The interview of the President of the Republic of Poland for Polsat News [FULL TEXT]

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

27 September 2024 · Interview for Polsat News programme 'Graffiti' · Presidential Palace, Poland

Context
Duda gave an interview at the Presidential Palace to Polsat News in September 2024, discussing Ukraine peace prospects following his visit to the United States and UN meetings.
Main themes
Ukraine peace plan, restoration of international law, Russian aggression, Polish national security, Polish-Ukrainian relations, Volhynia genocide dispute, territorial integrity of Ukraine, Crimea status, European security, Trump and Zelensky peace proposals
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,954
91st percentile
Sentences
349
96th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
8.4
6th percentile
Syntax
2.65
10th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Polish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

349 sentences in 145 paragraphs

Marcin Fijołek, Polsat News: I warmly welcome you all. Today, "Graffiti" is exceptionally and specially from the Presidential Palace. Our guest today is the host of this place, Mr. President Andrzej Duda. Good morning.

President of the Republic of Poland Andrzej Duda: Good morning, Mr. Editor. I warmly welcome our viewers.

Mr. President, we are speaking just after your visit to the United States. Many important discussions, many meetings. I wanted to ask about one aspect that – I have the impression – did not resonate as strongly, at least officially: the peace plan for Ukraine. We have a peace plan that is to be presented – or is being presented – by Volodymyr Zelensky. We have Donald Trump's idea for peace. We have ideas from the Chinese, the Hungarians. How do you see this? What was said in the corridors of meetings, dinners, including with Joe Biden, which you attended, about how this war in Ukraine might end?

I do not change my opinion on how this war should end. This is the opinion of the President of the Republic, a perspective from the point of view – of course – of our interest. Our interest, meaning the security of our part of Europe. But in my conviction, this is also an approach from the perspective of global security – to be clear. And it is unequivocal. I keep repeating this – I can say – practically everywhere and all the time.

The primacy of international law must be restored. This is, for me, a fundamental issue when it comes to ending the war in Ukraine. When will the primacy of international law be restored? When Ukraine regains control over all its internationally recognized territories. That is, when it regains control over its borders. That is, it will have full control over the areas it controlled before the Russian aggression against Ukraine in 2014.

So including Crimea.

Yes. Including Crimea.

But is that possible, Mr. President? Because you see these ideas that – either officially or unofficially, off the record, sometimes in the media, sometimes in the press – appear, for example, about a scenario in which the Crimean Peninsula could come under some control, UN administration.

In my opinion – what I said – this is the baseline, absolutely fundamental point to start any conversation.

But is it a realistic point, Mr. President?

I repeat once again: as the President of the Republic, I would like the primacy of international law to be restored. Why? Because in my conviction, it is like this: if even a piece of Ukrainian land remains in Russian hands and the world somehow recognizes the fact of this annexation, this seizure, this permanent occupation – let’s call it that – or even the incorporation of some part of Ukraine into Russia, it will mean that Russian imperialism has consumed what it wanted to consume, and it will want to take more pieces, it will want to take more territories. This war will then return. In my opinion, Russia will attack Ukraine again, it may attack other countries.

To cut this off, to prevent this from happening, today – as I say – I keep repeating: Russia must be punished for its aggression against Ukraine. There, on the fields of Ukraine, it must simply lose this war de facto. Because losing this war will mean giving up the occupied territories. It is absolutely not about taking any territories from Russia. It is not about attacking Russia – no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. It is about ensuring that Russia does not take any part of Ukraine, meaning it does not have the satisfaction of gaining anything in this war.

And we should not consider any plan B at all?

We, in Poland, should not consider that. Because what good is it if the world is satisfied that it has settled the matter and that it can return to business with Russia? Let’s not deceive ourselves – many today are waiting for this war to end just so they can return to business with Russia, freely and without shame. And we will be in potential danger.

That is why I say: as the President of the Republic, I demand the full restoration of the primacy of international law. That is, the return of control to Ukraine over its internationally recognized territories, over its internationally recognized borders.

Mr. President, was there an opportunity in the United States to talk privately with Volodymyr Zelensky for at least a few minutes? I ask in the context of the friction, tension, crisis – I don’t know how you assess it – in Polish-Ukrainian relations. Do you see this dispute over history, over the genocide in Volhynia, and over honoring, exhuming the victims, and over Ukraine's path to the European Union, and even about the Ukrainian boxer at the airport? Did you discuss this with Zelensky?

We did not discuss these matters right now in New York. We met at the United Nations headquarters. We greeted each other. For a moment, we exchanged a few words. We did not touch on that topic. We talked about frontline issues, about what the situation looks like today on the front of the war.

However, I will say this: I have spoken with President Volodymyr Zelensky – on the topics you raised – several times. The result of these discussions and my slow, but consistent actions in this matter – slow, because these are delicate issues, they are also difficult for the Ukrainian side for reasons that are partly understandable to me; they are difficult, which does not mean they should not be resolved, I understand they are difficult; of course, they are very difficult for us from a completely different perspective – the result of these discussions was Volodymyr Zelensky's presence in the cathedral in Lutsk with me on the anniversary of the Volhynian massacre.

That was an important symbol, Mr. President.

That was an important symbol and that was…

But there is no agreement on exhumations.

…and that was the result of calm and very thoughtful work on this issue. I will continue this calmly and thoughtfully until the end of my presidency, as long as it is possible for me.

However, I want to say one thing: let us remember that these agreements on exhumations have already been made. The issue of further agreements on exhumations was the subject of my recent longer discussions with Volodymyr Zelensky in private, when I was in Kyiv for the anniversary of Ukraine's independence on August 24.

Do you think there will be a breakthrough in this matter by the end of your presidency?

I hope there will be. However, I would not want it to happen through a disgraceful – frankly speaking – blackmail, which, in my opinion, will not bring good results for Poland in the international arena.

Are you referring to the words of the PSL leader, who said: "Either an accelerated path to Ukraine's accession to the European Union, or Volhynia"?

In my opinion, that is not a good way to present values. This matter – I believe – should be resolved differently, not by threatening to block Ukraine's integration with the West.

Because let us remember that blocking Ukraine's integration with the West is one of the reasons why Putin attacked Ukraine. After all, we all know this. Therefore, engaging in such a way in relations with Ukraine is, in a sense, following Putin's path, which we would not want to do – as Poles.

Mr. President, let’s return to Polish ground. The government and the Sejm are working on a special law that is supposed to help in dealing with the effects of the flood. A big discussion in the Sejm. There has also been quite a commotion among politicians, as is often the case on such occasions. Do you think the state has passed the exam regarding its response to the flood?

I believe that the state is currently doing everything in its power to help – at least that is what we are doing. I believe that the government is also taking many actions. The appointment of Minister Kierwiński as a special member of the Council of Ministers specifically for actions related to dealing with the effects of the flood and helping flood victims has taken place.

I expressed my gratitude to Minister Kierwiński because I believe he deserves it. Let us remember that he resigned from his mandate to the European Parliament in order to take on an extremely difficult mission. Because this is a mission where there will always be people who will feel wronged, harmed. This is not a mission that can be completed with satisfaction and with full public applause. It is extremely responsible and extremely difficult.

But you hear, Mr. President, the opposition today…

Calmly.

…the politicians of PiS, who say outright that Tusk's government has fallen apart – Mariusz Błaszczak.

I said to Prime Minister Donald Tusk, because we had the opportunity to talk in the corridors. I said: "Mr. Prime Minister, the opposition has its right. And you were also in the opposition and you also criticized very harshly at all possible levels. Therefore, I ask you to leave this right in a democratic state to the opposition, that it has the right to criticize."

I am today part of the executive power, I am not the opposition. And in state matters, I cooperate with the other part of the executive power, that is, with the government, to the best of my ability, because I have a deep internal conviction that today we must primarily help people. And that is why I say: let us leave the issue of accountability, discussing whose fault it is, for after the matter is resolved. And for now, the matter is to be resolved. And that is the issue of helping these people – as quickly, as efficiently, and as effectively as possible.

There are so many dramatic problems and human tragedies where people have lost their entire life savings, where winter is approaching in mountainous and foothill areas, where there is really horror at this moment – that all hands must be on deck. There, we must primarily provide help today. And those who hold in their hands the responsibility for the executive power – and today it is held by the Civic Coalition on one side, PSL, all those who are in the ruling coalition, that is, the government, but also I, as the President of the Republic – we must put in as much work as possible to help. Everyone in their own capacity as much as they can.

Mr. President, regarding cooperation with the government. I wanted to ask you: Tomasz Siemoniak, Antoni Macierewicz, Mariusz Błaszczak, and Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz – with which Minister of National Defense have you collaborated best?

I have worked longest with Mariusz Błaszczak.

And best?

I have worked well on military matters with practically all Ministers. However, it is no secret that I have also had various conflicts and frictions with them, right? After all, these are long years – nine years. I worked very briefly with Minister Siemoniak. I had no disputes with him. That was, by the way – as I said – a relatively short period of cooperation, just the beginning of my presidency. But I met with him several times, substantively, on issues related to national security and the military – and those were good meetings. That is how I assess it today.

Then I worked with Minister Antoni Macierewicz. Let us remember that together we accomplished something truly great, which was the establishment of the Territorial Defense Forces. That is a great merit…

But there were also frictions, like those memorable Ubecka methods that you pointed out to him.

We had a clash regarding one high-ranking officer. However, that is a completely different issue than building the military potential of the Republic. And indeed, the contracts that Minister Macierewicz signed – the Patriot system, building that multi-layered air defense system. The creation of the Territorial Defense Forces – I emphasize once again: an extremely important, groundbreaking…

Which is evident today, by the way.

…fundamentally important decision for national security – a great merit of Minister Macierewicz.

Minister Mariusz Błaszczak – long years of cooperation. Increasing defense spending, very important contracts signed in connection with the modernization of the Polish army, also his great courage in making those decisions, for which I will always respect him and will remember that with respect.

Today I am working with Minister Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz.

Is it a good cooperation?

It is good cooperation. We are carrying it out calmly. I can say with satisfaction that the modernization of the Polish army is continuing. I personally thanked the Minister for signing the contract for the purchase of Apache attack helicopters from the United States. It is very good that elements of Polish arms production are also being implemented – I am thinking here of the light armored transport vehicle. These are really important decisions.

I am asking, Mr. President, about this cooperation with the government. Because sometimes there are such images, like during the nomination of Marcin Kierwiński – a declaration of full cooperation. We had your meeting with Prime Minister Donald Tusk on the warship, which has taken on a bit of a legend. But we also had such frictions or statements – like those of your Prime Minister, who thanked God that you only have 330 days left in your presidency. What does the current cooperation with the government look like? Is it a rough friendship? Is it cooperation at all?

As you can see, it is cooperation, right? However – of course – there are also moments of friction in this cooperation. Of course, we are from two different political camps. After all, everyone knows which political camp I come from, right? But today I am no longer part of that political camp, I am not a member of Law and Justice. I am the President of the Republic, part of the executive power – according to the Polish constitution. And today, together with the government, I am carrying out tasks for the people simply. And for me, that is the most important issue. Today we need to help people affected, harmed by the flood – that is absolutely fundamental at this moment.

And at the political level, Mr. President?

That is why we are doing what I can in my own capacity – here, the Chancellery of the President. We are sending another transport of aid, we have obtained dehumidifiers and heaters so that people can dry their homes more efficiently.

Of course.

We are sending them to the vicinity of Lewin Brzeski right now. My wife is also involved in organizing these transports. We already have three groups of children planned at our residence in Wisła. The children will be coming from the Głuchołazy area and will be able to spend time there while their parents try to rebuild a normal life. So we are doing everything we can today to help from our side as well.

And what about cooperation at the political level, Mr. President? Is there any room for compromise – whether regarding ambassadors or the judiciary? You have had the bill on the Constitutional Tribunal on your desk for two weeks. Will you sign it?

Mr. Editor, if it is in accordance with the constitution – yes. But for now, everything indicates that there are elements in it that are inconsistent with the constitution. And that is indeed a very serious problem that effectively blocks the possibility of signing it. That is the first point.

Secondly, regarding cooperation on the issue of ambassadors – you raised this issue – there is always room for compromise. I just want the customs that have been in Poland for 35 years in the cooperation between the President and the Minister of Foreign Affairs to simply be implemented. If it was possible to do this for 35 years, then why suddenly, when Minister Sikorski came and this coalition – and the Civic Coalition is in power at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs – are all these rules being broken just because the President is not from their political camp? Either they recognize the principles of democracy, or they do not.

Did you mention this to the Prime Minister?

Yes, I did.

And what did he say?

I conveyed it to the Prime Minister. Minister Sikorski also knows about it.

So I understand that if there is no change in Minister Sikorski's policy, you will not sign any ambassadorial nominations until the end of your term?

If Mr. Sikorski continues to believe that he decides who the ambassador is, or if the Prime Minister decides who the ambassador is, in short – if the government decides who the ambassador is, then they will have a problem with me, because according to the constitution, it is the President who gives the ambassadorial nominations, and that is a presidential prerogative.

Read about the rules for taking photos. Download the photo.

And do you see any room for compromise...

Of course, I see room for compromise.

...in connection with the proposal for the verification of judges, which Minister Adam Bodnar spoke about? Those judges appointed after 2018. There was also talk of active regret as a condition for such positive verification.

I think Minister Bodnar probably felt uncomfortable when he spoke about it.

What does that mean?

That he probably felt uncomfortable.

But do you think that was...?

He had a bad day as a lawyer. He probably had a bad day when he talked about judges reporting active regret, because it is a criminal law institution. Active regret is a criminal law institution. So he probably felt uncomfortable.

But even if we call it something else, perhaps it really... because then Minister Bodnar actually withdrew from that term with us, in "Graffiti." Do you envision any form of verification, disciplinary actions for judges after 2018?

There is no reason to verify anything. Every judge was appointed in accordance with the Polish constitution, in accordance with the applicable law that was passed on democratic principles by the Polish parliament. It went through the entire legislative process. And the fact that someone did not like who won the elections at that time and believed that as a total opposition they have the right to challenge the results of democratic elections is their issue and their problem. Apparently, they have not matured to democracy.

But this is a problem for all of us, Mr. President, because we have chaos in the courts because of this. Judges are questioning each other. They are mutually overturning each other's rulings...

But this is a problem of judges who should not be judges because they are not suited for it. Because instead of dealing with resolving citizens' cases and administering justice, they are engaged in politics. Unfortunately, there are more and more such judges. Over the last nine years, they have become very clearly visible.

From the perspective of our viewers, I wonder if a reset would be necessary. Perhaps forgetting about who, when...

A reset would be necessary, but then we would have to verify all judges – all of them.

Would you be in favor of that?

Perhaps it would be necessary to verify all of them. And simply remove those politicians from the judiciary.

But who would check who is a politician and who is a judge who cares about...?

Exactly. Exactly. And that is our problem. That is why I propose that the responsibility for appointing judges be left in the hands of the Presidents of the Republic. Because until now, no one has dared to verify the judicial nominations granted by previous Presidents of the Republic.

So let’s leave the judicial nomination, for which the President is indeed responsible – as an inviolable matter and in accordance with the constitution, just as it has always been until now.

Changing the subject. A bit of pure politics, Mr. President. We are talking on the eve of the presidential campaign. Some have even already announced their candidacies. The political camp from which you come is struggling with who should be the candidate. Has anyone from PiS asked you for advice? Asked for help in choosing a candidate? After all, you have won elections twice – you know how it’s done.

No.

No one called?

No.

And do you expect such a call?

No.

Okay, let me ask differently. Do you see anyone from this short – or slightly longer – list of candidates from Law and Justice who would be suitable for this?

Ah, that is my sweet secret; I keep that to myself.

You won’t reveal that secret?

I do not nominate a candidate in the elections.

That’s true.

It is the electoral committees, political groups that nominate candidates for elections.

I am just asking for your opinion. Do you see anyone on the horizon – let’s call it – from the center-right?

My secret, I keep it to myself.

Alright. How do you perceive the rumors, signals suggesting that someone from the Chancellery might run? There was talk about Jacek Siewiera, sometimes about Marcin Mastalerek.

Mr. Editor, potentially anyone can run. I always smile that every politician has a presidential scepter in their backpack. It is like that; somewhere there is the peak of Polish politics that, at least from some theoretical assumption, every ambitious politician would like to climb. I repeat: theoretical assumption. So everyone has that presidential scepter in their backpack. Some jump out, showing that they have it. That’s how it is – that’s politics.

I can’t shake the question that if Chairman Kaczyński called asking for your opinion, you wouldn’t give it? You wouldn’t offer any advice out of old political acquaintance?

I think that... first of all, let’s start from the fact that Chairman Jarosław Kaczyński – now not joking; completely seriously, right? – I believe that as time has shown and the circumstances and facts, he made an extraordinarily insightful choice of candidate 10 years ago. Because that was almost 10 years ago. Actually, yes, because... yes, 10 years ago. My candidacy was officially announced on November 11.

I remind you that at that time some laughed, and Chairman Kaczyński really took on an enormous responsibility – an enormous responsibility. Because for the head of a party that has a chance to win elections, such a decision is of absolutely fundamental importance. And that was a great responsibility that he took on his shoulders. As time has shown – he did it with extraordinary insight. I think Chairman Kaczyński does not need to be advised on who should be the candidate. That is his decision.

Did you contribute, Mr. President, to the Law and Justice committee?

I am the President of the Republic.

But you are also a citizen.

I am the President of the Republic today, above all.

So you did not contribute?

I am today the President of the Republic.

But you won’t answer “yes” or “no” to that question?

Please check.

That is not public information, I understand, at least for now.

Yes.

I understand that you did not contribute. You will not answer that question directly.

I am not financially supporting any political groups in Poland at this time.

Oh, and that is a direct answer to the question. I ask in the context – you know – of the turmoil following the decision of the National Electoral Commission, which questioned the electoral report of PiS. PiS MPs are now suing members of the Electoral Commission in court; they have the right to do so, of course.

They have the right to do so.

However, I wonder if this could also affect the campaign? Are those funds absolutely necessary for a PiS candidate to win the elections?

I believe it is not good that such a decision by the National Electoral Commission has been made. I believe it is a very precedent-setting decision that actually poses a dangerous precedent for Polish democracy. And attempts to show and forcibly stretch which actions of the government were supposedly campaign actions are absolute madness.

Because we will not have an end to this type of suggestions and this type of settlements. And depending on who has the strength to exert pressure on the National Electoral Commission in various ways, that is the pathology we will have at that moment. And I believe that this is a terrible situation. That is my personal assessment.

Read about the rules for taking photos. Download the photo.

Did PiS politicians go too far in the campaign? When it comes to the use of state institutions, the government, government administration.

Mr. Editor, do you remember how Prime Minister Kopacz traveled by train all over Poland just before the 2015 parliamentary campaign? My wife once personally met Prime Minister Kopacz along with part of the government on a train when she was being escorted by the media to the platform, and my wife was quietly traveling to Kraków to our relatives. So let’s remember the facts, okay? Because I know that many years have passed and some would very much like to forget about it. But that’s how it was.

Mr. President, what was the idea behind having Beata Kempa as your advisor?

What was the idea?

Yes.

We have a situation where today we are struggling with a flood, the effects of which will probably have to be dealt with, unfortunately – I fear – until the end of my second term, which will last another 10 months. I fear that the effects of this flood will not be removed so quickly. Minister Beata Kempa has great experience in carrying out humanitarian tasks, which she was involved in at the Prime Minister's Chancellery. She has a lot of experience in this area.

And today she is my advisor, and she will be dealing with these matters for me, especially since the flood has affected her region, which is Lower Silesia. Therefore, I considered that appointing such a person today to support these efforts... I can say this: I was a bit quicker than the Prime Minister, who appointed Minister Kierwiński and indicated him as his candidate for the person responsible for removing the effects of the flood. I previously indicated Minister Beata Kempa as the person responsible for this from my side.

Mr. President, we have two minutes left. I wanted to ask about what comes next. In good corporations, sometimes they ask employees: where do you see yourself in a year or two? So I would like to ask you, if you allow me: where do you see yourself in a year? Because looking at you, it seems that it’s not retirement, a bathrobe, and slippers.

You know, when I take off my glasses (the President takes off his glasses), my vision does not reach that far.

But you must think, Mr. President, about what comes after next summer.

Mr. Editor, above all, I want to bring to completion the Polish matters that I am currently handling, which my compatriots entrusted to me in 2020 for the second time – that is, to fulfill my presidential duties to the end. And that is absolutely the most important and fundamental thing for me today. And I am not making any arrangements with anyone for any cooperation after my presidency, because I do not want to take on any obligations in this regard that could create any undertones in the effects of my work here in the remaining months I have left.

Do I understand you correctly that you will think about what comes next in August or September of next year?

Yes. About what comes next...

Because that is a huge political potential: 10.5 million votes, a leader in trust rankings.

I will think about what comes next when I finish my service here, when Poland has the next President who will take over this position from me and continue to lead Polish affairs; when I am released from this obligation and from this responsibility that rests on me today. And I will be able to calmly consider how to direct my fate further.

Let me ask one last question. Do you think that this duopoly we have had for 20 years – we are almost at the 20th anniversary of this duopoly of the Civic Platform and PiS – is something good for Poland, or would it benefit from being loosened?

That will be answered by the voters.

And you – as a voter?

I also have my answer to that. I primarily care that Poland develops and that people live better, more prosperous, more comfortably, but above all safely. The task of ensuring Poland's security is probably the most important today.

This is also a test of how the Polish state functions – what is happening right now and the assistance to the flood victims. Will we manage this better than we have since 1997, after the previous great flood? And after the previous floods, which were also significant but occurred more locally than the one in 1997.

We will see to what extent Poland, after all these years, when the standard of living in Poland has undoubtedly risen and when the wealth of the Polish state has increased, when Poland's budget is getting larger, will be able to effectively deal with the problem it has today.

President Andrzej Duda. Thank you very much for the conversation in "Graffiti." Thank you all very much. Marcin Fijołek. See you soon.

Thank you very much.