Statements during the meeting of the President and members of the Cabinet.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

10 November 2004 · Meeting of the President and members of the Cabinet

Context
Khamenei addressed President Khatami and Cabinet members during a Ramadan meeting on November 10, 2004, delivering a religious discourse on faith from Nahj al-Balagha.
Main themes
Religious faith, Nahj al-Balagha, faith versus knowledge, submission to truth, faith as foundation of action, Islamic theology, prophethood and monotheism, disbelief and denial, Ramadan reflection, spiritual guidance for government
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,605
89th percentile
Sentences
204
89th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.01
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 68%46%
  • Economic 14%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%6%
  • Geopolitical 6%4%
  • Institutional 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 32%

204 sentences in 21 paragraphs

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

A council has been formed. God willing, hearts will become more familiar with one another and will not have fear or aversion from each other. God willing, our hearts will not be afraid of the truths that are always accessible to us—especially during the very blessed days of the last decade of this month—and will become familiar with them.

In the past years, both in the previous government and in the current government, it has been our custom during Ramadan to read a sentence from Nahj al-Balagha and briefly explain it; this year is no different, and I have selected a few sentences from various parts of Nahj al-Balagha regarding faith that I will present. Of course, there are more discussions about faith throughout the noble book of Nahj al-Balagha; however, since the version I always hold is a four-volume edition bound in two volumes, which I have been using for about thirty or forty years, I had to choose one of the volumes to bring. Therefore, I have brought the second volume—which is actually the third and fourth volumes and includes the annotations of the late Abdah.

The Imam says: "The path is clear and the way is illuminated." Faith is a path whose course is completely clear. Faith is the brightest lamp. The meaning of faith in this phrase by Amir al-Mu'minin (peace be upon him) is religious faith; that is, faith in God, the Day of Judgment, and the Prophet, and this same faith to which the religions of people call them. Of course, the absolute importance of faith is evident; because faith is the foundation of human action and movement. As long as a person is not attached to something and does not embrace it, they do not move towards it. Faith is different from knowledge. Sometimes a person is knowledgeable about a truth, but is not committed to it. This means that in faith, merely being knowledgeable and aware of the truth is not enough; something beyond this knowledge is required. Of course, faith without knowledge is also not possible—faith does not have meaning in doubt and uncertainty—but knowledge alone is also not sufficient for faith; as you see, the Quran speaks about Moses and the events of Pharaoh, saying: "And they denied it while their souls were certain of it, out of injustice and arrogance"; meaning that when Moses presented his invitation, the Pharaoh's elite understood that he was telling the truth and that it was a reality; but after Moses showed this amazing miracle, and after the sorcerers—who were thought to be doing similar work to Moses—acknowledged that this was not like their work and, despite Pharaoh's threats, prostrated and believed in Moses and accepted death, it became clear to them that Moses was telling the truth; yet at the same time, they denied this truth; "they denied it while their souls were certain of it." They were certain that Moses was telling the truth, but at the same time, they denied it. Why? Because "out of injustice and arrogance"; because their arrogance and carnal desires and the injustice they wanted to commit prevented them from submitting. Faith and commitment are a form of submission; becoming submissive to a truth. Sometimes a person understands the truth, but does not submit their heart to this truth and stands against it. Thus, you see that in opposition to knowledge, there is ignorance and doubt; but in opposition to faith, they do not bring ignorance; in opposition to faith, they bring disbelief; that is, covering it up. Sometimes a person accepts a truth, but covers it up and hides it. The opposite of covering up is faith; that is, being devoted, embracing, surrendering, fully accepting the truth, and submitting to it. Whatever you consider to be the truth, if you have faith in it, this becomes the foundation of your action. Today, you see some people passionately defending a certain economic or social principle and investing in it. A clearer example is the existence of Marxist tendencies during our youth, which some of you have also experienced. Some were truly willing to give their lives for those Marxist concepts. They were devoted and had faith. This faith becomes the source of action; and that too, an action as difficult as fighting and being in the field, killing and being killed. If there is faith in a principle, that person automatically moves towards the goals of that faith; there is no need to constantly remind them. Faith brings action along with it, which we will discuss in the next sentence.

We said that here, the meaning of Amir al-Mu'minin is religious faith; it is not faith in something false or faith in idols and materialism; it is faith in the One God without partners, faith in prophethood, faith in truths, and faith in the Day of Resurrection. He says: "The path is clear and the way is illuminated"; meaning that the course of this path is very clear. If someone enters this field with their intellect and innate disposition, they see the path as clear, without doubt and ambiguity; "the brightest lamp." Then it continues: "By faith, one is guided to righteous deeds"; it is through faith that a person is drawn to righteous actions. Faith is what leads a person and indicates righteous actions. Then he immediately says: "And by righteous deeds, one is guided to faith"; righteous action also indicates faith. This means there is a mutual influence and effect. In my opinion, this is a very important point. We must strengthen our faith with righteous action; just as we must recognize righteous action through faith.

Consider the incident that occurred in the Battle of Uhud. Those fifty individuals who were cursed and lamented by all Muslims throughout these fourteen centuries were Muslims; they were companions of the Prophet; many of them had participated in the Battle of Badr; they were not bad people; but these very individuals fell into that calamity; that is, because they abandoned the high ground for the sake of collecting spoils, they gave the field to the enemy and caused a significant amount of pure blood to be shed on the ground; blood like that of Hamza, the Master of Martyrs, was spilled on the ground; the Prophet was wounded, and the Islamic government and the nascent Islamic system were shaken; all because of the negligence of these fifty individuals. The Quran speaks about these fifty individuals, saying: "Indeed, those who turned back among you on the day the two armies met, it was Satan who caused them to slip because of some of what they had earned"; meaning that what they did was the result of mistakes and slips they had made before. Every slip, in turn, imposes other slips on a person; that is, it weakens the foundation of faith, and the weakening of faith has its adverse effect on our subsequent actions. When we slip, this slip affects our faith—even if imperceptibly. "Indeed, Satan caused them to slip because of some of what they had earned"; a wrong action is performed by someone, and then this error negatively impacts their faith, without the person even realizing it; just like many times when a person goes from one state to another, but does not notice the change in their state.

May God have mercy on the late Mr. Khatami (may Allah be pleased with him); the esteemed father of our respected president. In 1979, when I returned from exile, I visited him in Ardakan. At that time, he was about seventy years old. They said he did not feel old. He said, "I say I am old, but I do not feel old at all; I see myself as I was at thirty or thirty-five." Years later, I asked him if he still felt the same way. He said, "Yes, it is still the same." Now we are the same way. The image we have of ourselves as gray-haired and elderly is the image of ourselves from thirty years ago. We do not perceive the passage of time and the remarkable transformation that has occurred, with all the tangible physical effects it has. The transformation of faith is the same; that is, a person does not feel the decrease in faith; because it does not even have tangible physical effects that a person can understand and perceive. Thus, that slip and mistake affected faith. The decrease in faith impacts our subsequent actions; for example, when a field of jihad and testing arises, our lack of faith reveals itself. We, who were able to take a leap and make a significant move with abundant faith, when faced with the same task, find our hands and feet trembling; just like someone who could jump over a two-meter ditch in their youth; but now, when they reach the same ditch, they cannot. The negative effect of action on faith and faith on action results in the defeat of the Battle of Uhud; it results in various setbacks; it results in the fact that fifty years after the migration of the Prophet and forty years after his passing, his grandson—who is the dearest person to the Prophet; that is, Imam Hussein (peace be upon him)—stands against the government of the Prophet's successor and is martyred in that horrific situation. I once said these are lessons from history; they go beyond mere lessons.

In the thirtieth wisdom of Nahj al-Balagha, it is stated: "He was asked about faith"; they requested the Imam to speak to them about faith. He said: "Faith is based on four pillars"; faith is established on four foundations. The meaning of the four pillars is that if the foundations are strong, faith remains; but if the foundations become weak or collapse, faith collapses in proportion. It does not completely fall, but it collapses to that extent. The Imam stated these four pillars: "Patience, certainty, justice, and jihad." The first is steadfastness and perseverance in all areas. If you want to pursue a program, stand firm until the end of that program. If you want to accomplish a task, complete that task. If a calamity occurs, do not lose yourself in the face of that calamity. If a duty is prescribed for you, endure to fulfill that duty and do not become impatient or exhausted. If you are faced with a sin, stand firm and do not submit to sin. Steadfastness manifests itself in every situation. Of course, the meaning of steadfastness is the same everywhere; that is, it is the same human strength and perseverance; however, it shows itself differently in each situation: patience in obedience, patience in disobedience, patience in calamity.

The second pillar of faith is based on certainty. As we said, certainty is the same as knowledge. The foundations of certainty should not be shaken; this doubt should not gnaw at the foundation of certainty like a termite. Certainty should be maintained firmly. If a question naturally arises in a person's mind, they should pursue that question until the doubt is resolved; however, they should not allow themselves to be tempted; they should not undermine certainty in themselves or in others; they should not turn certainties into doubts and make them questionable.

The third pillar of faith is justice. Justice means placing everything in its rightful place. The literal meaning of justice also means moderation. The term moderation comes from this word; it means being in its place, without excess and without deficiency; without going too far left or too far right. This is why it is said that justice means placing everything in its rightful place. When everything is placed in its rightful place, the balance that is created in the natural order based on justice and truth comes into existence. Justice is necessary in human behavior. Justice is necessary for rulers. Justice is necessary in positioning. Justice is necessary in expressing love and hatred. The Quran has stated: "And let not the hatred of a people cause you to not be just; be just; that is nearer to piety." Therefore, justice is also one of the pillars of faith. If there is justice, faith remains.

The last pillar is jihad. Jihad means struggle. In Persian, war and strife do not convey the meaning of struggle. You say, "I am struggling": I am struggling academically, I am struggling socially, I am struggling politically, I am engaging in armed struggle; all of these are struggles and have meaning. Struggle means a vigorous effort against an obstacle or an enemy. If there is no obstacle in front of a person, there is no struggle. On a paved road, if a person presses the gas and travels with a full tank of gasoline, this is not called struggle. Struggle occurs when a person encounters an obstacle, which in human fronts becomes an enemy; and in natural fronts, it becomes natural obstacles. If a person engages with these obstacles and tries to remove them, this becomes struggle. Jihad in Arabic literally means the same; it means struggle. Jihad in the Quran and Hadith also means this; it is not always in the context of armed conflict. Of course, sometimes it applies to armed conflict, and sometimes it applies to unarmed conflict.

Then Amir al-Mu'minin explains these words—though I will not delve into it—both patience, certainty, justice, and jihad. For example, he says jihad has four branches: enjoining good, forbidding evil, truthfulness, and honesty in positions; exactly the same meaning that we interpret today in terms of positioning; that is, a person should be honest in political and social positions. Therefore, truthfulness in positions is itself a form of jihad. "Among the believers are men who have been true to their covenant with Allah" means that.

Another branch of jihad is "and separating from the corrupt and disbelievers"; I specifically say this to you; everyone should pay attention to this. Your account must be separate from this current; it should not be mixed with it. You are familiar with me, and we have been with you for about eight years; with some, even longer. I do not believe at all that one should cut ties with disbelievers; no, your boundary with disbelievers should be clear; your boundary with the corrupt should be clear; your boundary with those who do not accept the Islamic Republic should be clear. Sometimes it is necessary for a person to interact with someone who does not accept the Islamic Republic; but it should be clear that he is he and you are you; do not mix. I have always been dissatisfied with some within this system and our own group; because they have blurred the boundaries. I sometimes told them that when you blur the boundaries, the problem is that many, due to the lack of boundaries, go from this side to that side, and from that side to this side; they keep coming and going; that is, the limits are forgotten. If a country does not have clear borders, it does not have collective identity and collective unity. Let the borders be clear; let it be known where you are and where they are. "And be angry with the corrupt for the sake of Allah; Allah will be angry with you for your sake; and He will be pleased with you on the Day of Resurrection."

"In the words of him, peace be upon him, regarding faith: There are two kinds of faith; one is stable and established in the hearts, and the other is a loan between hearts and chests for a known period." We have two types of faith: stable and established faith, and borrowed and temporary faith. Temporary faith is also faith; it does not mean that the person is a hypocrite; their faith is not deep-rooted; therefore, it quickly fades away. Stable and established faith means it is settled in the heart, supported by a reasoning and a deep insight, and backed by good deeds. The other type of faith is one that arises from emotions, not from logic; a person has not acted upon it with good deeds; they have merely given a slogan of faith and sometimes have shouted it very loudly; however, they have not expended the effort to struggle and fight against their own desires for the sake of this faith; that is, this faith has not been nourished by good deeds; this becomes borrowed faith. The Imam says: "And some of it is a loan between hearts and chests for a known period." What is that known time? As long as this faith is borrowed; until this faith fades away from them; like a sparrow that they have trapped in their chest, it flies away and leaves; because this faith has not become part of their existence. In what situations does this kind of faith fade away? In times of trial and moments of temptation. For example, if someone is greedy, when they are faced with a crossroads between money and preserving their faith, their faith flies away and is extinguished. Some people are afflicted by temptations of the soul and sexual desires; some are afflicted by the worship of status; everyone has their own way. Each of us has a point of weakness; as the Westerners say, we have an Achilles' heel and a vulnerable spot; that is where we are struck; may God protect us from that strike occurring. The way is piety. Piety, which I have repeatedly spoken about in this session and other sessions, means being constantly vigilant over oneself. One understands the secret of some of the 180-degree transformations from the beginning of the revolution until now here. Twenty-five years have passed since the beginning of the revolution; sometimes you see that some people have undergone a 180-degree transformation; that is, they have changed from a sincere, honest, passionate believer who shouts slogans into an adversary, an opponent, a stubborn enemy who makes excuses! We have several types of enemies: some enemies are enemies, but they do not always want to confront the revolution directly. Others, however, always want to poke their fingers into the eyes of the revolution and the Islamic system and confront it. When you look, you see that some of these are those who were very fervent and hot, who did not accept many people; like a flame that rises from dry grass. Of course, sometimes a strong piece of wood also produces a significant flame; but from dry grass, which has nothing, a flame rises, but it quickly dies out. Sometimes we have people of this kind; their faith is not established; it is borrowed and subject to fading and without reliance on a solid reasoning. As we mentioned, this fading faith does not announce its departure; it does not ring a bell and say, "I am leaving, and from this hour I will no longer be a believer and will not pray"; gradually, a person does not realize and does not notice how this faith has faded away from them. One must be very vigilant and seek refuge in God.

The fourth and final sentence relates to the command of the Imam to Malik al-Ashtar. The letter of the Imam to Malik al-Ashtar is very remarkable. The wisdom contained in this letter is "not to be counted or enumerated." He said:

"Whatever I say, I will explain and describe love,

When I come to love, I will be ashamed of it."

When a person delves into the depths of this letter, they truly feel a sense of humility in the face of the greatness that exists in every phrase and sentence of it. He says: "And indeed, the ruin of the land comes from the poverty of its people"; the ruin of the land results from the poverty of the people of the land; that is, when the people are impoverished, the land becomes ruined. The Imam does not state this as a philosophical point; he states it as a reality. The "land" he refers to here is the same land of Egypt to which Malik al-Ashtar is going. Of course, at that time, Syria, Iraq, Iran, Medina, and every other place in the world that has a ruler cannot be compared to Egypt. They say that the land you are going to, if you can make its people wealthy, it will prosper; but if you keep the people poor or make them poor and cannot do so, this land will not prosper; it will remain desolate. It is the people who must cultivate their land with their own vitality and the abilities they acquire. The initiative of the individuals is what cultivates the entire land. Then he says: "And indeed, the people become impoverished." "Impoverished" is a verb form, but it is necessary: the people become poor. The Imam states with a causal "lam": "The poverty of the people is the fault of the rulers"; they are the ones who cause the poverty of the people; because what is obtained from wealth and benefits, they want for themselves; this causes the poverty of the people. Of course, sometimes the rulers are like the tyrants of old; like Reza Shah, who wanted everything and was never satisfied. Some people also benefited from him; they took as well. First, it was the king's share, and then gradually those who were on the periphery of the king each took their share. This is how the old tyrannies were. Of course, the modern form of it was in the Pahlavi regime; we have also read about the older forms in books from the Qajar era and the time of Nasir al-Din Shah and others. One form is the modern method; that is, the method of seemingly democratic governments that have a tyrannical essence; today, the reins of these governments are in the hands of economic companies; they are the ones who design the policies. They seem to be insignificant, but in reality, they send representatives to the parliament; they bring the president to power. The president has aides, ambassadors, ministers, and various managers at different levels; in fact, this whole group is in power. The way tyranny is exercised is not like before, where they would say, "I decree." When Reza Shah wanted to exercise tyranny, he issued a declaration in Tehran and included "I decree" four or five times in it. Today, the ruler does not say "I decree"; they do not lose that democratic decorum at all. They do not decree at all; however, the course of action is the same as "I decree." That is, the law that is necessary for this company is certainly approved; the movement that is necessary for the survival of these companies is certainly carried out; even if it involves an attack on a country like Iraq. Who benefits from the reconstruction of Iraq and its oil? The governments of America or Britain are not sovereign states that the company and oil and everything belongs to them and we say they benefit; no, it is the financial and economic apparatus that dominates these countries that benefits from anything new. Of course, they also have rivalries among themselves, they have enmities, they have competitions; but it is that financial apparatus that benefits from the oil of the Middle East, from the dominance over the Middle East, from something called Greater Middle East; it is the ultimate beneficiary. The government, the president, the foreign minister, the defense minister, and the like - who, of course, in many cases, are also part of that same financial and industrial management group of the country - are the front line and the forefront; they support and are the backing; they are the ones who are taking action; the people are also making their own movements. You might say, for example, that in America or Britain, there are no poor people relative to the population of these countries. This should not be counted; one should look at how much poverty the British government has created in the Indian subcontinent; or how much poverty has been created by the government that colonized Africa or Latin America; or today, how much poverty, hunger, and deprivation has been created in the world by America with its economic influence that spans the globe. These are the criteria. Of course, there is also poverty and poor people and a very large class gap within these countries; it is truly astonishing. Sometimes in our statistics, unfortunately, we see naive, simplistic, and shortsighted statements that, for example, the economic gap in our country is greater than that of America or some other place; these are words that stem from ignorance and a lack of understanding of the realities; they are completely unaware of the realities. No, the economic chasm in capitalist countries is terrifying and beyond imagination and greater than anywhere else in the world. Moreover, they should not be compared within those countries; rather, they should be calculated across the entire world; because the scope of their influence and power and movement is global. For now, we do not want to delve into global and international issues; we should assess ourselves. If we want the world to prosper, we must control ourselves. You and I, who are the rulers and managers and have the administration of the financial, industrial, and agricultural affairs of the country in our hands - that is, the active choke points of the country are in our hands - must control ourselves. It is not just about ourselves; we mean the collective. You, meaning you and your deputies and influential managers and officials. Of course, someone may make a mistake in a corner and at very low levels that cannot be controlled, prevented, or predicted; that is another discussion; but the collective that you are the manager and head of must have these characteristics. "For the oversight of the rulers over the collective"; they want to gather, "and their suspicion about remaining and their little benefit from the lessons." "Their suspicion about remaining," means they are suspicious about what will happen to the remainder of their lives. One should not have suspicion; one should have good thoughts about God Almighty and oneself. He also said: "They benefit little from the lessons."

We hope that what we have said will first have an impact on this humble self. I am truly the most in need of it. One of the reasons we choose and say these matters is that perhaps, God willing, it will have an effect on us and make our movement towards God and the right path more real and serious. In the supplication of Kumayl, we read, "And grant me seriousness in Your fear"; in the fear of God, one must be serious; one should not treat it lightly; these matters are not to be taken lightly. If we are to be considered among the wise of the world, we never take the real issues of life lightly; we take them seriously. More serious than the issues of this life are the matters of death, the matter of the grave, the matter of divine questioning, the matter of Barzakh, and the matter of Resurrection; these should not be taken lightly; they must be taken seriously; these are important matters.

We hope, God willing, that God will affect us and you with the wise words of the Commander of the Faithful (peace and blessings be upon him).

And peace be upon you and the mercy of God and His blessings."