Plenary session of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

25 May 2018 · 22nd St. Petersburg International Economic Forum · St. Petersburg, Russia

Context
Putin addressed world leaders and delegates at the 22nd St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on May 25, 2018, discussing global trade, protectionism, and Russia's development priorities.
Main themes
Global economic governance, free trade and protectionism, multilateral cooperation, international rules-based order, Russia's national development priorities, technology and innovation, investment climate, geopolitical tensions in trade, national sovereignty and interdependence, WTO and trade agreements
Duration
~163 min
99th percentile
Words
19,582
99th percentile
Sentences
1,083
99th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.3
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 40%40%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

1,083 sentences in 350 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Emmanuel Macron! Dear Mr. Shinzo Abe! Dear Ms. Christine Lagarde! Mr. Wang Qishan!

Ladies and gentlemen! Dear friends!

I am very glad to welcome all of you to Russia at the 22nd St. Petersburg International Economic Forum.

Meetings in St. Petersburg have become a good tradition. And we cherish the atmosphere of trust and openness in which the forum takes place. Just now, we were exchanging impressions in the corridors about how the work is going, and Ms. Lagarde just told me that she is pleasantly surprised by this friendly atmosphere.

Such discussions, informal dialogues are especially important today, when the system of international political, economic, and trade relations is undergoing a serious test of strength, and the conditions for doing business, for investments, and everyday life are changing dynamically.

The quality, sustainability, character, and speed of growth of the global economy are increasingly determined by new competencies and knowledge of people, advanced technologies, and communications that were simply unimaginable not long ago. Those who can effectively utilize these growth factors will be able to ensure a leap in the economy, social sphere, science, and education, significantly improving the quality of life for citizens.

We have identified these goals as national priorities. In the near future, the newly formed Government of Russia must translate them into specific action programs, national projects, and legislative initiatives, and provide the necessary resources to accomplish these tasks.

In our development, we intend to rely on our human, creative, and personnel potential, we are ready to learn and adapt the best global practices, and, of course, to use our own successful experience in solving complex structural challenges.

We will act, first and foremost, based on our national interests. This is natural for any sovereign state.

But interests can be promoted in different ways: either by ignoring others or by respecting the position of partners, understanding that the modern world is interconnected, and countries are interdependent, and each state, especially the major leading economies of the world, bears colossal responsibility for the common future.

Russia is a part of the global economy. We actively participate in integration projects, exert serious influence on energy, food, and other markets. Our country and companies are deeply involved in international trade, financial, and production ties.

Therefore, we carefully study what strategies for economic, technological, and social growth are planned to be implemented in other countries. And, of course, we are concerned about what global trends will gain strength in the long term.

Until recently, the foundation of global development was based on two fundamental, defining principles. First, it is the freedom of entrepreneurship, trade, and investment, enshrined in common rules adopted by participants in international relations. And, second, the stability and predictability of these rules, ensured by clear legal mechanisms.

Based on these values and principles, the global economy, despite known problems, has managed to achieve impressive results, bringing the overwhelming majority of participants in international life, most countries, onto a development trajectory.

However, today we are witnessing not even an erosion, I say this with regret, but a de facto undermining of these foundations. The system of multilateral cooperation, which has been built over decades, is breaking down instead of undergoing the natural, necessary evolution, and it is doing so roughly. The violation of rules is becoming the norm.

The openness of markets and fair competition are gradually being displaced by various exemptions, restrictions, and sanctions. The terms may differ, but the essence is the same: they have become a fully official tool of trade policy for many countries. And some states are simply forced to adapt to this, to respond, to apply mirror measures.

I want to draw attention to a telling fact. Until recently, almost every meeting of the leaders of the G20 or APEC ended with a joint statement on not introducing new protectionist barriers. These statements were partly, of course, declarative in nature, new barriers, unfortunately, did arise. But today, it is not even possible to agree on such symbolic steps.

Another example: the slowdown in the pace of concluding free trade agreements. This process began 5-7 years ago. In 2010, more than 30 such agreements were notified to the WTO. Last year – only ten. And there is a feeling that their number will continue to decrease.

And finally, if previously classic forms of protectionism were in vogue – which, of course, was also regrettable – such as additional import duties, technical requirements, or hidden subsidies, today we are talking about a "new edition" of protectionism, about the use of obviously contrived pretexts, about references allegedly to national security interests – for what? – to suppress competitors or extort concessions.

The launched spiral of sanctions and restrictions is only gaining momentum and hitting an ever-increasing number of countries and companies, including those who were confident that they would never be subjected to a regime of trade restrictions, that such problems would bypass them.

But arbitrariness and lack of control inevitably give rise to the temptation to use restrictive tools – again and again, wider and wider, to the right and to the left, for any reason, regardless of political loyalty, of talks about solidarity, of previous agreements and long-standing cooperative ties.

There are many representatives of business in this hall, and you know well that the exit of one party to a contract from the legal field, the disruption of agreements always means significant risks and costs. This is an axiom of business practice. On a global scale, such behavior by entire states, especially centers of power, is fraught with the most negative, if not destructive consequences. Especially now, when neglecting existing norms and the loss of mutual trust can overlap with unpredictability, turbulence from colossal technological changes.

Such a confluence of factors can lead to a systemic crisis that the world has not faced before or has not faced for a long time. It will affect all participants in global economic relations without exception.

Global distrust calls into question the prospects for global growth. The logic of economic selfishness poorly aligns with today's specialization of countries and companies, with the construction of complex global production chains. In fact, this could push the global economy and trade far back into the past, into the era of subsistence economy, when everyone was forced to produce everything themselves. And this inevitably leads to a decrease in economic efficiency, to losses in labor productivity, to the squandering of scientific and technological achievements capable of improving people's lives.

We are already seeing alarming trends today: the stability of business ties is undermined, disintegration processes are intensifying, forms of multilateral cooperation are being devalued, and the effectiveness of international institutions and agreements is declining.

Thus, the global community has still not managed to find acceptable solutions within the framework of the World Trade Organization, which, despite all the complexities and contradictions, remains a key link in the global trading system, the most important universal platform for resolving disputes and dialogue on issues that affect all participants in economic activity without exception.

The WTO, of course, is not perfect. Nevertheless, there are no insurmountable problems in the WTO system either. To abandon it without creating anything in return means to destroy the established balance. And then, in trade disputes, there will be neither plaintiffs nor defendants. Who is right will be determined only by force.

Naturally, the issue is not to freeze, to preserve the existing order of things, to turn into dogma what has outlived itself, what is unviable. The world is certainly changing, and institutions and rules must change with it. But one thing is obvious: these rules must be transparent and uniform for all, and must be observed by all participants in international economic relations.

And what is fundamentally important is that we need to jointly develop and implement a legitimate mechanism for change, within which the global community will be able to rid itself of outdated, sometimes ineffective, archaic norms, while preserving all that is best and creating new tools that meet the demands of the times.

Thus, for the global trade agenda, particular relevance is presented by areas where multilateral rules are still being formed. This primarily includes the development of new technological markets, such as e-commerce, access to information and transparency, protection of intellectual property and consumer rights for new, digital services and goods.

Negotiations on most of these topics have been launched. It is clear that these are not quick processes; meticulous work, patience, and persistence will be required, but I repeat, there is no alternative to jointly developing rules in the global economy and mechanisms that can guarantee their implementation.

Today, we need not trade wars, and not even temporary trade truces, but a full-fledged trade world. The motto of this year's St. Petersburg Forum is "Create an Economy of Trust." I am convinced that life itself indicates that the role of trust as a factor of development will increase.

Look at high-tech companies, startups, in science, in innovative fields that are outpacing existing traditional legal and corporate regulation. The work of partners, even if their relationships are complicated, is largely built on mutual trust. I know that this topic has been raised repeatedly during discussions at the forum, on various platforms today.

Of course, we do not try to idealize the situation. Rivalry, clashes of interests have always existed, exist, and, of course, will always exist. But at the same time, it is important to maintain respect for one another. It is precisely in the ability to resolve contradictions, in fair competition, and not in its limitation that the key to progress lies, the source of progress. This is the foundation for confident, sustainable development of each country to realize the colossal scientific and technological potential that has been accumulated in the world as a whole.

Russia advocates for free trade and economic integration, for constructive partnership dialogue, and calls on our partners from Europe, America, Asia, and other regions of the world to move together towards the goals of sustainable development, to develop a growth model that provides the most adequate response to modern challenges. I mean overcoming inequality of opportunities, addressing demographic and environmental issues, preserving national cultures and identities, increasing the well-being of people, and widely utilizing the advantages of the new technological wave.

All countries face these problems in one combination or another. Our peculiarity is that we face the entire complex of these problems at once, and in order to be and remain ourselves, Russia, we must solve all these tasks simultaneously.

For us, ensuring state sovereignty and preserving national identity is an unconditional value. At the same time, we need to make a powerful leap in development, to enter the ranks of advanced countries in terms of the duration and quality of life of citizens, to become one of the global technological leaders.

Our vision for the development of the country is based on four key principles.

First. We intend to build our policy around the person, their well-being, interests, and requests. I am convinced that only a country where people can fully realize all their abilities can be strong and successful.

To achieve this, we must continue the modernization of the economy and the creation of modern jobs, ensure the growth of citizens' incomes, and make domestic healthcare and education among the best in the world.

We intend to use advanced practices in the arrangement of cities and towns, in organizing comfortable spaces for living, working, and resting, significantly increase the volume of housing construction, and solve the problem of housing affordability primarily for middle-income families and families with children. An important direction is improving the state of the environment, which will also contribute to Russia's efforts to address global environmental problems.

Every person should have the opportunity to express themselves in public, volunteer activities, in production, in business, in public service, to take a successful life and professional start. Social mobility and strengthening human potential are the keys to the confident development of the country, its movement forward.

We have launched a whole series of projects to support and promote talented, goal-oriented youth – schoolchildren, students – and already established professionals, as well as to develop a mentoring movement.

To put all this work on a systematic basis, an autonomous non-profit organization "Russia – a Land of Opportunities" is being created. The relevant decree, many in this audience know, has been signed. And alongside the already established structures, such as the Agency for Strategic Initiatives, we will coordinate this work between the two organizations, addressing the tasks I just mentioned.

Second. We will expand the space of freedom. We often talk about this. This is not the first time that I and my colleagues have mentioned this, but these are fundamentally important things. Therefore, I consider it necessary to say this once again. This is fundamentally important for the formation of a strong civil society, for the development of the economy and social sphere, science, and culture.

The course towards removing barriers, towards liberalizing legislation primarily meets the interests and requests of our citizens. We will create conditions for doing business, for working in Russia, that will meet the highest standards, including support for business initiatives.

A year ago, speaking here in St. Petersburg, I emphasized the need to actively use project financing tools. Today, and this is a positive fact, we can talk about the launch of a new mechanism, a kind of project financing factory. Only within the framework of this forum, agreements will be signed for the financing of new investment projects totaling more than 700 billion rubles, and overall for the year, the volume will exceed one trillion rubles.

This program was implemented jointly by the efforts of the Bank of Russia, the financial and economic block of the Government, and Vnesheconombank. We managed to alleviate some bottlenecks related to banking regulation, guarantee the interests of investors, and as a result, attract significant private investments with minimal budget expenditures and, I emphasize, based on a market-driven, transparent mechanism for selecting projects for support.

Much in the implementation of plans and development projects in the economy, social sphere, and infrastructure will depend on the regions, on their efforts and effectiveness. I consider it important to continue the line of qualitatively renewing regional teams. It is at this level that a new management culture is largely being formed, modern approaches to solving economic and social problems are being developed, and open formats of interaction between the state and society, as well as citizen participation in self-governance and in solving everyday tasks, are being established. And you know that a number of successful governors have joined the new Government of the Russian Federation.

Today, competition is growing among regions for the quality of the business environment, for investors, for the best personnel. Essentially, this means that we have managed to launch a mechanism of constant change.

A significant role in this has also been played by the national investment climate rating. Traditionally, I would like to congratulate the winners of this year: Tyumen Region, Moscow, the Republic of Tatarstan; the Tula Region made it into the top five leaders, and, what pleases me especially, for the first time my hometown, St. Petersburg. I would add that the Far Eastern regions, as well as Buryatia, Kaliningrad, Pskov, Novgorod, and Yaroslavl regions, have shown good dynamics of change. I am confident that all our regions will consistently continue this work.

Third. For a technological breakthrough, to be competitive in the modern dynamic world, we must be receptive to new ideas, to technologies that change people's lives, that determine the future of the country and the world.

We have adopted a large, comprehensive digital development program. It will become one of our priorities in the coming years. This primarily concerns the development and widespread use of end-to-end digital solutions in the system of public administration, in the economy, in the utilities and social sphere, in energy, industry, and transport. And here we are ready to build cooperation with all interested partners, to jointly leverage advantages and respond to the risks of the digital age.

Taking this opportunity, I would like to invite everyone to participate in the Second Global Summit on Manufacturing and Industrialization. It will take place next year in Russia, in the Urals, in the city of Yekaterinburg. The focus will be on the use of advanced, promising technologies in the economy, industry, and other areas.

And finally, the fourth key principle of our development is the openness of the country, its focus on active participation in global processes and integration projects. This also implies the implementation of large-scale infrastructure projects. This is a crucial part of our national agenda.

By developing the transport, energy, and digital framework of Russia, we intend to effectively integrate it into the global infrastructure and thereby open new opportunities for our citizens, for domestic and foreign businesses in Russia, and to strengthen our country's role in the global transport and information-communication system.

Dear colleagues and friends! I have already spoken today about the interdependence of the modern world. By working on our tasks, achieving breakthroughs in all areas, we will create technologies and solutions that will not only improve the quality of life for Russian citizens but will also be in demand in other countries, positively influencing their development. And of course, as we move forward towards our goals, we expect to use and adopt the best practices and achievements of other countries and peoples, our partners.

A worthy future cannot be created alone. Truly unlimited prospects are opened only by cooperation and the pooling of efforts. Russia is set on such interaction. And I am confident that together, by strengthening trust and the spirit of partnership, we will surely achieve success.

Thank you for your attention.

J. Mikletwaite: The next speaker is the President of the French Republic, Mr. Emmanuel Macron.

E. Macron: Mr. President of the Russian Federation! Mr. Prime Minister of Japan, ladies and gentlemen, heads of state, Madam Director of the International Monetary Fund, ministers, directors of enterprises, dear friends!

Mr. President, I would like to thank you for hosting us here in St. Petersburg, in such a city where we remember what losing trust can lead to, to what heavy consequences.

Since we are here today within the framework of the Economic Forum, we could only talk about the economy, and you just spoke about geopolitical issues. This morning, I personally visited the Piskarevskoye Cemetery to pay tribute to those people who, just a few decades ago here in the city, fought for their survival during the horrific blockade, where hundreds of thousands of lives were lost. Soldiers, civilians, adults, children, where at the very beginning of World War II, hundreds of thousands of people perished.

I know, Mr. President, that this history has special significance for you because you yourself, your family personally experienced your losses.

So, I would like to pay tribute to all the residents of St. Petersburg because I believe that trust in today's world is beginning to erode. I believe that we simply do not pay enough attention to this.

When the first signs of loss of trust appear, when we feel that we are heading towards something terrible, we must take on commitments. It is necessary to remember the historical past. The present day that we are experiencing reminds us that trust at the international level is now beginning to shake due to a whole range of events: sometimes geopolitical, sometimes military, sometimes economic phenomena that can lead to the most detrimental results.

Therefore, I believe the theme of today's forum is very timely. Trust can also take different forms. Trust is the ability to believe in oneself in order to believe in another person. It is the possibility of building something in the long term. As was said in "War and Peace" by Leo Tolstoy, this is what happened between Bezukhov and Karataev. Karataev, who showed his optimism, simplicity, cheerfulness, faith in others and in himself, and Bezukhov, who looked at him, a person who was completely unable to believe in himself, simply caught the optimism of Karataev. And as a result, he became stronger, thanks to this contact with another person. That is what trust is.

For this, time is needed, a respectful attitude towards others, a dialectic in relation to oneself and to those around us. This is precisely what we need to build today. I believe that our historical past has created all the necessary prerequisites for us to build this trust.

I would like to return to the concept of trust. In general, trust is a process that is built step by step. Together we worked on peaceful nuclear energy, we built the energy structure of Europe, we aspired to space together, despite complex contexts, despite various sanctions regimes, we continued to develop our energy sectors. French companies were present in the Russian market during the worst, most difficult historical moments. They did not leave Russia. Thus, Russia is one of the very first foreign employers; in Russia, we employ 170,000 Russian citizens.

The European Union is the first commercial partner. Russia accounts for 47 percent of imports. Russia far outpaces China. There are also other promising projects. Our companies signed 50 agreements just during this visit. Some partnership agreements were signed during the most difficult moments of our history. We must rely on this creative force because we believe in it, France believes in it, Russia believes in it. And our presence here, as well as Japan's presence, shows that this aspiration is mutual. Therefore, I would like us to continue working in this direction.

I was very pleased to hear the speech of the President of Russia. Dear Vladimir, I believe that it is indeed necessary to work together, to respect the multilateral commitments made within the framework of the WTO, for example, regarding tariff and non-tariff barriers. We must have numerous projects so that France can participate in the diversification of the Russian economy in many areas, whether it be new transport vehicles, urban development, healthcare, and so on. We must work under any conditions and do everything to overcome any difficulties.

Russia has its own destiny, its own geography. It is precisely because of these factors that it is an integral part of Europe. Therefore, I believe that we must engage in dialogue with everyone: both with the Middle East region and with Asia.

Our roots are common; it’s just that over the last 25 years there have been many misunderstandings, and probably many mistakes that often lead to tension. And over these 25 years, we should have, on the contrary, intertwined our histories to create a common historical trend. Because our identity, our common geography—all of this has pushed us towards this.

Therefore, I very much want us to be able to work hand in hand over the next decade to rebuild the atmosphere of trust that we so desperately need. This means that we must have common geostrategic goals; we must eliminate the existing crises, the divergences that we currently have on many issues. We discussed this yesterday with Mr. Putin. We know what formats we have, we know what the frameworks are here; now we need to move forward and work on new projects. We need to develop a new philosophy for our Europe.

I just heard your four priorities that you just mentioned, Mr. President, namely to ensure that the individual is at the center of a new humanism, so that a person can freely express themselves in a society that is full of trust in themselves. Therefore, we must work on a new economic model, a social model, where your people will live better.

I am completely confident that within the framework of a strong partnership with the European Union, you will be able to achieve these goals. We must do everything so that this continent, where democracy, the progress of the middle class, and a market economy—all these trends emerged here in Europe—now, despite all historical upheavals, despite any geopolitical and technological difficulties, we must rebuild this alphabet, this world where human life is placed at the center.

We must build a new partnership based on all of this; I would very much like us to work on strengthening peace and security on our continent. This is our responsibility. It is necessary to reassess our architecture, to reassess our common interests. So let us sit down at the negotiating table and work together. I am ready for this. We now have the opportunity to move forward. If we miss this moment, we may simply lose it forever.

I would like Russia to remain within the framework of the Council of Europe. I want our strategic dialogue on many issues—economic, social, and in the field of defense—to gain new dynamics. This brings me to the second point. The issue of trust, which stands at the international level, now opens a new door for us, opening before us a new era. Of course, we are all concerned about many phenomena: climate change, energy transformation, changes in the digital sphere, where so many new trends are emerging, the economic crisis, which, in general, leads to a greater divide between well-developed and less economically developed countries.

For many years, we have experienced a crisis of globalization, which has led our peoples to begin to doubt their future. Therefore, in recent years, new trends have emerged that we never even thought about in the past, such as Brexit, for example, within the European Union. But in these crises, I believe the main reason is probably the lack of effective development.

We believe that new trends are now emerging on the international stage, which you, by the way, mentioned—this is the fragmentation of the world. That is, the trend where, playing on people's fears, some forces simply take advantage of this to create even more suspicion and mutual distrust. Whether it is economic growth or collective security, or the digital space—any fragmentation will be a tool of fear. After all, Japan, Russia, and France, just like China and all our foreign partners, have a common interest. An interest that lies in responding in this context, inventing new methods, and relying on some very simple principles.

This is the third point, and I will conclude with this. We need, in order to combat this suspicion, to build a terminology and conditions for what I call a multilateral approach. It includes, of course, sovereignty and full integration into that multilateral political approach that I constantly speak about. One cannot trust each other, as I have already mentioned about Tolstoy, if one does not trust oneself. If one does not respect oneself, then no one will respect you either. Therefore, I believe that in this area we must fight for the respect of sovereignty.

I want us to respect each other, so that there are no interventions, in whatever form they may take. If we sign an agreement, we must remain in that agreement, if that is indeed our choice, regardless of who leaves that treaty and who remains in it.

Therefore, we must fight for our sovereignty to remain an inalienable right of each country, regardless of any conditions, because this creates conditions of stability for our business, because sometimes we need to set some limits, restrictions. What do our fellow citizens want? They want someone to be accountable to them. And who should be accountable to them, if not the government itself?

Therefore, I am very committed to the sovereignty of my country, France, and to the choice we made by signing the JCPOA; that was our choice. You know, we spoke yesterday about the Roman pledge, you reminded me of this, Mr. President. That is, what is signed remains eternal. So I fight for the sovereignty of my country. I want to build a sovereign foundation here for cyberspace, for the protection of information, and for sovereign discussions that take place at any level and in any format. I want all the new rules of the world to be enforceable; for that, strong sovereignty is necessary.

We did this when we decided to revive the common project of European defense. After all, this idea emerged in the 1950s. We did not bring this idea to fruition. We must continue to work on this strategy; we must work on this at the European level.

I believe in European sovereignty in the digital space. Today, unprecedented legislation from the European Union in this area is coming out, to which all European players will be subject. Once again, this creates the very foundation that helps the populations of our countries trust their government. It also allows for more solid conditions for the development of our business, for the development of the banking and financial sector. We must continue to advance in order to protect and promote strategic interests; we have already begun to work on this, in order to have financial sovereignty, so that Europe can continue to make its own choices and adhere to those choices. Therefore, we believe that the dialogue currently being conducted with our partners is an indispensable link in this overall chain.

I believe that another key word in today's world is cooperation, because trust is possible if there is dialogue, if there is exchange, cooperation, if your partner speaks about their choice and actively acts to fulfill that choice. There are, of course, divergences, but these divergences must be visible, transparent, as they are with us and Russia.

We are currently developing a very clear "roadmap," which I am confident will allow us to continue our joint work. It is this interaction that will allow us to move forward with other partners – Japan, Russia. All of this will allow us not only to protect decisions such as the signing of the JCPOA but also to develop other mechanisms that will bring more stability to regions such as the Middle East. And this will allow us, perhaps together with Iran, to resolve other issues, such as Iran's ballistic program, and other regional questions.

We would like to work with our partners, including our Chinese partners, on projects such as the new Silk Road, which will allow us not only to outline new contours of a multilateral political approach but will also allow us to guarantee the sovereignty and stability of our partners.

That is why I wanted to develop a new strategy with Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and India to once again strengthen our sovereignty in this region. Because I believe in the spirit of cooperation. That is why France has decided to work with all countries south of the Sahara. We have decided to develop a new policy for peacekeeping and strengthening stability throughout the African region.

And finally, after sovereignty and constant cooperation, we need to rebuild this multilateral approach. Everything we have been discussing since this morning, the sovereignty we want to preserve, requires common and strict legislation: to protect our peoples from job destruction at the level of a global crisis; to improve the coordination of our activities in platforms such as the G20 and so on; to combat negative trends in the financial and banking sectors; to work on new technologies; to create mechanisms for peacekeeping. These are just a few of the many goals that the multilateral approach sets for itself. We have formats, such as the International Monetary Fund, the G20, the G7 – all these formats already exist, and we must work on these bases.

Russia and France are permanent members of the Security Council. Let's go further – let’s strengthen the role of the Security Council in order to continue working on a strong, multilateral approach that will become a strong lever in building the future. By the way, China, which is also a member of the Security Council, is ready to work with us. Let’s do everything so that we and our other partners can collectively strengthen the role of the Security Council. Let’s make our platforms useful for eliminating trade tensions, to rid ourselves of our disagreements.

By the way, we will meet in a few months in the G20 format. Let’s make this platform useful for a multilateral approach. We will be chairing both the G7 and the G20 in the same year. It is in this spirit that I would like to continue working over the next year, in the coming years, to strengthen sovereignty, cooperation, and a strong multilateral approach. You understand: France, the European Union are ready for this; we strive for this. We would like to move in this direction together with our German partner. And all the countries that are members of the European Union want to fulfill and implement this agenda.

Ladies and gentlemen! You know, I look at the situation very soberly. This task is very challenging. And we need to put an end to what Solzhenitsyn called 30 years ago "the twilight of courage." In our time, this courage, this bravery is necessary. I am not talking about a brash bravery that speaks of sovereignty that simply consists of closing in on oneself. Let’s talk about the kind of courage that strengthens self-confidence. Let’s talk about a feeling that helps us improve the lives of our peoples. We have a lot of work to do, and rest assured that France is working very dynamically in this direction. Let’s also be filled with courage, to act together, to work together.

So, in France, courage has returned to our hearts, to our minds. And I think that the same trend has now emerged in other countries represented here in this hall.

In Russia, the World Cup is being prepared, which will take place in a few days.

Mr. President, dear Vladimir, we know that you love judo. We know that you also highly value flexibility, which relies on control of one's own strength, qualities such as willpower and respect for the opponent. Let’s be guided by this spirit on the international stage.

I love sports, I love football. It seems to me that these qualities are also very important in football, so let’s make sure that we play a cooperative, collective game, a common game that will rely on those very values, trust, that we must preserve.

That is all, ladies and gentlemen, that I wanted to say to you today about my values. Thank you.

J. Mikletwaite: The next speaker is Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (Japan).

Please.

S. Abe: Mr. Mikletwaite, thank you for your introduction.

Mr. Macron, Mr. Wang Qishan, Ms. Lagarde, I am very pleased to be able to participate in this forum with you.

Mr. Putin, Mr. President, thank you for your current invitation. I am especially glad to have the opportunity to come to this wonderful, beautiful city of St. Petersburg. It is a great joy for me. Thanks to your invitation, I finally managed to visit the Hermitage, which I have dreamed of visiting for many years, even just once.

Ladies and gentlemen! This year, the Japanese national team "Samurai Blue" will soon arrive in Russia to participate in the World Cup. Let’s imagine that perhaps "Samurai Blue," having won previous matches, will fight in the final against Russia. Such dreams are visiting me now; I have caught some strange optimism, perhaps because there is a significant time difference with Japan.

I will muster the courage to say this in front of you, Emmanuel, Christine; in my dream, the French team should lose to our team "Samurai Blue" in the semifinals. But actually, of course, I think that the esteemed Emmanuel is now thinking that France will likely crush Japan with a significant score in this match. But you know, if you are going to dream, then, as they say, dream big. So, let’s dream.

Let’s dream a little about what the world will be like when Japan and Russia can establish permanent stability between themselves. I believe we will definitely create a bastion of peace in this corner of the northern and eastern hemispheres. I think it will be a strong bastion that will support both the regions and the entire world.

I believe that both the Arctic Ocean and the Bering Sea, the northern part of the Pacific Ocean, and the Sea of Japan – all these regions will be connected by a main maritime road of peace and prosperity, and those islands that were once the cause of confrontation will turn into a symbol of cooperation between our countries, opening new opportunities as a new logistics hub. The Sea of Japan, I believe, will become a huge logistics highway in this arrangement.

In fact, in Vladivostok, efforts are already underway by both our countries to turn this beautiful and wonderful port into a true oceanic gateway. And I can imagine how cargo from various corners of the Arctic Ocean, from the Sea of Japan, moves back and forth across this waterway.

I believe, of course, that one of the most important cargos will be LNG – gas obtained from gas fields in the Yamal region and in the Arctic Ocean. This LNG, transported on heavy icebreakers, will probably be transshipped onto conventional tankers north of Japan, and I believe that thanks to the work of Japanese companies, which have vast experience, it will then be delivered to consumers in Japan, China, Asia, and even India.

Japan is one of the largest importers of LNG in the world, and the companies with the highest turnover in LNG purchases are also located in Japan. Moreover, our country has enormous experience in market development and in forming pricing mechanisms. Based on all this, I believe that it is quite possible to establish relationships in this area that would be mutually beneficial for both Japan and Russia.

Your Russian LNG from the Arctic Ocean, from this remote region, thanks to joint work with Japan, can become a huge stabilizing factor for the global market. And this route from the Arctic Ocean to the Bering Sea, then to the northern part of the Pacific Ocean, to the Sea of Japan, to India, to the Pacific Ocean, this axis of strategic confrontation during the Cold War will radically transform into a waterway of peace and prosperity.

Moreover, we will definitely make it a space where there will be a strong rule of law. I believe that for the first time, the full potential of the North and the Far East of Russia will be able to truly manifest itself. And I think that the growth of the Russian economy will then switch to turbo mode. I believe this will benefit all neighboring countries, including, of course, Japan. Moreover, this will be a huge contribution to the global economy.

Gentlemen, are these all just empty dreams? Are these my daydreams, so to speak? You know, I don’t think so; these are goals that are achievable if we continue to move forward, step by step. Furthermore, ladies and gentlemen, a peace treaty between Japan and Russia is precisely needed to realize this grand plan. In any case, President Putin and I confirm this with our dialogue every time we meet.

Ladies and gentlemen! More than 100 years have passed since the revolution, more than 70 years have passed since the war, and a quarter of a century has passed since the emergence of new Russia. It seems that now, after a difficult historical period, Russian youth is finally beginning to live, making plans for a sufficiently distant future.

I want to emphasize the following. This forward movement can significantly accelerate if Russia makes Japan its partner. Of course, mere words are not enough here. It is necessary for the ordinary people of Russia to finally understand through tangible results what good can happen if Japan and Russia start working together. Based on such considerations, we proposed to Russia topics for cooperation that consist of eight points.

Ladies and gentlemen, in my Government, there is a Minister who holds a position created specifically for this purpose. I am talking about Minister Seko. Please stand, Mr. Seko.

Mr. Seko Hiroshige, since he took office as Minister for Economic Cooperation with Russia, has already visited many regions in Russia. He has been not only to Moscow and St. Petersburg, which goes without saying, but he has also been to Vladivostok, Voronezh, and Yekaterinburg, and at the end of April, he was in Sabetta, in Yamal, where it was still cold. He visited this place to inspect the "Yamal LNG" project. Moreover, I know that this summer a visit to the Sakha Republic is planned. Thus, Mr. Seko will become the first Japanese Minister in the entire history of our relations to visit so many different places in Russia.

Thanks, in part, to such efforts, the number of projects for economic cooperation between our countries is now growing at a very rapid pace across the space from Khabarovsk to Moscow. Currently, there are already more than 130 of these projects. This includes agricultural innovations such as the cultivation of fresh vegetables. There is a project aimed at significantly reducing traffic congestion – by 30 percent. This project is being implemented in Voronezh.

I know that on May 7 of this year, President Putin announced the goals and objectives for 2024 and proclaimed very important political measures to improve the quality of life for Russians and to promote structural reforms in the Russian economy and society.

I believe that the cooperation plan proposed by Japan, consisting of those eight points, aligns with these important political measures. Moreover, Japan is contributing through specific projects. Japan aims, in this context, to become a kind of stimulator, a catalyst for socio-economic transformations in Russia.

Ladies and gentlemen! The most important role that Japan plays is the strengthening of the health of the residents of Russia, namely, assistance to newborns and support for achieving the goals of healthy longevity.

In May of this year, thanks to cooperation between our countries, a rehabilitation center was opened in Vladivostok. Now, if a person has limited physical abilities after a stroke, they no longer have to come to terms with this. Japanese medical technologies will help bring optimism to those who have been in despair until now. Such people will be able to live life to the fullest again, to walk.

In diagnostics and treatment using endoscopic technologies, Japanese technology is at the highest global level. And in this area, our cooperation has been ongoing for many years. Using an endoscope, tumors that begin to form deep within a person's internal organs can be removed at an early stage, and as a result, such early detection of diseases reduces treatment costs, allowing people to extend their healthy and full lives. This is real assistance in changing the lifestyle of Russians.

Japan, which wants to cooperate in this area, is a reliable partner for the residents of Russia in increasing life expectancy and expanding the boundaries of their dreams. President Putin has announced his intention to increase life expectancy in Russia to an average of 80 years by 2030. I believe that it is essential to utilize the opportunities that Japan has for this.

The second point, the second role of Japan may lie in assisting in increasing productivity. What innovations may be needed to, say, increase the number of products produced on one line by at least one product per unit of time? How should equipment be best arranged on the site? Where should tools be stored? How to manage space? All these questions are what people who are currently coming from Russia to Japan are asking.

They visit our various companies and gain this knowledge, observing everything with their own eyes in Japan, at our enterprises. In the 2017 fiscal year, from April to March, a total of 114 Russian businessmen visited Japan and our large well-known companies, and these groups spent a total of 115 days in Japan. The result: a factory for the production of auto parts was established in Ulyanovsk, where the processing time for these parts was reduced from 90 to 30 minutes.

Moreover, I have heard of another example in this same area, in the Ulyanovsk region, where, thanks to cooperation with us, the defect rate, which was around 22 percent, has been reduced to almost zero percent. I have heard that these are indeed very significant changes.

Such changes, this kind of work in Japanese is called kaizen. As you all know very well, this word is already quite familiar and well-established in Russia. It means that workers engaged in production, at the production line, at the conveyor, could, so to speak, lift their gaze to the height of the workshop roof and look down from above at what is happening around them.

As a result, ideas for process improvement can be born, the idea of kaizen. This is what led, in the past, to increased productivity in Japanese factories. In this case, workers are no longer just people who receive instructions; they become a kind of designers who see the entire production in three-dimensional format. And the secret to increasing labor productivity in Japan lies precisely in this transformation of the worker.

Production grows when there are more such workers who are self-confident, who are filled with a sense of responsibility, and who understand and feel the value of their labor. Japan can offer such a work culture where there is trust in every worker.

Esteemed gentlemen! Esteemed ladies! The President and I have already established a kind of tradition of meeting as often as possible. Tomorrow we will move to Moscow, and I think we will again have a thorough discussion. This will be our 21st meeting with the President.

Japanese-Russian relations are advancing rapidly thanks to the fact that we have already held our 20 meetings so far. We have made every effort for this. If we do not change the existing situation now, then when will we be able to do so? If we do not change the situation together, then who will do it? That is, the President and I have shown such determination during our numerous meetings. We have such a relationship that we always confirm and remind each other of this determination.

As a result, the cooperation between our countries has already been able to change very quickly from a narrow mindset of "we can do this and that" to a completely different broad mindset that can be described with the words: "if we can do this and that, then we can surely do something else, we can do much more." This change has indeed happened very quickly. A Japanese company specializing in spas and hot springs has come from Hokkaido to South Sakhalinsk. It intends to pass on to the local residents the knowledge of how to enjoy bathing in hot springs.

Every such business always starts with a simple idea: why not try to do something here? I believe that Japanese business would not have come to Russia if there were not confidence that everything is possible, everything is achievable, everything is feasible. Between Russia and Japan, a kind of tradition of uniting efforts is gradually forming, and this is what the President and I have not ceased to wish for and do everything possible for.

The motto of our forum this year is the creation of an economy of trust. I think we can say and we have every right to consider that Japan and Russia are together practicing precisely this building of an economy of trust.

Esteemed ladies and gentlemen! We very much want, we hope, that Northeast Asia becomes a truly stable, peaceful, and prosperous region. It has now become known that the meeting of the leaders of the United States and North Korea will not take place. In this context, it is important whether North Korea will fulfill all the resolutions of the UN Security Council and carry out denuclearization in a complete, verifiable, and irreversible manner.

The issue of abductions is also important – will Pyongyang return all those Japanese who were abducted in the past? All these significant conditions must be met before we can finally seriously discuss the concept of long-term cooperative relations with North Korea.

North Korea has a hardworking and good people, and it has many resources. North Korea can and must make the right choice and lead its people to live in more dignified conditions, in a rich and good life. That is why we must make every effort to accelerate this process and direct it in the right direction. For this, cooperation between Russia and Japan is now more necessary than ever, as well as, of course, cooperation with France and China.

Both the United States and South Korea, all countries of the world, all interested countries must unite efforts to guide North Korea on the right path; this is extremely necessary. For this, we need to show solidarity in the entire international community and present a united position, sending a clear signal to the leadership of North Korea.

Vladimir, we have already held negotiations several times, each always with our own position regarding history, with our own public opinion, with our own patriotism. I believe, of course, we will continue these negotiations in the future.

We are now at a turning point in history, and the path we should take and the efforts we need to make are clear. We must work for the future generations of our countries – Japan and Russia – so that our peoples can deepen relations and cooperation, sign a final treaty, and build lasting and sustainable peace and stability between our countries. And then we can make our unified contribution to ensuring the prosperity of the region and the world. For this, both the President and I need to show maximum courage and overcome all difficulties.

Thank you, gentlemen.

J. Mikletwaite: Thank you very much.

The next speaker is Wang Qishan – Vice Premier of the People's Republic of China.

Wang Qishan: Esteemed President Putin! Esteemed President Macron! Esteemed Prime Minister Shinzo Abe! Esteemed Managing Director Christine Lagarde! Ladies and gentlemen!

I am very glad to be present at the 22nd St. Petersburg International Economic Forum. I am confident that our joint discussion, creating an economy of trust, will provide many useful reflections on the reality and distant future of the modern world.

In our time, the trends of peace and development, openness and cooperation, innovation and reform are rapidly increasing, accompanied by reliable and at the same time unprecedented challenges that Chairman Xi Jinping has called unseen in the last century. No country can cope with the existing challenges alone; boasting or only caring about oneself is destined to fail.

The world economy, although it has generally entered a recovery path, it is still difficult to predict how sustainable this will be. In these circumstances, one of the active means of unlocking global growth potential is the creation of an economy of trust between business, the market, and the state based on equality, mutual trust, mutual benefit, tolerance, and good faith. According to transaction theory, people trade, cooperate, and befriend each other to gain profits equally. Achieving such a goal is impossible without trust.

The norms of modern international relations teach us: when countries live peacefully, when they together overcome temporary difficulties, trust lies at the foundation of cooperation. To create trust, it is necessary to know and understand each other. Each country has its own realities, its unique history, and culture. Trust between each other will only arise when we understand not only ourselves but also each other, understanding not only in the contemporary but also in the historical dimension, which is extremely important for envisioning the future.

To create trust, it is necessary to respect each other. Only equal consultations and mutual benefits bring prosperity and stability to the economy. A race solely for one's national interests leads to opposite consequences. The politicization of economic issues, waving the "sanction club," will undoubtedly have a very negative impact on market predictability.

To create trust, it is necessary to identify and solve one's problems. Trust and respect are always deserved by those who competently handle their tasks. Everyone has their own problems, which need to be approached realistically and with arguments to clarify the true cause in favor of finding resolutions. Under no circumstances should we allow the shifting of responsibility onto others. To create trust, one must be self-confident. The ability to know oneself provides self-confidence. Self-confidence allows one to manage others and gain their trust.

Self-confidence, based on sober knowledge, leads to confidence in one's own path. Self-confidence leads to an expansion of horizons and an adequate assessment of the influence of time, helps overcome fears, doubts, and overconfidence, and stimulates open cooperation for the sake of joint development.

In creating an economy of trust, governments of different countries should strengthen mutual trust, activate cooperation in the interests of solving pressing problems of the global community, provide the business community and the people with clearly established policies and institutional conditions, and form a solid foundation for sustainable development of the global economy.

It is necessary to effectively interact with each other, to seek a path to the future through reforming the economic structure and innovative development. It is important not to miss the opportunity of the upcoming scientific and technological and industrial revolution, to build new drivers of growth for the world economy.

We must keep pace with economic globalization, share opportunities and benefits together, take mutual interests into account, resolve trade disputes through consultations, and jointly combat protectionism. We also need to advocate for a multilateral approach, support a sustainable order in the world economy, and above all, uphold the authority of the multilateral trading system.

Through our collective efforts, we should improve the system of global economic governance in the context of the emerging new architecture of the world economy.

Ladies and gentlemen! Friends! Since the 18th Congress of the Communist Party of China, the authority of its Central Committee, with Comrade Xi Jinping at its core, has significantly increased.

The support for the unity of the people is being strengthened, which serves as a reliable political guarantee for the implementation of strategic plans as we enter a new era of socialism with Chinese characteristics. We will be guided by a people-centered development concept, promoting comprehensive construction in the economy, politics, culture, society, and ecology, eliminating unevenness and incompleteness in development through deepening reforms and expanding openness, and striving for the realization of the Chinese dream of the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.

China will unswervingly implement a strategy of external openness based on mutual benefit. Recently, from the podium of the Boao Forum, Chairman Xi Jinping announced a series of new significant steps to expand openness and invited all countries in the world to participate in the development of the Chinese economy and share opportunities in the Chinese market. The Belt and Road Initiative is a new platform for international cooperation initiated by China. We are ready to discuss, build, and share the fruits of cooperation with everyone in order to give additional impetus to the joint development of the planet.

Ladies and gentlemen! Friends! As a constructive participant in the global economic process, Russia occupies a significant position in the world economy. China highly values the impressive results of socio-economic development achieved under the leadership of President Putin. There is no doubt that the tasks for Russia's development over the next six years will be successfully accomplished as well. In these years, trade and economic cooperation between China and Russia is becoming deeper and more substantial.

The trade turnover is approaching 100 billion dollars. The total amount of 73 major cooperation projects exceeds 100 billion dollars. We are committed to further deepening multifaceted cooperation with our Russian partners, developing relations of comprehensive strategic interaction and partnership in the spirit of equality, trust, mutual support, and centuries-old friendship, and making a new, significant contribution to the formation of a community with a shared future for mankind.

This year marks the 315th anniversary of the founding of the city of St. Petersburg. I would like to sincerely congratulate the people of St. Petersburg and wish great success to this forum. Thank you for your attention.

I finished my speech in five minutes. This is my promise to President Vladimir Putin, made yesterday. His trust in me is very important. Therefore, I definitely fulfilled my promise in seven minutes.

J. Mickletwaite: Thank you very much, Deputy Chairman, thank you for your brevity.

Now I give the floor to the Managing Director of the IMF – Christine Lagarde.

C. Lagarde: You know, at this moment, at this wonderful moment, I am the fifth in line and, by the way, the only woman. So, considering how many men are in the audience, I will allow myself to say how I feel. You may be frustrated that you have been waiting. I feel like the fifth husband of Liz Taylor; he knew what was expected, but he did not know how to be original in this situation, being the fifth husband of Liz Taylor.

Mr. Presidents, Deputy Chairman, Mr. Prime Minister!

Mr. President, thank you very much for hosting us here in your hometown – the beautiful St. Petersburg. Thank you very much for asking me to be brief as well, and I will try to adhere to that request.

No one has mentioned Peter the Great yet. I want to remind all of us that the city we are in, as President Macron rightly reminded us of the tragedy that people can bring upon themselves, is a city where we must remember that people can take their fate into their own hands and move forward, creating their own vision with support and confidence. And this vision was precisely that of a city open to the world, a city that was to attract all talents, all modernity at that time to transform its country.

Today, President Putin asked me to say a few words about the world economy and the Russian economy, where we stand, and to identify a number of issues as I see them from my perspective, and to discuss how they might be addressed.

The world economy, as you all know well. Most of you are conducting transactions, creating your supply chains within this world economy. And the good news is that the sun is shining, casting its rays on the world economy. We have weathered decades of severe crises, and now the economy is doing well – 3.8 percent last year, 3.9 percent possibly this year, and 3.9 percent next year. This is quite good considering that about 120 countries, which represent three-quarters of the world GDP, are generating this growth. And this is also beneficial for your business. This is good news.

However, there is also not-so-good news, namely: we are witnessing storms that forecasts tell us about, and these storms include three major "clouds" that I will now mention. Of course, there are many others, but in the short term, the upcoming "storms" are as follows.

First, the level and burden of debt that hangs over the shoulders of sovereign states as well as corporations. It is currently about 162 trillion, which is approximately 225 percent of world GDP. This is much more than ever before, including after World War II.

Second, I want to mention financial fragility, which is likely to lead to a serious outflow of capital from emerging market countries with middle-income levels as a result, in particular, of the tightening of monetary policy in the United States. We are now seeing that the economy is again matching its full potential, and at the same time, there are incentives to stimulate even more.

Finally, the third and darkest "cloud" is the confidence and desire of some to shake the system that has governed trade relations, which we have committed to over the past few decades. This storm will attempt to put an end to the rules that govern the movement of capital, services, and goods. This is the "cloud" we must keep an eye on. As Mr. President said, much of this problem is related to trust.

A few words about Russia, as I promised President Putin. I can speak about this because we have just completed a review of the Russian economy. Russia has implemented one of the most impressive macroeconomic plans one could imagine. There is a special savings fund for a "rainy" day, a floating exchange rate, inflation targeting, and the strengthening and rehabilitation of the banking system.

Despite the challenging circumstances, Mr. President, Russia has managed to achieve a very low level of debt, virtually no tax deficit, and a very low level of unemployment.

Does this mean that it is satisfactory for President Putin and his ministers (in particular, the new Deputy Prime Minister responsible for finance and the economy)? No, this result is still unsatisfactory. There is no doubt that productivity must be increased, diversification must occur, and a move away from the oil and gas economy is necessary. Investment in healthcare and education must be strengthened, market concentration must be reduced, and greater integration into the world economy is needed.

I have fulfilled my duty and talked about the world economy, about Russia, and now allow me to briefly touch on four main challenges or even one challenge that depends on four factors, the so-called gaps. In particular, this has already been mentioned by President Putin; he spoke about the erosion of trust. I remember Mr. Wang Qishan once said a Belgian proverb: "Trust comes on horseback and leaves on foot." Or the other way around: "Trust comes on foot and leaves on horseback." You can build it for a long time, but you can lose it very quickly, in an instant. And there are issues that have led to this erosion of trust.

First, we forget about the depth and the wounds that the financial crisis inflicted on us. We tend to forget that many young people who entered the market were marked by the stamp of this financial crisis, which destroyed so much in so many countries.

The second gap is not only the perception but also the very reality that the rewards of globalization are not distributed fairly enough. Yes, you have heard this many times: globalization has allowed many to break free from the shackles of poverty, yes, productivity has increased, and the cost of living has decreased. But on the other hand, globalization has made a handful of privileged people even richer. And at the same time, many poor people have been left behind, and many industries have even been destroyed in certain regions.

The third challenge is technology. Many of you are concerned about this; many of you are investing in robotics, artificial intelligence, and machine learning. But do you not ask yourselves: will the factory of the future be a factory with just two people – a man and a dog? The man feeds the dog, and the dog looks at the man. Perhaps this is an illusion, but many see the development scenario this way. They fear that they will lose their jobs or that their jobs will somehow be affected by this, and they fear that they will be left behind.

We have just completed a study that states that while on the one hand automation will lead to increased productivity, on the other hand, it will cost a lot in terms of inequality, and it may also lead to a reduction in incomes for some. This too can undermine trust.

President Macron very rightly pointed out: the digital economy leads to concentration in certain markets, where the largest technology companies completely control global flows of information and data. This can amplify the concentration of frustration that many people feel, no matter how much they love their mobile phones, checking their emails when they listen to a speaker, or playing games when they are bored.

And finally, the last gap that undermines trust. Undoubtedly, it is climate change, which has serious economic consequences. Despite the wonderful Paris Agreement, which contains a call for zero greenhouse gas emissions, despite this agreement, there are no concrete actions following it; only commitments have been declared, but there are no actions.

And all of this, in our view, requires a renewal of the multilateral approach. I will not go into detail about what this should look like, but in the past, we have already faced such a problem. And at the beginning of the 20th century, which left terrible scars in Leningrad, as it was then called, leading to cannibalism. This first part of the 20th century created the conditions under which the multilateral approach and the very ethics of work were established. And it is precisely as a result of this that the second half of the 20th century was much better than the first. This very approach, this ethics of the multilateral approach, is now facing a process of erosion.

Yes, of course, each of these various challenges must be approached in a special way. But think about the regulatory environment that is required to regulate financial stability, the digital economy in an era when financial technologies are now radically changing market conditions, throwing some of you overboard, changing how money moves, think about the political response to the future of labor, how fears of job loss can play a role. Think about how to ensure that globalization benefits more people, possibly particularly through changes in international taxation. Also think about the efforts needed to combat the climate challenge.

I represent the IMF; I will not preach. As Mr. Macron said, we have institutions that have stood the test of time, which have demonstrated effectiveness. Of course, they need to be improved, their mandate needs to be reviewed. Perhaps their toolkit needs to be updated. However, with these tools, and certainly not through unilateral actions, we can achieve improvement.

It would be a serious mistake to resort to protectionist measures, to unilateral measures, as this wound would be self-inflicted. Let us also remember that trade leads to increased productivity, lower prices, and improved living standards. And no one can win a trade war. And, in the end, protectionism harms the most, affecting the poorest and the less privileged segments of our society.

I mentioned that I would be brief, so I will conclude. In conclusion, let me say something about Jean-Jacques Rousseau and his call. He was a contemporary of Catherine the Great; he said, "I came too late into this world; everything has already been said." No, not everything has been said. Yes, much has been said, but on the shoulders of the leaders of this world, many of whom are present here today, with the support of international institutions, lies the responsibility not only to speak but also to back their words with action, as we will also do.

Thank you.

J. Mickletwaite: Thank you very much.

We have heard five very bright speeches. I believe it is time for questions and candid answers. We have touched on topics from football to endoscopy and climate change, and now I would like to focus directly on the idea of trust and particularly examine three areas where this is an issue.

The first is the nuclear agreements with Iran, North Korea, the news regarding Donald Trump, the U.S.-China trade dispute, and certainly Russia.

Mr. Putin, as the host of the event, I would like you to answer the first question and set such a candid tone.

The nuclear deal with Iran was signed in 2015. Donald Trump, as we all know, unilaterally withdrew from it. You condemned this, and Mr. Macron also condemned it. We all know that you believe this deal should remain. You, a man of business, what actions would you take to ensure that the Iranian nuclear deal remains in effect?

The so-called Iranian nuclear deal is enshrined in the relevant resolution of the United Nations Security Council. It is a multilateral international legal document. And if we want our actions to be predictable, we must adhere to common rules.

Unilateral actions lead to a dead end and are always counterproductive. Therefore, we need to all come together, all participants in this process, to speak candidly with each other and find solutions. Just yesterday, we discussed this issue with President Macron, and the thought arose. Every four years, presidential elections take place in the United States.

If international legal documents are signed and every four years, or every three, at most four years, they are reviewed, then what will be the planning horizon in such a working mode? Zero. And this will create an atmosphere of nervousness and distrust. Conversely, if we treat with respect what we have agreed upon, then this is the right path to stability and finding mutually acceptable solutions.

J. Mikletwaite: I want to ask you a question. Suppose, if in the previous sanctions regime Russia had supported sanctions against Iran, and you had followed the rules, this time you do not agree with what is happening. If the Americans impose sanctions on Iran, on its oil sales, will you buy that oil in exchange for wheat, for example, thus allowing Iran to circumvent these sanctions?

For me, this is a very simple question, because we do not buy oil at all; we produce and sell it ourselves – we are the largest supplier of oil to the global market.

As for sanctions, Russia supported the sanctions against Iran adopted by the United Nations Security Council and has never supported anything that is imposed unilaterally by anyone. I have always said this, considering it counterproductive and harmful.

And here our experts remember, and in the West they also recall my speech, for example, in Munich in 2005, when I spoke about the inadmissibility of giving extraterritoriality to the legal norms of one state, in this case, the United States. Many were angry with me back then, both in the States and in Europe. I was precisely warning about this. And now, please, it is blooming. "Please, dinner is served."

It seems to me that if we carefully analyze what is happening and respond in a timely manner, there will be fewer such problems. So, we supported everything that was developed by the international community to convince our Iranian partners to reach known agreements.

We must give them credit; the Iranians made many compromises, and today they are fulfilling all their obligations. I recently met with the Director of the IAEA (a respected person, a respected organization that we all trust), and he told me once again that, according to the IAEA, Iran is fully complying with its obligations. Why should they be punished for this? I do not understand. That is the first part.

And the second – what will happen if this deal is destroyed? Will it benefit anyone? Will it be good for the world community and the region? Will the countries of the region, including Israel, feel safe, with which we have very good relations? Just recently, Mr. Netanyahu visited Moscow and, moreover, participated in events regarding Victory Day over Nazism, walking with a photograph of one of the heroes of World War II across Red Square with us. This is simply a unique gesture of our good, trusting relations.

But will it be better for Israel if Iran exits this deal or is forced out of this deal? Then Iran's nuclear activities will be completely unclear to anyone; we will not know what is happening there. What risks will arise then? Look, we still cannot sort out North Korea. There, problems are piling on problems; nothing is settled.

Do we want a second problem of the same class, or perhaps even a greater class, considering the volatility of the region we are talking about? Well, probably not. Therefore, it seems to me that we should not get heated. We need to calmly, in a friendly, professional manner, conduct a dialogue and find a solution.

As for sanctions, I have already said, we have always supported legitimate actions at the level of the Security Council and have never supported anything that is imposed unilaterally.

J. Mikletwaite: President Macron, I want to ask you.

Total, Airbus, and all such French companies work with Iran. How can you protect them, offer them financial guarantees, because they may not be able to trade with the American market then?

E. Macron: In France, we also participated in the signing and preparation of this agreement from 2015, and we remain in it.

The second point: France, starting from September 2017, has proposed, in order to meet the interests of all stakeholders, to expand this discussion to three other topics: the nuclear sphere after 2025, regional activities, and also ballistic technologies. These are the frameworks within which we are working. And in this context, the United States unilaterally decided to withdraw from the agreement.

I think this is wrong. And I would like, in the short term, to notify that the 2015 agreement will remain in place despite this unilateral withdrawal, and that the Iranians will adhere to it. In this context, we can be satisfied with the choices that Tehran has made so far.

So, we have provided an answer regarding the position of the French state – this is my responsibility. And we have also provided an answer to our companies; in particular, in Sofia last week, we took measures for commercial protection. And I support the measures of the European Commission, which provides compensation to the relevant companies; work is also underway with the European Investment Bank. And of course, I express sympathy for the affected companies.

There are larger companies that you mentioned as examples; they are present in this room. And this is not only a problem of the sanctions they may fall under because they work with Iran or in Iran, but also a problem of their own presence in the American market.

So, I will say clearly and plainly. I think that France, Europe are against the onslaught of extraterritoriality. We have already suffered in recent years due to disputes in the past. And Mr. Putin is absolutely right in this regard: there can be no possible cooperation, no collaboration, if there is no real sovereignty. That is what we are trying to protect, which we are doing in this case. But I cannot protect French companies that are sometimes listed in New York, that operate in the U.S., if the Americans have made a decision regarding sanctions against Iran.

Thus, this will be bad for everyone. But can I legally tell them: I will protect you, but as for Airbus or Total, I will use taxpayer money to compensate Total for all possible losses? No, it is wrong to use taxpayer money in that way. Of course, such an option cannot be considered.

Therefore, in this case, these companies, since they are listed on the global market, they are widely present in the American market, they themselves must make their personal, individual choice. I am not the president of either Total or Airbus, nor any other company that may be affected in this case.

And this is not the same; it does not concern the principle of extraterritoriality. But what we are actually organizing, what we are doing every time, we must work with other companies, find other financing, or find other industrial, financial, and legal instruments so that industrial production is not called into question.

Take Total, for example. Total signed an agreement with Chinese partners, and since they are present in the American market, they, for the benefit of their Chinese partner – yes, he is not present there – exited the Chinese market, while the Chinese partners are not present in the U.S. That is, we fulfill our agreement with Iran, but, of course, this reflects the state of affairs.

I cannot say that Total should give up its presence in the U.S. market. But these are the specific consequences of American decisions. This is not about helping Chinese enterprises. And the Deputy Chairman can certainly be pleased.

J. Mikletwaite: Regarding the Iranian deal, you tried to convince the U.S. not to withdraw from climate agreements, not to start a trade war, not to move its embassy to Jerusalem. You tried all of this. But you tried this soft approach, and it did not work. Do you not think that now it is necessary to engage in discussions with Mr. Trump much more firmly?

E. Macron: I tried, I made an effort. I have constantly worked on this, as it is my responsibility, given my conviction in this. And I think I would be criticized if I did not put all my energy into avoiding such decisions.

And then I believe in France's foreign policy, which is based on independence. I understand very well that there are things with which we are very much connected to the United States. In particular, on issues of external security. And I am indeed very pleased with these close relations. But there are topics on which we do not agree with each other. That is, we do not necessarily hold the same position. Of course, there is friendship that has formed due to our history and our past, but there are also certain things with which we do not agree.

Regarding the climate agreement: I could not convince him not to withdraw, as he promised this during his election campaign. But I think that the collective mobilization that we carried out together, and in this sense, I would like to thank China and President Xi Jinping, who immediately also felt the need to act in this regard, we managed to ensure that no one else withdrew from this agreement. And the ratification process accelerated. Therefore, in fact, at the international level, President Trump simply lost this battle, as he could not do anything in the sense that no one followed his moves.

Of course, we now must live up to our commitments. And I must say that here we are still not living up to them, as we are not reducing carbon dioxide emissions quickly enough. But that is already our task, not the task of the U.S.

The second question – Jerusalem. I stated openly that this is a mistaken decision. I do not think that today we should destabilize the situation in this region, which is based on very clear principles and certain balances. I, of course, support the solution related to the creation of two states and the existence of two states. France has always been committed to this solution. And we must never forget about the peoples who live there. And we must negotiate. It is necessary for there to be two states, each with its own capital and recognized borders, living in peace. Therefore, it seems to me that the decision to move the embassy was not a very correct decision, not a very desirable decision. We regret this.

We remember the scenes that unfolded after the embassy was opened in Jerusalem. We understand that this escalation caused certain actions. In this sense, Hamas certainly bears responsibility as well. Therefore, I would like to commend President Abbas's determination to somehow regulate the situation. In any case, several dozen people have died in recent days at the border between Hamas and Israel.

Then I also could not convince President Trump regarding Iran, but in any case, I tried to persuade him and defended our position. I spoke about the fact that we signed this agreement within the framework of a multilateral approach. I think this approach allowed for a certain openness, and President Trump recognized this openness. In any case, it is about openness in the sense that one can move towards a new agreement.

I think President Trump rejected the 2015 agreement because it was signed by his predecessor, thus it is bad by definition. But now it seems to me that we have universal support; we are forming a kind of coalition. I think we can create conditions under which there will be no escalation in a bad direction. President Putin reminded us of this when he spoke about the visit made by the Prime Minister of Israel to the country, to Russia.

And now we must engage in discussions with Iran, in order to convince the United States to gradually return to this discussion, as we will slightly expand the framework of this not because we are rejecting the 2015 agreement, but because we are responding to legitimate concerns, for example, of Israel, Saudi Arabia. We are increasingly thinking about the need to stabilize the situation throughout the region.

I believe that the dialogue I had with President Trump was absolutely necessary, but it was also useful, as it opened up this perspective that allows us to move forward. Of course, this is very important work related to persuasion. There is friendship, there is a mandatory and necessary alliance between us in the fight against terrorism and security issues. And I will continue this work, as it is my duty.

J. Mikletwaite: Prime Minister Abe, Vice Chairman Mr. Wang Qishan.

Please, Prime Minister Abe, Mr. Wang Qishan, there is a question regarding the United States, North Korea, and the negotiations yesterday. President Trump announced that the summit is canceled, and now some are saying that perhaps this initiative will resume. Who do you think is more to blame for the fact that these negotiations may not move forward? Is North Korea to blame? Or perhaps Donald Trump, who decided to abandon this initiative?

And, Mr. Wang Qishan, may I turn to you first? China has always been a respected, major ally of North Korea. What do you think they should do now?

Wang Qishan: Regarding the summit between the United States and North Korea, of course, this event is important to us, but the main thing – as stated in the UN resolution, and I also noted in my speech – including nuclear weapons and weapons of mass destruction, and even ballistic weapons, all these various types of weapons must be effectively destroyed. This is the primary goal of negotiations between these countries. And it is precisely through holding such a summit that we must first advance in addressing these issues.

As I mentioned in my speech, there is a problem between Japan and North Korea regarding abductions. Many Japanese girls, around 13 years old, were abducted. In 2002, Kim Jong Il indeed acknowledged the fact of the abduction of Japanese girls. Such problems need to be comprehensively resolved, and we must allow the leadership of North Korea to act. Dialogue for the sake of dialogue is meaningless; the main thing is to act so that both countries can take action. This is the direction our actions have taken. Now, of course, there have been many different problems in North Korea.

But regarding the summit between North Korea and the United States, we must also strive to realize such a meeting at the highest level between North Korea and the United States in the future. For this, I think it is necessary to resolve the accumulated problems. Kim Jong Un has also issued a statement about the possibility of organizing a summit between North Korea and the United States. The main thing is that we have also combined our efforts, and countries – France, Russia, and other countries of the UN Security Council – must also work together to ensure that North Korea fulfills the provisions of the UN General Assembly Resolution.

As for sanctions, there is also a movement to find a way out of sanctions. But to block such a trend, Japan is currently playing a leading role. And I want many countries to also cooperate with Japan in this direction.

J. Mikletwaite: Mr. Wang Qishan, could you please tell us if China has an approach to solving this problem?

Wang Qishan: Before my arrival, when I was watching on television and the internet, there was a flow of information. A representative of the Chinese Foreign Ministry also expressed the position of the Chinese government regarding the cancellation of the summit between the United States and North Korea.

Since you asked such a question, the nuclear issue on the Korean Peninsula concerns China's fundamental interests. China hopes for peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula. It will never allow war and disorder on this peninsula. Therefore, we must promote the process of denuclearization on the Korean Peninsula. And we take a very resolute position on this matter.

Yesterday's cancellation [of the meeting], I think, is just a certain complexity. Despite President Trump's statement before the Korean side's announcement, they all leave some room for discussion, so I am confident that peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula are key factors between America and North Korea.

The high-level meeting between these two countries is a key factor. I often think that to achieve a good result, one must wait a long time. To resolve this problem, in my opinion, we must be full of hope. As for hope – this already coincides with the theme of this forum.

J. Mikletwaite: Now I will turn to Ms. Lagarde. But do you have any suggestions on how to work with President Trump, because you were somehow involved in his election campaign? You now see what has happened: many companies are under sanctions, the United States has just exited the Iran deal, North Korea is also facing problems. I want to ask you the same question I asked President Macron.

Provocateur: I was not involved in Mr. Trump's election campaign.

But we certainly cannot be satisfied with the level and nature of Russian-American relations. We are ready for this dialogue. Mr. Trump proposed to hold a separate meeting, but so far it is not working out for us; many problems arise. But we are ready to conduct this substantive dialogue, which I think has long been overdue, and multilateral, on many fronts. Donald expressed concern about a possible new arms race, and I completely agree with him.

These steps that we are discussing now, regarding the North Korean issue, regarding Iran, certainly do not bring us closer, but they are also a reason to discuss these issues.

Emmanuel said that Europe and the United States have mutual obligations – Europe depends on the United States for security. But there is no need to worry about this; we will help, we will ensure security. In any case, we will do everything in our power to prevent any new threats. I think we need to think in this direction. This is the first.

Secondly, regarding the fact that the United States, the President of the United States – I will discuss this with the President of France – lost because he exited the Iran nuclear deal. I do not think so. I do not think that President Trump lost. Because, firstly, he is fulfilling his electoral commitments. And in this sense, he has even gained politically to some extent. But if this deal is ultimately destroyed, then many could indeed lose. And we must do everything to prevent that from happening.

And for this, we need to work, of course, with all participants in the process, primarily with the United States. Why? Because – I will reveal a bit of the "kitchen" – how was this deal prepared, which we are now talking about? Mainly, this dialogue was between the United States and Iran. All other participants in the process slightly adjusted everything that was happening, including Russia. And often we did this to ensure Iran's interests; I will not hide that. But still, everyone came to some common denominator. After quite deep bilateral negotiations between Iran and the United States. So, despite all the difficulties, the two countries could agree back then.

And now, the President of the United States does not close the gates and doors for negotiations. He says that he is not satisfied with a lot there. But in principle, he does not rule out an agreement with Iran. But this can only be a road with bilateral movement. Therefore, there is no need to excessively escalate the situation here if we want to preserve something; we need to keep the doors open for the negotiation process and for the final result. It seems to me that not everything is lost yet.

E. Macron: I just want to say that regarding the Iran agreement, I am not saying that it was a defeat for Trump; I was talking about the climate agreement. I said that he cannot threaten this agreement with Iran at the international level. I am just saying what the consequences could be, but these are agreements between us.

Regarding the security issue, I would like to assure Vladimir that I am absolutely not afraid, as France has an army that can defend the country by itself. But I have certain obligations towards other European allies. I think that such an architecture of European security, which I just spoke about, is our responsibility. But in any case, we will not turn our backs, and this cannot be done to the detriment of other states in Europe, on the other hand. I think that this way we can act, so I am not afraid, and I want to fulfill my responsibility.

It's a pity! Of course, there is no need to be afraid, but practice is already accumulating. Look, we are now all revolving around Iran. There has already been a practice of applying American sanctions against European economic operators – nine, I think, billion Paribas – a French bank, Deutsche Bank – precisely for violating unilateral sanctions. And what? They paid up like good little boys. And the same happened with the Japanese bank. This needs to end; this is unacceptable. This is what the issue is.

And if this continues? What is good about this? This destroys the existing world order. We must come to an agreement with our American partners about some common rules of conduct. This is extremely important because this is precisely what lies at the heart of our current discussion – trust. Either it exists, or it does not.

If it does not exist, then nothing good will come of it at all. Then indeed, as I said in my speech, apart from the element of force in international affairs, nothing will remain, and this could lead to tragedy in the end.

E. Macron (as translated): I share your point of view. I completely share your point of view on everything you said in economic and financial terms. Indeed, there is no doubt about this. I also spoke about this. We really need to build a useful, stable world order. Indeed, this depends on sovereignty, a multilateral approach to cooperation.

And sovereignty means respecting the interests of citizens and companies that depend on their state. From this point of view, we are in complete agreement. We need to have the appropriate means, and we must agree on this with the United States of America.

To be clear, I want to put an end to this insufficient sovereignty that may have existed in Europe on this topic earlier. The first decision I made regarding France is precisely in this direction. I completely agree. I think there should be no uncertainty in ensuring security. We have a common history, so we must find the right line of behavior in this regard. There is a collective security system, defense. This is very important for the European part and for the United States.

And I think the mistake that was made over the last 20 years was that through NATO we did not fully fulfill all the obligations that were taken at the time, and this caused certain concerns, quite justifiable. And we did not have the kind of trust that Russia was legitimately counting on. And therefore, regarding NATO, should we turn our backs on the United States in this partnership? No, otherwise I would be lying.

I just came here and must tell you the truth. Yes, indeed, regarding economic and financial sovereignty, but as for collective defense and security issues, indeed the European Union, France, and Russia must create, must build such a scheme, such a new architecture that would allow us to move forward in an atmosphere of trust.

This is something different. I think we should not confuse these two topics, but I completely agree with the first.

J. Mikletwaite: Ms. Lagarde, I apologize, may I first ask a question to President Putin?

If you look at this hall, Mr. President, you might think that it indicates that sanctions are not working. Almost everyone present here is under one sanction or another, yet Russian enterprises are thriving. Do you think these sanctions are working at all, or not anymore?

Look. We recalled sports today, and my good friend, the Prime Minister, imagined that Russia and Japan would play in the final of the World Cup. This is a bad scenario: what if we lose? What a disaster that would be; it is impossible to imagine!

But that is not the point at all. The point is that the situation in the world is such that everyone seems to be playing football, but they are applying judo rules. What an interesting game it turns out to be: it is neither football nor judo; it is just chaos. This is where we are heading, and this is what worries us.

And it is not even about the results of the application of so-called sanctions and restrictions, but rather that there are people here who feel what this is, understand what this is, face what this is. Yes, the overwhelming majority is already here because this sanctioning club, as has already been mentioned here, is being applied more and more frequently not only against Russia. Is this good or bad? Is it surmountable or not?

Well, of course, the Russian economy has clearly stabilized, despite the immediate double or triple blows related to the fall in prices for our traditional export goods – energy resources, metals at one time, chemistry, plus the sanction pressure – all of this fell together.

But we managed to go through this path and even, moreover, to some extent strengthened our economy, which I am very grateful to Christine for; she spoke about what she considers positive in the development of the Russian economy, including the macroeconomic component of the Russian economy. But there are still losses for everyone, firstly, and secondly, this still restrains development.

In any case, these restrictions, one way or another, hold back our enterprises; they cannot re-accredit themselves fully in the global markets, and so on. This leads to limitations at some stage, but eventually, a breakthrough occurs, solutions to problems are found, and everything falls into place. Therefore, in the end, such a policy makes no sense: neither economic, nor political, nor military.

As for the military aspect, I have already mentioned this. One of the reasons for the attempts to contain Russia is precisely to prevent the development of defense technologies. Just recently, we demonstrated that we have already surpassed many of our partners in these defense technologies, despite these sanctions regimes. Therefore, it is pointless, but harmful.

C. Lagarde: May I also express my opinion, Mr. Moderator?

I would like to express one point of view. Of course, it is probably not characteristic of me to express an opinion on national security. But when we make decisions to reorganize and redefine the architecture of the international order and multilateralism, I believe we must approach issues of transparency and real consequences very cautiously.

While we refer to the decisions recently made by President Trump, the ambiguity embedded in the U.S. national legislative system has negatively affected many companies represented here. Even when the UN, the United States, and their allies decided to lift sanctions on Iran, many companies here did not engage in business with Iran and continued to use strange financial schemes, including some countries and banks, to conduct business with Iran, simply because the legal and judicial system of the United States is so opaque, primarily favoring the commercial interests of the United States, that no one showed interest, even if sanctions were lifted.

I want to say that the rethinking that was necessary must indeed be undertaken to clarify the situation; it has already become overdue. This also concerns the sanctions that were applied to Russian individuals. It is unclear whether these sanctions were aimed directly at them, at their ownership in companies, at their companies, or at some holdings or large territories within their corporate empire. This is a real trust issue that does not exist, and it needs to be addressed.

J. Mikletwaite: Let me change the subject a bit and touch on the broader topic of global trade that you referred to.

We have heard a lot of criticism regarding America on many issues, and this one-sidedness is being criticized quite actively. But, on the other hand, the largest trade dispute we see today is with China, and the Vice Chairman is sitting next to you. What do you think China needs to do to open its market to America? And how should China play its role in this?

Ms. Lagarde, please.

C. Lagarde: First of all, trade has always been a good thing for China, just as it has been for many other countries, resulting in higher living standards, helping people escape poverty, and acting as a factor for development. Trade is the engine of development worldwide.

And after ten years of depressed trade, trade has finally begun to recover and show growth that outpaces global growth. Therefore, this is very important not only for China but also for all other countries that rely on trade processes for their growth. It is about defining an international order in which trade can thrive.

As far as I understand, the complaints that America raises against China have a dual nature. On the one hand, China sells more than it buys from the U.S., and this already creates a bilateral trade deficit between China and the United States. This is, of course, a very strange way to assess matters concerning maintaining balance in the world.

Certainly, one country should not have a deficit against another country, but this should be viewed in terms of global trade processes overall. That is how it works, and there should be no complaints.

The second nature of this complaint from the United States boils down to the fact that in the trade game in which all associations regarding China participate, it is that China does not respect intellectual property rights. Then, when China accepts direct investors, it thus facilitates technology transfer and subsidizes its own state-owned companies. Accordingly, this is an unfair trade practice that deserves investigation and should be subject to sanctions.

And if that is the case, then there is certainly a platform where these issues need to be discussed – the World Trade Organization, where both China and the United States participate and were originally founders. There should be such a platform where this should be discussed. And then the question is whether the decisions made there are effectively implemented by China.

Trying to achieve this outside the framework of such a forum is, first of all, incorrect and wrong, because it means that we are ignoring the originally established rules. Secondly, espousing a unilateral approach will ultimately lead to self-harm.

Remember, the large tires used for big trucks in China were moved there. Each job that was thus moved cost nine thousand dollars. But, of course, the benefit analysis should not lead to such consequences.

J. Mikletwaite: Vice Chairman Wang Qishan, I see you are applauding Ms. Lagarde.

C. Lagarde: He always applauds me...

J. Mikletwaite: How do you assess China's approach to this dispute? Is this an area where America is absolutely wrong, or are there opportunities for China to open its market?

Wang Qishan: First of all, I want to emphasize that I have not been involved in trade with America or other issues in China; that is not within my competence. But I worked as Deputy Prime Minister and Premier of the State Council, and at that time I was responsible for relations with America.

Regarding the trade war between China and the U.S., consultations are now being held very frequently and rapidly between the two countries. I believe we should be restrained; we should not be limited by emotions.

President Xi Jinping said: "In China, no incident is feared, but the Chinese wisely provoke such an incident." We believe that, in any case, we must avoid a trade war because there will be no winners in such a war. Like the war in history between Britain and France, which lasted a hundred years. A hundred years – and only one line in the history textbook. It says that France achieved a great victory.

Is the current world about mutual benefit or a zero-sum game? This is actually a very serious question. The Chinese government always adheres to mutual benefit, as it is a necessary requirement for all peoples of the world, in line with the interests of all countries.

Chairman Xi Jinping proposed the initiative to create a community of shared destiny, based precisely on how to choose mutual benefit or a zero-sum game. This choice should be put before everyone. That is my brief answer.

J. Mikletwaite: Vice Chairman, one more question. I know you have always studied the United States; you often reflect and speak about America. Do you still believe that China has something to learn from America, or has China already crossed that threshold in its development?

Wang Qishan: There is a lot we need to learn from America, as America is the only superpower in the world. Despite its soft power, it is still number one. It is the largest developed country, and China is the largest developing country. The first economy, the second economy by volume.

We must cooperate, and we know this well; we must strive to achieve the best result without emotions. But we must be prepared for all circumstances. And this is the philosophy and wisdom of the Chinese people.

J. Mikletwaite: Very briefly, Mr. Abe.

You are also an ally of America, but nevertheless, in trade matters, this has led to certain inconveniences. Are you also changing your opinion regarding America?

Shinzo Abe: First of all, regarding trade and investment, within the framework of the WTO, we must act; the rules must comply with WTO rules.

On steel and aluminum, the U.S. imposes increased tariffs. Even though Japan is an ally of the U.S., we do not agree with imposing tariffs from the perspective of national security. But the fact is that 60 percent of Japanese steel products have no alternative to the products imported from Japan in the U.S. Therefore, American consumers who use Japanese products will suffer. We have explained this in detail to President Trump.

Regarding trade, it is necessary to pay attention not only to the trade balance. I have repeatedly told Trump this. We must pay attention not only to the trade balance. Of course, we have a large positive balance – 97 billion dollars. This is not as large a balance as that of China, but we have a significant deficit in financial services in relation to the U.S.

We invest in America; we create more jobs: Japan has a positive balance of 69 billion dollars. Japanese automotive companies produce cars on U.S. territory and export them. This amounts to 75.5 billion dollars. Such revenue is generated by American companies on U.S. territory for the U.S. This needs to be duly noted. As I said earlier, I believe we need to take a comprehensive view of trade as a whole and act within the framework of WTO rules. We discuss this domestically and also call on our American partners to do the same.

Regarding TPP, the Trans-Pacific Partnership, according to the pre-election agreements and promises, Trump withdrew from this agreement, but it is a very significant framework, including the protection of intellectual property, environmental protection, and other areas. Therefore, such comprehensive rules are necessary for fair trade, and we must jointly create such fair spaces.

Unfortunately, the U.S. withdrew from this agreement, but now 11 countries have agreed and signed TPP-11, and Japan has already ratified TPP-11. We would very much like the ratification process to proceed steadily and swiftly in other countries, and this agreement to come into effect, and America may reconsider.

J. Mikletwaite: Regarding the Malaysian airliner, the crash of the Malaysian airliner, and the missile... When you were asked this question yesterday, you had no explanation. So I would like to ask now: what is the explanation? How did this happen? Was it fabricated, or was the missile simply allowed to cross the Ukrainian border? What happened specifically in the management of this situation?

I said yesterday and can repeat. Unfortunately, we have not been allowed to participate fully in the investigation, so we have no grounds to fully trust the results of this investigation. We are not participating in it. And the arguments we propose to be considered during the investigation are not accepted by the commission conducting this investigation.

I would like to remind you again that this is a terrible tragedy, and Emmanuel said correctly yesterday that we must always think of the families of those who died and of those who lost their lives as a result of this terrible disaster. Of course, we will always remember this; it goes without saying. But for some reason, the fact that Ukraine did not fulfill its obligations under ICAO, the International Civil Aviation Organization, and did not close the airspace over the territory where hostilities were taking place – for some reason, no one even remembers this.

There are various versions of this tragedy, but they are also not taken into account. And therefore, if there is no full investigation, it will certainly be very difficult for us to accept the conclusions of the commission that is working without our participation. That is all.

And unfortunately, we have had other tragic incidents related to Ukraine. They once shot down a Russian plane over the Black Sea that was flying from Israel and did not acknowledge their guilt. Later, they did agree, but compensation was never paid. We have negative experiences, unfortunately.

As for this particular tragic case, we would like to take full part in the investigation.

J. Mikletwaite: One last question on this topic: so you assert that it was not a Russian missile?

Of course not.

I repeat, there are several versions, including the version of a Ukrainian army missile, and an airplane, and so on. But, I repeat, there is nothing that inspires us with confidence as final conclusions. And there will be none without our full participation in the investigation.

J. Mikletwaite: Mr. Macron, if you could also touch on this topic, because it seems to me that you often disagree with Mr. Putin, as you say. And I am curious to know, will your approach in relations with him be the same? You came here to make a statement about your stance on the Iranian issue and other matters. What do you think would be the best way for Russia to restore its ties with the West?

E. Macron: Actually, this has already been said, and we need to take a humble position.

On the last topic that was raised, I think President Putin is absolutely right that we must remember the victims of this tragedy, the families, whether they are Dutch families, Belgian families, or other families. But an independent investigation has been launched, and I think it is now very important for cooperation to be organized. And therefore, I agree with what Mr. Putin said yesterday: cooperation with Dutch justice is necessary to understand what results have been achieved and how these results have been achieved.

What is interesting and important in this context? It is necessary for us to have a constant dialogue, and this is indeed happening. It is also necessary for us to do useful work, purposeful work on collective security issues, particularly regarding the situation in the Middle East.

Yesterday, I believe we made progress on very important positions related to Iran, ensuring the preservation of the 2015 agreement, working on the possible continuation of negotiations on Syria. We also adopted a joint humanitarian initiative, and we agreed on interaction between the mechanisms that exist between us.

That is, the Astana group and the so-called small group, which was initiated by France a few months ago with a number of members, including permanent members of the Security Council – the United Kingdom, the United States, Germany, as well as some countries in the region, particularly Jordan and Egypt.

We agreed to create a special coordination mechanism to work on a single agenda, to work together on developing a common "roadmap" to ensure the future of Syria, to ensure peaceful sovereignty and inclusivity from a political point of view for this country. This is very important progress.

Next, we must, of course, build our future together in Europe in a geopolitical sense as well. I believe this depends on our ability to resolve the Ukrainian crisis. On this topic, we have the Minsk agreements, there is the Normandy format, within which we will continue to act.

In addition, we need to have a strategic dialogue on cybersecurity issues, on cyberspace, and on economic issues. This is what we have been working on together. Moreover, we have outlined quite specific measures, and you noticed that we signed about 50 agreements in economic and strategic areas, which are very important. And in the field of cyberspace, we also agreed to work together to create a kind of unified charter, within which we can resolve various disputes that arise between us – this is a very important point.

And in strategic terms – we exchanged some humorous words here – of course, there are certain inconsistencies and misunderstandings between Russia and the European Union in recent decades. But it should be said more precisely: it is about the European Union, NATO, and Russia. And France, which always pursues an independent policy, has a very strong army and has a clear foreign policy, I believe that France can act optimally to build and think about this new architecture.

Because if we manage to establish certain lines of strength in geopolitical, military, security, economic, and cyberspace terms, to establish a certain common grammar and common vocabulary, if you allow these expressions, I believe that this will be very important and very useful in terms of stability in Europe and in the world as a whole, and it will be very good for our peoples and the European Union.

I think we need to be cautious about expansion issues because there was a certain euphoria on the part of the European Union about expansion. But when you expand and do not carry out any reforms, it does not turn out to be very effective. Therefore, it seems to me that the European Union should be more united, more sovereign, more democratic, and should understand what its strategic priorities are.

I think there is a centralized Europe that shares certain rules in terms of taxes, as well as labor law. But there is a Europe that is somewhat in other regions and does not belong to this centralized core.

In this sense, of course, there is a place for Russia in Europe. Therefore, I often think about Russia's place in the Council of Europe. Therefore, I believe that this is possible. I assume that certain work is needed here, that reforms are needed on the part of the European Union. In addition, I believe it is very important for us to have a common deep strategic project for the coming years.

J. Mikletveit: President Putin, what are your goals for Russia, for the West? In what capacity would you like to see Russia and the West, despite all these misunderstandings that are happening? Where would you really like to lead Russia? Do you want St. Petersburg, which is perceived as a symbol of Westernization in Russia and Western capital… Are you ready to move in that direction?

Every country has its own national priorities and interests. I spoke about this during my speech today. And we will certainly strive to implement our national interests. What do they consist of today and in the near future?

In internal development, first of all. We must ensure productivity growth in our economy, we must create conditions for attracting investments, because without investments it is impossible to solve another task – it is impossible to diversify our economy.

Yesterday, Ms. Lagarde spoke to me about this and hinted at it today. But we had a 4.4 percent growth in fixed capital investment last year, while economic growth was 11.5 percent. This is a good indicator – accelerated growth of investments, but it is absolutely insufficient. Absolutely insufficient!

And in order to attract capital from friendly companies and countries, we need good relations both with Europe and with the whole world, and with the United States. We understand this perfectly and are aware of it.

But if we are faced with a choice – either we exist as a sovereign state, or we are subjected to some restrictions – then we certainly choose the former. Because, after all, the substances being weighed on the scales are too incomparable: either existence as an independent state, or some investments in the form of already some handouts.

We are striving for one thing: we are striving for the return or development of new rules of the game in the field of security and in the field of global economic policy with the help of international institutions that have already been created and which certainly need to be developed.

But on this basis, we want to solve the next task – the diversification of our economy, giving it an innovative character. We want to work on artificial intelligence, on robotics, and so on, and so forth.

By the way, Christine expressed concerns here about robotics and job losses. In fact, it is not that scary, although such phobias certainly exist, and such fears exist, and the danger, to be honest, does exist. But still, according to experts, including international experts, only five percent of jobs in the world can be fully robotized, and only 10 percent are currently robotized out of what could already be done now. So there are great prospects for both our economy and the global economy.

Of course, on this basis, we want to achieve the main goal: we want to improve the lives of our people, we want to reduce the number of people living below the poverty line, we want to ensure that the main indicator of well-being – life expectancy – increases, as I have already said, to 78 years by 2024 and to 80+ by 2030.

All of these are absolutely solvable tasks, but, of course, favorable external conditions are also needed. We will strive for this in every possible way, not forgetting that this is also part of our national interest, but we cannot, of course, sacrifice our sovereignty and our deep, fundamental interests. I hope that this balance will be found between Russia and our partners.

J. Mikletveit: I cannot help but ask you the last question: who will win the World Cup in football?

The organizers will win, who will organize this wonderful celebration for the entire international community, for all lovers of this wonderful world game at the proper level. In any case, we see our task in this.

As for the team that will win, the strongest will prevail, as they say. I would very much like it to truly be a celebration for all who love sports: for the football players and for our guests. We will do everything to ensure that both fans and specialists and players feel at home in Russia.

J. Mikletveit: As we can see, politics continues to work in Russia indeed.

I want to thank our speakers. I have been told that it is already time to conclude. I also want to thank the audience for waiting. I know that you had to wait a long time before we appeared. But we did it after all.

I want to thank Christine Lagarde, I want to thank Vice Chairman Wang Qishan, I want to thank Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, President Putin, and President Macron. Thank you all very much, and I apologize for slightly jumbling my own questions.

And on my part, on behalf of all my colleagues, I want to express gratitude to our moderator, the host. I think it was done very professionally today, and you managed to make our discussion today lively and interesting.

Thank you very much.