Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen's speech at the European Conference on May 24.

Denmark Anders Fogh Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

24 May 2002 · European Conference

Context
Rasmussen addressed the European Conference on 24 May 2002, outlining Denmark's EU presidency priorities and his vision for the future of Europe.
Main themes
EU enlargement negotiations, Danish EU presidency, future of Europe, division of competencies between EU and member states, national parliaments' role, democratic transparency, EU efficiency, subsidiarity, security and counter-terrorism, sustainable development, EU citizenship rights, European Convention
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,539
68th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
8.7
9th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 77%73%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

170 sentences in 72 paragraphs

I will concentrate my speech on two topics: the Presidency and the future of Europe. The main emphasis will be on the latter.

* * *

The Danish Presidency has one very clear main task - to conclude the enlargement negotiations with up to 10 new countries. Not only because enlargement is and has long been a Danish priority. But because the negotiations have now reached a point where it is a realistic goal. The EU countries have collectively decided to place this task in our hands.

But enlargement is not the only task. We also face a packed and very content-rich agenda in other areas. I emphasize that we must also take these tasks seriously and deliver a focused and professional presidency there as well.

The headlines are:

greater

security and safety

– the fight against terrorism and crime sustainable development

- economic, social, and environmental.

food security

– mid-term evaluation of the agricultural policy and new fisheries policy.

the EU's global responsibility, including the common foreign policy and the two major meetings under the Danish presidency: the Johannesburg Summit on sustainable development and the ASEM summit with the Asian countries.

I have elaborated on the content under these headlines in the Folketing and will not repeat it here. During our debate afterwards, I would be happy to elaborate on our plans for the presidency, if desired.

These are the tasks we can foresee. But as always in European and international politics, one must expect the unexpected

. We

know that there will be crises that need to be managed under the Danish presidency. We just do not know which ones and when. But we are also preparing for this challenge as well as we can.

* * *

That was what I wanted to say about the presidency. But we should also already be thinking about the time after January 1, 2003. The discussion about the future of Europe is in full swing. We must not neglect it.

My starting point for the discussion about the future of Europe is actually very simple: We need a strong and effective EU. This is crucial for a smaller country like Denmark. But we also need an EU that people can comprehend, and that does not take up more space in everyday life than people can accept. Otherwise, support for the EU will disappear.

Today, I will present some of my ideas on how we can meet this dual challenge. Not as a definitive list. Not as a final government position. But as a basis for discussion.

In my view, we should aim for five goals in the convention and in the intergovernmental conference:

1.

We need a clearer description of the division of labor between the EU and the member states.

2.

The national parliaments should be strengthened. National parliamentarians should be more involved in the daily work of the EU.

3.

We need more openness, transparency, and democratic control - openness should be the rule and not the exception.

4.

We must have clear and distinct rights for citizens.

5.

The EU should be made more efficient - pomp, grandeur, and festive speeches should be discarded in favor of practical work for the benefit of EU citizens.

The first two of these headlines are the most important, and I will therefore focus on them the most.

* * *

First: a clearer division of labor.

If there is one theme that has recurred when we have discussed the EU in Denmark, it is uncertainty about the boundaries of the EU. What is it that the EU should actually deal with, and what should the EU countries keep to themselves? And how do we ensure that the Commission, the European Parliament, and the countries in the Council adhere to the agreed division of labor once we have decided on it?

Therefore, I would like to emphasize: the distribution of competencies is still on the agenda. The crucial point is not whether we call the reform a "catalog of competencies" or something else. The crucial point is the content. And the political goal is crystal clear. We need a better and clearer description of the distribution of competencies between the EU and the member states.

When I originally brought this theme into the Danish debate – on the evening of September 28, 2000 – I used the term catalog of competencies. This did not imply a commitment to a specific legal-technical model, but merely a desire to focus on an important problem area. I must say that this has been successful. Today, I believe everyone agrees with me that this is where we, from the Danish side, should focus our efforts.

Fortunately, we have good allies in the other countries. The division of labor – or the distribution of competencies, if you will – is a central question for the convention that has now begun its work. And it is a question that attracts interest in both the EU countries and the upcoming member states. I experience this myself when I discuss the work in the convention with colleagues from other countries.

I would like to emphasize that for me, it is not a question of rolling back the development in the EU. On the contrary. In a number of areas, we need stronger cooperation than we have today. But we also need to make it clearer what the EU is responsible for and what the member states are responsible for.

So how can this be done?

First: we can state more clearly what the EU does not deal with.

Today, the treaty states what the EU must deal with - what the EU's tasks are. However, the treaty generally does not say anything about what the EU does not deal with - what the tasks of the member states are. The EU must solve the tasks specified in the treaty - and only those. If nothing is stated, it is because the member states have not delegated the competence but have chosen to retain it themselves.

Although this is the fundamental principle, there have still been some areas where it has been decided what the EU does not do. Just to be on the safe side, so to speak. This has especially begun in recent years. For example, in connection with the fact that in some areas, majority voting has been adopted. When countries relinquish the lever of unanimity, they want to be completely sure of what the treaty can be used for.

In my opinion, there could be more such statements about what the EU does not deal with. Not to roll back cooperation – as I said. But to clarify where the boundaries lie. To emphasize the rights of the member states.

Let me give a couple of examples.

There is general agreement among the member states that distribution policy and the countries' social arrangements are not a matter for the EU. One must adhere to certain principles for sound economic policy, and one must not discriminate, but once those conditions are met, there should be free rein. That should be possible to express in some way.

There is also broad agreement that the arrangement of income tax systems is a matter for the individual EU countries, and that the EU as such has no competence to levy taxes. Again, there are of course some principles that must be adhered to, and when it comes to cross-border issues such as taxation of interest income, there is also a role for the EU. But even here, it should be possible to find formulations that everyone can agree on.

In addition, one could also consider setting clearer boundaries on some of the more marginal EU areas. Since we do not want to legislate on culture and sports in the EU, does the EU need to deal with such topics at all? And when everyone agrees that we should continue to determine the content of education in the member states ourselves, how many resolutions, support programs, and action plans do we need?

Finally, I believe we should establish certain fundamental ideas and overarching principles for cooperation.

For example, it could be the principle that the EU can only act where the member states have conferred competence to the EU. For experts, this is self-evident, but it may still be useful to state it more clearly than today.

It could also be that the EU is a community of independent states that have chosen to exercise part of their sovereignty together. Again, this is probably obvious to many, but it can still be useful to write it down.

One can discuss what the form should be for such formulations. Both regarding statements of what the EU does not deal with and regarding fundamental principles. Perhaps they should be included in the treaty itself. Perhaps in the preamble to the treaty or in a separate document. That is not the most important thing. What matters is whether one can agree on texts that lead to a clearer description of the division of labor than we have today.

* * *

The second goal should be to strengthen the national parliaments. Not least when it comes to ensuring that decisions are made as close to the citizens as possible, and that decisions do not go further than necessary. This means that the so-called principles of proximity and proportionality must be respected.

Today, the parliaments of the EU countries primarily play a role through the control of their respective governments. This should also be their most important role in the future. But to ensure that they can fulfill that role, we must provide them with the best possible working conditions. This means that decisions in the EU system must be made with as much openness as possible. It means that the parliaments must have access to the documents being processed. And it means that there must be sufficient time for EU issues to be addressed nationally.

But the control function in relation to their own governments does not need to be the only role for the national parliaments. Already today, we have the association of European committees – the so-called COSAC. And already today, COSAC has the opportunity under the treaty to express its views on how the EU institutions manage the principles of proximity and proportionality. This could be built upon.

Today, it is primarily up to the EU's legislative institutions – the Commission, the European Parliament, and the Council - to ensure that the two principles are respected. In principle, the Court can review the political discretion of the other three institutions, but in practice, it is difficult to legally challenge such political decisions. In my opinion, there is a need for political control that is independent and therefore cannot be exercised by the EU institutions themselves.

This does not mean that we should build yet another legislative chamber in the EU in addition to the Council and the European Parliament. We should generally avoid creating new institutions that would only make the legislative process heavier and more bureaucratic. But even with that starting point, we should be able to find a way to involve the national parliaments more.

I would like to see us establish a forum of national parliamentarians that can continuously evaluate the legislative activities of the Commission, the Council, and the European Parliament.

One could consider integrating such a forum into the legislative process itself. This would allow the national parliaments to express their views on the Commission's proposals before they are adopted. In return, such a model could easily affect efficiency. A better option might be to allow the national parliamentarians to express their views on already adopted proposals. How far-reaching the powers of the forum should be can be discussed.

For example, one could ask this forum to express its views on the institutions' respect for the principles of proximity and proportionality at each meeting of the European Council. The forum could both comment on legislation in general and draw the European Council's attention to specific cases where the Council, the European Parliament, and the Commission, in the opinion of the national parliamentarians, have gone too far.

One could also introduce the rule that a number of national parliaments could request a specific legislative act to be presented to this forum, and that the forum could then take a position on it. The forum could then decide that the Council and the European Parliament should reconsider the matter, or that it should be brought before the Court. Possibly, one could require that a special qualified majority be needed for the forum to intervene. This would probably not happen very often, but the mere possibility could have a certain preventive effect.

Finally, one could strengthen the direct role of the individual national parliaments in the EU. One could consider whether the national parliaments – individually or if some of them agreed – should have the authority to go to the Court – for example, regarding compliance with the division of labor, the principles of proximity and proportionality, and perhaps also the application of the so-called "rubber clause," Article 308.

Again, the specific model is not crucial. I have given some examples of what can be done. What matters is that a solution is found that simultaneously strengthens the national parliaments and ensures stronger political control over the principles of proximity and proportionality.

* * *

My last three points I will only mention briefly.

My third goal is greater openness, transparency, and democratic control. We should work towards full openness regarding the Council's legislative activities, and we should try to see if we can write a simpler and clearer treaty.

My fourth goal is clearer rights for citizens. The Charter of Fundamental Rights is a good and clear text, which has the additional advantage of already existing. We should explore the various possibilities for reflecting the charter in the treaty.

My fifth goal is to make the EU more efficient. This can, among other things, be achieved by introducing group presidencies and more extensive and consistent use of qualified majority voting.

* * *

Those were my five points. They represent, in my view, an improved EU, but not a completely different EU. I am not proposing to wipe the slate clean and start all over again. The existing model is far too valuable for that – not least for the smaller countries. The risk of throwing the baby out with the bathwater would be far too great. We should remember that the existing EU is, after all, a unique construction, and that it has been a colossal success. This is evidenced by the very great interest from other countries in becoming members.

Some may think that my five points together would equip the EU with a constitution. If this means a new fundamental pact that replaces the constitutions of the countries, that is incorrect. The outcome of the next intergovernmental conference will also be a new treaty between the countries. But if it means a clearer and better foundation that clarifies both the rights of citizens and the rights of member states, then for my part, no alarm. I would gladly sign such a constitutional treaty.