on cooperation on specific projects, and on improving relations between people. This is very important now, as some borders are closing.

Therefore, the Arctic is an example we can be proud of. By working together, in good faith, we strengthen our cooperation in the interest of peace and stability, and in doing so, we realize the enormous potential that lies in this region, our region.

However, the Arctic presents us not only with new opportunities. It also poses a number of serious challenges. Scientific data leaves no room for doubt. The climate crisis in the Arctic is not a scenario for the future. Changes are happening right now. Reports from the Arctic Council indicate that average annual air temperatures in 2014-2018 were higher than in any year since 1900, and in September, the volume of sea ice has decreased by 75 percent since 1979.

It is often said that what happens in the Arctic does not limit its impact only to the Arctic, and that is true. It is also true that what happens in the Arctic does not always have its causes in the Arctic. A global mobilization of resources, a global program is needed to address the challenges facing the Arctic. A new Arctic is emerging, and it requires a new response, it requires new measures in adaptation and resilience. And this responsibility lies with all of us.

Global warming and its consequences in the Arctic can lead not only to a natural, ecological crisis – to a catastrophe. Potentially, these changes could pose a threat to global security. In other words: there is a bill that needs to be paid. Warming in the Arctic could result in costs of $90 trillion by the end of this century.

The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and the Paris Agreement [on climate] are signs of a changing paradigm; they allow us to develop society and achieve our aspirations, ensuring a better life not only for us but also for future generations.

We are now on the brink of a global transformation of our energy system, transitioning from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources. This transformation is not only financially justified, but it is also fulfilling our moral obligation. History tells us that major transformations based on technology and innovation create new opportunities and foster economic growth.

I am convinced that the future is in the hands of those who embrace a new "green" economy, in the hands of those who will invest in sustainable technologies and energy systems based on renewable sources, in the hands of those who strive for innovation for the future rather than trying to draw solutions from the past.

That is why Sweden has set itself the goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2045. In the long term, only by ensuring a low-carbon economy can we achieve growth in the future.

Ladies and gentlemen! The Arctic is by no means an isolated region of ice, wilderness, and harsh landscapes. It is a region defined by the people who live there.

Take, for example, Swedish Lapland – it is reindeer herding, mining, the largest university; that is what Swedish Lapland is, it is stunning natural beauty and places that attract tourists, it is achievements in high technology and IT, as well as the space industry. The North must, of course, develop so that people there can live as well as anywhere else in our countries. However, this underscores the need to ensure sustainable economic, social, and environmental development.

With the help of science-based policy, the Paris Agreement, and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, we have a strong foundation upon which we can build our work. Our common goal is to protect the Arctic through research, business innovation, shared priorities, and, of course, without a doubt, through political will.

We need decisive steps that will lead us to a sustainable future. And, keeping our grandchildren in mind, I would say: "Let's do this."

Thank you.

J. Fryer: Thank you very much.

Now I am very pleased to start the discussion. We will touch on many of the issues that were mentioned in your opening speeches.

Let me start with energy in the Arctic.

Mr. President Putin, you have spoken a lot about expanding Russia's energy infrastructure in the Arctic region, you have talked about utilizing Arctic resources.

This has always been one of your key goals as President.

However, when we look at the energy market and the trends that are observed there, we see that the world is moving towards renewable energy sources, that there is now a lot of shale oil being produced in the United States. Moreover, it is currently very difficult for Russia to implement large projects on the shelf due to sanctions.

So the question is: has Russia missed its chance? Perhaps this Arctic dream will turn into disappointment?

I would like to ask the moderator for two minutes to make some comments during my colleagues' speeches. Is that alright? Thank you very much.

First of all, we have discrepancies with Sauli regarding the data on warming in the Arctic. According to our data, the Arctic is warming four times faster than the rest of the world, and Russia is warming 2.5 times faster than the rest of the world. These may be different calculations, but both are certainly alarming trends.

S. Niinistö: Yes, the warming is happening very quickly.

Yes, absolutely.

Now regarding soot. I know this is a serious issue; Sauli and I have also discussed it. We have different calculations regarding the volumes of these emissions in different countries, including ours, with discrepancies of several times. But I gave him an example when I was far up north, telling him that in ancient ice deposits we observe large inclusions of soot. This was in the Middle Ages, perhaps even earlier, when there were no industrial emissions. The fact is that the emissions from one, say, volcano, can be greater than all emissions from humanity related to automotive transport. Nevertheless, this is a very important issue, and our experts are also working on it.

But what is extremely important, in my opinion, and here I completely agree with Sauli, is that, of course, if ships switch to more environmentally friendly types of fuel, and I mean primarily gas fuel, especially ships operating in northern seas, in the Arctic zone, then this is certainly extremely important. This is absolutely obvious. And we should encourage, of course, shipbuilding companies and carriers to use such types of transport and such fuel.

Now to your question: is Russia, as the largest economy in the region, doing enough to ensure environmental safety in the Arctic? I apologize, but I must correct you. Russia is not the largest economy in the Arctic region. According to the IMF, China ranks first in terms of purchasing power parity and economic volume. It has significantly outpaced the United States, now at about 25 trillion.

J. Fryer: Excuse me, are you saying that China is an Arctic country?

I have been patient while you said all this; please be patient as well.

In second place is the United States of America. And the United States, along with Canada, is an Arctic country. But unlike the United States, we signed and are implementing the Tokyo Agreement, and we signed the Paris Agreement and intend to implement it. Moreover, Russia has committed to reducing emissions by 25-30 percent from 1990 levels. This is, in fact, a significant burden. And as the President of Finland said, we are currently planning ratification, of course, we will do this after a comprehensive analysis of the consequences of implementing these decisions, but nevertheless, we are moving in this direction.

Although I have already mentioned this, the exact causes of warming are still not fully known, and what they are related to: emissions or some other, more global reasons. This is a question. But nonetheless, it will not be worse if we reduce anthropogenic emissions, and Russia is taking on such commitments. But it is not the largest economy. We currently rank sixth in terms of economic volume and purchasing power parity. China, the USA, India, Japan, Germany, and we are in sixth place. But we will strive, of course, to improve this position, we will try to move up.

Now regarding "from here we will threaten the Swede, in spite of the arrogant neighbor, here a city will be built." I want to recall another poem – "Poltava." "Hooray! We are breaking through, the Swedes are bending..." – there are such lines about the Battle of Poltava. Now we most often remember this when we watch the Russian national football team play against "Tre Kronor." And, unfortunately for our fans, we cannot often reproduce these lines from the poem because the brilliant Swedish hockey team, of course, delights both its fans and ours, and, by the way, unites our countries in humanitarian terms. It would be very good, Mr. Prime Minister, if one of your clubs participated in the games of the Continental Hockey League. But that is outside the scope of our discussion today.

Now regarding your question, will Russia sleep through something or not in terms of developing these resources. Of course not.

First of all, the resources are indeed colossal; they are of planetary scale. According to preliminary estimates, we have about 13 billion tons of oil and 95 trillion cubic meters of gas concentrated here. These are colossal global reserves. We have already begun development. Mr. Mikhelson is sitting across from me; he is leading the Yamal LNG project. This is an international project. You mentioned restrictions. Yes, they exist, they are harmful, of course, both sanctions and others, but they cannot stop this process, including the development of the Arctic. I remind you once again: no matter how the sanctions instruments work, the first shipment from Yamal LNG went to the United States. It’s funny, but it’s a fact. And, as far as I know, trade continues. Because where it is profitable for our American partners and friends, they realize everything. If it is unprofitable, then they tighten something there. But if it is unprofitable for them. They have not been paying much attention to the interests of other countries lately. So, we will implement other projects and expand this one.

How quickly humanity is moving towards replacing hydrocarbon raw materials with alternative sources is still a question. According to expert data, energy consumption in the coming decades will grow, and the ratio between hydrocarbons, renewable sources, nuclear energy, and hydropower will remain approximately the same.

Today – fortunately or unfortunately, but this is happening – this relationship between different sources is not changing. The total volume is growing. But we must not forget that Russia is a huge country with hydropower potential; we are developing and will continue to develop nuclear energy. We have only 16 percent of our energy generation from nuclear power. In France, it is already over 90 percent, and we have only 16. We need to at least reach 25. Our neighbors, Finland, are planning to build. And so on. So we have not missed anything here.

Now regarding the impact of sanctions: does it hinder or not? It hinders to some extent, but not critically. To a certain degree, it even pushes us to actively develop our own technologies.

Last year, we invested 600 billion in import substitution – that is, to produce ourselves what we previously bought abroad. (Addressing M. Oreshkin.) How much did we invest in import substitution last year? The Minister of Economic Development does not remember. Even about a billion rubles.

And this will continue; we will increase these efforts. And, to be honest, this is yielding positive results. Therefore, of course, it would be better without any restrictions that distort the market, distort global trade, and lead to a slowdown in the growth rates of the global economy; it would be better to avoid this. But the implementation of Russian plans for the development of mineral resources, in general, will not be hindered by this.

J. Fryer: Yes, you are absolutely right. Yamal LNG is a success story, and no one doubts that there are amazing reserves of oil and gas in the Arctic, but extracting them is very costly. In other words, yes, they exist, but do you believe it will be economically justified to extract these resources considering the energy transition we discussed and the technological sanctions?

I told you that we do not see a transition. We see humanity's efforts to develop alternative energy sources, but so far there is no critical transition from hydrocarbons to renewable sources. A critical transition from the perspective of those who extract oil, gas, and coal. The issue is not even oil and gas, not fuel oil. The fact is that mainly coal is currently used for thermal power plants, not even fuel oil, not oil, and not gas. Gas is, after all, the cleanest type of fuel among hydrocarbons.

The most coal is burned in the world today – that is what we need to think about. And this amount is not decreasing globally... Well, there are such indicators; in some countries, they are reducing, but overall, no, almost not – in the world. So that is what we need to think about. And I do not see any threats here, for the most part. By the way, we are also working on alternative energy sources in Russia; we are actively working and will continue to work. Therefore, I see no threats for us; they do not exist.

As for the cost, you mentioned the extraction of oil, say, in the United States. But we know how this extraction occurs – through hydraulic fracturing. The most environmentally harmful method of extracting hydrocarbons. In some states, where oil is extracted in this way, you probably know better than I do, instead of clean water, some black sludge comes out of the taps. Perhaps colleagues there are currently dealing with this, but it is not an easy task. And the profitability of extracting oil in this way is much lower than extracting oil and gas in Russia, even in hard-to-reach regions. Therefore, we feel absolutely confident here.

Moreover, if oil prices, say, fall below 40 dollars, then the profitability of production and growth in extraction in the United States will be called into question. Of course, today technologies are developing, and perhaps the profitability of such extraction will be higher; perhaps it will go below 40 dollars per barrel. Perhaps it will be 35-30, but still, the profitability of oil extraction in Russia, I won’t even mention gas, I won’t even name those figures to avoid scaring anyone. It is much higher than in the United States, than in Europe, and even than in some gas-producing countries in the Middle East.

J. Fryer: And finally, the last question regarding energy in the Arctic. It is still expensive to extract oil in the Arctic and hydrocarbons. Is there talk of special tax incentives for Russian companies operating there? Can we expect more?

I have already mentioned that we intend to create and are creating and will continue to create favorable conditions for those companies that operate in challenging Arctic conditions. This is not only related to the lack of infrastructure development; it is also related to the need to invest in technologies that would ensure 100 percent preservation of nature, which is very fragile in the Arctic; we know this, and all my colleagues sitting here are well aware of this, first.

And second, when organizing such work, we must think about the interests of the indigenous peoples of the North; this is also an additional burden on companies, and this burden should largely be taken on by the state.

J. Fryer: Prime Minister Solberg, let’s turn to you. At Bloomberg's website, we talk a lot about Norway, and the question arises: Norway is the largest European oil producer. There has been talk of environmental threats, primarily to the islands, and we have discussed this; we talked about the exploration of gas and oil that Norway is conducting, and, in general, it has not brought encouraging results in recent years. We know about other situations as well. May I ask: is Norway really kind of dropping out of this oil race?

E. Solberg: No, I do not think we are ceasing to be oil and gas players. But we are concerned about CO2 emissions in our country and the impact on the world from this. We have serious regulatory measures, including taxes. We must reduce CO2 emissions. Here we take into account European emissions quotas. So the taxation of production with high CO2 emissions is very high.

Well, we love our ocean; it is a symbol of Norway. Cod plays an important role there. It is a rich area, and the fish stocks there... 500-600 years ago, we sold to Portugal for their Christmas table. It is an efficient natural region. Sometimes there are conflicts, yet we continue to extract oil and gas, continue geological exploration. We have the fourth, largest area, these oil reserves; now it is in the second stage of development. I worked in the government 15 years ago, and we thought then that we had reached a peak. Then we found new fields, and now we think we have reached a peak. Maybe not, because we are still continuing exploration. But especially in the Arctic, we must make additional efforts in the interest of nature, plus everything is more expensive here, and this should influence our development.

J. Fryer: So the Arctic, when it comes to oil exploration, still holds new opportunities?

E. Sulberg: Yes, it holds opportunities. We are currently attracting companies to put forward their ideas regarding oil exploration. These areas are open to us. We believe that this brings positive results and income.

Yes, of course, there is a demand for cleaner energy, but in Europe, there is also a demand for natural gas as a transitional fuel, so that society becomes cleaner in terms of emissions. And gas does not produce the same emissions as, for example, coal, and in Europe, this would allow for a reduction in emissions. And this emissions system has now increased costs. That is, the cost of CO2 emissions in the European Union is higher than it was two years ago. This means that the difference regarding CO2 between coal and gas will grow, and this will allow us to transition from coal to gas, which we have been striving for over the last 10 years.

J. Fryer: President Johannesson, let me turn to you.

We have heard a lot about the negative things that are happening now: the threat to ecology, climate change, melting ice. You are a small state in the North Atlantic. How is Iceland affected by changes in the Arctic? What opportunities does the Arctic hold for you, considering all the changes that have taken place and are taking place?

G. Johannesson: First of all, I do not think we should talk or focus on the negative things. You yourself said that perhaps something good will come out of this. But we do not feel the positive effects of climate change. But, of course, there will be changes. We must adapt to them. The potential for increased traffic in the north, along the Northern Sea Route, will allow us to carry out transportation from the Far East to Europe, and this must be taken into account. We will witness how the situation there will change, how it will positively affect the economy of Iceland. And from this perspective, the Arctic and changes in the Arctic open up new realities for us. We are no longer joking about how we will benefit from global warming and climate change; we no longer laugh about it. That is one thing.

The importance of transitioning from fossil energy sources to renewable ones also shows and implies that we can integrate into this process. Yes, we are in the middle of the North Atlantic, a small rock, but an active rock. We have great geothermal potential. We talked about energy sources in the Arctic. So, geothermal energy is one of the special sources for clean energy. For example, in Kamchatka, Icelandic and Russian companies and experts are working together, and there is significant potential for sustainable use of this resource.

In conclusion, I can only say that climate change and its negative consequences do not open up positive opportunities, but, in any case, they open up new realities.

J. Fryer: Prime Minister Löfven, I want to ask you the same question as your Norwegian colleague. This is the first time the Prime Minister of Sweden meets with President Putin in a long time. Does this mean that you are no longer concerned about Crimea and a number of other issues that led to disagreements between the countries, as in the past? Has this changed now?

S. Löfven: Well, you know, I came here because the Arctic Council, and the Arctic region in general, is of immense importance to Sweden. We came here for cooperation, for discussion, to talk about what we can do to mitigate the effects of climate change, and to discuss how to make the Arctic a prosperous region.

And here is what I want to say: Russia is a very important country in this region. It is a large country, and we have many common interests regarding investments, business, climate, culture, and people-to-people contacts, ice hockey. For many years, we have seen wonderful Soviet and Russian hockey players and teams. My team will not be able to participate in the Continental Hockey League championship this year, but we will see. But we need cooperation, the best mutual understanding. But at the same time, Sweden is also a small country, a non-aligned country, and we will uphold important principles. But we need both. We want to have good relations with Russia, but at the same time, we do not abandon the things we believe in and view differently.

J. Fryer: Finland will be chairing the EU in July. Do you see signs of improving relations between the EU and Russia, perhaps a warming, just like in the Arctic? And can you envision a change in the situation regarding sanctions?

S. Niinistö: I will start with sanctions. It is very clear to everyone, I am sure, that sanctions were imposed due to Russian actions. If the position does not change, the sanctions will remain, that’s simple.

As for the EU presidency, I must say that the importance of the EU presidency is not as significant as it used to be. For example, you remember all the discussions about Brexit. Did the EU presidency participate in that? No. We understand this, and my personal view is that perhaps we need to start from within the EU. I want to ask all EU members: how common are our interests? This question usually arises during a divorce. That is, is there something that still connects you, something in common between you? If there is, then they will continue to live together. We need to discuss in the EU whether there is something common among us in the EU? I think there is.

Now, regarding external relations, relations with the outside world. I have already tried to say in my speech that we all say that dialogue is very important. This is repeated every month, but usually, that’s where it ends, as I said. Everyone says it is important, but nothing happens. Finland, and I am sure that during our presidency we will try to do this, we will try to conduct this dialogue. It is not easy to say that it is important, and dialogue with Russia is also important, because ultimately, despite what has happened in Ukraine, from the Atlantic to the Urals, we are Europe. Europe is a neighbor of Russia. And the same can be said about Russia: Europe is a neighbor of Russia. Therefore, we must maintain the best possible relations with our neighbor, as much as possible.

J. Fryer: President Putin, can you respond to this?

Yes, I want to.

Regarding sanctions, which we have returned to, Crimea, and so on. Crimea, as far as I understand, does not belong to the Arctic zone, yet I would like to say this about it. We have gathered to discuss Arctic issues. We would very much not want the Arctic to turn into something resembling Crimea as a result of untimely measures taken—or rather, not taken—because a crime, as lawyers know, can be committed through a criminal act and criminal inaction. So, we should think together about how to prevent the Arctic from becoming like Crimea and how Crimea does not turn into a desert. This is what we should be discussing today.

By the way, these are not empty words, because if you look at the deposits in the Arctic, you will find remnants of tropical plants and tropical animals. That is, this has happened before in history. We must understand what is happening to the planet and respond together.

I will again make a historical excursion. When our reformer Tsar Peter I and the romantic King Charles XII were fighting each other, dividing territories, a lot of time has passed since then. And now some of the problems we are discussing today can only be solved by joining forces. That is why we have gathered here today. And I think this will be beneficial.

As for the EU and mutual exchanges of sanctions blows. You surely know, Bloomberg cannot be unaware of this, according to estimates from the European Commission itself, I believe, for the 15th or 16th year, the losses of the European Union amounted to about 50 billion euros, while Russia's losses are estimated at around 25-26 billion. But it is clear that the European Union is losing more than we are. According to German estimates, from specialists in Germany, the lost profit for Germany is 56 billion, while ours is three times less. But this does not make us happy, because it is three times less. No, there are just common losses, and this is really causing damage.

Now regarding the nature of sanctions themselves.

First of all, any sanctions must be, if they are legal, sanctioned by the UN Security Council. And since this is not the case, they are illegal—this is the first point.

And secondly, in my opinion, the most important: for some reason, no one imposes sanctions for interference in the internal affairs of other countries, for disorganization of internal political life, for destabilizing states. No one imposes sanctions against those who bring about a situation where other countries are forced to take certain measures to protect their interests.

Let’s just return to the observance of elementary norms of international law, the UN Charter, and perhaps then we won’t have to think about the consequences of the bombings in Yugoslavia or any issues related to such gross violations of international law and their consequences.

Let’s just return to normal political life, realize that the world is interdependent, and to achieve a common result, we need to work together.

J. Fryer: Mr. President, you have a reputation worldwide as a realist and pragmatist. You can rightly say that sanctions are unfair. But still, many European powers say that sanctions should remain in place. What will you say, how long will sanctions remain in effect? Another ten years? What is the future of Russia?

The future of Russia does not depend on sanctions. The future of Russia depends only on us, on how effectively we can transform our political system, how democratic it will be, how it will bring to the surface all the healthiest forces of society, the creative energy of our citizens. How effectively we can use all of this. How effectively we can utilize the internal resources of the Russian economy.

I mentioned that we invested over 600 billion last year—637, I believe, in import substitution. And all of this is working effectively. We have wonderful science and education. We must support all of this in the right condition and move it forward. And I am confident that we will succeed, including in the implementation of national projects.

Sanctions are a tool—if we want it to work—that should be placed exclusively in the hands of the UN Security Council. Everything else needs to be resolved through dialogue and not impose one’s agenda on other countries. That’s all.

Sanctions today are used not even as a tool of geopolitical struggle, but as an element of simple competitive struggle in the world. Take the same Nord Stream 2; our American friends are fighting against it. But it is clearly beneficial for European partners. “No, don’t build it!” It is difficult to work with the European Union; there are many countries, and almost everything is decided by consensus.

We have already built the Turkish Stream with Turkey under the Black Sea. The Turkish Stream will start operating at the end of this year. With the Europeans, we still cannot come to an agreement. The same thing happened with our American partners opposing the gas-for-pipes project we were doing with Germany in the 60s. Absolutely the same thing.

The same was true regarding Nord Stream 1. If there had been no Nord Stream 1, what would be happening now with international energy? I can tell you. Prices would be even higher than today, that’s all. Do you want to buy mineral resources at higher prices? No. I don’t know what else needs to be done to put pressure on European countries. Only to make them cover the price difference between our gas and American liquefied gas from their national budgets, because it is impossible to force them to buy a product 30 percent more expensive under market conditions. It is impossible to do; they simply will not buy. Households will not pay just like that.

So what needs to be done to put them on equal footing? Cover the difference from the budget. But that would be the height of cynicism. But I think that if this continues, it may come to that. But that is no longer our choice. It is the choice of European partners.

And the demands to increase defense spending? Do you think this is related to the overall deterioration of the international situation? That is just a pretext. The main motive is to load the US defense industry with additional European money, that’s all. Here lie the main answers.

And to prevent all this from happening, let’s return to the observance of elementary norms of international law. We have already talked about this many times.

J. Fryer: President Niinistö, did you want to say something?

S. Niinistö: As a representative of a European country, yes.

Mr. Moderator, I have the feeling that we have plenty of problems far beyond the Arctic. We can compare the situation to the divorce between the European Union and Britain; now we are also talking about Crimea.

But let’s remember the Minsk agreements. I do not want to take anyone’s side, but the Minsk agreements are a great example. I am absolutely sure that everyone would be satisfied and pleased if the Minsk agreements were fully implemented, word for word. Everyone would say: good. And that is exactly the agreement that was reached, but nothing happened afterward. And in my speech, I tried to say that yes, dialogue is necessary, a clear understanding is necessary. It is clear that not everyone can have the same opinion.

But, for example, at least the level of cooperation that we have in the Arctic Council. If we had our own Minsk agreements in the Arctic Council, they would be implemented without a doubt. That is the spirit of the Arctic Council.

J. Fryer: Mr. Löfven, would you like to comment?

S. Löfven: Yes.

President Niinistö, it seems to me, as you rightly said, we are drifting further and further away from the discussion about the Arctic region. But just a brief comment.

We are a small country. And of course, it is very important for us that international law is upheld by everyone, that all follow the decisions of the UN Security Council. Because, for example, Sweden, being a small country, can also start to worry. And our population begins to be concerned: what is happening and how can we ensure our safety?

But I would like to emphasize that despite the existence of such opinions and disagreements in views, we must maintain the best possible relations between countries. The Arctic region and cooperation in the Arctic is a perfect example of where we can cooperate and are cooperating very successfully. Especially those regions that currently live in this area, in the Arctic, they are waiting for answers from us, they are waiting for actions to combat climate change, to create new jobs, and to implement new technologies. And of course, for the rational and responsible use of resources. Therefore, I would prefer that we talk more about this topic; otherwise, we may spend all our time discussing Ukraine. And as Mr. President rightly said, Crimea is not part of the Arctic.

J. Fryer: But still, one more question, if I may.

Is there a risk that Arctic powers will find themselves in some kind of isolation? It is clear that you want the Arctic to be a place of harmonious cooperation. But, as I mentioned in my introduction, the whole world is now looking at the Arctic, and the Arctic itself could become a point of conflict. Everything is interconnected now, and it seems to me that the Arctic has long ceased to be an isolated region; it is already part of the global world. And of course, this presents new opportunities. But at the same time, it poses a risk of greater geopolitical tension.

S. Löven: You are certainly right, and we cannot be naive. We are undoubtedly facing a new scenario. And of course, we can see that there are a large number of countries and new actors beginning to show interest in this region. As far as I remember, there are currently 39 states with observer status, 39 organizations, of which 13 are states.

But I want to say that we, the Arctic states, must primarily remember our interest in keeping the Arctic a region where tensions are low or, better yet, absent. Therefore, from the very beginning, we must declare: "The Arctic region is a territory of peaceful cooperation." This should be our strategic goal. But you are right, globalization certainly brings its challenges and complexities, and the situation is undoubtedly changing for the Arctic as well.

J. Fryer: Thank you.

E. Solberg: Norway is not a member of the European Union, but we are members of NATO, and we support sanctions. But we have made it clear: this is an international response to an international situation, to an international incident.

Of course, Russia and Norway hold different positions on many issues, but despite all this, we are trying to develop a strategy that will allow us to jointly tackle common challenges. And we find areas for cooperation. And of course, the Arctic is a key issue on this agenda.

Yes, of course, we see increasing interest in the Arctic. We understand that there will be more active shipping, that economic activity will develop, and industrial activity will also grow in this region. This means we must be prepared for it. For example, one area where Russia and Norway have been cooperating for a long time is search and rescue operations in the region, and it is clear that the challenge will become increasingly active.

Not long ago, we heard about a large cruise ship in northern Norway that found itself in a very dramatic situation when both engines failed. We had to quickly mobilize resources, and that was relatively simple. But if such a situation occurred further from shore, in cold waters, it would be much more complicated. We must remember that we live in a closely interconnected world, and we must address issues together; this is our political responsibility to our people, to our voters, to work not only on the big agenda but also not to forget about cooperation in the Arctic.

J. Fryer: You are right, cooperation in the Arctic is very important, but as the Prime Minister of Norway, you certainly cannot forget about the political agenda. Three weeks ago, we heard news that two Russian bombers flew over Norwegian territory. Do such incidents complicate cooperation in the Arctic?

E. Solberg: But we can always respond; we responded by sending our bombers to escort the Russian aircraft. Such situations have been happening for a long time, for many years between our countries. This happened during the Cold War and in relatively peaceful times. We know how to respond to such incidents. We always inform countries when we conduct military exercises. That is how Norway behaves. We strictly follow the protocols and regulations that were established back in the 1990s.

We have a direct "hotline"; we inform our neighbors: we are conducting exercises, and we are letting you know. If it is a large NATO exercise, we have invited Russian observers. They came, and they participated in this process. We would like to see a bit more cooperation from Russia in this regard, a bit more responsiveness. We would be happy if we were also invited more often to exercises because we want to be open; we want to show what we are doing; we want to demonstrate that we are not provoking any incidents. We do not want to create problematic situations ourselves. But yes, there are points where we have disagreements, and we understand that Russia has completely legitimate ambitions and tasks regarding defense and various military activities in the north. But Norway has similar needs, and we must find a balance because, of course, sometimes there are disagreements. But if the necessary openness is demonstrated on both sides, if we discuss these issues, if we try to take into account the needs of our partners, particularly the security needs from Russia, and understand that we also have concerns, then everything will work out.

J. Fryer: Mr. President, would you like to respond?

S. Niinistö: Not to this part of the conversation. Earlier, you mentioned that new actors are emerging in the Arctic. Let's focus on the Arctic issue. We have the issue of climate change and combating warming, and there is a second part of the question that you raised, which certainly interests everyone. Of course, everyone is going there not to take selfies; not all tourists heading to the Arctic are. But we must remember that there is the Arctic Council, there are eight permanent members. And we bear the responsibility for caring for the Arctic. No one can accuse us and say: guys, you are not fulfilling your task; you need help. No, we are responsibly fulfilling our tasks.

And of course, it is a completely different question if someone tries to come to the Arctic or somehow, perhaps, violate borders. Of course, this is a big question for the future. If the ice continues to melt as quickly as it is, it is clear that the interest of all parties in the Arctic will only increase.

J. Fryer: President Johannesson.

G. Johannesson: Let me respond to the last words of President Niinistö.

The ice is melting. This indicates that there is not only a threat but also new potential for fishing and shipping. And within the framework of the Arctic Council and all relevant organizations, we are indeed observing that cooperation and active thinking can bring benefits.

Let us not first argue about how we will divide and use this new resource. Let us first determine how to do this in accordance with the principles of sustainable development, and for this, we first need to conduct research, listen to the opinions of scientists and experts. Therefore, I tend to say that we need harmony.

If there are any disagreements, they are primarily our conflicts over fish. And even with Norway, our good neighbor, Iceland has often had conflicts over fishing. And this example applies to any situation. The world is full of problems, but we must at least understand what we do well and use those competencies.

Of course, we cannot turn a blind eye to all other tasks, but let us ensure that we have the opportunity to say that at least this is what the Arctic Council has done well. This is the path of cooperation; this is the path of international exchange of experience in the scientific field. And let us focus on the responsible use of our resources. And of course, it goes without saying that less military attention to this part of the planet will benefit everyone. This is especially true for those countries that do not have a strong defense industry, such as Iceland.

J. Fryer: President Putin, I apologize, but there are still a number of international issues that I would like to raise.

I know that the last time we met in Moscow a year and a half ago, you scolded me for taking too much time from your guests by asking you questions. But I promise I will return to the Arctic issue and to the other guests. But first, let me ask, this is indeed a topic relevant to today's conversation.

You mentioned energy prices, and the whole world continues to wonder what Russia will do next. Will there be a reduction in oil production and extraction? The next OPEC meeting will be in June. Let me ask: do you agree with the position of the Russian Ministry of Energy that current oil prices are acceptable for Russia?

I think the Ministry of Energy of Russia should agree with my opinion. I would prioritize our work correctly. And I must tell you that the practice of the Russian Government is such that we are always in contact; we always discuss these issues collegially, based on the interests of the Russian economy in its various directions. We do not advocate for uncontrolled price increases because, although we set ourselves the task of diversifying the Russian economy, it is still significantly linked not only to oil and gas but also to industrial production. And industrial production, in fact, Russian ones also suffer from excessive price increases. Therefore, we are balanced in the development of the global energy market. We are quite satisfied with today's prices, and we see the production volumes in the United States; they are increasing. Indeed, the United States consumes significantly more than we do. We produce 11.5 million barrels per day; the US is now producing even more.

We are satisfied with the situation as it is today, but we are, of course, together with our partners, primarily with the main oil producers – Saudi Arabia, the Gulf countries – closely monitoring the market. We have agreed that if our combined efforts are needed, we will meet again in the second half of the year and discuss.

In any case, we are ready to continue cooperating with OPEC in developing common solutions; I would cautiously say we are ready to continue this cooperation. But whether this will be a reduction, whether it will simply be a halt at the current level of production, I am not ready to say.

We have plans from our companies for the development of new fields, and we are also approaching this carefully. We understand that production should not stop; investments in the industry must continue; otherwise, this could also create problems for us and for the global energy sector. Therefore, these will be balanced decisions. But we will continue our cooperation with OPEC.

And still, I would like to return to your previous question regarding this tension. I do not actually see any particular military tension in the Arctic. It is not there. The only thing is that NATO conducted the largest exercises in the region; that is true. We do not conduct such exercises in the region. We conducted large exercises, but that was very far from NATO's area of responsibility; that was in the east – that is the first point.

Secondly, I want everyone to know this as well; we always invite foreign observers to all our exercises without exception. Always. We have certain agreements; they have always been present.

And now regarding the aircraft. Our military aircraft do not fly over Norwegian territory. They were not there, and I hope they will not be. Yes, they are in neutral airspace. The aircraft of the country near which our aircraft routes pass, yes, indeed, Madam Prime Minister is right, escort them, just as we escort NATO aircraft if they appear near our borders or ships. Therefore, I do not see any major threats here. We must, of course, just keep this activity under control.

The President of Finland, as a representative of a neutral state, suggested some time ago that military aircraft fly with their transponders on, that is, with devices that identify the aircraft. We agreed and immediately submitted this proposal within the framework of our relations with NATO. The response from NATO was negative. So ask NATO why they do not agree. In my opinion, this is an absolutely reasonable proposal. It is a technically complex solution, also not easy for us, but I have given such an order to the General Staff, the Ministry of Defense; they are ready to implement it. Let NATO implement it, then it will be clear which aircraft is flying where, military, and where it is at that moment. Our aviation activity in the Baltic Sea, in the Arctic is an order of magnitude lower than the activity of NATO countries, an order of magnitude – this should be known.

J. Fryer: Let me return once again to OPEC, and then we will move on. As I understand it, you currently prefer to take a wait-and-see position regarding production cuts. But do you not think that the crises in Venezuela, Iran, and Libya will lead to the need to support prices? In other words, is it not likely that this will not be necessary?

Yes, of course, we are thinking about this. Both the crisis in Venezuela and in Iran, but there is no crisis in Iran, there are sanctions that limit the country’s access to global markets, in some African countries, including Libya, yes, we see all this and take it into account. And this is exactly what I meant when I said that we will closely monitor the situation in the market. We also mean that the volumes of hydrocarbon consumption, including oil, increase during the summer period worldwide. We will see.

But right now, global reserves are such that they do not require special intervention. There are also plans from our companies, as I have already mentioned, for the development of new fields, we must also take this into account and assist our companies. Here, assistance can also take various forms: either starting drilling now, or ensuring that they operate at break-even and profitable levels using various state support tools. We have our own opinion on this matter. We will closely monitor the market and make decisions accordingly. But we will continue to cooperate with OPEC.

J. Fryer: Alright.

One more question. In other words, if it is necessary at the end of September, will Russia agree to continue production cuts, in other words, is this probability high or not?

We have practically not reduced production; we have simply kept production on the shelf, as oil workers say, we just did not increase it.

But if the market situation develops in such a way that reserves sharply increase, for example, the United States takes and seizes Venezuelan oil and quickly increases its output to global markets, fully loading their plants, and releasing their oil onto the world market. Or something positive happens in Libya, for example, politically, God willing, the situation in the country as a whole normalizes, and Libya enters global markets. Or suddenly someone decides that it is necessary to stop pressuring Iran, to try to create conditions for Iran and Israel to somehow come to an agreement, the situation normalizes, and Iran enters the markets with additional volumes. But then we will have to take all this into account and make the appropriate decision.

You are pulling a more specific answer out of me with pliers – you will not get it. We will cooperate with OPEC and make decisions depending on the market situation.

J. Fryer: I am a journalist, so I have to do everything in my power. I have one last question for you on international issues before we return to the Arctic.

I apologize to my colleagues; I am not to blame here.

J. Fryer: Yes, you can blame me for everything; it is all my fault, but we will return to the Arctic.

Before this meeting, we spoke with users of the social platform Bloomberg – it is called TicToc. There, mainly young people, a lot of young users. We talked to them, and there was no particular surprise – many are interested in the question of U.S.-Russia relations. This question often arose. Allow me to spend a few minutes on this.

At the Helsinki summit, President Trump invited you to Washington. Now that the Mueller report has been released, this is no longer a problem, do you think Trump will be able to fulfill his promise to improve relations with Russia? I know you have an invitation to the White House this year.

You know, there is a good book called "The Twelve Chairs," and there is a phrase: "Come to visit, dear mother will be very glad," but the address was not left.

The situation must ripen. We initially said that this infamous commission of Mr. Mueller would find nothing because no one knows this better than we do. Russia did not interfere in any elections in the United States, that is the first.

And secondly, there was no collusion that Mr. Mueller was looking for between Trump and Russia. We were not acquainted with Mr. Trump. Yes, he came to Moscow, but as a businessman, and frankly, it was not an event for us. This is complete nonsense, aimed solely at the domestic audience and used in the internal political struggle in the United States.

Therefore, that it would end up as the mountain giving birth to a mouse, as they say, was clear to us in advance. I have been telling you this all along. But now it has happened, but the internal political situation in the U.S. has not become any easier. Some new reasons are being sought to attack President Trump.

It seems to me – forgive me for digressing – that this is some element of a crisis in the political system of the United States itself. Because look at what is happening? Those groups that attack the legally elected president do not agree with the choice of the American people, they nullify the results.

This is the crisis of the political system. We have never seen anything like this in the history of the United States. Yes, there is a fierce electoral struggle, but if a candidate wins, then everyone agrees with that, it has always been so, and they unite around the head of state to implement national tasks. Nothing like this do we see now in the States. On the contrary, the division continues.

Do you understand what happened? They placed their group or party interests above national interests – that is what happened.

I am not defending President Trump at all; we have many disagreements with him. His administration has imposed a huge number of sanctions against Russia, which we, of course, do not agree with and will never agree with, and we consider this counterproductive. But if a full-fledged, equal dialogue between the U.S. and Russia is resumed, including on issues that are of interest to both us and all of humanity, on disarmament issues, we would be very happy about this; we are ready for it.

J. Fryer: President Trump says he feels vindicated by the Mueller report. But personally, after everything that has happened, are you happy as a person for President Trump? After he called it a witch hunt, after the Mueller report was published?

President Trump knows better. What a "witch hunt" is, we know from the history of the United States. This is a dark page in American history. I would not want it to ever repeat itself.

J. Fryer: I have one last question in this context. This is the last one, I promise you.

At the famous press conference in Helsinki, you said that you hoped Trump would win in 2016 because he promised to improve relations with Russia. Do you want him to win now, in 2020?

You know, I have already said that we have many disagreements on international issues, on the resolution of certain crises. But we also have elements of cooperation. No matter how differently we approach the resolution of the Syrian crisis, cooperation is still taking place; we are working together.

We have common problems in the Arctic, by the way, for which we have gathered here to discuss. The United States has many of its own interests in the Arctic zone. We have many problems related to climate change in general. We know that the U.S. did not sign the Paris Agreement, and the Administration has its own reasons, its own logic. I am not one of those people who think that it is necessary to attack the current Administration in this regard; we just need to have a dialogue. And then, it seems to me, we can try to find a common solution. Because without the participation of the U.S. in this process, just as without the participation, say, of China, India, it is difficult to expect effective work from the international community. The U.S. is a major emitter of emissions. This is an obvious thing; we must understand this. Therefore, we need to find a solution, involve the United States in this and invite them to dialogue. Overall, as far as I understand, Trump is not refusing. First or even second.

Third: many things, it seems to me, are being decided today on a bilateral basis under the pressure of domestic political circumstances. We hope that when this situation normalizes, we will have prospects for cooperation in a bilateral format on all the issues I have mentioned. And here, there are terrorism, epidemics, ecology – yes, many issues. And disarmament issues.

I think we are all interested in this, but as soon as conditions in the States are established, we will work. Whether we want to or not – this does not depend on us. What is it: to want or not to want? This is not the sphere where such categories apply. We respect the choice of the American people. Whoever the president is, we are ready to work with him.

J. Fryer: Alright.

I promised we would return to Arctic issues.

There is a question that we have not devoted much time to – the growing interest of China in the Arctic. Now that the Northern Sea Route is opening and China is saying that the Northern Route will become part of the new Silk Road that China is promoting, perhaps President Johannesson can tell us what you think about this?

G. Johannesson: Yes, undoubtedly, a major power like China is interested in closely monitoring the changes occurring in the Arctic. We have already spent some time in this meeting today discussing this issue.

There is nothing wrong with that. I believe that the Government of Iceland is also monitoring China's approaches, China's initiatives, without a doubt. If a new transport corridor appears, there will be, for example, major countries in the east – Southeast Asia, China, Japan at one end of this corridor, and at the other end of the corridor will be Europe as the final destination, and perhaps also as a transit and transshipment point for trade in other regions.

Without a doubt, the authorities in China and businesses in China are participating in this process. Yes, we are a little smaller than China, so we are keeping an eye on what is happening.

J. Fryer: Thank you very much.

We are almost out of time. Allow me to conclude by asking each of you a question, perhaps within 90 seconds or maybe shorter, as briefly as you can respond.

Excuse me, regarding the Northern Sea Route, a very important thing. For example, from Yokohama to Rotterdam takes 33 days through the Indian Ocean, through the Northern Sea Route – twenty, through the Northern Sea Route – seven and a little thousand kilometers, seven thousand three hundred, while through the Indian Ocean – almost twelve. That’s it, the savings are colossal both in fuel and time, so it will certainly be very attractive not only for China, but also for Japan, South Korea, and Indonesia, perhaps even, this is a very interesting and promising area of international cooperation, and this cooperation should bring us closer together, not divide us.

J. Fryer: Now, as we conclude, let me ask each of you a question, for which I expect a short answer.

What is the greatest opportunity, the main chance that opens up as the Arctic opens up? And what is the greatest risk?

Perhaps we will start with Prime Minister Solberg?

E. Solberg: I believe that the opportunities in the Arctic are enormous for research, for development, for new industrial activities. However, the challenge is that this is the area where nature is most vulnerable, and any human actions have much greater consequences, and dealing with negative consequences will be much more difficult than in other regions. And of course, there are certain complexities for search and rescue operations as well.

In any case, we believe that Norway's economic power will grow and largely move northward. And this is good for our society. However, we need cooperation in all these areas. If maritime trade and transport grow, and we are a large country, we must be better prepared for search and rescue operations, we must be ready for ecological disasters, we must help the people living there. After all, the North is a region where indigenous peoples live; they lead a more traditional way of life, and it is necessary for them to participate in this development.

J. Fryer: President Niinistö.

S. Niinistö: I believe we have already talked about transport connectivity, and this is a colossal benefit for everyone, especially for indigenous peoples. They can improve their standard of living.

As for the risks, I believe the greatest risk is in the area of security. You mentioned our proposal. This is a military solution; there are transponders. Yes, we actually proposed to use active transponders in the Baltic Sea. The idea is to have an early warning system so that nothing unexpected happens, so there are no incidents, as the Baltic Sea is very small. A few weeks ago, a Portuguese plane unauthorizedly entered our airspace – here is an example. That is why we need a common warning system. Perhaps, within the framework of the Icelandic presidency, we will pay more attention to whether we can create such a warning system, as well as a system for search and rescue operations.

J. Fryer: President Johannesson, please.

I wanted to give you, Mr. Putin, the floor in conclusion.

G. Johannesson: Yes, a lot can certainly be said.

Let me return to the motto that we constantly recall as we take over the chairmanship of the Arctic Council. We strive for a sustainable Arctic based on joint efforts with a special focus on the marine ecosystem, on "green" solutions, as well as with a special emphasis on the protection of indigenous peoples in the Arctic zone. Without a doubt, I agree with President Niinistö that search and rescue operations are an area for joint cooperation that we must pay special attention to, not only because of the incident mentioned, for example. But there have been other problems, such as a ship off the coast of Norway. All this just reminds us of what can happen here, in these dangerous zones of Arctic waters.

In conclusion, I believe we are all a little tired; let me once again thank President Putin, as well as the Russian Government, the organizers who are hosting us here. We received a very warm welcome, my delegation and I are very grateful for this.

I look forward to seeing many of you in Iceland when we take over the chairmanship of the Arctic Council. I hope we will have the opportunity to return the favor, to show you reciprocal hospitality and warmth.

Thank you.

S. Löven: The opportunities related to the wealth of the region, I am not only talking about resources, minerals, there are certainly huge opportunities there. But I believe that globalization means that more and more people, more countries will be interested in this region. China has been growing very rapidly for several years, as have other countries in Southeast Asia and Africa. So all of this means that there is significant interest in our region. I will say this: we need a low level of tension, this is a key element for all of us, security for our people.

We need to combat the consequences of global warming. This is happening in the Arctic. But we also know that the reduction of the ice cap, or the reduction of ice in the Arctic, affects tropical countries. And I want to take this opportunity to say that this is a global issue.

Sustainability: not only to combat climate change here, but also to achieve sustainable development for the entire region. We need to cooperate in research, this will help all of us. And we have talked about this. We have, for example, the icebreaker "Oden," which we can use for research purposes.

And finally, and this is no less important, as the President of Iceland mentioned, the people who live here, the indigenous population and generally the people living here as a whole, must be respected, we must demonstrate to them that we will strive for their development, and they will thrive.

Thank you.

J. Fryer: Mr. Putin, you have the floor for your concluding remarks.

I think the main advantages we can gain from the development of the Arctic are as follows.

First of all, I have already mentioned this, it is the global reserves of resources, and they must work for the benefit of all humanity – that is what is important. Within the framework of known rules, international rules, agreements between the countries of the region and non-regional players, but they need to be put to the service of humanity – that is the most important thing. Just as we should utilize additional opportunities in the field of transport and communication.

The biggest threats, the greatest, I think, are primarily ecological. It is sad for the bears in this case, the polar bears – but I say this metaphorically – for all the fauna in general. Because both due to warming and possibly due to the development of the Arctic zone, economic development, of course, the risks are increasing. We must take this into account. That is why it is so important that we gathered today and will continue to gather, including within the framework of the Arctic Council under the chairmanship of our colleague to my left.

All decisions of the Arctic Council are advisory in nature, but these are very important recommendations that have great moral and political significance and cannot be ignored by all players in the implementation of their national plans. Coordination of work here is extremely necessary. Therefore, cooperation in the Arctic zone, and this is also a very important advantage, provides a good example of how to and how we should address the issues that are on the global agenda together.

Thank you very much. I want to thank you and those colleagues who came today to discuss these issues in St. Petersburg.

J. Fryer: Thank you all very much.