CLAUSE 20.—(Offences in connection with lotteries.)
Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping
- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on November 7, 1934, during Committee debate on Clause 20 on lottery offences, pressing the Home Secretary on newspaper imports and broadcasts of Irish Sweep results.
- Main themes
- Loophole of broadcast lottery results and advertisements, Irish Free State sweepstake, importation of Irish newspapers, newsagents' liability, seizure of newspaper editions, German press seizures as precedent, risk of Irish retaliation against The Times, illusory attack on liberty, Home Secretary's unforeseen difficulties, Clause 20 offences in connection with lotteries
- Duration
- ~8 min
- Words
- 1,010
- Sentences
- 49
- Readability
- 67
- Grade
- 8.8
- Syntax
- 2.78
- Vocabulary
- 2.00
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other49 sentences in 8 paragraphs
I will not weary the Committee by prefacing my remarks but will come directly to the point I reached in the course of my speech which was interrupted, to which we must have an answer. What is the answer of the Home Secretary? How is he going to stop the loophole of perpetual broadcasts of the winners and the advertisements? Has it ever occurred to him that there was such a loophole; or has it dawned upon him now for the first time? I thought he was startled when he began to realise what he had to do in the case of newspapers coming from Ireland. Whoever is going to benefit it is certain that the Irish newspapers will benefit very largely. They will have a continuous feature in all their pages of the state of the Irish Sweep, the methods by which tickets will be drawn, all those descriptive accounts which are such a shocking offence when committed by English newspapers, and also a list of winners. These papers will come in by the thousand; their circulation, of course, will go up. People who are following this matter for their own interest will ask their newsagents to get them. Is that to be a
1115
crime; is it an offence? Are you going to make it an offence? Let us have an answer before we cast these things into the form of statute law.
Assuming that a great many people would like to have the "Irish Times" for a particular week, or for particular days, is the newsagent committing an offence if, in the ordinary course of his business, he complies with the desire of his customers and gets the necessary copies of the journal? If that be an offence, we want to know. The Home Secretary said that it is a question of those people who are trying to advertise the sweep. These people do not care anything about the sweep; they are only selling their newspapers, and they are going to do good business. That is a point which must be met. For the moment I am enlisting myself on the side of my right hon. Friend, trying to face the difficulties which will confront him, difficulties which will have to be met. I thought that he himself would have made some contribution towards a solution. If you wish to be logical and carry this thing through with the high hand, or foot, as the case may be, you will have to have a new series of provisions designed to deal with the import of foreign newspapers, or Irish Free State newspapers.
The hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot), in his desire to put down this evil at whatever cost to liberty, has tried to play upon anti-Irish prejudices; he has tried to work up our dander against the Irish Free State. He must face the consequences. If the Home Secretary is effectively to prevent the circulation of the list of winners and other advertisements of the Irish Free State Sweepstake in this country, he must take power to blot out these passages in the Irish newspapers and in foreign newspapers which contain these references, or he must seize the whole edition. There are plenty of precedents for that process. In Germany at the present time we see in our newspapers again and again that a particular edition of the "Morning Post" or the "Times" or the "Daily News has been seized in Germany. Do you propose to do that? if you do not, you cannot handle this matter. Thousands and thousands of these newspapers may come in and the
1116
information will be given. If you are not going to take power to seize editions which have these advertisements and the results of the draw, then it is a farce to attempt to deal with this difficulty, and you are subjecting English newspapers to great injury and injustice. What are you going to do to Irish Free State newspapers? What are they going to do to you if you take power to blot out whole pages, say, of the "Irish Independent" or the "Irish Times" or to seize the whole edition? Do you think they will sit still and do nothing? They will retaliate. They might stop the "Times,' a great supporter of His Majesty's Government, going into Ireland, and then what a row there would be. They might say, "Let us have a quota, let us have reciprocity"; there is no limit to the difficulties into which you might get.
The Home Secretary may be a little vexed, but we are doing him the greatest service in warning him of these difficulties. It is amazing that he has not foreseen the pitfalls which lie before him. The whole of this Clause becomes valueless unless you take power to deal with the importation of foreign newspapers and also with what has never been mentioned before until my hon. Friend mentioned it—I confess that it had not occurred to me—the fact that everything can be disseminated by the broadcast, and that with the greatest ease millions of people in this country, between five and six million people, can listen to the whole story of the Irish Sweepstake. What a zest will be added to it when it is a way of getting round a law which carries with it no sort of public sanction. Instead of listening to the Home Secretary extolling the National Government, you will find them all listening to these other broadcasts. There will be a keen hour on the air. What is the right hon. Gentleman going to do about that? Is he going to start some great station to queer the atmosphere, set up atmospherics, to strike in with a. great boom? If so, he will raise further difficulties. Nothing is more dangerous than an illusory attack on liberty. Under the Liberal impulse this poor, unforeseeing Government is being drawn step by step into a series of confusions, contradictions and muddles, which will make it the laughing stock of the country.