Results for Europe. Speech by Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen at the University of Copenhagen on Friday, April 21, 2006.

Denmark Anders Fogh Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

21 April 2006 · Results for Europe speech · University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark

Context
Rasmussen addressed the University of Copenhagen on April 21, 2006, outlining Europe's challenges with globalization, EU reform, and the stalled Constitutional Treaty ratification.
Main themes
EU reform and results, globalization and economic competitiveness, Constitutional Treaty fate, popular support for European cooperation, EU enlargement, internal market and common currency, EU institutional reform, Denmark and the EU, China and India as emerging economies, EU decision-making effectiveness
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,725
83rd percentile
Sentences
256
93rd percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.68
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%30%
  • Geopolitical 30%30%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Environmental 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

256 sentences in 123 paragraphs

Europe is facing significant challenges in these years. Globalization is upon us. But economically, Europe is lagging behind the USA. At the same time, we see new economies in the East, not least China and India, growing rapidly. The EU's ambitious goal of being the most competitive economic entity by 2010 places great demands on the willingness to reform in the member states.

Politically, everyday life has also returned after the success of the latest enlargement in 2002. The Constitutional Treaty, which was supposed to crown the efforts after the enlargement, has been rejected in two of the EU's original member states. The decision to take a pause was seen by many as an expression that the EU cooperation is in crisis.

What has gone wrong, one might ask? Has the cooperation come to a standstill?

My answer is that the EU has been and continues to be a success. But whether the EU remains a success in the future depends on how we tackle the challenges that Europe faces.

Europe is facing two challenges. One is how Europe addresses globalization in its broadest sense. The other is what I would call the popular challenge. How do we ensure that citizens support the development of European cooperation and feel that the EU is also beneficial to them?

The two challenges are inextricably linked. An EU that delivers results in relation to the challenges posed by globalization is a prerequisite for popular support.

We must acknowledge that the EU in recent decades has been very focused on its own development. Five new treaties in less than 20 years. And from 12 to 25 - soon 27 - member states at the same time. Many citizens have a sense that the EU has been more about institutions, procedures, and paragraphs than about concrete progress that benefits the citizens.

That said, we must not forget the many significant results that the EU has delivered. The EU has been primarily responsible for ensuring freedom and peace, growth and prosperity in Europe since World War II. And in recent years, the internal market, the common currency, and most recently the large enlargement with the countries of Central and Eastern Europe have united the countries around some very large, common projects.

Today, it is difficult to envision similar large EU projects. This does not mean that we should shelve the vision of a strong and committed cooperation. I believe in a strong and integrated community in the EU. But the work of creating concrete results must not be overshadowed by lofty political projects.

* * *

I will not refrain from saying a few words about the Constitutional Treaty, which is indeed the reason for the pause we are currently in.

The fate of the Constitutional Treaty is still uncertain. My guess is that there will not be a clarification for the time being. I expect that the pause at the summit in June will be extended.

I am very disappointed with the situation we are in. For the Constitutional Treaty is good from a Danish perspective. It contains concrete progress in relation to the challenges and tasks that the EU faces. Therefore, I would have very much liked to see the treaty ratified.

It would also have given us the opportunity to reconsider the reservations afterwards.

But we must respect the outcome of the referendums in France and the Netherlands. As long as France and the Netherlands cannot approve the treaty, it is shelved.

It is too early to say what a clarification might lead to. There are three possible options:

First, that a solution is found to France's and the Netherlands' problem, and that the ratification process continues. There is currently not much to suggest that this will happen.

Second, that there is agreement to completely abandon the Constitutional Treaty and continue cooperation based on the existing Nice Treaty. But I find it hard to see that option. A majority of the member states have already ratified the Constitutional Treaty. They are unlikely to accept continuing on the existing treaty basis as if nothing has happened.

Third, that there is agreement to negotiate a new treaty.

The ball is now primarily in the court of France and the Netherlands. Regardless of how it ends, the challenges that the EU faces remain the same. The enlarged EU must be able to function effectively and represent the interests of Europeans. Therefore, many of the proposals in the Constitutional Treaty are obviously correct. This includes proposals for more effective decision-making mechanisms, increased democratization, including transparency in the legislative process, a permanent president of the European Council, an EU foreign minister, and in general, creating clarity about the EU's structure and values.

The discussion about the fate of the Constitutional Treaty will not disappear by itself. We need to achieve clarity at some point. Otherwise, I fear that the EU will continue to return to that - instead of concentrating efforts on what it is all about: A close and committed cooperation that delivers results for the benefit of the citizens.

* * *

We are entering a new phase of the EU's development. After 20 years of large and significant projects, we should now focus on concrete political tasks. A whole series of projects that together constitute a massive effort to create concrete results for the populations of Europe.

In relation to the development of the last 20 years, this is a new approach to European cooperation. Instead of a few mega-projects, it will henceforth be the quantity and sum of many small and concrete projects that will ensure progress in European cooperation.

I will call this new strategy "Europe of Results." And today I will outline a work program for such a Europe of Results.

I see particularly three major tasks for the EU in the coming years.

First: How do we ensure that Europe is able to create growth and employment in the future? And thus social security.

Second: How do we ensure citizens' security and safety in relation to cross-border problems? How do we effectively combat terrorism, organized crime, and illegal immigration? How do we ensure food security and environmental and climate protection?

Third: How do we strengthen the EU's ability to represent Europeans' interests on the international stage?

Growth and employment in Europe

Europe needs reforms that create growth, ensure more jobs, and prepare us for globalization. This involves labor market reforms, education reforms, welfare reforms, and much more. The responsibility for implementing these reforms lies primarily with the member states. Some have progressed further than others. Denmark is at the forefront in most areas.

But it is also a common challenge. Therefore, we in the EU must exchange national experiences and inspire each other. But first and foremost, we in the EU must work closely together in areas where there is added value to be gained. Let me point to five areas:

First, we must further develop the Internal Market.

We need an internal market for services.

We must continue to strengthen competition at the EU level - for example, by making it cheaper to make payments across borders and use mobile phones across borders.

We must ease the administrative burdens for businesses.

We must combat economic nationalism and protectionism in the EU.

We must become better at attracting highly skilled labor.

Second, we should aim to create a real internal market for research, development, and education. Research, development, and education are crucial to ensuring welfare in Europe in the years to come. A European initiative in this area must therefore be given the highest priority.

In January 2004, I launched an ambitious plan to strengthen research, development, and education at the European level. Since then, Denmark has been a front-runner in this matter. And we have already achieved good results:

We have achieved an increase in spending on research and development of 75% over the next 7 years.

We have ensured the establishment of a European Research Council to support research at the highest level in Europe.

We have ensured that the number of exchange students will gradually increase by about 10,000 per year by 2013.

But we must go further. Not least when it comes to mobility for researchers, students, and educators. It should be a completely normal element in educational and research careers to spend a period in another EU country. Europe must be able to attract and retain the best minds.

We must establish a common European technology institute.

We must strengthen competition among universities in Europe through benchmarking.

We must enhance mobility through an even stronger focus on exchange programs. The goal must be to double the current level.

Third, we must create an internal market for energy. We must ensure that European businesses and consumers have access to sufficient and affordable energy while promoting sustainable energy.

We must continue the liberalization of electricity and gas markets in Europe.

We must ensure the necessary expansion of the electricity and gas grid across borders.

We must ensure more transparency regarding gas storage and consider common requirements for gas storage in the member states.

We must increase energy efficiency and the use of renewable energy in the EU - among other things through common goals and support for more research at the EU level.

And finally, it would be a good idea to establish a permanent forum for cooperation between energy producers and consumers - a kind of "energy OSCE."

Fourth, we must strengthen consumer protection at the community level. Specifically, I propose:

that the Commission commits to consulting a consumer committee in all matters concerning consumer issues before presenting proposals.

that we in the EU develop a common European labeling system for food. We need a system at the European level that clearly identifies healthy foods and promotes public health.

Finally, fifth, we should not only liberalize trade in Europe but also globally. For our own benefit, but not least for the developing countries. We must therefore fight hard to reach a WTO agreement. Unfortunately, the prospects for an ambitious outcome are not bright at the moment. The EU should therefore in the future put more effort into entering into bilateral trade agreements between the EU and third countries. Bilateral agreements with countries, especially in Asia, which can ensure us better and more stable trade, are therefore also a way forward.

Citizens' security and safety

The second major challenge for Europe is to effectively address the cross-border problems that create insecurity and uncertainty among citizens in the EU.

This particularly concerns issues such as environmental protection and the fight against man-made climate change. These are clearly problems that we can best solve together at the EU level. The EU has already made significant progress in the environmental field, not only for the benefit of all of Europe - but also for Denmark.

The EU is of enormous benefit to the environment. Of 192 EU legal acts in the environmental field from 1994 to 2006, 83 have had a positive impact on environmental protection in Denmark. 107 have been neutral in relation to the protection level in Denmark. Only in 2 cases have EU rules represented a deterioration compared to Danish rules.

The new chemicals directive is a good example. With the directive, we will register about 30,000 chemicals and keep track of the most dangerous ones. This will mean significant environmental improvements and better working conditions throughout Europe.

We must also continue to maintain and strengthen EU cooperation on environmental protection. We must:

promote new environmental technologies, including prioritizing this area within the 7th research framework program.

strengthen research into alternative energy sources.

work for ambitious common rules on reducing air pollution. We have already jointly adopted common frameworks for the protection of water and nature. Now is the time to tackle air pollution.

The benefits of close EU cooperation in addressing cross-border problems are also evident in the fight against international terrorism, organized crime, and illegal immigration. The EU has already delivered many results in these areas. But we must continue and set new goals.

Let me be specific: We must strengthen practical and operational cooperation in the EU. We must, among other things, ensure a more effective exchange of information between police authorities, including through the development of the Schengen Information System and cooperation in Europol.

Human trafficking and illegal immigration are a major challenge for Europe. Hundreds of thousands enter the EU illegally. Some are women and children who are sold into prostitution by cynical traffickers. Others are poor people fleeing from countries without a future to find work.

Recently, we have seen how many try their luck across the Mediterranean in small boats. To the Italian and Spanish coasts, to Malta or to the Canary Islands. Many hundreds drown in the attempt. It is deeply tragic.

Closing the borders and building a wall around Europe does not solve the problems by itself.

We need more effective control of the EU's external borders, which also stops human trafficking as well as arms and drug smuggling.

We must strengthen operational cooperation in the EU's border agency and establish a visa information system with biometric identifiers.

We must strengthen the EU's cooperation on the return of persons illegally residing in the EU. And we must ensure a safe return to their countries of origin.

But that alone is not enough.

We must also strengthen efforts in the neighboring areas regarding refugees and illegal immigrants. We must help them and the authorities in the areas from which they immigrate before they set off towards Europe. Denmark has taken the lead in cooperation with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, but we must go further. Through the EU, we must:

Support the building of capacities in the neighboring areas to handle refugee flows. This includes control, administrative capacity, and cooperation between European and local authorities.

Invest in structures that can provide refugees with a livelihood in the region. This involves securing work, education, health, etc.

The neighborhood initiative must go hand in hand with the EU's other development aid, trade agreements, and foreign policy regarding the regions from which the illegal refugees come - both in the EU's neighboring countries and further afield.

A strong common foreign and security policy

This brings me to the EU's foreign policy challenges. What do we do about the poverty, unrest, unfreedom, and instability that send people fleeing towards Europe? What do we do about security threats such as international terrorism and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction?

These are challenges that the EU is already facing today. The question is how we can best strengthen the EU's ability to tackle the major challenges - and to safeguard European interests in the rest of the world?

I would particularly like to highlight three areas where progress is needed:

We must strengthen the common foreign and security policy through better coordination of the EU's policies on the international stage. We must enhance the EU's ability to act in crises and provide assistance to EU citizens internationally. And perhaps most importantly: we must develop new forms of cooperation with the EU's neighboring countries.

Most people know that the EU today is one of the world's two largest economies. In terms of the size of the economy and foreign trade, the EU carries the same weight as the USA. Few know that the EU together accounts for about 55% of all the world's development aid.

This economic weight must be used more actively in the EU's foreign and security policy. At the same time, we must become better at utilizing the entire EU toolbox.

The strength of the EU is precisely that the Union has a very broad palette of instruments at its disposal. But we must become better at using these instruments so that they constitute a coherent and comprehensive policy.

It is also about the EU speaking with one voice in the world and acting collectively. We must improve our ability to formulate and pursue a common policy.

Already today, we have good examples of the EU's foreign policy significance. We experienced this from the Danish side in the case of the Muhammad cartoons.

The EU expressed full solidarity with Denmark. Solana's tour of the Middle East was of great importance. And Trade Commissioner Mandelson played a significant role in keeping the boycott of Danish products at bay. The Muhammad case has shown the value of being a member of a strong and supportive community - not least for a small country like Denmark.

We can strengthen the EU's foreign policy within the framework of the current treaty. Specifically, I propose:

that we increasingly use majority decisions within the common foreign and security policy that we strengthen Solana's staff.

that we fully utilize the Commission's many tools in foreign policy, particularly the trade and development policy tools.

that we ensure more effective coordination, including better cooperation between Solana and the Commission and better use of the Commission's delegations around the world. I would like to see us move towards a common foreign service that can give the EU a common face abroad in third countries.

The second area where the EU should strengthen its efforts is in safeguarding citizens' interests in an increasingly global world.

In recent years, we have witnessed a number of disasters around the world. Be it natural disasters like the tsunami, terrorist attacks like those in Bali and Egypt, or unrest during the embassy burnings. It is evident that we in the EU must work closely together when EU citizens are threatened.

We must strengthen the consular cooperation between EU countries' embassies outside Europe.

We must strengthen common crisis preparedness and evacuation procedures for EU citizens outside the EU.

We must come together to establish sufficient airlift capacity for disaster assistance and evacuation.

And we must strengthen cooperation on civil preparedness.

The third and perhaps greatest challenge is the relationship with the EU's neighboring countries and the further enlargement process. Throughout the EU's history, enlargement has been the central instrument for spreading freedom, security, and prosperity in Europe. This policy has been a tremendous success.

Just look at the enlargement with countries like Greece, Spain, and Portugal, which just a few decades ago were dictatorships. And most recently, the enlargement with the Central and Eastern European countries. How would Europe look today if we had let the Eastern European countries go their own way 15 years ago?

The same applies to the countries of the Western Balkans. The EU has made a tremendous effort over the past 15 years to stabilize the region. It is important that we continue to take our responsibility towards the countries of the Balkans seriously. They are part of Europe. It is important that the perspective of EU membership is credible, even though membership may not be on the table for many years. This way, we can encourage them to implement the reforms that can make them a stable and well-functioning part of Europe.

In general, we must stand by the promises we have made. But that said, it is also clear that the enlargement policy has its limitations as a stability-creating instrument. There are limits to how quickly and how far the EU can expand if the EU cooperation is to maintain its ability to provide solutions to Europe's challenges.

The question of the EU's external borders is naturally becoming more pressing. Let me make it clear: I do not believe it is possible to draw a line through Europe once and for all.

But we must take the EU's ability to admit new members much more seriously. This applies to the EU's decision-making capacity, the EU's common policies, and the support of the populations behind the EU. We cannot solely rely on the promise of EU membership as the EU's primary foreign policy instrument.

As an alternative, we therefore need to invest much more in developing an attractive neighborhood policy. A policy that offers reform tools to countries that may never or only far into the future can be considered for EU membership.

I envision that we will eventually move towards a genuine pan-European economic area. An area with free trade and economic cooperation between the EU and the EU's neighboring countries.

A pan-European economic area must also involve strengthening the EU's neighborhood policy. We must ensure that neighboring countries:

to a greater or lesser extent can gain access to participate in the EU's internal market can participate in a number of EU programs, such as student exchanges, research programs, etc.

can receive substantial financial support for reforms - for example, for anti-corruption, border control, and judicial reform.

As we move towards a pan-European economic area, we must also consider whether countries in certain defined areas should have the opportunity to come closer to the EU's decision-making process.

It is in the EU's interest to ensure stable neighbors rooted in democracy and market economy.

Conclusion

The EU today bears the main responsibility for developments on the European continent. It is up to us collectively to take on that task.

This is a colossal challenge. We must together create growth, ensure more jobs, and prepare ourselves for the challenges of globalization. We must collectively solve a number of cross-border problems, including better environmental protection and more effective combat against terrorism, organized crime, and illegal immigration. And we must collectively strengthen the role of Europeans on the international stage.

The answers must be found in a targeted effort on concrete projects that together constitute an ambitious strategy for a "Europe of results."

A Europe of results that focuses on tangible solutions and progress rather than lofty goals and illusions.

A Europe of results that emphasizes the development of policy rather than changes to treaties.

A Europe of results that prioritizes the expansion of concrete cooperation rather than the expansion of institutions.

A Europe of results where each individual citizen in Europe can clearly see that the EU is the practical tool to solve the tasks and challenges that we can better address together than alone.

A Europe of results where Denmark plays an active role in setting the agenda. Where Denmark comes forward with concrete proposals for the development of cooperation. Where Denmark is purposefully at the core of the EU.

A Europe of results in close harmony with the concrete needs, desires, and goals that we Europeans have.