Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen's speech at the opening of the euro hearing at Christiansborg on January 22, 2009.

Denmark Anders Fogh Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

22 January 2009 · Hearing on the euro · Christiansborg, Denmark

Context
Rasmussen addressed a parliamentary euro hearing at Christiansborg on January 22, 2009, arguing Denmark should reconsider its euro opt-out amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Denmark's euro opt-out, financial crisis costs, political influence in Eurogroup, economic costs of staying outside euro, EU financial regulation, fixed exchange rate policy, Lisbon Treaty and Eurogroup expansion, international role of Eurogroup, Danish monetary policy
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,701
49th percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%69%
  • Geopolitical 14%14%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

101 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Thank you to the European Committee of the Folketing for organizing today’s hearing. A hearing that is supported by a broad majority of the parties in the Folketing.

A broad and thorough debate about the euro and Denmark's euro opt-out is highly relevant. The financial crisis has highlighted the costs for Denmark of being outside the euro area. This applies to both the political and economic costs.

The greatest cost is the loss of political influence. Denmark does not today have the same access to influence significant political-economic decisions in the EU as if we participated in the euro cooperation. There is nothing new in that. We have long seen that the euro countries discuss and coordinate their views at meetings attended only by euro countries. It is standard practice for euro countries to hold separate meetings prior to each EU finance ministers' meeting. Pre-meetings where they discuss the issues. And often also effectively negotiate the issues.

The financial crisis has intensified this development. We saw a very concrete example of this in October. Here, the Eurogroup held a summit at the level of heads of state and government for the first time ever regarding the financial crisis. At that meeting, they effectively determined the handling of the banking crisis across the EU – even though only euro countries participated in the meeting.

The EU has shown great determination in handling the financial crisis in recent months. Not least thanks to a very effective French presidency. In November, a common EU strategy for better regulation of global financial markets was agreed upon. And in December, we reached an agreement on a recovery plan aimed at boosting the European economy. During the financial crisis, we have seen a decisive EU – and we are very satisfied with that from the Danish side.

The EU can and should play a central role in efforts to create more transparency in international capital markets. We should ensure that all financial institutions, hedge funds, etc., are subject to appropriate and effective oversight. And that the necessary steps are taken to ensure that such common rules are followed by all financial centers in the world.

A significant part of the further discussions about the financial crisis is expected to take place in the Eurogroup.

Denmark has a strong interest in influencing the work to strengthen the regulation of international financial markets. Experience shows that smaller countries can achieve greater influence than their size would suggest if they have good arguments and pursue a sensible policy. But the euro opt-out means that we cut ourselves off from that influence.

Already today, the Eurogroup plays a significant role. And with the Lisbon Treaty, the Eurogroup will be further strengthened – among other things, the scope of decisions made solely by euro countries will increase. There is little doubt that euro countries will further enhance their political cooperation in the future – also in areas not closely related to the euro. In the longer term, it is possible that topics such as trade policy, development cooperation, and climate policy will also be discussed in the Eurogroup.

We also see that the Eurogroup is increasingly playing an independent role on the international stage. The Eurogroup is now regularly represented at G8 meetings. The chair of the Eurogroup meets regularly with international partners, including key economic countries such as the USA and China.

We cannot predict exactly how and how quickly the Eurogroup will develop in the future. But we can observe that the financial crisis has intensified a development that was already underway. And we know that the greater the role the Eurogroup plays, the greater the political cost of Denmark being outside the euro will be.

* * *

The economic costs of being outside the euro have also been more evident than usual recently. The financial crisis has put pressure on the krone. The National Bank has been forced to raise interest rates to defend Denmark's fixed exchange rate policy. This means that the interest rate spread – that is, the difference between the National Bank's and the European Central Bank's interest rates – has increased. And it is precisely in economically unstable periods that the economic costs of being outside the euro are greatest.

And it is an unfavorable situation for Denmark that we risk an increase in interest rates, precisely when there is an economic crisis and looming unemployment, where there might rather be a need for lower interest rates to stimulate the economy.

* * *

The financial crisis has thus highlighted both the political and economic costs of being outside the euro. Denmark conducts exactly the same monetary policy as the euro area. But we do not reap the benefits in terms of full political influence and greater economic security.

The euro has now existed for 10 years. And it has proven to be a success. For citizens and businesses in Europe, the euro has become the completely natural means of payment. With a number of practical advantages. Advantages that we Danes feel when we travel in the euro zone.

The euro is not an experiment. It is a solid and well-tested currency that is used daily by more than 325 million citizens in Europe. And internationally, the euro has developed into a strong and stable currency, which has even become one of the world's most important reserve currencies.

Therefore, the government is firmly convinced that Denmark should join the euro.

* * *

It has sometimes been claimed that euro cooperation takes too little account of employment. And that the euro limits countries' ability to respond to economic downturns.

Experience actually shows the opposite.

The frameworks and rules for euro cooperation support growth and employment.

One of the rules is that deficits in public finances, under normal circumstances, must not exceed 3 percent of the country's production – of gross domestic product.

Fundamentally, this rule aims to ensure sound public finances, so there is room to stimulate the economy if needed. In other words: It is wise to save and set aside in good times, as this provides better leeway to give the economy a boost in bad times.

The rules in the so-called Stability and Growth Pact do not aim to prevent an expansionary fiscal policy during periods of recession. On the contrary, the pact aims to create the conditions for such an expansionary fiscal policy by ensuring proper consolidation of public finances during periods of economic boom.

Moreover, the rules in the Stability and Growth Pact are flexible enough to take into account economically difficult times.

In bad times with low employment, there are a number of exceptions to the pact's normal requirements. For example, a country will have more lenient conditions if growth is negative or very low for an extended period.

EU rules thus provide ample opportunities to respond to economic crises. This is also underscored by the fact that at the recent EU summit, there was support for a recovery plan aimed at stimulating the economy and maintaining growth and employment. This shows that the Stability and Growth Pact in no way contradicts a common and coordinated effort to counter an economic downturn.

From time to time, we also hear in the debate that it would be harmful to employment that the European Central Bank aims to keep inflation at a maximum of around 2 percent.

I would like to emphasize that there is no contradiction between high employment and low inflation – on the contrary. With the right economic policy, it is possible to maintain high employment and low inflation. That is precisely what we have done in Denmark.

If inflation, on the other hand, is allowed to run rampant, it could threaten employment, as it would then be necessary to take measures to bring inflation under control.

You see, inflation is the erosion of the purchasing power of money. When prices rise sharply, we must remember who is hardest hit. It hits the most vulnerable the hardest, for example, pensioners and low-wage earners. The wealthiest have better opportunities to protect themselves against inflation by placing their money in assets whose value rises with inflation. So what can be said is that high inflation leads to a redistribution in society to the detriment of the most vulnerable.

Keeping inflation at a stable, low level is therefore very much a policy with a social aim.

* * *

Let me remind you that Denmark is already subject to exactly all these rules – the same rules as the euro countries. From the public debate, one might sometimes get the impression that Denmark would come under a new set of rules if we adopted the euro. But that is not the case. Denmark is already today subject to the provisions of the Stability and Growth Pact.

The situation is that we must comply with exactly the same fiscal rules as the euro countries. Yes, in reality, the requirements for us are stricter, precisely because we are outside the euro. We are to a greater extent than the euro countries required to prove that we conduct a credible and responsible fiscal policy, so that there is not a moment's doubt about the Danish fixed exchange rate policy.

Since 1982, we have conducted a fixed exchange rate policy. And this fixed exchange rate policy has been a cornerstone of the economic policy that has made the Danish economy one of the strongest in Europe. Therefore, we have pegged the krone to the euro.

So my conclusion is clear: We can choose between a fixed exchange rate policy with influence by being part of the euro or a fixed exchange rate policy without influence by being outside the euro.

Denmark should be part of the euro because it economically costs us to be outside, but first and foremost because it is a significant loss of influence to be outside.

We should be part of the euro because it is simply in our own best political and economic interest.

Therefore, I welcome that a broad majority in the Folketing has requested this hearing today. I hope it can be the starting point for a good and thorough debate about Denmark's relationship with the euro.