Statements at the meeting of the organizers of the National Conference on Hakim Tehran (the late Aqa Ali Modarresi Zanouzi)

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

23 April 2018 · Meeting of the organizers of the National Conference on Hakim Tehran (the late Aqa Ali Modarresi Zanouzi) · Qom, Iran

Context
Khamenei addressed organizers of the National Conference on Hakim Tehran at a meeting in April 2018, honoring the legacy of philosopher Ali Modarresi Zanouzi.
Main themes
Rational sciences in Iran, commemoration of Hakim Ali Modarresi Zanouzi, Islamic philosophy and Mulla Sadra, scholarly tradition in Tehran and Isfahan, intellectual criticism and innovation, flourishing of philosophy under Islamic Republic, prominent Iranian philosophers and sages, Shia scholarly networks in Qom
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,708
49th percentile
Sentences
43
27th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.59
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.48
95th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 64%63%
  • Ceremonial 31%30%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

43 sentences in 10 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

All praise is due to God, the Lord of the worlds, and peace and blessings be upon our master Muhammad and his pure family, especially the Mahdi, the remaining one of God on the earth.

Welcome, esteemed gentlemen, and dear scholars of the field of rational sciences. I would like to express my gratitude to Mr. Fayyazi, who is truly a blessed presence and has been able to establish and launch this collection in Qom, which, as you have mentioned, is very valuable. Fortunately, during the era of the Islamic Republic, rational sciences have flourished. Before the revolution, there was not much happening in Qom; when we were there, for instance, a class by Mr. Tabatabai had only a handful of students, about forty or fifty; but now, for example, Mr. Jawadi, who has been active in this field for years, Mr. Misbah, Mr. Subhani, and their organizations in the field of theological issues, and the various philosophy classes that I have heard are available in Qom, these all herald the promotion and elevation of rational sciences, indicating that such a foundation has been established.

The work that Mr. Fayyazi and the gentlemen mentioned, where a new argument or a new interpretation or a new proof for an established matter, or a new refutation for a false claim is presented and discussed, is very valuable and very good; these are the driving forces of rational sciences. One of the characteristics of the late Mr. Ali Modarres is that he is a critic of Mulla Sadra, meaning that he has advanced philosophy to this extent; he has critiques of Mulla Sadra. This work must be done; I do not want to delve into the critique of Mulla Sadra, but I want to emphasize that the discussion of criticism and the introduction of new ideas, or innovation in rational sciences, is a very important issue. Sometimes a school or a thought has multiple interpretations; as we see now, the Westerners are active in this regard—because the Westerners in the field of advertising and public relations are truly incomparable with us; they are much stronger and more advanced than us in this area. For example, regarding Hegel, you see various interpretations of his words and the books and texts he has written—meaning they present different understandings; this itself helps advance thought, logic, and rationality in the realm of rational sciences. Therefore, this work is very good, and I hope that, God willing, this collection that Mr. Fayyazi oversees, and Mr. Jawadi, Mr. Misbah, and Mr. Subhani, as they mentioned, supervise or guide, will be advanced as strongly as possible; this is a very important and necessary task that must be accomplished.

Regarding commemorations; this work is significant. We should not view the commemoration of someone like Mr. Ali Modarres merely as introducing a great person; no, this is the introduction of a thought movement, the presentation of a thought and a great thinker. You gentlemen wrote the title of the congress as Modarres of Tehran, the sage of Tehran; well, yes, he has been in Tehran and is indeed the sage of Tehran, but the sage of Tehran is not only the late Mr. Ali Modarres. As I was listening to you speak, several names came to mind regarding the sages who have been in Tehran over the past hundred years; from Mirza Abolhassan Jalveh to Mr. Mohammad Reza Qomeshai, who is in the field of mysticism, to the late Hidaji, to the late Mirza Abdullah Zanouzi. Mirza Abdullah Zanouzi is his father, and Mr. Ali is his student; both were students of Mulla Ali Nouri of Isfahan. The late Mulla Ali Nouri is also one of the great figures in this—so to speak—field; these are the individuals who revived Mulla Sadra's philosophy. Mulla Sadra's philosophy faced severe attacks and declined after a certain period; then some individuals emerged in Isfahan [and revived it], and they are all from Isfahan; of course, many of them are not originally from Isfahan, like him, and many of the gentlemen and great figures whose names are mentioned; they are not originally from Isfahan, but the center has been Isfahan; this indicates that Isfahan has been the center of rational sciences. Then this father and son—late Mirza Abdullah Zanouzi and late Mr. Ali Hakim—moved to Tehran, and at that time, Tehran became the center of rational sciences. In any case, these are very significant personalities; until recently, we reach figures like the late Amirza Mahdi Ashtiani, Amirza Ahmad Ashtiani, and the late Shah Abadi. Amirza Mahdi is very well-known, but Amirza Ahmad Ashtiani is not known as a sage; while he was a great philosopher and truly a sage; likewise, the late Sheikh Mohammad Taqi Amoli, who has a commentary on the "Manzumeh"—you have seen it—meaning he was a sage; of course, he is a jurist, a great jurist, at the level of a source of emulation, but he is a sage, meaning he has expertise in rational sciences. In my opinion, these individuals should be brought out one by one from their corners of obscurity and anonymity and be presented; they have thoughts and matters to share.

Now, you have printed the book "Bada'ih al-Hikmah" of the late Mr. Ali Hakim here; well, someone must sit down and read this detailed book to understand what Mr. Ali is saying; how many people are ready to read this book? How many do you have who have the ability to do this? This requires the same [effort] that I mentioned regarding the late Mulla Sadra—though a small effort has been made; it is not bad—that a group or a committee should sit down and extract the essence of Mr. Ali Hakim's philosophy and say what he is saying, what his thoughts are, what his intended message is. Once, Mr. Jawadi showed me a book from Mr. Ali—if I remember correctly, it was a book or a treatise of his—that he said, "Here, in response to this matter, he has said this"; I do not remember that statement now, but I know it was an important one. Well, these should be extracted, brought out from among his books or treatises. He apparently has a treatise on "relational existence"; Mr. Ali Hakim has multiple treatises; they should sit down and compile these so that suddenly Tehran—which you say has been the center of wisdom at one time—feels that he presented a profound philosophical thought, for instance, over a hundred years ago when he passed away—apparently around 1307—such a thought was introduced in Tehran; meaning it should be summarized and clarified, his school and his thoughts and foundations should be elucidated. And likewise, others who are present, like the late Mirza Abolhassan Jalveh (may God be pleased with him); he has many commentaries on "Asfar"; he was also very good at writing. They say that he would write margins on various copies of "Asfar" that he taught; one of these copies of "Asfar"—which is a copy with the handwritten margins of the late Mirza Abolhassan Jalveh or Haj Mirza Abolhassan Jalveh; I do not know if he went to Mecca or not—came into my possession, and I donated it to the library of Mr. Misbah's institution, which should be there now. Well, he has thoughts; you know that Mirza Abolhassan Jalveh is among the critics of Mulla Sadra, meaning he is one of those who has arguments and critiques on many of Mulla Sadra's principles, just like Mr. Ali; he is the same; well, let us see what his thoughts are; someone should extract these thoughts, bring them out, and present them. In my opinion, these are very important tasks that have been left undone; we have been late to think about these, and we must accomplish all of these.

In any case, inviting our youth to rational sciences is very important; the attention of the seminaries to rational sciences, especially philosophy, is very important. Some of the esteemed and respected gentlemen, who are very honored and respected by us, have raised objections that philosophy and mysticism classes have increased in Qom; I told those gentlemen that if you remove philosophy from Qom, individuals in other places will take on the responsibility of explaining and teaching philosophy who do not have the competence and qualifications for this work; as we see now, some individuals who are recognized as philosophers outside of Qom have superficial knowledge of philosophy; it is not that they do not know, but their knowledge is not deep; it is superficial; they have read something and are just repeating a term; well, this is not good; it is better that it remains in Qom, in the seminary. Tehran is the same; the seminary of Tehran, which was once the center of rational sciences, if the teaching of philosophy and rational sciences becomes prevalent there, in our opinion, this will be something very good and beneficial, God willing.

I did not mention the name of Mirza Hashem Ashkouri here; or the late Sayyid Kazem Assar; of course, some of these taught at the university, some taught outside, they are later figures and their students, but those we mentioned are from before this generation. Whenever the school of Tehran is mentioned, they want to refer to these individuals, meaning these gentlemen, the father and son; of course, you did not mention the late Mirza Abdullah Zanouzi at all and did not pay attention to him; he must have works and his contributions—the late Mirza Abdullah Zanouzi—should be presented, because Mr. Ali is his student; these gentlemen are known as the school of Tehran.

In any case, we thank you for the efforts you have made and the work you have started in introducing the faces of philosophy. May God bless your existence, and may the great philosophy teachers in Qom—who, thank God, we see how abundant their blessings are—may God support them, protect them, and continue their blessings. And also you gentlemen who are responsible for these tasks, may you be among those who receive divine success, divine support, and divine guidance, God willing. May you be successful.

Peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.