The Prime Minister's speech at DIIS "GLOBAL CHALLENGES FOR EUROPE - The EU after Enlargement"

Denmark Anders Fogh Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

9 March 2004 · DIIS seminar "Global Challenges for Europe - The EU after Enlargement" · Danish Institute for International Studies (DIIS)

Context
Rasmussen addressed the Danish Institute for International Studies on March 9, 2004, speaking on global challenges facing the EU after enlargement, drawing on a recent visit to China.
Main themes
EU enlargement and global challenges, China's economic and technological rise, European competitiveness, knowledge society and innovation, research and education investment, global division of labor, EU single market, brain drain, high-tech job creation, EU research framework program, Europe-China relations, security policy
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,453
81st percentile
Sentences
227
91st percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.74
16th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 46%46%
  • Economic 26%26%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

227 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Thank you for the invitation to speak here at the institute. Today, I will talk about the global challenges for the EU.

A couple of weeks ago, I visited China with a business delegation and had meetings with the new Chinese leadership. After this visit, it became clear to me that we in Europe will face entirely new challenges in the coming years. Challenges that most people probably have a sense of, but that very few have realized the extent of. In any case, my eyes were opened quite significantly.

It has long been clear that Europe is lagging behind the USA when it comes to economy, technology, and international influence. What is new is that China is beginning to resemble an economic, technological, and security superpower in the making.

China's economy is still modest. But the dynamics and growth rate are so enormous that in a few years, China will have overtaken Europe's largest countries. China has not yet reached the same high-tech level as we have. But the Chinese are moving forward at a rapid pace and are betting heavily on investments in research, education, and innovation. China is still keeping a low profile in global security policy. But the Chinese have begun to play a more active role, most recently in the six-party talks on North Korea.

We should not view this development as a threat. On the contrary, we can gain significant benefits from closer cooperation with China. But for Europe, this requires that we think much more offensively and globally. We must be much better equipped to participate in the global division of labor, both in terms of economy and security policy.

* * *

In the coming years, we will see a significant global relocation of jobs. Production will move to where the best conditions exist. The production that requires a lot of labor will move to where there is plenty of cheap labor, including to China and the rest of Asia. The production that requires large investments will move to where there is plenty of cheap capital, for example, to the USA and Europe.

This is a global division of labor that can be to our mutual benefit. But only if we in Europe become better at creating new jobs. Europe must simply take a mega-step forward in terms of investments in high-tech jobs and the development of a knowledge society where research and education are top priorities. We must develop Europe's economy into a strong, competitive, and dynamic economy.

We have taken the first significant steps. In the 1980s, we started the development of a single market. In the 1990s, we created the common currency, the Euro. And on May 1 of this year, we are implementing the expansion of the EU from 15 to 25 member states. A large single market with over 450 million inhabitants. The world's largest economy.

But unfortunately, not the world's most dynamic economy. We are falling behind technologically. We are losing old jobs, and we are creating too few new jobs.

In a country like China, the annual growth is nearly 10%. And the enterprising Chinese coastal regions receive an influx of 20 million new workers each year. This is growth and development that is tangible.

Also in vital areas such as research and innovation, Europe is lagging behind. This is especially true in relation to the USA. Americans spend more money on research and development. They have more high-tech patents per capita than Europe. There are more researchers in the USA relative to the population than in Europe. However, this is not because Europe does not educate many researchers – we do, but we cannot retain them. It is estimated that more than 400,000 European researchers work in the USA.

We must put employment for Europe's population at the center. And therefore, we must now launch a large-scale plan for the development of the EU into a leading knowledge society. We should invest very heavily and very purposefully.

I propose that we set the goal of developing a new and genuine common area for research, development, and education.

Research and education should continue to be national matters. But we should supplement the national efforts with initiatives at the EU level. By pooling our resources in the EU, we can undertake research projects that individual member states cannot manage on their own. This applies, for example, to advanced space research.

I believe that in the coming years, we should double the EU's efforts in research, education, and development.

I will specifically propose five elements in a strategy for developing a single market for research, development, and education.

First, funding for the EU's framework program for research should be significantly increased.

Second, we should establish a new basic research fund at the EU level. The fund should be used to strengthen European basic research in future technologies, such as nano, hydrogen, and environmental technology.

Third, we should strengthen cooperation on innovation and technology dissemination. The task is to translate research results into new productions as quickly as possible. We should facilitate the exchange of information about new research results across borders, for example, by establishing technological platforms where multiple stakeholders work together to solve common problems. The European patent should be implemented immediately.

Fourth, we should significantly expand the EU's programs for European exchange of students, teachers, and researchers. The ambition should be to see the EU as one area where students, teachers, and researchers naturally study, teach, and research anywhere in the EU. And we should establish a European research prize that can highlight the great importance we attach to research in Europe.

Fifth, we should expand our exchange programs with other regions of the world. The ambition is to make Europe a leading international center for education and research. We should attract students from, among others, America and Asia to a much greater extent than today. And we should establish Europe colleges or universities in other regions, such as America, Asia, and the Middle East.

Such a strong investment in new areas requires that we make significant reallocations in the EU's budget. A ceiling has already been set on the EU's agricultural expenditures from 2007, so they will constitute a declining share of the EU budget. We can also target structural support to the poorer regions of the EU so that it more effectively stimulates the development of knowledge societies.

The single market, the common currency, and the expansion of the EU represent significant steps forward for Europe. Now we need to take a new significant step forward. Make the EU a leading knowledge economy. By creating a common area for research, development, and education.

We must put people first. Also in the EU. We must ensure employment by investing in jobs with a future. And by educating and qualifying ourselves for future jobs.

* * *

But we also face new challenges in security policy. International terrorism, failed state formations, the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, civil wars, man-made disasters, the whole well-known list. Europe must address these global challenges together with like-minded and proactive actors, primarily the USA.

The EU should play a particularly responsible security role in Europe and in Europe's neighborhood, for example, in the Middle East and Africa. The EU must be able to deploy its many economic, aid, diplomatic, and other instruments alongside military ones. This will create added value in security policy.

But this requires that we enhance the capacity of EU countries to initiate and carry out military operations in conflict-affected areas. And it requires that we improve the possibilities for formulating and following a common foreign and security policy in the EU.

The cornerstone of European security will continue to be NATO – and thus cooperation with the USA and Canada. But within this framework, we should strengthen Europe's ability to prevent and resolve regional conflicts on its own.

The EU has taken the first step by establishing a rapid reaction force that can undertake military peacekeeping, peace enforcement, and humanitarian tasks when NATO as such does not wish to engage.

The EU has already taken over the first military operation from NATO, namely in Macedonia. In a few months, the EU will take responsibility for the operation in Bosnia from NATO. SFOR will become EUFOR. The largest and most demanding task for the EU to date.

Also in conflict-ridden Africa, the EU can play a positive role. Both through direct operations, as we have already seen in Congo, and by supporting African organizations' own peacekeeping efforts.

As in NATO, we are still talking about national military contributions. Defense remains a national matter. But countries that wish to do so can contribute troops to such EU-led operations.

It is a natural next step to improve the military capacity of EU countries. Therefore, it has been proposed to establish a European agency for defense material, research, and military capacity. I believe this is a good proposal because it can hopefully also contribute to strengthening Europe's own technological research and development.

But the EU will only become a serious player on the international stage if we become better at speaking with one voice.

Let us not be naive: Foreign, defense, and security policy will continue to be primarily a national matter. But we should be better at finding a common position and following a common stance. Only such a common approach will give Europe's voice weight in the international community.

That is why we should establish the new position of EU Foreign Minister. A strong office where the EU Foreign Minister will chair the Foreign Affairs Council and have the right to propose initiatives alongside the member states.

Such a position does not guarantee that EU countries will speak with one voice. But if we choose the right person, who understands the balance between national and common interests, then I have no doubt that the EU will take a significant step forward towards a stronger role on the international stage.

* * *

The Middle East and North Africa are part of the EU's neighborhood. From the Danish side, there has traditionally been a tendency to view the entire region in light of the Israeli-Arab conflict. And that is how most other European countries have viewed it as well.

But we need to consider the region from a broader perspective. The populations in most of the Arab world live in unfreedom and under such miserable conditions that it creates intense anger and frustration. This frustration can quickly be directed against the rest of the world – not least the USA and Europe. Although the causes of the populations' woes and frustrations must primarily be found in domestic political conditions in the individual countries.

Here is a foreign and security policy challenge that the EU must prioritize highly in the coming years. There is a need for cooperation with the countries in the Middle East and North Africa, a partnership based on five main points.

First, a political dialogue on democracy and human rights. The goal is to ensure respect for human rights, to reform political institutions, to ensure free exchange of news, information, and ideas, to strengthen the rule of law, and to combat corruption.

Second, ensuring women's rights and their participation in public life.

Third, improving the education system and the social system.

Fourth, economic cooperation, where the goal is more free trade and strengthening the private sector through special programs for small and medium-sized enterprises.

Fifth, a regional security cooperation. The goal is disarmament and arms control, but also ensuring the legitimate security interests of the countries. In such a regional security cooperation, NATO should play an active role.

The EU's efforts could consist of providing support for reforms in these areas in the Arab countries.

Some may rightly ask what incentive the authoritarian regimes in the Middle East would have to initiate cooperation on democratization and opening their societies.

I can see at least two incentives. First, the economic benefits of enhanced economic cooperation. Second, the regional security cooperation with NATO. But this last point emphasizes that a new partnership with the Arab world cannot be carried by the EU alone. I believe that the establishment of such a new partnership with the Arab world must occur in cooperation between the EU, the USA, and the Arab countries, which must have a sense of ownership for the necessary changes in their societies.

In reality, we could be inspired by the model that was used in Europe in the 1970s. In the midst of the Cold War, it was possible to create a dialogue across interest differences and attitude differences between the communist dictatorships in the East and the rest of Europe and the USA and Canada in the West. The formal framework was the security conference, the CSCE, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe.

Perhaps we need a similar formal framework for dialogue and partnership with the Arab countries, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in the Middle East, CSCM.

But the crucial thing is not structures and institutions. The crucial thing is the content. And there have been several proposals for establishing such a partnership with the Arab countries. We must now consider them. But I consider it absolutely essential that the EU formulates a special strategy for the Middle East.

The Nordic and Baltic countries started with a concrete proposal at the EU summit in the spring of 2003. This has since been followed up with an interesting French-German initiative. And we know that the American government is also very focused on this idea. The summer summits of the G-8, EU/USA, and NATO will likely deal intensively with how we can strengthen dialogue and cooperation with the Arab countries on security, democracy, and economic development.

* * *

A comprehensive and long-term strategy for the Middle East is, in my view, a natural point in the transatlantic cooperation between the EU and the USA.

There is a need for new momentum in transatlantic cooperation. Over the past year, we have witnessed a number of serious political tensions in the transatlantic relationship. This is particularly true regarding the Iraq conflict. But also the International Criminal Court, the Kyoto Protocol, climate policy, and the trade dispute over genetically modified foods are examples of difficult and principled disagreements that have strained the relationship.

In my opinion, there is a need for a genuine relaunch of cooperation between the EU and the USA. A new beginning.

NATO is today the framework for the security policy dialogue between Europe and the USA. But in fact, NATO is the only formal forum we have for a regular and organized transatlantic dialogue. Between the EU and the USA, there is a rather formalistic and bureaucratized dialogue centered around an annual EU-USA summit.

In my view, there is a clear need to strengthen cooperation on larger themes based on a discussion of the real, difficult challenges that Europe and the USA share. Also the points where we disagree.

Let me highlight three major themes of cooperation that I find central:

First, we should continue to expand cooperation in the field of trade policy. We have vital interests at stake in ensuring a smooth conduct of transatlantic trade. The vast majority of trade between Europe and the USA is unproblematic. But it is clear that we must continue to work to avoid unfortunate trade disputes. Here, both sides must take responsibility for the trade. I would like to see developments lead to a genuine transatlantic free trade area in the long term.

The second area is development policy and sustainable development. Here, the EU and the USA truly face a common challenge. We must stand together to combat poverty in the world. It is a matter of human decency and justice. And it is a matter of long-term security and stability in the world. We must work together for sustainable development based on increased market access and free trade, development aid, good governance, and a greater effort for a better environment. Development policy and the environment are areas where the EU is the leading force in the world. And we must insist that these issues are given high priority in the transatlantic dialogue. It is also in the USA's long-term interest to seek an expansion of cooperation in this area.

Third, there is a need for a broader foreign and security policy dialogue between Europe and the USA. Counter-terrorism should be a main topic for such contacts between the EU and the USA. We have a mutual interest in a stable world order and the promotion of freedom and democracy.

Cooperation between the EU and the USA should, of course, be characterized by balance and equality. Here, the EU countries can make a significant contribution by improving the EU's ability to speak with one voice. A united EU with 25 countries will be the world's most powerful economic entity. If we manage to stay united on a common line in major international issues, we will be strong and impossible to ignore.

The first steps to strengthen transatlantic ties should be taken at the upcoming summit between the EU and the USA in June. Here, we should seriously address the major and difficult themes of cooperation that I have mentioned. In the next phase, we should also consider whether strengthened cooperation should lead to a more permanent and decision-making structure for the transatlantic dialogue. A possible model could be to develop a Charter or an agreement between the EU and the USA as a basis for a dialogue that extends beyond pure security policy.

With the Constitutional Treaty, we are proposing a significant strengthening of the EU's general foreign policy capacity, among other things with the new EU foreign minister and a permanent president of the European Council. One of the areas where it will be most obvious to utilize this new capacity is in a revitalized EU-USA cooperation.

Europe and the USA share a common past and a common political and cultural heritage. We have shared values. And we face tasks and challenges that, in my conviction, we can only solve together.

The USA is today the world's only superpower. But the USA needs partners to address the challenges of the future. The EU is the world's largest economic entity. But it cannot act alone in a global context. We have a mutual interest in cooperating. The relationship with the USA should be central to the EU's common foreign policy and our efforts to create a strengthened European role on the global stage. And the USA has a clear long-term interest in a strong Europe as a global partner.

Therefore, there is no contradiction between wanting a stronger EU and at the same time wanting to strengthen transatlantic cooperation. On the contrary, the USA needs a Europe that is strong and united. And Europe needs to be strong and united so that cooperation with the USA can take place in a balanced and equal manner.

* * *

Today, I have deliberately not spoken about the Danish exceptions. For I would like to put an end to the kind of Europe debate where we in Denmark cannot discuss the great challenges of the future because we keep digging into the debate about the Danish exceptions.

The Danish exceptions are harmful, yes. But primarily for Denmark itself. They do not affect the global development and the global challenges we face.

I would like us to have a Danish debate about what we want with the EU. How we can use the EU to meet the global challenges.

My conclusion is clear: The global challenges are so great that the countries of Europe must cooperate to meet them economically, in foreign policy, and in security policy. Therefore, we need stronger cooperation in the enlarged EU to give Europe a significant boost forward to become a leading knowledge economy in the world. And we need enhanced foreign, security, and defense policy cooperation. That is also why we need to get the new Constitutional Treaty in place as soon as possible.

Europe enters the 21st century reunited and strengthened. But also with a new agenda and new challenges.

With the enlargement, the EU has truly taken the step from a regional to a global actor. Europe must increasingly engage actively with the world around it in the coming years. This applies economically, in foreign policy, and in security policy.

Europe's potential is great. And the goal is clear – we must be at the forefront of development in the 21st century. We must engage positively and constructively in global development. For this to succeed, it requires the will to tackle the big tasks and think anew.