Unemployment.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

16 February 1933 · House of Commons debate on unemployment · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on February 16, 1933, in a debate on unemployment, criticising the Chancellor's ten-year outlook and urging public works to bring 250,000 men into employment.
Main themes
Ten-year prospect of unemployment, moral agony of the unemployed breadwinner, criticism of the Chancellor's speech, public works to employ 250,000 men, stimulus measures that mitigated unemployment, the £50,000,000 Sinking Fund, Prime Minister's broadcast on unemployment, Bethnal Green letter, government's overwhelming parliamentary majorities, hopelessness of government policy
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,412
41st percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%50%
  • Social 22%20%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

56 sentences in 12 paragraphs

I will only venture to detain the House for a short time, because I had not intended to intervene at all until I heard some of the statements which fell from my right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer. I must say I think something should be done to express the feeling of disappointment, and even of hopelessness, which must have arisen in many hearts as he proceeded upon his precise, well marshaled, orderly discourse. What is the picture that he puts before the House and before the country? What is the proposition? It is that everything is being done that can be done and that all is proceeding satisfactorily and in due course, but that, in spite of all this, many years must pass before the figures of unemployment can be reduced to—I think he said—a small figure. That is a ghastly prospect for us all to have to face, and it was that phrase of the right hon. Gentleman's that induced me to trespass for this moment upon the time of the House.

Ten years! Is that the last word of His Majesty's Government? I rejoice to think that by the unexampled provision which this nation made for the relief of distress through insurance schemes and otherwise, and by the faithful performances of the taxpayer, material distress is to a very large extent withheld from our people, even in this terrible time, but material distress is not the whole evil of unemployment. There is this frightful moral agony of unemployment. Take the case of the 3,000,000 unemployed. You are not merely dealing with the weaker brethren, with men who hardly ever keep a job, but you are dealing with a couple of million men who have hardly ever been out of work in the whole of their lives. Take these men. I see the figure of the breadwinner, the father of the family, sitting in his chair in his cottage. Ten years! His wife has perhaps got a job

1232

—perhaps she has got his job—and his daughter may have got a job. His son, a young boy, may have got some blind-alley occupation. The father of the family, whose honour and faith are pledged to carry those dependants on his shoulders, sits there in his chair, a burden upon the house, helpless in the midst of those whom he had vowed himself to defend, his very right to exist challenged in the land for which, perhaps, he had been ready to sacrifice his life not many years ago. It is no good going to that man and saying: "Keep pegging away!" What has he to keep pegging away at?

I am not impressed by the argument of the Government, neither with those which were used by the Minister of Health yesterday, nor with those of my Tight hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer, that all measures of stimulating or subsidising production in one form or another ought to be ruled out at this time, because they have failed in the past. I do not think that it is true to say that they have failed. They may not have stemmed the enormous world tide of unemployment, but they may have mitigated it. In fact, you can show that they have to a certain extent mitigated its force. Naturally, if you have a great world tide of unemployment flowing, you will be able to show a much larger total of unemployment at the end of the year, although you may have received benefit from those measures. I deprecate altogether the non sequitur that because unemployment has increased while remedial measures were employed such measures should no longer be adopted. I think that the Government would have been very well advised last August in taking some steps to open up, as far as they could, the building trade and the development of public works. There are some very well-known, great public works, one of which I see was destroyed last night, and which at any rate would give us a better island to live in after they were completed.

I would not for a moment ask the Government to perform impossibilities or to reproach them, because they cannot cure unemployment, but unemployment has only increased about a quarter of a million in the last six months. It would have been quite

1233

possible, by taking prudent steps last summer or last autumn, to take that extra 250,000 off. It would not have rid us of the evil and it would not have solved the problem, but it would have given the Government the right to say that they had stemmed the tide and that there was a diminution, however small, and not an increase, in unemployment. Believe me, an event of that kind would have a far greater effect upon your credit, upon your national prestige and upon the reputation and authority of the Government, than anything you will get out of a £50,000,000 Sinking Fund, however strictly and punctually it is enforced. It would not have been a reasonable thing to embark on another large, bold programmed at a time when there was public panic, as there was in 1931. Of course, you could not do it when there was a great conversion operation, but all could have been put in readiness, and I am bound to say that nothing that I have heard in this Debate has shaken my view that it would have been a wise and reasonably prudent step, justified on the highest economic and on the broadest grounds of long policy, to have set on foot a programmed sufficient to have brought a quarter of a million mere men into employment at this moment.

I entirely agree that these are but palliatives. What I felt in the speech of my right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Exchequer was the hopelessness. I greatly preferred his speech, with its carefully considered and marshaled arguments, to the Prime Minister's broadcast; that, I thought, was most deplorable. The Prime Minister likes to broadcast. He has endeavoured to secure a monopoly of it for himself, and he endeavours to exclude from the use of that great organ any opponents and any critics. I am surprised that the right hon. Gentleman did not make a better use of it. When I heard those statements about the duck pond—no, it was the paddle-pool—and the rope mats, and the renovation of the archaic Roman bridge, I thought of those men sitting in their cottages, in this distress that falls upon them, and I am bound to say that I think that that speech must have been a shock, a very great and an insulting shock to them, coming as it did from a Prime Minister who, in the first in-

1234

stance, led the Socialist party into office on the claim that he could cure—virtually cure—unemployment.

Then the Bethnal Green letter—the "death-knell Green letter" it might be called—which has been expanded and expatiated upon by the Chancellor of the Exchequer this afternoon, is virtually a statement that there is no immediate plan or policy which the Government are pursuing, other than allowing the great drift of world events to take their course. I do not think that it is right to condemn men because they cannot encounter the tide of world events, but you are entitled to condemn them if the spirit which they produce does not show that they are endeavoring as far as they can to do so. Immense powers reside in this Government. You compare its action with previous Governments; that is not fair. No previous Government, except in the War, has had the power which this Government has, an absolute power. In both Houses of Parliament, overwhelming majorities; a mighty Press to support them; broadcasting. You have every power at your disposal, and all that is to come, is what we have heard today. I am sure that when the right hon. Gentleman's speech is read it will be felt all over the country that it is very poor, thin fare for this nation, and that a far greater constructive effort, more grip, more mental energy, more resourcefulness ought to be represented by those who have those great powers, and who are in charge of our destinies. If this that we have heard today is the last word that the Government have to speak upon this problem, then indeed the outlook before us is grave and lamentable.